{"id":"zcr_xQFV--4","comment_count":1272,"extracted_at":"2026-10-01T17:18:20+00:00","extractor":"yt-dlp","extractor_args":"youtube:comment_sort=top;max_comments=5000,all,all,50,2","note":"Reply depth limited by yt-dlp YouTube extractor; browser \"load all replies\" automation is not used.","comments":[{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:56 Link: How Much Does Altitude Change Sound? \nhttps://youtu.be/WZ4tU2BICzk\nAnd how have I not seen or watched this yet? It's not even saved to my watch later?","like_count":362,"author_id":"UCUGrcP5rvNMEYVz2m2qvLVg","author":"@imark7777777","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lxS09f_1aVof0kcfP_j0cMpm5TM5n_mA1E5V3X7BnJpQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@imark7777777","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":true},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEADWvCvjtYSN","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"Thank you! I couldn't believe he hadn't linked it in the description to start with! 😄","like_count":18,"author_id":"UCPbPipx-UayHt1ZPvrbDPzQ","author":"@DanishHoodieGal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cOuY_uu4-Y2NTC8qxb-zSzHHEWgGjbiFi1sW2qN8-34NqQlnidlBMNVVwU4c11QSKBxGwnJzcQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DanishHoodieGal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEADXsP2fxa23","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"Absolute genius. Both of you guys","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC79t6a2bcKVlHgFVHVJ-JTw","author":"@JustinsJourneyReal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5TWtO9h2-liw67uMl4eO8YutZUSUbt-2VzMG_32XD3HynvCeTtYLAx_JnJQTXc83rXykxRrYLpE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JustinsJourneyReal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEADgA9OWQGHH","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"Link guy, you're my hero. ❤","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC0aVW2uXP-IgQmsvHhCx-gA","author":"@sunimasuno3718","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llZRbhbKPoANBVHr_LksOgXj4YQSyIskv5yRBcGsKPU2I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sunimasuno3718","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEADkq1A4CaoF","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"16:00 the first moment the specimen appears can see the plants stomata, where it \"breathes\" from. \n\nTo increase light, hold an LED flashlight above. This helps greatly when viewing specimens meant more for stereoscopic microscopes, but those of us with brightfield biological types (like you have) can view things far easier. Using a stand and flashlight makes things night/day difference (pun intended) lol","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCpfXzDRdX_DMEz_eEdEgMnQ","author":"@forestfloored420","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/AYkQfjh7gT65EYqpJxiUhQKlxH4GnY8o4Z-3fQhCxb9Y8SeRGhm5v4ZGIx45vbCV_zErba-f=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@forestfloored420","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEADYvyDBy7_7","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"Thanks. I was hoping he would link it in the description.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCbGtolYFu16nLFVQ4PoTFyA","author":"@maxleveladventures","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/88xym1FWHqfYupzBtddzfVtu6FmNPbEcg_ohDuvuWKwcQTersWcEeRn_Jy7VT4vRElm4_8HZ5g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maxleveladventures","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEADf-NirELWK","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"There's also studies finding out that plants communicate with each other through high frequency clicking sounds to warn of insects and drought and other things and it's mainly super high frequencies they can hear because they have the ability to go farther, and I can feel the wave wave vibration and differentiate it better than a low frequency which covers a wide range.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBnQ1LurWE2ZSUfYji9GLMA","author":"@ErickNyevzRoosevelt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZvDHYsgcmnfAGGcJu5oQqVtsUSi87J0hoBpX-fZzH36VFOVsG35oZMVaCFXgV4__ZnpGQS_5=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ErickNyevzRoosevelt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEAEp3sIu_R0Q","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"Holy crap! Thank you algorithm! Love this Channel! ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCe8GJyEvMRhw0pC29rAKw2w","author":"@LaMagnatron","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NnnGaWFL9SpZEvQFmtw34k97DBKmcw_FIACLAMUr8nd1DrwIbGwwT07uFW4Wr0_xUVrj6NZpixI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LaMagnatron","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEAFXUq3MuSw7","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"Ty when he mentioned it I was all ears and about to look for it <3","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCePpzD9gQ0xhXhY1Q3kGzOw","author":"@ScarlettStunningSpace","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nv3hWbk_nji3fcbJW203nxnwPQiVFmtfWYR3ga-8kH39iJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ScarlettStunningSpace","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEAIfgtYfuWUY","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"Thank you, Sir!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCh8fWNCiTc7Ql1KIPOVSwTQ","author":"@RaveDigger1337","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/tmsdWSA-_LmilAu8JSrEalfyAnsG3iTOeG1Uno9X7EgkSAl0CGiU525ThbNu-6QlNUPMhVIE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RaveDigger1337","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEAJi2DFkElzl","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"How Much Does Attitude Change Sound?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCS0srmVYVeRzdzljZ5Z6ZBA","author":"@soon-to-leave","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lL1Zt0LqeuFxQrupFfJGWqXa6XcsNcyBRl_R_NNPB-OT8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@soon-to-leave","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEAKKomdvulVV","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"in the first 30 seconds, i found myself immediately attenuated and then continuing to smile throughout.  ;)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvwu0nN08PUUlIdhl39K1nQ","author":"@danielle78730","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dUp6bd9L0QNOTeEDZKAweVF-xIFHsd0utGmZtML5qzcYTP7CEJkZTgQdGIEBbtOl9k2hsskvfw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danielle78730","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEAWyKn0WyNFW","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"Are you still working on this experiment?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvI9hcd7sOwYmPmWQaAOobA","author":"@ianmckenna29","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n7n9p9mI0ZKWcJ43hL3Lsl6jgfKUlEG6DNdSQhkiW3KAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ianmckenna29","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg.ADW3QJgVuiEAYy-pV7W84D","parent":"UgzVmNx37j3Bf3XFlbx4AaABAg","text":"science is broken, and its not horseshit. because science as a tool is funded and influenced by culture, and culture is broken. we are at the same point in science as galileo was. if the pope disagrees that the sun is the centre, then he has to face being burned alive for it, or change his mind. be it medical, meteorilogical, enviromental, psycriatic, psycological, physics or chemistry... they all suffer under the yoke of wealth determining the parameters and defining truth. politics should take up less space than it does. but i have no fix for it.\nlove this channel, new sub btw","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQRx-ySD8mHADar4UY4YW5g","author":"@sebastianbergstl4423","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LAbJrVKnExNOOTCU8uqpT0algywk2tsnHGVjC45uxGETMK9napIt4x9INjLOVpzfVIjAAp7kiQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sebastianbergstl4423","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"should've done a double-blind trial where the plants don't know if they're hearing music or not","like_count":5700,"author_id":"UCbuShYj9cF96pP32ORWu7vA","author":"@RoamingAdhocrat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n72uK77j5lpKqo4kFY0aLEQHe-_8QgyftO0qYPWNiYtUQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RoamingAdhocrat","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADUlwGW02IM","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Other folks have done that when studying whether plants react to the sound of a predator chewing on their neighbors. Their methods included 1) plants with no equipment in the room 2) just putting the equipment in the room, not turning it on 3) playing other kinds of sounds and 4) playing the sound of the caterpillar, that specifically eats that plant, chewing on a plant. The plants react by increasing the levels of tannin (iirc) in themselves to make them less tasty. (Zoe Schlanger has more neat experiments covered in her book The Light Eaters) Super neat stuff.","like_count":263,"author_id":"UCxhc_LfTuY6C-La4pVbgjbA","author":"@MeldaRavaniel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vSbuiFIfOuqEHATZ6mzMHn4hcnEreHgCEJF35WbgKVHOYCZXWNr6cALqB02j330JHpcugwnX=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MeldaRavaniel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADUn4EBbZO_","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"good point. if a mozart concerto plays in the woods do the trees sway?","like_count":113,"author_id":"UCx4VZx2Co8vLNxewj-HIvfQ","author":"@Sim-q9t","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8XKHqSWkWTWqWfEqmk_VKzILNNjD_Lzb82OiQOJGQrEQgbhrNF_TgQFrd7LuMlqJAqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sim-q9t","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADUP6eKtNSY","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Sounds more like double-deaf trial.","like_count":309,"author_id":"UCf7O52dxG6ypBlydjhGTSfw","author":"@woowooNeedsFaith","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kuKKw5EkQqOnk6aqMnGZEf4JV_3HGUqLYyG7OHvUg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@woowooNeedsFaith","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADUr8yVjfS5","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Lmfao","like_count":14,"author_id":"UC-nCRgm2Izeoa1klV4Nhk9Q","author":"@alilseman2979","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kegjxiQ2HeNHfA94IVIRIE_f1ZxH5o_aucVkp-oSLtS-0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alilseman2979","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADVlbWx5ItH","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"We need to try them with and without earmuffs :P","like_count":13,"author_id":"UCSWT3Ofbk74kn5HGs1AfTDw","author":"@Bozebo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMAWEJ-SiK_7yX-GyZGMPRkEpt6wiQjNwWvitOdE2-vQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bozebo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADZEC8WTfwf","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"While more research is needed I feel leaving Dolby Atmos outside the test setup was a huge oversight... But yeah, sample set should be huge and the test person shouldn't know which plants got played and which not, it should be correlated with the growth data at later phase.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCc4gInRLJ9jkk8V0Z9sLkKQ","author":"@McSlobo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lffhsJc-zHM8NM4yfLgIG2j3BvY9N8CKsg4hnvaEw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@McSlobo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADWPsgW1QYu","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Bias plants haha ... love it!","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCV8NBPQzgfhKs24KL0mta-g","author":"@Dafty_Boi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kPdB3ou7yuCkUsLFKJW2jgp1bWjzZS3WiFOSM5QRPAEj0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dafty_Boi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADXT1sF-VLg","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"I was \"like\" number 999. Congrats to whomever hits 1k!","like_count":6,"author_id":"UClH6-_LwHATF7mOTC_WpN0Q","author":"@Nphen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kaNIWxUvaWO7ygDoMBe4FNggNud3UtKJtl940JYnrt9w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nphen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAJDgmZEHwWO","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"More so. Some plants should have been told that they're special, but given no sound at all. Just to rule out another psychological bias.\nMaybe Ben should also not know what he's doing, to reduce the odds of him sneaking up at night and giving more fertilizer to the plants that receive sound 😂","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCnKVJiVBraJlF_-XMuy2HxQ","author":"@hickscorp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXWiHiQ-w6hRiU2wzQGZPOWF1DwKTP70A2EHzrhfMGsw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hickscorp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADZQDGlZtzs","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"cool profile picture","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCYAUwCxhrdTr6eqpXHn-I_A","author":"@greyemrednus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kXJHrmyvlG8Omi_bVIibnM9sp57NfzOXaETRq6BFLzIEs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@greyemrednus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADg5OZChnwj","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"That's not what double blind means","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCsZ4B2UzChnFwbpdNvU2IpQ","author":"@darkstudios001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nrfpKTA4q-WEgiJnht1Sl8rXS00UHWCLvoesUj9P412g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@darkstudios001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADtCZT4aqni","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Rookie mistake","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCxRYcx1fX9DgZURZg1P6FpQ","author":"@shineisland7447","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NJHUj8Q0X18_a9sbH42tluZQAQZtFiRfTj4UgNqlylLyO0iNhJ525XdXveqxKdHpttMW13YMIk4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shineisland7447","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADun1Ptt88Z","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Possible with binaural beats and pitch/tone frequency gennerators.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UClsqY3rRxkFogTthbpcnN2g","author":"@lmschlmbrvrmrnfyhstlsihx-9r","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Ut3e3id5cV80O4OHQVut46R4RdKM-YWkGcnzal21dKRZpGhGgpqoefqpPvul8FL3XNgU7s3PIA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lmschlmbrvrmrnfyhstlsihx-9r","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAJn8i4-uhNP","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Now I know what the monoliths in Egypt were for. It has been postulated they were using sound to heal. Egypt was the bread basket. What if they were using sound and vibrations with the pyramids to heal both people and make the plants grow better. The water making the pyramids vibrate or something. The Osiron (spelling?) they think was a water healing sound thing.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCF2cbRfjjFpL3C5ZfTCjgdw","author":"@JennySimon206","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VN_fCBBlG-V0erx3SLHKLTYls7kRSZs22ElR3ly905u_I8bYODF3kX7onKAduFSfKd9Ak1fiSA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JennySimon206","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADWaDozE6pV","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"And what is music?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCqyob4YLkyzLDyj6_P2STdg","author":"@RonNewsham","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nVA9tu5ZHhIwQ7zgw4y_bI5Ydu92RmLA7quQqswL_WNg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RonNewsham","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADWw2_X3nfz","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"😂 good one","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC3om5R3Y4w4HT5KfMW4z3BA","author":"@Ohwhale79","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n97oAoH3xkb1dmujrlA2KKTmLnFFaXDF5pYqPZ1hOqTQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ohwhale79","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADiwsZOcXmv","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Haha you're silly","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC44zYVsfORWI0phSJuQuZeA","author":"@fire34084","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nqA5ygwZNvoMVwFF90kOIkYsigSL9TxueEjvXXukKLjw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fire34084","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADyDBH7SHKU","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Lol 😂 ur awesome....","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCn6sN4bKlFUF0YXNbdea7hQ","author":"@Lumencraft-","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FRV_-OjiwNgefspgFGiNUS2fwyjyQeg7lxLhIJsJJqoKyUqGy4jOw-gflt5FOJwECU8StZWn_A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lumencraft-","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAJESe21tPmT","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"ok sounds dumb on surface but what if its the wires and the electricity that is going around it and not the sound itself, cos the sound is generated using transducers that are just magnet and coil what if you generate the em field and not the sound. \n\nso in essence it woudl be a double blind test","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCcUX_iEILSmQmZ12BpWZQGg","author":"@vasanthsreeram","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NObAC9ehzkoTgUxEKpBLm_zrm_rQJd8bQvvzJX-dgQ-JW2AFdDsvUr54zovH7xZ4abpSEQpCg6U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vasanthsreeram","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAM7Uo7pGEaj","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"For a proper double-blind trial you have to blindfold the plants, and yourself!\n:face-blue-smiling::hand-green-crystal-ball:😀😃😄😆😅🤣😂🙃","like_count":1,"author_id":"UClDXmiY8r0csi7HF0VDnT1w","author":"@bachtube11","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m_AbvIRcJmi6AFxWcjF8ubzRNanvouv7RgufvwBuo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bachtube11","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAOtdpzUHicJ","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"you need a placebo trail where you tell them the music is supposed to help","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCwz2Z_tGbU4Z726WMJ9ipFQ","author":"@FloralOvercast","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xL0osx_fMlKY_JjfR_1YBdw2540VmBfaAGmvjDe6j2QTZR4rbYbXbzCKuJK4ia6hMm6DEr19Aw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FloralOvercast","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAYij1WPSIPo","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Triple blind all the way, plants don’t know, scientists don’t know and there is no way to know which plants get the music and which didnt","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNlw1HKONp7-MAsQQziPSVg","author":"@YuriiTheHuman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_khrITzI7Y8J38vcku4Y8VZViR1Y9V4XoRtn0D9GNk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@YuriiTheHuman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAIOKQ_ZYVgp","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Thank you for this video!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZ0a_J9zF77qW_biY1UTw9Q","author":"@raven50491","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ltUH4ybLgxChs6nS3sN6nTXxZAPlAQKFYup3xhQC4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raven50491","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAKPKHBd5DIz","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Wouldn't it be hilarious if it was quantum effect, the plants you expect to grow faster, do.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLfAqSIADddvxJ_qtv0ZcuA","author":"@samgramajo116","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mGB8Jah7nDvDNJCRq3lDdIJRMj_0On_7EDjoMLf0Ifw2to=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@samgramajo116","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAKUUuTQScjq","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Maybe Blind Melon could conduct it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7LJiVT9v2UoSQi83AzdREg","author":"@russellm7530","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTsn_SEf4XL2vXIaaoqLUud5NQ9oq-8qVva6nli6qHfYKIw450e_k2BCXQMQ4EGZfOvw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@russellm7530","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAKo2hyhEn_F","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Please!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKPyfZoqWNE3Qx23rTJmDlA","author":"@Janesbongs","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mhsmnYE8s43yKvrOUEuO15ubUhsinTg2sCvnzOqI9_bv10vBFKsBHnJGDP5ESWQFEWmg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Janesbongs","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngALMBwxJHywf","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"considering plants just absorb whatever is given to them, i think its fair to say they didnt know","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCerHkC6mKu6TMZWEfbgXH-Q","author":"@Blox117","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3neoaHRkNiJPPdiwc0qoqULpnxhORQpWOwVzy0pjxwg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Blox117","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngALX4fy0WMmw","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"A better test would be to try it with a couple groups of plants that only hear either: no sound, nature, city scape sounds, people/animal sounds, different kinds of music. You could also compare different genres of music against each other at different time intervals. \n\nBasically there’s enough research to be done for 100 people for 100+ years.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgsJIvW1BwzSOAGfyFQloZQ","author":"@cyrilio","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iSfsHPVA0-WsXvZcaQ32JXruyZvIOCH99u1dRHnAjJAbWQlPI0ZLGd4OSbGqrFALIs7qsdQxUIM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cyrilio","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAMX_vi84xpx","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Got a chortle out of me. Take your like good person","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1t8bpxEBPMD3hK3hwxSxAg","author":"@daltoncrow6486","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_noRCoUHrk4Gi1OtXsecNqeDjuiO4PVFatiyZxwoes=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@daltoncrow6486","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAN1dTClANDy","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Excellent","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOlpfsbRUpiocNVlnnB3_zg","author":"@CoreenMontagna","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kE_7daLXy3sd9Mp5fka68rgRpTWgH572vGoGV1GGo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CoreenMontagna","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAN_bOts8yj2","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"That’s single blind :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuIdeDgxjaK5b0Bo4QQcAKw","author":"@michaelfuchs794","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l66pkjHn0wUBXmCzNZ4YMf3LVwchsx-yVL-iVLP5DyZChD=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelfuchs794","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAQbgSGR_Gfp","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"16:38 literally how I feel as a foreigner in highschool, I didn't do Ib, no one told me about it, and now I'm always  regretting it when someone asks if I am doing it. Context: there is an advanced program called IB in some schools in the states.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClVckN6wSC9CFr_1GyQJ55w","author":"@-Aloy-","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3zObwTPNdyStu8-3fcMqVRFeQ1DC5QUGaS0FAQLhFRYKWnrIA4o4tjmE-ZqsT16YIHxyWspL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@-Aloy-","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAS-ZHLQ2xoA","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"silly human you can only go blind once","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbqLCib3zb7Zl61UnUcFnBA","author":"@elementneon","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MQG9PiXrvUsAxAF6-d1cL0obRB0MFagrYEFBKombI3VQ2b2zKB14ebdlIpMXZ2Lw2UOdiyg2yQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@elementneon","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAWtkdv26BI5","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9jv_GesjjugmFExhW8UOJg","author":"@mvl3713","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ltwcVwpdqB1n2swCuE5xaN6XDEqXyl8wx19up1yv1XzQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mvl3713","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAX-0LUjQS3R","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEtYgEY2vKB7JkTjhs_xQ4Q","author":"@BradAcquilin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7pgkH9XKLTRPv4q2Go7lIuN2Hoa6Rp-SSFcN_GKer2KnrV9dKWpjrcoeV6dXOSYD-NaipgXNaA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BradAcquilin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAXM8_xYhQ96","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHSnbVj4ZcKm6ZnhulRGvtA","author":"@MTweedC4","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FvR7i3hY30FBOitEbU56CNehhgZtfOwY85uXjOwlIhUWFL3UjebsucSLK4oKoUjeVHnDxPt1=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MTweedC4","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAY8owYgmdEu","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"That would single blind/deaf. Double blind means both the treated and treator are blinded in the study, i.e. neither plants nor human experimentator know whether the sound or which sound or with which amplitude has been played.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW1ggJdLUjmh0Z7lj8R1YTQ","author":"@TheWanderingChemist","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l7rbdmMCa2EVgyv1sM24nRumRDJ89Kw52w8EznGEk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheWanderingChemist","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAYmc_lwaPLS","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"There is !!! It's only that they have shadow banned it for you not to know about it !!! How about that?!?!😊","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCG9yqZfTwREv3e7U9LrSPxQ","author":"@joecualquiera","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_magpIOxTWdWZZMngv3sqntz5LAoestlNEDXo_eCpg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joecualquiera","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADr3vZnwd6K","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Yeah. This is pseudo science 😒","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCbYOmoUU_8Yo9wNZYERh7Aw","author":"@policeman1104","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lhP9DuGU22hdF2MFYjaKVEMLyOe2hz0hwljs64LvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@policeman1104","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngADgQR8XuQcK","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Thats what happened when metal was played for them","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCeDswCa7_w4gwPuf6O0xBSg","author":"@jadabaudelaire118","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ne7u5s_RSkfoSf8dnvuxgd-JBNHhBHZWm44StKfQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jadabaudelaire118","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg.ADUKXfUTVngAE4rGr0Y8fE","parent":"Ugxd2to38jl3Wr45PmV4AaABAg","text":"Knowing they're hearing music would require them being sentient.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC5yum6iLOqU-MmdWluY4MdA","author":"@go56dofro","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZpeHMSH5m79IVWfdOv2Qtr05_WV-Nlxc-34gLnEA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@go56dofro","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzyI0y0UmDvMIPO0GV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Me blasting guns and roses, \"Welcome to the jungle\" at my one surviving house plant.","like_count":87,"author_id":"UC4MhVpbVhYyALv60_e1av3Q","author":"@carlomatismus8458","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k22jR4xs1jcwW8ZOqswoRwelrMCIxpYZncIx9YQsZ22WA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@carlomatismus8458","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzyI0y0UmDvMIPO0GV4AaABAg.AWmM-RvydkrA_2zEcx-8Hs","parent":"UgzyI0y0UmDvMIPO0GV4AaABAg","text":"Picturing this in my head actually made me cackle, thank you","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5dB7gjdoTQQe4ucczW0fOg","author":"@Doctor_Straing_Strange","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/N3vkf8oLNQUCJBckNQwXyVjLfZxU6ouFKYpAh_qwpsNRZvENR9Pzi2eaGO6cvg7wCDnKLJ6qQw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Doctor_Straing_Strange","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I believe you, Benn. I have listened to classical music every day of my life since infancy, and today I've been authoritavely informed - by a real doctor - that I have a larger than average biomass.","like_count":1100,"author_id":"UCvaueucz_Mw4tJV_zF5GZRg","author":"@MrBitflipper","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mBDtI_dZ7nP-j9mAfZPXToi4gpjrtg1P85uX0Edxc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrBitflipper","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg.ADUUXTMlJJEADjSoxJ4r70","parent":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg","text":"Bury biomass early, bury biomass often, endure.","like_count":14,"author_id":"UCSbGAOzAdNXWKm0FSm50exg","author":"@Cineenvenordquist","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTKNe3IKVZN6WgMc3GtF1dOm_XNZH13WTTPkuAlL5b5FE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cineenvenordquist","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg.ADUUXTMlJJEADqZ3vu6q3u","parent":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg","text":"I got like same effect with beer.","like_count":46,"author_id":"UCJDPq8Kq8zJrsNVam6Dl1zw","author":"@haraldlonn898","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lqdSlWVz-dEpxdbiHkjf9tawrlAtanLW83XT6H80Qh2w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@haraldlonn898","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg.ADUUXTMlJJEALCyP_e0U-5","parent":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg","text":"According to Dorothy Retallack’s book @19:05 you should listen to some Led Zep if you wanna lose some of that.","like_count":8,"author_id":"UC0ZfRoi3_0fY2-FS8RDChFQ","author":"@JohnQPublic143","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mc31H4lbvHOdudzj2WfmjeGM7VtzwWRA3zNvWWnw4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JohnQPublic143","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg.ADUUXTMlJJEAE8IDvg63Y5","parent":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg","text":"Rofl","like_count":4,"author_id":"UClWjDBvxg8gaVGUKg-sGbTA","author":"@slaffsla","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nao6LkpTcYTcNcntsrEK-IRNhsblHWgc6mqxfhzRME_pM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@slaffsla","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg.ADUUXTMlJJEALDP7n0-tDq","parent":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg","text":"This is how easy it could be to prove how this is simple anthropomorphism","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCjxJtcMoB-qMc0Jmzqcnrhw","author":"@monolith_g","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/tmxMB1ED-37suefo_RwEIBfQKLByn85AP7SXdI2heF05Ex92A7fxUYzX2VK-s3GSJWIay3K4VQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@monolith_g","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg.ADUUXTMlJJEARgA0HajuSM","parent":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg","text":"lol","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC902i18JmICsxquqxzxMENQ","author":"@SOVEREIGNDesigns","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4dZg45QcIPjobPSluipRQwwc1l7koKqBjbMqC8elx5BY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SOVEREIGNDesigns","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg.ADUUXTMlJJEADVSFZcC8r1","parent":"Ugzr1Pq9zIbkDW6oUYt4AaABAg","text":"Fatty","like_count":47,"author_id":"UCXMqPqRo1OQMYmx36YfscLQ","author":"@KILLRXNOEVIRUS","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/EBtTfupOP5csVMokQ0XDv3Nxf4OI1bLn0dLEdgQOrd6Jcw1jHkZCK6v7X6qiYlM5EXZFF197=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KILLRXNOEVIRUS","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think the most interesting thing to compare here is Wind Vs Sound. When you grow seedlings indoors you should have a fan constantly blowing on them or else the seedlings end up weak. The extra push from the wind strengthens their cells and makes them more rigid. This probably stimulates some growth in general but the wind also strips moisture away faster which can counteract extra growth. Maybe the sound waves can stimulate the plant without stripping moisture thus making it grow faster!","like_count":388,"author_id":"UC2UruAEdaagf4JdtnMP-LrQ","author":"@jacquesinthegarden","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sEbGg4CAwgXeWYw6lZMsWPWEIkdlmtRPtnQ6cSrzXCnG1Qyw7Fzhpcgh-kkI2t7yVjeYPvAwKA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jacquesinthegarden","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAJzrniKVIjF","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"I do research as a career and it's not surprising from the realm of molecular biology. Everything in the cell is sensitive to mechanical cues, and its been shown in many context that if you physically stimulate cells they grow thicker cytoskeletons (aka become \"tougher\"). Im assuming acoustic waves, or the wind, work in a similar fashion to make 'stronger' seedlings","like_count":24,"author_id":"UCbDRLs93zecYnXZSlmwZ5CA","author":"@phgzgz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ntGx1bbDOI1R7Z3i3Y8ZPggSnlzYyEZeNfCfMFWHYhTLD-7TzXhrwUGRICT2ubH8-hrw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@phgzgz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAJo28XIBHXu","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"Indoor growers always use fans to simulate wind flowing because it strengthens the plants and helps growth. Like resistance training for muscle","like_count":10,"author_id":"UC6H8p08X3F7NqNkgfMetZnw","author":"@billysgeo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pYPStuSX4i8LuOHb3szIB8Zo7H0K3vas3j1Q6rIKGYc5wPrg6vKOPLXf8ogvMNB315mMJODA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@billysgeo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAIKDpvYR1Q3","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"YES!\n\nWhat most of these experiments miss is the fan or wind.\r\n\r\nYou’d be surprised how much faster plants grow when you provide the right amount of wind pressure, along with some movement caused by that wind. First, test the effects of wind alone, and then test the sine wave along with the fan/wind.\r\n\r\nThere is already research showing that nearly all of these experiments are flawed. When plants receive the right amount of wind pressure and movement, adding sound makes no difference - they grow the same. However, if you grow them without any wind or movement, sound can help a little. The key is that they were missing natural movement and vibrations, which aid in nutrient translocation, as well as transpiration which is one of the most important factors of growth speed (nutrient intake and everything else)...\r\n\r\nTry it yourself!\r\nYou can find the optimal wind pressure for each plant online if you dig deep enough!","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCz2a3Yx7lOAYYr2gv7BvXVQ","author":"@heavygruby8476","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kDVWTVor4oDMnrA8JSn1QfWKy679_pAFdisj868GXmAFhdW5SbK7lG9s-tsd8cKauiOQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@heavygruby8476","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAJo1vm61G9a","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"Exactly. 👍","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC6H8p08X3F7NqNkgfMetZnw","author":"@billysgeo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pYPStuSX4i8LuOHb3szIB8Zo7H0K3vas3j1Q6rIKGYc5wPrg6vKOPLXf8ogvMNB315mMJODA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@billysgeo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAK-_oQVeBnL","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"This is the way","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCX3UBwWhZjby4d99f24hWxw","author":"@Boredhammer2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DbsXfpfYaqYDXw339BD0VkAttiOiPdA9focDsk7C0p5CoKB-dlqwj3RXjKBLr-id6qxivVnuAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Boredhammer2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAKSifyo3hwz","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"Yup i had a very similar theory.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCCFQznrIqVN7Xw-TdSlFqrQ","author":"@dknigh73","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nCguCeRFC4dF2gWCgyGdRPfF2wgCGisMvB9fLLuJo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dknigh73","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAMUvIeDeBub","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"It might also be interesting to do day/night at say 16/8 and do an A/B test with the sound only for 8h of \"day\" versus 8h at \"night\".  Maybe tease out if it's helping photosynthesis or other cellular activity?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCFJvyp4sJoiii3sLVrX4bzw","author":"@anubyt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kNarItmyzKRQV2Z5mC2xxApG_38cn0XRCJNbsgHQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@anubyt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAPwseFernDu","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"Its not entirely true. plants will grow bigger and faster with very little to no wind early days. As they get a little bigger you should start low at 10 mins wind per hour. too much wind will stunt growth way more than not enough\nif they're stretching and falling over you've probably not got enough light, turn it up a notch and you'll get a sturdy little plant","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-L3emAIEX-WZ4JzNKaMYWg","author":"@oligould8575","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8DpEU2KBaIXAEQS-s0n257wfxK1OUlZQm8MdJ1lM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oligould8575","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGARikNunTxTW","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"I always have 12 140mm PC fans running in my 4x4ft grow tent, it's a storm in there lol \n\nSo much better than occilating fans btw got tired of buying those for 50€ and them always breaking themselves in less than 6 month\n\nI use the high pressure fans for radiators and 3d printed mounts, 1 in each corner and 2 on each side","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJcnN165fsiBJipb2h0PZ4g","author":"@LuluTheCorgi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wpVKQq7MySQfniaF5vcoIDeScMLKw0-YiahwbS6b3qJt7X4ZGn3ZqTBqCTpHTUACYSqW-PjzSUc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LuluTheCorgi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAXtB2VrqPOn","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"Exactly my first thought! I first was like \"well, I wonder what the other differences were occuring within the tent,\" as working in a greenhouse I know that humidity and temp can easily \"settle\" in closed spaces. \n\nThen I was thinking about how the plant might react by being set on a vibration plate, having the growing set up attached to a fan that is vibrating as it runs, and having moving air jostle the plant. Is it the case that the plant treats all jostling/vibration the same, or do they react different to each sort of stimuli? Does one type affect cell structure more than others? Does one type elicit a different set of plant defense mechanisms than another type?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdZmKR7zULeX_-Dm_nB2PjA","author":"@Zen_Handlebars","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9RDbJaTbnEeDfO5Jk4MdMIl3t2otHsQAGTzlxwH91hCGU3ryODI105GPjSLVO-deTtNDBVIQTw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Zen_Handlebars","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg.AESBDbEcJJGAJheuIsNZcl","parent":"Ugzh83EBhLbPQn7QgDh4AaABAg","text":"I have no idea about that. I do not grow plants and won't need that info but it's exciting to learn nonetheless. Very cool.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC5rOZrcOdix9CFwo34MR-_w","author":"@BlueDuck-vv3eu","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l6LfiGUOovI1gGphSJuRe0J78AzT4UMRYC_hyCjtiSi8XqkNILzrxpVmBSvC9ns51YqA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BlueDuck-vv3eu","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwWyyN3L7OTrj55d4Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I really truly appreciate your zest for figuring stuff out balanced with your desire to see bad stuff dismantled. Thank you","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCUD6-rXkSBIV7-oloOr9DHg","author":"@Codaay","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FvUuTfCov4i2C2EuL66ZKIG_mHG27_0zmP_Rqfm8MdQ6pibnvcSHiPZkdozkluGWgrJ0xW7Yug=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Codaay","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In sterile environments like yours, where there is no natural wind, and you vibrate one group and not the others, I would expect exactly this. Plants respond very well to wind. Plants need movement to grow for multiple reasons.","like_count":614,"author_id":"UCCJgDMyqIc7urN3HGLio2kg","author":"@ramonbril","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kewPV0VmTV4zmJKtueGWn5OFTFYSkQMu80U_1LsuBgKWkH=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ramonbril","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADUOg4OxVYt","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Hmmm so what would be needed is testing plant growth in those conditions with or without sound","like_count":32,"author_id":"UCsYrY3qSWMRtniUKAiILhAQ","author":"@deathrobloxian","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_Yr0gZb6Uhxry3dx9-c984LN8oRlv-Q-ezaR3Zx6G_A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@deathrobloxian","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADV6rulosMA","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Yes I would like to see a separate experiment using small fans instead of sound.","like_count":24,"author_id":"UCB3P-2SfiD5jgnirDbWM9qw","author":"@thedanyesful","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lffMhP1wlHxsZ7aJmkXrdbBE_SbFZ4OevYzfUH988=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thedanyesful","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADVV41xSc4Q","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"I had the same thought when Benn was presenting his three theories! When the blades of grass are transpiring in still air, I assume the oxygen they emit would just have to diffuse through the rest of the air, creating a more O2-rich zone directly around the plant. Pressure waves could possibly shake things up and help the plant access CO2 more quickly.","like_count":22,"author_id":"UC6qiLnpZQW-Rl2NpqeuOm2A","author":"@rascaltwitch22","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZhA7_fxLsUtIjry3MtgVJx7yjSNy16mqWRBuZCpA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rascaltwitch22","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADVEEmBEJz3","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"I was slightly surprised that he went for levitation before an increase in CO2 transport and/or wind as hypothesis","like_count":15,"author_id":"UCBFE9mWe-cjCtbXjN-sJGbQ","author":"@tarpeyd12","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m35m1gzuePd0NvMP5dvTDu0TJl2yx3PfHcPN3VoO3AfqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tarpeyd12","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADVqH5F_4o5","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"fans or mechanical vibration have frequency content as well. perhaps replicate field-collected wind recordings: not audio recordings of wind across a mic, but anemometer readings?","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCnjFyq4GdclD4M-8m0yJ7yA","author":"@poofygoof","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTtVIReDaPHx0mdpXu8CjoiYK3WcB2seKIOiP8-JI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@poofygoof","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADXRvZh_0qR","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Imagine a human that never moves or stretches.. We all need movement","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCnDbn_Wa2PXMnyNu9hCCGJg","author":"@gay_unc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RIb-XY-H_BPQWokbMsg-NcDzPilf-T2AwdX8SNxsZEIuCt88-sgOhXSTNQjO_D-iR7k24baq=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gay_unc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADUzzc2uidD","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Next test. Should place the structure on a vibration plate - no audio, just vibration.","like_count":65,"author_id":"UC_vFFNwnE4jBXFNJUqg3nSg","author":"@jamesgrant3343","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mrqsE2i4bN8pt7AtHFCnJn9l2E_nUozLtD1HphzU4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jamesgrant3343","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADmmgqZBYQf","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"I did a similar experiment with plants in school and blasted one group with classical music and one with death metal and the death metal plants grew faster haha","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCq37heaAa60JobArqMw1bjQ","author":"@aurora-custom-concrete","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/u6dkCAWAgYA1uCtYcTn55i8UVnD6_u6HvkoF4_xp266Qwb8imgrMPQURhzj3JV9bDACgL4h3NZQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aurora-custom-concrete","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADrpJY_3wOi","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"This is my guess as well.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCaXRkt9jrEnVsfRr_PNwoUw","author":"@MadsterV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_HwK0b0_WV_1774a9jor63raUEKz1lUQfOxO-wTGGCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MadsterV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-AE0cx7HEl_2","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"YES!  We have freakishly strong wind where I am and our cherry tomato plants do better than other garden people in my area. BUT we ALSO have them in an area where they get light in the morning, and again from ~3pm - 8pm (in the summer). I was still getting RED cherry tomatoes from our plants Oct. 9, and they were finally getting close to done at Oct. 23rd (I have pictures). Other people's cherry tomatoes stopped ripening in Sept. 🤷‍♀️","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCFrkeqjBe0kB8tdl-N9GrJg","author":"@jessicaf6358","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mu7hfz-Asci-KneVHm6z7QOFtIJ1rNC89zfMdYqdQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jessicaf6358","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-AV6hf7AGN_O","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Also one can  hypothesize that the mechanism may be the disturbance of the air/plant boundary layer due to vibration. Thus, the exchange of \"breathed\" air with fresh air is increased. This may also happen in windy environments as a boundary layer persists although thinning out with wind speed. A problem may also be that wind also dries out leaves which may impact growth too.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCFardmia9RfxKQl4_WqJvqg","author":"@lalilu3382","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nUGw4jAqjLY5eQXTvzAmqPYv6aeCwZMi7VbuxLN9I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lalilu3382","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ADwZWxVWkRH","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"I don't think 4000 hz sound causes plants to vibrate any more than the hydro pump (and bubbles/current of water, hydro tents might be sterile but they certainly aren't silent or vibration less)... maybe the silia, but not the leaves like wind does. The only way to control for that would be another 4,000 hz wave which is the experiment. 2 more samples with wind is a good idea tho.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoqJ7oq6UfkyQMqjZdoCQ8A","author":"@jasonwakeman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lIxgxX7DPRtOYrBjCCWvFtBDt5QFBtIT66UZO6Esk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jasonwakeman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-AEDYfg1Bpmn","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"This makes the most sense to me. I feel like it’s even possible that some plant structures may act as compliant mechanisms that pump water and nutrients around within themselves","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmdRn3Nu5E_6cK2tbaKMl4A","author":"@ohokcool","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RlZpizvNVu-4L3AOQTSarH2Ag_CUKUAHtdpETlgf_vYR0yiw1uMLvvU1ywWggp7PquERwFUVmw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ohokcool","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-AJjL-Vrm1E_","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Have you looked into Michael Levin's work?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjqksZqCzm6hLTktdDOgYUA","author":"@yakiudon-c5i","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/alcHKgnIW-lmDsIYFMK4It8_SSDE4PCQmPFcxOWWxTsNvEawQkxY9QeAGGCdO_C1xuZuz6JaD4o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yakiudon-c5i","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-AJoOQL9vEg1","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Its all vibrations, brother. Imagine thinking it doesnt affect human aura","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-T4VpZ0sYRu4BRK8Sjo6Gw","author":"@CardsandCrypto","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FE-x0W-fbgbMoZSQtFfuVri0vIvEmerGCKh4umfSuMK99-NW36bwyomgBNHIA92UwufMnt3T9mA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CardsandCrypto","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-AKoLLbjKebd","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Keeps them exercising, but ugh the attitude 🙄","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC73lPWCETsyn365Ae_ghJzQ","author":"@mthomas1091","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsBrK1lw4dV11a0fgBp0rS6sd5GnSpQAHEx_UMtOg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mthomas1091","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-ANTOR90fH8f","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"Why consult with experts when you can just not? Don't you know this whole video is about how experts don't really know things?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdkH7SgymGzAXUdSMX2eThQ","author":"@LUM-kb2rl","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kPDMU8J-5OP_YtAcKVXOoReR_tew_AUnKDv_uWHEeEUrz_hb-YzHO526b6KJ0TceMuJQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LUM-kb2rl","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-AOCUmqSUom0","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"I know that whenever recording music in the studio you have to shut the fans off because they always make a sound","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoqN6SWtscN_rzMEsUm071w","author":"@ricoloco2803","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrC8dU1qXQUJcpoZX5Zxc53GkLZD0bJpJ2uGOIu8oEXH0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ricoloco2803","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg.ADUNmjVTkC-AS6GBvM4Xf0","parent":"UgyQ6l7la4wQcgMjRhh4AaABAg","text":"You really think the vibration of music is causing that much more airflow than the electric lights , if anything the electricity and music is wayyyu less than a 1mph wind, put a fan on any plant and it will grow better usually thats something everyone already knows, put a fan on both these plants and add music to one, put a stronger fan on a third, the difference in airflow from music explaining a large percentage of increased growth doesnt make any sense to me at least","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7Q9yvxbMpbcK0dIbcA3Jew","author":"@UrNotCupcake","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lhzfQ8kxinPOlurew0Wspi3cdCDEiKei9Urhqbps7itHRIYJDgyebki8Q8jHdUKH3NA7nRdL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@UrNotCupcake","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3 Things i noticed about your setup: \n1. The speakers have LED´s, are they affecting the growth or are the LED´s turned off during normal operation?\nThe second and the third point are about the stacking:\n2. Since the control is above the experiment could it not be that it is in a slightly warmer environment then the plants in focus?\n3. Since the control is at the top of the chamber there might be a humidity and CO2:O2 gradient within the chamber affecting its growth. So the top might be in a more humid and in a higher O2 concentration then the bottom one.","like_count":241,"author_id":"UCqUL5LRwl-NrEsA0At33qSw","author":"@fulli1921","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kcXEOu6k8h4vhd7TDiBQEyGlFlZxCRHzbQX8RkSVGKqSDE8MJMACx0THsWFFcXjtrIGA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fulli1921","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg.ADUcD4O_XIeADV3Z9yxEu1","parent":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg","text":"I was thinking this. Did you run a control experiment where everything was 100% the same (top and bottom trays, speakers present and powered on but without the tone playing), and confirm that the two trays grew the same amount as each other?","like_count":26,"author_id":"UCKUtqvQbBJmjmwKDqtmI4AQ","author":"@ashchap","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/t7TcqJYyn2JNKlCpwCg_a8BYZfuban90stu94YnQMmZaIRzIYAFzg7J6JkRsWvxFexW5_7iB=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ashchap","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg.ADUcD4O_XIeADWRAXi5y9d","parent":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg","text":"Yeah these are actually pretty big issues.  I'm a professional ecologist with a focus on quantitative methods, and there's been decades of work dealing with pseudoreplication issues specifically in ecological experiments conducted in greenhouses.  You can get plot-level effects from things like minor variations in lighting, how close the plot is to the door, etc., and if you don't mix your treatments up properly to average these effects out and have a statistical analysis that accounts for residual design effects, you'll be wildly misled about the phenomenon of interest.  There's a whole subset of stats called \"mixed effects modeling\" that is specifically designed to treat this issue, and it's super cool.  Unfortunately the practical upshot of this issue for Benn's particular experiment is that, in the worst case, the effective sample size could actually be far smaller than the number of plants and a statistical analysis that doesn't account for this is quite possibly positively misleading.","like_count":23,"author_id":"UCliqrXh1xdVFD8dxOEcfBng","author":"@danlwarren","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lCNg8GRPKtx5ZpsqoUwHMwiYdKL6OF099QLhzhp9QdRzA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danlwarren","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg.ADUcD4O_XIeADUpgsNyFqW","parent":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg","text":"Good point. If the room isn't even ventilated, maybe small air currents caused by heat differences and gas produced by the planets and/or their soil could play a role? Science is hard, but worth the effort. Great video.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCwywFErWGp4ndonhjjYFe8g","author":"@dat_chip","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nLhhFjwB0ruGd6uneZdjF_h4nuGoyaY0guiPxZ-HguJA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dat_chip","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg.ADUcD4O_XIeANZzd-tEOcG","parent":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg","text":"Also the light from above might be bouncing more of the walls to the lower one","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCLAlN53imDOVPP-rNxrEUPw","author":"@Jouniii","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cd-mJRPESWr3glDsRUW1iPl9l9JeVC4rnCTcusyy-S8XTfnXV-B-1E2KuHZ4sFbfjU_sXno55Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jouniii","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg.ADUcD4O_XIeADXY-nKV-4g","parent":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg","text":"OP, LEDs* plural, no apostrophe saying LED is. Diodes has no apostrophe. 🕊️","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZoaMxNp3As7KDAna-NBJ_A","author":"@thekeysman6760","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lThIgNF494biSlFOwWRM57q9AtOWrhYz84emx_97Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thekeysman6760","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg.ADUcD4O_XIeAKRQgHJC03x","parent":"UgwQ_d7c1ETfJcUB0Qh4AaABAg","text":"I agree, there is room for another study. But this was a great study","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiuwvNgYouv7pktPjC6qOVQ","author":"@lynnwilliam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGiaPm00GNQg-B5ZGyTGZM3l4k5_cPv9-5ZLHfgws=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lynnwilliam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Love this video. I was a plant scientist for the first twenty years of my career. I managed a project on plant sound perception as well. \"Plants like music\" is a thing we talked about a lot and how there were all these theories for something which we generally viewed as hokum. Not because of the \"crunchy\" vibes a lot of it gave off, but more that in the way we think. Like, we can't imagine a molecular mechanism in a plant which could perceive \"sound\". For us where we fall off is that the studies fail to articulate the quality of the \"sound\" (sometimes it's music, sometimes tones, etc.) but few go into comprehensive study. While there are plant \"mechanosensors\" which sense things like \"touch\" (another difficult word, because they actually sense strain on plant cell membranes). For our project there was this idea that these mechanosensors could react in such a way that a plant could discriminate between the sounds made by caterpillars eating the plants. We didn't really find anything. I wasn't surprised, because I could conceive of no means by which a plant could do this they just don't have the hardware for it.\n\n\nI mean we have a whole giant brain to process \"music\". Insects communicate with sound, but they actually can only percieve the sound that they make. Insects, with rare exception, cannot \"hear\" anything except the narrow range of sounds involved in their mating/signalling systems. A neighboring lab to ours studied Katydids, who are rare in the insect world because they can actually respond to both mating sounds and bat echolocation sounds (very different frequencies) and respond to them differently. They put electrodes in their heads and play them sounds. They have a sophisticated brain to do this with.\n\nPlants don't have that. \n\nHere's some notes on future investigations:\n\n* That is WAAAAAAAAY too much methlyene blue. Dilute that like 50X first please. The dye will accumulate in the nucleus, but you're not letting it do that by dumping it everywhere. Don't feel bad though, it's a classic beginner mistake.  The background should be completely transparent if stained (and washed) properly. \n\n* You should do a \"wind control\". Put a fan on some and make sure the difference isn't just the plants getting moved around and improved air circulation. My experience tells me that tent probably got pretty warm where we'd normally grow things at 22C, ~70% RH, and much better lighting.\n\n* Do any kind of statistics, at least show us all your data so we can do our own. The \"average\" is the least of the story, we need the variance. We need to see the spread of your data. That spread will tell you if ratio of the plant-to-plant variance is smaller than the sound vs. no sound treatment effect. Rotating the plants & speakers from both positions in your growth chamber daily is also important. My first job in grad school was to randomize the positions of 200 poplar tree seedlings in a very hot greenhouse. We were concerned about all the different ways the environment was not isotropic in the space. (Incidentally, this is one reason citizen/non-institutional scientists are at a disadvantage. The extraordinary lengths professional scientist go to is just way beyond what a non-wealthy person could do. You would get rejected out-of-hand for doing this in a grow tent instead a climate controlled growth chamber (some of these even have systems to maintain CO2 concentrations). I mean what relative humidity are you maintaining? For the plants we grew I could tell you right away that that grow tent will be too hot for them).\n\n* Your biomass measurement should ideally be dry mass and not wet mass. Like 95% of a plant's mass is water, and if we're measuring plant performance (as in, ability to increase biomass) you want to be sure that sound isn't just causing the plants to just expand their cells rather than dividing them.\n\n* I didnt notice if you said, but did you measure the root biomass too? A plant's roots could easily be 50% of the total biomass. There are lots of examples of gene mutations, treatments, etc. which increase aboveground biomass at the expense of belowground biomass.\n\n\n* You had your trials on different \"levels\" in your enclosure. In future experiments, you should move the speaker between these two levels to account for any effect of that. It would make sense to me that the upper level is warmer and collects more humidity.\n\n\nIf I was your PhD advisor I'd also encourage you to ask what it is you really want to know by \"Do plants grow better?\" Taller? More mass? More seeds? More viable seeds? Produce seeds quicker? Be more resistant to environmental stress?  There are lots of genes you can delete from a plant that make it grow better. If you delete the gene in tobacco that makes nicotine the plants will put on more biomass. Nicotine is a pretty \"expensive\" chemical for a plant to make. If you grew them outside though they'd be stripped bare by insects. Also, where is this extra biomass coming from? Are they just taking up more water? Are you saying sound is increasing photosynthesis? Or is sound decreasing the amount of some other energy-intensive plant process? Also, did you measure the root's biomass too? If so good, but if not, why not? Maybe sound causes the plants to suppress root growth. Do you think if you did it outside it would make a difference? Do you think a cornfield next to a noisy freeway grows better? If this effect is true, is it ecologically relevant? Of course I'd expect you to at least propose a mechanism for this. That's the only way you can design future experiments. \n\nAlso DM me with your data and I'd be happy to run a statistical analysis for you! Complete with charts and graphs :D","like_count":3000,"author_id":"UCY-8IYKMhyJBkAcRbDOIt9w","author":"@claytoncoffman2951","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n1V-FRQlIiExlZ8NTbaLwrXfT72CJQEh1WWtOFpmEH5RgA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@claytoncoffman2951","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADVOh0lR2IJ","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"This a very good critique, thank-you. Excellent video but if he wants to understand how to design a good experiment there is a little more to it. I hope he reads it!","like_count":271,"author_id":"UClfLn1EnkUYnhWa9UZnHUEg","author":"@nordboya1656","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l2za_DyyS7OqarT4QMNVyaobHZDI4yWC-hKK96_G8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nordboya1656","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADVVOz2gnS_","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Commenting for engagement cos this deserves to be read, at least, and really I think you deserve to get your hands on that data just for the effort you put in here.","like_count":207,"author_id":"UC-0ZrbD8pN4pwGmOxSqlRZg","author":"@bentrolley4316","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mVZvtjnpXC8KR1HrDHTpDD4lNTJECJG9Hs4kB9_J8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bentrolley4316","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADVaUiom6EH","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Nice response! Say - I've heard (but never verified) that air pressure fluctuations on a different scale may change the conditions enough that plants growth patterns respond - such as wind conditions strengthening or modifying root growth. Any validity to those conjectures? If so, then we may simply need to re-adjust the experiment of Acoustic Stimuli to Very Low Frequency Oscillation ranges of Delta P over Delta T? 🤔","like_count":44,"author_id":"UCt8JkLB6HFWP83phOSVXBaw","author":"@billsybainbridge3362","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lvJRjRHkInOarXEnYvpMGWiU7BRAkXJRu-ww-kfLFpiw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@billsybainbridge3362","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADWc1tnTsvp","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"I think one thing most people miss is that \"sound\" is just our interpretation of mechanical waves(vibration) propagating through the air. If plants can sense pressure in any way it is possible they sense the vibrations.","like_count":41,"author_id":"UCn_j7CuJ6dN6k2Ci3stzVyQ","author":"@chocomalk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WbCoN9gJoiBlYalow5NoyWI_JcidhaXUFDvxPG4ep-HAsGV1iaxNPYW_pZVRzcfuvvtJqGxQbQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chocomalk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADVWu0rdg8I","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"This is a really good comment. I’m not an academic or a scientist myself, but I have a lot of friends who are, and honestly it seems like 99% of the job of experimental science is just getting more and more and more dialed in on making every single aspect of the experiment controlled and accounted for, for like, a decade. But, I still think this level of thing is super useful and cool. He’ll hit a limit of what’s possible to him, but as he says, if he’s sharing the data, then it’s all super useful stuff.","like_count":127,"author_id":"UCZwH9PubZHL_ajyZvvIIIYg","author":"@Bezz_Jeens","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4Up1V2FoBfaI8y2Wi_JQHXnK625RjjCl0SkXVP3PKRrYz-xVG79LM17JkBjc0TnJL5AoKHpT=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bezz_Jeens","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADVnDmMlvGa","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"I really hope he reads this! Fantastic critiques.","like_count":31,"author_id":"UCr0rUH4onhEqmb1ahyp_c1Q","author":"@kaitlyn__L","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LtR47bxehVeH3YwdHNtqvJ-t7-8_f68Oj0o8vR2tP1TD6vS8UBoMXPF23K0eEad99CU10m6KMic=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kaitlyn__L","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADW5SRGAqpe","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Thank you ! That was super cool and interesting to read, and it gave me a clearer idea of what pro scientists do.","like_count":30,"author_id":"UCD0Fv3C6QYsxZi0__J-KOOA","author":"@JeromeJaglale","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kmbQw-RcqAl6auub_rG5pdmSukoXHB_8JoTIrQ1LJ0uQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JeromeJaglale","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADXdHEiwqtf","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"I ran a slightly less scientific study back in the day when I may or may not have been growing cannabis. I found that they grew faster and more robustly when I played music for them. They responded most positively to Bob Marley, ironically.","like_count":15,"author_id":"UCOVt_uqIlfaVH1ZoJovrTZA","author":"@marcjones2493","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1rgM3t3SXkCBaBsBnDK-WviZuMFYPpdAuD4Qdoyu06A3mjJIAbi_y9SLrDID4VFdxNhuXfgiuh0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@marcjones2493","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADX3iYSS0Dx","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"As someone who studied science in multiple disciplines (I didn't finish all my studies) and who now works with plants and occasionally does experiments with them, I'm ashamed to admit that sometimes I just leave out the outer row of plants to get some uniformity :P\n\nEdge effect is a female dog.","like_count":12,"author_id":"UC-0_MZltaVskeI71Hoe349w","author":"@egregius9314","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGIzjFeBv1nRE2bPLsyY_uxG3ZgH8KZwuV8dVyWmUVkg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@egregius9314","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADXVUYKpw8q","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Thanks for participating so genuinely and enthusiastically in Ben’s experiment!!! It’s wonderful to have a scientific conversation about earnest and well designed investigations that can be easily criticized as pseudoscience because of the prejudice some folks bring to this topic. Let’s learn something, and watch out for the “magical effect” pitfall, in which no plausible mechanism exists for the effect in question. Your background in plant biology is thus super useful, and I love the suggestion that Ben should try a fan to blow air around, both to mix the air and to stress the mechanoreceptors. I work in the field of medical ultrasound, and the debate about whether ultrasound accelerates wound healing is fraught with similar questions. Carry on gentlefolk!","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCtEMxdniQLK3x_-zPXiI6ug","author":"@pejoka","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l4pwDPpqiW_0q4-7MM1DRshnSmOUxmlJdDQPhh2gfVmM4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pejoka","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADXYN1KFzj_","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"I think one of the big areas of interest in recent research has been the Ca2+ ion concentrations mediated by acoustic stimulus response in some subsystem affecting MCA channel proteins.  Several studies have reported Ca2+ cellular responses to acoustic stimulus, and I think there is some model building around interactions with MCAs and microtubules and sound, but I haven't seen anything that purports to give an end-to-end causal chain from acoustic stimulus to the metrics of these kinds of tests like biomass growth.  I know they've found a number of minor effects to other surface proteins in their metabolic function due to acoustic stimulus, but those are typically pretty small or occur at ultrasonic frequencies.  However, I've seen some papers showing panels of tested proteins with some standout effects that seemed significant.  Obviously, with panel reports, you have greater instance opportunity for significance fluctuations that are meaningless long-term, so they all needed followup for individual causal analysis, but I've never seen anything quite as promising as the evidence around the MCA channels.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCDjxeZ3HnTwLg5vmWiogSzQ","author":"@theEx0du5","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mE7B1t7FZ1ORt1egWbzhQjodGvxTxSpzqpg3eGsA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@theEx0du5","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADigvSOkKbu","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"BRO MAKE A CHANNEL AND START MAKING CONTENT. YOU SEEM EDUCATED. PEOPLE NEED YOU OUT HERE MAKING US SMART","like_count":9,"author_id":"UCvXVwsHPD2BxbYrEkUt0SMA","author":"@krisdrums","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/uYZ_jKO9fkzsMadLlM0aDl9a_HgDfjxsJVHil9EWCx1uJEcOWUGIRlXKc38pF77IMJeezFLDN1k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@krisdrums","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADWjpl8ip1o","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"This is awesome thank you for the detail and knowledge","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCFznbK64QJm1pW8OS0kWEMQ","author":"@barcodetheworld","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lwWq5TnZKUOr0QRXHZmY50vIOLcBPF8s0BeE5fgJhoqA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@barcodetheworld","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADjs6Hq-B53","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"bro still hasnt read or replied, shame","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCpC8DqU3flcelz9Em_kDyWA","author":"@mikebiff","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xwJLjFVAngUkWSMlycY1zmOIvjlrlBeJvHIleZfp6VJdBddQ2u1pSq5H2Vms_viMFG20XTt2_w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mikebiff","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADWUJgkixec","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Nice critique","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCopeKpNRTz2-MtOlF8Gjq7A","author":"@Vhill7299","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FaluIdBrOoEebuZbLfdGAW86ENbYssIQx-FuAEJwfxLSwfc9xf-BP_bVYWQR14PX7oMPTsjQoA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Vhill7299","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADWpWdkXgrl","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Also suggest having two sets of apparatus. Run control and treatment at the same time. Then switch conditions across apparatus and repeat","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC25Vsu5ZfrAvV5VkTgfcKBg","author":"@andrewolney","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhoibYeeU0ymrWzDhv6TozqD1ELmB8vHF_83nh63APwGY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andrewolney","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADXL6ekNtxm","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Wow","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCeIVTTw3ksebouJONyxoivQ","author":"@ryun_d3v","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RscICWMrYK54s1tTiQ2TT7nnxXiIdwMoD_dGzGMhq5tGxhIxoHXm1I2A8a0-sfnXWMnyrH_VVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ryun_d3v","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADoXGMiPxTZ","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Thank you for your comment… coming from another plant scientist/research greenhouse manager","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCSZ7tSGLwq5bsZJ7hYkafZw","author":"@treemanog112","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ktmneEuF5DKR86Pb1zyCb2ck_bWFSOVfo-dMC4vAu1kQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@treemanog112","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADXaHfKmKk-","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Super insightful, thank you","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCN9mU0Vb4-9LmzAz61cTlKw","author":"@DuCanonCreative","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vjq-F6_WVGxoFzNHS8FTWYcA9vANDO4gNSuD_yHA7JP5bFRQdtCDcHsbvPsweZrkS7j_FMasJ4g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DuCanonCreative","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADYuHqJobbh","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"wow... I didn't know plants even could be scientists...","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCLwydIkVDJCzVb5dGUVb3HA","author":"@cloppyclip","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/jqDMKs0gBQInwldToDJYiVlCJiyBoz_6ZeLmg7J9Lgv8G8Muqf5zqEgxg_Jrm6M24MJVmbINmQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cloppyclip","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADcRaKtui7p","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"What an awesome response.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCR_r2s2QNJGGmIFNwVnIJNw","author":"@MatthewPherigo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lmRyh62ivxpTxKQD6R-txY0KYveskp1GWPw4w47g5OowI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MatthewPherigo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADjMWK6GqUX","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"As a student, that likes plants, these comment has been helpful.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCp11iCHwpLNqIa04KtqNZ5w","author":"@andresdiaz7938","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llyeyiJqYwBw-1YwHoBg5jLpN68QiQbwHRME-boDw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andresdiaz7938","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADsu0ywj8Sp","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Benn?\n\nAlo?","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCFgjAF-laI9YOBi1bNqDxaA","author":"@TheChzoronzon","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hUsFZfPV9e2l-HS0p5-QK3MXlqdO6ArkS7qBB8Evg6w_F4Xkrg3QOoHeDAOG8RdN4jVWohmc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheChzoronzon","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAEOxPV3B_5q","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Whoa this guy plants. No but seriously I work in computational physics and it’s always refreshing to see people who really know their stuff provide peer review online in a constructive way. It’s also cool to see how fields other than my own apply the scientific method to experimentation.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCgM1LbXTWG_dbhoKz7fKkRw","author":"@markhaus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lv_rLcX8egnD8lbdltzdoyFq_4BGZVslzmfDdlopcavUg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@markhaus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADdMZkqSwt7","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"I really should have scrolled through the comments to read this before I asked my little question about sound vibration taking the place of the \"touch\" of natural wind. This was very educational.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC-JgQKyUXrAhn3n61xzIq2A","author":"@Harringtonize","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lK0KU15BcWy0IQsqyj1RBiZwdbp9iPnquLmAiCdwQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Harringtonize","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAJVMyP9eDVt","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Very cool comment that makes me appreciate how little YT experiments really prove sometimes 😔\nIt takes an incredible amount of dedication 'n knowledge to even know of all these variables. \nConsidering that it'll be faster to get great results by sponsoring a local lab to conduct the experiment for you, maybe less expensive then buying all this stuff yourself anyways.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCHG5kM-aUkfeUwOSSNAmuQw","author":"@littlemonztergaming8665","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mPnTi0Af1Ki_BfzIlZXxr5h9UyS9xtDQkXfzH6UnyBeg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@littlemonztergaming8665","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrARUWPUOsUfE","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"A reminder for the kids who grew up on Mythbusters just how much detail really goes into experimental design  for professional scientists.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCvrRYvB6zjSaj7mN9fGpTug","author":"@Amanda-C.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3rfTTWFtXrtapsMJZUUsBaNXaFGrYpCkOimudYdg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Amanda-C.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADb7-e72ZOH","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Woop woop, science discussion!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCKpuF-Kz9LtwFz9gOgwh-iw","author":"@RedHeadForester","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_klUvPCD_ZkDsXaL5llzpMBW9kk1wDlzjJBpzZI-gc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RedHeadForester","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADe4-V7-sGe","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Thanks for this as it has justified my results from growing gourmet mushrooms and my less academic comment.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCCUPrZPMf9RgvIHKQm6AYeQ","author":"@magicclippy101","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/X_6cuho4swAPvystENVg1H1WFUKgVE_s9MZ8TEoOXO-t9J8P1DJkn60mGTfszmncPghLWSR50eg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@magicclippy101","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADhivgPpLJz","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"You need a level control.  My wife has done experiments like this, and controlling for the position of the plants is important.  My hypothesis is that it comes down to temperature.  It could also be that the monitors generate a small amount of heat.  You could have a heat control.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCOyaFMBrbfsiXj7Ccm-Bt7A","author":"@xlat808","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m-sN5mb4PXnrNxl08ipTMUoMX7Zxf1WmLD5KcAKbzGX6dW=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@xlat808","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADjE1aV5JdC","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"So do you think the plants are reacting to some sort of biochemical frequency relationship....I'm not smart maybe I didn't ask that right. Like is it sound or is it something in sound that you could make with electricity or kinetic energy or whatever...","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCRZXVDa_WWgAY9JNCi-5LMQ","author":"@CoD420NiNjA","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/PQlEsEgnnxFs8Sfhha0sFJtUtN5TIph2u2uUBH7kTAVTNf_36Tz3_MNr-uBDARggM_N5dDIu24s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CoD420NiNjA","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAE0fCz52WxD","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"MinuteEarth has a video about how all plants have color vision. Not really related just to say that sometimes humans not realizing there's a mechanism for sensation doesn't mean there is no mechanism","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC02SdLN7lozZv852PwOumtw","author":"@gaston7261","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JAo9MoztKuYeM7_1YXErvwUw_DHtd0UTl3KzfeBvyF4Zs1kAxvHOQkfUaERm4F0QAcAtg91P=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gaston7261","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAEAyKtLIK-y","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Great reply!\n\nIf there is any sort of evolutionary factor to this then you would expect animal or insect sounds to have an impact. Especially if it is insect sounds then you would expect to maybe see increases in the expression of anti-insect compounds in plants that would produce those compounds. Much more likely, though, I imagine that stem stimulation, temperature, or transpiration to be the culprit and maybe root intake or some sort of stimulation of enzymatic activity, genetic activity, or germination.\n\nThe stem stimulation is straight forward. It's well known that light wind stimulation on seedlings increases their growth by stimulating growth of their stems through minor stresses. If the sound waves were able to stimulate the stems in a similar way then that could explain the increased growth. You mention this in your own comment.\n\nTemperature can be produced from sound waves especially if you have 2 opposing soundwaves of the same frequency causing constructive and destructive interference increasing the total wave amplitude and energy transferred to the medium as heat. Heat has a massive impact on germination and seedling growth so checking to see if this increased temperature in any significant way would be important.\n\nSeedling transpiration is also an incredibly important. The greater the rate of transpiration the more nutrient will be moving through the plant and fueling its growth. If the sound waves, through pressure or temperature or even air circulation are helping the seedlings transpire more efficiently then that could also be an explanation for their increased growth.\n\nIn a similar vein, if the sound waves are helping with passive root intake of nutrients then it could be a factor. Since this is a hydroponic set up I think this would be less of a factor but I don't know enough about the specifics of root biochemistry to really say.\n\nFor the stimulation of germination you could look at mass germination rates or germination speeds. You would have to be monitoring temperature but otherwise I think this would be straight forward to check. I don't think it would explain such a big growth difference though.\n\nAnd stimulation of genetic or enzymatic activity falls into that sort of technically possible but really hard to test area of science. Which genes or enzymes are being stimulated? How? Is it increasing the activity of an enzyme like a protein pump? Is it helping to bias the binding of CO2 over O2 for Rubisco? Is it helping with cell division or simply leading to increased activation of genes? I know there are some incredible genetic testing machines that could probably help with this but I imagine finding and showing strong certainty for a specific biochemical pathway impacted by sound would be a huge head ache of a task.\n\nEither way this is a really fascinating topic and I love that even such a simple question can turn into a massive rabbit hole of hypotheses, variables, and even more questions. It really is why science is both amazing and a big mess all at once.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCAJ793dLoIFet281OoFWcrA","author":"@DeBezzir","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lAc5dph2OBI6wk15p0KgPDFDejyPNT08bR_wIpyxM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DeBezzir","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAMfJ1sCBAWc","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"I keep reading in the comments that plants would not process sound as they don’t have a brain to be able to. Could the plants use those tiny hairs to pick up vibrations and process the info through an underground web system connecting plant roots like the fungus I keep reading about?\n\nI would love to hear from the researchers. I not a stem person. (I couldn’t resist the pun).","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCdswbQ39Yix8QcexCuwGvHg","author":"@Kigo-9999","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n3Xx1mvCz_szHdpA0RIWCc5V_SU_8pU0mTDoG0t2ChO9BdC1UxtAQdNr99K6YVG_TEcg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Kigo-9999","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAS_AbW_7da2","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Hey Clayton if you see this I’m investigating this now. Have you seen anything promising. Plants don’t need brains to interpret audio to have benefits . Sound influences humans without psychoacoustics either. Would’ve good to hear your thoughts .","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCsiSjUuN_-nM2cmrr_iR3cw","author":"@i.i4115","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k2mUi7v-IWO_mJV_pvzoujSEUZtgac7KfwlgdeqVk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@i.i4115","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAWtdHaZdBDQ","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"This is my favourite video comment I think I’ve ever read.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCPRIwmlBWKb2mNFleb_YvIQ","author":"@pete65390","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nusKmZATTFepe_OlKa8JyO-6iYOa1X47MpI9Y2RzmxHnb3yNgJRjgNAhXoZlMjqL8eQA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pete65390","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAWxaLEdeDew","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Why isn't the study focused on vibration instead of if plants \"hear\"","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCojA4sTovuIFYyyZ4iBJvLQ","author":"@bjangles8718","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/jogadvY6JZC4VEo5xAohoeJmzfMOcuvIt3Pjbs5KKpGlAxSRBWe9HidrSf6tvfr2TtysSlke=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bjangles8718","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADossvp-Gn6","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Hey look the internet","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfH0hBDhzkCz3hJG7E1-XBg","author":"@OnionSauceGo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/nc506eX3r0oH52sHbIF6rUATSdHkvjgNAoy836NC1ggNsGOhhn7HyMAVTNx0Fx8QX5J_rjhv7g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@OnionSauceGo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADqJYZ1Wmlf","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Yay for the actively controlled science. Only when all other variables are controlled for, can you assert that the variable you're testing is the one making the difference.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwjmMHHmZeySIq-zWAgEhNg","author":"@tealkerberus748","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nJZvybahcAuL_0ERBaLv-h0YXKtJ1TL1JX8lREas2nnQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tealkerberus748","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADrPZ-NlA37","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"An elegant critique! Bravo!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZasdoPn7Vqa-DvnBzbSGhA","author":"@karendunbar8321","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mo-ngw2iXTjilc4X3R9TWfKMVubJaaWmP-E9AYx2N-KkwGfZ7Ck2wgooJGVstqf0wbRw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@karendunbar8321","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADuFlhNwcgn","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"The gold is in there comments","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzuaBfEVysvRsWcBPJBB8kg","author":"@APOCRYPHAL","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nDMk5FH_6OE0x8YWK8hTXZ5oy9NZnPqozQk86OUOpyjlw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@APOCRYPHAL","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrADun3aem4nJ","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"aw a real scientist. this is so great. what other areas have you scienced in if i may ask?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRauoZNxL1eoj6ZmTO2aXGQ","author":"@twentyNinebark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ukElNbttLSKd5oL_VxXqdloxYnFXjbTqDl8C4tT7Ln50zUr18oBS2XRBDoPjgw--y2lhWx0okg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@twentyNinebark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAEB0DdzQTqr","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Disclaimer: \nI know plants don't really hear water - it's more a vibrational effect, possibly a magnetic effect and the ec of the soil changing as feeder roots spit out more mechanoreceptors to detect moisture (all?)\nSidenote: Roots have to use water to find water.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUuXxb6mJctk3rk9AXkFZXQ","author":"@Freedom_Born","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ncD84pzDUCY6-IdQ6Hlcr9wz2dz8m6W-ANuu5E5NiP_18=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Freedom_Born","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAEI34DnNB4g","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Clayton.... let's get. In touch somehow.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJ9WmKSn2vFMiEB2gqa258g","author":"@ganjagridplantvibrationtra72","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nm3hfpwPJB63ecm5HYHSfchyqaleaG4GFIQoK0il_qWwlU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ganjagridplantvibrationtra72","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAFIUYRWZZZV","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Love the detailed and insightful response here! Hopefully Benn reads and responds to it :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCujUEiE1wPZCF3ECE3oQpPA","author":"@wujuntanktips","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x1TFg4PutogeN3Cr8bprK1ZShUresuKQzgWOolF744JG05PwG5DFJN1M7UmdWE4wdD_C9D3IFQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wujuntanktips","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAFixObYS_mj","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"true scientist","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3gScVAtwy7k4LzSOJkFJSA","author":"@akioasakura3624","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n5YPbnptyDT8sTAnZY-LLNnr-TpCLblaWqDc3Kxp0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@akioasakura3624","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAFjKMyQHDsC","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"I love this so much. I read the entire comment.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChW7ThnE0gW_bfhFD5HgQwA","author":"@amandajones661","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMfes_rNm0OdcigH_scQrkPeGzHlxY8sJ205trXLk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@amandajones661","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAFmSSAVLx6z","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Great information! Is Ben also forgetting a control, like a plants in another tent with similar conditions without exposition to the sounds?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9MT6JOa4M4gBUTcUQhoFpw","author":"@oblique_strtG","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lBc8A6NLGWuH3jOHt0D3qfN1Di8Vuk2KhXqQNQB6fFMpt6dyTCL2KPf6tIdech3tj4nQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oblique_strtG","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAG6F0esu1E4","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Thanks so much for this contribution. As a relatively new flower farner this was so insightful.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4OfvyQsYYer5PIf3nuigow","author":"@anthonyrau5313","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_8dqTzeCifyNvyvBmg6mS0UI2OMlHCprBfrTl1BE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@anthonyrau5313","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg.ADUv5ET1WDrAGOSgL2mSH_","parent":"Ugwy_dSOO8xN7owelxF4AaABAg","text":"Here:","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCq-jEZSNKWUF8eAP_XlAeqA","author":"@STARBROTHEROFANOTHER","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_miAAAPZKICt45qLVk9PCfhKibQpsxJuYKJ1jCv5OhzuED7_B4kfBYRTHdu6Lm8ocHlAQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@STARBROTHEROFANOTHER","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyfpXDVfLaKtcc_EAJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a metalhead that regularly blasts his house plants with music, this video is what I have been waiting for","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCQUR-fbTlCK2q7MBPSBt6NA","author":"@ein_stain","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZMoprs1gBPydCY0jmjOYA01Eg9Preh5yaUX7uyxXdueN0EkxytUrpjMdtYvJuonmnXfOOzZmWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ein_stain","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz7-h3IPEgm4SaMy6V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Airflow from fans (or even physically pushing with a machine) has been used in horticulture for some time to increase the hardiness of plants. \nThe process of lifting themselves back up makes the plants stronger. \nBecause of this I lean towards the acoustic pressure being the cause of your results.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCp5h8K0puPmXMcgNh7IyEKA","author":"@Datadog-1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/eYEDADnNg7MWEL_u-efUEIkpATK379CSRTSrBTGdeBqpzTbUoAPZLCg31WHIb3MlPrYN7RDMbA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Datadog-1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hmmm, whenever I play any of the music that I've made for my plants, they get up and leaf.","like_count":163,"author_id":"UCJoMg1q1_Z2c6OdL7YaM_7w","author":"@GlasTaibhse","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lFxgJkPkiRfGJ-pBqnK-9FP4xUQXwuElmUKz7hfWRc_vAZ-2dn_KqTefonj_oPQ57D8J30P_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GlasTaibhse","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg.ADUSgddMVm2ADXYCxUZGfs","parent":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg","text":"Perhaps genre-wise you could try branching out.","like_count":12,"author_id":"UCZoaMxNp3As7KDAna-NBJ_A","author":"@thekeysman6760","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lThIgNF494biSlFOwWRM57q9AtOWrhYz84emx_97Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thekeysman6760","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg.ADUSgddMVm2ADUk55nKpFe","parent":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg","text":"\"you make like a tree and you get outta here\"","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCUk7047n9otBzDH2031cHhg","author":"@stephpicher","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kGhg7z3TajaH13604Fp4erI4PL9Utzs3eqvb9oXBDw0FA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stephpicher","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg.ADUSgddMVm2ADvtJtyfDeC","parent":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg","text":"You should really dig-in and grow this theory.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UC3Gvcmvt4mdrmp0t0DQifcQ","author":"@TheRainHarvester","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_naoVGMajsT4qos-zJiLrxcaYmemiURl3qCOCoMmnhWew=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheRainHarvester","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg.ADUSgddMVm2ALj4z5sWtoP","parent":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg","text":"hello fellow clippy","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCWcOjhP85wselK6goQoT9JQ","author":"@jadedzilla","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/HvG_DaFGPIO2jeW2aO-r7Y_x8YtMQuaZ_Z1E2WqSkd-uQZkROTtHAJduo1QUW4lj9WUFhZgPFyg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jadedzilla","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg.ADUSgddMVm2AQnBapAgELA","parent":"UgyIjx08aaAjMvsIuO14AaABAg","text":"\"Badum tahh\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX1Dy0LfYyIAM6IDqIMKbdg","author":"@MilGrip76","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fpVJHl_QXhtfkrwL9zPU7yGKbGVfVNVSoMqfzVtwdcPzPSdcJJ0JZnINu3kznqTz0MQ_ehyRKg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MilGrip76","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your 'mic clip' meme game is next level in this video.","like_count":375,"author_id":"UC40ckFNo6lHmNLQrUcBECAw","author":"@intriguedviewer501","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Jds20mIro-HIhxaf6Fn2xRYDar0I-AVv5kmMFPe7SA3bMrDGr0jQxGgfhYrt6Mu-5XlKZGjJDA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@intriguedviewer501","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg.ADUJLOMnnFvADUKZkAwy7e","parent":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg","text":"The stick mic stand was especially amusing. 😂","like_count":30,"author_id":"UCigAHxHbgY3OwH4SXK51-wQ","author":"@ultimatediscdork","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lk29fmSZY8NbCfWog7LxCiHTPzt4HDIHf11tsItZ_Llv4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ultimatediscdork","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg.ADUJLOMnnFvADUUPfDP46W","parent":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg","text":"I came here for this comment and to encourage further exploration of mic clip performance art.","like_count":19,"author_id":"UCzx1yn9yY1OKCN5OyKSK3eg","author":"@raisonvarner8175","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k0fnYuh6uIWx2TX5IXZxI6nk5gcV65HPZbtUWlmA0GcA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raisonvarner8175","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg.ADUJLOMnnFvADV4r58ZUm1","parent":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg","text":"Sound engineer; Pillow at 3:56 actually has some merit, a slightly empirical meme…😅","like_count":12,"author_id":"UCcAiVaSrLxeBnracnL67hfQ","author":"@musiqtee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kbaIW6-zGon-T51qIpyqa0v_LScC255ml1Ud0ZdLcXRZk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@musiqtee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg.ADUJLOMnnFvADWoSJtmhce","parent":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg","text":"As an amateur dumb enough to do his own electrical work, I appreciate the wire stripper mic especially.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCj56fBVrV5fEtGZsBBkEc6g","author":"@robertfoshizzle","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4NPWNubSRsA5FQZUNyVN3nRfZys2l0KKNjQ5Fb48fnHI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robertfoshizzle","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg.ADUJLOMnnFvAILFNCtJ_Av","parent":"UgzIb4ojbsqjQYIKaIl4AaABAg","text":"Damn, now I’ll have to watch the video again just to focus on the mic sticks that I’ve missed. 😁","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCTULJZjdklKjU7XEdo5dufA","author":"@Conservator.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lEhbgMxXYYs63K2ExQJTM5_uSbbWwqKrZL3TgXRZCFvUQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Conservator.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1Len8tdQBb89DJfJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My mom's potted plants won't see Perverts by Ethel Cain coming","like_count":18,"author_id":"UCUn1GH1ju_2-fZzFr2uev5Q","author":"@WarisAmirMohammad","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mzksONrz3OSuVyyUUITS-9yLU_QutU4tCOAyRp5DM_vrG8UFaU5FJrp_beNznUEi3uUg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WarisAmirMohammad","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw4Zym8MFhf-4Mc4eh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The random “so what’s up with you?”made me laugh out loud…and the sound created when I laughed helped my weed plants grow marginally faster. I knew this one was gonna be good. Kudos Benn.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCgJPVG8n0JhhEzDTQNuxePw","author":"@shauncarter924","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kIM8be1uSG68RKdQ-7HEufp7qWjI0TfRxxHdFVlaA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shauncarter924","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwYjWnH7ijSgyOgn2Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:12 those plants gonna be crispy at 6000K","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCpoOPjkKRQOlktJUN686JuA","author":"@tkAmaee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ngZOaSYLP3OS1LcGOt9Q5W63NbK4dOqQdtGQBAYEYVS0g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tkAmaee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"2:41 this can't be true they have someone called Robert Plant in their band.","like_count":111,"author_id":"UCdzwSqzjr25gtTVKbGnoi2w","author":"@Alex-cw3rz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n0P3r2dt_xOW7IMpld2RrxGBWw0u14CCrewTD_k6rGgh-rAJJjEjQc9tcAQhDqX28vZA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Alex-cw3rz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg.ADUHLUoMjNlADUkCBAENLg","parent":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg","text":"Imagine if Roger Waters them.","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCUk7047n9otBzDH2031cHhg","author":"@stephpicher","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kGhg7z3TajaH13604Fp4erI4PL9Utzs3eqvb9oXBDw0FA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stephpicher","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg.ADUHLUoMjNlADUO4YNQSwC","parent":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg","text":"Yeah, what the heck - even the name \"Robert\" meaning origins are \"bright\", \"fame\" \"glory\"\n\nA godly, well-light Plant, won't affect? What's next!?","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCHp3t0B_h4gbw_PY2EcfJpg","author":"@kaspartambur","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ng4Avg8FE3iHftVx57Sv63eZV9yoMX7JorAar03CuBvVk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kaspartambur","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg.ADUHLUoMjNlADUUivUvroq","parent":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg","text":"Yeah, but Jimmy Page is pretty confrontational, since pages are largely made from cellulose. I know I’d find it pretty hard to focus on the music of someone named Gary Flayshisfriends.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC-RzIGaefbdBreCIHRD96KQ","author":"@silverXnoise","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Nd5T55oLrKNWc1gwUBFnuyae3EkGjvqIQzcUEV7vI0Pct0UvvfEqQGPxBAWadH5lbjNw1KNh=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@silverXnoise","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg.ADUHLUoMjNlADXCavMpHMb","parent":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg","text":"this joke is only zoso","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCoawpfYLWm4rvp5Qcd1I0sQ","author":"@notaverygoodusername","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kv2C2XY6azYV8TaHbRgnbKdlA6ojOUp0KRNb6oUQI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@notaverygoodusername","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg.ADUHLUoMjNlADgrXwGMKJn","parent":"UgyzCSYET3SijWTd7614AaABAg","text":"😂😂😂","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCO2kaE26-SwJhOaChvPxjaw","author":"@vladimirhaviernik3568","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hN75blUt_yX43s7WE3fF3BUUSdZntb706NGwdJ9PYTtLfyC6-bdiM6snX0orib5etE5Wf6bsJQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vladimirhaviernik3568","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzSlfO1TuvvSxtEqyh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hello Ben! I love enjoying the fruits of your curiosity. I'm a mathematician and want to clarify a couple of things about Kurt Gödel's incompletness theorem. It only applies to formal systems that can make statements about arithmetic, not to reality in general. Further note that a true statement about arithmetic that cannot be proven in one formal system may be provably in another. The therom is about the deficiencies of formal systems, not truth.","like_count":86,"author_id":"UCR3-Qw_baqHlZdM97lO28sg","author":"@shawnmurphy4757","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mzzlCtTku22SAt3Ld3vOsH4rzknqsVyd0Pa3MNH4khyTY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shawnmurphy4757","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzSlfO1TuvvSxtEqyh4AaABAg.ADZMK55X1jjAMkFCxC8HfB","parent":"UgzSlfO1TuvvSxtEqyh4AaABAg","text":"You know that moment when you were being taught to compute the area under a velocity curve to compute distance  and in a flash of insight you see integral and differential calculus in a new, more revealing light?  Just had one of those moments!!!   Thank you  Shawn!  Bad ass!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCk83cL1FzGQ7pcUVSxm25TA","author":"@jasonbender2459","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJ4zCCUHXS1NoVE-jewo-r5p2FiIF7nZw8hO0rkvvLc2w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jasonbender2459","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwWPEq3f_tfkcQJOR94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:56 you cracked me up so much and so unexpectedly with this","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCfrbrxarqXG2g07N9Voop6g","author":"@Malkovith2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9ZG8uzBGWRUKY11N9Y0P3s4hFkkd9IosTPia-q24FtHwtqujwSWz_bJdwT9xdNGTwGFQDRvYO_Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Malkovith2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxUPUkvBAsNYwbP5CV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This man spends insane amounts of time and energy and resources in his videos. And I relate to you on the barriers to the scientists who are not formally scientists","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCYeuWevgirLl4bHa2gd8cng","author":"@randomdosing7535","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/e8_DexZWjqkSVunNbmkM2-7eRj5H1NnzfTQpf345hXFiza6N6AeeQTfrZSetSpHJNFPd1gsm=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@randomdosing7535","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQbZUFgQKp418VywV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:47 was golden","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCh7sbPNc5ZQaOo41q9A_egQ","author":"@thecianinator","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kNcx7AKLzbN62cUxpf3U5tlt5Wdrn_utHR6gC07ME4OQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thecianinator","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Home Depot plays classical at night for the plants lol","like_count":119,"author_id":"UCzxF4Mzqc7mwExlKl_GQdYA","author":"@BirdieBlrrrd","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2goab4b__dB9ywBotaEITBVwZsNDCTuSFinrdhoKGPx6hsZ86emc5iVtIP-WtrxutqXJ_QoOxQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BirdieBlrrrd","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg.ADUJa9vbtrSADUKcuXMr4d","parent":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg","text":"What?!?? Really? That's amazing. I need to inquire about this","like_count":68,"author_id":"UCshObcm-nLhbu8MY50EZ5Ng","author":"@BennJordan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n4yN6OoQTOtdKr9MtPVRhT38hPTP0NUkc10Ni6wZWljek_9XRq0EuBi7PbmJb2bRs_WxcgQe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":true,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BennJordan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg.ADUJa9vbtrSADUPlijwQCs","parent":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg","text":"Dood ussually in the day it's Smooth dad jazz lol","like_count":13,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg.ADUJa9vbtrSADUv-OCXWms","parent":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg","text":"are you sure that's not to keep the youth away?","like_count":11,"author_id":"UC0RhRTzx0ujABtGFMeqLs6w","author":"@mozismobile","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ntNOgV4nbcAo5Bb--Wwko3CtZ608hQQOWMEaTjma8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mozismobile","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg.ADUJa9vbtrSADV4OPDaj-C","parent":"UgzqRZ2vaTGNDGk21xZ4AaABAg","text":"No home depot anywhere in my state does that. Either its just some weird local policy, or you made that up.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCzhLkXbKDmKMjK7Ar-cgsvA","author":"@Vgamer311","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kW_bXWV7k4rFx3O4HSuLuPPIiF4METw-9WTio0KxCwg4CGcdBkOEn6xuHTqAYiwQcNLQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Vgamer311","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgztayK7NlFmUCQs-Zd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"After learning that we only understood that green light breaks groups of water molecules helping to cool down green surfaces more efficiently in 2023, which is possibly why chlorophyll in plants optimally would be a green pigment (there are non-green plants in different conditions) I'm no longer surprised we don't know basic things.","like_count":61,"author_id":"UCdzfYee_9n_vmLa9m7hg-MQ","author":"@dmitryburlakov6920","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYJekDouvi502EuO3umxExYnwZH6KidliHje2O0NCnLao=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dmitryburlakov6920","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgztayK7NlFmUCQs-Zd4AaABAg.ADUFEjURaIPADUWA-s1SVb","parent":"UgztayK7NlFmUCQs-Zd4AaABAg","text":"wtf they figured out photosynthesis? baller","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCh_lyyX4YjECiChtU8AJ_qA","author":"@EugeneHoverhand","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/T2OJ9PwwvRuZrqceAodERfQ6bHfFOEI3BbMRRgdGo0eDVnxnKtydtkm7YQG6n5LGjyjWgeKm_hM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EugeneHoverhand","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgztayK7NlFmUCQs-Zd4AaABAg.ADUFEjURaIPADjVT1aT4C1","parent":"UgztayK7NlFmUCQs-Zd4AaABAg","text":"That's fine, but chlorophyll isn't a surface compound but does absorb (but also re-emit some) VIS that would damage DNA and RNA, spectrum-wise?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSbGAOzAdNXWKm0FSm50exg","author":"@Cineenvenordquist","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTKNe3IKVZN6WgMc3GtF1dOm_XNZH13WTTPkuAlL5b5FE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cineenvenordquist","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgztayK7NlFmUCQs-Zd4AaABAg.ADUFEjURaIPADxxR5_6qhc","parent":"UgztayK7NlFmUCQs-Zd4AaABAg","text":"In 2023 we also learned that blue colored objects tended to survive the Lahaina wildphyres, thus supporting the theory that much of the heating (or, rather, cooling) there had something to do with the repulsion of blue light.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLPO5ESK9R15Q38yk4Rb1uQ","author":"@ToxiCom-777","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7uxzOYs3cWZHUogcV2qlr8O1-PfJD2vAlHqx2mU4eHF_ZY_Q0YeM0_Z910jrl8G-jwAR5-feJA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ToxiCom-777","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My theory: the processes that make their vascular systems work are affected by physical vibrations (i.e. wind, in nature), and sound likewise has corresponding effects. Makes sense that sonic/subsonic/supersonic vibrations would have effects on plants, simply because you're apply forces across them... and likewise, it makes sense that the results would vary based on the characteristics of the vibrations... and likewise (part 2), it makes sense that the maximum impact to their overall growth wouldn't be the zero-input condition.","like_count":83,"author_id":"UCGesXQ87nLZJScIBhtVNj_Q","author":"@seedmole","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/INLZZTg-yE1Q9HjYUQjnbpJw2K-vKcfCkxi8HKAODr1sBIJJTuCs4naM1DdxgaXc7oHeariiQg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@seedmole","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADUV8QVwNeK","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"Came here to say this but from a purely mechanical perspective: a plant subjected to movement (as seen in breeze/wind) will build tougher structures and therefore strengthen it's cellular systems overall","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCk83NPgGukaXyfu3iq5TBFA","author":"@JB-fh1bb","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kpit39kzF0M2fVdGyNL-sRS3K42066_MMYrTrP2No=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JB-fh1bb","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADUMYzCySLH","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"Yup. Look at the research of vibrating plates on muscle and bone density.  Mammals benefit from vibrations too, just at much lower rates.  Cats most likely stay agile and strong despite being horribly lazy because the frequency of their purr helps muscle and bone.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC6ao0eTUn8gs4lW4ErMa3nQ","author":"@ScottPHardin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/i_phrJf-bumQK_W-ioYOHumw99BPpEtwWdYBSHWCQwm1fgg1UlnGG03zKpYITD6Vt5P8oEEcyK8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ScottPHardin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADUNma0bJKD","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"This was my own layman's theory. I just assume sonic energy helps the transpiration of co2 into the pores on a molecular level and increases photosynthesis.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC2-2WRy6Evru_UGw1jEGaug","author":"@WestCoastWheelman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pd5U5KYQlKwWMBv_7OcaW55i2UlbRESrehPcf9rTGeLjmbM1xDrVrmCUqtnIGuLGKh6MVWyjkA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WestCoastWheelman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADUfUNz2lK9","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"My theory: sonic transducers have been shown to speed bone repair \n\nCertain vibrations from sound may mimic vibrations experienced by plants undergoing stress from wind, encouraging deeper roots and thicker stalks.\n\nGrowing plants together tends to dwarf them slightly because plants in the middle are protected from wind.\n\nOne thing would be to determine the harmonic resonance of plant leaves and stems and then see if sounds played at those frequencies stimulate more growth than others.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC0tOjwSyPjJrlKW3OoKurkA","author":"@DanielJoyce","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kGehn1oAKiBWKRcW-qihcQb5DFFsTZF9pr5Km_eGnxmjZq=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DanielJoyce","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADgpOqSHUxo","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"Also might be a Lunar cycle? Or air composition indoors. But mechanical vibrations helping cells work sounds reasonable.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTMMhzudkfaRkSgewx9nayA","author":"@Baronello","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOS7IRkbame0zzn6zYDRBIP4j0eercHO1W6RHlum-W1w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Baronello","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ARDUEl3iheU","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"How does this increase biomass production? How does a plant get signaled to increase biomass production? Remember theres chemical signals involved here. Whatever physics happens here, you beed to show this makes the plant produce more biomass by the same method. The plant will still have the same number of photosynthetic aparatus, the same number of CO2 molecules going in, Rubisco will still work at the same efficiency. How does the vascular system help produce more biomass? I am not claiming this explanation isn't the case, but remember that the plant is seeming opersting at the same capacity as it would even if the vascular system didn't change. I would have to lean more of signals to the plant that increase photosynthetic production to show this actually leads to more biomass. A comment below proposed vibrations increase CO2 absoption at a molecular level... I don't know if there's any evidence that this can happen, but of we assune this is possible, then they have a better explanation: more CO2 available increases Rubisco production, we have to remember that since Rubisco works with blar Carbon and Oxygen, the fact that the plant has some oxygen in its system, means Rubisco will make the mistake of use oxygen instead of CO2, but with more CO2 (increasing CO2:O2 frequency), Rubisco makes less mistakes, and increases carbon fixation.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRKcR8zHPyE0_FDkyuYWnkw","author":"@MrFreakHeavy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lpq-cAEN_6e0FaopfGuCKu2K-GWjprwRlm6czV0pbQoQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrFreakHeavy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADUL2YkIXL7","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"+1 to seed moles opinion.\n(Original commenter, if name changes)","like_count":2,"author_id":"UChS9ADu0h_XKimePDpbv-pw","author":"@antman7673","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m7JEpNpvtEeaUxH6l4zGpXJtMa5wC0--kbWnessVFwXbbc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@antman7673","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADULbsE32UA","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"I will test that method in my growtent too 🥦💚✌️","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCSrbKTbEYghjI1hrOeIHj0w","author":"@swineapplebbq6485","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bFLn_wzaRT1dasHS4NN8QoG99enjmcCR2NzV_EAsr5dfcYowErqAkLwUlezLCd31kLQDU_94q1E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@swineapplebbq6485","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADUfKkjBxgG","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"But would that not make more sense for the drums instead of the violin to have the best results?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7Uylw4VdINbCMRJCaeYeEA","author":"@therasco400","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kZX-aHwmD4tOaaEhfFb-KiaggaBnrXseXRP5dzBfg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@therasco400","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg.ADUGo7GMqP0ADUHiNXEzzR","parent":"Ugyq4_U-UiZKCWCZdOl4AaABAg","text":"Yeah I could buy vibrations... but it seems likelier the music draws humans and other mammals to the planted area and they will provide excrement and exhalations that impact the growth of the plants in better known ways","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCcqSMvjERFtayHaS6Xnbrdw","author":"@swindel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nDzAnMfE3wPMPlPZ7dwj2aOyP6VTb72tPfkJCXEho=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@swindel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwzkSgdkSyC_B9KWVt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You put my feelings toward repeatability and the philosophy of science into words so much better than I could. What a satisfying video to watch.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCV0bx6qpX_cGKKjKhX9LxfQ","author":"@andrewdavis6687","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mzuTwxRQ5Q9C2HgdXj3bD1mFp5kWFmp5JWK1G0trwfnR0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andrewdavis6687","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx_i3HCLKJU5qw1kI94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The segment about the Karmen Line (7 min) made me LOL\nGood one","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCf8WDfyxZf7vOdqmRHB0avA","author":"@banderson8444","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nNXJISngLqkbbEJ7ZjbJBqsrga7LDpw65aRVm2Iyk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@banderson8444","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7dev7y8f3x5vocAJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I have an idea, 15:18, I know certain plants grow better with some wind presence because they're adapted to having to resist that push. Maybe the pressure wave is like a \"workout\" for the plant. Could test if this is worth investigating further by checking the improvement rate of plants that naturally occur in windy areas (like most grasses) vs. a species that typically wouldn't have that exposure, like a ground plant from the jungle. If I'm right, the jungle plants would see significantly less improvement than plains plants.","like_count":27,"author_id":"UCjA2CHPzU1FlqAU_MZLSMmA","author":"@thomashokanson2001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nrr4-L9oqpKKPCK9Y-XxPaRPUuBC57NjFaoS591zfPTcE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thomashokanson2001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPHxURnW2rPjzjgud4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"During rainy periods, the plants that i have in the greenhoue and get exactly the same amount of water as always grow noticeable faster. I'm pretty sure plants evolved to speed up growth when it rains, becasue of the incoming amount of water, becasue of water carrying out seeds or wathevr, but yeah, sound is a notorious part of the rain, and thunder might even let plants know its coming in advance.","like_count":26,"author_id":"UCEgLQ_el0iqtYTbEfVTanGw","author":"@SUB0PT1MAL","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wd1WzlJreo9uzihzWkv0_J0XQHrVtgZBY5ux0sfSODX-TaIpG6iX6Fc9hs0aLl-AQ2tftnVej1w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SUB0PT1MAL","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPHxURnW2rPjzjgud4AaABAg.ADUiTijyHixADfjpkq9rAP","parent":"UgwPHxURnW2rPjzjgud4AaABAg","text":"When it rains outside the humidity indoor is higher.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClv1_fTQAZMI_ykRXwH8OVw","author":"@jsbrads1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nXMQq3zo6BZnD4OKSqqK2UzkyRaUocapNOkGwoOlQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jsbrads1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTmb5_0X8A9lP-yod4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i got an undergrad in acoustics and one of my classmates studied this for a final project.","like_count":21,"author_id":"UCNLrRyEFnvnhR6YlTzZVWEg","author":"@erich1394","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nSfvpwx2PhzSyU_M9n8lYAW4FpFEtfDQKtXbsvQ-B6gqpO6a-tAgKgrKCG1CzDX25FcA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@erich1394","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTmb5_0X8A9lP-yod4AaABAg.ADUFcWXYD5cADUPR_BxJNZ","parent":"UgzTmb5_0X8A9lP-yod4AaABAg","text":"all REAL","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTmb5_0X8A9lP-yod4AaABAg.ADUFcWXYD5cAE2xMVBAX4K","parent":"UgzTmb5_0X8A9lP-yod4AaABAg","text":"Any conclusions?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8uLlDUzGRcyxcYxrXNzn7Q","author":"@justinw1765","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lW0uE0YE5HajZzGsO5Pg2j_fUOCP2xdVZa89BindY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@justinw1765","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwMfGKMHoar2IZmHCV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The first thing  thought about was that sound could improve the gas-exchange of the plant with the environment.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCb4-GilI5kP2OL_wblsZMOg","author":"@maartenvd2653","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kFuuBAmjXoVt_JPqPIDd5NK-9bPkmD2YQ61lMfBlYnUm0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maartenvd2653","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwMfGKMHoar2IZmHCV4AaABAg.AF3EAhleb-3AWvv_sSuZvM","parent":"UgwMfGKMHoar2IZmHCV4AaABAg","text":"Same here. I think that is the explanation.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNZ0JHORLi7Cax-LrYKCymA","author":"@FLPhotoCatcher","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k4HWAm3QjnizdPvi3Lr8hs3LrzA__54OFNGmc_W7qvbg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FLPhotoCatcher","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxMS5pdFK4-rNKX5_Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This was a fascinating roller coaster that I didn't think I would get to the end of, but I'm glad I did.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMKGGJdMzyj4Stze1w6TKAw","author":"@kenichigoXtomoshimo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llgFIwjI1QDr-2wtHADMkJDa493yXEd4TmnZv8Z9xWTC0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kenichigoXtomoshimo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwelM3NFCjXt7BeS9d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a former academic and music producer, I'm glad I exist in a timeline where Benn gets to do whatever the fuck he wants. Epistemology is win.","like_count":186,"author_id":"UCWsK8eMs5R7ABXo7n6SLbuw","author":"@orphic-trench","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/j8pxxymLm5QaokZcaUBIA_8ecrw57U13Gw0r7pbJmGrlYPLCfMSwx82DSm-B2gyvHUB6jxj1=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@orphic-trench","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwelM3NFCjXt7BeS9d4AaABAg.ADUcVZYkm9YADXY5bZgmzn","parent":"UgwelM3NFCjXt7BeS9d4AaABAg","text":"It sounds like you don't know what epistemology is. 😐","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCZoaMxNp3As7KDAna-NBJ_A","author":"@thekeysman6760","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lThIgNF494biSlFOwWRM57q9AtOWrhYz84emx_97Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thekeysman6760","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzeJjcd9_hSeiIglFR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:13 could’ve done a bit talking loud here to honor the late great Lynch but this was probably recorded/edited long ago","like_count":12,"author_id":"UCZlAi7KWRWBLpmDrK2tvaOQ","author":"@Tuckermoore","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FNO6n0wmbYNo0xsCwQ-NSbewCAcCOd5IZz7GXYnCul1Meoj0aBkezFB6ZNRIHGdDq8yHkuPVwQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tuckermoore","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi Benn, I’m actually a plant pathologist that works in ag research, and a large part of my job is designing/maintaining in planta assays similar to yours. I’m also a huge fan of your work, so please don’t take some of my points/questions as a personal attack to your experiment and/or video. On the contrary, I definitely want to see future experiments to better help answer your central question!\n\nSpeaking of central question, let’s start there. I rewatched the video and took notes, but (and I’m sorry if I missed it) what is the central (or even foundational) question you are trying to answer? This is something that I’ve personally seen PhDs fail to do, and it’s often the most underlooked facet of an experiment. \n\nFor instance, is the central question of your experiment asking:\n“Does a continuous sine wave played at 4kHz lead to an increase of overall plant biomass (shoot + root) after 12 days from initial sowing?”\n\nEDIT: I see that it’s “Does sound help plants grow?”, however what if there’s a preferred “sonic range” and once you get outside of it, there’s a negative impact on the plant’s growth? Look at it as starting from a central and testable question and build from there.\n\nGetting to your methods, there are a few variables that would be ideal to check off as not a factor in your results. This is actually a reason why experience is important (in reference to your point about the first question you’re asked at talks being background related). 100% yes absolutely, there is an ego around specific institutions and universities. It’s the same in any career field, and while I hate the nose upwardness, I partially get it from where it stems from: how do you know what to look for that isn’t a potential driving factor (variable) in your results?\n\nA good example of this is I’m not a plant physiologist, so I wouldn’t be a good resource and/or have sufficient experience to classify nutrient deficiencies/toxicities in an abiotic type assay as others with a stronger background than mine. I could set up an assay similar to yours, but at the end of the day, I don’t know all the potential drivers that could affect my results and how they apply to my discussion/interpretation of the data. Moreover, this supports why there’s a hierarchical nature/organization for any field of research.\n\nSorry, for real now getting back to methods, in regard to the lights being used, have you measured the light intensity at the soil surface for each set of plants? Light intensity is another underlooked variable for in planta experiments in ag research.\n\nAlso, and this one is really important, 22 hour light cycles are incredibly stressful for any plant, even if it’s a C-4 plant like wheat or corn. Plants in general need sufficient dark periods just as much as light ones. It’s important for their circadian rhythm as night times are essential for regulating their defense mechanisms. Something I believe would be worth trying, is drop the light cycle to 16-8 (light hours-dark hours) and run your experiment a few times swamping each rack of plants at all the various heights of your setup with each new run. Furthermore, I would measure the temperature of the soil surface across each rack of your setup to see if there are any significant temp differences, just to insure it’s not a potential variable. \n\nAs for seed health, I love where your head’s at with weighing and making sure all seeds are similarly sized. Seed size is usually an indicator of a seed’s overall health, i.e. bigger seeds usually lead to healthier plants (at least with field crops). \n\nIt also kind of goes without saying to make sure there aren’t any cracks and signs of pathogenic infection. A good way to measure this is to perform a germination experiment beforehand to get a baseline impression on the overall health of the seed you’re using. Also, by measuring the germination rate of your seed, you can account for (or check off) seed health as not a potential variable.\n\nAs for measuring and further interpreting your results, I have a couple of recommendations:\n\n1. I would measure and primarily focus on Shoot Fresh Weight. That is cutting the plant at the soil surface (if you’re measuring the height as well, do it beforehand ofc) and use the weight of the above ground tissue as a data point. SFW is a widely common and accepted measure of a plant’s overall health. I wouldn’t focus as much on the below ground tissue as roots (and even the process of extracting and cleaning them) can be highly variable (at least more than SFW).\n\n2. I would figure out a way to quantify or measure the “activity” you observed using the microscope at 40Hz.\n\nFor #2, another point I would like to make is that science is a lot about quantifying a result/observation. That’s where you get into those crazy formulas you were describing in your video. As humans, we are inherently biased, and one of the most effective ways at controlling those biases, is through properly quantifying an observation into data. At the end of the day, while humans lie (even subconsciously) data doesn’t.\n\nIn closing, I sincerely hope my comment doesn’t come off as an discredit or dismantling of your experiment. I say all these things to further improve your protocol and shed some insight on how the scientific community works. Furthermore, I’ve always been fascinated with the potential effect of music (or in this case, sound waves) on the overall growth and health of a plant, and I would love to contribute to your work anyway I can!\n\nAll the best,\nTreyheartsweed\n\nP.S. I’ve been struggling with trying to find a place to insert this, but I wanted to share with you one of the best pieces of advice my mentor gave me:\n“the only failures in science are poorly designed experiments”","like_count":239,"author_id":"UCXHnlEABBY_mqRLzvNM9kRA","author":"@treyheartsweed2342","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mN0QNk0y59kjHZNrWG-FagRhaJ0F1f2YnfvaOeXhs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@treyheartsweed2342","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2ADWxly4NkaT","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"Great comment, man","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCu24abdxW8kn1jkYq-80ZhQ","author":"@KneeNinja1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXX0Fy4RI3Q6ch7AaAmVdKYKGeoXcTDYJi9S1fj5U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KneeNinja1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2ADXLs9rthmq","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"I thought your post was wonderful! I gave a thumbs up in hope he reads!","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC2jFerPTGjzuv9w4rsPJeWw","author":"@williamblank2213","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m1vDLKt-xGFvP-5six5wf-RbsD2IBk7y4Ckf24sBs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@williamblank2213","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2ASnKZIQQLtB","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"Nerd","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCDOe6CNcAK7ZGXQY3LTkxbw","author":"@fadedflage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nNRmuCpCx77mP5hJtlP24UwNyYzIAACSVUNSWcI7U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fadedflage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2ADjTidQJaTB","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"Obv. tag the exosome, piezoproteins and pumps or pores, respiration effects (this is more tagging and microscopy rather?) and grab an exegesis on the literature on sound and microbiome of your plant domain.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCSbGAOzAdNXWKm0FSm50exg","author":"@Cineenvenordquist","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTKNe3IKVZN6WgMc3GtF1dOm_XNZH13WTTPkuAlL5b5FE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cineenvenordquist","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2AWqpYC2ZAKC","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"Bro didn't see this :(","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCQhUM8yAlmjetnLsoJcwmNA","author":"@user-en5vj6vr2u","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nNoSs34o59tjwNK65bBhe1lnW80I9VvZ-SlljHFTrYC8M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@user-en5vj6vr2u","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2AD_WOBrseOJ","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"🎉🎉","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAM4vq57Z6-Mb5k4_UA1gyw","author":"@youretheChrist","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1LaXdaKMQLskaCFS1TFumMqxK0VlDq7yUTXI6_luzH0DrFbGWvOeENDOavnZnmh1hlg9rPlEKrs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@youretheChrist","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2AMbtxL7d0F2","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"It would be really great if you reposted your comment to your channel in a post so it can be archived ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1wa-t064oE6r7pogqG1MXw","author":"@Wanhope2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kskRORQDdiL77woWW2hQBzwjI6doIBz_bh5vl2b6c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Wanhope2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2ADWVVLQFVCE","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"Hiya, it looks like the question is set out in the first couple of minutes: does music help plants grow (larger &/or faster, maybe better (for a given value of 'better')) in response to Retallack's book.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCKkQVYeSN2a_MVbs-4hQDzw","author":"@Jablicek","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nHLpwCc6-2J0SskIalBikhKgLNU09KysQVxH4txiXgoQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jablicek","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg.ADUeg8COiO2ADX1YE1LMu8","parent":"Ugz-o67ClPz80-w8tXd4AaABAg","text":"This is why science is so stagnant. You miss the forest for the trees. Focusing on an arbitrary minor aspect on attempt to disprove the experiment. Why don't you make the experiment to your specifications to satisfy yourself.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC0Ga0OyKX2M0WHmYsRs3MeQ","author":"@thesteve4235","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMTd0bTprnq2t5KuLHbMZsxlUitmJZQonKmMWMpsc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thesteve4235","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwpH0Hrg4O_kIfJNDh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"there are no dissapointing outcomes. Results of proper scientific method can only reward you.... And any criticism should only enlighten you.\" \nAmen. Very VERY well said.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCmeB9ondyED0FIccydR-yKw","author":"@youbewb5581","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhkFhwTpTADDDLQVwY2AI26aoqBXK6MPnB3vKpETOJt1gxMYLW7pekykIYotIXNfKauA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@youbewb5581","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyHgCMwi3Lotf0JX7p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for your nuance and attention to details. I haven't even finished the video.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCDU6_F_gexwWB4ffaV3aNOg","author":"@JakobNorthblood","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nz4WUF__Jq_kgYseSTWipak1zFzJRS0gB9f_ep2YeDOdw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JakobNorthblood","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwwZD4HB7fXtg8wg3R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love how this video jumps from plants to stratosphere and semantics about it, that's what I subscribed for x)","like_count":8,"author_id":"UC_mX2SzXO4IHNx0-FfQWEbw","author":"@Billy_Herrington1969","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cAvSzpOr-L7cgYihVWTcsl0HT96fen3pfFeP6F4PS5Im7hhUn9nJsQgn9bNTex6KPvkdW8IlVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Billy_Herrington1969","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyCYwelow5jJzXECWh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is the kind of stuff that got me so excited in biophysics when I was back in college. In recent years I've lost a lot of that enthusiasm to a rather soul-sucking software career, but watching this channel has been bringing back some of that excitement I once had for DIY science. \nThanks Benn. I will now go CRUSH that like button.","like_count":21,"author_id":"UCovgqu2xbewsRoOLUuBXF_w","author":"@harrison298","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Qg9J_LPIhWwRkjhVfhg1oh1Do2h75YKDW0CBKgMAlONVkPXjDTFgEfjsuxCVW0_-9MosQ3IrQFA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@harrison298","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyCYwelow5jJzXECWh4AaABAg.ADg81J8WYAPAOUtyVRKPFT","parent":"UgyCYwelow5jJzXECWh4AaABAg","text":"get an arduino and some sensors and go nuts man. i'm headed in that direction myself.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzLpAfwtYxATQRTJWjToKpA","author":"@OccultAesthetica","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CCld3Si5rq8Gc8J_Aw6hhFiMyWmuZm39Lenlju5tcvxzk2KbHYcx42XyNhRoDyJNaODX27oQCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@OccultAesthetica","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxUJyKi7JDYGhbpyrF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Never before have I seen someone both \n1) Regularly use a siphon brewer \n2) Use such a crazy brewing method with a $50 Cuisinart grinder","like_count":161,"author_id":"UCFzNVzlt_C3nxsizA2o20Lw","author":"@jibbs_aim","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NTBElQGzle0HNC3luTS0G7d7CqgRg46DUt4sBhnEEUwyAq8bLG3BTzhl-dSphIcx3EAoLqjmrw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jibbs_aim","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxUJyKi7JDYGhbpyrF4AaABAg.ADXomrkRCqQAFggbajt71C","parent":"UgxUJyKi7JDYGhbpyrF4AaABAg","text":"Ooof. 😖🫣 His coffee is still better than mine, though, I’m sure. Though…HIS world would probably still be completely rocked if he chose a better grinder.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCFnh2ap_NDaknvyizQEKUAg","author":"@ec9833","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNIWk1OfZtSlbDzl15vA-uvw-YtWAxUttO4TCjbfY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ec9833","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz4iLr9X-kvRsjqHxV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The chicken toss sound effect at 9:29 is glorious!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbos_xxhT1VKFhs-fyJ6KVg","author":"@pepperthrowshands","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VpyeMTm3zqXFZViKa9_akirK19wJmyghibNG_HIZvNWo1XBha4bz_fweJuaOIbLl81Okf-rqjQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pepperthrowshands","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwr2-nvC9sOUMlhYGJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sound is pressure and as such variation in pressures of music assists in the gas exchange process. There was a Morman musician, Michael Ballum, in the 80's who made claims on good vs bad music and I even as a kid found that flawed... \"Music and the Mind\" was one of the books my grandmother had on audiotape.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCgqPDWm01hLUyIGjVT5pG6w","author":"@UnstreamableMe","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ebCKY7Cbu6dOON8pK2Vqv9FISN9tTWTPTCA_CfaYaHUuKGwJ6mOf6m4Fbygb5Csv3W_BoZdC4g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@UnstreamableMe","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIj6N0ATpVDR8RTXp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"17:56 more people have seen this video than would read a published scholarly journal about this topic. There is no barrier to entry anymore. .","like_count":34,"author_id":"UCnftzUi7luSrUOaipWPfN0Q","author":"@HereWeGo0o0","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MpKw4O9TWkUJv96lYRLz2UqpJKpeb7FZXN8jl93jKDU91HYVfFAPCBCaCW4WyGzts07QEtFZ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HereWeGo0o0","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIj6N0ATpVDR8RTXp4AaABAg.ADwYCrkV8cMAMbuJZZUjaW","parent":"UgyIj6N0ATpVDR8RTXp4AaABAg","text":"Well there are barriers to more robust data for sure.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC1wa-t064oE6r7pogqG1MXw","author":"@Wanhope2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kskRORQDdiL77woWW2hQBzwjI6doIBz_bh5vl2b6c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Wanhope2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIj6N0ATpVDR8RTXp4AaABAg.ADwYCrkV8cMARr9ErqpDWp","parent":"UgyIj6N0ATpVDR8RTXp4AaABAg","text":"never been a bar","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgTJMtLmWvtUPTklbGGngfA","author":"@baldworks","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kkGlq36u1Dc_3Hw9v2ly2ybB-VA0V70j7szQL-VQc7kg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@baldworks","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx95ySyN5VCvl7EA3l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"tl;dw Benn screaming and cussing at his plants like David Tennant in Good Omens","like_count":15,"author_id":"UCPMh3E1MWQrJeo70GlwnL1A","author":"@MakeAWoosh","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/HSAkO9FVfpdyDWAtgaoLKpI9XzPWqawybEhxiPW865ix6ndaSur4G10JoLCxojTQCRV1skJ4-6E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MakeAWoosh","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx95ySyN5VCvl7EA3l4AaABAg.ADUFjilviBPAX7uW1DlN3S","parent":"Ugx95ySyN5VCvl7EA3l4AaABAg","text":"This is reason to watch all of it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJfR7J3_O_T6L5WzvxUuQZw","author":"@chloecccc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cXplhSayJJac5awUUee7IQ3Dh2rI31kTEGHEJO2dZoABXJYhSUwXStEs3u4OR6yiJ1v-COtKwp8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chloecccc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwnGbLps96B8GDTXl94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe the sound waves are assisting in moving fluid around the plant? And somehow the different frequencies in music selectively vibrate different parts of the plant? Maybe try to play a combination of sound waves, or some that fluctuate in frequency","like_count":15,"author_id":"UC__8MGM0XRy1miUUpPdyYrA","author":"@lolzdatguy4987","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mgncXZvN_1iVXYbSxfjqUS6VdAIejHJuwAqDThEic=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lolzdatguy4987","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwnGbLps96B8GDTXl94AaABAg.ADUIvIFH4lTAD_AVLMYOgo","parent":"UgwnGbLps96B8GDTXl94AaABAg","text":"Important, and probably hard to isolate and compare. Plus subtle electrical currents induced by patterns of sound reverberation in solids and air.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCWim5bPBGvZ8cV3lilpo47w","author":"@rickZR1982A","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kMYxzuoALeklp701_RTTqcGyDmQBNx8RUq7hexDYiJAbjeefA32v6O8iwKUH_tJvomYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rickZR1982A","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwnGbLps96B8GDTXl94AaABAg.ADUIvIFH4lTADULZ_wie5n","parent":"UgwnGbLps96B8GDTXl94AaABAg","text":"Sound thinking","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCFfvckRiGuOAdvzg4ZHEWLQ","author":"@saladdays180s9","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kU_XaXqn1DukSlPr36qMzYzTC86OKnVn7M6D6DoKsQyw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@saladdays180s9","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwnGbLps96B8GDTXl94AaABAg.ADUIvIFH4lTAWwAsMfciIn","parent":"UgwnGbLps96B8GDTXl94AaABAg","text":"Maybe like ball bearings in a funnel... They'll move along better if you jostle it a bit 🤔","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCuTaAtY6Qfvr79KK19lbLRg","author":"@codemiesterbeats","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m_59PmLmpRWLHVzvMn4Zno6McR8nCTezjgGABYLJN_4Nd_buwQGbZdr1bm1g3WLWz_33B08qumA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@codemiesterbeats","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrikP3y6UzrTy3apd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"just discovered your channel a few weeks ago and am totally addicted!  gonna head over to watch more now…  thanks for your humor, rigor (without the mortis), and candid curiosity.  i hope you know how rare these things can be, when taken together.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvwu0nN08PUUlIdhl39K1nQ","author":"@danielle78730","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dUp6bd9L0QNOTeEDZKAweVF-xIFHsd0utGmZtML5qzcYTP7CEJkZTgQdGIEBbtOl9k2hsskvfw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danielle78730","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxmV8eWHL4Y8E0w8kd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Beautiful video. I clicked on \"plants can hear music\" and was met with some of the most insightful perspectives and thoughtful reflections on science I've ever heard.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzNWgs2TFqi7G01GkofsXpg","author":"@CashsCoffee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_npz7jbO3VWKBcFsyXMn2AwjdZ1xbIZeDxIr9vknp_KvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CashsCoffee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDjof_4Q-tLWsMz7B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The best science channel by a musician. :)","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCtWeyAVEfyU45pPM3DWqPVg","author":"@ArturdeSousaRocha","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mCiqS5AQkKUSRu0m7jLEDWIG1gnnYJacDbw2_RwdJb0aWy=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ArturdeSousaRocha","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDjof_4Q-tLWsMz7B4AaABAg.ADUHwi292F5ADUPpIfCbZE","parent":"UgwDjof_4Q-tLWsMz7B4AaABAg","text":"ZippyZiip zamm","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWu0gzqlMWetJpeON4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This guy’s work is immense! Just look at all the little funny details with the placement of microphone, and asterisks from the pocket, and almost each shot is a different room or place. All the jokes and structure of the video. OMG!\nI get very inspired when i see so much dedication!","like_count":21,"author_id":"UCpchPGe2TKBALzTTvNaFJFg","author":"@IllumifIow","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8Zv8gY7WO2J_KRlkRmCn036Auo4n7Fl76ACxAIZElElMVq5Cr8ENjjFo0zWEsQE7Nvnp834d4GE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IllumifIow","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGntPHvLrgfzlFPhl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey Benn! Just dropping a line to let you know that I really appreciate your openness about your past. Having some experience with \"troubled youth\" myself (that eventually led to dropping out of uni several times) and being lucky enough to be in a postition to deliver presentations nowadays, I totally get the feeilng that one has when asked about prior education. I just roll with the \"Let me tell you a story...\" line. 😎 And of course, love your channel, awesome work man! 👏","like_count":23,"author_id":"UCC0FZjzMq6kTF4y-mmgeapQ","author":"@djblankaround","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/uj-JOJPkOBtWp1wISjF9jCg8nr9CbCo--kyvtBNIc0E25ZLvLnAYkiGNVQzaSkvdu9NPxnZiZw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@djblankaround","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz45zHI6iS3kmi3uoh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Not even 10 minutes in and I plan on making the day learning on your channel. So much awesome work, thank you!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCncu89Eexe2b9GvaULo2qYg","author":"@SunflowerDogs","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lGlw_jLgDWUOEs19NOLS8zsVPVG_yjbMdGiaw4HgJvMAo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SunflowerDogs","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZV3O03rPsdnlT4ON4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love the random objects you have the mic clipped to lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_Lmv9NKhknc6ndrBk1Ptrg","author":"@AWO7_BigToph","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/EkIcYDtjeF5tsIoP_MogOt3S8zFhIbEFahr5KloL0iATQIBq2Q7ShNysOphZ2_SYWnL3gYmCTg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AWO7_BigToph","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzHX-f88lon39C9tR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The range of pitch of running water, or the vibration of rain could reasonably attract root growth, I'd hypothesized this ever since I saw worms attracted to the vibrations of me hammering in a stake.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCLZ0I1HQsVsU0SuHb0_KTtw","author":"@gangofgreenhorns2672","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_niA2njjrRzDKzEZxIA8HHgXPWJtfnr5b5XMnO8gWYMpg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gangofgreenhorns2672","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyqRX97WhzadohXuYp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dude. Fantastic video, once again.\n\nA thought I just had, I work with coral growth a lot.\n\nThere is some evidence that shows coral being consistently, slightly damaged, increases it's growth rate because the coral is constantly in \"quick rebuild it\" mode vs \"ok everything cool\" mode.\n\nThere are similar theories about cats purring to help repair micro fractures in their bones.\n\nPerhaps something similar is happening within the plant? Like the pressure waves are damaging the plants cell structure in such a way that the plant is both repairing its self and building at the same time, therefore growing more?\n\nJust a thought.","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCJvOwZux6nrYzxgsEZuwfiQ","author":"@MakerofThingss","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_meR8HwW3DnHwNg3-7lL73zB0_EJYJbMUaBmdHMAnA4EQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MakerofThingss","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyqRX97WhzadohXuYp4AaABAg.ADUVQgYt_xcADUtH56zU9L","parent":"UgyqRX97WhzadohXuYp4AaABAg","text":"Interesting.  Pain is a gift, after all.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCDTk6DH5VAwenDirff_YN6g","author":"@jeaniebird999","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVPnGaZIow_slbjhSlC7EFVOPls2Kp8524DcemQfjEP3fM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeaniebird999","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbC3FsYhsK-MbtEhh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Has science gone to far? NO! not nearly far enough!","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC7m7zp5fUhW2qfAnkRpusjQ","author":"@NeonNijahn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kB1Y4VejPbjbJHtM7h0ptS8MqhwDvzfuM7cOhS_TJEtcIo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NeonNijahn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJT9552PlIhngIaSx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As an Aussie, veteran, mechanic, grower, landscaper, ADHD and now, 3 pins in my arse from a work accident... I love your content because you're thought process and methodology is spot on! \nDeliver is high speed, on point and blunt honesty!\nCovering necessary physics, materials, coats for testing conditions and using a great blend on modern terminology and everyday lingo (colloquialisms) is super easy to listen to and great to reference the shit I've NEVER heard off 😁\nNever stop learning man 😉👍🏼🦘","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHh_kUIDGbDUnCGqCUJlGOQ","author":"@Jnr079","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kP4erGjnAUhiNQ0VnPGXooaQw781Bn_1h1gK1YHwah-AhDSPIfdE3GhM2SEw5u20eWVtLgEe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jnr079","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzG1AweNhH_QoPQhNJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hands down one of my favorite YouTube channels, if not my absolute favorite. And I just found it a few weeks back the unbiased information and straight to the point\nPhilosophy are much appreciated!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMB_ZSq2roBZ5nIREim4LEw","author":"@shanefages","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nv4R1PyETymqBIs5_-xnTNqXN-JsWgGg2upK9hOCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shanefages","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwv33Z-L00leqzCVfZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It makes sense in there is a boundary layer that is depleted immediately above the surface of the leaf. Inducing air replacement not only by vibration of the air, but shaking of the plant itself","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCPeUUQIse_cD9fOOMxV08Mw","author":"@geekswithfeet9137","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n2hPSRbFyVCsa3DH40XVgkFocQ-Hk_e-t9yMJMT50=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@geekswithfeet9137","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwv33Z-L00leqzCVfZ4AaABAg.AIdmMiK2iA2AJxZLGhjRsq","parent":"Ugwv33Z-L00leqzCVfZ4AaABAg","text":"Shaking can make things flow more easily through the plant, I think.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3xtVHPMhKAJbH9nLS5Dn3w","author":"@ivanjelenic5627","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kMLPvvXh86D_eStMu0q-FCjI70hQ9HCdHBsu1zPNA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ivanjelenic5627","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwv33Z-L00leqzCVfZ4AaABAg.AIdmMiK2iA2AMkG7vM5mmi","parent":"Ugwv33Z-L00leqzCVfZ4AaABAg","text":"Yeah, no.  Brownian motion is a thing, dude.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk83cL1FzGQ7pcUVSxm25TA","author":"@jasonbender2459","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJ4zCCUHXS1NoVE-jewo-r5p2FiIF7nZw8hO0rkvvLc2w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jasonbender2459","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxryJKdhwh8Dg3lsB54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"12:57 Bro broke out the 'ol Bunsen for his morning brew XD","like_count":8,"author_id":"UC_2eXvgdRulV_8UfqpaNUJA","author":"@chuckyb_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/e85h8h5Gx2wgwrwygYd_8t8P9IdTl1urWeLKNe4Pr2M05uUkErHE4TQ1XesaLARQgLzgUwCb1w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chuckyb_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My hypothesis: The sound waves mix up the air and move it around the stoma. The pressure cycling might even pump air into and out of the stoma to some degree. This allows the plants better access to the carbon dioxide in the air by ensuring the air in and around the stoma is always \"fresh\". \n\nBasically, the effects of sound are equivalent to if you had increased the baseline amount of carbon dioxide in the air. The sound waves make the plants more effective at accessing what carbon dioxide is already there. \n\nThere is, of course, a well know correlation between carbon dioxide levels and growth rates. That carbon being the source of the majority of a plant's dry mass as it grows.\n\nA good test of this hypothesis might be comparing control versus sound versus fans that move air around the plants aggressively but produce no noise. Humidity would need to be considered carefully though, as the fans might dry the plants out in a way that sound wouldn't. \n\nOr maybe it would? Another worthwhile test perhaps - plants do lose almost all of their water through the stoma as a sacrifice to obtain the carbon dioxide they need. This is why many plants close their stoma at night - no need to waste water to obtain carbon dioxide if they can't do anything with it since there is no sunlight.","like_count":30,"author_id":"UC997h3ItnzZpEY5KsDoIJ-Q","author":"@nickkinnan7485","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nqi769VhZMr6_EvWB4AoUO9_I5OD63OX5SYjtC7BA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nickkinnan7485","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg.ADU_JMvwOcUADUvBlq9ER3","parent":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg","text":"That's what my first guess was as well when I heard about this. The completely still air in this test setup is pretty different from the natural habitat and could impede the plant from accessing fresh air. The sound could just be mitigating that by introducing some motion to the air. Would be interesting to see if this effect still exists if there's a fan producing some air flow.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC5uMkJh1XWBcZKBJbAxAM0A","author":"@reeeeeeeeemmmmmmmmmm","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mLJS8aNwc-9ViFMXXljSBfBHSP1U4zGNc-4ByWOYs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@reeeeeeeeemmmmmmmmmm","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg.ADU_JMvwOcUADUijfo9xYi","parent":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg","text":"if that's true, why would there be a difference in Hz, especially higher frequencies performing better?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCAL_SNX8B6ZokRynChmYHJg","author":"@phronese","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOAwOjcLmxnbVTchAUcMxW75a9qdpmnBEGSG-mTPc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@phronese","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg.ADU_JMvwOcUADUtm7mZQjP","parent":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg","text":"If I could, I'd add a second upvote for your use of \"my hypothesis\" at the start of your hypothesis.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCanZgz4HXzmWUat7jHk32DQ","author":"@robertmyers6518","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lHFRlZI50E5n9D8LYfqwiRdkBOWPue87b4FmwoMiaFp7k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robertmyers6518","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg.ADU_JMvwOcUADVLVaztF7V","parent":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg","text":"Agree. I posted a similar comment. Sound also has the advantage of mixing the air efficiently all around the leaves, whereas a breeze mainly just exchanges air over the leaves facing the wind direction. My hypothesis is that means sound + breeze will be better than either alone, but too much of either might lead to dehydration so there would be a middle ground where you see the best performance of either one, too.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCRMfHQmPm1tIyo8vltK6sGg","author":"@simontillson482","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mu2kRuTPtMqaHRlognJEygvN4mF6ULfFeamrgF2sV6Lcc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@simontillson482","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg.ADU_JMvwOcUADvtY02KYSG","parent":"Ugzy3oXKEOCn_-iaQNx4AaABAg","text":"I also came looking for this hypothesis.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3Gvcmvt4mdrmp0t0DQifcQ","author":"@TheRainHarvester","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_naoVGMajsT4qos-zJiLrxcaYmemiURl3qCOCoMmnhWew=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheRainHarvester","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyVxNX2ISVBKpV0XwV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You might have the coolest channel ever Benn. Thanks for the quality","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtvouuwOv-qZd15Dtapb1zQ","author":"@VesselRx1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hYUXJX9QMgqLoWwI1dg2r9HZi0GOpcRNePf7ra3M3MF8HA15qDPB6U4HqXM-2pABovuEkVl7=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@VesselRx1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0pk9vrUGglxUDbnt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You feel like a yogi to me. Each one of your videos heal something in me and i dont even know why. I swear i love your videos❤ keep up the good work sir.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UChXLUUwknsyhHLYgenwHTuA","author":"@aamirhassan438","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m4cXva8VQzs9d-XF_QSO6qGWIXX06VCwp2qxRHMdtse641=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aamirhassan438","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyTUTyNtuU5-XJZb0t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't really know why but I was taken aback by the reveal of you dropping out of high school, by watching your videos and seeing all the amazing things you've been able to accomplish in such different fields I was sure you'd have some sort of higher education. I guess it shows my innate bias towards institutionalized knowledge, thanks for the wake up call.","like_count":9,"author_id":"UCmlPGydvOH8Wc_rMDFHyIrg","author":"@Devilm00n","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/HgiKwCWNgS_81aOhuZQd15FFHdapL_oohEKPUg8EU_e8nCYuXY6_JQpG2Ijj8xgmCuo-sUAibg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Devilm00n","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyTUTyNtuU5-XJZb0t4AaABAg.ADUIDAzV-7tADURd8xN9rF","parent":"UgyTUTyNtuU5-XJZb0t4AaABAg","text":"I had an inkling. Because his interests are quite vast AND he's quite cool, as it were.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCA9uJXSkSSOsLZbM_k6DZ2g","author":"@psypsy751","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nnHX-KaefOq7aAsNvN68K4AixFYzycvG0ma17AI_E2Xh4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@psypsy751","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyW7KZyLx4OnIGhIFF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"With every video I see from Benn, he pulls increasingly farther ahead of the pack in terms of being easily the most interesting person on Youtube.","like_count":117,"author_id":"UCz4DCC68mgE-aL-8aIanAYQ","author":"@PNWIRE","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/gnpUxi234J5L0iybF2P_hpW9IIEwJ4L6uiLVz7tcLF-jGVqdugbuc3gCAlL77ODMtrHBXtmdng=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PNWIRE","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQDJ2u_M5SuDjY2mZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am not a botanist, but i read something about this a while ago. They say the mechanism could be plant stomata. They're little pores on plant leaves that allow for respiration. It seems like they open in response to some frequencies, and vary in size, based on the plant. Researchers are still looking into it but that's one theory about the mechanism between ambient sound and growth: stomata diameter. The catch is, wider stomata means the plant is more likely to take in an allergen or something that makes it sick. But it also means the plant can \"breath\" more and therefore grow more in the same amount of time. I hope this is something worth looking into.","like_count":20,"author_id":"UCHRjoniFDQgxYPJDwkNAZMA","author":"@alissaadornato8951","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n3m7xeWn5ptA_zwpmU81y3O6-jbv8WvjnnpyQKbi9YeNOmEZNThwjQW3EwN3-DVI6pDA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alissaadornato8951","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQDJ2u_M5SuDjY2mZ4AaABAg.ADUtYuv7djgADW4TG8kAUR","parent":"UgxQDJ2u_M5SuDjY2mZ4AaABAg","text":"There's a company called Sonic Bloom, started by a guy named Dan Carlson several decades ago, which sells products that revolve around the idea that sound opens stomata and a few other principles, making some bold claims of staggering success by those who use their products. Their products include small sound emitting systems with audio CDs containing specific frequencies, said to be those found in birdsong.\nI wonder if anyone has rigorously tested their products and the claims of their founder?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCXSDXRO-f__ywtslSRpm5KQ","author":"@josiah6794","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XQ0C8U_ATjD_W8Ho2UAMzovaBICr1UbKrI5jXUows4_NSlg_p7QAh8HXaeQNxwCDbGRguisEww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@josiah6794","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQDJ2u_M5SuDjY2mZ4AaABAg.ADUtYuv7djgAEI3eoSVCtK","parent":"UgxQDJ2u_M5SuDjY2mZ4AaABAg","text":"I concur","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJ9WmKSn2vFMiEB2gqa258g","author":"@ganjagridplantvibrationtra72","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nm3hfpwPJB63ecm5HYHSfchyqaleaG4GFIQoK0il_qWwlU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ganjagridplantvibrationtra72","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQDJ2u_M5SuDjY2mZ4AaABAg.ADUtYuv7djgAJDgb79W-CE","parent":"UgxQDJ2u_M5SuDjY2mZ4AaABAg","text":"Funny, I just saw your comment after leaving one myself, very naivelly thinking about air circulation helping with biomass - I see that your thoughts seem to also be along the same line, but yours seem much more educated than mine :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnKVJiVBraJlF_-XMuy2HxQ","author":"@hickscorp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXWiHiQ-w6hRiU2wzQGZPOWF1DwKTP70A2EHzrhfMGsw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hickscorp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVMZQ-B3Ldrc0in1Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I bet bird cherping, running water, or rain noises would also be interesting to add into this study.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC2Gyepy66cke6OS5n5Nl0Dg","author":"@Teafoam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n-94q6fcaw4NHPSxerrMIQ4n7h3lUf9SSpCcWytRb81WdY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Teafoam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzt3wXXoDivFuWAOiV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dude blows my mind. I admittedly struggle with math & science and have always had more Philosophical leanings, but he breaks things down in a very helpful way. (with humor that I consider a bonus and also a good memory aid.)","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCX9t6HNSj_xWkYD3zuwWgTw","author":"@jeremyhennessee6604","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lIfvQEm8zMAguFQojnVNc7SGDEyy9t3n8NdU46ScbibJA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeremyhennessee6604","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYVhR23oD3CD1Z8pd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In my opinion, without strict control of things like air temperature and humidity, small growth experiments with one group placed over the lighting of the other shouldn't be considered strongly indicative, of anything. Seemingly small differences in temperature and or humidity can have a very big impact on plant growth. \n\nExperiments comparing seedling height after a short time has one big advantage, they're very easy to do. The drawback is that modest differences can't tell you much with any relevant degree of certainty, besides how much seedling height was affected, under the conditions of the experiment.\n\nAs many already pointed out, air movement can be very beneficial to plant growth. I wouldn't rule out the possibility that sound under some conditions could be somewhat more efficient than modest general air circulation for getting CO2 through the boundary layer. But then again, sound being beneficial to plant growth being such a widespread idea, for a very long time, indicates very low probability of undiscovered practically relevant potential benefit.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC8EWbrj2S_8RM9Lva4p-VBQ","author":"@fishyerik","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_d7-54bJzI0zgKHr3d__NO2a8UvIRQ-85GLwb-QbsVEQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fishyerik","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYVhR23oD3CD1Z8pd4AaABAg.AE08YPlT6gVAMbu97QPD9Z","parent":"UgxYVhR23oD3CD1Z8pd4AaABAg","text":"Absolutely, I strongly suspect this entire endeavour was setup to spark these critical discussions and hopefully inspire/annoy someone enough to do robust research ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1wa-t064oE6r7pogqG1MXw","author":"@Wanhope2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kskRORQDdiL77woWW2hQBzwjI6doIBz_bh5vl2b6c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Wanhope2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxSJdP-mPivwq8bUTZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Not 90 seconds in and I'm hoping the microphone holder will continue escalating its derangement.","like_count":20,"author_id":"UC9uFeYTVSntez99Ek_JNHGw","author":"@ericlaska4748","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_koJlFNDMqmMyOGD7x6r1B3_E5MgPTeIsrRnK_5uF6p2A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ericlaska4748","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxSJdP-mPivwq8bUTZ4AaABAg.ADUG_qO6MOIADUIE17kZ9L","parent":"UgxSJdP-mPivwq8bUTZ4AaABAg","text":"Another hypothesis (from my ignorance): The sound enhances plant respiration by disrupting the boundary layer of air around their leaves. Mass transport/acoustic streaming?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC9uFeYTVSntez99Ek_JNHGw","author":"@ericlaska4748","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_koJlFNDMqmMyOGD7x6r1B3_E5MgPTeIsrRnK_5uF6p2A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ericlaska4748","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxSJdP-mPivwq8bUTZ4AaABAg.ADUG_qO6MOIADUHsNor5Rb","parent":"UgxSJdP-mPivwq8bUTZ4AaABAg","text":"Nothing can outdo Stefan Milo's lap mike on a plastic spoon.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtWeyAVEfyU45pPM3DWqPVg","author":"@ArturdeSousaRocha","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mCiqS5AQkKUSRu0m7jLEDWIG1gnnYJacDbw2_RwdJb0aWy=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ArturdeSousaRocha","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxSJdP-mPivwq8bUTZ4AaABAg.ADUG_qO6MOIAWvvIq1zGUS","parent":"UgxSJdP-mPivwq8bUTZ4AaABAg","text":"love the variety!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRcO-O_FitiKdHreStuJ6eA","author":"@jeffreyleonard7210","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kDM2ii_t6J3vYZ1e46baZBofw60FqCMQXpZc5ka-7i6D8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeffreyleonard7210","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxEVnq2R385soFqdRJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Do bonsai trees grow better listening to minimalism?","like_count":24,"author_id":"UChU7nPAeKxeOlQ4M_g1iSGA","author":"@_portsmyth","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_my9gqymOePJXbNPccoGcl60o_yU1Mm33M8gy0l8rkyEtM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@_portsmyth","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxEVnq2R385soFqdRJ4AaABAg.ADUFLdPyOZxADUkmpjnhNL","parent":"UgxEVnq2R385soFqdRJ4AaABAg","text":"Fun fact: composer John Cage was also an avid amateur mycologist (he liked to grow fungi). He co-founded the New York Mycological Society, and his mycology collections can be found in the library of UC Santa Cruz.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UC-RzIGaefbdBreCIHRD96KQ","author":"@silverXnoise","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Nd5T55oLrKNWc1gwUBFnuyae3EkGjvqIQzcUEV7vI0Pct0UvvfEqQGPxBAWadH5lbjNw1KNh=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@silverXnoise","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwOsNLWmTZ3DSuGbc54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I especially like that you did the process of natural selection before proceeding with the sound card ;')","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCIIIl2Y1fZhkzJx4yYHe_VA","author":"@RogueVigilante","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nUcnu8hRmQ_rd0cO6g9O53Q94j5G354kHtUmEPgFWo3A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RogueVigilante","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx_zis2y4Ra9_S9LCJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Others have mentioned testing if motion without sound can help the plans grow like with a fan, so I'd definitely try that next!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCx4bYlR4L9asuQZIApWrn5A","author":"@jeremayaayala1767","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l7mk59lu1WF3QkzAf7CqUqoIOoQAUPXRXba14kD8mUnw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeremayaayala1767","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzsrbAf7A3N7Swr0sl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:19 That is not a very good way of summarizing Godel's incompleteness theorem. A better way would be to say \"you can prove that for any formal system of mathematics, there will be true statements that are impossible to prove within that system of math\".","like_count":12,"author_id":"UCceNl_-Hj6GiWOHySEBhNxg","author":"@isocle","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_khpGa-H5XvuzAVdUGS4W4VYGuoCZ50sPQeJFMnjzA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@isocle","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzsrbAf7A3N7Swr0sl4AaABAg.ADZNBi79orAAWoX1ldKFxb","parent":"UgzsrbAf7A3N7Swr0sl4AaABAg","text":"I came to make this exact comment. Also, there are complete mathematical systems - Gödel also proved that. The Peano axioms are consistent and complete. The Peano axioms are also not a full definition of arithmetic. Godel proved that any system which is complex enough to encode the rules of arithmetic must be incomplete.\n\nFurthermore furthermore, any system can and will have many things that are both true and provable. Godel just showed there will always be statements which cannot be proven to be true or false within a fixed set of axioms.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6Rsvd7fMH_E5SEnfqHc0NQ","author":"@alexanderbrady5486","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_npPhTElyJDp2j3UoxY1yBDqdqj1N_xMkXrW5aLtFcO-A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alexanderbrady5486","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My initial impression is that the extra growth effect is primarily due to mechanical vibrations around the roots rather than acoustic vibrations of the shoots.  Vibration of the roots and growth medium would likely enhance water and nutrient transfer.  The platform is going to have various resonance frequencies.  So, some frequencies will acoustically couple to the platform better than others.  My hunch is that haptic transducers attached to the base would be most effective.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCvQefGVYQ0Su8sQW_U-SCgQ","author":"@quantenmoi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8kPNFqZ8JDoO57jnHsHoJdKzQ076irORouwMnpFQxieAb9x29xjLBou-9GS9Bm8lNnjUgO4JSg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@quantenmoi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg.ADUTqda7ki6AD_AHzidaa4","parent":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg","text":"This, good catch. Plus the complex arrangement of nodes and anti-nodes per those resonant frequencies forming in his setup exposing plants to varying conditions in a single experiment for both air and soil. Also involved is charge transport which not only follows within and on node/anti-node regions in solids, semi-solids (loose soil) but even insulators like plastic racks and sheets, and even air - and humidity.  TLDR: cymatics and electricity.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWim5bPBGvZ8cV3lilpo47w","author":"@rickZR1982A","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kMYxzuoALeklp701_RTTqcGyDmQBNx8RUq7hexDYiJAbjeefA32v6O8iwKUH_tJvomYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rickZR1982A","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg.ADUTqda7ki6ADrqL5Oq_IL","parent":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg","text":"could have an effect on capilarity","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaXRkt9jrEnVsfRr_PNwoUw","author":"@MadsterV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_HwK0b0_WV_1774a9jor63raUEKz1lUQfOxO-wTGGCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MadsterV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg.ADUTqda7ki6ADupApPYY4h","parent":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg","text":"that rhymes","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRauoZNxL1eoj6ZmTO2aXGQ","author":"@twentyNinebark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ukElNbttLSKd5oL_VxXqdloxYnFXjbTqDl8C4tT7Ln50zUr18oBS2XRBDoPjgw--y2lhWx0okg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@twentyNinebark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg.ADUTqda7ki6ADupl-PofXs","parent":"Ugzji6OKiPzWc6eSpm54AaABAg","text":"the 4khz test tone used isn’t going to rattle things enough to transfer into soil and roots i feel like though. 4000 hz is very short length sound waves. lower frequencies do vibrate more yes but i don’t believe he applied that..? or did i miss something.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRauoZNxL1eoj6ZmTO2aXGQ","author":"@twentyNinebark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ukElNbttLSKd5oL_VxXqdloxYnFXjbTqDl8C4tT7Ln50zUr18oBS2XRBDoPjgw--y2lhWx0okg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@twentyNinebark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxULM-HWc6cCzd1nr94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ben how did you go from dropping out with no degree to being paid for research and lectureing? thats a story i want to hear. are you entirely self educated? anyway your always an inspiration to me. :)","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCK_FDqTYXaz-2bFB5pghuLw","author":"@Inputsignwave","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QzHTYoYYUGOOm-gA-Mcpq6SW0OCyJlVIi_LkQKYX0S8BVUxDDV7jNUSgblTFXGIPSxBVBqbO6w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Inputsignwave","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIY_QYyYj2UKVwLoR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"9:20 I had no idea I would be so excited to hear somebody else say this - it's exactly the conclusion I came to but never met anyone that thinks that way. Thank you Benn!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKt50XjzhmGMMPMWfm5JTLg","author":"@jakubwolski4755","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nqaYlwgXrQ6JXPH0-gKFdHnPA1A3zbED8_cpW7XoVXCqk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jakubwolski4755","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1uouzBrYIOMv_g8l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm excited for Ben's 500th celebration video: \"All the Things to Which I've Attached My Lav Mic\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcH33bnb-OBgTdEthx8PIeA","author":"@kcapkcans","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ThdIaQG4cknNTyfil7Ql7f_1joWHSxsAY2BLlHliSMV5jxmDR8Ro7UmHauHeBVdCo1yTNrVJLg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kcapkcans","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzTQHu98kzuslET5R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"11:30 at the danger of whataboutery; given gardeners (I have more than one hobby) will sometimes place seedlings in front of a fan as wind is felt to help with \"hardening off\", could the sound waves be moving the air, and by extension the seedlings, in a similar way? I don't know how much energy a soundwave would impart at the volumes you were playing them at, nor do I know of a way to eliminate air pressure as a variable, given that changes in same are, like, sound, but I would be intrigued to see what happens if one were to put the seedlings on a vibrating table, say. Apart from a giant mess and a lot of dead plants, perhaps.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCHsiat973sIFWiDu9cMLw8w","author":"@bobbler42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nd79loOwWiWqcASpxUZYw8bHjDW0S4g2tSeLhPMOTk_e4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bobbler42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzTQHu98kzuslET5R4AaABAg.ADUQjwNXoTvADUeSra77w7","parent":"UgzzTQHu98kzuslET5R4AaABAg","text":"This was my thought too. I’d be curious to see a third shelf with a small fan running 24 hours a day","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzbJv0Biz6bUHx1uY47BoWw","author":"@parkerlamarbrook","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kTdHDy7C0EYmdg3a8jeqMwKYobavmaglEWs7ui4cHL_g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@parkerlamarbrook","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzTQHu98kzuslET5R4AaABAg.ADUQjwNXoTvADm-i9kFxy4","parent":"UgzzTQHu98kzuslET5R4AaABAg","text":"Me three","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSqRSzGnVM_bXscyH_EKyQA","author":"@weedfreer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n8hRu-Q2XsnSX34h8PVZuRaWwLulzBmWKkcvHT1q4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@weedfreer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzTQHu98kzuslET5R4AaABAg.ADUQjwNXoTvADup16x5G5o","parent":"UgzzTQHu98kzuslET5R4AaABAg","text":"same yah! 4khz barely moves air that humans feel up close but plants might.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRauoZNxL1eoj6ZmTO2aXGQ","author":"@twentyNinebark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ukElNbttLSKd5oL_VxXqdloxYnFXjbTqDl8C4tT7Ln50zUr18oBS2XRBDoPjgw--y2lhWx0okg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@twentyNinebark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a highschool dropout who's struggled with imposter syndrome through my life, I'd absolutely love to hear more about your story. \n\nBefore covid hit, I was working as a lead product developer for a flavor lab. Creating a catalog of 250+ different food grade flavors, all self taught through hard work and dedication. The company was wildly successful with some of my flavors being in products nation wide. \n\n\nCovid hit, I lost just about everything, and now I'm working as a security guard as a liberal arts college. I have my side projects like building circuits, researching things that interest me like partical physics, and watching YouTube channels like yours. But I find it hard to find people I can connect with and learn from. I think hearing more about your journey could not only help me, but a lot of others.","like_count":91,"author_id":"UCUJYgWAvf0B2XNWND5s0vdA","author":"@dustin860","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mB6aX6ie90aGdZ-fHW5oMIH57977vmNa4zhnb58Vg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dustin860","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg.ADUNQCDFM_5ADUa45g-ZHu","parent":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg","text":"My youth was similarly derailed, although I managed to get plenty of higher education (an AFA in photography, a BA in media studies, then an AS in electronics engineering, all over the course of 6-years), my first big setback came from a multiple sclerosis diagnosis when I was 18, which ruined my financial and professional prospects just as I was getting started in life. Although the MS ultimately helped pay for college with the assistance of vocational rehabilitation programs, a felony conviction in my mid-20’s caused me to lose nearly all of my most productive years between the age of 30-40 working in menial, low paid jobs while I navigated court, conviction, and my sentence. \n\nAfter I completed my sentence and probation, it became apparent that my background would likely preclude me from most conventional career options, and so I instead chose to become a freelancer. It’s been better, as I am fortunate to be very self-motivated, skilled, and personable, but I am still far behind my peers economically (I may never retire, at this point), and I will always suffer from the regret and guilt of my wasted potential, and the additional burdens that I placed on my family. \n\nWe do what we can each day to be good people, and to define our existence with something meaningful. Benn’s career in music has inspired me for nearly two decades now, and the things he’s achieved through his YouTube channel are amazing to see. I hope he is proud of himself, and the things he’s achieved. \n\nI think we are probably a larger cohort than we might imagine, people for whom the rigid constructs of contemporary society have never fully accommodated, for one reason or another. I would love to see more examples of how people like this navigate the world and the many, many pitfalls of moving against the grain. It would be nice to find more resources—things like professional development, employment opportunities, and social support—for folks who do not (or cannot) achieve more via the “traditional” modes of being. It seems like the internet could facilitate such resources, but outreach and awareness are likely challenging for communicating with people who are necessarily out of society’s traditional pockets.","like_count":13,"author_id":"UC-RzIGaefbdBreCIHRD96KQ","author":"@silverXnoise","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Nd5T55oLrKNWc1gwUBFnuyae3EkGjvqIQzcUEV7vI0Pct0UvvfEqQGPxBAWadH5lbjNw1KNh=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@silverXnoise","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg.ADUNQCDFM_5ADUbQ4sc1ar","parent":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg","text":"I wrote all those words, and somehow neglected to say this: I sympathize, and hope you are doing well.\n\nThere’s a quote from the inimitable author Kurt Vonnegut that routinely helps me reckon with the enormity of existence and my own fleeting, inconsequential place within it: \n\nWe are here on this Earth to fart around. Don’t let anybody tell you different.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UC-RzIGaefbdBreCIHRD96KQ","author":"@silverXnoise","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Nd5T55oLrKNWc1gwUBFnuyae3EkGjvqIQzcUEV7vI0Pct0UvvfEqQGPxBAWadH5lbjNw1KNh=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@silverXnoise","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg.ADUNQCDFM_5ADU_0ZH7uIq","parent":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg","text":"Holy fuck dude. Life is hard","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCP74FoTYezcHuIDW0Wm8lSw","author":"@gqh007","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_Qy00NuBdOfbvl6um7SdS21tfwoS0iWvrEqLoAXIz3iwd4MG0XExkilW_fHx8j37WjnZ4cgn9A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gqh007","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg.ADUNQCDFM_5ADjVrAp73AR","parent":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg","text":"Good luck with that Flavorbook thing.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSbGAOzAdNXWKm0FSm50exg","author":"@Cineenvenordquist","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTKNe3IKVZN6WgMc3GtF1dOm_XNZH13WTTPkuAlL5b5FE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cineenvenordquist","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg.ADUNQCDFM_5AMkFz0smmSo","parent":"UgxpfcqWvPA4ggEcsdF4AaABAg","text":"Loved your work in Cherry Cola, Zima, Impossible Meat...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk83cL1FzGQ7pcUVSxm25TA","author":"@jasonbender2459","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJ4zCCUHXS1NoVE-jewo-r5p2FiIF7nZw8hO0rkvvLc2w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jasonbender2459","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzVppNdgmvVC89uYF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Love your “sound” topic videos, and inclusion of scientific methods.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNuuo_1zi5Q-CmZTJp8ZoxQ","author":"@JamesGrieve-kt4su","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/IkmOAZ3bMcNIQSvTvoi1PbezGriewaOwhjuW7gX3syTXaXcMwzGfNxtIA8Ti4mKzl4acpGV8Zw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JamesGrieve-kt4su","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6KaMxPf1AzojA9oF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I clicked because of the title. I stayed because it's interesting. And my inner nerd instantly subscribed when I saw the atmosphere experiment and I'm gonna spend my next 8hrs of my shift watching these videos. Thx. <3","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCR5KYT6JPlkRi4iYwt1BB9g","author":"@koborattila2466","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_neWo6X_UR6F1IOyvwr5IY43pp_b98XVQX9h5Vf8RNThNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@koborattila2466","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx96WVih9m1nOxbVuZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"What we need to do is wedge right between those two biases in a way that is only fueled by our raw curiosity. And with that mindset there are no disappointing outcomes.\"\r\n\r\nI took the trouble to pause and click back in the video several times so I could get this quote typed out.\r\n\r\nThis is the crux of it all, isn't it? Follow your curiosity without bias and the outcome will not disappoint. It's good for science. And good for music, too, if I can speak to my own personal experience.\n\nGrowing up, I remember tuning in to PBS eagerly awaiting the next episode of James Burke's original \"Connections\" series or Carl Sagan's \"Cosmos\" and I get the very same feeling from these deep-dive videos of yours.\n\nI truly appreciate all the work you put into making these episodes. Thanks.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCanZgz4HXzmWUat7jHk32DQ","author":"@robertmyers6518","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lHFRlZI50E5n9D8LYfqwiRdkBOWPue87b4FmwoMiaFp7k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robertmyers6518","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx96WVih9m1nOxbVuZ4AaABAg.ADUs_RIckxCAEDZdfoCTU8","parent":"Ugx96WVih9m1nOxbVuZ4AaABAg","text":"I find this approach of finding the middle path to be helpful in life in general, I think it’s a big part of what Buddha was trying to teach people but of course a bunch of us went and turned it into a religion","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCmdRn3Nu5E_6cK2tbaKMl4A","author":"@ohokcool","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RlZpizvNVu-4L3AOQTSarH2Ag_CUKUAHtdpETlgf_vYR0yiw1uMLvvU1ywWggp7PquERwFUVmw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ohokcool","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwSAhAjZ1ZMSGD_hdJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Funny, isn't cymatics the foundation of what gives structure to the empty space of elemental matter?","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCFvnHXyl3jOU0jP1x5UI3Nw","author":"@johnweaver4421","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ktf9w-_Y-Ykk2WaCOrvRvto-DqwRfZrCwkWm-etOgO-lhcHcpTYkUtyPAuK6d42C4TAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johnweaver4421","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwSAhAjZ1ZMSGD_hdJ4AaABAg.ADUGCKPHvR5ADUPuNAE727","parent":"UgwSAhAjZ1ZMSGD_hdJ4AaABAg","text":"Soo MIDIchlorians","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwSAhAjZ1ZMSGD_hdJ4AaABAg.ADUGCKPHvR5ADUKOK-VOEP","parent":"UgwSAhAjZ1ZMSGD_hdJ4AaABAg","text":"Corinthians 14:7 And even things without life giving sound, whether pipe or harp, except they give a distinction in the sounds, how shall it be known what is piped or harped?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCFfvckRiGuOAdvzg4ZHEWLQ","author":"@saladdays180s9","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kU_XaXqn1DukSlPr36qMzYzTC86OKnVn7M6D6DoKsQyw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@saladdays180s9","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1Z4j7NxkozEvRdud4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I work at a musical theater summer camp in a garden each year, 60+ children singing songs daily, strolling and dancing through the garden, everything perks up for that month, the garden never seems more alive, in bloom, buzzing.","like_count":14,"author_id":"UCUd2E8N3lW7jt5njCXllBpw","author":"@Garbagepond","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/G5HZri874E1VY-UoKuD1JOuxESM0bMGvgzG4su0tMV8qPd5IaYCMYWI3vseGqBdQw7EzrJBHHA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Garbagepond","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqPGMfKjo5eQs8VkR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've never been happier for a click-bait video.  I came for plants, and left with a better understanding and appreciation for science methodology.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCqg7hR_KK5wSBLIqI2xPldA","author":"@amberkluga8949","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ktSoqZ1jkyW2KPi_GyXX7jSPz6TZ5P_CyYOTSkTuSaqQY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@amberkluga8949","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxwsJNbBVrKOXlGCPF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If there was a way to fall even more in love with you and your channel, you just found it! As someone who adores music(I am a professional dancer) and is a flower farmer from South Africa, I have always felt that there must be something to this. But to then see your science brain explode and I felt seen just tipped me evermore in your favour.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4OfvyQsYYer5PIf3nuigow","author":"@anthonyrau5313","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_8dqTzeCifyNvyvBmg6mS0UI2OMlHCprBfrTl1BE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@anthonyrau5313","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9lFWFBPd6-mJUbzF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"We need more Benn and less chronic noise box people to improve society’s signal to noise ratio.❤","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCL9acQ6XF64o9CcLz04dZjg","author":"@SS-im3kb","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nS_h4QLOYm-ZBNGTFCTBc5CQoSI287hFKM7OUBx5Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SS-im3kb","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9lFWFBPd6-mJUbzF4AaABAg.ADUMn1n48-xADut9LKDdQS","parent":"Ugz9lFWFBPd6-mJUbzF4AaABAg","text":"haha signal to noise ration. nice. do you mean like all the perfect cute upper middle class hip synth gadgeteirs or the creators that talk a lot but don’t say much.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRauoZNxL1eoj6ZmTO2aXGQ","author":"@twentyNinebark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ukElNbttLSKd5oL_VxXqdloxYnFXjbTqDl8C4tT7Ln50zUr18oBS2XRBDoPjgw--y2lhWx0okg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@twentyNinebark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy3TnEYn97cuy7hrd14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe this comment won’t be noticed, but I gotta get it off my chest haha.\n\nMy guess is that the plants are growing better because you’re directly putting more energy (since sound is oscillating air) into the system. \n\nI would ask the following questions:\n\n* Would raising the temperature of the plants’ surroundings by the equivalent amount of energy being put into sound lead to similar or better yield growths? \n* If you have the plants’ environment at the upper end of its appropriate growing temperatures, would adding sound still raise yields? \n* Does sound allow you to lower the “minimum viable temperature” of the plants environment? \n* Is the efficiency of sound in growth yields more effective than an equivalent amount of energy put into temperature? \n* What about all the above points, but with light levels instead of temperature? \n\nCool work you’re doing, good luck with the rest of your experiment! “Citizen science” (parenthesis cuz, as you say, it is viewed derogatorily) is definitely valuable too! Just cuz we can’t afford fancy scientific equipment doesn’t mean there aren’t valid experimental designs we can do with the stuff we can afford as individuals or non-well-funded groups/organizations :)","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCUCSQPdOTlY7rrEOC4UQAeA","author":"@99jdave99","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m90r-75Msk42CZMdDfHtWC4ljDlukMzLBjw0xMx-s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@99jdave99","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7gcFIDbFMD0UskIl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"17:07 This is why the education (including university) should be public AND secular and unrestricted (without age filters or entrance exams). Public, good quality education is the best strategy to increase socioeconomic mobility, just to name one thing.","like_count":9,"author_id":"UCYH1hzMiY064r6P6691xanA","author":"@ReinaDido","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lWEqU-EuA1tDzTCFU5UyiLK36e4DIKx6_VZEEGmBTPYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ReinaDido","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7gcFIDbFMD0UskIl4AaABAg.AMDK5IBAeLvAWzeCPm09EP","parent":"Ugy7gcFIDbFMD0UskIl4AaABAg","text":"This.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCP8e7KIxJ7a383Oyh8P2BWg","author":"@BlargathaTheGreat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/beTIgt7cGmjlQ_zzpDZ2Bjfi5OKSzjQNjy9K6T6-RLGZ5tThQEBKoIvQDh7QuJwlL4FhcTpM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BlargathaTheGreat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzd311LdJ0tN1XCMkZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I can't believe you hired three separate people just to read out those search results at the start. That's commitment!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmon-XRFC7SFWL9ptXhFW1g","author":"@paulunga","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kfs4MWgOvfLBugRfMV-h3Uz_jpq6p61c6QCFfAw0otPRLRP_hx84xFjVfB_U6K82A21g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@paulunga","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzRYj55_JCFnLlscxR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Resonance and the fact they can feel the sound","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYzZWaPknnNJMlxPg2xtPeQ","author":"@liannblack2427","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nazlhct1lCojaY520gU25EkK9A95CIztEmpGJ-KqyVP5A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@liannblack2427","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzW55YpmW1-CYHztdJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I disagree with how you presented that \"there is no absolute truth\". For start, the incompleteness theorem is a highly abstract idea that doesn't affect everyday math like paying for groceries. \n\nI do agree that not everything can be exactly defined every time, but that doesn't mean that nothing can be exactly defined.\n\nFor example: how many buns are there in a bag? 99.99% of a time, you will have a clear, specific and objectively true answer like 5, 0 or any other whole number. But then there are the 0.01% of cases where two buns are partially merged together because of a baking error.\n\nThe fact that you cannot count the buns precisely/easily in those edge cases DOESN'T mean you cannot count them every time, you absolutely can.\n\nSo it is true that there isn't an objective answer always, but that doesn't mean it isn't there ever.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCUUq2o8mhqBzIDNc3lP8CCA","author":"@kajacx","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/g3huTGXHbdAoK_ibLZlZnk3k9oNpH0UXOL7eS4uke1obN-T5bFkWDnZtbMm7hTmJsAHQhPe2=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kajacx","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzW55YpmW1-CYHztdJ4AaABAg.AK6M1-_AFwyALDSyjwk0gi","parent":"UgzW55YpmW1-CYHztdJ4AaABAg","text":"So, there's sometimes an exact answer? But not always? That seems like its essentially  the same problem? At least I think  it is. Thanks for  attempting to explain the issue - really appreciate it. FWIW I thought Ben did an okay job explaining a very complex notion is a few sentences.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCroBxfXgLZF8_YtEZMIJtsQ","author":"@MrF_oaf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k18TQOefWzLa5SvdJmEE0dDZLfk4am4CaTqv-UUpCP4ll3lucs6Ttsxlbnh6UOy4Y8dw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrF_oaf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgytYFEn1euJfgPKtCx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Gardener VST in production already lolol","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCPyFTU7o-UoNYnKi1E_ZEhA","author":"@foxbinos","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YNNk2hVdmifS4PzTamwYTf28YJsfQevvLREjxXzppEV42lReDPhoyimmNKbK-znID9rTG2Y3=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@foxbinos","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgytYFEn1euJfgPKtCx4AaABAg.ADUFZ_UKFsWADUQHThArqS","parent":"UgytYFEn1euJfgPKtCx4AaABAg","text":"PLANT RAVE","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz1HG1W2KM8Gic3Gbd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn, someone else might have mentioned it but it seems from the video your experimental setup doesn't account for air movement. It is a well known variable in the hydroponic community that air movement plays a role in plant growth. I am not a sound engineer but I believe the air would be moving more around the plants in your setup where the speakers are than where they are not. Love your videos!","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC5LkLW43LEuTWyBvn0BgWFw","author":"@FarFromEngineering","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_no7OoWhNSrbw3ZZXoNRmfWiaJO0qOjebICiQ-nA92GrEJAGZ8yTqrZipZENrF2zTqaqg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FarFromEngineering","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwygA75DdBnxSetLZ94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The more I watch of Benn and the more I watch of others and I find myself loving his videos more and more. As someone who is probably crazy or maybe not eyebrow wiggle I feel as though I can read people. A LOT of people YouTube are are not genuine people and their smiles and emotions do not match their presentation of themself. Benn seems to as genuine to himself as he can be and I notice and appreciate him for it.... ALSO all the topic of the videos are always the type of stuff that interest me, so good on you! Oh, and thank you and what not.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9J30Ce24Ff_6YxA-I5igsA","author":"@dr_pennysworth","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kbHICZXgX6HNDERkIdWc8-Bm8U-sQ435u3Hzwti8fQbzo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dr_pennysworth","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq2VFGc9QQgVlrlZl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You’re the first creator I’ve considered joining a patreon for. Still considering… but you almost got me on this one. Great video !","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCto5IUcotJ--hVo16jL1c7g","author":"@BRAYZN","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lotwq9kZ-zhxXUPYTHDURWd2bPVUP7N6Lmrz_CAiHeSQgwSE_79junSbEt4Q9YRbEFbA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BRAYZN","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzBqbKIbRHRFxS4FZ14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:32 Is there sound in space... Answer.. YES, there's a lotta noisy s**t out there... does it travel in space, Answer, YES, as long there is a medium in which sound can propagate... If you are in a dead vacuum, then NO, sound cannot travel.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCFBvXu-Dl3JyCIJkrSG-ymg","author":"@Neuralatrophy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l5UlX2ikEsTZEE_vrmbWGWFgYCFB8Ubr85ZXsixKZg6oE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Neuralatrophy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqOh85fdxmG_AcELB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yet another \"science philosophy\" vid with Goedel incompleteness theorem abuse. Sad.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCQR24CYP1y67vjegbBu19ZA","author":"@dariuszantoniuk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mrjO9OGCV3s4KL5FAO-JkZCuMMdHk-I8doHCLmp6C9osfz_JqGDDAT1lwVBwdRzZ35_w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dariuszantoniuk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqOh85fdxmG_AcELB4AaABAg.ADUG1TcfosoADUJB1MTs2r","parent":"UgzqOh85fdxmG_AcELB4AaABAg","text":"yup :/","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSQMa9D5MzzpvbKiBVlovTg","author":"@creepylookingtree","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nr9xE_2vBhbh6K--Fq-aive21XyEQnu2y02BiS_JoIPeuEzrRmJAz6CHewA8Z5_h4Pew=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@creepylookingtree","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqOh85fdxmG_AcELB4AaABAg.ADUG1TcfosoADUNVLEhiuw","parent":"UgzqOh85fdxmG_AcELB4AaABAg","text":"Math cannot prove itself in the same way that a computer program cannot run itself.\n\nI didn't get the vibe that this was misrepresented. Incompleteness also implies that there is only so much precision available to an observer. I think that was what he was trying to say here.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCUUUM9iIqBlQRbGWu9DObCA","author":"@misterscottintheway","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lBcb1s-eLm8xTzzn7WZCbz6o6czUwuiwEJ-9rFlB8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@misterscottintheway","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqOh85fdxmG_AcELB4AaABAg.ADUG1TcfosoADUGcj3LkGP","parent":"UgzqOh85fdxmG_AcELB4AaABAg","text":"We have no idea what that is nerd","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0dHUODtyX6yZo2BqsFLXTQ","author":"@ileutur6863","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x0EiYJOarePlvhIHojszjcM9P1NGNJSqtbqZ5Vft79QbUFGhFDNIKPSib0M7BBrT8GOWXnXJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ileutur6863","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxwRVBGyvV4gQsE0Ut4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is the first time I've come across your channel. It's great! I love the way you present information. Nice work","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaYUHrsqppqQXi5uJEbNdaA","author":"@KratosMetalworks","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zpPiqNySnQZXUggQq7jFLcucmzyTHu_J15UYwcHUjPGhNWFcXd_bdZns1dFeQGNiHZxyqIM9jw8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KratosMetalworks","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIfS_SPMaXa53_3Hp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I shall be playing reggae music during my next pot cultivation cycle ,thanks Benn","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCv7dYH2RXzNVtXFKkSpGxkA","author":"@enochroot9438","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mcNfgvEKBSS76lsZwTgNUUDJodBDtRcCZ2xUm9QMwgYBs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@enochroot9438","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzFWEUGtPMbfEts65V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wow. \n\n\nVery few people , very few , have any type of experiences that paralel mine, and fewer end up on the more cerebral side of inteligence. \nAlways a great ride Ben.\n\nThis is good stuff.\nMy economic reality is improving, and I reslly want to join your Patreon in a meaningful way.\n\nOk, bye","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRMgIA-Baj3LBxnlLpPgQjg","author":"@ilias4156","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kBzsaQTwTDvvv85sX12lAGs9kQ59LMJqgFzPEC66M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ilias4156","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwqqmaxB8XuSZlWj-F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well done Benn - this is wonderful!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9Jg0zsgjNxjltlFjE0YvNw","author":"@MattPowersSoil","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sIfxgQicoFGz57bD9V6FzV8FcOCSKnfRMCAykIphrxbWQfRWQ6nN07WVivhoX_7UZRBjFDSW=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MattPowersSoil","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzleyBUrg3De_D9KtZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Oooh, pre-floc Benn. what a treat. These were the times.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXH1CH31bMXDAyxJ3XUAwLw","author":"@ZLAWK","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/joG1G9ZCncsXCZWPwAN5OdWO4YEmu4BiW0O1Ab75br7-iwPeZXJEWSYivXQVU5rWeVANIqGtaA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ZLAWK","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzdvlFPKpCBFQLZF0N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a young and ambitious maths grad interested in pursuing a career in the field, Gödel's incompleteness theorem was by far the piece of thought that influenced me the most. After I got familiar with it, it slowly destroyed the platonic convictions I had in other scientific fields too. I think that the vast majority of our world's problems can be summarized by this: the platonic ideals that our civilization chose to compose the cultural status quo of, have been reaching their limits in the 20th century. An example of this is Gödel's incompleteness theorem in maths. Some other ideas with similar implications include: Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, Heidegger's critique of metaphysics, Wittgenstein's turn from Tractatus to Philosophical investigations, the rise of post-structuralism after structuralism, and the linguistic turn (most of these are of course overlapping).\n\nTo me, it's apparent that the crisis of these principles affect us on a deeply personal level. Classical economics is permeated with platonic ideals and idealisms, and the effect of it on human psyche needs no explanation. The same can be said about politics. \n\nTo take a few steps back from postmodern philosophy, one can say that Platonism has had it coming at least from Kant's Critique of Pure Thought. Various forms of realisms lived on though, although Kant's transcendental metaphysics can certainly be seen as the predecessor of the aforementioned ideas.\n\nAnd of course, there is Nietzsche, the so-called anti-Plato. The shortcomings of modernism were pointed at during it's time, but took real effect in the 20th century.\n\nHowever, it needs to be pointed out that Platonism has had it's counter movement even at the Academy about 80 years after his death. The so-called middle period of the academy strongly emphasized philosophical scepticism. Basically, the idea of what Benn mentioned when holding the chickens: there is highly probable, and highly improbable, in-between, but no certainty.\n\nIt's crazy to think what would've happened in history, if scepticism stayed in favour there more than 2000 years ago.\n\nThanks Benn for the book recommendations! And it's pretty cool that you know about this!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCcIyGPj5caHJ_vPuRAxk9SA","author":"@barnabasfuto5529","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mhMgbg5302iqhwBObvNE8CSV0zK0_ez7mxhjfAcKyHac0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@barnabasfuto5529","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw-g1tZp1NKQ2voFD14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did a trial and currently doing one with classical music and can confirm from the first one that the flowers did dance and move towards the speaker.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgSP8jQ26tCLbFN1LAZmAJg","author":"@Synthetic-Chicken","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pAnWtFbaeTI2K2bezvjA5mCQ8r94HH3T-jvcnUDFW-JDvx1L04kuTwoqtRfUFnzlhO8rClCMgtU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Synthetic-Chicken","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2hmyE7AHvLhUkCah4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You had me at “I did a whole F#@king video on this that nobody watched.”\nSubbed up,let’s go!🎉","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChT9NvgKuzs97bRWF-X_LRw","author":"@bonesdoes6142","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kMz0I8dV9w28C6ONZKJxx6RREoHTUWNiTXCyl4jWE_Ww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bonesdoes6142","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2hmyE7AHvLhUkCah4AaABAg.AKLWCq9KHswAKLYEs36VIl","parent":"Ugx2hmyE7AHvLhUkCah4AaABAg","text":"YaY! I had a felony cannabis conviction myself 😂Actually two. They actually charged me with B&E and Manufacturing Narcotics. For growing weed. In the woods. It sounds like I kicked someone’s door down and started a meth lab  🤦🏻‍♂️ \nAnyway,I’m rambling because I’m stoned off of my home made tincture but I wanted to say that I like the way you communicate,explain things in an understandable manner and make me laugh while you’re at it. Loving the content so far.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChT9NvgKuzs97bRWF-X_LRw","author":"@bonesdoes6142","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kMz0I8dV9w28C6ONZKJxx6RREoHTUWNiTXCyl4jWE_Ww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bonesdoes6142","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwiKR7ckaBvo8YmMT94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Late to the game but I greatly appreciate your \"pedantic\" conversation. You basically just explained how good science starts!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCi4PeLqa7YRMGEbo4eVVpaw","author":"@T3Knical5urg3","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nL7MSoQrXLwHpsndwF9G0OwUzBvgwheJTa6_RmPC_QN6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@T3Knical5urg3","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxBb9CXu7fRDw-NyDZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But nowhere near as time consuming and expensive as SMASHING THAT LIKE BUTTON AMIRITE!!!\n\nLove your videos man. Always wildly insightful and interesting, great work!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3XGu-TgUONQmLLR5VMYvew","author":"@MacThane","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qM89zc6jN9OBYOdxKX0XSlEadCcP1I54ljLHUo_-zo31QijymO7NQkODWbDBEfp9yIZtMhMa=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MacThane","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXgK_16pQkvtLLIbp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wow! Helped me extend my thought process in random unthought directions 👍","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQeIqVUI-bBlbsuVD5oPnuA","author":"@TN-Chaudhry","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hx6OavcRSvVzCGdNxTcl9K9vRuZ7-G80BCbvZ_ZhbwMjUpxrdyIGPQvbbywTv3kWc96lWWG3zuc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TN-Chaudhry","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyr0I6gccyj7KvIwz14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As soon as he asked “what type of speaker?” I got a chill up my spine “oh god! Here come the audiophiles 😩”","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7xsUzNgWwQqqLFanVxN5Jg","author":"@bidensbloodvassal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/y33J35hrqsVdZQvHJDOgvS2fS7MYMrLMiOsxUG8oCAehT7f4KEMpXM6_fzJ7sKyRsEgN-O3M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bidensbloodvassal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2AICXBU_xcf9NWbl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Mort Garson was right after all. Plantasia is such an amazing record, highly recommend","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC6vqx3ftKm2D27Axs502HXw","author":"@lucyalicenox","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6yFa53Wd4QZl_lgj3PKyEX9i0iNPRSRvNSd1m5yo6tmfgg94O1aJxN5IRl5VHI7_2YLv2sTX=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lucyalicenox","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxjlUUnJw41CWnR80Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for all your work and opening up, your videos are important","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtTFSLq4OR1XVJLUBWDAOvA","author":"@sinoftheinternet","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xJk9cuVltZSxqIIY3kwUo6qQaKIW0Yy_5fFKGSj2bevgVEdqWaxuTTK3XnYoZEcYQCgo1P7r=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sinoftheinternet","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzT0PvHFV50BcEI-rp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"PMSL, Christ, only found you this week and I love what you are doing. Brilliant, the way you think is great. Why are you doing this? It's great, but I can't believe/am amazed that you have capacity for YouTubing! Maximum effort, Keep on keeping on. Nuts and great, hug a tree and keep it real, expensing your grow room,  Epic.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVxSIfVIgipOfYQlSFwLv1Q","author":"@tomunsworth7971","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lX2ptxE2lvmayY-VcXNXea3USbX122PSaY7KhMpDxgtlo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tomunsworth7971","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugym5yk-rzGFDMBWgDx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"the value is incredible","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-Md58mDZT9WphmuvOSxXNg","author":"@sam-hutch","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/F-XuMwViws-I1i7rKIEdhP4Y2cjlhBFnTSwhZ8U_zgdbslwNDUgQktDVAhkjoDJz78OZs4_FwA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sam-hutch","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxq65xWXFmV-inyjA94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Now I am super interested in testing plant growth rates in an anechoic chamber.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIszvaABA6yCVYSpG1yRVyQ","author":"@bradlyely","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nD0Z4-qGTGBlq9YiwsdLtN6wHcpwtqROr1YMVCNv-qiEY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bradlyely","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwt1ThiN_62BWz3QMN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"There was a study done in Australia that said not music, but certain frequencies stimulated microbe activity and efficiency in soil.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfggspweDZh6lvpgx-2zh5w","author":"@Steve-dl6vm","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8XKHqSWkWTWqWfEqmk_VKzILNNjD_Lzb82OiQOJGQrEQgbhrNF_TgQFrd7LuMlqJAqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Steve-dl6vm","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwee8KBDW7a9M4V_kd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The earth plane is a stationary enclosed realm.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpQDESYa8f9LEcOm2nf28CQ","author":"@jedijeff2070","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3Hn4srhvZA0QIKe6IZs9gpxJpfnIi1YQuB9tfP-c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jedijeff2070","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago (edited)","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6_V-kBBofffmcQ7R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Love your set up - respect to someone who knows how to audio engineer. I put my plants in the room next to my server room. Those near 100 120hz server fans run all day long. lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzCPpm-SO7UkpG203G5sXWw","author":"@doit9854","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nmb9a7AAEQVy59oXDEJ0u4zE-tJ7DG2Fb1jC_CrsSbkIc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@doit9854","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzBJE4csnoURPTT1F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Looks like you've broken into a new audience for all your eurorack gear!  This is a game changer!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVuqGPMvQDU3-6xBDecbWuQ","author":"@afreezaphorogiancossack2194","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lV9tECIoP00k6Hmh1-grQzHIigtOnb8_oie9wAzF6CJwQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@afreezaphorogiancossack2194","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1oAfQOL9t-Jqef_J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Nice! I've watched an entire video about Gödel, that was handy!\nAnd I sure do want a followup video :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKVFkkxpcOu6RKfxZZ7fvJQ","author":"@MakooWallinen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7MzX9nR89delrMRkOZxtzp45G8sCilNClZ4pneeuQn4AQaT76io3e4qiYSc15JFTWP_9aqqT=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MakooWallinen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwEmeX_kF0yHUHZ2W54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"15:14 what a great mic stand.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk9krvBHhjVJzWkNnElayyQ","author":"@g0ldER","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lmPVF9rW8csRKuC6oLOaRhkEhY5JFMvqPg0rbD_ZAkWX8NIsQLU1CeGCbIaWW-9RJUhZbP2m4Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@g0ldER","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzUSggMz69q9wH1ZN14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I cannot even believe you have not created the most accurate chicken translator","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXA9DwFYs4LKGL4OJUQuVbQ","author":"@meb3153","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kfurqBXvKjpKhsZWRzjh5ZSDAeaG6LDh5BL0nx_tNqEDI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@meb3153","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyeQ3gxwOXhI8zAV014AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I thought I was watching Wet Hot American Summer for a second when you threw the hen and I heard a terracotta pot breaking! lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvI9hcd7sOwYmPmWQaAOobA","author":"@ianmckenna29","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n7n9p9mI0ZKWcJ43hL3Lsl6jgfKUlEG6DNdSQhkiW3KAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ianmckenna29","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxwsNX38mP_V2a0tcZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I researched this years ago. It has been a dream project for some time. Awesome work. Pair with fog ponics and its get scary how fast they can grow under the right conditions.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSNR1EqM-LBm8T6OjSCi3IQ","author":"@Just_Lew","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nnNucBzzxBEW7w6VY6C_rI-0iH-gSOnhkD0QpD6e_dIF_B=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Just_Lew","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6jDqjdCoN8t10KbJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:57 this just made me laugh my ass off, I'm going to watch the video after this😂😂😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3G2kSSe7_mG0byKFiHQZVg","author":"@FGMCI","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wdVZOOVjkVVERdcqYkRJaSPmvi_IHHssOJT03w6SuEOlRULSGFUs08Y6bClHaOxj9bBuKzOL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FGMCI","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxbgwnx8X___EVh0eB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've always thought the plants liking sound thing was simply plants liking air circulation. I very much liked the jazz music in the video. Jazz music makes all things jive and thrive.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRTDz93jzUNrKtQWtV7TfWw","author":"@TM10000","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Cszn2l4enpNaDe_KxyS0QKgRE7j2x3MzEakeRBciMc-O4zWRdtGTFt9bKwLo5Q7V6AGyZ_ud=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TM10000","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx0-MoP3i_xTJRX1Pt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Okay - you're the coolest person alive Benn. It's been decided.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5tDwT_Dd3Ld96EngYzk3Uw","author":"@ArtificialIdentityDisorder","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/gYAt72jZAYNOcpE7WrnK438nuHf34xcZn2wz86i4BR4DLXaCNL6JhXLvGr7caJ6tDTQLYfhTDA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ArtificialIdentityDisorder","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxndLiBQOcbL6aQF9l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I saw one study that showed that plants can hear water under ground which makes sense, it was pretty interesting.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPcMg2EjBWkwEXpOYfjZUgg","author":"@Solarpunkscience","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Efgz5_NyBylM4aW8nEn5Rug0WS6XrqvENOguj50HDDmySIRu3u17Dyb4eILs3UfS-_obhqDp=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Solarpunkscience","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCjYrE7RF_1BUGmZl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"someone needs to start a Cit-Science publication, for those without a degree to publish their work.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCqg7hR_KK5wSBLIqI2xPldA","author":"@amberkluga8949","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ktSoqZ1jkyW2KPi_GyXX7jSPz6TZ5P_CyYOTSkTuSaqQY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@amberkluga8949","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7UYr-EXePjvJD69x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This channel makes my ADHD brain so happy. Such brilliant work. I appreciate how well you’re able to communicate such quality information.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDQSMI6VwXDzqLYAPbdzwcQ","author":"@Robbie_Bobb","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mdKzaAtdqkW_S2bsHuO6lzBbkc-iZrBjawLa3IU3IPnxk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Robbie_Bobb","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwAFVFcyqYk7vSRfG14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This made me lol so hard I subscribed. The dad energy is strong here","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9Q52rtRFl8QjHWaGV3FAtw","author":"@craftwerks5644","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNEgL32hZjSZCfz_tIWwN6ykXJf8YNc_9slbcDym0pZA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@craftwerks5644","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwAFVFcyqYk7vSRfG14AaABAg.AEJB5WQG0tfAEJD5txJI6o","parent":"UgwAFVFcyqYk7vSRfG14AaABAg","text":"\"anyway what's up with you\" literally crying laughing","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9Q52rtRFl8QjHWaGV3FAtw","author":"@craftwerks5644","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNEgL32hZjSZCfz_tIWwN6ykXJf8YNc_9slbcDym0pZA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@craftwerks5644","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxfjP4LoHhodd0OtO94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for your integrity.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC02CJR-42zoggdCcXT4hnyg","author":"@EllhaDavid","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xggd1k_3HfhQNIujcxZI0MCGB9_l4Wb2S_UvUuA8yjealiKHV7ESyZDOjF8XICLcRp2T0vb7swo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EllhaDavid","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxznIlThfQxDsKeOu14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"sound from the pillow mount was the best.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtGo7ygSweS7vog0sWjnwSg","author":"@TimGray","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mu4--VeKl1PGg-F0xJMC2i-saIl5OmHhTa4luv6IzRfSDR=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TimGray","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxw38YJQz5EMoJl1ad4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Holy shit!!!!\n\nThat opening joke is basically one I have used since I was a teen, it's crazy to hear it from someone else, and kind of a bummer 😆","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCN7YVds-n9G9wA39l-kJc9w","author":"@unclemikescomedy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kAvXwKhF9W-758960a9XjLrXxvSdrZkX4XZl0vZ0CotMcCwuJe0HKveyMX8NMWQ9UFfw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@unclemikescomedy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbexANHUct8by4oXh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3:57 Dude with and Oud! 😂 Ben, from one man to another, you have a nice rack! 😂 Awesome collection of strings man. \nIt would be great to work with you on a project. Thanks for you channel and the plethora of content.\nThanks.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHRFzwWQSsZdiw0l_7VF1EQ","author":"@cajuncrackerranch7990","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xfBxrpcr-dUzuGdk02tqPC_ddu_JQReb_PeOXmVvBVCHzxgMFqvXoCImREQAEEfxY_x9-veiUzc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cajuncrackerranch7990","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxG37b1J4Lt76ZVAeF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Amazing content, YouTube Negan, I've subscribed","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCun0Tye7CWcwAuYOkfNkthw","author":"@reactiveboi5215","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nDn8aVVdYsznYIfHssVbZpuT3aDhoNH0gLSv-MF2tuyaQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@reactiveboi5215","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzJ7ST50QiomD8WaBN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I like your headphone's man!! Man of culture","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCERZP01Rlhi-24LJoX6JTFA","author":"@driesvancleemput4430","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mQ0F3Uvf6dG1khY9rhDr9XkB_LsWlNb_vmXFJ7_wQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@driesvancleemput4430","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgytCCs-aiWLR0bdrTJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You have no idea how lucky you are, your life path is just amazing. I wish I could say the the same and do something similar.... Although people won't understand, life in most places of the world is just hard and unwilling.... I'm surviving not really living, and honestly I don't see any changes coming in the next years. I thank YouTube for escaping and discovering, I am healthy and happy so no complaints😊.\n\n\nHappy new year, I truly love you and glad you exsit","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4t_z0vaaDAdLL1s3ibVooA","author":"@fryedupjoe","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lT8Qu4LCD_pf9EwiAYpLW0gk_IeN8X9SN8VrwEe_FldWB8_Tdy3pM5DhTGCs4a8PJ_Cg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fryedupjoe","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqiEPu-EIIxNaD93d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I ran a small hothouse/shadehouse production nursery for 4 years and i swear by the growing properties of death metal","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsMg4o6dQNz56CjlbB-Dbyg","author":"@jameshunt4097","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DSAbDV2n4MFi-eSVcjU1a8SkBvD_c9KrKNWK5ZYsnUCj71L2Snyk82d7JxbelgI7WrLl4OkI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jameshunt4097","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyeFDOKTMKs_i7KcEN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wish i could help and inspire people like you do, but im an inventor thats all i have the brains for","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiuwvNgYouv7pktPjC6qOVQ","author":"@lynnwilliam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGiaPm00GNQg-B5ZGyTGZM3l4k5_cPv9-5ZLHfgws=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lynnwilliam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxFOY4oul8gOMhHs0x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video. Super interesting! You are very entertaining to watch. Quite funny.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCC-FrJ8SHcGi4FWNRNQyTQ","author":"@patrickschooley3503","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mr37oRls3u6k7EE_8gDqBxn_k1Cw9-a1KK79pSS85YEcYWkOxBOW-pyk2xx5PX-pxcIw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@patrickschooley3503","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2hHJRctKR69v4JbV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I won the Chaminade science fair with this experiment. '93. I had 10 different types of music in separate rooms with btcn' stereos and a several control batches. I ran 2 crops to fruition and the results were identical.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiBtEnrx0oE-6wuhTbK-iQg","author":"@sloppyoppie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kkHqP8UMQhP_6PHdUKSGJi0K_du7YvT7a3gGvyQ2PgR78=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sloppyoppie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyOeN98yRRPvyOQoJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The way you formulate thoughts and express them seem to be extremely similar to me. Also I have a similar history with school. I was diagnosed about 2 years ago with ADHD and now I’m starting to see people with similar qualities and wonder if they might also have the same diagnosis. I love to study many different subjects independently and have many hobbies. I’m not always right about people but if you said you have adhd too I wouldn’t be surprised. I found this video because one of my hobbies involves  tissue culture production and collecting and propagating rare plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCY9CDoqi9pX74b_Rt83jShw","author":"@Travgrieder","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kmOKEGg3EmUiZNjri0BovmPf-mxWmgvHbWW9UoziEzvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Travgrieder","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwEHgxx8-f2I8cbPQt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:40… good gracious 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdhF1L-ykY2FqySAdY0gGbA","author":"@Ohyeahspinach","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x8YPJogvR8qR5_DzxizAjKNqez9O3-2QdP1-sqNMMu1FlYPlRExEIFmRE7YW2ghPfno3dj2z=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ohyeahspinach","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzMUZ2-OgVYpp9wkIR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3:40 puhhh hit take. We don't know if plants do have feelings ;)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDO9S2TqJSUGPWs2sqfEWmA","author":"@nonymous-l2b","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kTfRBP_E4ChFYHLrVwtZUM3u04-NItvxqRNJoUMINHmS1x-0mHyXhAT9keVUg0jG7i7g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nonymous-l2b","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrY3JVuy26hvizbTh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"subbed.  thanks, i look forward to more","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFcg0ZV8XmdDToFtcvpR8fw","author":"@ianajames","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lj_OjbaymPbI9iFJScs9TlxHpC5SwUf0-richjzPftZVg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ianajames","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKDHmjB6yTkRQyRrx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"We absolutely need studies to cover all and variable soundwaves.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGog6j44yoG8NWlLAZHeW7w","author":"@nidodson","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nXkOTAb7K1FOybVprEDp90Vkcmwcwzc5iN50lOZU0eCi4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nidodson","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzcnUr1KegFb9RpvrR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"BENN, thanks for sharing all your insights. God bless","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW08ERVj2IBJF32FJ62lfEA","author":"@CMDoreOTR","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_khJnjW9cPQ0da4sL09dxvSvco6z8POYQ037il2iDbrcak=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CMDoreOTR","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz19f8XV5Yp-9qgKe94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The bit about acid rock killing the plants is funny. Years ago, an old roommate of mine and I played black metal for our jalepeños to try and make them hotter. It was just for fun, so we didn’t run any kind of control for comparison, but I can tell you those plants were very robust and the peppers were indeed hot.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHQTnX941qYtnYawa-6kgbw","author":"@JohnFWitt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kLjoe5g_6s5VDvwxSYVXHnjE0PbhjV9DOmP9xsoYGxWA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JohnFWitt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyn2NX-0wzBZV1Q4KJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is why we have a little speaker that blasts a bird song frequency every day for an hour in the mornings! We also use a special spray fertilizer to use with this during that time once a month. The plants grow INSANELY bigger and faster! It’s called “Sonic Bloom” and it increases the size of their uptake holes during the bird song. I highly recommend this for all plants you want to grow bigger and faster.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCURPXm3DngxQf05qHBznjnA","author":"@getblated","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/p-3Mga19moSgMUWBLWacFuBfFVG5G4Y6YkU3ZtoZ16dgTiS6EQ5_SPoJXa0e1GKLF66Qnmfn=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@getblated","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJf-mzEa8Vygsj9Wh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ive noticed plants definitely respond better to sound than without.  I play all sorts of stuff for them.  Bird sounds in the morning and evening bec they open the stomatas, then crickets and frogs at night.  Rain noises on days i water.  Various genres of music.  528hz pure tone. Frequency sweeps.\n\n  I'll even throw on laughing compilation videos, and that seems to show the most growth!  The plants bounce back quicker from any nutrient deficiencies (on plants with weaker genetics) and genuinely perk up.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn5f02hWKzpvcwIICgYmThg","author":"@zensational.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/P8VNsmhgg-Vl4nwDdav5PERGmuHi6qSd_LfRHcDwA33pQ7u85Amzj39D0nwbb1Ze0sSjcGC_AA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zensational.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz4003R72QkrFC40Hx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"16:42 I see where the interest on how to grow plants faster stemmed from -_^","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChWPh_7X_Z7tB0nZ2T0-n4A","author":"@PsyCoCinematics","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lRbi_nBCdtSrQlkE3EoxoFEYJc6eD78-pjozvWgcIgqA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PsyCoCinematics","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJEEWf9gqfFAW9bsh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Lol 😂 I cannot stop laughing at the point which you walked outside and are talking into a twig your little microphone attached. You were cracking me up earlier when it was attached to the purple pillow and I'm like why doesn't he just attach that to his collar LOL but that's the second time I've actually had to stop the video to laugh my head off because you're totally just cracking me up and the third time I had to stop the video because I couldn't stop laughing so hard that I couldn't even hear what you were saying I had to back it up and listen again was when you said I made this video that got no views and I was just that hit me so hard in the tickle bone that I can hardly stop laughing just to make this comment but I figured anybody who makes me laugh that many times I just have to leave a comment as I wipe away the tears of laughter from my eyes thank you so much I'm enjoying your videos it's fun to listen to someone else think knowing there are actually people out there who use their brain in today's day and age . I really enjoyed your video also on the mysterious hum because I've recently discovered I have ADHD or at least I was told I do and I do have a lot of the symptoms but supposedly I have a really high IQ which is really only relative to the questions you're answering so honestly I don't believe in IQ as a measure of intelligence I think emotional intelligence is completely underrated and of all things needs to be taught and is completely overlooked but he's getting a little bit of attention in the last 20 years but what really caught my attention was because of the mysterious home the connection that was made to ADHD which is connected to a low dopamine level in the brain but I have always heard really high pitched noises and sometimes inside a store walking in a store I have literally actually had to turn around and walk back out because the sound is completely deafening it's so loud other times hearing super high pitch sounds before crossing the street and realizing it's coming from something that has to do with the signal changing that's as much as I could figure it out trying to figure out where the thing is coming from or where the sound is the loudest as I would be standing on a curb trying to cross the street and be hit with this super loud high pitch sound that no one else seemed to be able to hear accept my friend who's eyesight was 20/200 ... in other words he was almost legally blind but he had amazing hearing and he could hear it too . Thanks for all these fun videos and for cracking me up tonight. That was awesome😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCI4QJc6XKYoSCVx4CwmibCg","author":"@AmeliaStender9","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2OLFFkmie79QjiP1Whb4chdG6Ff_OmFfYMvaPwssA_ipD9Yx5fwLH-LUCmw3BkGSu2dg5gfN8Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AmeliaStender9","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzmJj47LVu0ps5nEN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Already thumbed up in the first 20 seconds for that insane intro","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHybpGZn8IfttlQyqOeTJ0g","author":"@corbinbrody1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kLPU5S65JsLbRo99A4mavyPaXSaoDHSHK4jBPZUzn5TA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@corbinbrody1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaNO8b6cbBudApGGF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"“Plants don’t have feelings or emotions”: citation needed 😉","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCm5qMNQjk7uCFklnrVnVV_A","author":"@Nellybeee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mQPSrH_ciG7qqWxXbvLdt-yOWg8iIxIJ94kZavog4xQVh7F-Pwyaiwm5oLdrxwNC7pVw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nellybeee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxN7UgiNietKCGeIPt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sonic Fertilizer is an excellent name for a band","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtl0pbZzCpWRDcILDVWmY8Q","author":"@doris41236","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dY_28AwW7V0kf1gHfGV1Wu_x38vmkA5_qrMn_bDqm3TQ_Jkier4QdOyhFgmkM8k154SOQ0Y8AA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@doris41236","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyjhJHU0yIe3J1SbC94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The birds sing to my outdoor plants all day long and they're doing grea. The indoor are not doing so good and I have nothing to lose if I give it a try.. let the music begin!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCw1cT-VvyCLeBBJGJFXZuwA","author":"@JustiNourse","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/K36IuRehLHOr_zMcnkq_4Mf5gUF21KndiizzrjCLYa7NPywKvT02egOyow5TxvjBcDxFHG-1=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JustiNourse","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwF0_Wx14rHhFq9gWl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn has found a break from the unrelenting march of the dystopian state, to make a cosy scientific video","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXxyfnIh4oLDdW8MLngZ5xA","author":"@SirFlukealot","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kAgyMaANwzbotu9Sb79KvKBdqeOMz6SW8AAZxcQvzpXLE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SirFlukealot","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9Btp4sIw7Bv297Ap4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi! First off, love your content.\n\nSecondly...\nI was a research assistant at IU Indianapolis under a genius man named Professor Park. During my time with him, I learned of a concept called the p-curve. The p-curve is used to detect selective reporting, publication bias, or p-hacking. It exists in a relatively new field of science called meta-science, which you touched on very briefly when mentioning that roughly a third of published studies are reproducible.\n\nYou sound learned enough to understand the concept. For brevity, I will spare the full details, but essentially it evaluates whether a body of statistically significant results contains evidential value by examining the distribution of reported p-values across studies investigating a given question or theory.\n\nMaybe I will explain a bit to pique your nerdy curiosity...\n\nImagine a graph: the x axis represents statistically significant p-values, typically ranging from 0 to .05, and the y axis represents the frequency of those p-values. When a set of studies shows a higher concentration of very small p-values, closer to 0 rather than clustered just below .05, it suggests the presence of a real underlying effect and a lower likelihood that the findings are primarily the result of p-hacking or selective reporting.\n\nIf this goes above your head, I highly recommend reading academic articles on meta-science and the concept of the p-curve.\n\nCheers mate! Keep producing fantastic content :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4Ol_jJ7eU-N3vqWDSWq19g","author":"@kolbesmithmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8HA1yRJzRmUFIy8gBwQsKgWNxdIaE3bHrSTHdkwxKV4YKNfljz4hP7hGQBfdLya4uLHavz0LyA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kolbesmithmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxEDr0fZmep2VVrkS94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is a very deep rabbit hole ❤ 👍","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKZHiz7ZsutQzCRpTBA4Ytw","author":"@SimplyHEARTLESS","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zM2vMEAhGvFUnWSjItpRVXc0dnyULJOXtwzIHj3edU7-xdKmRd9igmFyaUWv8S1s4McMx8LBDA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SimplyHEARTLESS","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzfcv51ceWnUXZRpxB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's interesting how the postulates we're formulated. IIRC, biomass comes mostly from air not soil.\nTherefore it'd be interesting to establish a control group that are in front of a quiet fan... It might simply help establishing the extent of how sound helps with air circulation, thus really just bringing more molecules into the biomass absorption / conversion?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnKVJiVBraJlF_-XMuy2HxQ","author":"@hickscorp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXWiHiQ-w6hRiU2wzQGZPOWF1DwKTP70A2EHzrhfMGsw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hickscorp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-0JHUPp05h039wPB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sound is energy, plants are just absorbing it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSuQn0KEI3A4ixYMB9rqAKw","author":"@menezessilva3007","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lS2pXDVQuBWG16tcSDDYZz1mwYIl1DmxTTib1fhUAAPQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@menezessilva3007","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwrOrzNretqFNbZLa94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"2:41 i played knocked loose for my plants and i swear the next day they were much more dense","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_CMQ7VXYptgGKPQOeLyAXw","author":"@Crazyclay78YT","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mPxRlzxrnaAP79RSAD2NLOuse78D1AQn6rS9WHf6LEiZY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Crazyclay78YT","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyC1eYOX3cQO6Uh2T54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hilariously entertaining and educational with a side of inspirational.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEtYgEY2vKB7JkTjhs_xQ4Q","author":"@BradAcquilin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7pgkH9XKLTRPv4q2Go7lIuN2Hoa6Rp-SSFcN_GKer2KnrV9dKWpjrcoeV6dXOSYD-NaipgXNaA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BradAcquilin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwnpXq1GytEbDw9KP54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hen sounds soothe my troubled Tylenol.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaUnfBJ8obAgxTL85w2pj4g","author":"@ComicusFreemanius","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0rLGyzcn7fXGeOoAX8jPcbYQXvu9OnUTZehCZ7fuF8GqN8hAEcbpur250cuzyu8NMYohzmmuvuo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ComicusFreemanius","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQztbB8-Dy0KBiao94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The super genius back at it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIiC4LbBfdc8V_f28mUs9vg","author":"@CatchinAlaska","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/tARLcbfSFbGWCmLDnL1vtBAGrRyBTC5tkfp5yBuvBWFY2dk4xzfgdQHXwUaz5U2ppLfhdsQXQ3M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CatchinAlaska","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-6dal5QNsy93zGVF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dawg it took me 5 seconds to look this up. Yes, multiple scientific studies show that sound waves and mechanical vibrations can influence plant cellular activity, gene expression, seed germination, and root growth","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpqP79oF6ISOo7LmxyPx7vA","author":"@ainamal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mvpYxiDWcErp55kO81b4aGZn4wFjAeaDyJEFG3-CE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ainamal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyG6S9Ny-0Dk1UP7U54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I dropped out of hs as well but went back and got my BS and masters at 30.  \n\nI really appreciate your work, Ben.  It makes me miss the access to the stuff that you mentioned during this video that’s hidden behind the research firewall. (And the equipment/funding ).","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGE-VtWSIea24zojUwpeBYg","author":"@Hazard4K","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3FHmgqOMcuFZ9DBM7doRd1_ycu2iFhsiUl_hZM1Dq_uQa=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Hazard4K","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzBm9oUsjrYQtI6g1Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i'd love a booklist from you. ive always wanted to be an educator","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-2LLD1hDndPbLCpU4wsv7w","author":"@bentleyreynolds8577","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ln8PMUaxfgy07uFRPUtmfo-kvUUqu4OTvvFQB-QqoY9Aex=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bentleyreynolds8577","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwiblzCNWJp711vavd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I played Phonk to my cactus.\nNow its a Rose bush.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCM_VxKRuMi0B-q9bm03oJpA","author":"@miroto9446","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kPGS2GqIUb46NDs-9vh7w893i6V0fnZ3TlI4ZZj6Qug5A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@miroto9446","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxoZoJt-_By3ctCmmx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Suffering is a great teacher brother","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCJwgUaYis3VgEGLssWttfw","author":"@Dkthearn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nLaU8yPouSIvjIpUeCCev6QixHb-31QoZ-bn1BGmw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dkthearn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhabTXCV9kl-Wec154AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"9:30 that violin sound reminds me of the similar sounding meme every fucking time.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMefjirCV_5sAAg1JgdJetg","author":"@max_ishere","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nSJAHRroX76yQW5ezi4fMtRLrUsGNVf08JvmH_SnDNU9NFB_WfBwS0tezeJxAKUUlBoA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@max_ishere","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxlchZsWr75Th3Q-JB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"That was a HELL of an intro 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8GuTZO0PYkPPxxDCupLlQA","author":"@JoMcD21","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mYtOVG_pB4c7IezwTYTKCyCrtVFpfJ1c6CKQSF16-dEg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JoMcD21","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysmVNAqheqUCIRcg14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"LOL this was a great video man.  I would be interested to see a comparison to a small breeze.  Plants always grow bigger and stronger in response to the stressor of wind.  My theory would be that music is acting almost like a microdose of wind just causing small physical stress on the plants resulting in the growth response.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC-Eo_w6SnMPhsZFJDadBPKg","author":"@carvedwood1953","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kIO5bjIMMyYmXOKv_SeRkJp6N-9mTcgzT74QQi_2c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@carvedwood1953","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzic9TQF3UntrXSC0x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"That description of Gödel's incompleteness theorem was a straight-up misrepresentation.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UClLQ2W7hj1bSW5k1p5UGBrg","author":"@Zahlenteufel1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lj02TKBBvKVNzloeOlo16SCb4O5cJ_b6282uJJfxCk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Zahlenteufel1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzic9TQF3UntrXSC0x4AaABAg.AJRJqTHFQ03ALDSYt0pYqe","parent":"Ugzic9TQF3UntrXSC0x4AaABAg","text":"Then set us straight, Sensei.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCroBxfXgLZF8_YtEZMIJtsQ","author":"@MrF_oaf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k18TQOefWzLa5SvdJmEE0dDZLfk4am4CaTqv-UUpCP4ll3lucs6Ttsxlbnh6UOy4Y8dw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrF_oaf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwxtUnFJdxxPhwULjl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I want to make a research study platform for citizen scientists. That will guide them to make quality research that is well documented, suitable, and published. \n\nSomeone doesn't even have to perform the research themselves, they could take your video document all the findings, methods and put it into a standardized format. You would get the credit for doing the research, they would get the credit for compiling it. Improving both your credibilities, and ultimately helping out the scientific community as a whole.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC7OHXo3Teklr0JjhaI0WfBA","author":"@tristin5723","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NyElVu0fOxvRf2ePPuqVucOskgXaWjXxqXYS8_Ai14koA6qwQi1b52dCYDk3wPr9L3DL2K0rBw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tristin5723","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwxtUnFJdxxPhwULjl4AaABAg.AMY8BjmQ4ohAOpxOmvqL3J","parent":"UgwxtUnFJdxxPhwULjl4AaABAg","text":"The world needs something like this. Maybe even some kind of decentralized tools to propagate information based on emergent economies of trust and interest. Don't know if it is actually a reasonable dream, just feels like it should exist.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpy5Iy_xuG2VRNAJoqW1pDg","author":"@jbe665","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ks4PCvQ8bAK18GCHq5C-nQnz4nMA3vJAaWGOK-jS_oShvV4gmjBc6viSjRWiWV1phKsw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jbe665","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyq_1vtkUMLMQYEVPR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As someone who noticed some years ago, that the same plants that were grown indoors vs outdoors, the plants grown indoors grew much skinnier and taller, but were less robust so that when they were moved outdoors, the wind easily blew them over and kinked their main stalk. Plants grown in the presence of agitation from wind grew shorter, but had more girth their stalks. Perhaps agitation from sound waves affects growth in a similar fashion to agitation from gusts of wind. I'd be interested if this test were done where pants were grown in the presence of a mild, intermittent, breeze.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMEJ7NUZxUCbiFMQ9g4z26Q","author":"@Lardzor","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m4vVsJS4h0nK89t7NhEDnSTHgRS9HQ9tHFHJCe7580ktk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lardzor","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxKeXJy6DjxBMjT-zl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"SO funny SO educational. Incredible content","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6EY5S-Wy6_PJ83vPcX1qpQ","author":"@jackgamble8674","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVqnZ9sK-1LYpj_4mu2eUQieeyna7AQPKLrv-Gjkl7aQw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jackgamble8674","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy_ZyOIkqEoXVbpHRx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"your kitchen looks awesome","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLbr-N-d2NfAshH3dv9UXVQ","author":"@salmonskinlover2365","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_msAHlXHNh7ZS_FpimcVqintgTAU14nmsqWTz-re_o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@salmonskinlover2365","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyTGKni5M7hdEhHU-h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The new Carman line is however high Jeff has to fly to get them to give him space wings.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOutTzO5Ag-safMD7Xrqo0g","author":"@Name-ot3xw","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nnRPNCpFxkWN13DovDPs1Iejr3mlOFlN4EGr1iacYGtWY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Name-ot3xw","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrUjevla7mb00Ngld4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wait what.... you did a video on sound existing in a vacuum and I haven't seen it and the YT algorithm didn't recommend it. I LOVE EXPERIMENTS involving the science of \"nothing\" aka vacuums. Ha ha! P.S. I love the work you do. Keep going...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSAqSICz0zljRPcu8jXsX8A","author":"@verlouria","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lCCSwdg27uJ5j8oTJ_QL0SYXKs3E5bj18kT1ILtyUqIQw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@verlouria","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpxjSJXodJ5N8ORSt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've just subscribed to your channel. Your explanation and straightforwardness is refreshing. As a new subscriber I have a request. Would you please make some of the background darker? As I watch you with the white or off white background you seem to get washed out in the foreground. Sorry if this seems presumptuous or rude. I'm just asking.\nAs for why the plants are reacting to the sound it's probably the water in the plants. First there was a Japanese scientist that exposed water to sound and people speaking then quickly froze the water. The different ice crystal formations in relation to different types of sound were  rather drastic. \nSecond, as I understand it, the water in our own cells is a bit different than when we drink it. If the cellular water is \"slippery\" then our cells are healthier. \"Slippery\" was the term used in the documentary I watched. \nThank you for the experiment and the information.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRB-MBltqy9B7a3D6HUR5IA","author":"@daniellore2961","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_koRtQTuIwjQ4FP3RZVg1uE66PaOdUeqFgH8lWkw-1bt37GjlJuRBJ7yTL7l5mFm3VeNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@daniellore2961","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz66IkJMdxDwi_fCDF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Harlan Ellison had a very nice video about how you could hear sound around the Babylon 5 Space Station using appropriate transducers","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfwpABOUuFUHo4kmpEjNceg","author":"@tomholroyd7519","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BobuthLB-7763K4kJiTjIndvmyws5C05ZR4FPSdw7Z2ZYQrWp5OtcXXcgrCOEnsqrXygr518=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tomholroyd7519","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzK0Qiil3zrGZNebh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I played music to my plants when growing cannabis, I was convinced it helped the roots grow faster....always was some super dank herb too....(Also sang to them, told I loved em)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6x8R5T_BcD4OWn4xVemu6g","author":"@CoolBubs-22b","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/E00g-oULAbajcYR87GddNQlD7FdXI1ehogO2FOjr6XWHVfATEGIU0CIcaAbQ7L9mHF86eJmK8PE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CoolBubs-22b","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxeFHPxQY-qKp_YyZN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What could also be a reason for better growth with sound, is  that it helps with disburbing the stale air/ improve air circulation","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmc1S3DxCASFNYl36YF0k1g","author":"@ivotakens3441","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_neKLkcl9a517XkvU-PWqFG0jijg43I0ExRu7OJp8U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ivotakens3441","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzHTIR3JKYFGhq8iht4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My dogpanion and I play music 🎶 in the forest everyday and the chickadees follow us through the forest so the trees can hear and feel the music when we vibrate the ground and the birds sing and touch the branches.\nWe play a lot of East Forest.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrIYm4qLNFU4YL5nLTWb2lg","author":"@birdMANandatomicDOG","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/t4oGM3ZwKF20QoDVO-l8pj8yemhNX6YWmmrGs0fQYdxH_qR_DBslX6l8ZYdJzU6Yob73ITBf=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@birdMANandatomicDOG","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy61SMJyrAkhuiVamR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:44 Exquisitely put🤌🤌","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCh3X0BBTBJtDv_jBodTf8OQ","author":"@Fash3050","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JTfYOfZz11WSLBG3myLzhhWDEXAq4Xb6ntbRUE9UgZnvGKVIztSlV50i8VI4ddDmaRNlxsc0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Fash3050","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwITie85Xcg58nsbzt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love the flexibility of your intellect. I am often amazed over how most people simplify their reality which can get really bad consequences as we will probably not handle the climate change crisis in a sustainable way for humans, animals or plants. \nA small example. Most journalists that write about EV:s  and EV owners say that you must precondition your battery to get from A to B the fastest. But none of them calculate the need for compensating the loss of energy from that preconditioning. \nAs an example. I had a Tesla model 3 on home plug 230 volt charge over night outside in minus 22 degrees Celsius. As we started driving home several hours away the car suggested preconditioning before a supercharger about 1,5 hours away. I decided to not do that, navigating near that same charger and the estimate was 7kWh less energy usage. So instead I could navigate to a charger further away and as I drove mostly on motorway the battery heated up enough to get decent charging speed. Partly because charging itself creates heat to the battery, increasing speed better than the charging curve dropped so to say. \nThe result is that I spent less money per kilometer and my theory is that I might not even loose time in the long run but I did not make a scientific test of the alternatives. \nI hope that you could arrange such an investigation 😇\nAnd of course use common knowledge that charging from low state of charge to about 70% with more frequent charging stops can be the quickest.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzrTA0FNbW2EFtYcH9-F7pA","author":"@michaelenglund","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lD0W0I-VifOVwIT6xXaADTqMCgvMs5R4omsDpu5_QvvufdEROCNH5JAItvPjpMuwDOu2_h6glEI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelenglund","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyf0wRN6nwKoMVHLO94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"Sonic Fertilizer\" great band name","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCf3mmxUmY4HWnsdoti388Vg","author":"@lorenloiselle1733","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_le8rnzo4-kiKPewZn0xxCHEpCixoCDiI5HaQoMlfg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lorenloiselle1733","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzqAaV2D86iuh1eex4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"First time viewer here - do you always put 5 videos into one? 😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5yHS0NK1WSYlmHX_lHprCA","author":"@juraj_b","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nTJi0x5CYtCREhnG821i0D9sQT76fe4jrlcw_hqeYVLtg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@juraj_b","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwAEm5PwbUfBN7e5fh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm sure that I have seen your other videos that were mainly music related, I wasn't sure what I was going to be watching when I clicked on this.. But I'm glad I did, here I was looking at a scientific experiment but I'm seeing music production equipment in the background and I'm questioning what is really happening here? This guy appears to be into music production and science? Okay this is interesting.... \nYou background history is also interesting and inspiring... You were saying something that really resonated with me.... Finally here's a person who gets me! And I love what he's saying and doing... \nThis has earned you a subscription.... \nI have more faith in people like you that what acadamia has produced.... \nBy blocking so called citizen scientists from publishing papers, it's loud and clear that there's a system and it's geared to protect the people who paid money for an education that they could have obtained a lot cheaper... It's all about the money 💰.... \nAnd this citizen scientist label is a slur.... It's scientific racial profiling.... And it's wrong! \nYour masters and doctorate don't mean anything to me! You only have the ability to parrot that which you were taught but you never even questioned it to test if it's true or not!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4Gh1uLDDEqmVaPQC54XSIQ","author":"@PeterMilanovski","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nMmOOExYB2ZHOvNcIPs9N4Ht-99GJlR3miTSMmlv8AM6I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PeterMilanovski","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6YAPBymg5r0jLYMt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Von Karmen is kind of goated for saying \"Actually, that whole thing was stupid\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLxQYHeR-1HLoZd5ytFgPuw","author":"@Kazner0h","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mlKveh06N4SeOLchymwM3qh-zPLHrhdjzdgbV6eajUy2w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Kazner0h","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyisa7q_8ubLSxNRWt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"ahhh you too with the coffee? yumm do some coffee bubble sounds !!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT8eQjqTQh9dKfLLuv_uGdg","author":"@AlexWolfLikesPie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYRU00UDiEtgF-BrxJDuIrvgbh5JkVQv15oWY4G5K2sPBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexWolfLikesPie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwI4xjkaosYgrmQPIh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video :)\nSubscribed","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-hHMCegrQylyI6k-xZCp6g","author":"@HaecEsneLegas","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l6EjBF6Q6elJv2SC2he6fRqyLtPpifAj3QEheKk3mPY-ws=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HaecEsneLegas","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPW48siTMDbPwtYVV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I did a test with my soundcore boom 2 where i tuned it to sound as good as possible with a boost in the 435hz range plus the bass up on and I got my cannabis seeds to germinate and break out of soil in under 2 days playing them classical music and nature sounds so yes i will be doing this from now on for sure.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCO9ylxaSt-Cjei_X47O8F4g","author":"@JohnnysGrow","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kxWKjspeVVe6IaNj086v-yd2gqzTYi5_lVzJyBnUhXGeODTCnU6YgUOWwwoo0883zni75_reQkU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JohnnysGrow","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxs6S3Or_z4ptPdjod4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dude, WHO ARE YOU!!!  Every so often the world, or maybe just YouTube... Throws me a person who is incredibly interesting and I wish this content was available when I was a little kid growing up soaking up information like a sponge. I find the videos and things you research amazing! I only wish I could participate and figure some of these things out myself. I get you have an unusual past but really, what the hell got you to where you are now? I think this type of information could be incredibly valuable to somebody growing up that just needs to know that there are these cool ass things out there in this world and needs to discover some rabbit holes that DON'T lead to some weird \"manosphere\" or some crap... Please consider sharing this information and if you already have, please point me in that direction! Passing on information to the next generations if INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT in my opinion and I think you have a TON of VALUE to pass on. Thanks for all the work you do. It truly is important.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqQAG1IIjKIbAF0_d_LRhTA","author":"@AnthonyCelata-ForCongress","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BXLKCOLe6X652L9Ya5WtkA-YeiIR7bpNFkkoCNP3yMrR5CDg5lZG-t6LNQ9qLWE6lsY31BnH=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AnthonyCelata-ForCongress","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw6H6ePOlwuHzx3zNt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"4:31 that sounded personal.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHjLkbatpK-7T4kYsTBr9TA","author":"@Chezboi30002","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Jm1-tbkxVkpWnba3nFefBIoDA21Q99YqOZhAXeWOB16WGefHnoymhtVVSaYQ-a0NCgMB1PxYi50=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Chezboi30002","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyG8aoilrGmGzOSjg94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wait. Wait. Wait. Unless i'm mistake, you got so tied up in your tangents about objective truth that you didn't actually SAY what you did for the second test. You saw such amazing results in the first test at 4000 Hz I had to go back and see if my ADHD kicked in and made me miss it in the mess of tangents, but no, you just didn't really say what frequency you used in the second test that \"worked better than no sound, but not better than the first test\".  Also you mentioned that you saw increased activity at 40 Hz, which is INCREDIBLY far off from 4000 Hz, so is the plan to run some tests at more reasonable frequencies nearer to 40 Hz? In the past I explored those \"mindfulness through pure tones\" type videos/audio (on account of the previously mentioned ADHD), and I always found around the 100-200 Hz to be most pleasing to listen to, with the tones maxing out in perceivable differences out near 1000 Hz, so 4000 Hz sounds just absurdly high for functional vibrations to play a roll in the mechanics of cellular growth. Looking forward to further videos!\n\n\nPS- Speaking as someone that came from a very low-income single-mother household, and who went to DeVry University because I had most of my tuition paid by scholorships and grants due to being among the top attending new students (in my knowledge and capabilities in both general education and I.T.), I thank you for offering your backstory and showing that it does not need to stop us from pursuing knowledge and science, even if it might make it that much more difficult to pursue efforts in professional settings. For what it's worth DeVry as a University should for me, more or less, but I still don't recommend it to anyone for a number of reasons, not the least of which just because it has a tarnished name attached to it due to its incessant advertising in the 90's and sharng common brain space with ITT Technical Institute, and I think hurts more than it helps on resumes in my experience.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCbqLCib3zb7Zl61UnUcFnBA","author":"@elementneon","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MQG9PiXrvUsAxAF6-d1cL0obRB0MFagrYEFBKombI3VQ2b2zKB14ebdlIpMXZ2Lw2UOdiyg2yQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@elementneon","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz5w5lzbEOy84mcgGF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:44 😂😂😂 THIS IS UNBELIEVABLY RELATABLE! 🫠","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYHkP-SYeK-_kcIaTyaw17g","author":"@BBWanKenobi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/g0p6dyZSHui7TGY5J5g_wmSlwn7r5BARFB5AGJnfaa1AufLXqbolXiRMywwE6VonPHKTv2w1X5I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BBWanKenobi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyo6mpsZ8WxpRbhOzl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:40 i've always considered the state of being known as \"in space\" to be defined as meeting the following condition: orbiting the earth in freefall in a trajectory that would complete at least one orbit before decaying into the surface of the earth. this excludes any \"i shot my dick into high altitude and impregnated the sky\" rocket flights and includes all space flights that required partial or complete orbits around earth. it also allows for very low altitude orbits that anyone would consider \"in space\". my definition only requires you to be orbiting the earth fast enough such that maintain freefall. in other words, you are moving sideways so fast that you never hit the ground when you fall. when most people talk about being \"in space\" what they really mean is being in freefall without the felt effects of gravity. that is why these ridiculous rocket flights or parabolic flights simulate being in orbit so well","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCz2s2c3SuPA1dm5cCOZkgNw","author":"@Gunbudder","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/A-AcKv4B0GzV2hhTHBDIH-TsiAG-YKpULUTj5u41cZnJhwq8KvTIQ7vJQFqdNYpHSc_hCoPpoA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Gunbudder","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx8L-M7o2aZzwCO0RJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's good that you addressed the repeatability crisis. I heard that esteemed musician/scientist/philosopher Rodrick Heffley performed the same experiment, and came to a drastically different conclusion (all music kills plants)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6-RgXrsfHlJcok50DfrU-Q","author":"@doughboywhine","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fteLN24G_qQvA8XIjuGQMtwT6qCJe7wkftCGlvIXzzX6qVnJLQRD6Qwz5hkIoScL_dROVCUDRRk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@doughboywhine","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynfhxzV2ne6bJsIm14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3:58 Dr Cleon doesn't give a single shit :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgL2fjeoW_8Ugfz0t46Y9Eg","author":"@onomato-l9g","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/U_-6vbBOqIVlgERe1ImPXZs16nzC3EwNWZ5hZoC9Spr7WrYzyfEACpAEl0GXgBZnSwSGoI7QqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@onomato-l9g","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx5Oz3sw3XAXTDLwX94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:09 — one reason why it costs millions to do science. Annoying details don’t come cheap!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCKmmuryzn8Ia7dFK4XH6MqQ","author":"@Sethicorn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FqsPs1FQdZmi58GJWAKrwVDa3SF7mc3d0C4RqGxs_xRnsFSruS9ed6Kdk1PGYK6XWsTtj4Hq=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sethicorn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyTyapCdqc6BOqxPZh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's probably worth (for completeness) building a sound-dampening/anechoic box as well to see how they grow in the absence of ambient noise and vibration.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPwtZIgWReW9BNsHpF9dqRw","author":"@Zahaqiel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/csk0w2i2x8KeKeEvtx92oNipGgMntqs8XWzR9We6cM7oGMqSrN-cclLTB9R2l6k44He2UUEi=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Zahaqiel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy3ZDKMELKk4Fu4zWd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"it impresses me how much random stuff you know how to do","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKqPB6stJO5mSuwtg6QWd_g","author":"@The24Pages","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/knaoF70qG9x7LSrz6mwEaK5kFLHrx4JtnnXuOhf3RdezQ31v1NzTIfMz9sB9ocHGVnRdQO3l=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@The24Pages","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzkBGM0zhKkhWVxV4Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I remember reading something about the bird song opens the plants cellular pores which has significant positive effect on their growth rate. Plants in sterile environment grow slower, no doubt. I've also once made my own experiment where I played nature sounds to indoor cannabis plants and they grew larger and faster than plants that I've grown without sound. So yeah, plants obviously react to vibrations around them. You could even say they need sound to thrive.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0vlKByknA0oB-6Xi_kXyiQ","author":"@visalehtinen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/PbzKPLAK9BCe50lAOtqdLbUawyWaDeADbEcV6BXayiABE7wlOIz8YOcXtJxmzWEg1dzX05OorDM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@visalehtinen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6alA6Ii6o2MVLER94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dude what a great video","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCh6FFej8o8JbbwY74CjLWdg","author":"@mbeining11","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l7pPjUkfHTWJjC4GvkQlMDEcBk4AVJweGn_qINPDc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mbeining11","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyfzeeiVSM02r6Srh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I really liked your breakdown of the scientific process and how you point out the bias with mainstream science and academia towards themselves and away from independents","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUPTgOG4J5AgojUJhRItoRQ","author":"@Lurksin1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kL1n08fWdaNBv6x_KlcqfMjyzJiHY5IPa7ar5o__9Fwg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lurksin1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyfzeeiVSM02r6Srh4AaABAg.AJgC5e3PMF7AK6iw4iSN71","parent":"UgxyfzeeiVSM02r6Srh4AaABAg","text":"lolwat? he defended mainstream science by accusing anyone detracting from it of misusing science for political gain. the fact the examples he used werent doing that and he was doing that is ironic but also sad.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4QiEoSTkO8VFDPu1ca68Qw","author":"@face0001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lziHycyh8NSZpgk-9BnembuSmGg7ufcwMBtBl1U-VI7U8Dbo9yF4kgdhowTJBLsuIz6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@face0001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyfsEtd7f9ZbI29U8R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Im a horticulture major, ive always pondered this idea. Ive always theorized that the sonic waves cause tiny movements in the plant material, a lot of plants release growth hormones when moving in the wind, its common practice in cannabis growing to have a breeze on the plants creating more vigorous growth and hardiness.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJktzCZFZ4iobDozRvkChYw","author":"@undutifuloregon1644","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/clqu9kYxGsPNHOQccY1ZzdKgPZ3L0qjDn6-GuEeKIUASGQRw9qkYdkVDGwcGmG_vaM7pzcxneg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@undutifuloregon1644","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxDWMg8-ajJMpCTowd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As for watering plants and getting seeds to sprout and grow through the potting stages, rain water is the best.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvIAy2r3yync5HI5DJXrqpg","author":"@MichaelWashingtonAE","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nUV1mF_VDxtKv232HDMy7bQSkEzoszKun8YDpcVzl9MYA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MichaelWashingtonAE","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyt6BLru0VrZzfiVRB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:37 Mostly, I'm sorry to you, Ben. I'm sorry I played Tiddly Winks with your heart.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCINVwnMlkI1RN9i7wHzNX6A","author":"@_c_e_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGOxC0p5-IJYlknyMvRz4gk7-l0Syy-RfwxXcA0St2XA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@_c_e_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxA8cCqzekXT1rXSB14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I was already planning to get a robotic lawn mower but now I have to figure out how to rig it with speakers playing \"Yakety Sax\".","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHjLkbatpK-7T4kYsTBr9TA","author":"@Chezboi30002","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Jm1-tbkxVkpWnba3nFefBIoDA21Q99YqOZhAXeWOB16WGefHnoymhtVVSaYQ-a0NCgMB1PxYi50=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Chezboi30002","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJgOR3RX6o8JUPn9p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Love the background music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkZrRvaefYJIekXP2qqvPpA","author":"@KyasheMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kgiPsEsP1vl6JtE_c0UawIT4QI33NRPn7aa6yaL9qKICI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KyasheMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzuuGAcIQ6NLUWjaNJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"From one dropout to another, cheers!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcXH0iOJStUaRgyCpRPBVvQ","author":"@JoelGlidden43","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mTnE4KzD4pG_wxeeqMcqLgZ2YfQrG6ZO3w66OZvkFUwrEU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JoelGlidden43","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwkxaPyrKvV9_DFEM94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:30\nMy physics professor told us \"everything we know is wrong. We only know as much as we need to know at the time\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCp1MgsgVPbYWN0R1qimdnmg","author":"@BeckJoseR","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m9ZsTDm3rZRoC7lH0eTDXOAmITx1_Xn5zazf4PvWEi7Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BeckJoseR","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzX_vbwHSkqLvhml5Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a landscape co.pany owner, i have learned to pray for and talk nicely to my lawns. There is more to the sound thing than just frequency. There is something coming from our brains in the form of radiation or something else on the quantum level that gives our words power over water. Which plants and our bodies contain a lot of","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRpQo3K8zQRzxwotfzJzOng","author":"@beardedopinions336","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7MSFH3vclC2T67CRUToXWAYVB3lDBmS57fW7yR0qKrZGhpLamX7L3B-y_8a3uk8S15BCMpy-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@beardedopinions336","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwg3Qqs6R0u6XusBo54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I saw a video of a pastor talking about how this farmer noticed the birds chirping in the morning would wake up his plants so he started playing classical music and his crops trippled in size","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxJwuok-jHEhd_-bAhk4YJQ","author":"@inovishion","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4G3WjBsSJW_jQGKGLd57u3vmKkc4jpgyaXF6qXlJInfo6O4DqTtc47yd4DHyP-igoiCtpDbZ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@inovishion","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyr-PWLQL7S4NcVrnp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3:18 I was thinking how cute your pup is ! Like let me see Lucy not you but your voice on her cute face cuz I wanna hear what you have to say lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-2lpS4hiMcGfulk25n65GA","author":"@MissLanaFunk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YcV3sOAMs7gwjuxR2qiWwnK2hIcyUEYjqc1YUXr9s5w2UxHDV6XPeFPAl4Vela9jjzaBewUQOg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MissLanaFunk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwY2D14IXorOXlkXWV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I remember Tory, Grant, and Kari tackling this one.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRt5W_jO8cq0HdYnPOCPM-Q","author":"@randydietmeyer5883","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nn4P6v9nBqWESk1AgOlzOdXklTmn5F4IynVlIblOQfW_fg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@randydietmeyer5883","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxtKMRq0aBltgalVgZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It increases the entropy floor. And allows their systems function more effectively","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWGyHSgHBaVPx472oribQ9Q","author":"@peterwookie7779","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrwZ0ESoquCgjkO6E01z6lSRYB94neO1GNxd4q_Y4Vxg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@peterwookie7779","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzb4E-xs5BMZhn7yml4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I may have missed it but since sound is vibrating air could the sound also be facilitating gas exchange in some way? Speeding up the plants ability to respirate and therefore grow faster?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UClwQhU9wlchdAwq2zsgF9lQ","author":"@H_Industries317","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kvKO-NdlW4JOCPTazhh0aNmlhpYd_DuRwKuSTZzz8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@H_Industries317","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzffsYwyYI17ALl0Jl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Aeolian harps for every wind-plagued garden","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwnoPdgLuju-tzpm2XO6tow","author":"@MichaelSmith-un9ru","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nfy3XRFONQMv1g2SqwHNJ0Vnr45-Q0p8Lf6I5t8p_6kQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MichaelSmith-un9ru","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxjugMuZEaMcXj4BMF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am an independent scientist, i am a very young, very new independent scientist, that dropped out of highschool years ago, and never get my ged. It means so much to me to see a scientist I look up to address the institutional classism I have been struggling so much with. \n\nI was genuinely starting to feel like a crazy person making things up, because the things I am studying are so tied to requiring 5+ years of expensive schooling. I didn't even realize how much my brain was saying \"You can't be a scientist. You can't study neurology! You didn't go to school!\" \n\nCause that's what it feels like. Like my information, my studying, my work, doesn't matter. Just the fact I don't have any credentials keeps people from even bothering to take me seriously. \n\nThank you for adressing this.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC97FCfc6t1PyxoQsPfcSn4Q","author":"@voidsp00kz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3nSHy43fQmlaCRJR7MgWlGT7UDtBX_dHeZ1DpAAsO808zTbCIRuvJxcgUeKj8RyWdc449k98=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@voidsp00kz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgznlK8xFgUphg8OlKV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In junior high I did a science fair and wanted to see what type of music plants responded to most. I came up with classical music but I have no idea how I reached that conclusion I don’t remember measuring or analyzing anything lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHsbRJtZRpwvzZfetlUAfDA","author":"@plnkfloydian7814","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4DK1TMQrBEb-LeYAp2WmcW9JgkYN0e13fH1p7v-7XCZA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@plnkfloydian7814","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyRf29Gbi379KoRgTx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Broski, I love this video every facet of this information and to borrow your own words about \"Horse shit\" for the validation side of things. I would love to go into business with you and get you your own lab as I have an invested interest in this subject matter, furthermore I specialise in real estate sourcing and business development meaning I've got you bro!\n\nI'm very much an activist not just some business guy, really consider shouting me and let's change/heal this world using real knowledge.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsAKzSeC75PsDzVR7tvfHVQ","author":"@JanWinMoudrak","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fJAZHacudp_DB0t49zoZju3VLv_fTcWIDzfTHySYAq56NP2hPDVMy0WtcCr4U5mkjPv8CyxqYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JanWinMoudrak","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw5DOf9fQNznfB8pGp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey that's a nice telescope and astrophotography camera you got there! But I'd recommend a slightly beefier equatorial mount for your setup, the SA GTi can be quite finicky!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC65vvpQDX5rymeqrYt-Bb1g","author":"@CuivTheLazyGeek","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l97DRGHJCggbtJ4ORTHM9EZrlZ9VAlhechwF-0vya9ySPs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CuivTheLazyGeek","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzgdbW0j7UK5Gjbgox4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn shares a patent in acoustic levitation?\nok yeah that scans","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCeH7oWYIND76H2fCKAT_ajw","author":"@doubleyolk12","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhalN_CgTub1a7AZ_zoukdW6NwxWuVNMeAH4eet4HZ0Kw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@doubleyolk12","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymWcV8Y1XFoPWtsOV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I did this experiment for my final assignment in highschool science class, \nThree groups \n1 control group \n2 music group \n3 pure carbon dioxide group \n\nI thought either the music vibration mimics wind and therefore strengthens the plants as they grow making them grow stronger and faster, or that talking to the plants and spaying carbon dioxide on them makes them grow faster \n\nMy results? Inconclusive. All the plants in each group grew wildly different and the averages all ended up so similar I couldn't say if anything has any effect","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC85cXMvOduu-ghd1ig85WHQ","author":"@tobytheoneandonly","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsrz4zSg5dCaCCnEm7_KS4-_Sfa1doGWI7EyxUDUrudZ1ahvhxsdDwvXeOce18W0Drwg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tobytheoneandonly","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxV0s_mRTCkMsvqrRd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This sir, is amazing content.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2es7eH8rU4Xil4LsqI-yUQ","author":"@javonburgess5496","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kbYmo1FP-p91ojXY9i9-Mhl1tLmdMc6Ei8StgIXTY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@javonburgess5496","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCCtmWHrd8UuF1aGZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants enjoy the wind, and grow in response to it. Aesop mentions also that the Oak and the Reed have different strategies:\nThe Oak stood proudly and fought against the storm, while the yielding Reeds bowed low. The wind redoubled in fury, and all at once the great tree fell, torn up by the roots, and lay among the pitying Reeds. Better to yield when it is folly to resist, than to resist stubbornly and be destroyed.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfwpABOUuFUHo4kmpEjNceg","author":"@tomholroyd7519","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BobuthLB-7763K4kJiTjIndvmyws5C05ZR4FPSdw7Z2ZYQrWp5OtcXXcgrCOEnsqrXygr518=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tomholroyd7519","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgybbfpVdwTh9AQ_LcV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"They used to sell this item in the hydroponic stores (Biowave) that ran more than $2,000 that claimed to use sound to boost your plant growth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCP4KyVdn4pvV-3MpQOggjZw","author":"@404Lambo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FFb2vfflb7qdkXbmAl63DgLQm1zP9W962SXd2y6c4tCXAAlRXYlXq8vCa_Uy7_slA3zhJy6SGA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@404Lambo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyvJaQii69srzd5tDx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if it just improves airflow?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCqmcvY979aZhsNwaEVI9Rhw","author":"@servrcube6932","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mB0AEzuPBnHUnbJ05Kn6OFC0GWil99rk2mq0C8tMcOp8jSTPBxtIYFzdnOER1R9KYpvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@servrcube6932","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxU08agjCKp3XS2NSB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I kept waiting for a Plantasia reference.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqXnuiMcl_Y1-lsPWjm4WdA","author":"@Lantertronics","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/b0WA0QB368SmSn1KPHs7AZQw2aPx0nv3uk0aw_QnTsoG4Lcs7b9vCzoa39g_CErOTxACRKkZlA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lantertronics","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyz4x0VPa8zHWM9V0p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I saw a hypothesis that said there are internal organelles that might resonate with certain frequencies. \nI add my own hypothesis that those resonating organelles could stimulate growth hormone levels.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXHRWb45WlWcxqKwOTcsYlw","author":"@Gfyplz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lLrYAuVo3DxpXP11VLecewayL4fSdonFK7OJKjx_I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Gfyplz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzeGf4_ua7N2io2SUx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:59 How many times have I asked my kids which method is faster:\n\n1: Doing a task correctly \n\nor \n\n2: Rushing through a task then redoing the task correctly.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHjLkbatpK-7T4kYsTBr9TA","author":"@Chezboi30002","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Jm1-tbkxVkpWnba3nFefBIoDA21Q99YqOZhAXeWOB16WGefHnoymhtVVSaYQ-a0NCgMB1PxYi50=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Chezboi30002","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxh7lYS2ZQi8f-_7KF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants have feelings and emotions","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjqksZqCzm6hLTktdDOgYUA","author":"@yakiudon-c5i","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/alcHKgnIW-lmDsIYFMK4It8_SSDE4PCQmPFcxOWWxTsNvEawQkxY9QeAGGCdO_C1xuZuz6JaD4o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yakiudon-c5i","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyiHaiDFRWS4STQgV14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"For plants you need to couple domains and magnitudes by fifths. a 4000hz sound wave is 27cm so experiment with 18 cm and 40.5 cm. You always want to have the amplitude magnitudes lower as a saw/ramp wave. a pulse train of 4000hz every .5 to .083hz . Adding rotation to plants with a static light emission does a lot too. Lots of coupling potential to boost what a plant would naturally experience in a day is what you strive for.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5v7G58s04iUKCrvi2Exw_g","author":"@olmchowning7324","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lZZU6VpXa4r5QNb7GHWneibG9Ikwv7R4ENY0rg0swQeG2EqnXjjCQcQ8S3FN8YSEnofSekirUfo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@olmchowning7324","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZKVsfP3TUL4UflJZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video!!!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7XnYxm2-jjGng5dP73Lx9A","author":"@SoundSnakeStudio","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7O1aCNg0qYl0UwWuBbC5Xt3oKz5C30ByegVCWMCZqGpxTGd-RZDhw3yhf6uHccvclscFULER=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SoundSnakeStudio","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYggg8YmRBrLDWvBZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"#hotpotatogardener will try this out on dragon fruit! ❤","like_count":2,"author_id":"UClWc0lRwmlCf0LU6Lk0f1ng","author":"@HotPotatoGardener-HPG-143","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SZcIP2lfoRrncsnO-Zj5f5hvGqvBd6Q6WD2tV86pjC7WpZkCsIZSGFQ7XPGP-ayXqopl-Bpaew=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HotPotatoGardener-HPG-143","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxeX4TGcM981AIMig14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for the video","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC67UY0JrQQD9AUDLlzh14pg","author":"@CIYF1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_miO0N-InRI0ESiytC0JAdDAgiCaJAgFFN5kITr_Efsaxc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CIYF1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxH0P7nYDrVP7PVwU14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I had to figure out a potential problem in disk drive manufacturing, and I chose to alternate running control runs and test runs, then look at the results of both runs to see if a zig zag pattern showed up in the results.  The reason being that drives often just get better just by repeating the process.  Probably has something to do with general wearing in of the bearings and such.  By alternating, I was able to eliminate changes that occurred over longer periods.\n\nMy point being, you may have variations from run to run that you haven’t accounted for, so alternating runs might be useful in your experiments.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC03U5Cjzm87HAcj-GaUNuTQ","author":"@freelunatwo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m6FTLPXPIrD0DHM9UWPnrHkAlXmah3m-w8qhPMYQPsuzo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@freelunatwo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwf2ysndvV9Gw2DqL14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Do you have one of those machines that can show a plant making music and then match the same vibration level it puts out and see if that makes a difference. Really appreciated your video.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJ62XGHtajoZ5Sdm-IiXmYQ","author":"@harryhoover25","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYuJi_EnPpcDy9lO8J8p1QQn7SuWHtv4PK1YBfwdQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@harryhoover25","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzo-sp29FVv0v98S994AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The sound of birds chirps open the stomata on the plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxo2sT8PBhKwctKgSjv7CFQ","author":"@REM-4444","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wpgUnXB_S9t92ZJF9vKNv-5U6P_tlJsUKe34amBbl4DKIsjF8jvJr7vs2uWUC3RGIi1W8YuJz1s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@REM-4444","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzrDQnJ7fjFnP0StMV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Personal thoughts on this, trees that grow without wind fell themselves; the sounds add stress for the plant to resist and build up, like wind. Two: it helps movements at the cellular level, small jiggles give cells extra energy to use, but also in the soil, making nutritiants flow easier in the soil and plant. 3: singing particularly close to a plant can increase it co2 uptake (your breathing) in conjunction with the other points. 4. Why is there never a group with fertilizer and sound. Do they add together. Also the soeaker would have to be massive for a farm.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaJ7E-8Od0lm9G1uAdfkVRA","author":"@tjl102","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kyd7inOcwSZw0gq8BGAwTTMbWC0ekPhpBWDCn-kbQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tjl102","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgywMVkLm6_frXxE_gp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"you, me, and anybody reading this comment are in space and are hearing the sound from Benn's gorgeous voice. Soooo000OOOOooo00 sound does exist in space.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJ5bnz2RGZa5AQGqgIlkTeQ","author":"@boxalox","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nlpqvmd1uuhUhmtSQQCNR27Cxd50Zy10cE6SiBPRzHwZY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@boxalox","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKA-SSLbKI3EMsTNl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i have another theory:\nmaybe it's the sound of the birds that is the initial reason for plants to grow faster or more biomass then without.\nAs I was sitting outside today and the spring is emerging more and more birds keep coming and singing their songs. I thought that might be a natural equivilant to classical music or in general music that occurs around plants. And sounds around 4000Hz are very likely to occure in birds voices. So why might that be? My answer would be that plants spread/evolve better when birds help them and birds also benfit from plants by using it for breeding/refuge for food and probably even more. So when there are enough birds around them indicates better conditions to grow and more chances of surviving then without. And when plants grow faster even more birds might come.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCaa0xQQIHAz5oqaA9IIpe9A","author":"@FrederickHase","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/o9rq0AHckoBqHvPh4TAxSn6uAdgr_NJEOZGpQVnRQWZRCCZgUqThiIZy1AXXM6JnTrEn6VHh=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FrederickHase","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKA-SSLbKI3EMsTNl4AaABAg.AH9CZQ2d8WaAIKDwQl-iXZ","parent":"UgwKA-SSLbKI3EMsTNl4AaABAg","text":"What most of these experiments miss is the fan or wind.\r\n\r\nYou’d be surprised how much faster plants grow when you provide the right amount of wind pressure, along with some movement caused by that wind. First, test the effects of wind alone, and then test the sine wave along with the fan/wind.\r\n\r\nThere is already research showing that nearly all of these experiments are flawed. When plants receive the right amount of wind pressure and movement, adding sound makes no difference - they grow the same. However, if you grow them without any wind or movement, sound can help a little. The key is that they were missing natural movement and vibrations, which aid in nutrient translocation, as well as transpiration which is one of the most important factors of growth speed (nutrient intake and everything else)...\r\n\r\nTry it yourself!\r\nYou can find the optimal wind pressure for each plant online if you dig deep enough!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCz2a3Yx7lOAYYr2gv7BvXVQ","author":"@heavygruby8476","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kDVWTVor4oDMnrA8JSn1QfWKy679_pAFdisj868GXmAFhdW5SbK7lG9s-tsd8cKauiOQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@heavygruby8476","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyE6jz8PYJ4-GXPL414AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"lmao the drumstick mic made from a plant :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUnGShnSEItizsRknU0G23g","author":"@chrisbishop6928","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_njZJosX5E5mECNXAOujgnftnxXcD3gwNPUdjdPMq4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chrisbishop6928","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaqyTzg34GIidAlo14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"you should do Electrocultrue next, it works crazy well","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUMKjy2TmM-tQ6pQhwYvtOQ","author":"@bighaverlegend33","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NqvvnDpOIpx2wxOYNaaMvN9usdkTZJSqgTf6oj77YCgyw6I7eN0K-YoRieTTLaKEbK6RnP7f=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bighaverlegend33","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw18Eluy8DRurX3D414AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants will grow mass in response to wind or other forces that cause flexing of plant tissues, i think your on the right track and the proper resonant frequencies that cause resonant constant movement of the plants will likely make them grow more tissue to combat the movement stress","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMcnCIoyejFx93PcT9K8otQ","author":"@sproutingresilience4787","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8QupcRQvbDTNunMbxMIlDDvaFWPclA_IVwR08EsulFck_XPdAOuTDGVp7ar33MyPvDtySsnzTAE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sproutingresilience4787","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwwg9JTfPF2m_i40J54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This will probably never be seen but I suspect the effect is due to aiding the exchange of gases. At the tiny scale of stomata openings boundary layer effects are going to be felt. As in the gas molecules that close to a surface act kind of “sticky”. The vibration of sound probably reduces boundary layer effects. But I’m no biologist. Just an aspiring polymath. \n\nI can’t tell you how good it makes me feel to find other people that want the truth. That care about truth enough to get out of the way and let the reality of the world talk to us. Thank you for your humble approach to science.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC5hxRU1HbvJCpK_wjcvt0XA","author":"@MICHAELJOHNSON-pu6ll","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lot5YKJA9TdokzeoUh0rifcvp3u-5QNkatFjC8KRLT7Ss=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MICHAELJOHNSON-pu6ll","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBg3tZOHT73q1qgYh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wonder if it's something similar to how just generally causing disturbance to plants also makes them stronger. Like blowing a fan around near a house plant. Maybe there's something about the sound pressure waves that's  disturbing the plants in a way where they strengthen themselves against a perceived environmental irritation","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKQkU34e42fcNLmcjb93DmQ","author":"@nigeladams8321","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_maeLWRS1rkbokzWAOfPI30derXBS3w0leohr6uPaSMK3KH=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nigeladams8321","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwrY8A-FMP2XdVomXx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's because sound is used in a green house. The vibration helps the plants grow and water to go throughout plant. You get the same result from natural wind outside.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCJXwcOiPToZeH00zgziTTCQ","author":"@David-h5r1x","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n6uXwQUZQrJSqgJ6ZF2m7yPyU86vA2cV06lZe_vIJ30N0POsPL-swpaX5qoZBX-P1M2A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@David-h5r1x","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyY7uiavo1tBGCmVNB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Add a thermographic camera to the experiment, and sweep the frequencies on a set schedule. This might help identify which specific frequencies the plant prefers.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdUdRYO79vDf0qVYEdLA7TA","author":"@RedPillArchives-Editor","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KUM9Z9Wv-qDgoiyuj5P60X27V4Ap2N7BoWR7i5XogHgUghgF0ay44eaPy8tGBnOaD6Pan3kWHQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RedPillArchives-Editor","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzu_Pp8ZdNOu47DX-x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Something i would consider is how do they grow in a completely sound free environment. So that would entail heavily sound proofing moving all pumps and motors outside etc and just have as little as possible in there. I think that as a control keeping the rest of the parameters the same should be reasonable for a home job (I'm in no way discounting the effort and difficulty required to set this up).\nAnother thing i would consider was if you could use fans that work similer to the speakers ramping up and apund very quickly to see if its the sound or the movement. Also if you wanted to go one giant step further you might want to consider getting the seeds tested to ensure they are all the same genealogy because slight differences could be the difference in the study results or at least that's what someone might say to discredit you while highly unlikely it still falls within the rules of probability. I think you might require significantly more testing equipment that a university might loan you if you have some contacts. Also the tent in which you are testing the sound waves probably requires to be sealed with sound proofing material less so that sound gets out and more so because it could be argued that their was an extrenal sound wave making its way into the test thus causing the stimulation and not the sound from the speakers. I think you created a really good study but it just requires some refinement. Also the numbers by which anyone onewho has studied science want to see are the P value and the standard deviation. These can be invaluable, but I'm aware that people can lie with numbers it seems like you've beeb quite upfront and even better than most papers you have video documentation, which is awesome. \nOverall great job and i really hope you add more onto this study. Im not sure how they work in the US but i would be able to get a grant here in AUS from different government bodies without having finished my degree to be able to conduct an experiment similar to this but maybe a bit more comprehensive so maybe thats an avenue you could explor because there is a lot of people happy to give their money away for science as a tax write off.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCl-PvCVOxtLLZkaUkLZ97WQ","author":"@thomasnixon6911","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nKRhU0ciHMTNiDEzOPelcv7oNLr9iOw0b9xaO4Iy8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thomasnixon6911","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwpYbA_k1DkKOe4hUZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"15:45 makes me think of the pandemic...","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCTw13Pq8OGggRONKz12R79g","author":"@TheUnhousedWanderer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yuzggJcdieB1HO-VFGyNsUoHS3jLPnTI7aUhFGJ8_rfnqrWzoOLsMpFWGepcjcACe9Ymmk2k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheUnhousedWanderer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhZ6YnTqQZW8V3Q-B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'd like to add a 4th possibility to your list.\nThe speakers are generating sound by shifting air, so the plants in the sound tent are experiencing greater airflow than the ones in the non-speaker tent, increasing their access to carbon dioxide and oxygen. \nI think it'd be interesting to repeat your first test but with the addition of a third tent containing a fan which moves air at a similar rate to the speaker. \nI suspect both the speaker and fan tent would experience the same increase in growth over the non speaker tent.\nAlthough I appreciate all that would be a lot more work lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCj82oQOt8CN79EeP-S8-NoA","author":"@CactuarKing","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8BFB96w-ZrvPS4uaYpV_pJqLmBT04wt6QmPW1VvWZIetM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CactuarKing","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6C5FfTGqx7YurmeF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Not gonna lie the tune of “camp Grenada” in the beginning really distracted me from anything he said cuz I have such good memories with that","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-ZUuudpuH5ZRJCkQefAXYg","author":"@zeke_da_iconix3944","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/buqP1Pcli2XXzv-U3RZoGbOk5iiqfboedVwAtZJtwrkcsAqkEjU_M_2T0QaTG4hRu28e36MZ7w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zeke_da_iconix3944","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwHRg8apCCtoviOINl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sound moves air and plants that get wind vs stagnant air develop differently too. You should test plant growth with that in mind.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNqlSo5zpA-N3yWCBHdRZFg","author":"@Anon-wo2xg","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_moQoccmecKRz1p9T_vLMs1fTpzx7V8DLlYFUxeEb8oTg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Anon-wo2xg","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwc0wIr8j0NjBm92wR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"mad respect","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrQ1nHOgUiq3mDQI7OHhZOw","author":"@hazelleazh","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lOYd4X8hVmR5kARlhm-NA3BG-tzQyzXIxa4-jGe7rLZbWp53qy9pnOuB6JwgXpObLLABriIG=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hazelleazh","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxIL9_NJOA_f2jy6hh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The very best thing for plants is to feed them Brawndo. It’s what plants crave!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMe50H9hs-DlGf3NKr8rhbg","author":"@jimmykelly2809","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/J-gbDVS_P67Z4gzn3SYR0hU82DRIFKPFs-9c5l3vPkdMkKaVvrhd3NlGPeUo8MnnVliiml-rw-4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jimmykelly2809","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTeVf4WydJCkDqnIl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Anton Petrov had a video on this, soil shrooms react to some frequencies","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMZk2diJAAgnwcpXOxOSV9Q","author":"@a30thium84","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lxZPoscRsay9dx-OTP-U1GjJPGFqd7cdckDgVQzkC0JA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@a30thium84","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzxpj12y_zuS0pUxyh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I would love to try this experiment with closed \"barrel\" aeroponics as well with one barrel being a control and the other having the sound interior to the barrel. I'm curious if the effects would be greater or less without the presence of sitting water or direct leaf exposure to the sound. Just the humidity in the air and the fine hair roots within the barrel chamber.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3WRfO_lKtSGDfL56hjKgIA","author":"@michaelvollrath3192","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n-YuVeTdq62gDpN9tXRULjMYBzzNB7izzlI5mIdyEVIVc0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelvollrath3192","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwlxSzmsDmXITFm5UJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"theses videos are class lad proper banging well interesting like","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4ZSVA4gA6y7EvqYZatK-dw","author":"@gune678","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mSTDm0ojZh_hvw5KYIIQxfES9hHzxlEhX71ryqkOsOp_Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gune678","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxcmSGfCz7UF0rVcRd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Glad I watched till the end, to hear that answer regarding education. I'm the same, poor, and denied a fair education, but that definitely won't stop me from learning new things every day, contributing as a \"citizen\" scientist, and maybe one day publishing my own paper..","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCshs24uBR564tU31OJ5NdwA","author":"@DoodleDan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/EvTyzudQ_J-A9PhV1oeLgU_psjXOjRqTzggJqDTVH8bpbf3iqWCu_lAde30otRqKRu1XYuynzw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DoodleDan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx__r71r37eDgTKixp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Like 25ish years ago I did playing music to tomato plants each day. Played nirvana for some of them and nothing for the others, the nirvana ones grew bigger by a bit on average.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxwYyH6YGRCzjeYSl-skw2w","author":"@radfaraf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3xb9SEAS-RnNBY9yoO2d4HzI29wnwNCF9DPdpj1k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@radfaraf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzjkvzuToh4Z7I9ZHJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Interested on this topic if gentle sound helps only in indoor settings; if the wind outside is a general replacement for sound waves","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUj1LoT6RqlOJwJqUAU4tlQ","author":"@ryanfoster6926","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_naoBIncp6sB4GtB7nR8jrIvsMJ6yu36w7jRLHx_zwUaA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ryanfoster6926","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyLTOOE1rp1Aiez8_t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Lawrence Taylor from The Waterboy: \"Gentlemen, which brings me to my next point.  Don't smoke Crack.\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPUGpedR3KnwmCmi9HuYKhw","author":"@jayhawks2042","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kJYdqNNfI_MZbFU9SrBsjDI8I0fDHEA7slpcq8NqfmHg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jayhawks2042","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyXN_98kufQHqiw0xd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn, did you wash the concealed metal containers! Benn? Benn!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX5WOF78fjzWfLADNE-JSiA","author":"@UShistorymatters","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QJZbJLZhgMx_dmYLKgkZMydjYzhe_mosRy0Zl5-D2IBtmft1KbwjVnAQ90wAv81jNmREbnaK_lc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@UShistorymatters","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyc09KU9AjmZiHbDrV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My brother and I did a school experiment in elementary school and found that our corn grew better when listening to KoRn vs classical music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCs2nqVcMuZ_1lJ0OoDdIRng","author":"@coralely879","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kCvGPxMT1y2oGvRgQKZ7xL6xqyksR0XSEsrj2pZBoa4ck=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@coralely879","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxRiPnNKN0KbYGsQrt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You could use a chicken head as a natural stabilizing gimbal for a small format digital video camera","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCcsAOiQSeoUIhSvJgCERwA","author":"@ChandelierLeBlair","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nCvnYi6yoe7IOb9Pkq1nMugq135-0hG1qxSmyyYp0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ChandelierLeBlair","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxNnqbKpXB23WYtiDB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Daddy Chill\n\nIll watch your space soundy video after this one buddy.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC95_zQzZlxVhkjBAsqu4YIA","author":"@ItAlwaysGetsWorse","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9Sc77fH32l3KiJBF2CnB1AtgUfrWJx0_0OWtxRFAvDYlc4joTGMqepA8bdkW_tgrf7cxNe4_H5g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ItAlwaysGetsWorse","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzpxJm53KAScw_aLs54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sound is energy.\nHeat is probably the explanation.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjsT2zyyOzOgBaP094w6tUA","author":"@asianb3854","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nLOZiVoOnOY9sRG6PEfbeJQZgNEc94Ld_-R0YhapW-QHpFlNNHtQIwpPu8VJKX5wVYKg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@asianb3854","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwm4rmYWcL_FacKZUx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In India, the ancient Vedas had an entire subject of growing crops, herbs and trees using natural decoctions, chanting sounds of mantras and performing fife rituals on pyramid shaped copper urns.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk6hfsqc0e_a6tjaJHcaJZg","author":"@MrBiswas123","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nFtcLJ7dxo_qEdGYU5ImV3VM5nva7iYEfXB8D4irgJXx4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrBiswas123","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyXNU-G5zuGcRlofcR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I suspect that the pressure waves are helping to move fluid through xylem from the roots to the leaves. This could increase the rate of photosynthesis. Kind of like how a leg massage could temporarily improve blood flow in the legs by assisting in moving blood through the veins back to the heart.  Xylem works via capillary action which can be sped up by sound waves.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk76AT-6ObUXROuAjiAI2VA","author":"@jmforeman02","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kzpgPlQaV42m6Lo_sHnHDDyS_SZ8q1803NoxP_0GC05NI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jmforeman02","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxOj2SufrGp7DfuFu54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This reminds me of bird dawn chords, somebody on maybe JRE said the birds were calling to the wind that was created by the suns rays or some crazy hippie shit, was memorable😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEDmt8DuIlKEkafkAJR0Pzw","author":"@fsg2700","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n9HTp-4UQcnJM39FegDcwl1d5tFiyqv913B_3Z-gDWqzay=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fsg2700","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxZJcLJuwoI4cZFiLl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wow, imagine that sound waves similar to wind actually strengthens stems.  I dunno if it’s Lignin or not.  Grow-ops don’t use fans because of the smell.  They use it so the plants have a little adversity, and don’t collapse under their own weight as seedlings.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCs8QnOYzGeVCtVmkkJ39wfw","author":"@peters3592","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nt5wlNTGxbR1mpHITKSJoNCZWIrRORTlkSHltyQBI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@peters3592","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPT735zQsWE-Gi2c14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"lol, only a third of results are repeatable. I love the humor in recursion.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVZVYfnD7gRIX0CEPa24Swg","author":"@j33tsud0-t9s","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nnAi_oSHKjJEKwqVDxQHOO3zkIv5IltpbQYyG7hKf2HkaNfV_LPb9_CrTBmyqxIEhu9A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@j33tsud0-t9s","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKOEsStpp_Dr-0zHB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"His experiment on the atmosphere could explain the angelic music that The Apollo crew heard. Look up the audio. It's interesting space had some sound wtf😮","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCJwgUaYis3VgEGLssWttfw","author":"@Dkthearn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nLaU8yPouSIvjIpUeCCev6QixHb-31QoZ-bn1BGmw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dkthearn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKe7cMMjJvGzxwqj94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Let me get some of that magic coffee salve","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDOe6CNcAK7ZGXQY3LTkxbw","author":"@fadedflage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nNRmuCpCx77mP5hJtlP24UwNyYzIAACSVUNSWcI7U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fadedflage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugym4-61SWe84x7jRj54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"And why am I seeing this 4 months later?! Youtube we need to talk!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRe7O3nZmiBfkqnicX5ZHYQ","author":"@themagiccookie2614","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bOIflJaKnbRa2TAOQJfvZ_qXMn2KIxuy0MvG9tLtgV0-43h8u6dQyrB8yCDQyq2v14nq0Qka6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@themagiccookie2614","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzOf4wRgw_sRjXovw54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about the heat difference with the led below the upper root system? Root temps are a huge factor. And that I am so glad I algorithmed onto your videos!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCr1QIMCqH2Z6LdYMn5PWNfA","author":"@SubtleSpeedShop","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MNoPo2Erqi2aG-NNqr4IBap4Ss3l0PXURPcRALgAeN-IatsEhTYk6FbVOGw1GMJ3HRzyKjaB7g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SubtleSpeedShop","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwl5Q0VbIjLodC775V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Cows and sound and milk production are apparently interrelated. I worked at a small dairy farm in PA that played music while milking the cows, they seemed to like Simon and Garfunkel.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLofXXsO-P-H6sV70Wo2Gag","author":"@marktwain622","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mlppK4JKvq0sh6Ddc4SzeTdWmEkXatQUpbay7jXivFS7U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@marktwain622","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwpkyh_wL0t_bOmSVp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My guess as a gardner would be that the sound wave in the water improved root aeration, and wouldn't have an affect in an aeroponics system","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjahByP3OtaTE5g2vGRMk7g","author":"@thematronsmilitia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DmGNZDZR_Rr3UwzsmChaN6pOSvP-clEQevQYQTHtwK4-FSGU_4wWOQgPHgwEN-0JgODOztYKEA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thematronsmilitia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxN7i5uGSpDQgoQkd94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My guess as a gardner would be that the sound wave in the water improved root aeration, and wouldn't have an affect in an aeroponics system","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjahByP3OtaTE5g2vGRMk7g","author":"@thematronsmilitia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DmGNZDZR_Rr3UwzsmChaN6pOSvP-clEQevQYQTHtwK4-FSGU_4wWOQgPHgwEN-0JgODOztYKEA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thematronsmilitia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2KooUMMVEENkVzUZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is wild. It's entertaining","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-nBaU44P79TFDluJkUID3Q","author":"@twhite7551","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/L8WdPDgR-jyydz0pdmtlWeEiq_Fp5GI1HHcPV7TGYsiPY9YN5LHoOg3B43sOZ32jogsvRax-Pg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@twhite7551","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxBUXBQH4ujPu1DakB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I propose it increases the speed of growth by helping things move internally, the same way vibrating concrete helps it flow better. kind of a Brownian motion assist.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLOVkeTIjvfot0Ee8SLHPzw","author":"@mattf2219","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ly6PPLuxsasHx2yKCIshs9JjXNxE2yYMVRrGZTnqdt2oc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mattf2219","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKQggyv2NDYK2zISd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Somebody did do a test and figured it was the vibration in your voice that's stimulates plants just like if there's running water near by the roots will grow towards it and not because of moisture it's the sound.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLrN4mmwcUXLWUVcTWsc-RA","author":"@junglejuice4u","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kq7_L9c615T4Klj6mupZb4crgBGskEKASkthv4_CXGjWe16RiPpO6dqQMQ1C5V7tBaWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@junglejuice4u","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgytRIVpHiP_dt5Yp1N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"lol my dad never taught me a lot, but i will always remember he told me his weed plants always did better when you put a fan on them and played music for them","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJgpLcikxP861r5Di7t72TA","author":"@ashen-one--x","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dqoyxmGax2pUYxui2TiIroGgcX709g1W4xSdlTakQxgncI54kOu7ZSunVovwlMYBm4v6a6xW=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ashen-one--x","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzcfSLSuvU3vMRxO0x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I read a study a while back that said 20,000 hz would stimulate the stomata opening them 200%. But like co2 this would be useless without raising everything else along with nutrient levels uptake, co2, 20k hz sound, temp, light levels, etc. which is the truly tricky part and why most have inconsistent results and bro science springs out. But I’d like to see a proper study with sound co2 living soil hydro combo to push out some astonishing results.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5EYt9FZATJJxachIz9EhKg","author":"@ChaosUSVI","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7YILor3mNQ8K_vxOPMySNR1QEgstFm5IEEnWTG9SXQbw7nrmSFl1ZpXAuzMRUATfwnTph_R_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ChaosUSVI","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_jSzI2ikotPGl9wt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well now I want to know what the plants would do in a completely quiet space. I’ve heard tell of a guy that has sound proofed a room to make it “the quietest room on earth”. Would be interesting to see what plants would do in there","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpcRWBUMn09uXK55if3lC9w","author":"@saxonkuhle7008","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ljmRILXVa0o6loiP9KYgPzXbydCFx7wKFfyvZKX8Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@saxonkuhle7008","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVsyEb4DBTtUaC0194AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is it bugs?.. Would vast swarms of insects generate frequencies around 4 kHz, prompting plants to devote as much energy to biomass as possible to hopefully outgrow the losses they may be experiencing?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCymTMAr63R9-AZbn9ammnwA","author":"@BickNadger","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Fxw9XmrO84PYhGCLiOKICxWV2YeRTT1Y5fNQqWKetFuOu5hLfWmByDNFVkAiJm4KIQDEblAuQf8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BickNadger","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyAFEmgOnZD95fh_r14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I hope this can encourage someone out there.\n\nI, too, was a trouble child. I had a felony with a strike at 18. Did 4 years in prison. Couldn't get anything when I got out, school, job,  housing, etc. I was sleeping in a tent on the sidewalk. \n\nBUT. I have had a love for computers since I was a kid. I'd sit in that tent, practicing, creating, and eventually making money from my passion. Enough for me to get off rock bottom. I still don't have no fancy degree. Im still not (anywhere near) rich. But I have an apartment, the bills get paid, and I don't have to interact with people pretty much at all. Its not the dream. But I've accomplished things I never could have dreamed of.\n\nChase those dreams y'all. \nThe only thing you need is you","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCO0j9c9TXtT9ldzn1z4fbfA","author":"@jftemp2143","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lymbSXYzfcfxAZ3ZlfIiLE5j67KjvyB7rC_hWt0H8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jftemp2143","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyjrrAuAKnd-WycVRV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"yessss plants Benn! ❣️","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT8eQjqTQh9dKfLLuv_uGdg","author":"@AlexWolfLikesPie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYRU00UDiEtgF-BrxJDuIrvgbh5JkVQv15oWY4G5K2sPBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexWolfLikesPie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxliFI9K6vZjKIilaB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am amazed how some people have all the time in the world to do stuff like this. Probably if I lived off playing around and had no kids...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmrBtuxTOMQYn_FdvmL_MNA","author":"@chriss3913","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nJZIXYaBCQHvhCayHMdjGNTjocncgcwx1e_BtdWW4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chriss3913","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9UN5j8V6TePO6yJt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My theory is the pressure waves increase the effectiveness of gas exchange through the leaf's stomata, particularly noticeable in an environment where there isn't much wind.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdwvZL71UUXhDl_4_mo3sWg","author":"@WorBlux","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kvHRBKkww16jelDt6e4AS-UY_jyPXiPJJh6TA032I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WorBlux","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2gjvYWYhn2A77LWl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’m wonder if the music’s effects will on the water is what helps the plants grow better. Kinda like how that guy who froze water he said nice things and means things to it and got different results in the actual pattern the water froze into.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCq4I9Mv7vwV8b5PuIeBw6Lw","author":"@loganmarshall5414","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mqTN0Pwks-u0D6QO4GlufUpRAvfHwefK65lLNJ4kw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@loganmarshall5414","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzoCK66VKNnnlUKcuV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3:22 myth busters got the complete opposite from their test. It showed hardcore music actually made plants grow better.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVD6JPzT0pFPQ_k8pTvWdow","author":"@stickmanrobert1949","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RKZjt770z4fqAIYeXVaHeyip2aueU0phw2ahWFRkiMJeVXC6aO8DyLNLhNZZu14MnJHxxc5V=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stickmanrobert1949","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwZP3NBQWHaWUNd_Ql4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey Ben It is known that electricity and magnetic fields impact plant growth. Methods go from putting a big antennae in the air and a grounding element in the ground and creating an electric field , called electroculture , to more simpler one of just placing conductive wire by itself without electricity. There are experiments with water treated with magnetic fields that increase plant yield/reduce fertilizer consumption and also wounds in rats that heal 5 days faster  (20 days control vs 15 days if I remember correctly) with  weak magnets.\n\nIt might be that the speakers are inducing a magentic field that interacts with plants . The frequency plays a role as well. In the book The Body Electric the researcher/writer could heal very difficult wounds with very very low electric currents and specific frequencies as well if I remember correctly.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCL3rEHbFwhau8qfag4pFYaw","author":"@polxhaferi6671","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n64iQkPbG6oJws1h-VrIG_OvNK9e5TOVeHDRNAAOpPe2A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@polxhaferi6671","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxCzwxVtiyFe48vPZt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You should have played different frequencies into the water to throw a little of Dr. Emoto's water findings in play","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPzqSnbKEeukAgUL_CaUlVg","author":"@Yeahwaffles","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kBCvSOMSg-QRptB3fPdQ1u37UJO73wZYgiNv7-4CJrGAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Yeahwaffles","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxM-HzPbSY9JDCJYLR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey so just on the off chance someone hasn't posted this, it's hypothesized that plants have these tiny granules called statoliths that allow them to sense gravity in their cells. The granules sink to the bottom and promote signaling that encourages the plants to grow in the opposite direction. I always hypothesized that perhaps music vibrates these statoliths which promotes a growth signal. I guess the only way to check that would be to genetically knock out statoliths or decouple any form of signaling they produce and see if those modified plants still respond to music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsdC9ToSBbp_NBgXDxKnhIw","author":"@JoelSexton-tz7rs","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mXl5vEZetSFCfuG2B7_VLqc38fE5TVJMtL_CGIeMUbdXJf55quvy5KONcX81xCv66Llw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JoelSexton-tz7rs","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzMBQ9h04bsmkkx8jt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You sound like the Alexander von Humboldt of our times. I love this channel so much!!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCN6s_D1zX9gzphtIE4DdLLA","author":"@moth_machina","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Lls4S62DGLIjGgYW4KoqQ2oPKxYuRrZI9orpl2oqKplMaNZYMi0x_afDJXAJWsxAe2f79omu=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@moth_machina","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7Vqk2HRcuzYxU1Sh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ooo I've got one. What about the sound waves increasing cellular respiration by moving stale air away from the surface of the cells more quickly, back and forth, and helping to mix the air in the boundary layer of the plants?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZgx2hv63Bs7qibm6asGwdA","author":"@BotanicalBasil","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pC1HA-Q15RcfrXqFkxmdYTzGqriFEEN5NBvCwqGLato11DSryxYDLr6xussQGzW0cf1is3hMtg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BotanicalBasil","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2JpTCZvriCHNjOrd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Keep up the work","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkhLS06SGYirfjsFheTH96Q","author":"@blackfeather777","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9b-91NCOJWWEcwzBDql7KXL1dfqYu_KM0o4kqN9yuwh4cNZbfmAAXxzRNEHTbr5aX90tgWEWjPg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@blackfeather777","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx75MtqFmdn878lxWJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your background is a shock to me. Id guess you were holding some PhDs. Take it from me...sound can do alot of work. I love the massage i get from my system. Its incredibly stimulating. \nMy opinion, its that its possible there could be mechanical stimulation of the plant cells, assisting with exchange of molecules. I would like to believe that it is very frequency sensitive as tuning to the plans molecular structure would be the key.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGQggX_ICWiBjfntpbHISig","author":"@Subdynoman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7CH4gLJOOz5zErwI3RKTxJA4JI67mIBeqmtuJt4PDZpJ2MXrgDgJU6ENFwLI_8hRsc8-Fweizg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Subdynoman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLOzy5pi6YWoZyWjB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a fellow modern polymath with a misspent youth, I'm curious as to how you have positioned yourself in those academic worlds and private research. Much love","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnxkNJghf4fvyfE6BDQCcmw","author":"@milklordnomadic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/odU45gJ4MsPb52Udrdfx4mJSFlQ7IUiPuu87uKB0q0C2umB7Bg4I35hX8FzAGr3dULQPBha6ag=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@milklordnomadic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQN-q7HkZNdK3nGEp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Excellent video.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCg2Jgh6NocqSFc0wuARnLTw","author":"@tophertrimmer5841","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kaYzD9oFm0g_gJZfAvClbjMm81SLWZSoXNlvPQ4AyI3A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tophertrimmer5841","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyzp8qwixfJJsNgu5x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I like this data nerd, just discovered him but love him.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCE78NCow1A9RU1xB-tyZ-vg","author":"@davidbaker4903","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mJagPtY0oaVPUSHrKXiIZMvA5gYnngsdcNYRxczF0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@davidbaker4903","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyNV2KbN5xnsx7473V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well it makes sense if the sound vibrates the plant then that helps its fluids flow and its roots more space to grow easier.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIwb5c53Bm-9zvpXiTVz_uA","author":"@Aers_Exhibit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_xExuKIP_rzR1-hjmq8p8g-7HqUvAe-PDMsXZm95nhuHqAxK-wk_LxgW9M9iutQF21XFwzKbYw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Aers_Exhibit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyBE6-fqecOxh-w3DJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Does anyone else remember that one kid who tested whether different music played for plants made them grow faster for the science fair?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyVqLHN6c-xvajSpSDPYKug","author":"@kirmie44","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYAmy4B8HS4A7fF0nd9E6OkO-ymfHaBdEwf2SuiFYZxQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kirmie44","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy60-UZNks8aTV0EqZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"PSA! Veritasium has created a fantastic video explaining Godels incompleteness theory","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_1D7xgRO3J7k8SQbqkTBfA","author":"@wtfyman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kLskAJT4RUJBPEWY3fzBcItjzHMDSzbLIbxQF4dMU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wtfyman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQNtAxlsYMZ-ZF9gd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Technically the award would probably be a Nobel… 😊","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKmmuryzn8Ia7dFK4XH6MqQ","author":"@Sethicorn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FqsPs1FQdZmi58GJWAKrwVDa3SF7mc3d0C4RqGxs_xRnsFSruS9ed6Kdk1PGYK6XWsTtj4Hq=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sethicorn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzDNiH6GWTFyUdVXNJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Probably late but I'd wager that a major part of the way the sound is helping is by assisting the flow of water through the plant, by mechanical action and perhaps by the pressure waves helping to disperse water vapor from the leaves. More water flow means more photosynthesis and more nutrients pulled in.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZ73mnQvS4Cft4v42hjSChQ","author":"@bridgetshepherd5202","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nSY3SKVIB-lh59yGyZKnSBMStdyKAx-ey6Y__AoaVIck-hLXmMGqnd_XiRQfZveTs5Jg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bridgetshepherd5202","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyWH5d5_Z44-PC2phx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I do bellieve it's cellular stimulation, based on the memory of water - look for the experiments Japan makes in school with its young students with rice and see the books on ice crystals which differ on the frequencies of different waves around them- electromagnetic and mechanic (sound) written by masaru emoto and the the other by henri coanda. Oh, and the frequencies of church bells - that is also a \"tool\" that has been used, but haven't yet been studied enough, or there might be some books regarding it in the Vatican who knows...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2Vnq_WD2PJ3XdgVuTq5gLA","author":"@ionrares3832","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mD6Em4Av_Uyoat6_nLep0UXFshNZfxCGMj3Df_xkI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ionrares3832","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyC77JMLYOkHPgra614AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I put a cannabis seed into soil and i started to get anxious because for 3 days the seedling did not put out its head. I blasted the slim shady album yesterday with the speaker next to the pot, today i have 3cm tall seedling :D","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCu9FWXRKOxWgUMSqa4aq3ow","author":"@msz42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GvNEOAcgHEkTsotJl_DsxfG3kp4_BRfEYwoX_H3cwcZvNgjA853c_PTVdI2X8YnINchn2X4BHg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@msz42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxv4iV7dK8nnaAVLkx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What you need is someone with data on an enclosed environment, then add the sounds.Building out a repeatable study on sound with plant growth really depends on the plants ability to grow in the environment given. I also don't think grasses are the best option for the study either. But I'm just a random person on the internet. I'll have to add a speaker to the greenhouse and record the results one day.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaOiC2jhEpkNWmEZkp_KQsA","author":"@ShelleyD1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WmJi_rRDV3rAz2xup4YIIQyrnTPXukZFY48nkcnPEQXlXi8Hfw2Pv_qmgONuLd39z0gNXZAm=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ShelleyD1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCVVW7-S3NlpQT8ON4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"maybe also the atmospheric pressure make a role in this project .. or some factors missing if there is an uncomplet research so there missing a vector/Value of the environment","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCCHaLhJfwVO3-5fZin_g6sw","author":"@AndreKayser-ev5cc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ka_OJb0XNJYDEohFXLN9aw8SQx2wooMyAYwzwnScVwBS5AeOdo4U3-cDL-EXswMyKilw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AndreKayser-ev5cc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyUgywgMiQs3JYBiTF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I use to play music for the trees on y hikes...i miss my hikes. (new to chronic pain)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_OFlB0IgW45VqTlefION6Q","author":"@stateyourthesis","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/i6UmYkrDdG6-bMwcy9LlqcTUOFHeqg808870rRPyM_tK7BOAXDny926Guzm-msRnq4AnpPzdpQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stateyourthesis","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyphW050Ccjn6dIpCl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Want to really knock your socks off!?\nDraw a heart on your water reserve container","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9xhpxW9sa7ohboxy6yh-Bw","author":"@FXPips11","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lABQ4fOvcaO_OMVhqYk2WKVGqlHERbieDLkUP_qTs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FXPips11","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxUCP8SimHfYt22lzV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:17 One of the best examples of the issue on repeatability is water boiling and making/baking food.  Water doesnt universally boil at 212º F or 100º C,  theyre the average.  Different altitudes, barometric pressures, and mineral content, etc. effects the temperature at which it reaches a boil.\n\nSimilar with making food,  you have to adjust moisture content, heat, and time for your location and your specific ingredients.  If a recipe doesnt work like it should,  and you did everything correctly,  this is often why.  And why measuring by weight is better than volume.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn5f02hWKzpvcwIICgYmThg","author":"@zensational.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/P8VNsmhgg-Vl4nwDdav5PERGmuHi6qSd_LfRHcDwA33pQ7u85Amzj39D0nwbb1Ze0sSjcGC_AA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zensational.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwb5PP9I1bYeJ2Z5Xt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants do have preference, memory n feeling. It's been measured through electrical potential soundings","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCb9lEs8VPN9s6-vdrYkexSg","author":"@trevorbarnhart3752","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mUhtYHe3HWqNKe5NtyGmWEMvlPFHt14CMkFiwtmuDMfg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@trevorbarnhart3752","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKjdBACv8qVo7M9pV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Chemical reaction rates are also influenced by pressure, and there’s a lot of chemical reactions taking place in biology. Even if the rate is only marginally higher, it could be several times better for a plant to have access to sufficient amounts of feedstock molecules or energy levels due to a slight rate increase that allow it to use other more efficient processes consistently compared to plants that have to take the regular process.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQONP-1HBD9tS_XPoE1U0gQ","author":"@Nitsirtriscuit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mOLUmh8cm9_qc21IQwf4FSH2RH5NoX1ckrBo_sDfc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nitsirtriscuit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKCTCVTOG6q5GyRhR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The tones of roshar help growth","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrPP-0IGEwJub2jav9QKBMw","author":"@Trippytacoeatingtortiose","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/y4aM6FB4cvKrtlcGEHsOlgH6OwrQEFXaQkul7TiaLkPawOr-Nj6TgysBHUQKp4ndoNJ2bDxN0xs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Trippytacoeatingtortiose","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgydlTMWaDZ99BgRK1J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Okay so imma blast sax heavy Steely Dan as violin substitute and some stringy Flashbulb, Kirlian Selections and the likes. To a good grow!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT4BWuCI4R6qd1AqTBIMXPA","author":"@kaustik185","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_QIEOPdZTGzhkBYhhs2-3S3urOCl4ZRhWCdIjYYB1ASY7l1rTcyYgm_17e6Wohmw4Dq48iRfZ4Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kaustik185","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxF4iVVtVJ0fMjd0YB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"11:35 late but maybe it simulates a breeze. Like trees growing stronger to support against winds if they are exposed to them from early on.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWzK-9cWRmSEbDvdUNQstfQ","author":"@lptimey","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/M9jZv4YqiZKeRgtT6JYoj5BtMvYRZrP9eReVnV-ghNzzSdfs1QXHiYsSIYWQvXc5kBt_S6AGSP8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lptimey","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-iKLkpihzCfUIg4V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is the reason the plants grow better due to the sound vibrating their cells, and in doing so that helps in the process of many of the plants cellular systems?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCTM1kPt4L0arv64wZo5rzkw","author":"@TheHistoryOfTheHike","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9GdsLgKZJoCz50e4dhVgKDdwZzoh22JBBTLKin3h7cjt9qoHi4o-ht7FDhHGQ74PVrOUlrFJNg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheHistoryOfTheHike","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwhbufJSYOt3SJj22V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Institutional science is a disservice to humanity.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCY8oqS2BkriFQboEZzSrS5Q","author":"@satisfactiongamer7385","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Kt6Z4gYL55YjyfORhnrOKA-tKmb1GnLfOzplM2NXrHe5yQrYg1evmtXg_9fcjoW0hNjyrKGP=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@satisfactiongamer7385","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwFFFzV75VL6uFJHIN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You know what also makes sound, despite music? Running water.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC71OVTtXhfFYuHGw-tzQJFQ","author":"@MarioAndreschak","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l1-jFN2O0R9U6LxGYvnR5N3MXp5cczIMmjcmYWBWE2lcQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MarioAndreschak","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxvD81eh_mHCCsVA954AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I just subscribed solely based off you owning Australorps which are the Chicken Master Race.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6RHvVRYPJVv7YbY4NcRzKQ","author":"@MoietyVR","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/r6QWVwhVHwjv8JflqcUq_L2YU_xcNJh34lQbnv-APIdiSpLO3UYLr3v8NV0XwIEDFLv7ST-9wg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MoietyVR","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx5U1Bd47fg1dvcvmJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:31 amazing, after completing a year long project at the end of my electrical engineering degree I now have this trait after being questioned by multiple engineering professionals throughout said year in this exact manner. Lmfao","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCz-TVVKcbJsAejocK3TAT2g","author":"@danielvides1741","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mlO-Y9VjrCm71sGkaKVFWMNwi7_P-RomByDJglLu3AYXk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danielvides1741","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysxHjQbsvgyjT9bBd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dropped out of high-school?  Awesome!  Grade 10 here, and proud of it.  high-five","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiGmM3PbY5jjihFOfbVWjjA","author":"@artdehls9100","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kDQ8Cippfu4x6KyXqhAVv3pGCBv7BPTOmQ7U6c5vGd8Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@artdehls9100","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwVHRCQmW2aeQ-dE-t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:20 I appreciate your mention of ad-hominem attacks on researchers. The Discovery Institute…or really any proponent of the intelligent design hypothesis is a group well familiar with these kinds of attacks. ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgXghF7djTY6EVfOm2uexdg","author":"@mattd624","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kjWixIUZMw34K87VITgdtyEOIkoHWkvA3ErsiR2Wh6PAM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mattd624","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzmNnP9EkXbh-pO3Nt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My guess is that the vibrations are doing something more simple than stimulating or supporting growth. They are agitating the soil in an even pattern and allowing roots to grow between it virtually effortlessly. Then the more dispersed roots are collecting nutrients more effectively and growing faster as a result. I would check the compaction and root growth between the control and the sound wave test. Perhaps make another rig where only the sprouting part of the plant and only the rooted parts of the plants are getting sound waves.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCh_e2y7X2JJTnUjglLGGTWg","author":"@pauldeddens5349","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mUFCghqlSvSl52PVHjxMwJKriR3pDyrEitUodOcGVzkZI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pauldeddens5349","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzC8k_JyAcfhUUR5BV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"God I love this channel","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT8eQjqTQh9dKfLLuv_uGdg","author":"@AlexWolfLikesPie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYRU00UDiEtgF-BrxJDuIrvgbh5JkVQv15oWY4G5K2sPBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexWolfLikesPie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxKv0ULDv6_fwqzxMN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"15:05 bravo","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3rSV7swcToCF6nbRtQdAvQ","author":"@LevyBytes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/u1Vx8VzG0QJS8qJFxiK4O6V4148xP5yvF5VKoU17j8D2cf2KmmpUxsiDIonA3CEvKD9zUVAgiQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LevyBytes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxI9DSOZoyKi-28IzN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm interested in fruiting plants such as peppers and tomatoes. Can you post what sound equipment you used? Specifically, how you generated the sound and what devices you used. Also, what backup system you used. Thanks!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRlz06nPWywubixXkRFOOtQ","author":"@Happilymarrieddad","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lAZxaGCLYyfDM41vbwy7p5Od9K2MQyjOj6bjA628tfNaI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Happilymarrieddad","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyiwPP_7nI6_Ioad-J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"man ALWYAS banger intros","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT8eQjqTQh9dKfLLuv_uGdg","author":"@AlexWolfLikesPie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYRU00UDiEtgF-BrxJDuIrvgbh5JkVQv15oWY4G5K2sPBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexWolfLikesPie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyK8BpAblGn02KBEph4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Music versus pesticides","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCST0orZG1FIXNhvEAUzfETw","author":"@craig265","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l0unFGWhapp4SeAREdg7Abu9_Rsv8T3eOQU3hw8M1blpI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@craig265","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwi5UdvKIoYImNQlWx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The hardest thing to control for in a study like this is going to be the between seed quality itself","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCioHEaeVfAcN9zQv0lP7fgw","author":"@Dronebertios_World","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ncz9Gb4Im69cTRAWz_Jb9CcvVbkp_-tU0fK5aC8z4Da5Mm5JD-DwDRF66Nn96ksBpTrvJJIBfg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dronebertios_World","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwi5UdvKIoYImNQlWx4AaABAg.AWn3sVKvi3LAWnAhiHmmRx","parent":"Ugwi5UdvKIoYImNQlWx4AaABAg","text":"This bears out obviously when you are doing thousands of plants but…. There is your replication crisis. Great video.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCioHEaeVfAcN9zQv0lP7fgw","author":"@Dronebertios_World","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ncz9Gb4Im69cTRAWz_Jb9CcvVbkp_-tU0fK5aC8z4Da5Mm5JD-DwDRF66Nn96ksBpTrvJJIBfg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dronebertios_World","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyL3SZ8QiBvYPF-0ux4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe some sound waves or frequencies or vibrations can be utilized to improve circulation in a plant thus improving efficiency? \nSound could be moving air around a little bit so in some cases providing better CO2 exchange?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2_GHSCxBbLTsOhX65pBwig","author":"@matthewhealy4752","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mnLUqrgKnxvp10du-JZpE5NeUjtnD1ilPVeXUMokNFLA8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@matthewhealy4752","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwZjSt8vd14H4Srwb54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey! Fun fact! At one point NASA was doing experiments to figure out how to grow trees in space (Biosphere 2), but for some reason when they tried growing trees they were weak and kept falling over. Eventually they figured out it was wind that was helping the trees grow strong because wind activates the triple response in plants.\n\nSound is pressure waves in air, I would not be surprised if it acts like wind in terms of helping plants grow larger and stronger","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0GhOpdg0Evd45kyj0zcE2w","author":"@CakesAndSuch","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/u01NoJSytdbraJU5pVYBlWt1p2B4Se6g006qu4fsW0dl_11wHPdT35SgqFWsbMujsVtDIgCLQA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CakesAndSuch","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyfT-lD6HrWWIxOEXt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did you check the temperature in each group? Could be that some of the materials heat more from specific sound waves.\nAlso the speaker might heat up and overall increase the temperature of the environment the seeds are growing in.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOG2oQJOlpX7UZz2PvuojmQ","author":"@6111-b7h","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/jipK68UsJbEZLflo7WBwpNnIqeDnpTKHud_tj_aErU748kn0HuS-qgjx6uEz8NOD1zmN1WAApQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@6111-b7h","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynLQla0kqm_KEnjtl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"bro why you yeet that chicken like that","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxJbqT7PPD4mnQwHDzVZ4vg","author":"@lucasheuer6983","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JIM53PYLtdxAU-BYFccNfQiEZFcKnPOHWq5-LYZ4x80u74oTcMUq2cPXNrh9WFU3UXD1wUvtB4k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lucasheuer6983","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7DxIL7NzaCOGQrTh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3:40 that's a very unscientific statement","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClny-1ZLCHtJhHKeXHe6Kvw","author":"@freddie5ive","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ALpqw9pS-C87x0sy9z4zMkwIT59j5rAfmAFuU-tG6FVBhzGgczujU9xGOTbi-q_8dTcI18_YUvc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@freddie5ive","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxxGwpmFgqVWPRwgPx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love how he even put a lighter as scale.... I guess its not his first time growing \"grass\"😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2f3AZPYQ0XHxdKX7zBknTQ","author":"@tim8505","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mBu2XC2q5f58AobcuXEj4TTTRZ5fqCJqnFjdxH7rk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tim8505","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyO0WhufpEAbbzW3PV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I would imagine that the sound waves affect the stomata in some way, either allowing exhaust to clear faster or have an unknown effect on carbon dioxide, maybe moisture, or maybe evaporation. I would suggest trying it in different vapor pressure envelopes, to see if the plant respires differently. I found huge increases in growth when I perfected my plants preferred vapor pressure. It actually had the biggest effect on growth of all the variables I tested. CO2 concentration didn't even make much of a difference.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCafJEBdmO0relqdRjZaHIGA","author":"@Y.o.T.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kAFgmKPRw5_SEIlX6hPyjxd69r4EHaHe-LHndKGhw3oPPJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Y.o.T.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzoMwXNBiNwRJVEy0J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I put this in someones comment but wanted to put it as an independent comment now that i finished the video:\n\n \"I do research as a career and it's not surprising from the realm of molecular biology. Everything in the cell is sensitive to mechanical cues, and its been shown in many context that if you physically stimulate cells they grow thicker cytoskeletons (aka become \"tougher\"). Im assuming acoustic waves, or the wind, work in a similar fashion to make 'stronger' seedlings\"\n\nIn particular i have a lab mate who put mouse cells on some magnets that move versus staitionary material. The ones that underwent dynamic movement had mature cytoskeleton structures versus the ones that stayed stagnant.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbDRLs93zecYnXZSlmwZ5CA","author":"@phgzgz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ntGx1bbDOI1R7Z3i3Y8ZPggSnlzYyEZeNfCfMFWHYhTLD-7TzXhrwUGRICT2ubH8-hrw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@phgzgz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyLgAj4hkgiIpmrK-h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:10 I will be watching that video next","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClVvD9m_UsqTDb-_2J5ppJQ","author":"@aethervvav1658","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SfPYTv2UCARgWxvMQC5tEBirGNNKYIksZGKHFKdaYQuq1uVg0G4O7cxqtqBJYfRozQQrR1aZKw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aethervvav1658","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy1dRvnfSyFyTeo_hx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love this , amazing","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChNwQ0ALybkPw14dkJE8AAg","author":"@TheGodhan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lE7WYYlG5KSjU14NQQr0uc82mQIr7auKMTHgttTZyGCQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheGodhan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwqa_20GqZ0ywEhkxh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hia Benn, quite late finding youre experiment but love everything i've seen from you til now 😊 and this, been hearing many different opinions around about music. \nBut have you heard about plants and bird cherping?  Could you simulate the best between the two i wonder....","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkGG9R_qVPshLq-kJ0n4bkA","author":"@jcmcfarland3775","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kSIVgA7NCBb4Ri94h23d5L-eEdjfjYtv4GSBhBCYnJxg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jcmcfarland3775","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7tTR4LqvqN-TAaYJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wonder what would happen if you did the synthesizer thing with mushrooms where they make sounds and pump it back towards them w a speaker for growth","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZXw3iMOeq77mqNRYdf_uoA","author":"@robbiess9635","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhjrfs0JWo7O9UeNu4gvqo7slyWE8uyengrcN3CwIUE2g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robbiess9635","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx7SoYBW14Y27MUAbR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hmmm, my violin grew to the size of a cello when I started to grow Indica plants.\nWhich is great, because a cello burns much longer than a violin.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCcl5MPxjZCf51wjrSpfxLuQ","author":"@Moon_Metty","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lC3NO0x7loocv_d763_j7F7tY_fYwD6I1Dn56-iB2Q_Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Moon_Metty","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKiLjYu60h4CCppDd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"One simple thing you might do is repeat the first run exactly just moving the speakers to the top row of the chamber.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYjhfR9V6gf0CRAXsnWerpw","author":"@wayneroach6736","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kUcWDrehPU9uXi6laKkcnBtHkq-tGitR3Dn0WaYW4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wayneroach6736","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqDC9YwOsaXMRCBkh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think you should try simply putting a fan simulating wind to see if it's changing the results of the experiment with sound or it's just vibrations caused by wind too","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpzIGC-gI6OC6e1qv-hszxQ","author":"@sergclevitz3170","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVrK0Me4l0Jqk_QR0ukGlalER0XqXUcPWuQjV30xezuUk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sergclevitz3170","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfQvhaki8BojGjkOh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ok, so I'm just a biology student but the thing you mentioned about the frequency increasing photosynthesis efficiency might be the likeliest reason? Photosynthesis relies on a probability of a chemical reaction happening, so if that chemical reaction is either stimulated or jostled a bit by the sound it could increase the speed, but not really the energy efficiency.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuAJ0al1a1EfRXsgNrJNLwQ","author":"@wulfleyn6498","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mpTPJEuVWc3CG9CGK50end9GAKK1L8Bep_jcn5bGj2Uqc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wulfleyn6498","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhCQj6WJNeI9Oh50R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Classic rock seems to be my plants' favorite.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC66sToJrEm1QVhLYkeGImvg","author":"@kodeshian1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m4OHD0XblgESUfU5HDTwnNJsb3WPT1e0EYV46vS9w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kodeshian1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9XXLRQRGxeixJ8MB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:39 is that Teflon, Benn?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5RDV9_dDW0ByjDfHZ23myg","author":"@SickofTired","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Iel0Kx0Ah1dwi42R2cExguoYeHuB0DXSQAgT-pzW_zgDkBMbDUOnupM9894bgMTjeqYobl9hrg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SickofTired","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugze-Dps0UgFOSCAPjJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did music and fertilizer and got major yields","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaN7WQW8amIGcGvcAAwge8Q","author":"@Bigtruth1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYQvAmUyrYtkF2soc7ppz6IxaER9_xGSrVZLHiG4eUGMeY1Tl-U5nqn34h_UtOew4GdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bigtruth1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxBqa8fA7sWyIOd5i14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i'd assume it's been done and I'm not going to look for it, but the sound in space pressure waves mention makes me wonder how plant grow at various levels of atmospheric pressure?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxlHCudmbxL__ojg4Gcdikw","author":"@redrum3r","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kBZbAn1GswJxqwQFKaRn3r5btwyATiCzSzRii3vGY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@redrum3r","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwbLlR2fT5n3vKJ9uJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You know I always assumed it would be the vibrations promoting more oxygen to the roots by causing really little shifts in the soil/medium or something. If that is the case, a pulse in the sine wave of some sort could work even better","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvvjS6Ul6MaAJrTFQ8psySA","author":"@kade4040","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lEq4WwDp4LWmL4TxvmyoQloNDAEJ16o2SwPwdt7zs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kade4040","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwNd7vvFi84fYBiwmZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bro that’s inspiring.  I was also a troubled youth with marijuana charges.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFbkChk6XNJYKtff8BBegJQ","author":"@cultclassics587","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lH7MiBJrWz3srnfbc7_s3MnCMZUu1nq41zw0xleKnQag=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cultclassics587","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzEg24Ad9TP0YGD-P94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Excellent video, as always!\nJust a comment about the Gödel incompleteness theorems: they're about deriving true statements from formal systems, I don't think they can be generalized to \"everything is on a scale from unlikely to likely.\"\nThe summary in a nutshell is rather: \"in a formal logical system, there are statements that can neither be proven nor disproven.\" Whatever empirical science is highly unlikely to depend on these statements for the analysis of its results.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCu33tLSgOLWOAhOLD0jhMpg","author":"@Felipe-eb4zm","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mdcy88_MZfY4MIt6uALkceY4M8RkYzOIACUg--vZA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Felipe-eb4zm","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzhbS570DoFB0ndlZh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I design ventilators that use high-frequency oscillation to transport oxygen and Co2 in and out of lungs without \"breathing\" per say. Oscillatory sound pressure is likely to speed up molecular gas transport in the exact same way within plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsGOdGWIGEKItXFZiixJvkg","author":"@ILiketoBreakStuff","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/aYPpOJlLoVBqcfZxChFWfNoYgOk7PTmfWvEuCRuJWcr1aqHEAGPYhElhrzMxDDYrcBvTGTK53Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ILiketoBreakStuff","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzkWcnU2RpZKVO0J_h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My garden likes Yacht Rock —-probably because I spend more time tending the garden when I listen to Yacht Rock 😂\n\nI like saying \n\nYacht Rock \n\n😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFnxyzHVrhevtoIBC8vl2ig","author":"@SearchIndex","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrV8OJgNXOwlrdryKcQh2foN71GntyUnXh0sRe_bQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SearchIndex","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw-pCMiRIogcA_l0Tt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think its from the vibrations that it helps it grow better","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvjmm5D22wAm6_N14GsFTWg","author":"@TacoAlligator","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/34t3dnaJZbKDJcBBQsJVV4BkwilIL5aizsY0ApWpGWwQYhDEQM-qe1H574F1ChvJff5wD6Jvr2s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TacoAlligator","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwX53RymfN5jOVkeex4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants grow stronger or hardier when exposed to wind or a fan than if grown in a still room.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCm73vscpyDxp2joe6sHIJrw","author":"@robertkitts1761","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mEJt0VKuI11YvJ05RioCLn7T9HXZNN93Si3AThhJM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robertkitts1761","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyoOeI3KoK5CsYiGC54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In meditating with dissociative psychedelics over a few years I spontaneously discovered that sound vibrations and a certain deep breathing technique that I can only describe as primordial and deeply natural and plaintive and open and of singing for the nature of reality itself. \nI couldn’t previously even consider breathing focus in meditation it would make me panic. \nAnyway this sound current opened up the space in front of me in the creative conscious material of what is and magical things happened. I sustained some notes and feelings and even grew a second copy of myself in front of me in white light starting at the throat. A faceless thing with a skull shape. Almost looking like an alien. I never see beings in this space. \nLater I read this is a thing in some Buddhist and Tibetan and other Indian religious practices. It has names. And the sound must have been some kind of Om. \n\nI then used it to open up a sort of large tunnel. \n\nAnyway I feel this vibrational thing connects all beings to the higher self and I can only imagine wolf howls, blackbird singing and sound around plants is a sort of creative growing energy. \n\nThe song of creation.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqD1ywTgTbtcWM80IR2a5Rg","author":"@Cowhaircut","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JBXeytmPdxDwaDjLnZOnJWvTSgLzjb1C_paia097pax9OLc1RMZGYFtFhk92uuCdaDajNcPHXg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cowhaircut","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQLBhQwqs_YbgBL054AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You should have a gas monitor in there as well, in case the speakers add or remove a gas.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwcSliSjDFeFgwADKAk4X2w","author":"@danielpas368","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kGwqlzazZbr_Ud7gOaCuAszwwsDmsiKulSzETorEsAyOM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danielpas368","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxckLG2Y5JZXOUCgMl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"2:49 I felt like that was science to reinforce the idea that rock was evil. Because it makes sense, but I’ve never seen real evidence.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7_zczCP7Nd_MHHs8YYF2Iw","author":"@Foiled_Foliage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/HQ9NSKIOpxftsaRC8ZuJXFvJi_d27Lsz9kiBdpBXwq5FYUJPprHI3GnUCwKdY7OJ87mhti3t=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Foiled_Foliage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxzbLUKhISxFDs8I6h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ben finally found the way to write off all this gear so he can grow the dankest kush","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPDJwUG_dFh2g0QlpVUm1ZQ","author":"@NomadSoulFull","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_knzBzXc8F4Iko9M7Wjgjb2E2MyoxKfQWgmiY3rxQ0V7Gs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NomadSoulFull","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-i6lh_o9vHGXI4l94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"„Anthropomorphise - the longest word I have ever said“ \n- German dude sitting here laughing quietly and thinking about the „Rindfleischetikettierungsüberwachungsaufgabenübertragungsgesetz“","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHfkpr4ERfacs7E_Xq5yucQ","author":"@Balu_tB","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1EZna9ZXX_LsiMNzHhPR09cec49R0kbDXtEWEz8u2KiTWY1koI9BGZmRVjUiOaPhWZc6b35RHw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Balu_tB","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBGedKbP2_rLDsy_t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about option 4? Music makes the plans happy and organisms thrive when they’re happy.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChuPydn_1NxK1Va_E3I6HUg","author":"@Ash.in.alaska","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7DV5l2AMZIwvuL50cS_gvrk8tHIyhpdAtOd_Hd3slRa4XH4x6OoGoLus5sygaASlEALxcagW=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ash.in.alaska","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy43qCalr-iYyCf1PJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i will watch that video eventually dont you worry","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNge41ynQAfJeVgFX_PqHcA","author":"@pebcak420","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WwmK7nt1Tbki5uMGQxycvfL8WeXspjtWtiidlwecq2jSZlRGjammncCKgH2rCylPYPtHSUe2gUk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pebcak420","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxmo8-VZMQbUzP6Mkl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"“There is no such thing as ‘true’.”\n“Oh, really? Is that true?”","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgXghF7djTY6EVfOm2uexdg","author":"@mattd624","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kjWixIUZMw34K87VITgdtyEOIkoHWkvA3ErsiR2Wh6PAM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mattd624","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzn1GlkuTI9vCUwmWV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dorothy Retallack's book has some interesting though not well controlled experiments. I did my PhD research on sound & plant growth & genetic stability. Monica Gaggliano in Australia has also done work in this area outside of her plant consciousness research.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOI_hfbdh6XnclXpInD5IZg","author":"@kosmicmagi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXNBnVor2T5FVc9Go-w378cXn6JmX-YLkW1G6mVZyFzwgLjg01XTaBOrjvCuKmfuRq9g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kosmicmagi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzT6seyTuKAq0zANhd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"do it with plantclones too please","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkjtK8J8OteIAV7SvK13T4A","author":"@kitastro","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ag2cxX6enIX_2s--wywlfqzKtanUPgfEXW9pPRzYnBNHpgxk9uxTov1kHY2a7a_Yf17eBgFrlZ8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kitastro","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTQBW8O99xlpbexQ94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It may be what the sound drove away and not what it directly did to plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwELZEVqw7ci-plgZ8XWuZw","author":"@BobNobody-p6l","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fb0IYD-IVfWEhq_Ds8WibKL7TrPsTgHeggq47ctJghLmfQbRVDDNprCaADAgY2jvhvtTrVteeQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BobNobody-p6l","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzo9ft04yU9iJf7DT94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Do you think the heat from the speakers could cause better growth? that would explain the difference in growth from the bottom and top as well.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCUPRIDdzQIBWPK5IARZo2HQ","author":"@HeartPlusUp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mI6vRRDTwIMOOzPczinhAbQLOIKDuGI2tgUb4bV9gkTVEEP4kKDM5HnQojR6yHm04Yo-aEFMfA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HeartPlusUp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzo9ft04yU9iJf7DT94AaABAg.AJ1lvmAh-eWAL58bUojgQl","parent":"Ugzo9ft04yU9iJf7DT94AaABAg","text":"My thought as well. It seems like the simplest explanation and he did not mention that he controlled for temperature. I guess humidity goes hand-in-hand with that too and might deserve controlling.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn2xGNYlPVSDhKiEoi_n6ig","author":"@sirdiealot7805","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nmj2ErdiFWsJTNDGWX8_eI0dzbxHNRIqvmGvitGa_Rd80=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sirdiealot7805","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxuBQvGMKRMjB_NWz54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dope!!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmxl26qxEySuMRA0I16kfGQ","author":"@GLDNSCTN","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lZbTR4ruqX4gb79e3pYp6J1tw7nxnxN8nk8rtkTzY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GLDNSCTN","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzG9rwdMOqBVNkHeNd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Now check out what plasma can do for plants ! From treating the seeds to the water. IMO what plasma and sound have in common is they both have access to the Aether or vacuum. Check out what happens when you grow the seeds from some crop circles","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtA9FhW44IBVzXmKC5bpwgg","author":"@CagliostrofValetta","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vHP-J_SEAOliWXbp6-ws2AJtAzEnZUjIcyZqSp3ne8lyX7xGRbZhbvvbSJsZvbNzloVkLWROXA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CagliostrofValetta","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwsN24uRSJRRhnvXTl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I can't even get repeatable results from control groups with plants, let alone actually test anything. My scientific conclusion is that some plants hate you and some don't. No autographs, please.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCM6--IaIsDD442A2vK_fEdA","author":"@JSTKSK","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n8Qs6Jl5RVuApD1iCmew6ZO4wWpUVXlt5inn_M0-zQHA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JSTKSK","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLRZUK7JrTpy8zHnF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yould really enjoy the lectures by Dr Randy tent of diverse health solutions and the many subjects he mixes in with the lectures he gives to his patients and other doctors at his clinic. He really spent a great deal of time studying different researchers who looked in many crazy topics or made insane inventions that were naturally taken control of by the gov, along with their parents, because they were focused on energy and frequencies etc and how it all effects all living things","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuY0Vmpp85xNxCWT5DzcAuw","author":"@ambersykora352","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kCwJwDpNrVeUanr6fyeYVkfvatIpVEdhjd0SBkBpo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ambersykora352","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxkGr0DSKg27Q5ajp14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you watch plants closely, the vibration from sound gives them a bit of kenetic energy to move around, grow certain ways and reach certain things, like if they have a creeper vine.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaZCHI3VgYZIIcfyNJ4SRjg","author":"@VampireSquirrel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kItUivAPMM1UpYFuepU9SlobRePEUfc4LwYQ_czHlPB2z7=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@VampireSquirrel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxkGr0DSKg27Q5ajp14AaABAg.AOudDEfq3LmAOudTCND3ws","parent":"UgxkGr0DSKg27Q5ajp14AaABAg","text":"I think this is why the results are so mixed. the steralized enviroment is not natural, so in the wild, they could actively hedge their bets to survive better by moving to brighter spots, or growing the way that's most effecient.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaZCHI3VgYZIIcfyNJ4SRjg","author":"@VampireSquirrel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kItUivAPMM1UpYFuepU9SlobRePEUfc4LwYQ_czHlPB2z7=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@VampireSquirrel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzs1ty9J5LPnqynbft4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My guess is that you're constantly giving the grass a really nice massage that lets it move nutrients and waste more efficiently","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrOK_AG2Ic4pw6EmFoWLyAQ","author":"@unskilledpyromancer7825","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MWsai09FDYGZkOd_3xpoAFm7nM1k1VzU-fHcc5WRu1cQ3tKecSUm3XMrwX4xi4K3oh66tu1l=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@unskilledpyromancer7825","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzxIIANav9Rt3kA9BF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Amazing!!!! Lets try now with mushrooms","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwWuaWmcAEJIERXy-jGUXgw","author":"@juanlozada4366","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOLm-ghLUyNeR63dHQLSJT7oFA7-F0BvqAJOjYEsiDZh4OjaFpfbdHReaGhCF6aq9AXw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@juanlozada4366","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzII8JY16lkpXY18FJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Unfounded theory:\n\nGeorgia Tech has some research on crab urine accelerating oyster growth - simulating a nearby predator makes baby oysters stronger.\n\nSo… what frequencies do the most common plant predator insects talk at?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEqLSdnLVy8cs805oN6uDMA","author":"@b38tn1k6","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrCeMJ-HtnAcK-D-Q3tuI55_JwTDcskiaYnPC51FLZoQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@b38tn1k6","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzCJVqw1kSvE1ODMhd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"8:24 did you calibrate the tone generator and the speakers? were the cables phase matched? lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCz2s2c3SuPA1dm5cCOZkgNw","author":"@Gunbudder","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/A-AcKv4B0GzV2hhTHBDIH-TsiAG-YKpULUTj5u41cZnJhwq8KvTIQ7vJQFqdNYpHSc_hCoPpoA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Gunbudder","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxxQrjctQtP82trrr14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I have noticed my plants appear healthier, grow faster, and produce better product when they are placed in my bedroom rather than anywhere else. My bedroom is pretty noisy with my tv, fans, or computer speakers going nearly constantly, so I wonder if thats why they do better.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxCR-yCw_C4QOx6RgMzRzlw","author":"@_motho_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Na5h7UUwGFUEJAsoxUCQu3wySwaSzg3UMDw9Y5G56FHLheX-jr8XLyR43uOO6nBPoEFG2cQ6_04=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@_motho_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-ikmegLrmE8EGd7h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A fourth theory for why sound would help plants grow could be related to why plants grow better with air circulation versus stagnant air. The pressure waves of sound may provide enough movement to provide growth benefits in mold resistance, improved CO2 access, or stimulation without triggering negative impacts or damage.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8VzTbeJkFRvttpVjQb2Rsg","author":"@RadDad419","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3gt51TT92yka_EGl1-t57f6iMfodyw-KcQ_Dr3eeA3rlaGD6w8gF0OErsFa2lvFLZkAP4645zw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RadDad419","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy97sbKUYgvYL6CpCF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe the sound waves trigger cell growth via thigmomorphogenesis?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCO4Ij-pBmMIdx3rvr5ACCvw","author":"@Blazinmoney1801","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/AcXTEjc0vvW8ZZEB_QURSs8H41td5wMkKlaFu5fmtJqH7EsitZsHdR31EtZu_k0CBIMsvGKbcw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Blazinmoney1801","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzI445uYQqOqMYBRY14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"🟰 Sonic Bloom 🎵🌱📈","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNU-zSXYWIOKl8xqJ9-Tuqg","author":"@fanaticforager6610","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mAVWEobams39PYVydfTWIWfs31MvXfLmRarSEgwWwoZFs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fanaticforager6610","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwYBk4lL3FxMY01bb94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"imagine what these data centers will do","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCp2rC9HF9wBHOg1V2naJNnQ","author":"@TheOtherOtherMike","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kBzqr9o-xs8wkXKI0Utpe17kxvaVVrvS6oK2qtdzo5Tzs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheOtherOtherMike","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzobt34k5MSt317DPp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My plants seem to thrive when I play/sing hymns.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOFbYKRJQ9fGvHOTGtFqB_A","author":"@JCC_1975","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kGPxnTl21O5bpdV50UKzzjh6aRq9AEK9R3LtuztdKQcuxnoZLsjPLMyQjq08vhwyUdn_3-h9=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JCC_1975","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy5y14AuXnKcFWd2sx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've been planting seeds from store peppers for a decade and I can't get a single one of them to even begin growing so I'm going to play them some Father John Misty albums and see what happens 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmhe97U5j14nv_-nJYXtZ_A","author":"@adricklynn8882","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n2vhawj-Q_xhdgoXom0Hvqll0w_cfv9nWN_pV-mNZ9f2c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@adricklynn8882","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx47e8LquRylutOagB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It would be interesting to see if birdsong helps plants to grow.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCM4HXakUj9lNQ-3VEV2gG4A","author":"@birdscds47","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n-c5gLOI1RH86ydXsZgLIZx5nmai0nbUpMliIqqw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@birdscds47","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy4YMXDKG1UaV5Ik3Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If plant corculation is based entirely on sqelueezing liquids through veins via passive measures, vibrations could help with circulation.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiOyYF3iDLlcOfEa_3QIdWQ","author":"@BAGELMENSK","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4VAupsc_tsEtaOUp2swOglJKtFw54q0KVKUaPRYFKdxRx2yI48vbh5bHtPKJxpI2wlX7NGQeOg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BAGELMENSK","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7_vEmYwWlRdgiIF94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My fairly arbitrary guess is that the sound gives the plants just the tight amount of struggle to help stimulate growth - i wonder if similar results could be seen with mild to moderate wind (compared to still air)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuWKQTxSHp2w9qXKNTuirSg","author":"@Rallion1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nX9AhufG_QT8sOrpQIDE7efYfAU8ZxIR8hCR_-Uh8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Rallion1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz90Tj1VuZgtsTNPg54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ben, I need that coffee pot. where can I get one?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqFIpLgC0lANBWwutF2UZCw","author":"@LynnColeMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/c6ROfnCHi8NDIwyBNa6TVECE-3o1etxdfW670mmBI-y8s6OVHykvaIm_TZQUX-xDGHe8PHG6=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LynnColeMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxIDHQEDBr9Dt-BFMx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The sound of birds chirping early in the morning signal the leaves to open their stomata allowing it to take in more carbon dioxide for photosynthesis thus bigger faster growth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBD0lRTuN121aDGh2AX460w","author":"@trilogen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZDT1Y1aNlHw3HSVhs1okfYKqfhhgEXwve-wvQtUnWiOkcd8VJwY2i0q-KLs0o7iQ5JTt2DC9Qw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@trilogen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxrQiDqZ2skwvGWDrt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I want a song from 0:53. What a drop!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC66v3Tvu0rTtjq59zy9M2FA","author":"@SzyGrz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mdqlumn3bMVRC9e9mG7FkMvgHk3P54_xiPjTXUm8c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SzyGrz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyu0FaFnv55iM5ToZd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well I do know that wind helps plants thicken and strengthen their stems so I wonder if the sound waves are working in the same way since they will both vibrate/blow on the plant and move it around. This is a well known phenomenon for indoor tent grown marijuana, if you don't put a fan on the plant early on, the stems end up being hollow and weak and as soon as the plant flowers, the weight of the flowers will pull the stems down until they snap.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0W-i5FpHvEMcbibC848lbA","author":"@JM-ym8mm","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m_I9e2u0W7WiRtiIt7rdlVLVqs1vNU_4VeuFjT2NJT0h0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JM-ym8mm","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0tz-c4fcnreYa-ZJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i have plants all around the house. the plants in my livingroom where my big studio speakers are grow so much faster and better. same light same soil same fertilizer. but i think its something much simpler its cuz its only working with monitor speakers. maybe something like micro vibrations stimulating the plants growth. everyone likes bass ;D","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9ZiCNohWzM9Tu3QxOUYJJA","author":"@NyecoGuapo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ks4Bt5KtFJMlxT_1D26VTiefYCgTfI5siAeL1ctpdSV8M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NyecoGuapo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugws7a_nBhdBhHEsWTp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I suspect that its a response to vibrations due to needing to accelerate growth in an more active environment.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChOPp9Eru9-AW3VyHPXse3w","author":"@morlanius","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lhMzWiE_ZxM20op_L7tdL3joLWe0iI8O0413WAk9F9TQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@morlanius","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxUERsSKp-_Hk3ydhR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If it cannot be replicated, it's not science.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCo-a5bXPKyGQh0smXPCDhew","author":"@anonnymouse2402","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sxtMtBfhiQb1ty52sxZcGcvrR0oCO_6mPv2sd_974SW0b4Hmni3OTfXbpHFrKPTalGGfxNGUvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@anonnymouse2402","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxUERsSKp-_Hk3ydhR4AaABAg.AJA5q3XpiLHAKPCdZy0Jp7","parent":"UgxUERsSKp-_Hk3ydhR4AaABAg","text":"If it cannot be replicated, then it never would have happened in the first place, and it wouldn't be published.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCus5sZIzN1O0ut56m3Al2TA","author":"@evrythingis1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mo7TgC4jxd3ktyWBI7tKmbAy7G5YVr_cJckwIYA8kbumQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@evrythingis1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzlIKv7NBIJX3C-Iv14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sound waves could increase gas exchange or water exchange in the roots.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmqbWrNlRmPdqoIF_U-UWQw","author":"@LemursLabMycology-e6i","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fbNfcnTNv1MN9Ma2fxsoUtIkb7eyW7miqFgIr2Ep6L2uU_J2DWgKGbmOr-VitTBd5rWKdE8J9w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LemursLabMycology-e6i","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzX-P8D0h0AClgcFex4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ben , great research, you're an honest man, but   what's not clear is where the speakers were placed? do you know that speakers 180 degrees apart will cancel each other's sound waves? this is a detail i cannot determine from your video. again thanks for your hard work!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrgE0JE-R2WtOeyCTzOy6fQ","author":"@ronaldorme6375","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mT9lKS7H7pzKzSSjBlpsLJnqXVUGK5NzMcncjSGdw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ronaldorme6375","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyxXMAa7F_tw60PfZh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Physical sound resonance effects like vibration as you know is relazed to the size of things. So your sound will shake or whatever the different kind of cells of a plant more likely if you find the average wavelength for lost cell sizes of a given tyoe like roots, soil bacteria or plant cells. \n\nJust throw many waves rhat are likely affecting the cells of rhe fiven size. \n\nDirect and indirect also sucks. 1 and 0 is better than 10 and 5 as a control. \n\nMix your seed batches thoroughly to remove batxh outliers. \n\nMix your soil thoroughly and have them always have the same soil freshness. \n\nMeasure temoerature continuously to conpare between expeeiment 1 and exp 2. Temperature is a huge deal for plant growth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDJpiYS0I97ncugtBb0Kwrg","author":"@lucelxebinog","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_leFFe8KMeL6dviJz4lflNtiouNm3lwAszN8UUFbfSwdMLOPurEgsecMSCzM5JDe-AUAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lucelxebinog","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxT4Ov5TIY6iAa2dGZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I hear corn has the best hearing.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvVTl17CqJnLMpOLjdUDqOg","author":"@treesmantrees","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dbkoQCSmjVOfbH7C71-ngvreWqj8mAgKBPcxQuY2kAx7M9slJyK2DXP77ELz4Tc4X92RjS4I-w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@treesmantrees","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy3XLlVGoWv0gsE0eF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'd bet it's the air movement and possibly plant tissues moving that aids in fluid transportation.\n\nAir movement improves oxygen and carbon dioxide transport away from and to the plant.\nPlant tissue movement improves sap transport along the plant (plant blood) similar to massaging improving blood flow by literally mechanically pumping blood through the massaged tissues","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfL0pl39EwOL1h7SWChiZ2A","author":"@puddlejumper3259","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kMd0I78L0hgEDKV6-ScowAzf28J5zvlF1J7FwKkVI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@puddlejumper3259","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxA0tjc_8eOylay_jl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe you should try different speaker technologies and compare that towards you singing for the plants, to find out wether the type of source makes a difference, and what about the different potential volumes? maybe also hire 5 singers of different genre too ... 🤔","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW1IXSEKaRcpJJ_IX0BjHyg","author":"@DonC876","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_93Zf_Lpcc5A_7aXmYTxfAKzbZNw6jVtMjlRjUv9W-QExHuMdTe-VgAIlGxrKW5Vc_Ea5nitqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DonC876","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwbTBe8HR-xLZ1pbH94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"tried to figure out why the thumbnail for this video was upsetting, realized it's cuz it looks like an isekai manga recap about some guy trapped in a tower with an overpowered farming skill","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkYH_1KHbXklQ6wUr5-jUYQ","author":"@sneptech","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pm6hBycyH6a7ZQirLCHhxDn5SfHkxKsbHWVWvoNbWnWTA_DgQ-EAoA1j30tJVpjA255Yt-9deg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sneptech","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyvhtFquxOV7n_EsKh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Considering the color temperature of the light and the plant specimen used in the experiment...... perhaps bluegrass music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1XB3wKZ8-SUhTLyJWukexw","author":"@5p0ng3b0b","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l9kSzlBXqPl-CgOKDwbpybCIpjhjLpemaWLyhWxPG9gm0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@5p0ng3b0b","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugylon3s1rjWX1W4GfJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i actually love you","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoUtJZ-XL-JRn2itVKkF64Q","author":"@aaronyoungs4870","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nOVsSz3TnerBEufWidtZYf5-DqYrR__F-6orACIxc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aaronyoungs4870","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgznflqH47lyZaT9xkN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if plants have their most optimal fav music we dont know","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbuVsNDfCEIdNnN92NvmEFw","author":"@andrewcardarelli5648","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6CQjyHYbfwD8-zuGe1rBpgoA6U-18kHT0UhIkkLYLcdkc6RwVRrLfV8XbypohZe3pg1AhrHdnw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andrewcardarelli5648","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwhSzW_dyAVjfdg-lt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It might be an evolutionary adaptation in flowering plants to know when insects are around.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3jAjcrcg7tcWitBirRdCCg","author":"@annaclarafenyo8185","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3_Bi7ZX-39-bZ1ZlaNv7HofbbD21n0_yJYTPN8sY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@annaclarafenyo8185","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy1Wgr-K-YLoDS772B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Kudos to you! My college degree is crap.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbArfOJIpVw1jLbUODWOjBw","author":"@clarkisCotton","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2bwSyAs52li4CMy6MyZGCLQbD22bzW52WK_a_sOSaRGtWfZKlUiTUwbSqtlipESVVILyqOsL0A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@clarkisCotton","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYCzBeNvFb3XB98vJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"bruh my dog looks very much like yours and is also named lucy. Neat","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRLsvCPWJNj_LispFnCA8ng","author":"@garyhamilton2104","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kPc5aIMuIHIDACUF5DnQSO1NT0P0IeTMfJKTfVXA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@garyhamilton2104","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw0WqrYDeTuX5pNys54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Singing to plants works in The Sims, so it must be real.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoZ6gNIDKAQyJajrGyLu_-Q","author":"@DamnitDelwyn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lH1zJmlsA1WqGJZyMpgTbIfXRnmiC714MlofQqnMaTuRgkpG4o42a60HhOGPyJpAPAuA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DamnitDelwyn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0u6aBGLz5pw6ZueF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You are doing the world's work. This is a genuine question: how do I work for you? I have been trying to figure out what to do with my life. And I love science and making meaningful progress with experimential work, but the world of science seems so fruitless right now, so ive been working for summer camps and non-profits because I love feeling like im making in a difference in the world, and i love the freedom to experiment with what works and what doesnt. but I have big dreams for what the world could be, and the work that you do on this channel aligns with that. So do you have employees? Where do I go to apply?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkmOZwFOJF5Q7Cdd1AMulow","author":"@elliottwood5423","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lSkir0yujUJAlh-S7k-ShKESv4mgqz2q_xBAuGMyVzYt_G=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@elliottwood5423","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWG9PTR3hoWyiDend4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Many have made the sound/music connection to plants and am bird sounds.  The sounds cause the stoma to open absorbing water, any nutrients on the leaves until the birds stop.  I believe it’s rue.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCukMtca-31M60JvOqKOOJog","author":"@Catcat123-w3l","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XqqVhCskc6kgjK90aKFnoaHWGqqaTbmsewlm5FJcmA-9uUOOOzIbM5VuDidfw4PazUfEywWwYVw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Catcat123-w3l","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzi28_FW2tiyIRQuah4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"60 seconds in. my theory: specific vibrations of atmospheric molecules might promote gas exchange on a surface area? the way we use ultrasonic vibrations or UV light to clean stuff in liquid? Mother Earth's Plantasia is a cool album to try.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk-mrkIasEh8C3fP3etXRvw","author":"@empireDirt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/w6t9BjJTn-HF04FM0PQx1UvdNDPFYchlHDNQnpjhFBIJrIAYzAK37LE1Ud2ixLHVI627uhRF-LY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@empireDirt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwRjlfRQ88oSoyAeTF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Firstly,  the heading says sound but sound and air flow are related but not necessarily the same thing. Air flow could be akin to DC current and sound could be akin to AC current .  We would need to split between this .","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXpNMOetW6f2bvbM4oC6HQA","author":"@das250250","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m5z3S4ApwL0S2T4K21LUaZqlLdLNUaZQw6UnVl_aS5gWI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@das250250","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyZ_LAYh9UOI6FTYIp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wondered just like the light wave spectrum we have the sound wave spectrum","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfKEeq7W52wu8dVWq5i8Jgg","author":"@joebiggs.sc1231","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kS8wjddMiS5nMAXup-qchP1NOBW9D4t2QjK9OfBPU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joebiggs.sc1231","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-T2JY2kNnhFKASll4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe the shocks of the soundwaves helps air molecules to penetrate the leaves more easily and vice versa.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCm4IJWZswDfUet-2N4YwrbQ","author":"@philipmariusmueller","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kGiCSPEsl7XMT19ncOwXHPONswTouxWdIb7Sge54M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@philipmariusmueller","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyNFpKOndwYthNn0ph4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"For at least twenty years, the grocery stores all across the the west have a speaker that plays the sound of rain when the mist spray comes on.  How hard is this to understand?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmLVzYjjp4CvfUtOAO6V6Qw","author":"@theloniousscalliwag","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l6NPlpyAuFfd9RgIk4zWRQIJbWdB7qQflnRE75JKs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@theloniousscalliwag","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz86YJcNoqHsfWRsll4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I come back to this video for the first 30 seconds","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiZfq0ECyy765d1D-w8gB0g","author":"@Schell_A","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6sEO50Oxe74oRoJzVoH9CRaUi33RqJwmWe9wed1r_9USIFc1FMJX0_oWgY7vgxx6NWspEZsoeME=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Schell_A","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy68p5ZhpFU0BM42Lt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just starting the video, 2min in, but I think this evolution would make sense because if plants can grow faster to bird and insect melodies then they'd thrive faster for seeds to spread! I bet even winter has a sound vibration they can notice that we don't.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRERH72ISFC-VpEHRTFH_5Q","author":"@LiXiaoChunSpadeDuke-ish","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lC5UjgSPWc3r1T8gc9KJOojFMj-mlCQ5L8pOYWcfng_lbF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LiXiaoChunSpadeDuke-ish","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzUM8NQKRcIt9QmAKV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wouldve imagined supernormal \"signal\" for hormesis is the cause if it is an effect","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCavE9UPp9bdoN7siH6n0LLg","author":"@samgrainger1554","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nR2JQGgROGRSxtmezcowfnLpswHWC4DdmqdlmbVA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@samgrainger1554","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwUi4Hd1zZ72x3-8Np4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Could be vibrating water stimulates the roots.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCed3PKpTiPH6m3n0HAGtqwQ","author":"@sydvicous7743","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYhE2oJ9lV3nvo-rInAPFPItuXmtW6-LSDTCCeC38=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sydvicous7743","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyCk40FL8mCVMk9xKJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"the end was very empowering for me. you telling me i can do research even tho i didnt go to university? \ni cant pay for it sadly. i´´m very interested in chemistry and engineering. i work in Pharma lab (only with a finished appreticeship) \nit always made me sad - thats why i learn so much at home, on youtube, in books and papers.... so i can be atleast a part of it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCDurOtiBwE8U5EN3DjYv-Q","author":"@Nagria2112","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l16KRa71if41h70zsDJDTy8KmGKJatF2IM-l2cEeBHdQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nagria2112","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzd7M3WN83RZXV33qd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"lmfao you’ve earned yourself a follow, i’ve just got my me back and it’s so good to see a fellow creator who’s in tune with they self c:","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2LiQby6xwIPR1gVR-KwNbQ","author":"@aintapuppy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/EMINC0mrVFT1aplZiugKocHdpmFMYQE60OGzAAYyPjXNOKwt6tGBaglRdFeyx8eCcMw3sy_MGA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aintapuppy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx07kABIQQJ9PszniB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I guess now we know that if a tree falls in the forest, the plants will hear it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCy5viIitUN5WKcZxLqp9YHw","author":"@hahahaa7299","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m3xsDDWDtx-VsQBzH-zaTxJwjo7JpbicAiy1tcgjLGi4A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hahahaa7299","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfyuXnaMeovH_1yWx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am curious if it helps with the distribution of liquids, nutrients, and such. It could also be that some critical reaction is catalyzed by the sound pressure.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSWo2mfLoeEKi1mcYaJrVSw","author":"@rich1051414","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k53E6SdtQ3Lw_6TtgE_Jd7pybGLTbgClNVPAMi7-cxYHw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rich1051414","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxOXmzqjKMQxA2zuiR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Cannot believe the Mythbusters haven't been mentioned in this video at all.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCizW11dXNAChfj3in1XzRlg","author":"@thevideoman12","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0bNFYi4eTV7kNcMn6_4N73mNPUIRDQqSO4TT4nZb4poKgAk3PH_JlZv1vAI89R5NZe0lCuHUAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thevideoman12","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-P9F75oBPgggc4B14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:35 More like “For any useful system, it’s complex enough that there will be things that are true that can’t be proven to be true (and false things that can’t be proven false),” not that “you can’t know if anything is true.”  For example, the axioms of a system are, by definition, true.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyzqRnMArrKse02-KOdpJpQ","author":"@DrDeFord","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kPduUOCbV1NYLSG_KHQZ4JzD_Xr1OQvVbWUV8VpGI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DrDeFord","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwA6FEGf22Fv2UPGHJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’d imaging the frequencies in the pressure waves vibrating the stomata of the plant causing the uptake\n\nI bet you can can 2x it with c02 systems","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDs4nDSXDDgtM7XgXzRvGiA","author":"@cody_raves","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JzhSx9gEAB3xIoFqywNurfRG59uSnb6ASVx7V-2_wolTyAz5FmLnzW5os2qMAfiuKZn04chn=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cody_raves","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqBEqvoyo8SFJQ_eF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Would love to know how you learned all this without school.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEWrB9N6-8v3tmOAI2MuHlA","author":"@bojacktravis6701","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lcC8q2MbMv3vOaqvs3xyOPBSKjVYDO4vgqk2q8-UxoBQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bojacktravis6701","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyuXcEZ7QnvMu1pTR14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just a random guess. But life that ingests plants makes sounds (insects like crickets, birds which indicate the presence of crickets). Maybe plants are coded to create more biomass if signs of plant eaters are present to increase survivability","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKE7hRYQV_UO7b0SIoD5XTg","author":"@maxwellwhite","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wR8x4eERoSetcyY9o93gcx1XPCr10UOiaruuyjPaQu3CjBtHNBtaa0QWQ7-Addijjyg--uVnsw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maxwellwhite","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyjx2W-bJSTKDiML1p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My personal idea, is that sound waves (vibrations) help to cause gas exchange at the leaf surface (where boundary layer, van der walls, trichomes, and other effects can dominate)... \nThat is, it helps the exhaled O2 escape, and fresh CO2 get access to/from the stomata.\n\nIt helps them breathe.\n\nThis would be different from wind/airflow, due to effects mentioned earlier...\n\nI believe this idea is rational, and is testable... and since it doesnt involve any plant physiology/internal processes, somewhat accessible...\n\n\nBtw, I have a B.Sc Biochemistry degree (tho such things are never are guarantee of capability)\n\nCheers","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn5HZJmLSoymJi0B8uTQdIw","author":"@chrisclement3706","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nTUTkRYg72S8caAF7pMy9UobKTMAnIbHYe8fL4BAXSQw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chrisclement3706","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxXowMd_Ut7mwH5WZ94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I saw your video 9 months afterwards. \"Sound influencing\" gravity could be a thing due to the mass gradient of the leaf blade.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqwYJIQ7PTtEaD5j858UCdw","author":"@dougsmith5873","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mH0pGto86gJmH43KGTz5_Enkj5FUscngXEMlcPZkE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dougsmith5873","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6HssxnRYdxyWQEXx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"omg Lucy is adorable ♥","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCed0nHjHZTxLO6K16YM0owQ","author":"@erika_zZzZzz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/AaEwxG9L3IkY_DKEajbs5gHwDsTnsaSTjCvIvUmEsUuocmiiwVVdnFWygshsHvLjZhbivNxdTVU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@erika_zZzZzz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxp0i0dVrB47BUqAcd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"the sound pressure could be enough to stimulate growth just like wind","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCG7ly-82w0vQgwnYNVpLEQA","author":"@schnaps1790","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lDAcOkh6uc9eabruas3TGVMQU_u29s-WLtc1XCA-ZinQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@schnaps1790","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxEFqU7yh8fas1Ecmd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Mort Garson literally made Plantasia in 1976 we've known this","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCD6LGF4-pmm0rSPX62a-4Lw","author":"@RoachDoggJr2112","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CzufKCBHLGzZQzocjwNaLhAXkSxxiFoI87BdS_sH6LuIA58K6-elKyep3eJbif_uNsBC3nEP=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RoachDoggJr2112","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwOhdIihq9DiJgbgvh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I can see reducing friction at a molecular level let's the plants transfer water, nutrients, and gasses more efficiently. Vibrating things breaks the static friction which is why it helps open jars and slide things. It at least makes sense in the theater of my mind and I have access to plant growing areas, sound equipment, and an oscilloscope ... Because you can't do proper science without an oscilloscope.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQaoNXRRg_XmsQaiw2lXtmA","author":"@wilhelmschmidt7240","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kjbA0-pa2WMQ9Xd_EhbyNjBJhbK3UraiWRrJNbBUY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wilhelmschmidt7240","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxkVfNDnq3srT76n0J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Theory 4:  sound vibrates water, improving \"circulation\" of the plant.  Wind would also accomplish similar.\nI bet vibrating or shaking the pot could also work.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8ywQP7sGiNani9yvahomuQ","author":"@mellored","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lLRE_eiP4kt8EjE7n2g4BCoQ0tfuehMHLoNCJrAkFZ6Ng=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mellored","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugys86VqGW8oDIGy7gt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Man, there's this speech Ralph Waldo Emerson gave in 1837 in which he - among other things - reflects on the gap between science and \"the real world\". Especially as a social scientist, it seems as though universities sometimes use the \"just observe; don't interfere rule\" as an exuse to move on and get funding for the next research, and not looking deeper at the practical implications of their work. We know so much, but we leave it to people with an entirely different set of moral values to turn that knowledge in to practical products.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCF1oIWqufF0FlfW6qjbfx8Q","author":"@Pablo-h1e3y","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kQb66_r-tkBEn2iZDFhJ2GG4iHBNhSUfLuMmYXH4kfLpzB1eRO46tXEjwegiB59Ph2gg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Pablo-h1e3y","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2M9YaZCKUXf2epbR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"my theory is that the vibrational energy entering the ground causes the elements in the soil to immerse and dissolve more making it the things the plant need to grow more accessible. I'd guess you would need to test an apparatus that seeks to aim to do that and run it vs the sound and a control. Just a thought. Could be wrong.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8AnuDduLE6MtLMFmvDU-3g","author":"@elijahgooley385","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mjv7XtstzP4i_ZOOH26RGiXt_4dYhiYr1Lrvorz7o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@elijahgooley385","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzlXQn4Q6ZKY3SKQJp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"if sound is just a pressure wave through the air - could it be moving the air in specific ways that interact with the plant more efficiently? To use a metaphor when using a gold pan you shake and jostle and use gravity to separate the gold from the dirt and other lighter minerals. Maybe the sound is sort of doing the same thing with the air, changing the random mix of air molecules in to a more orderly mix. Different frequencies, I imagine, would be more or less efficient at it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuhnNhYCG8g9cnZMJGJCOXQ","author":"@AndPennyThought","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lEzMM0tu_DNlpWrmAlSeCAYvho37rV1Vb62p2c3QbcU3Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AndPennyThought","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxjjappcs_63aBccBh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"WE HAVE LEARNED THAT TREES TALK TO EACH OTHER.... And other plants..... and fungi. ... SOOOO .... 🌳🍄","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0mRegZEFk33Cy3E3wvoG5Q","author":"@shaec3405","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/aWPJLBohT1N3NtZ40geVHGzze-Yfd72xfh6c8ltSIWKrU7QUJ-LmqKTWm2Luhhk_gevJEDxJnd4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shaec3405","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-uN4z9qJ97eZDeql4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"9:10 Favourite science fact. Due to a bunch of complicated physics as you imply, as well as biology, cold isn't real. There's just heat and less heat.\n\nAnd yes communication like this is incredibly frustrating and should remain in the domain of fun facts","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCmKgxmdAdkztdtbgatASpg","author":"@Aryasvitkona","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n0HYiIwFDtrCJN30KvFSWRrAPYafqW3ONTWLvQcLfwd4Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Aryasvitkona","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz3uVLxLNuYBq3rgRt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thanks for telling on yourself. Impressive","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNjg43RcPi8K6bXKR6HijfA","author":"@BuiltAndHosted","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lEFFGYR6oeBpIUVPffyp4z8vhF7ZpZ9NcPctRKeZZRJawUUOTmIt2TNScChG4rX_7vWBNHrdpL0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BuiltAndHosted","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9U_7FA6Z5RN_WB9h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I thought this was proven honestly. 99% sure now I made it up myself, but i thought its was the sounds vibrations helping the roots go \"faster\" because the soil is \"less dense\" - so since i have no way of growing plants I WOULD LOVE for you to redo this with them in singular pots in a size or sizes matched to a resonnance frequency and blast it with that. Beans/peas cultures could also give you a yield vector. How does Mycelia react to sound i wonder rn..","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLzO7--dmMolQEXeEulDkfA","author":"@kngkunaat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/tJV_wKX3aS4gYTm9wzH5RqE2UjSDngCu0eGLXcBIjDZQ2crE362E3EgT_NZUy8FZEIRjJJU3nA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kngkunaat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzHeskarJO_UCUAPLd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"@1:00 my first thoughts were.\n1) are the vibrations from sound helping water travel up through the plant and help the water/oxygen expel from the plant?\n2) is it helping vibrate the soil so that nutrients and water absorb better into the roots?\n\nOr maybe both?\n\nMaybe try a vibration plate to see if similar results?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtn0R4GZtS9C6KruqsdrbTw","author":"@DCMAKER133","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iWtsvpQsvhMYaoA5tCyeXwqxh-PXh5p-Jp-RDEnFt9yFJ3-YdJaMdGWCcff_YugtaITiUSLhpg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DCMAKER133","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyiShmUOGm_nibFwGl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just a thought, the sound frequencies are vibrations, and may impart some of the same benefits as a small fan blowing on the plants or lightly brushing the leaves occasionally with your fingers to encourage healthy growth. \n\nI am also exceedingly curious, with little education, so take that with a grain of salt.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSoLVGb_c5RvpiiEMTf87QQ","author":"@johnabell861","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iNKZL_m0Vdq96bmKyWZ7AIK-MwHRmPZTCU1VyaTvMWTSPHFLWaMPchhRFWOqIi5pboocpix5TQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johnabell861","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzwo5yTFmkzU0__1fN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Any updates on this bro? Its SUPER interesting","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDOxkuN5fUoPUv0AUe3pPfA","author":"@ghatamandchill","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVfxBemKTXVOvYzuHj3r_aqBBGDF_m8iUtvR9qB3klUkFKm43FfQihtLRU7-euWiffJg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ghatamandchill","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQgkUauYRUONb1ZzB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It’s not just sound…sound is vibration. Also putting a crystal at the end of a copper coil will draw in natural resonance from the open elements and improve growth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa63zDvGMZNbZ44KMeTMvkg","author":"@beauknows_au","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kM2MT2-LEYNwAkt_qQMZJTeaCjU6Axjc-DOXJN9H4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@beauknows_au","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzk6l9s5fBC3K-3UM14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"maybe vibrations moving molecular machines to do work more efficient...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoAfxJ8Gomri2M_eLZOvMNQ","author":"@jedz86","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nE0VCjsa4a04RbsLJQnKsfrQeYxPNnGThLprpRNRqDXQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jedz86","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzeubAFsqt-mGCQ1Mt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"it's the pulse and vibration caused by speakers that stimulates the plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCt_cDi94hm8QUBHLWVm5UCg","author":"@SpockCycles","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/U1HD9VGcBNLw-guOsEg6tqyviI02r_9dob3x8fP_fObq57bH_dWh0_WdJ2lisum0EVp7Sl2DeA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SpockCycles","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwAOPZQ3YuumummYwt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:40 What about sound vibration just aiding the capillary effect? Similarly how a single drop can help merge other droplets, a drop gaining just enough energy to go against gravity might help the fluid below it go up","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcbzx4PqlZB5vDkgVXS-G6w","author":"@Dietr1ch","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ksjkZ_iLU5CuFWr7cjkK74gaSNrVt36DJ-EQ4LWoiPdKs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dietr1ch","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxKX0J3XGOsK7jmcLp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So you know the experiment with the  antigravity sound balls could you grow a plant in that gravity wave or a piece of it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCA3-RSIAgZKMM0LSV9H6bOA","author":"@markpepper-p7h","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nlnprfmsQHcKfVAXzIVaFY0IZBPvzSgCuRtHsL17l6KNYfMlJExcuh0mZf4C_9dnSVrg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@markpepper-p7h","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxtflE-E1MErzXBjeF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you want more precise measurement of eyeballing the harmonic, you can use harmonics.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC43sRL7IF7QJo1c2KArJ2eg","author":"@tutacat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTrrHNGPRIMVPlGVJWJRUZyPKZgYzMHAYeE5q4nDRgYMMh1I483VD9E0r_pf3-S3k_iQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tutacat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxwGovm9swwWKry9d94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"No plants have feelings and emotions, you’re unenlightened.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUtuOW8lmxLJKikuJZlYagQ","author":"@TheNightshadePrince","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7LD98UKu7IxVa4xrDMqrR61KVgMp8yecHs2tWmd3CQcw9vFtg-fE2I50OpuGhtvd0qa8VrF-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheNightshadePrince","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxTF_S4Nm3RZ7kSrLR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Orgonite also helps them growing fast af. \nI think it has to do with their ressonance in some form...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoTRJmxXJbHCIYBr-lrrhFQ","author":"@SoCreaty","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nk29xzl3jkWmMeCBId2V7nfwBHJroBSlP-UhmSAeZT_Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SoCreaty","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7wPvJj5hUuojOE0p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What coffee machine is that? It looks crazy","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5wjLU8y4bjgcECCnhkusAA","author":"@jeguschristie4300","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kf6DeqbZ5qqGWqCJsjgkd6r-Kka_nxeV1j5g56tVa0Mw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeguschristie4300","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzUiwvdJpwy6USjEXV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"We love science, but live in stories","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1iArrd0mgPhkGaCV21hkOw","author":"@brianbaumann07734","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_muTMWDW1QoDuNpw8mLeIoACenxBtjkVS5eafhRElw-rw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@brianbaumann07734","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz8xvBF3K8AHdN9vhN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:15 that's not what Godel said ! (not that i read it personally) but in a teeny tiny nutshell it's that for any set of axioms sufficiently consistent to do arithmetics there will always be statements that are true but impossible to prove from inside the system, and that if you try adding axioms to complete (prove the theorems you can't prove) then the system becomes inconsistent and you will run at some point into contradictions (theorems that you can prove both true and false, which makes your set of axioms useless). truth is very well defined within arithmetic systems ahd you can absolutely derive truth from math. truth and provability are very different concepts.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTo6v9MyDFSI_KmOpYWgpMA","author":"@merlinminy6871","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kB7WSX8ioeakXL4Ubh5PVIktAxn_KTDgqMDgCl2B7bsZk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@merlinminy6871","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxHoks1Sahxum4LLX94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Man 100% correct","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX4EkTXVZsa2N1Lf0ESPvMQ","author":"@cach_dies","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_muMrkc34UIi52_5sUnH3jMPgQpf68MsBAXw-WAWWnSuIA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cach_dies","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZKDUmMIA_rd04MBJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I sing and play music when I go to water my garden every day.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6vVfzEXGMYqP8werEEPRAg","author":"@jonathanwhite3507","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m_BZwsBvKR8zzFKwqnKdCjFtN6XXiZO1Ich3OMOQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jonathanwhite3507","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwjHEYMWHJB8YSalWh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love your chickens","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_OGni13p8eTBQUi-8vqTPg","author":"@embersaffron5522","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_HKiRglBdp52DzISF9pUlout-mVeSp0n5L9vYMZBrtok=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@embersaffron5522","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo0ZAZQMtSzOMEaq94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The plants in my basement prefer that \"Pyramid song slowed down 800%\" track like nothing else.    \nSadly im far to lazy to find out if it has ever made any diff, but the girls seem to dig it.  : ]","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBcBpWDhFjmTewb1Fe182vw","author":"@RayoAtra","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FmWGU7b6PW68iitqipq4Oo-rd8HC8Hrb2fEPh8TaAJG3yT9dVSfbAnTUabzaQYk_0HC3BUic=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RayoAtra","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxBj79eCybwmRXDfDV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This seems like air movement increasing access to co2","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC029koH-FUuBxV3yzqVAVDw","author":"@eva2k0","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lthhUlb283OA-WC_n7vhMhy7DKxlotMsbSpuoO1ns=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@eva2k0","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyuGnMqygkSdzV_gTl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Some thinks aren't ambiguous. Is the earth a disk on the back of a giant turtle? No. Not \"it's complicated\". Just an unambiguous No. \n\nEveryone knows its a tortoise.  ;-) \n\nBut science doesn't tend to ask questions like that.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCvN-13t2V0iWtjC_O8vCppw","author":"@donaldhobson8873","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_maTQBP4GMeRtPg9_4ORSrwSbJgJCVOYl0PzBTyTcCM3Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@donaldhobson8873","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxBY57qiTHr6ArR5Ox4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn, be careful with the chickens! You ought to give them some treats.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCheaaeSyL9IW__7Y3STCJ8g","author":"@75blackviking","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lYi_sfC4SkI2Fr0z8yckvtmKTLwSJivw4F1JloxZg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@75blackviking","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxC5N_aWNLMe8Kn8P94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Has anyone tried this with a specific flower that’s popular to grow at home","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMRiZmRaPFrev3biWOi33vA","author":"@danboyd6180","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mVvdTtjSpuE6-eOmQ8KQZtFsKJ2YfDv7sAl98jX0A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danboyd6180","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6WbbrNoAvHlKVeDN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My weed plants like Dave Matthews band.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCU52i7Ib7GfMastp7WJVxqA","author":"@YTOG.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/aUfynnvC3on4-mq00T0LKs-GGAf0zG4_5RCA3BqaIBxmzZS3PqtRk8KZm70lxziCTD14KGl9oA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@YTOG.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxGZVSfNTnETtCd23h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Would be cool to have crowd funded research, where individuals and companies with similar intrests can share a pool of resources and funds. It would be beneficial for all since you could conduct several experiments with the same N resources. \nOnly problem is governance and trustworthiness.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrYvNI8KaZwjb7zS7gT7lBg","author":"@BAMBAMBAMBAMBAMTV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LJHXluP4bIbEoCHzfpjZJt1_lQsEUB6N92Ys1Bp46_4MpUyW8HZg-rRkqO4v5ulF7j4n9TovkKI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BAMBAMBAMBAMBAMTV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx7KLo0xpu1lbWslp54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wonder if anyone has looked at sounds in nature around various plant development seasons & compared to frequencies that seem to effect plants? Maybe theres an insect or bird that makes a sound at a particular time in the plants development. Lots of noisy insects like cicadas have life cycle symbiosis with ligume plants. Perhaps the plants like to wait for birds to arrive before producing seed? I can imagine plants that seed for migrating bird arrivals/departures might get an evolutionary advantage. Some plants need seeds to be ingested by specific species to germinate. I wouldn't be at all surprised if the plants are acting on cues from a symbolic partner. \n\nAnother thought is the symbolic bacteria on plants roots. It helps the plants convert nutrients. Are you singing to the plants or something else? If its something else like bacteria or some other symbiotic partner. It might explain the variation in results. is if theres a bacteria or enzyme that responds to sounds and somhow promotes plant growth. It might not be present on all the plant samples. \n\nThe other thing I'm curious about is if theres pores or some feeding mechanisms on the plants that are a resonant length or cavity with the sound waves.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVdIg6jPSgEJqOh6-a0HQfw","author":"@MongrelShark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsWK2bB4hnbgjbT0WqIWoVtGA3Z6MvrE3Y1aLjp0jD1e0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MongrelShark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz3ifX71KblZuUvO7B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:55 scales don't need to be calibrated to compare two objects","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMbNpaiWc99MEqq4WlDSJIA","author":"@EthanSteed-g9g","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_lui30_R4aFboFtgT_VxYjD4iTGYWon2fteKOKgKDhtSlE3mEcaX1nF_zJZGiJY87Og=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EthanSteed-g9g","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwXoUJR1mrN7ZwobRF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wonder if having speaker with busted... diaphrams? can generate similar results. something about electromagnetic fields maybe","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3nQUZg_0lOIG4zEObCHK3Q","author":"@abraxas2658","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4wERyRm32kVT5HBTs7hImyPUIJ10fz4WYI_Y6wA6JLQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@abraxas2658","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwSQ5uWJCl-z079SIF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Have You considered that it's probably not the sound, but the Magnetic Energy discharged by the speakers when played at different volume levels?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMK3DFfQI7L7l_vvV8DWs6Q","author":"@adolfohidalgo7165","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mfvOnY_LRtIACBu1_2mOY9hTXHgutYURK7im5A6yyFAKE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@adolfohidalgo7165","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy42cSviBk4EXNFx8t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yes weed is a musical plant and it keeps people happy since the cavemen timeline","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCV5u4pVZF3_KDZ9pYb9WJnQ","author":"@ZARBONAF","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dx0b3NsFRPr9R2OWkHeu5AlkbhcZE3PT4lhXiP-YsRZcS56Kig1SRDqRNoT0Lw1HrP-i7IAC9Dc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ZARBONAF","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyArLXoAnIU-E2AE6V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wonder if the constant vibration caused the plant density to increase. Im thinking along the lines of how vibration or microfractures increase bone density","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcb0nbZPdIt7_lrU6-eUxwQ","author":"@alexprice1443","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mFXEGuLCF9TKplFFX7Lw3NzMn0rsjsrouVk3q5Fz0tAQE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alexprice1443","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxNKzVgeP-Q-hJWhu94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Try and demonstrate gravity acting on gas","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCskTiizP3PVZstc2y1QupAg","author":"@jimwest4060","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/asAdkLaHN9s2tFpWXqk06Bic6YUuifNrRGKN4PlGVT1W6Wr6_gbhRmc8cBYK00IdrL-rTbYSFA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jimwest4060","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6TVSsZFroVsEIYl54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Could it be that the sonic vibrations add energy to the diffusion going within the plant? Plants mainly rely upon water being transpirated out of their leaves to draw new water up from their roots. Adding sound could also increase the rate at which that happens, thereby speeding up the growth of the plant","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQH09LoV2IuG-ahJ2bfeg-g","author":"@MrMexi-oe8eq","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_moy42U5ATm5dnJ0xuKbJra-6hR8msGqT7BQ-RczLY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrMexi-oe8eq","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwMIiGRYoEBhoWbvX14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Not gonna lie, I want to know more about your coffee prep","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpK-5ex0-kXh7zXooJz3FsA","author":"@aidanpryde7720","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kEDrKn_fkzITV1qj28-1S_qfZ37fTNCcjNCd_OCj2JlWo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aidanpryde7720","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9j8ONEO_iwSeWr_B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm curious if anyone has calculated the amount of sonic energy absorbed by the plants and if that can be correlated with increases relative growth. Theory being adding energy to a chemical process increases reaction rate","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvfHKrQ2jCgMfeSet5yqZnQ","author":"@eemonster","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNf2rR1TBB0Rwfb65pfwDOInXnL_Hh9TybJeah0R3AfH6v=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@eemonster","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyD15OnBtEDt6Gjb3t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Curious about the fancy lights on the speakers. Was that difference negligible?\n\nAlso curious how you controlled for humidity changes.\n\nAnd barometric changes?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwQBsOQzpGtidLEHdvXsWUQ","author":"@atkiburrito","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7ntkEoAUZjMr2UAZgaofOjvyamCYxR4oyqz7Bt5CeOKAXiu2L1u9my0ZIxwSTgOOBORbG254=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@atkiburrito","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxrHHgWnf62NIa-f354AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Happy new year! Science?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkdz24rYFfI5fxNm2u9miog","author":"@ransombot","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9uuTEjqCf0eN51LhIxPiHjJiq1Ti_KPtwBAjDnj4QRYQHF4OOb22bKmaDP7MsCKzSi3ekE8I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ransombot","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx24-gkT0DWU5TyNT94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love this guy!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXkO4JveD9T5yTAC-YQ_upg","author":"@christinagiunta9036","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nscj-ejrZyTUrNIoiD3o6I-A_GjVtL_bpNccxd23QnJ561=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@christinagiunta9036","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz8F8Y4OIQeiu9-YYh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"@bennjorden, how about the soil being more compressed due to vibration..so the seeds/roots could get nutrients more easily?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3K8qEG7LtfdrqQ6lSuCf3Q","author":"@jamesheadfield","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nif4XUfN1qFFsu7JxrH5qJwAuYPPt5vrsnf8RSHUA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jamesheadfield","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwgZOllwy3Q-KCQZE54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"YouTube just showed me this exactly a year later! Do/will you have a follow up?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCB_mETh9246vMzS-eV46V1g","author":"@hairyneil","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nooNRiE1AqBeLkXYySzdp70dd6QfaDftiN37gpIfNRDQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hairyneil","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzKKNuYZ7aM8KCsc8d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What do these frequencies do to the nutrient water and resident microbes?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCg3XFgaYazzDW33yKEVEvxA","author":"@andrerodon3921","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kTnysc3OaGfpluwHAtdbUqty8w0A_CLauIeN3do2aDkilG=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andrerodon3921","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJKgD7WygDqsygb7h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"perhaps it's a matter of moving the air around them, thus fostering the development of an environment able to more readily resupply CO2 (and other things like water vapor or other airborn compounds the plants may consume) to the plants?\n\nto test this, calculate the volume of air moved in the area by a given frequency over a given period of time (e.g. 1 second). then, put together a setup in which a fan moving that same volume of air (all other conditions, such as the chemical makeup of the air, assumed to be the same) replaces the speaker, and see how they compare. ideally such a setup would allow verifiable cycling of \"used\" air through a system which essentially pumps a certain volume of \"fresh\" (i.e. initial conditions) air in one end and the \"stale\" (after plant respiration) air goes out of the other end, perhaps setting it up so that the fan/speaker blows from the inlet to the outlet, so that the pump is entirely powered by either the fan or the speaker. perhaps the volume of air traveling through at any given moment may be calculated as well via monitoring and moderation of air velocity at the inlet and outlet?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-Xnun9CNoc21HKnaZQM6dQ","author":"@briannadurso","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/gu9OE1T3y3_pfx2P3XTVCJnHlrS9w8OxVN2u1D_Hoamu0VdlA7LHA5nBST4cTEx_fMgk_nStCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@briannadurso","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxeiQ3gdjPOki5Jskd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Heard somethin like this b4..was oil spill somewhere an ppl went in and played music or sounds of ...don't quote me but like at 540hertz? Some # like that, pretty fascinating🤔","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwX51zgFHIHPJwKRSHX3zag","author":"@AbominationOfDesolations","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/u132Q48tLMhi4VF7RuT5I1-tkQlf90PX68k_h-zwh5d1rIYlsIyVt4Jud_41hZVUiJlyfZryWg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AbominationOfDesolations","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhsaKL9Gc8vQjEJxR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I was thinking maybe it's just the mechanical movement of the air? Like, at 4kHz, the displacment is 6nm, which is about the spacing of two CO2 molecules at standard conditions. CO2 is the limiting factor for growth in many situations, why they add CO2 into greenhouses, so anything that improved the ability to exchange CO2 would allow the plant to grow faster.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5sEkp8w5n94iSCGgcnhq4Q","author":"@jluke168","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m2jLwK8plf063aEEP9lrMVMRDnTGxANy8ZHoIsWIQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jluke168","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzHem3POFb9DFURCVd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I know that different temperatures of air have different densities and that sounds propagates differently through these differences. I wonder if the plants can detect the seasons or best time of year for highest growth possibility by noticing the differences in the propagation of sound through the less dense and more dense air of the different seasons. Someone should test this IMO. 😊","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCi1ebzQkir9LgODOnDFA_cw","author":"@justinh8810","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ktOQgjBDjaCeI998xnZgE6KFbUwH-HnJTQtUBOgz4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@justinh8810","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwzMFFOmIgeITrb9QN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I play music to my cannabis plants and they are gigantic!! 💪🏼","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaPa__gt2BHAPvvW2s2_Mrw","author":"@shredct3118","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kRChv9IiO7QZUJ7bFXGwsHwT9xu8V64EARoz4ItZE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shredct3118","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwEDTkOFVLuvgNq-oN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're the man.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdR2zVrR0BdOx8xdNkA-WJA","author":"@IntuitiveAndExhaustive","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/p6oVXLf7T4eEhnYcmo8ODP0_riR8IJmfQ2ufc6CuiKzHlNKTohWVkUU-dzV-JUr67HBOADsZrg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IntuitiveAndExhaustive","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysHutOT8WljMv_8Ox4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"if you put a few little speakers with solar into a wheat field somewhere during growing season - playing different kinds of song, white noise or just silence, i'd expect you'd see some circular results, easily. \nThis is a less than $1000 experiment that takes a few weeks and should prove easily observeable","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC28wgz82V5EMxPwuTmnsAlw","author":"@Maric18","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_keCzw7z1cesDwbAPfTsYlHYsqAwoTieDDWs01Br8mSlQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Maric18","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxHfqumSmRxO07f-QB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3. these frequencies signals the presence of pollinators, which are beneficial to the plant...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxxeErqY1iBTrTbpP8X92vw","author":"@Quoimais","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mnql_c1ghwBXEii21jp9VEounkCqODXBzzZUTPbAE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Quoimais","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzgRV_NOihPZ5g6Cd14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Im still studying biology constantly but from what I know and have seen in my own garden Gravity resistance sounds like the most probable cause for sound to effect it imo.\n\nCertian subaquatic plants can be terrestrial but then need gradual reintroduction from water to air because they dont have the correct cell structures for that much gravity out of water","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4W0yLmVRECCLARFldltVLg","author":"@silas7003","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kaOkXbAlblm_fo_mLkzhKdEfpfh73Zy_k4v-1JuIOg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@silas7003","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwIbOXV4Uh1_FgyOet4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you enjoy that level of rabbit hole you might really like mycology (SO many things to min-max)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwSoJRqV4pxZjoNxsXBUx1Q","author":"@autismgirlie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9A68bTj4claAsdRtWlMcV2GDxXbjmwbyUZ2tyXzwnTAwDZ3JG8nhXOrGQctTOf511GDUYb0Ykw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@autismgirlie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxXwAIfBoekou-v5Bp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"18:03 Amen","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3rSV7swcToCF6nbRtQdAvQ","author":"@LevyBytes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/u1Vx8VzG0QJS8qJFxiK4O6V4148xP5yvF5VKoU17j8D2cf2KmmpUxsiDIonA3CEvKD9zUVAgiQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LevyBytes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZpyiRUaIH15gZ6al4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"you know, from memory in japan once you have your name on enough papers you can apply for a PHD without having to go through formal education...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaBjSkgOXgt8j5iagYzLVng","author":"@pykey101","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k22tHogw6ZVlFAvxodn9jIIihaWyjhOplJk-sPx4I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pykey101","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw60AoHKZUUmhVeAat4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It makes sense that in nature plants wouldn't survive in places with complete silence, as there would be no birds to eat fruit and spread seeds, no wind to carry spores etc so plants in loud places would need to compete more for those things. Our gardening is just tricking plants into thinking they're in their ideal environment so playing music to plants makes them think there's heaps of activity around and they need to capitalise on the birds and wind around.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrhHVPeGPxrwXww6sPhqSHQ","author":"@ASC-n5r","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZFhl3RkqKxy3N6_iBd-5OFcZbO9NoiFADLMBqJ9OUF32QRCwB0D12m7p46sjvNiZ4vfuEE87=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ASC-n5r","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzUQ0HMVo9IXCwekbZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I bet it has something to do with helping the roots penetrate through vibration.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX3UBwWhZjby4d99f24hWxw","author":"@Boredhammer2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DbsXfpfYaqYDXw339BD0VkAttiOiPdA9focDsk7C0p5CoKB-dlqwj3RXjKBLr-id6qxivVnuAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Boredhammer2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTg3q9k_Byr6syRbl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I play music in my greenhouse seems to help","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbr82BdghXHp7c16fzwcVMg","author":"@brandonlopez8413","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mso6jM1G9h1JikRLM3wTKjUSPtXOfDrk_Q9ahsTUxJNE5m=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@brandonlopez8413","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzdG_r3PkSmmn2Gc-V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did the speakers produce any extra temperature making the sound exposed plants “warmer?”       😮😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEa91Q-TE6NLR43FMyEOAiA","author":"@Kalpatarutree","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/nL-amlNsnGFIez6akYjv03va0Mi5X6mmpz2TkzDxtsKqjYCfZ2rClrpBlQ3T56Gaz8IWOY-kxQQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Kalpatarutree","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxZLzO9QpCIqRX9wft4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A theory : vibration helps spreading the beneficial fungi faster and easier around the plant roots, leading to a better and stronger immune system for the plant and to a faster system that can extract the minerals from the soil for the plant.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCm5ljCdfzfSaAWTW64WN3vg","author":"@HellSlider42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/eDHv1pjjV0N1E3CiBTl1YslaHtUendm0TvHnvc2Fk7VdPzrWzun4ii0ul7t2NikPWtIRf0Ho=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HellSlider42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxD8Db0B_5jtgjkgFB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wait till you realize scientist have never isolated one virus in history","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCm4Sl98v7NLJ49fYQkqTkQw","author":"@kevinhauser8250","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0wkTu1puinGAZYtX6F0j1l3j1LR9sTTRJNqIKpAFnoBbzxZUu_2DyOiqKb9NMR47OiBtsk7WFPg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kevinhauser8250","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgznZbijwDeJBQVZ4c14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think I'm in love","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcNaooO4noAoO2ycJk57bTQ","author":"@DeeBzar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3fJN2mc3v3yG4tEOR_iQGCA9hmk4s75yzZjvfkGkbyD7Ql0hqG8I4tf74Ex8W8iCKo49yetLxQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DeeBzar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxm08Jk_zKAkFtT3Mh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"me running to altitude video ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT8eQjqTQh9dKfLLuv_uGdg","author":"@AlexWolfLikesPie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYRU00UDiEtgF-BrxJDuIrvgbh5JkVQv15oWY4G5K2sPBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexWolfLikesPie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgywYRQuzg2rtxhVmjl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"acoustic levitation by devin the dude is a really good song","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCeor-lWaMwGvlLUZWOaq9-A","author":"@moonjuicedmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GcepAFNlelqwHxWTbbXVRIopf-u0B8lzoJCCaANxqHJ8zGCoKjCTGMhDeww_sEbZKUNq8o4OtvY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@moonjuicedmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxRsxNGeVB9kpxtL_R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if you added a fan to the experiment? The frequencies of sound and the push of wind would vibrate the plant in such a way as to cause an increase in biomass. Therefore, we cannot fully determine if it is a response entirely to the sound or the physical stimuli or if it’s both. If both, to what degree?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoGiND5vpOeRTgBfzq-oeFw","author":"@Originetics","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bvRlnANZlhM3cKIsC4hTgre16ClTucip1LaLnHfMPL-q4VH5LHh81O1jC8HwfqMNzYkwxFlW=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Originetics","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgylHc3vOas4o4NMruJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How about a test with sound, no sound and a fan set on low. The movement of the chloroplasts is what helps the plant grow","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJ195NHGVzmemGV4pLm2lEg","author":"@MrScandinavio","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llo1k49sOx_8fk2NCYMbyKw5oDRpDsdub_IAnh1hamno0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrScandinavio","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyM7_lETsV6G4PZB9N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A speaker emits a few watts of energy. Are you compensating for the slightly higher temperature resulting from adding that energy to the chamber?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCadfsN5nLDO8oDGCOiUr2uw","author":"@axelliljencrantz4462","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_no6jYmg0X3dB-M2Bei0Ddu2ckmyfN22TBMTQPjMNyqaNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@axelliljencrantz4462","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFeolgTVxjnm89X1l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Look, I was related to the old drunken farmer talking to his plants and cows from the porch at night and I don't think anyone was interested in trying to talk him out of it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOutTzO5Ag-safMD7Xrqo0g","author":"@Name-ot3xw","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nnRPNCpFxkWN13DovDPs1Iejr3mlOFlN4EGr1iacYGtWY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Name-ot3xw","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwoVJLWUvpSFpQRLj14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I play music for my plants and they love it 🥰 specially my little mushrooms ❤😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgAPLkXrKS9GDEBpYFu1xAw","author":"@Arlet11369","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/64t88ezp1qXxUyMHCdPdEkqF-YLINjfUXwL31GZepaR8bmJxIMaw6V4LYEV8k0p3nMzxDoj6fw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Arlet11369","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWS8Pu8sHzoNm5Dql4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Could the music vibration make the plant go on sort of a survival mode thus growing faster?? Like how certain animals’ reproductive systems get effected by their environment(harsh environment=mature and mate earlier to ensure some offspring survive in case conditions worsen/die before reproducing in the first place)\n\nI don’t think plants can differentiate sounds that much so as far as they’re concerned, music vibrations might be similar to what bugs/animals that eat them","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzBYGCSgS86f4yi7Ryll1Uw","author":"@SSSSSS-lq2zz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_liynCmGQZxwI3ZPYji4Qa_Q08WYuYduKBI9QBk9yY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SSSSSS-lq2zz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyd-yV8aW_cprrx-AF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"That was a very weird to interpret Godels theorem as \"everything is stohastic\". It just says that in math there are facts that are true but cannot be proven to be true.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCmKhTrD0_V572QBzO5hT63g","author":"@darelblack4666","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mYtrHCFlLGrbbPiYFxLBUHipBmZ42bVik7bjPrlwev58s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@darelblack4666","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyd-yV8aW_cprrx-AF4AaABAg.AJmyZZqI0t3ALDT9We_6pV","parent":"Ugyd-yV8aW_cprrx-AF4AaABAg","text":"If it can't be proven to be true, on what basis can we assert it's factuality? I'm not disagreeing, just curious.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCroBxfXgLZF8_YtEZMIJtsQ","author":"@MrF_oaf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k18TQOefWzLa5SvdJmEE0dDZLfk4am4CaTqv-UUpCP4ll3lucs6Ttsxlbnh6UOy4Y8dw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrF_oaf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzP10-0dR-xpUaETfJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I found out that cannabis absolutely goes nuts for man is the bastard noise \"music\", no joke, the plants would twitch to it and the buds form earlier and denser than without music (also cannabis hates regea, I know that seems wrong, but I've tried and I've seen lol)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrAO-ZXN9JU6_qJUoQUV1gw","author":"@iantalmadge","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-RpKICXOnCI8-j6Z1wIMZULUp4lgbhDKqWx9A1viwcwLzCsOLhSBOoBTc0JxyNPEZeFsS-Fb0lc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@iantalmadge","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxXxyW_FmVEHmJYF7t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if in a similar way that massaging/stimulating muscle fibers increases blood flow and makes them grow larger and stronger, sound is stimulating the plant fibers allowing better internal flow which allows them to grow larger and stronger?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUVut_6n4FA6ZsGOAqgXWsg","author":"@shakeyoulikehaiti","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZ7X0PSmxMMWM7f202mMW5lg8dqdQlvoqreNFlo-1KhUA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shakeyoulikehaiti","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh8dAdMVGy2WpiUat4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It’s frequencies, or the electrical charges in the air that helps them grow. Also by grounding the potted soil to the actual earth helps. There’s also some science of running a small electrical charge through the soil, and having a ground or negative at the top of the plant stimulates more nutrient uptake and 30% more growth. I tried both on marijuana, and the small miliAmp electrical charge through the stem to the top definitely produced better, compared to the one that was traditionally grown. Both were in soil.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUbywsEBJ7tY89ADKYtNb8Q","author":"@MrLegalizeplease","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kTHM5x8Hjun58jR1fEA64LYW8nKTXpnWYV4bA6dVY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrLegalizeplease","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyZrjof05Hl7x-VSSx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Okay now lets do this again, but with worm compost bins. Play certain frequencies for the worms as they create castings then grow a plant with the castings and one without the sound treated castings 😬😬😬😬😬😬😬","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJ7yJInkBVyiKfNMPPoWuQA","author":"@JadetheGoober","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QHMmHFDJEy-YyDkHV2seAtpdZhTLDUZ_ksI5pTq4wfVtt8CjuwvWN8rU_ULXQ5F39uVg45jaMw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JadetheGoober","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy_k7zdH_R-bx4FDTx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I would argue that we have much of our modern technology thanks to someone who by modern standards might be called a \"cit scientist.\" Michael Faraday was a commoner, son of a blacksmith who apprenticed as a book binder. He did not have a formal math education. But worked hard to be accepted into Davies' lab (and thus noble scientific circles). By experimentation and careful note taking alone, he teased out the structure of electromagnetism. Maxwell (and Heaviside) later used his notes to formalize EM into the famous equations we have today.\n\nIf Faraday had not made that leap into academic acceptance, the industrial revolution may have happened much later.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCK3RY0tyxDvBWd9MBGCUfIg","author":"@electronsarerad8243","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0jBHa_UJyfjTjaqsfwM1vIs1DJKTxtmGcvBITmCpk_0xhAzBTHOYb0DjSWk3-SFfAPjB3dPEPA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@electronsarerad8243","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyfNnjKUeE9eIn7zc54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The comment section of this video essentially contains a peer review and dissertation on this experiment, and I love how nerdy it is.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUKQH4ZDRFPR6kqRwDyY6Vg","author":"@Dreamheartcat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lBha2moZ3XEuYR-6GNElJ-IS5FG9BjGrk6wnIXwDlfqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dreamheartcat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzsfar_h50ZbfzIcAJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How about the sound waves are moving air molecules round the plants leaves and enhancing diffusion of gasses through stomata etc and this increases rate of transpiration thus influencing growth ?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC53Ga62uESm76C6gZLXRymw","author":"@charlielamb2314","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/umqBBtj2E23BDSNd-vA-ET4hQui14URFrfwvmOpwTVparwNehmyt1wJNEXoXRx7alEt2OKWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charlielamb2314","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx8xGfzqn9Y1qJE-Ul4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wind helps to grow stronger plants. The music one seems to move move :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTub9FQjCL6eoKNmm1S_WTQ","author":"@MrHardzio4Fun","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mm8YM3bAktXeKumFs6GJLfXUliQdmysH2-VDT4VCQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrHardzio4Fun","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxE67NJexiL1xYF9-J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Cell production relies on alignments in space for growth, sound as music agitates the cells enough to increase chance of alignment.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmtrdm-torGExkVzUgWzNLg","author":"@bradkemble","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-fV59xItBW7DyToXmrZLLs6rHnj9AvESHGYlp1GFQYfpUuPHKiy4p0KlLh8R5MGo5w_yZQ_OZAQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bradkemble","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7z1C1yMxCjPs-abR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think your line of thought of choosing the soundwaves was based on \"easing\" the growth of the plant (I have no idea how acoustic levitation works) but maybe the result would be different if you slightly bothered the plant instead of trying to help her, maybe try some different song genres, or frequencies, I think plants tend to grow better when there's some disturbances\nThink based on voices in my head and gardening","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyXa1_4jGxAqLbkFTuDTPOg","author":"@oniria4ndth3v01d","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yfhD1IrvXuJ7sNOVI7K6FC8A32ANCGtpZleiibfEqISo_-Vzn-4Xt0OaVz2VjOmRBk_HF9PD=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oniria4ndth3v01d","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyExkZtut0u4OpS37d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Theoretically it could also be from the sound waves impact on the CO2 density consistency. Almost like repeatedly pulling vaccume and releasing it. Or the vibrations could be increasing the surface area of the water in the trey increasing the efficiency of its evaporation. Maybe both. Idfk but it seems logical with the information I've accumulated from this video and the everest video.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCklqdIDOCseoxJZFATHgsNw","author":"@GeorgeRipkey","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/H6qKsofan0Q2cX4B2AFAR44ieOP7iAsA5qnTZhbbj40ZtcOsR6JZTpCG_6KP0mVn-S9PyL13=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GeorgeRipkey","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9xACHzx0hsArOMFB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"this explains why I couldn't stand hearing led during my childhood","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuW0ngvm1cdxwn6e2IZgC2A","author":"@UntouchablePlayers","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m-VdmajTMuNKZTt2acXMVqoUKR6T2-TyGR9GPk_MV0cQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@UntouchablePlayers","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhT6dFxjDCZoI_EvJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"11:27 4. It stimulates light wind maybe?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQR60lRZtZwSZN_neapZtLQ","author":"@Xaymar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/PDTuO3Q4DUgAmQfLUJdpdKIQx6lFHVTdPjBtPam2kt8uXdAXhqgkTFvlyFgznuMph28cCanN=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Xaymar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugytr6fPa8NwFB8C1Rl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"did you try putting the speakers centered on the top shelf? wondering if your CO2 distribution was uniform as well","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgTHyHO5UEYE03Wx6zk2fqA","author":"@rre9121","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mjtBu7bfeLwwmeAVk4lqNgaCRO0pzRzYjY4ac2C8g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rre9121","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzunXMoThH4dPfwBkd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What’s the chance that the sound waves cause increased airflow(?) or circulation of air around the plant, mixing the air to help with o2 hotspots that might form around the plant in otherwise stationary air?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNpcOO-d-X0PhdKWuj_EMXQ","author":"@wolfiesgaming5216","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ny_mJiSkrvXwVl0sexnrH36RXshtsclH2061_ouDeL9g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wolfiesgaming5216","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2CZQExyE1OsB2LcF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i love your chickens","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT8eQjqTQh9dKfLLuv_uGdg","author":"@AlexWolfLikesPie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYRU00UDiEtgF-BrxJDuIrvgbh5JkVQv15oWY4G5K2sPBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexWolfLikesPie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx5VSvB_g6baNqk5x94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I could imagine that the sounds help to carry away the oxygen from the leaves, thus helping the plants intake more CO2","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdj9787cshAuY7GhvZGm9Ng","author":"@checkm8606","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/uXwJK3TgFzjybrFzwhth4FxRv2wqRT31uoymkFbVQgMc2kW-A3mNMBatgAarwwwFNZ-RX6Wh=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@checkm8606","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyjJq3phcA9cztDne14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"One thing I noticed about your setup that is not mentioned below is the permanent magnets in your speakers.  I have verified for myself that facing the South pole of a strong magnet towards the plant  increases my plant growth.  I tried it after seeing that others have done this.  Perhaps using speakers that use a field coil transformer instead of permanent magnets wold eliminate this variable.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiZlxqFPOVIk8WDbI8mCSUw","author":"@OverUnity7734","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nMr1HQcPny-lilPS6ZNjKoz9T_81h6CwoHcbeUbqvsNeE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@OverUnity7734","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyuG83xyM1Dk4HCkJR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You went to the school of hard knocks","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPh8k8VK0VjhQS1lhrt5Gmw","author":"@drewgoodwin9631","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mfhIqY6NahHac8CBcMlKahh2bbq6FkPK8Guj9MnXz74sM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drewgoodwin9631","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyctQkjlRMqIT0sGwt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I would guess as you hypothesised the sound waves invoke an evolutionary response to the stimuli causing increased growth or that the sound waves increase cellular activity somehow as you hypothesised as well or that the sound waves create microtears in the plant matter allowing for faster growth (but this is probably bogus as regular wind would do that too) or that the sound waves allow the rate of gas exchange to accelerate by exciting localised air particles or something \n\nIt'd be a good idea to monitor the air concentration and take samples under microscope to see if there's a noticable alteration in their formation, ideally you would use seed clones instead etc but hey we make do.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCacQgU8KTUY-UCWbhZ6Lasw","author":"@Betweoxwitegan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/D65jcIJ0A-Gufu0QkF-CtBwRUR37H9TyRcnTmgWL3vKh6TG_v8Ng4_0oB7rK86gFXiMxmQwPBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Betweoxwitegan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyctQkjlRMqIT0sGwt4AaABAg.AJbZfJvaSiFAKEG0oZM56_","parent":"UgyctQkjlRMqIT0sGwt4AaABAg","text":"I asked Mistral (European version of chatGPT); \"Do vibrations have an effect on photochemical oxidation, or the chemical evolution of gases and particles in the air?\"\n\n\n   \"Molecular Activation: Vibrations can provide the necessary energy to activate molecules, making them more reactive. This can enhance the rate of photochemical reactions by promoting the formation of reactive intermediates.\n\n    Photochemical Reactions: In photochemical reactions, light absorption can lead to electronic excitation, which is often followed by vibrational relaxation. Vibrations can influence the efficiency of these processes by affecting the distribution of energy within the molecule.\n\n    Particle Formation and Growth: Vibrations can affect the nucleation and growth of particles in the air. For example, mechanical vibrations can enhance the collision rates between particles, leading to increased coagulation and growth.\n\n    Mass Transfer: Vibrations can enhance mass transfer rates in gaseous mixtures, which can influence the rate at which reactants come into contact with each other and thus affect the overall reaction rate.\n\n    Catalytic Effects: In some cases, vibrations can have catalytic effects, lowering the activation energy required for certain reactions to proceed. This can be particularly relevant in heterogeneous reactions involving surfaces.\n\n    Resonance Effects: Specific vibrational frequencies can resonate with certain molecular bonds, leading to enhanced reactivity or selective bond breaking. This can be particularly important in photochemical processes where specific wavelengths of light are involved.\"\n\n\"In summary, vibrations at the molecular level can significantly influence photochemical oxidation and the chemical evolution of gases and particles in the air. These effects are crucial for understanding and mitigating air pollution and its impact on climate and health.\"\n                                              __________________________________________________________\n If the effects the vibrations have on the air, is playing a role, then surely the chemical composition of the air, the light, and all the other variables that affect the chemistry of the air, would need to be controlled?\n The possibility of creating an atmosphere favourable or unfavourable to the effects of the vibrations, becomes evident and needs to be controlled.\n There is also the possibility that in the controlled environment, the real world negative effects that are mitigated by the vibrations, are not present. In other words, the vibrations may be decreasing a negative effect, as apposed to increasing a positive one, which is often misinterpreted, when improvements are observed.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC90NzRlCLqKZ9dvrwIpdg-Q","author":"@robinhood4640","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l-gMrTUr0QAjIzpF9uZNs2Td_RntWRl1Nt1Vjc8vaQXg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robinhood4640","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-fEn0X61ioBSfBUx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about a fan as a comparator","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXpNMOetW6f2bvbM4oC6HQA","author":"@das250250","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m5z3S4ApwL0S2T4K21LUaZqlLdLNUaZQw6UnVl_aS5gWI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@das250250","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyL0p1NB04Ban4Izy54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hello.\nPerhaps, what written in the \"Mysticism of sound\" will open up more understanding. It's also about who plays music for plants and with what mood. Play an experiment (like a child's game without expectations) or wait for result.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWdzCk_F7ksv0FR1yPgH4jA","author":"@andreywhoplaysthatcharminmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/crsJ2oPaTggnpAFtDc8S_Dh-lV5F92_nQLLs8RFp7OGzph2G6de25CyutQJprV3tQJZtZ5DETw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andreywhoplaysthatcharminmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxN44iH1er0V3XT4454AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Credentialism has a limited future anyway. Is it bad that hearing about your arrest inspired me to finally subscribe?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCY-up4fyxYZ8j1Rlxw8Fy6A","author":"@KeenBeanPlayzGames","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/27i8NzAGUS1TEumXZzAgMPhIAbGoyDkqJsB3ASdCJHUUxg5GWsw_zU1TqBT57DzDEGcH99Wq=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KeenBeanPlayzGames","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9tT6mLi_XaN5xJk14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Could it be helping with the capilary action of the plant vessels? \nOr make the \"sap\" easier to flow like using vibration to liquify sand?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn2zYv_lmEaCKUaXZ4TnBTA","author":"@TJPDmember","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mbH3SzMMPsZjT1ITBEOR6oUXDnoAd_blP0oKVRakfWQw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TJPDmember","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwibT9yWraD4iY18hN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"the music may be effect the water structure. look at Masaru Emoto's work on water crystals.  He also found some music made beautiful structured crystals others made distorted crystals.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2zSdjUFT9bMuQDq-hwGsfA","author":"@infiniteflow8853","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fTlYZJvXsgf3zgRzzZC7Furs5-J7GLmJOJih0tqNmd744-KqTDWVkyoiZmsn_kKoQuzMDCZr_A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@infiniteflow8853","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzOWHfX8bTnlDtIQ9d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about electrocultrue or exposing seeds to a south facing magnetic pole during germination?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbO8rIaK_QVOfr5bms4YjEg","author":"@secretvoiceunlocked","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lCRXNeKiz9AFIaW5BsxEsnOxDqGipjZUV7gL1AjUVHoD6z0SvKCjTFUGPKCbcymbELIQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@secretvoiceunlocked","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxEtncYxRfjgV7CeKx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey, his little pedantic brain man is even stronger than mine, must be tiring.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyZtJ2Ak803yIiZkm3AcvDw","author":"@danser_theplayer01","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kCpMdBOq1QLD-HtC2Pr6joMxqFWJRkAlREHAN42M_kyTg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danser_theplayer01","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzd7N-qBvGzcCf51j94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if you just got a vibration motor attached to the base of the planter and test that instead?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiw2MXpApwFJ_QQ85NyxYRg","author":"@TheDrWes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nrvFD4oqpb4BiQ6s_ykVbq-ieSDOqdNg-uhLmzveRZHHTj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheDrWes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbAMl89XZej0AHgBF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm curious how you controlled for the varying light intensity across the footprint? It's always going to be higher toward, and around the center due to the multi point source. Seems a big potential flaw.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCV2M-WMZI7qxuzYtMjmikXw","author":"@TimTimTomTom","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYR-AVUnHuZ43omxlBDTjrRIe6NK_hpHGbLOMMh36VIAY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TimTimTomTom","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2io8gvN7yDZSEsf14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Try phish in an aquaponics greenhouse","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0oD3DhTSE3dpw-IVPrtnoA","author":"@ProudGoys","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kWs6MD0bSk1KdmkOUxJW6iMA_nWBCZ2RLISTc023pUH-y7G0XJUN9DGZy6oFjSPt-GnA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ProudGoys","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyjlL_9XCEdIGya_wN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi Benn, I was watching your video and I had another theory that might cause the increase in growth. Maybe the pressure waves allow more oxygen to move around the roots and increase the oxygen uptake for root growth in some way?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcB_Sw1IDEF08CRx4OhcEAw","author":"@Harige_Harry","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x70a8PwRbXl2PKGXbiQAOQqxMjZDOpQ4rcQMuQM79DonIqbQ3AEAKHaDcqUgVVtDR5-SnHmr9LQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Harige_Harry","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxdtqq--W30w184efp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Heat rises and humidity. The plants on top may have been warmer causing them to grow faster.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC__zv_uw0oIUaFQfAXp7ruA","author":"@cobovideo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mgE5GpmkNIH38dc_M3Tw9UmeeeaqEAmCKqCWTxdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cobovideo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJAQolULuQxTKMZ2N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"No True Binaries\" has been a phrase I've said a lot over the last 15 years and something I keep attempting to write a post on but never truly getting to something I felt good about.... ironically","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZot_wN_CZdV6R8P9HgliuA","author":"@Locane256","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mOnxduIcnRXjCU8c8VxMNrw5Wlxo1QuRs0dOmlAQt6bg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Locane256","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFYIpUfTw47s3iNH14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Electro-horticulurists determined that anything that mobilizes nutrient ions in the soil increases growth.  Sounds and electrical current can cause ions to be more bio available to the roots.  There really isn’t much movement under the ground under normal conditions.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHZMDOHL6M_Mc7rbT8TeP1Q","author":"@atari7001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxjBRrFQFABP-bJ7Q__gmJGI8F4br6E5VZrtR91jw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@atari7001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymhqPCuA6UfZHJCKl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"well plants get stronger when there is wind right? because the swaying strengthens the stem and the bonds of the plant, sort of like plant exercise. well, Sound is vibration, on a cellular level sound and the wind are the same thing just different frequencies, i suspect this is why there is also similar boosts due to magnetic and electric fields near plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCG7eawhsnBnDcYSgmTQI2Mw","author":"@NogrimStoneson","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mtxldbS3R9fBO-nsDM_O5HWDm_d0atGHlzcJKBpu8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NogrimStoneson","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDmoOSJil2JMDsUTF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants are material and they grow upwards against gravity. Adding a sight vibration will obviously lessen the push upwards, purly in a physics perspective. Adding sound vibration could maybe be comparable with the ease of lifting something heavy under water, completely diffrent but, its the only comparison i can make. It makes sense to me at the very least.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOXqRbCUtAEtSu1frDvwsXw","author":"@TheLostODST","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bSSRADRRGy2ty5klEbyrxTgsGjeuhBia4K4C0qMODL6f3f03RUEFkA3zwj0Pl5iXUP8826x-MI0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheLostODST","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwszkFw2n5DCY6eh-14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i love your videos! what about the fact that the plants are growing on different days? i know their environment is \"controlled\" - but they do still exist in our galaxy of neutrinos and etc. what if- just what if - that is another factor affecting growth?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGk3xY0kp_F2EyV0owOZIeg","author":"@firebirdR","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9zi_nHRBXVyzx8eSam2BBGskGm0XR-nzcLt-Vdx8kCVdQZ_LzQzsGARf7AzWk1oO-HAY2xdlaQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@firebirdR","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQSzUMoHEWquGorwN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is constant light a good idea?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC43sRL7IF7QJo1c2KArJ2eg","author":"@tutacat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTrrHNGPRIMVPlGVJWJRUZyPKZgYzMHAYeE5q4nDRgYMMh1I483VD9E0r_pf3-S3k_iQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tutacat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyg8dERs5jqnAX47OJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:30 set theory is the most basal math","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCo_SqZtkmjDrnGjUVV6RAEA","author":"@TreesPlease42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RegxOjPM-aUY2ECMcLxK8N9O2vkTbIVAi5x4_BLV_6zQdauhOD9UbhiVEjbBVMPtxaBhwE0ipQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TreesPlease42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwx9JAWwm1XnqiCJcl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why is there not a decentralized peer review system?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4pisXIobn_AL1OQInS4rMQ","author":"@yelllwow","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/o2Q-qZJFLen9F1ddrPiOqol4ccXfkQtPhHHqw1TdV5hZTfXFF0TDr9MYaG6oz9ZZ0lHZ37C90Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yelllwow","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyT5Z_6TVFwtdBoHct4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Please try this experiment with beehives and the acoustics of it and how the tones affect the bees like can you make them breed more or gather more honey. 🐝🍯 \nI would love to collab and you can use my bees and hives. ❤\n🤔 I also want to try an experiment by gathering the 2 Watt/Day triboelectric charge that they create within the hive from the friction of them brushing against each other and using that static & a small Solar for supplementals/Microcontroller setup to modulate the analog pulse as an IPM for Varroa Mites, using the Beeswax and other conductive & non-conductive materials to collect the electrons from & discharge enough voltage to the bees to kill it paralyze the mites, but not enough to harm the bees (possible due to their scale differences).\nWe could save the honey bees & give society a way to use them to generate electricity! 😁","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDFJvUg7GrBT_b47K-M10Vg","author":"@ogradus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lMSaJNTeZSB0PwzLIpiidOpwt_iHM1GcOSXS8Y-Ec=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ogradus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwGmP1pIdc_1uK16Z14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wonder if results might vary according Phylum, Class, Order, Family, Genus, and Species or in other words would different types of plants produce different results and responses?  Maybe some types do and some don’t.  Maybe some are more sensitive or picky than others.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC30_Kw-60w8gJO45SgvGHDw","author":"@nathenewendzel7806","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k1LWy2-ZaCt94WtaY4PUNFE_nUp-XVIvsg9jCs2tC1GNY_tKwPcAude-AKcSa6CckaqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nathenewendzel7806","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwfHqWFkoeWH-QoALZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"That intro was absolutely UNHINGED. I fuggin' love it. If you have granular visibility on the metrics, I stopped watching at 0:30 to applaud the intro and will now finish watching/listening to the video","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcnETQOwI-5OyZ_5ADPmm1A","author":"@Josh-anotherone","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k26uOWOxouE6EUj_2Bpg6Y0TG7WjxZeRlcat4u4FA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Josh-anotherone","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzaA6ye7a_K2wifzVd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Would a shared reservoir in a circulating hydroponic system reduce variability in both water and grow medium?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-hxlzy7wxHYT1bvHKLpheg","author":"@artfulalias3984","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-wZCbMBGC4wU4gTjxKhLckqcHfPXvp0Xpvyt4bTtDtpGdopa2NbpEYrZnVfGG-j-ovxnWgf8SKc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@artfulalias3984","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwyW__CSN8hwm8Fw8t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"what if you try with already established plants like clones. maybe some type of grass or thyme and you graph the regrowth in length could get you more consistency maybe?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClOu8aNasHf_k3_QXQ360kQ","author":"@TheMixflow","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m5RrW1R4x84lwmiParJ-rVQESGQHRiHu8psT2wcgHZ09U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheMixflow","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz1mGoU76wb5WdOJsZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I remember mythbusters doing an episode on this. Looks like it was just noise. Death metal vs classical music didn't make a difference. There was an improvement with sound playing.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtV9jbuN8sGQRrHVXPD4P4g","author":"@jsonmedia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m3r9zQjdjIdCLOs_DZ_U_A_So6XHp2u6jbw0P7efA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jsonmedia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyeHM2VQvgmQ00VvLl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"plant music makes my weed grow bigger!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkg8EshovT7xSDmJAGGuzPw","author":"@GrowWithMeddie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/q_b7pIHY4cxeeNRevoDGWujusQRxh9dr1gzCqIzDY4B50V9HX-JI2mXYsKG1iKdpkfhP43Y3KA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GrowWithMeddie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwRbllrLQA8yfCR60B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"2:28 they really like classical and Indian ragas. 2:49 and now the plants no longer like classical. That was a fast 180 almost a Blink 182. Not saying anything bad, this is still an amazing video, and I know this was probably a mistake. It was just really funny.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFs1iHYNZVU1PiMP_FbRtEw","author":"@derrickcook1824","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_leJyhoGDk8UiqY0_ZO9ii-JpMjyeWKFibl4MqPLDccwFE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@derrickcook1824","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy2v4bqrYb3Y6sfmZt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"while not obvious, it seems intuitive to me that plants require external kinetic energy to grow.  \n\nWhile I can't explain why certain types of music make plants grow better than others, it makes sense that plants would grow more quickly, and ultimately larger and healthier when they are being vibrated ever so slightly by music.  If you replace the music with an industrial air blower, so long as its not enough to damage the plants, they will grow even larger and more quickly. \n\nPlants in nature are almost always exposed to constant motion from wind and the movements of things like animals passing through the area.   We remove those externalities when we perform a study like this, but they're known to be somewhat necessary to healthy plant growth.  \n\nIn a minute way I expect music replaces some of the requirement for kinetic energy that plants would naturally draw from their surroundings. \n\nThe \"volume\" if you like, of outdoors is usually quite a lot higher than indoors, even when you're very far from human activity. \n\nI would also suppose that some rare types of plants found in unusually quiet places don't benefit from music in the same fashion. \n\nI understand that plants get most of their energy through photosynthesis, but that's purely chemical energy in the form of sugar.  Compared to the amount of moving that plants do intentionally, the kinetic energy in the surrounding air is relatively abundant so it seems reasonable that complex organisms like plants would evolve ways to take advantage of that energy at a cellular level. \n\nOn a larger scale, we see plants doing exactly that when they take advantage of wind currents to spread their seeds.  \n\niana bonatist.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHqOloVvhTVrxCfblpbaD7A","author":"@SineN0mine3","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYw4ISc3KtNEi_Xy17PiHbllGrPNyLf6OzfbzFyRk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SineN0mine3","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyD0_G4wrKTxTv2Y_d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sonic fertilizer? I too, have heard of Drake","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWmAWuaUi5e6XfpyldlNYEQ","author":"@_..-.._..-.._","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/jgLWA3mOsVa3LXAWrdHA8rL4S3QhIBBzaKsja_2ZMLNkVZGdjKiKDla7b0paERLuUASuugYvETk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@_..-.._..-.._","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyx4BMSX0ffqwavTal4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"We have done an experiment before with binaural sounds (try to pass it as brain waves tho😂) on germination of the lentils. Weirdly it effected beta and alpha sounds made them faster the germinate they also grew like a giant. The one took gamma sounds were dwarfs smaller than control. This is not very sciency experiment tho since there wasnt double control(we didnt have time) and I have no idea why binaural sounds actually effected plants at all. Normally it effects humans because of the frequence difference between ears percieved differently in the brain but plants shouldnt have this. So the frequences were really close to each other with only a few number changes ,it shouldnt cause triple in size.\n\nAlso the ones who say pseudoscience is tripping we literrally have a fda approved depression and addiction treatment called tms. Basically it gives electromagnetic waves in certain frequencies to effect brain cells and it works. How  people think  sound and waves wont effect plants's cells are beyond me.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQe6NBHBYnxn5kUX7VU8e5g","author":"@exosproudmamabear558","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9f9pT0MzbBlOtkR0XZ3BItNfVzRJeRuSEH08hVZZEA_LcxUQZ7Qgunu8X-YKT5gMXkA65HynYw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@exosproudmamabear558","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwNgg_JT4Chp0xKhWF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i have been growing plants indoors for over 2 decades. the way you have the grow tent setup isn't correct to make a comparison between the two. you have the plants in the bottom half of the tent and the upper half of the tent. not only do the plants on the bottom receive more lumens from the system above, but it also has a higher concentration of CO2, better temperature, and air flow. the plants on the bottom will almost always outperform the plants on the top. the variables aren't isolated, although you made a good effort in doing so.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-CkfGVBedX-VRr9cWzM2PA","author":"@phraunquejames2431","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kknXXWsawz72F1dbchXutABv8UPSsfOtkQzuRuEQM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@phraunquejames2431","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzu-VD6VhapV099Wg14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"ask your local weed grower about it and you’ll find out that most growers play music to their plants","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuVSGwpB8y4k1bURvJH6ikQ","author":"@jaxsonrogie2816","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l400TfCWPl9McuVIZFKOu1RxYHHXxYp4bIIVRLHSIbXg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jaxsonrogie2816","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxwMW_xLQMk9NXQGXh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"4. Music carries energy that the plants harvested... :O I don´t knooow...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCP2QuwXBtJd9EBs5UPuK0Dw","author":"@DBLQ06","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nFtMCg0XqpiiRN0fflJA_OrFyC0Kmgy0QRI-8lXnM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DBLQ06","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwefHn0Zy96VOumPS94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Nobody is upside down on a spinning water ball aimlessly blasting through this \"infinite imaginary vacuum\" faster then the speed of sound. You only think this because you see it on TV and trained to not even question the absolute absurdity of \"outerspace\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpQDESYa8f9LEcOm2nf28CQ","author":"@jedijeff2070","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3Hn4srhvZA0QIKe6IZs9gpxJpfnIi1YQuB9tfP-c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jedijeff2070","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzELbHfzj9NSxIRsvN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Should have given some of the plants a placebo 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_BLQcHUjrsaqoLCaIj1V2g","author":"@Craig-777","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lI1k0KUIBKOo0wt4NQgHJnMK7SbUv97ZlXbrZfkAs34SkKlYK7zuPLVXfphO5DY1TsmrVWWxNt8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Craig-777","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2-3oOmZ4PidBAlnN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"makes me wonder how well something like a BirdXPeller would work\n105–110 db at 1 meter Frequency Range:\t3–5 kHz","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNss9wWXvs4yp_NesqFGlNQ","author":"@automaticgiant","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lLHr2un8Y4N5TOD0a4DWH5dasXak_ip0jp6_Hmo-kF-Ro=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@automaticgiant","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwZOGCnciTLUW-wtAB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I personally would try 12 hours per day sound. Give the plants some rest. Like daylight.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6H8p08X3F7NqNkgfMetZnw","author":"@billysgeo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pYPStuSX4i8LuOHb3szIB8Zo7H0K3vas3j1Q6rIKGYc5wPrg6vKOPLXf8ogvMNB315mMJODA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@billysgeo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwq6C3xhrEXSXaiF1V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Okay so here's some things. Animals in general and I imagine plants also suffer in almost all chemical and mechanical exposure, leads to adaptation.  That is to say that if something is in a regular state of excitation, it habituates to this and tends to reduce the expression of the response.  \n\nHave you considered a shifting tone. Perhaps between 3,800 to 4200 HZ Rather than a steady state 4kHZ  which, while I have no proof that plants adapt, plants do adapt. All organisms adapt to steady state excitation and stimuli.   \n\nJust a thought.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGWCFyNnCoA_RdcQ-Nvdkxg","author":"@Lorentz_Factor","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zjQoZnOI-sKf5-fsYwDK7fjdfMRgHBaWWd1swIai8Hm0ZZtnMJSfvZYAlFNZ_AY2lioYmrLp=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lorentz_Factor","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwzwljYF5SNxKoksiZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What happens if a plant is starved of almost all sound?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYm3WHjgmvc_79j33jaHNSA","author":"@ColorCodedBraille","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oBIsqOh2TehHO4vsuWfRnyNOKqlPhj4QczCBxUd7NEQ8gXZ7jed2ZnGnQCQg2D5aLrUaBvLK2uc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ColorCodedBraille","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwM2dj_D6o06mG6sjl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is so cool and I'm only at 3 minutes.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFs1iHYNZVU1PiMP_FbRtEw","author":"@derrickcook1824","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_leJyhoGDk8UiqY0_ZO9ii-JpMjyeWKFibl4MqPLDccwFE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@derrickcook1824","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyZBcVHYxdB7jkccQV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think it has something to do with the sound waves physically moving the plant. If you put a fan on one plant and not the other, the plant with the fan will grow stronger to battle the wind...?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvHMecKXPI4wc_1M_lwFCYg","author":"@jacobsteele2929","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nI8kBtbAVlUr9oZjcvM1Igrg5_SFhzdELgMzLHJDRAus0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jacobsteele2929","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyRvtphPhfJ3c_exH94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:48 I see what you did there","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZTlybz5VpoJr1-yJPp6B8Q","author":"@Tobio-DEV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ALHGBN_vgEya2zcVJKkH17rU-AvHwFhhoKtZfPlXzJjQN3hrwaYWQr0bZDgl1gH3Qv1MXACEIQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tobio-DEV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-Ya5e29Dar9Ud-3h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wouldnt you need clones from a mother plant ? Im not sure how Phenotypes differ from this crop but they sure differ a little bit at least","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbHONULcctW7AzT9z5cct8A","author":"@ZazaMast3r","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/73m4qx2rN8_eJ1aMeXz2duEktwrpNPQ9rh0KH1ft1cqQYtO55OKaksohCECOfeSdkjp4p23n=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ZazaMast3r","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwl3r0RLjieSSDQZFt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's been almost a year. How are your results going","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtOn3rUf6MZwlwTOwRhZA9Q","author":"@phenixblows","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oVEytYDttiq7HaXFShPtlrMyJJH8RC24dRWOFl2O5AdUOKvinOrR4kaSOUaOAddjl-hyvdHj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@phenixblows","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyEnxDoS2b8ZDpHPR94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What most of these experiments miss is the fan or wind.\n\nYou’d be surprised how much faster plants grow when you provide the right amount of wind pressure, along with some movement caused by that wind. First, test the effects of wind alone, and then test the sine wave along with the fan/wind.\n\nThere is already research showing that nearly all of these experiments are flawed. When plants receive the right amount of wind pressure and movement, adding sound makes no difference - they grow the same. However, if you grow them without any wind or movement, sound can help a little. The key is that they were missing natural movement and vibrations, which aid in nutrient translocation, as well as transpiration which is one of the most important factors of growth speed (nutrient intake and everything else)...\n\nTry it yourself!\nYou can find the optimal wind pressure for each plant online if you dig deep enough!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCz2a3Yx7lOAYYr2gv7BvXVQ","author":"@heavygruby8476","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kDVWTVor4oDMnrA8JSn1QfWKy679_pAFdisj868GXmAFhdW5SbK7lG9s-tsd8cKauiOQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@heavygruby8476","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFtdzLx4NDVyxcyU94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:48 😂 Laughing like a 14-year-old here 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrPQqHZej2mCs606nvxTaBQ","author":"@bmacpher","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l5Dth5y5936e938CxVjEz7ej8Kvmgw4aeMR77mnps=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bmacpher","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx_ADzhuHJquzmar8V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I thought it was understood that sound waves move fresh air through the plants cilia buffered stomata","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7noPKAu1l91hEQAWrlwXZg","author":"@andgoodyo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Gh_ZTZO2E4f0u8X5-YWwGcJYF5X8o3d8f1O-WlMcb2ZCFrNLRcCUGznXKAwe0V_0mzXU7Ko-HA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andgoodyo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPiKpsRmhQzoyQnS14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"These days I've seen scientists at least in sports science decide to publish their research on open platform where other scientists who actually understand the specific niche of the field can critique the paper and it supposedly produces much more effective process that the peer review was supposed to be. Prevents the publishing company from using the papers as practically free income since the work done to produce the study wasn't funded by them, the peer review is asked to be done as charity work and the results are still often paywalled even from academic schools. It's a crazy system and probably everyone except the publishers agree with that. Some publishers are even downright publishing nonsense because they don't care to investigate. And there's the fact that when you first hear something, it makes a memory marker that's more difficult to erase with a correction. And many publishers don't even bother to inform about corrections or removing a bad paper. And they don't really like publishing studies that have negative outcome like \"we found out that this thing doesn't do anything or doesn't cause this or that expected outcome\". So there's a big bias in the information that gets published in that sense as well. And the science communicators or people who talk about science without being quite educators cause the same problem to be worse regarding the first heard information. They often times don't care to correct their previously poorly researched shared information on paper that got pulled back for obvious reasons or they communicate on topics where they are not specialists, without consulting specialists and apparently without understanding the big picture before diving into individual studies.\n\nIt's also great to hear someone who dropped from high school speak so coherently and nuancedly about science and educating people, sparks my belief in humans again. Although I understood that you were by no means someone who wouldn't graduate just fine in different circumstances. Not that I thought formally academically educated people were exclusively reliable, we have great examples of corrupt or very corrupt people in the academics, just that I was starting to believe that only a portion of formally academically educated people were honest to themself and not too attached to things emotionally to be ready to change their mind if evidence implies so, just curious to find out. But the fact that someone bothers to dive so deep into things and keep their mind clear from not trying to form an absolute binary view of things to get a definitive answer, but instead keeping in mind that it's a spectrum and it's still useful. And demonstrating how you can continue to refine your ideas and experiment results trying to figure out what's actually happening, that getting better understanding is much more valuable than getting a result that satisfies your view of life or wishes or ideologies. I really liked the video, I've been frustrated myself with the method of confusion where if there's even a tiny hole in the knowledge, it supposedly means that suddenly anything goes and nothing can be known confidently enough to refute nonsense claims.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC66wyYlF3eWeZjgtRI0KkbA","author":"@Yupppi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_knqxmK9eoTbzhtJpcfDo12WXebeZ_ZAYGDNiYBZmwThg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Yupppi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0SzwrTHl6O05wBA14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You asked how sound might effect plant growth. \nIn biology class we learned the growing tips of plants have \"gravitropism\" \nThere are cells with starch particles that settle on the bottom.\n Where they settle I think Auxin is released causing more elongation on that side of the Cell.  \nSo if your plant gets bent to 45 degrees the low side of growing stem  cells elongate more than the high side causing it to bend upward. \nIf your vibrate the plant it might screw with the settling of the particles resulting in more auxin ( plant hormone) release. \nThat could cause more plant hormone release making them elongate more than they naturally would. \nIn light wind that could help a plant. In stronger wind it might be weak and blow over. \nThis is just an unproven untested possible reason. \nIt in no way justifies beliefs that plants enjoy music or \nthat \"nice\" lyrics or harsh lyrics matter to the plant.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTL0vt1FAD43C3IUc7Lr9bg","author":"@JohnSmith-fj3uf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l-KRFXrAw4erQU2IIGVsN0G7cUQroC4lvibxExJ7I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JohnSmith-fj3uf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzdLAv8FS5uYRK4BF94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Could you make a video about tinnitus?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3j_CQ9je4haQHm6CHdfNAg","author":"@meioterno","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xDUqKUjTGZBut-G9hJx28IFUU3H_JeVRRzWrAQZkyhxDg1uez72yxICbszy3j0fcmmdYOfwxgw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@meioterno","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYnlbDgR9e1JpnAUJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Needs to be a way to blind the experimenter so that they don't know whether they're administering the sound bath or the fert bath.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQ624dO-gYPpHn0AC3XGvmA","author":"@Renatus_Eruditus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-IhmRg9MozzpGI4Ch6tTSGPqeyuXJcykRoXcAKNrFfFV9D4GT1hjAyPxrCylvGsxrKPYW8e4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Renatus_Eruditus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx5fngaOLB9-nmXnPx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wouldn't say plants don't have emotions. It seems likely they may be quite different or perhaps less complicated layers than our own, but plants experience and express a change in behavior under stress and different environmental conditions. As someone who lives with pets, they certainly have emotions and stuff, but they seem to have less complexity and depth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCC_f4Am9cm6OdsJdYtaYY0g","author":"@diskord42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nl4ksNqULoetIVqmAg_NTBhsiYbiW0vp78ey5b1ClsNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@diskord42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyR3CLOofPuSZVA7MR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If plants respond to being moved/damaged by accelerating growth, then wouldn't vibrations do the same?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGfqLxKhMqOxhyMNKH_eu5A","author":"@theflexitech","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l7A7Ye5dM9b8P8y-HaLkqOJDoVn9Za6eK89iJxp6iziA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@theflexitech","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzk8DiOUJbQp0g4LDx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Were the seeds mixed between samples before planting or did they come from two bags, there could have been different storage conditions for both \n\n(I think i would accidentally commit such thing XD)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1lRzYDG04wJbyGvmR8Qs_A","author":"@pimbel8830","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ncEXn5UKFQbpI0UmnlcM85_SFjG1S-cyAAsILFn2M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pimbel8830","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw5q9ZLkBl-4nasvl14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants may have feelings. They react to stimulus in some similar to the human nervous system.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChtv0M9tsEtp7rXIyV9LBQg","author":"@IJH-Music","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XbAh6ktMMhsUMigev62fsGiLu5cyHGHvmqZVFn87ala7UHDpvtoSn3Y3j05OanDfjYbrIQd7=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IJH-Music","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyWJPdP_h5z-ShWCUh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"how did you exactly measure the biomass increase? just out of curiosity","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEDp_Wx1PwA2jT0mm2KohDQ","author":"@MatiR-Pumpkin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kAvXwKhF9W-758960a9XjLrXxvSdrZkX4XZl0vZ0CotMcCwuJe0HKveyMX8NMWQ9UFfw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MatiR-Pumpkin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw1RFU3NLiRBzMJ9-l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sonic Bloom","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCStNcze_TC9XdmO7lUXZyMg","author":"@matthewcook2664","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ky4cB7MLRAKg73DMo6X0qC9_EN94Zo9r1gJmnn-GQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@matthewcook2664","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxn2tZi0_D4PZWJLPB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"when update video coming out looking forward to it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzGCPotB4dRH_ngYMhvOwIA","author":"@okiepokie2700","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k-lK_3N-qUxDJUif4agvSOcUfMRdBDTeHnKY3riYM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@okiepokie2700","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBfElMsd_H0l1_wZl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sound is ENERGY","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9Jg0zsgjNxjltlFjE0YvNw","author":"@MattPowersSoil","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sIfxgQicoFGz57bD9V6FzV8FcOCSKnfRMCAykIphrxbWQfRWQ6nN07WVivhoX_7UZRBjFDSW=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MattPowersSoil","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwHJ8PJiRR2JunEXzp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If dolly the sheep had not been reproduced then it still wouldve been ample proof that it was possible (*very very highly likely to be)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCavE9UPp9bdoN7siH6n0LLg","author":"@samgrainger1554","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nR2JQGgROGRSxtmezcowfnLpswHWC4DdmqdlmbVA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@samgrainger1554","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzvKdwoWOOGiKA3aTp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"nah its the vibes bro. all biochemical interactions are facilitated by some good ole fuckin vibes. yw","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzqbJ8BIrYK2UxdnQcNM4RQ","author":"@BigDivhan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kQnWSAD6Gm3-wtlJwdGQ5jT55-cFBUBsNuleFX8xZm76T3ar1J01mTypF-cd73dN1eDg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BigDivhan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxNanGWkKbgn3AODtp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Do you have a water softener that removes calcium and magnesium?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUkxpPenkPUMj7Dk0k0jgNA","author":"@erickplaystation","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ncK4aRmT4W1P47tTfjq8KtgAxzfy1tGgX5-7RvbJUYxiQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@erickplaystation","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyd9qbKBOVS_pHUcGB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why do you break the seal on your siphon when you finish your boil for your coffee? I leave mine sealed till it's done pulling the coffee back down so I'm genuinely curious","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6p1I010CtqxzrUgrgbnHAA","author":"@zerohour5400","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kCg2sEG9tb5uDgHTyTnD-RTfUnCRfKfV1gzqFLjAK2Ww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zerohour5400","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyxfVjBgH4EQiUlBR14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Where’d ya get a microgram scale Ben… also there’s DEFINITELY “audio fertilizer” for humans at least!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-ruoFZHCEA0mO-E5xRNFsA","author":"@shainemaine1268","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mzbQXVsDwQccDUUbsv6tXGHI3C4c3UEszKqB4ppPU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shainemaine1268","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwWjaeSUhgQRUwMiTR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well, lived experience of people does suggest it may possible have an effect","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC43sRL7IF7QJo1c2KArJ2eg","author":"@tutacat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTrrHNGPRIMVPlGVJWJRUZyPKZgYzMHAYeE5q4nDRgYMMh1I483VD9E0r_pf3-S3k_iQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tutacat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwbKJIladt1qIiSr3R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did u change out the light at anypoint? I'm not aware of any light source that doesnt degrade over time","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvfHKrQ2jCgMfeSet5yqZnQ","author":"@eemonster","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNf2rR1TBB0Rwfb65pfwDOInXnL_Hh9TybJeah0R3AfH6v=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@eemonster","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxGHCuHjAruY9FNgVN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I need answers!\nwhat was the EC and pH of the water used\nwas there a difference in temperature between any experiments?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0g740vS5_8hr9pV-58fg7w","author":"@Sleepy_Dane","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Ek3vuugfCcZ8XouETi26zVGXXFLYES7s7uUTqP_uSOjTXCuiZq1yTIKNF0UUkez0JgUxc-0_5c8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sleepy_Dane","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwbXzfFNqz9D-LkpSl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don’t particularly like Classical music but my Tomato plants sure do!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8Zv9lWquFV5k9uH0vQuwig","author":"@bigboss-tl2xr","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nOvqISFUrp0S4djGXAgg5U_vz5GqkAfJWxy51rJgM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bigboss-tl2xr","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyeYXDXi1J9i9934_d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is there a correlation in plant growth/response between the sounds naturally occurring in nature (wind, ,rivers, bugs, birds) and the artificially produced noise? I read an article that most life on earth operates around 2 beats per min. Might be a connection there.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-vf_LwyQRZxH7baufLAf_g","author":"@netherbetter8745","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/UdKQxplCbZ3HQFb5HHZ8SfZoVFdwS9kRA2h6CnCC1C-gf8XnYZJZErWTfVlEOtovwtFJ6SwH=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@netherbetter8745","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyG4ueKsgkCmK7HwXF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So I’ve heard that plants actually do more of their growing at night, so did you expose plants to 22 hours of light and then two hours of dark every day or continual light or a nice even split 12 and 12?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6mWcQ8a5JwBGMZbdYynTuQ","author":"@SuperMacGuy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/o0zbJBZd7VuOFTMpqYUWL-VMOgjyZLcMFSVFuHao4ST44VJHhn4mJbfZlwS4QYglLd3Gg1mTWg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SuperMacGuy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw5LVk8uHxJB5hm6VN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"late to the party, but running fans in your grow room is important for replacing wind, maybe the frequencies in music act as a replacement for the frequencies in an outdoor environment?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgi3jtkkB75i1_ghGNq2CAg","author":"@a_man_not_a_number","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kz059mFK3ntC2oqwaGduNNc_TnPOrQenCq5S8rh6N7uYpdjB5n42JVtM-teetQVZFhYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@a_man_not_a_number","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGFTJqRoSbJBsoHTV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So city plants may grow more than rural plants? Noise vs quiet?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClHTAW201B2oDfNuYX9VWVw","author":"@StrugglingElectricalEngineer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kRdiwgGASa43GPYT-c3Z6MApteJOGOBXuLd7u6TpOt2CJm9iQ6p6u16RMmQYwe-Tke3g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@StrugglingElectricalEngineer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwRGHowpE2LQ5sk0694AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"@BennJordan hi, I have a question somewhat unrelated to this specific video, but I think you'd be a great person to ask.\n• I want to buy my first keyboard, enjoy synth and sampling greatly, but am on something of a budget preferably under $500, even $350. I'm overwhelmed, there's so much!\n• Is there anything available right now that you immediately think of that I could be able to buy new, or look out for on the used market, that would be a great starter instrument? I did play piano when I was young and want to get back into it!\n• Oh, I also played with Reason 4 a lot back in the early 2000s and it was incredibly fun to me running things through other things in my digital racks. Maybe an influential detail idk.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgNnh_yk1U49BcC4QQj_pxQ","author":"@ssaammhhaaiinn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sNy-Asj3t3tqGnfgptPyB7dQZ5NACNrtj06ffx8CdtR4TFsLWQkFN1l5cpodDxjuF-Cuc-R7ag=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ssaammhhaaiinn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw9YJ1EcLQ3hv-AALV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"could it be that the plants are stimulated by sound as an evolutionary technique to align with seed dispersing animals, such as birds. If a species who disperses the seeds of the plant are present in an area only during a specific period (or due to seasonal variation in diet or migration) once they have the right sounds indicating their seed carriers are there, they boost growth to benefit from their presence, increasing the likelihood of dispersing their seeds. (im an avian biologist) It is similar to how many plants can indicate via electrical fields to a bee whether they still have nectar available for them.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkzRDj5iDy2b1wL_ZyoNsVQ","author":"@bhawk01","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nzQEtKHdvKvpYCQvc5l75lVq4xiJ_lMOA72fYxeIgkHQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bhawk01","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxmv51_8sttCed4b494AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So...Sonic Bloom works?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCv5txx68az-EGI8gSDZMrcA","author":"@bartercoins","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iR_xn3BSo1jvu7HtIrKjN0VOVj8kMyYd9mtbyF1llPdtfLrwx4r0pnP8fAmo6hqtRhwg0zkNMJs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bartercoins","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyPm8LxvbcsTjyU--l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Resonating frequencies pass electromagnetic energy.. between separate matter","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbBfGxM3hD8BNq1nIyavdHw","author":"@Monkfitnesss","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/u-dJI5OcNNeTLjpo1rXG7fYCt3ATL1iqU03hq-wz2593ikr86s9vcdxwM8iBEtAW0JIcpuQjgiE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Monkfitnesss","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCJoYdrUm6hFUjUf54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"13:55 i neeeed to know your method. i currently do pour over using a hot kettle. this looks better","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT8eQjqTQh9dKfLLuv_uGdg","author":"@AlexWolfLikesPie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYRU00UDiEtgF-BrxJDuIrvgbh5JkVQv15oWY4G5K2sPBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexWolfLikesPie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgylizGsCo_Ez61-l1d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a dog, I only understood 7% of this video","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCePEQPYtx8Z_kjuefrAHBAg","author":"@benny_okay","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pkw9g-yWGlPTDZbWmXAEDUB7Cw3we7yklWkOsVvLvWEfysIrGwLSTUZShJ8Sn32h68MnEuwZ2g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@benny_okay","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx_igr2GiBJab236KB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"16:20 when is year 2","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGRuT9xhdkTrP7mXWe_hZ6w","author":"@pauljones9150","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nlkkswMKIWjjF01uWWmDQrJ2tXOffSJnp5mPM2eblGiZOC=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pauljones9150","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyOj6fIzrzoMItesDF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The Shulman Resonance and harmonics of that?\nPls comment.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5RGul1H7oOPwagZT9gSodg","author":"@ArrowRootSolutions","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n1VrJUphR-XiYGNeUsUlTpP3ee9Wd8RWRYNUzw7uI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ArrowRootSolutions","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxocF2agLmP_-NaD0J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ostensibly, dawn birdsong has been shown to open leaf stomata, so there is relative truth that plants respond to sound...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDubez4UebckzB_X9_nKiYw","author":"@ruthlongridge","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9om8o_3c1ms4de3qzX51DikIIyeTZJlqvmWP0IUxoJiVK7VSaBlP3ou9nULw6xW_oAxS7A7vqJw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ruthlongridge","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxCsTOJIs-p-jMMc2N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The lower plant tray gets more light..? the setup is compromised to begin with? \nalso try putting up a four trays, 2 more with a fan blowing, to see if plant strain/stress can be ruled out.\nif it was the stress, a fan should do too, without sound.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIb6XHoocqOjKUsPwavMQ4g","author":"@Gartendalf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n46af5OBnpXVPVs61m6c0BLA13yajbWaqRch-Og5a_qg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Gartendalf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWPfp8ASJVcBfsk014AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe its the rarefied portion of the wave that causes the stomata to open and closes. Causing increases in cellular respiration.🎉🎉🎉","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdcVugB5r6PDcl5gxrApB3g","author":"@brettmoore3194","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mD1tY9BTvyE7KbcYQOM46BWQNSPbRQUCdgCW345to=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@brettmoore3194","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbvvWO9J1K-LSdilN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you physically disturb a young plant it will grow to strengthen the disturbed part. Maybe the sound wave is disturbing the plant physically in a similar way to just, for example, touching your young plants to make them stronger.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrPgwhJcMM927kTqTZ-TeSQ","author":"@glennthisfieldisblank838","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nngOJARWzfycDlvMgdd9Wz6r_unCIEekitjrknrISr-Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@glennthisfieldisblank838","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugydq8oeqlEg3IFQ0kh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I saw a very unofficial study  where they were talking MEAN to a plant, and NICE TO A DIFFERENT PLANT..... Supposedly the nice plant grew great.  and the Mean Plant.... was doing awful. . .  I mean it couldn't hurt to say nice things to plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0mRegZEFk33Cy3E3wvoG5Q","author":"@shaec3405","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/aWPJLBohT1N3NtZ40geVHGzze-Yfd72xfh6c8ltSIWKrU7QUJ-LmqKTWm2Luhhk_gevJEDxJnd4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shaec3405","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwMUYWQaN8_cY6Za8N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This will eventually become a formal field of study, or Benn is Ptolemy and these are his epicycles hahahah","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnxkNJghf4fvyfE6BDQCcmw","author":"@milklordnomadic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/odU45gJ4MsPb52Udrdfx4mJSFlQ7IUiPuu87uKB0q0C2umB7Bg4I35hX8FzAGr3dULQPBha6ag=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@milklordnomadic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyW4wMWugPcpUxDXBp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Could it be that plants grow better around sound because sounds means movement, movement means that the plants spread through movement of animals, air and water etc?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYWwyazwSzpfExzY2JGqOrA","author":"@Friction446","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOsYdYqrnZG0EkTwutE1XcHzeQoG7YNERd1-YtN6RJ_Ww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Friction446","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwdmOKZ60Mj1sTFB4t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Defending Bill Nye's less than stellar application of sound scientific principles during his activism, I mean \"science influencer\" outreach is a choice, I suppose.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCVFTLMXtSpw1awVPAWwn1sQ","author":"@chucklindenberg1093","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n1OM3S0PX9tfiaYc0c5GAioudUxcLSUaMW_TZLkqyeV0I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chucklindenberg1093","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzdCJGerh2Occys5M14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"holy yap dude","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDC5GMyVvJVNE9E4Valnrbg","author":"@commentaccount7880","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mwkYt6KV85975bSORXpAVdAhy6n5DMTRJtvTS_bmRm2lE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@commentaccount7880","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwcDmMSCoiDSvgYpxF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Only 1/2 way in so far but wonder if ... Could the Vibration caused by the sound be replicated by wind?  I know plants grown in higher wind locations grow thicker than low wind locations.... Wondering if audio vibration is simulating the effects of wind on plant growth patterns?  Watching to see if you addressed that point","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBo9BDldeKS4iJalwTAbHXw","author":"@mr_e_mc2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nBq2Ld1ssb-Cna0wkRAiftOp0TmqmtCVWXMH6A9wz1MiU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mr_e_mc2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9NMRbS39-QO3dvv94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You can't just say \"affirmation on x (it is impossible to affirm on x)\"","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCGlQrL5ebzEQ249TtKMm0Iw","author":"@phobos1963","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/AbkkA8xxH4QxoAPN7ek-qNv0ou61epxWb1LHWhNFEOTBT-V7X2DGL8sDPBF-ZTfcCk9GFApG=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@phobos1963","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZxvK6lSN--iJuQzB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If nutrient transport is driven by brownian motion in the cellular cytoplasm I can see sound excitation moving those nutrients to their associated receptors sooner because it has more internal turbulence than being at a standstill without agitation.\n\nCombine this with that one YouTuber who found plasma increases plant growth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCh5kzk-2iBRmJ7wQiBdHCWg","author":"@yoyofargo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMk6weWQVbCQqwgswJxTp08NwOyN0K-GS9ywfIfBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yoyofargo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw1cklOLedSKKCGg454AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I KNEW Plantasia helped plants grow","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWmK_7Cobica66jaLEOctkg","author":"@animal5602","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_khCzMLupqiO2Bh4RxyA9zHZBLI2yN_0_4-P9zlmwszj88=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@animal5602","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyC9nxYu-dUhciFo4B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You did a more indepth video of this???","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCG31if1DzWkuAoWfLLZHu5A","author":"@chrisriehl1696","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nTaN9H87jQ-qTEHN54InbnckGgiMnIyjPXlc1te6L4bEA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chrisriehl1696","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2HA0jjtRetB1bzl54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ben, did you wash your hands so not to leave nutrients on the outer shell of the seeds?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbF0fXJXmyFVJbi8VT2Miyw","author":"@Thomas..Anderson","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lf34C_RRcTiD-MGj1FGTfRriluacaHOMNKj2I9KuE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Thomas..Anderson","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzgiIeLzUHgjuWAoLd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"what a completely incorrect explanation of Godel's incompleteness theorm","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCVWZhHE2ae40oejUrYIK3xA","author":"@noThankyou-g5c","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mW0HX8nY-Aegy1UXDgfTB3j4snP03S3Xy5MBGZkW1hUbbYoGKtw-0B2eroA56mHZ8mFQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@noThankyou-g5c","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy5TCwEf_pO--pFk-t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am interested in how plant will grow without any source of sounds in a special room.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQbrlQ4Nck6G2nVsJYUg7hA","author":"@okolenmi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m1UMYIKlew31X17z70ONjmqtXecWUreVIofVHBF9SPT0Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@okolenmi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzuBL_C2mKkVYeqpAx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"4th hypothesis: the frequency causes the air to hit the grass in such a way as to optimize CO2 absorption. Though to verify that, we'd have to be able to measure the CO2 concentration in that air close/next to the plant and farther away and see if there's a measurable difference. Or if the diffusion in the air is fast enough as to make this negligible.\n\nWhen you grew the plants in that enclosed space, was it airtight? And if not, did you measure the CO2 concentration in the enclosed space over those 12 days? I wonder if the sound waves were helping the air from inside flow in/out into the room and was resetting the CO2.\n\nIn case you needed a reason to redo the experiment.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMJVfN4TsQ8qPGRsStE69sQ","author":"@Pirky","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n6_HEMKe5euvwNBl9jnxXgLMM6beEsXBJugFSkfoc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Pirky","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwATJ0_fy42JhSIqO54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"16:00 this part is only slightly annoying, because you had the chance to measure the distance between fibers, and didn't use that to generate your frequency","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCx0c_vZpkWjLhjWxFCTcIcA","author":"@RegulationHuman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LXcPrVURmsFIW_lINaQvo6RnAQCCRU9bTuPPIm1XhRTedPOwAgdADf_NlsJbRELxCJwKPxm3yLA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RegulationHuman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwRNELRPuMct_7JeT94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Haven’t watched the video yet but how does infrasound effect plant growth?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAZg14C-8CAYW3FRDXwxodQ","author":"@Zacpsen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/PzAVG3VlcLUCYaroga_sd1UyhngZBKW4BovvG43u2Xi9YqvXBOzrEdC96PnrqzrrJSp9JpIaLw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Zacpsen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh07oya3pxS_JDdVB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Doesn't the earth have sound in it? You know from all the small and big animals, insects, other plants bending in the wind and or growing very fast pushing the soil around, water rushing (water table, river, underground river, lake, rain, monsoon etc). I find if plausible that plants could evolve to feel vibrations and respond.\n\nIt could also be that constant vibration at a specific frequency helps to shake the soil around, so that the roots of plants establish a stronghold.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyZtJ2Ak803yIiZkm3AcvDw","author":"@danser_theplayer01","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kCpMdBOq1QLD-HtC2Pr6joMxqFWJRkAlREHAN42M_kyTg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danser_theplayer01","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzYarl_qGxcvzgC3c54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Does the frequency matter","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCJwgUaYis3VgEGLssWttfw","author":"@Dkthearn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nLaU8yPouSIvjIpUeCCev6QixHb-31QoZ-bn1BGmw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dkthearn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzs09O28xJ_ljXSP0V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did you experiment with the Soil? Would a Microbiome in Soil with and without music effect the Soils quality? I would think the tiny lifeforms inside the soil move more frequent due to the noise speeding up Biological processes.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCakQTqGMSMyqWMXa71uAU5A","author":"@AceRobo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/noJlYQQe8oiMmwXjpg2To_R7sZTkQeDhvHvp2U8P09HPzceC9wdJEOtEfL8bINCbzuUGA5ldyA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AceRobo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhKeSIDK591n0914d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You discovered sonic fertiziuler?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCt_vQVEYDOWm7uVnm7l8Fbw","author":"@TheArchontas","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kChe17QWgiLsGZC2Ri7yFVzT0aTTcKa6eRhmEGyZCRXQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheArchontas","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwe9MuW2gYU6X4u8wV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How about mushrooms?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfO2TkIi5jOWgpRsjZiJmxQ","author":"@otemplet9915","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xv09CUhgcmY-5La5nDxagCde1IzidLcuTjaJOEHlwdLiTWM-c3lWZXRK1z-bphlgbENCUvM96Uo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@otemplet9915","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwGNi-vzh7fM4OjHOZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If we say that everything is frequency then how can we not prove it? If for example we see tone and it's related sound. I am told by others more intelligent than me that elements, have unique vibrational patterns, and tone, for example, Hydrogen is Yellow and relates to the musical Chord E. So if we play the chord E in A432hz might we be signalling the hydrogen and this might mean music, or sound that carries many frequencies and tones might be activating elements that are necessary for plant growth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiEKNGis4fIVhfGK_j7n-Cg","author":"@partidaportet27","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3yyhRQRXHG7i2M6g5QTREquremg_o-0weqPLFcjzwacE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@partidaportet27","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwS0WIsvgfKumWLZbR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"17:46 The biggest reason that \"institutional classism\" exists is because there aren't enough people to review all of the papers that would get submitted if anyone could submit a paper on any topic. Especially considering that no one involved in the review process does it full time; journal editors are paid a bit but typically it's just a side activity to their job as a professor or other research position, and peer reviewers are not paid at all, it's completely volunteer work that people do in addition to their actual job. Restricting the incoming papers to people with verified credentials does a lot to cut down on the garbage that these people might have to look through in their very limited time. \n\nIf you don't have academic credentials but want to publish something your best bet is to reach out to someone who does have credentials and make a partnership with them, but again, they probably get a lot of emails from people claiming to have proved the earth is flat or something, so they might not actually read your email.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC37lK81GyKUIdpiafmmTIug","author":"@danieljensen2626","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nvCB_d7zg_Xmf1zc3iyBXAQDFWa7bzjFNrHBRyR3N-Hw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danieljensen2626","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwN2UM1CTk8laaFTDh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Perhaps enhanced gas exchange😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClN7KYgV7Ap76VaOKuhuogQ","author":"@bri83-42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/tDXmpGkiPkF0ncLFANNWK-EhPxY7p9Rl5XmJiWdSNy5Ir8quqiIB5PBBTkVxY4vrZnO4u7nu8A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bri83-42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgykkSTNCLVNk9iQWBB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"2:52 when myth busters did this experiment hard rock had the best results.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVD6JPzT0pFPQ_k8pTvWdow","author":"@stickmanrobert1949","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RKZjt770z4fqAIYeXVaHeyip2aueU0phw2ahWFRkiMJeVXC6aO8DyLNLhNZZu14MnJHxxc5V=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stickmanrobert1949","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzusNliOo0vb7SXTF54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Cool","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZXIHK5dlIyWFzT_jNiD5gg","author":"@AbdessalamM","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NqMebkfCQfEqDYe0OxS6XPHqCG470FR8JI-Ftjbb2xfGhApY668D4s1dPvOAYZPjaqNFs4l-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AbdessalamM","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzk4IdSa1rQwUS6BqR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The dedication to the setup and precision here is great to see, but there is a nuance to the scientific method that would make this kind of work much more powerful.\n\nThe problem with collecting data and then offering a few different possible explanations afterward, like signaling versus photosynthesis efficiency, is that it makes the explanation easy to vary. If one guess is proven wrong, the data just gets shifted to the next one. This creates a loop where nothing is ever truly settled because the explanation is flexible enough to survive any result.\n\nAn experiment does not really start to have meaning until it is trying to choose between two specific, rival theories. If you do not commit to a specific mechanism before you run the test, the data does not have the opportunity to actually refute anything. It just becomes a reported anomaly in search of a home.\n\nA common misconception is that science is about building up a probability of being right. But science is actually at its best when it is trying to be clearly wrong. If you risk a very specific theory, the data can kill it, and that is how we actually correct our errors and move forward. Without that rivalry between theories, we are just observing things without explaining them.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIglMxJTQZn0I4GHoSm0p1Q","author":"@pritomsarker8761","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CLVVN73yCIzY4M2D6jXNg8BYzEM_dTYKzrPbYwLZHtfzlR_uJm5DY5EM76SGGCqA0u5xGu-_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pritomsarker8761","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgypHQY-Yb0ZS8cu_mN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a coffee professional of 20 years, can I please teach you how to make a siphon in return for everything you've taught me?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLK4IOsOaWgmNMk9awwQJmg","author":"@matteoarpc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l-sVOOJaMPumixvsf7DqatcQkBeFhONLWw3_uU-AZuL4E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@matteoarpc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 weeks ago","timestamp":1789084800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwkKNUGx1iXoamiWGR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Science doesn’t try to discover “truth,” science evaluates how predictable models are.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzJq5AacrzD-bOby2n6yVcg","author":"@yewknight","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/faG2r3ANxWuxztXGkO9JkU9RJVK9g2IYBYCB-Xy5tEoAdZleOVeJOpWW1p6SpdVlrvTesCODgqY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yewknight","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0HNovN4d7PTe0MvV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe sound vibrations also have an effect on the soil, not on the plants. Looser soil makes plants growth easier.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW3MsZ7C3zOUhCqjfN8m-CA","author":"@amazakee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mij98bFdTbVcjV6eAZDb3FTXlQ_SI7jCdByZg1SwXkjg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@amazakee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw_CY3vGUsAYOX48hV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"just over 3 mins in and struggling to focus, dog is soo well behaved","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCK02VXibMLrBoIwIA0_qxnA","author":"@cs91-226","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l8L0TJqZB5vy_wSoWnPUp41hZqjFKi2vrB8iGXThNWdbedSaomLTqHOwXLKh-b_8ECSQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cs91-226","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw_CY3vGUsAYOX48hV4AaABAg.AKvSseoFtJjAKvTpd1Kfqi","parent":"Ugw_CY3vGUsAYOX48hV4AaABAg","text":"3 seconds later i find out the dog loves it and she knows everyone thinks shes cute","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCK02VXibMLrBoIwIA0_qxnA","author":"@cs91-226","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l8L0TJqZB5vy_wSoWnPUp41hZqjFKi2vrB8iGXThNWdbedSaomLTqHOwXLKh-b_8ECSQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cs91-226","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzdjUuMFc-8zZ3SG8N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants cant hear sound it's impossible, but they do feel moving air. A small fan could have given you the 28% increase in biomass that you saw with the speakers. When plants are exposed to a \"stress\" i.e. wind in this case. They react by building up biomass to give themselves the best chance of surviving these conditions. The inverse is also true and repeatable if you grow the same plant in an environment with stagnant air.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCF3kBE31jLmO_eTJh_qPEXQ","author":"@timmytenders8536","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m_8oMZj_A-hyz3wV-WLw2bbr5QZxzP5G7_2i3gpWGfFYoTMr2ysZ0sDfMztyKwJqgYt_AWV5H6I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@timmytenders8536","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyfchv6hxUGzGent7p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"no one can prove it?\nisnt it just caused by plants thinking its birdsong, which causes plants to mistake it as day and cause them to open up more and do daytime activities 24/7 ?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC8wdhWRQBGTjz6GHk9UGgbw","author":"@pigizoid9924","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QGwFXNEURWK2-Vks6ShLGX8LQaILicjbyIDtMNFfMiZk5tbXjISANFZam4obo7jniznHUXGP=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pigizoid9924","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyoBlEwKNiyIBUgA2t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I mean if vibrating the plants helps the nutrients move around more efficiently then yeah 'sounds' reasonable 😂... Probably, specifically, a combination of frequencies related to what the plant does while its growing. Grass probably \"likes\" different sounds than, like... tomatoes.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6la9_tIvajUQ5FdGveXglA","author":"@NijiflianBustock","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/o8orqpzssukGATufaz9wkuRSfA4i9CSd-Fa62fCyMIiztxIMhyEBtlo3iBq1F8Tcll44vsBE5Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NijiflianBustock","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy4QnC0_rflqj0MK2p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:03 can confrim. Didn't consider myself above average intelligence, and after trying to read Goedel, I have proof","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNYq1YM6t9tY8AYtwafVbsg","author":"@drewherbi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ky83sfKLZKg64QVSZaiBasWQFR7PKIrBMubBg--uaAlA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drewherbi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzYc1MOTEhNJ-d9kcJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:54\n\"seperate the science from the scientist\"?\ni can see how thats valid!though when it comes to crediting someone who made the discovery in the first place that should still be an honored facet","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCs7qY8zPrNPgOSUpXv-AvGw","author":"@Phantom_Nibiru","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/eLZdbz9KlWjhqMnoDs7K4O8Vl5q34tbChS5rhqXj4ZHnlhjmOBM0-Hws4lkzw-cngRCsLxvi=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Phantom_Nibiru","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwtEl922fh98fRwp494AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The speakers have blue lights on them. Isn't that wrong. Why choose speakers wich are light sources as well?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOtvfdfaPrD4tgWcX_2qqrw","author":"@gwitichis1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lir-OzZn41AltE4VBhrFUT_K3V0xAa-8tL2SLD6Tjjzg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gwitichis1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy1FVUTXJTeztPyLcp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I tried rubbing coffee in my wound, Now it's looking really bad and smelling really awful and not like delicious coffee at all. Kind of hurts when I poke it with my stirring spoon. Thoughts?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbp4cbGZQLYz8oA394B2f-w","author":"@kennyroody","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mT9Gc08WkcisSCKGYaXiXwdEIfjuT815HRpX_D0gN3PrI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kennyroody","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQy4kmbKKSIeEGuxB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wonder what Dave Farina would say about this","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCePpzD9gQ0xhXhY1Q3kGzOw","author":"@ScarlettStunningSpace","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nv3hWbk_nji3fcbJW203nxnwPQiVFmtfWYR3ga-8kH39iJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ScarlettStunningSpace","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwtvjz3Dyra9bB1mJt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"its #2 ... .cells are \"wiggling\" . i flick my MJ sprouts AS they grow because i never have proper variable airflow","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNge41ynQAfJeVgFX_PqHcA","author":"@pebcak420","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WwmK7nt1Tbki5uMGQxycvfL8WeXspjtWtiidlwecq2jSZlRGjammncCKgH2rCylPYPtHSUe2gUk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pebcak420","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwNiZnCw9nt0GoEPRV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"but what about the current phases of the moon during the experiments?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCeC4y_QL67NxmAyVTAyOYJg","author":"@BinxBubbles","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mhYMd8eRIZw_raiPQ_0axWm9uyydiERTzQTiAUmcLwaXTp-LIqnfZZsPeFGM2BjEvxXw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BinxBubbles","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymOE39QBa8qrdg8DV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you consider how fluids works on plants you should be able to put 1 and 1 together and get the answer for that.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDCsTGKM51hz6uGsSvp3SEA","author":"@Vegz666","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5uaILfMHhNIKIy9-bxG9D4KMwJyisPbmiJt0859vzjV6tt68nQ-OMDddu0WDjScKs9SLTtt9tg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Vegz666","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy5JukxVmUy7yXYOpl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As an indoor grower.  Light pollution is your #1  factor we dont think about 😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnQf7Y_R1jX3NdskkK_E2Ag","author":"@llewellyncox_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8abq16CepZ5DbMpsLphXf721M-_RGomPBYjU_jNXKGiSvm1r2T_bbGpXqK72iVa7o8uQF0lt=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@llewellyncox_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxW9cy0iKHjrYp_0BR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"im more then willing to hop on any research and experiments after i get my graduate degree in biochemistry so we can do some real scientist a favor and remind them this is an open source world","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRRs3yvBM4yMIhwzRFAcqRQ","author":"@SkunkworksAgriculture","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/R10L9oFuXdWGMHVcMoPNhvNkrPRccSoYXctEBuLBmfgz0iTlvgORSN3_D7q69ccTYqRoGcOu=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SkunkworksAgriculture","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzI7R6JeT85LZBsyGF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Next experiment should use magnets 😉","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgGAbujRsot-8nWTDMzBEww","author":"@tenthplanet3342","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lDjeYPz85NFuhXqmcwz2syeE9ES6fLviaDJeZJZf8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tenthplanet3342","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwB_jhUY7cTkWPPK0d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"4:42 I'd be curious to know if anyone tested birdsong. Because if anyone started blasting music all day, I think the environmental effect would be terrible. But this may be motivated reasoning towards a more holistic approach to farming, I guess ^^","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHJ4-B1Jb1E34XwC4llryqw","author":"@EliasMheart","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1fusy35tWPtWLYG1clLdB8xra2UaiLtSLQiqMuTLncZjcnu18FgpPjb0jThX1XSUwh64eX2e=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EliasMheart","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_vstn8sqv5-mhZLt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Im split between it being a 'cognitive' effect and it just helping molecules shift and move via vibrations. Like deep bass when you gotta poop.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5aVFR42V2ddcq0wE-wkGdA","author":"@andrewbrown6522","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/IT_2Xcru1xMuT1okMZfx7gvAE1qq2mnaQSU8Sik2k6irtslaVOxNpHSWEvOLlIQ8JvfaUujN=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andrewbrown6522","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzkJPOdRHZEgRHB2DN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"does this work for fungi?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgyOqWFHYfaPAVV2hAlkCKw","author":"@CyZit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yYhoALRYHKcw_OlVCisJFbOkiwP4ApxPcom4q_4S_Qv3WrL45qM2wMhqUQaK9VveHxt72poJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CyZit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_Mq8EXHn8gAZ5E5x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Nope, wrong, wrong, wrong... the plants were so happy to see you in your green baby grow!!! 8D","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW6cV6akqC2MazLkPiKZu2g","author":"@openroot","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lD8_L0FSBA_YPhhKImRBF_mDaSH28UmBOf6wWhKjM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@openroot","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPJMqumjSA0hKEtDR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The sound agitates the CO2 to get it into the leaves.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWTQglFS1yWxVAO38eduAFg","author":"@Brickcaster","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mKJ4KEEw3nTO0cS9koGmqjF-1lDtnQgr6Hq3V7tdXnGw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Brickcaster","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPZSnO48Ah8QvhRCt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"There might be some important variables we aren't aware off or we are simply overlooking them.\n\nFor example we still don't really understand why water behaves the way it does. \nWe might have found the reason why it differs so much from every other known liquid or atleast we found some clues. Looks like it's not a single LIQUID at all but more like a mixture of 2 LIQUIDS, changing their behaviour depending on all kinds of environmental factors. not just temperature or pressure but even gravitation, radiation. \npretty sure that also includes soundwaves/vibration. all those factors will make the water behave differently.\n\nso the key here might also be water. And to make water behave the way you want it to behave. so the water molecules will favor a specific state (the probability to stay in a certain range of states) that benefits your needs\n\nyou said how you treated and stored the water. but where did you store it? \nlike besides temperature etc., did the water get the same sonic treatment? 😁\nI guess you would want to isolate it as much from other sound sources (and all other environmental factors possible)\n\nHope it doesn't come off as hating on your experiment. actually it's the opposite I really really love what you are doing including this experiment.\n\nI'm just a bit excited trying to find the missing pieces for this 'mystery'. This behaviour of water might probably also explain other phenomena.\nExciting Times...\n\nlove you people ❤️☺️✌️","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5XwweGRWOLDV_E9TecaDig","author":"@geeminusc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_logZ4B84cS59f6Np3a0t5yk4-sqZWhjcKchtTfBVl_488=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@geeminusc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyH1fs3oB12rlfL5gh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Run this again but use a rotary subwoofer instead -- a mostly sealed grow box with a fan whose blade pitch changes with frequency and amplitude of the sound. That video you did about the sound some people hear that drives them nuts? Play that frequency vs. what you did in this one and compare :O What if the natural resonant frequency of Earth is why we have life?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmkAhcu8ecl0NYYeMAOtOAA","author":"@jimmio3727","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WVkxJU3ElsBBqXKvFxGQWLmCY2h0vsYJ5RutuH5iS62oVODVKEKr1r-IfH9zJ3QZ7gEi5R_uwHM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jimmio3727","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKh-qgO2x3yjYcmiR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if different plants like different music?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbuVsNDfCEIdNnN92NvmEFw","author":"@andrewcardarelli5648","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6CQjyHYbfwD8-zuGe1rBpgoA6U-18kHT0UhIkkLYLcdkc6RwVRrLfV8XbypohZe3pg1AhrHdnw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andrewcardarelli5648","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzcFa5wJ-PlBNVRorh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I LOVE SCIENCE.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvXb6txv9DdMffuh5QDrYVA","author":"@MetricZero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mgpjqnbpvWWDORTA5ERzZGdqaSRUx9f0-aLVsXb1ee6g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MetricZero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy3xE2V5syMdexuJp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"new age beliefs like ESP and astrology\"; two concepts that are multiple millennia older than, and more culturally universal than, the scientific method","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCdsm8EPx5gNSqO_iwyHze0Q","author":"@mmhoss","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nQHAFUGtbSnN6_08D7SvwHhu5Al54NkOHdPuS3MQddZfM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mmhoss","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwy3xE2V5syMdexuJp4AaABAg.AJafgGS1cs7AKPCTLT_eLf","parent":"Ugwy3xE2V5syMdexuJp4AaABAg","text":"Astrology and ESP are just the first two steps of the scientific method that never follow up with experimentation.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCus5sZIzN1O0ut56m3Al2TA","author":"@evrythingis1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mo7TgC4jxd3ktyWBI7tKmbAy7G5YVr_cJckwIYA8kbumQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@evrythingis1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyyeWUUM2BWHTHf--p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about plant life cycles in general. 20 hours of light may be normal in veg but not in bloom etc","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCdxpaMogRCmFPUWRfI5QLg","author":"@arrowspoint3321","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mIq3VHfPUrGhS9seKsJqeGzc2vC6doz0-nM2OENLkRxafGhMnaFzOjB0stCwcIPBngbw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@arrowspoint3321","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgytW0M3d_gkPtdATOJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Crazy theory.... what its its not the plant but the soil.  What if the music makes the soil vibrate and loosen.  But some sound are too strong and make it collapse and so you have different results.  They should try this experiment with out soil too. If they haven't.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnnXpRFlQYTPNfHm7M-bu1w","author":"@raymondbro","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k9f0tevHsL9jzvxR2mdfWqE8KqTFhvpb9B5in94A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raymondbro","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyRTGlPWR_zRhtIRtB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wind helps plants grow due to the plants moving in the wind and incentivizing them to grow stronger. \nI think sound waves have a similiar effect as wind.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDH29FFigY-H9f3ICbp0ozw","author":"@raptormenace529","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kg6RDK7X5e5OuRhTs1PKEuH3YREYYEWi7G6yK_-gM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raptormenace529","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzaIjTB2yP9sgVF-8R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"May i butt in as a cannabis grower? Plant thrive with wind pressure. If plants are grown inside without pressure waves showing it it has to grow strong to survive it wont bc like why even","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHLmna4oA6BvgLKn-6JS4pg","author":"@ImNotimportant-u8b","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nLDRFkW4-H3DXefKqVCiv64nSX1pCGNxxB-s1JqQGZT_lalhc7_7OcXHx652isf4T3ag=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ImNotimportant-u8b","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgySsqBK5q-_B-v6EvV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dropping out of school is a good way to become a critical thinker.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCr1_N4t1DBIyrQ-CBgmVZ4A","author":"@DaruthTheHuman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iLp50JyGdt-6i3rPr8DEHSWsrKo9sorVOTpAEuGLfQ-BFWCq76m7GQanw8bIphqyDJhcu72nVA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DaruthTheHuman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxz5Q8qfeVzfmZvKSJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Music does not help them grow, but I read something where it's certain frequencies vibrations that improve growth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvSLlsEy_54HNXh_MIVpvtA","author":"@shadowk3","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lyPLt3i6NGWLDITSnSKolNsbptD6x724hGdiCgoeT3q3I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shadowk3","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJScPCDkI7clzgxE14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey Ben, I heard that you can be awarded a doctorate after 10 publications ins some places. Have you tried that?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGZgDd6ZVNYL_j-PvFh-osw","author":"@gregorstrohman3619","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mBIVjsUahd4h2jU4rBomPq6kMcR06wKK2km8H_pyBx-oA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gregorstrohman3619","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJScPCDkI7clzgxE14AaABAg.AMo4y4UFB5UAMo86LHnuwA","parent":"UgxJScPCDkI7clzgxE14AaABAg","text":"Funny thing: I wrote this comment 2 minutes into the video, didnt know about your education at all^^","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGZgDd6ZVNYL_j-PvFh-osw","author":"@gregorstrohman3619","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mBIVjsUahd4h2jU4rBomPq6kMcR06wKK2km8H_pyBx-oA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gregorstrohman3619","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxO8xgu6OSicIobm8Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"maybe just try the SONIC BLOOM of Dan Carlson - i would think it would be a great place to start...blessings to all","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC69xQGLRKeOrn8_ohwf6D7g","author":"@paulbraga4460","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m0FEE_6SnpydiYbXEoMIRH2SmIazZW7xE_JUDo8Is=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@paulbraga4460","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwMB1jwVMPiXrunQMJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you treat the cytosol within plant cells as an organocrystalline, decentralized processing matrix, then tubulin scaffolding deeply connected to the LINC complex and CRWN nuclear structural proteins would certainly trigger mechano-acoustic stimulation of metabolic output. In simpler terms, specific sounds directly affecting plant growth appear to be a trivial consequence of a plant cell's biology.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCCF_V-tESVE7nOcWGiQ6Ag","author":"@freerun_dragon","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llkRrJf_R_5cwyo9DXQ2rzd4y-337NKJ4wS1Id0YY1vQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@freerun_dragon","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxzB4px20aZff0to8V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You forgot 4  stress response","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwPDrtKOmQqw2SUREGw8A2g","author":"@Mpcdude385","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zfglNRzdGpBrF6_im1xbdRT0CuFWYXTEFko9yCxeSfyHDWAMtiSRSM-3kBA-8XJVQ-L2JhdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mpcdude385","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxTFcMvv1d_MafPF7V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Electrostatic heating/cooling. Moves heat in metal object in ways that seem to violate thermodynamics. It doesn't. rexresearch 'electrostatic cooling'.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFP5vzvQq6f8hSEshSnYK_Q","author":"@polygon2744","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lVB6ew-CMGvTYIIGNr5AouqGqjteWyXy4mHVuA3beMPR0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@polygon2744","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxFD34o9BPsGaXHNy14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Its vibration. We know vibration helps plants grow. They are designed to have the wind and animals/insects move them.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvvTitHoaJefqOjJhVjSEyQ","author":"@Luckingsworth","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Ackq3Vs4v7CnGadY1XR8z2wBsXBUdIngvDs9hv4pav5zEv4pMRotzH4pJbrKGVFZBGStCp674hA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Luckingsworth","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwXU-8UvCPhXZ_u1iN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:17 how do you know if that's true?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVagH2Nzvf1EZlAUI5whvVw","author":"@iamn360","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ngmZgMQfW6S3S4_dnFaUyyE5iaOSwtlnAkD0THp8pn5H4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@iamn360","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzS3edbM5K7EyngEux4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Look at Dan Winter","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgwF1M3twMRNqH6VEjYZTCw","author":"@Zjalapeno","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Itvd862zE2P-_AcPSHDB6AUDZ0Y5_Z_z2qqv_AwIwAf227cE36eLsCN2H3piOSDvSi1r6EqqUA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Zjalapeno","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyi0ZLlSI5AQWBLrG14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"WHAT  -  THE FUCK  -  IS THAT COFFEE METHOD?!?!  Anyone?!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgNnh_yk1U49BcC4QQj_pxQ","author":"@ssaammhhaaiinn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sNy-Asj3t3tqGnfgptPyB7dQZ5NACNrtj06ffx8CdtR4TFsLWQkFN1l5cpodDxjuF-Cuc-R7ag=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ssaammhhaaiinn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwRBnG0QBRlXJhnWXN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"150-250Hz helps my cannabis clones tecover faster after transplant..its about cell walls, enzymes & nutrient uptake..different frequencies for different stages of plant growth.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCB-7bIRuyV74Mgrp4ieCvuA","author":"@deonellis7516","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVWy_1m7jUkJoQOK9Qqv3Ttt-VmQiaygulxz-6K7cUiA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@deonellis7516","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-BbCj2KHI4oEreo94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The incompleteness idea still hasn't reach the \"many worlds\" quantum mathematical fantasy folks yet.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdLdGponps48GKH3iHLpYJQ","author":"@briandonovan9091","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMmV1nl6xZt_ZIa_QBMULB-Gij9INJ3LE59SRGM-g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@briandonovan9091","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6A6dVjy74YxT7WaV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If they weren't clones then the entire experiment doesnt matter","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGYODmCkqWHJ4kiu1zsK_Fg","author":"@financialRedPill","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TyVg5BaEVJqPShVoHbEgzVY6uPZn6hHmdrxKfIMQ6pbuKAjDwptNmiVchWFdLNq5bawt-abiMQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@financialRedPill","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxfIjXfQbunPJ6XLx94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The Mythbusters study showed the opposite. The best plants they had were classical and metal","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9gOjtkVvpluZLcGp8RRSsg","author":"@jamesf.189","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XT-1wsSBfntrS6sCarzRVKVQXsepa8bdWgWhmfoSpC_iElRNB62hye-URuUeYvWQv1zhHEOrOg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jamesf.189","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxzrJFuBtvnMe8WgDx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bro's a goat","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCF_8ugcoBj6KYpMvGOB-Ucw","author":"@willbgm5x5","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/R3lr0CmDLI17htQmO6qUwm4rnLc3BYQDxaEG3DCz1wjrrrUl-SJYZxPdGw5E-qECN3o9uGKE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@willbgm5x5","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwK6Ia6bT-XA7Qxye94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Try with the sound of bees.  I read it stimulates plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMDvo7ImcW5RuDH-zdMf-OQ","author":"@GaryGaulin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_4Td7g6j2Uve5RWyBZ2C6-qYOmJ0duv_uGMve-Io5vkM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GaryGaulin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy1PfqiQOiAWsAsSqd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Scientist here: the replicability crisis is not funding, it's Chinese researchers flooding journals with fake results that we can't replicate.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEWWM013rc1PKq9yBrXZjyg","author":"@Miseric0rde","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m9qKfBBfbc4YxcejmVZ4MKSmvk3pSsqqbhaIqbNMSS1Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Miseric0rde","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwlsyEWIb_zSdD-5qN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"There’s no way to really prove plants have no emotions.  It’s plausible that they can.  However when making observations on these sorts of things, it’s best not to state perceived interpretations or assumptions.  Similar practices were actually taught for cadets teaching observations back when I took that class in high school.  We were told to write down what we physically noticed the kids doing, but not to mention what we think is the reasoning or the assumed emotions or interpretations or anything that could fit into the category of opinion instead absolute direct fact.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC30_Kw-60w8gJO45SgvGHDw","author":"@nathenewendzel7806","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k1LWy2-ZaCt94WtaY4PUNFE_nUp-XVIvsg9jCs2tC1GNY_tKwPcAude-AKcSa6CckaqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nathenewendzel7806","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxOrZp1p3RtLB8DKyp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"what about some more simple explanation like better air exchange?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGBywPBTQzfQ60hTtmerKAA","author":"@Stallnig","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XVZ18ESteFlROtdqyLf9pyzhf1gjyOF1VYFb0PNdD9bImy5dddAbUGKI8S1zgaEXR-elJzbFLQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Stallnig","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxs-LsOqlinOCciQQV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"they try withold cheese,\n\nthey prefer Hip-Hop","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdXp-A95HLXE0MLzapvmU7w","author":"@LppDelta9","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXQlkBHzG9V8JkvbqYZOBEBzw40lfujDosimU9dgo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LppDelta9","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxARSEiR7Ay6DkQCbl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I like this video, but I'd love to see you getting more psychotic about your coffee too lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCasT-oDEWWqE54XYJ2cSX3w","author":"@AnxiousApes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/F1GVA-K7e5vYOKU2vN2zcKjj-UZSfHqEmoUG4wfcdp1iA551CJhrZ5uTZKYhDcvrII-uO3r-Ww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AnxiousApes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgypGLuTNtEKCB5hRv94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If the thing about Led Zep & Jimi is fact .... then I would have no plants in my garden at all.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJksg92EbYApQS2B-mILirA","author":"@NINJATObeats666","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xO_bxnCYON5LD0Piioob7s674IHaAZoDNFIdRHF4fZEABGBAam3DepRvbk2NkTQK0yAX5I6HPQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NINJATObeats666","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx400LtWOrsHKbPN7h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Anthropomorphizing as a word is very anthropocentric 3:39","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClVvD9m_UsqTDb-_2J5ppJQ","author":"@aethervvav1658","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SfPYTv2UCARgWxvMQC5tEBirGNNKYIksZGKHFKdaYQuq1uVg0G4O7cxqtqBJYfRozQQrR1aZKw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aethervvav1658","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-8aBDKU_cCuAp9zZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wondet if soundwaves helped the capilary action","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwyLbejgscXQXaegFRO9AoQ","author":"@johntunstall4835","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kUkBC9V1NpNQPWZ8PI8-Eao0yZiOBPrz9nJhqXYFM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johntunstall4835","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw5IS3dG-Ee7mC1iwh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Nurture vibes","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2B1h0XY1BBwssWPV511tGw","author":"@intertenare8444","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x6bYSb88_BkS3nE3XxGKhBy_DBySBMWYXoURbmnh1Yut0LiaEODLy5qQxyRTJXhQtGxYZiep=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@intertenare8444","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzoTnEoZxHRKnVzcmt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So i was told by someone that has dedicated a significant portion of their life to frequencies that it i because the plants have a frequency of their own and that they grow more if you support that kinda like if you support the heart beating of a human that he would grow more (the thing with the human heart is more as an understanding referance i dont think it would actually help).","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCejoruQDm11quc9Vb3713Eg","author":"@LukasZiegler-k1d","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lH1zJmlsA1WqGJZyMpgTbIfXRnmiC714MlofQqnMaTuRgkpG4o42a60HhOGPyJpAPAuA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LukasZiegler-k1d","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwM04mTmbKBH-p6UT94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"16:28 what an atrocious and unjust law","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCl9y1v_l2AqSx6o1zz7IntA","author":"@Youssii","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nkBuFnz8LJWJrv9MjpxutZqZQzjbHaJFM4I1e8OZc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Youssii","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwG1e7MUBAiUfErqYd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If the end of this is just that sound means moving particles and plants can respirate better when the air next to their stomas moves, I’m going to be very disappointed.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1vZGgJhmwMKU_H0gyH4zWA","author":"@alexbruns4568","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n6lkbd82748tC1m0ffEqhTTEujhhNIFFFGLvqeBfJxebs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alexbruns4568","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz3r1loWjLpSpRePOJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Do the faster-growing plants drink more water?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC3QvxCVGKbbMc7bUwsnTadw","author":"@georgemasters4895","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kkOaZCUqsz2Vq4dyic3gDv_5On5lQBT8b-WM7vfhY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@georgemasters4895","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz3r1loWjLpSpRePOJ4AaABAg.AKDBPAmAzyaAK_ZvT706P4","parent":"Ugz3r1loWjLpSpRePOJ4AaABAg","text":"Yes","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzxYZ8ty0uqktB_oOy0OK-A","author":"@fadedtitan9336","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kPFheh-uaOEURzXVaCkGsDLmPdtAH70AdifZuN386vCw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fadedtitan9336","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxitl5wBAxOSzpONsV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Whats the name of the song starting to play at around 12:40. I started randomly play it (or something very close to it) with my guitar the other day, I've heard the song just cant remember who wrote it or what its called.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0vlKByknA0oB-6Xi_kXyiQ","author":"@visalehtinen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/PbzKPLAK9BCe50lAOtqdLbUawyWaDeADbEcV6BXayiABE7wlOIz8YOcXtJxmzWEg1dzX05OorDM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@visalehtinen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwetadRzuhE55fPckd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Actually plants do have emotions..https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MPpURDTTf8k","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCTEtwqTIpPBOauN1D0LhQA","author":"@anthonygalati4018","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mX6V-eT37EyPGI29oKFhgrCr5jkkImkUvL-h7NtAUdcyk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@anthonygalati4018","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwahb38crerIhhBcsl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The answer is birds.\nBirds sing. Birds eat seeds/fruits. Dropped seeds and pooped fruits make new plants. If a plant hears a bird sing, it will grow faster so the bird can eat it sooner.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnBNHXevRhgW--01qaWHG1g","author":"@paydaygh9388","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n0FWA0wrSTs6n5DOFg89EBE-9YaMi2dvfTA8LuGiKdiA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@paydaygh9388","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzhBK6KRaQ1v6WiIdt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your saying every flowerpot should be also a Subwoofer right ?!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYOkg1HYTOMltxqddKc0F3g","author":"@luxenburger98","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4SuR_G7DIGlyAUl8y-k8Tn3550KLYX8j6wem3D8BIUw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@luxenburger98","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzUPrzCMBRuWEWHIhV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Air vibration acts like a lung to plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDSqCc24C0fUM4QKYYLpZpQ","author":"@CTimmerman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_leHLvN6hVGIZ2UqoA6s-svefwlBqJ9mO1XMV2pNWN8u3g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CTimmerman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyJ93giS6G0DAq0I3B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I always interpreted Gödel's incompleteness as being \"there are truths that can't be proven true\", not \"no truths can be proven true\". Otherwise a good video so far.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVn2pjUqeUtY-7ixhuXhYHQ","author":"@kyrothegreatest2749","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mwOnM7TzzOWSYcHi5gNwnl_cV7bSh7za79shKwbCP-deI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kyrothegreatest2749","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwqdE5xFNyaYSGpP6d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It’s a real shame the scientific community has degraded to the point we are at now. Like you mentioned, you aren’t taken seriously unless you have a specific piece of paper, meanwhile the people with said paper are getting lazier and lazier. Imagine if we treated all the independent researchers, experimenters, inventors of old time like this… we would still be in the Stone Age.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBCFpQRyM7d0NKdSsiSyPhw","author":"@RoosterCP","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZZh8XPFAkYjyVWpkGQoUxA6VhlGrgxg_icRnkZ8TQ9XSkzkaMao3tgjGabShoqm1SuCJd_X9=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RoosterCP","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwXbNbKZg1oqJeaUjx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"16:40 as young person who smokes marijuana and possesses illegal weapons you genuinely give me hope I have a future","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnmPq1uZg2A4eLQOKxiXa0g","author":"@LanaLove-o5f","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mdLN5Vw0ziQ5ddgE3grZlftCzCzauZPJJB1SGPA9Rev08GjrvbczJYaMIAK3tfX9FBY47gLo28c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LanaLove-o5f","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxS7XsFYi7ALYyY4Oh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Can you investigate if plants make the quality of music made my musicians better? maybe it's a symbiotic relationship? XD","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7m7zp5fUhW2qfAnkRpusjQ","author":"@NeonNijahn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kB1Y4VejPbjbJHtM7h0ptS8MqhwDvzfuM7cOhS_TJEtcIo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NeonNijahn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQNXeV933MVxHQTkJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video! However, I think it's a falacy to state there is no universal truth 09:03, although different understandings of what is happening can be expressed very differently and all valid in their way.\n\nI only raise this because I've realised how many people dont just say \"there is no truth\" due to a lack of better words to express differences, but because they think there is no objective truth... which baffles me. Our failure to capture everything in a test or sentence doesn't change facts.\nScience is a process to reveal truth, you take it seriously! Thanks for these videos, they're very interesting.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5ORsZKWQuH1F0CbFtZW58Q","author":"@salemfoxtrot7659","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3z_-SbjiwFcVu55tf7DPE-yM3RciYuvH78KYQT0r43_Q4Q8RYG5vEQxEWbt1XL9QQjCPaygx=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@salemfoxtrot7659","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKfQ1IAbnBdAv7Ex14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"No sound in space… but isn’t sound just waves? So what if another race could hear different waves like some things can see different waves of light? Maybe there is sound we just can’t hear it?😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAokIpUGwjvg9vCx1I_3Vcw","author":"@Larimuss","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/o98vqsyuBmvv3rZUW4fucRH8JM-0_reuG3IDCff-dGyrWpgWEPC2PgcdFuoLyIBA4IputDkl6w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Larimuss","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9EFPHpFvisBexmp14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hello - why 43hz?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwQi_ZRa2cloFLGRDaaRCHQ","author":"@symcyto","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lKIWBK7rCGBS_b9CEbZR80GB6BJmMaBjG0rCD1YSOz7mTJZeJE6EnXibP3x-IPgNBqKA3KGk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@symcyto","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxG5wBcgJF_Iqy4aXJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"#SonicBloom\nBeen known for a long time...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgNfxh2dyDnygLLiLfNje1Q","author":"@mkemp8910","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_meZQDvkVwIytlz05tUr4sKYRoxduo30MYm6fDWZDFwo5Dx5x44u4bpmQY2f_R4uW4yGQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mkemp8910","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2tueHPQsDaKoxmzV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"energy, frequency and vibration....doesnt it sound familiar?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-XLlL_6MBMxWS_bs0rdZlw","author":"@vanlupique","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mYZS1CJELTTcdO-sq20skENSfB_z2_s3gJtlakQJ0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vanlupique","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhjIfd3N2LGe7Vyn14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I play Scarface for my coke plants","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbqNPkRxPkxzHYl_aI8m7oQ","author":"@FLEXOMAMBA","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bkoqD0BYdtjdh2w9PLExjHQ7yXE-xOcnw7ZJb9JPPq3wVkvI1AFt8_q1y5NiSDeMMDbiHiI6Yn4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FLEXOMAMBA","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxZsa1FiSSqGa1zmox4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"you shouldv'e played the lute you had behind you while making this... lute core all the way","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9arUaqBpW905UtdTOY7Qig","author":"@spicypeanuts","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lR2IjaLe-R2zBt8uAOOlwhGjFAPBOjCXpJ8rHiIjzdKg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@spicypeanuts","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwb9YMpa_C27aTRtTd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Summary of every Benn Jordan video:\n\"I discovered/created this amazing thing and here's how it works and how great it is, look at how many I'M ON YOUR POLITICAL SIDE great applications you can OTHER POLITICS BAD use it for, it's truly a wonder of science YOU'RE EVIL AND WRONG IF YOU DISAGREE and technology, thanks for watching.\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKR7q8MXBTe4cUR-WSYHHgw","author":"@darrenbreydsor5604","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nMknonzHvFRT-MYBLuAnU5ZgcsAjMHlS1uiSkhvvibhw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@darrenbreydsor5604","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwb9YMpa_C27aTRtTd4AaABAg.AQDgpdxABsSAQDh9ExvJSG","parent":"Ugwb9YMpa_C27aTRtTd4AaABAg","text":"To clarify, the things you've made and discovered are truly amazing, I'm not criticizing that. I'm criticizing the propaganda and manipulation sprinkled throughout it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKR7q8MXBTe4cUR-WSYHHgw","author":"@darrenbreydsor5604","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nMknonzHvFRT-MYBLuAnU5ZgcsAjMHlS1uiSkhvvibhw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@darrenbreydsor5604","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyX6vo0gRZn1EtZdzJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Now use Grateful Dead music!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGBf_fo9U2to6KMLTsqENNg","author":"@Idrinklight444","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DebAeuyt7arOFVD310SD8r1zdHhJaM3p9IwgyWDG92HI6cu6GJRe5SmmP4ebGrDtN1B_Wsn7Bg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Idrinklight444","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw1xyEc5-XozlSWN_B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I put a beats pill in my garden but my plants still died","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgh1l1R1gEcELrIejRXgieg","author":"@thomasfisher1829","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lmKLoX_75W3Zzo4CS6nkUMjMn2RerC2v3SiY3kUw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thomasfisher1829","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzna0JVgMPzZuRG_gx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But did you test this theory with YOUR music?? I have a plant room and I'd rather play that in it. xD","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClQ4XriFyHnHCM_lVa1FPBg","author":"@buzzbuzzgames","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iBULOIKjWZEAS8KU_T3mfLW0Kr6uzZy52CAry8XQQuJxtxxtMnM62O1nkegPgDmim9f9v7tMNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@buzzbuzzgames","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzOWpGDtyuCqSh88mV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Any plant that doesn't like Led Zeppelin has no place in my garden.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa4dI95rNs11ERZNL2Pb-fg","author":"@MusicPlayingPeon","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nlBilyjMA1U52oKK26XZ_UcnniCFBmVBEaZcWRZocnDN18ZKMnESUSGCHsm8S0Thv9RQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MusicPlayingPeon","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxCtt3HgVTiHumffyl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"And a fan +60% 🤷\nYou just discovered that air circulation helps plants breading.\nCongratulations.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoNk3mvFhoHEo5ROd-c0RVQ","author":"@blender_wiki","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/V06YB2juY_6auR6m7EWEGTpT8rKwnO11Dc3u5aRcPn-QcZnDKFCCnWesb_fcYIqu9M9ezsI9UA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@blender_wiki","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyfMc2T0HrE2bkYZRF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Vibration and music causing / energy movement / opening up their, err \"vesiles?\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCC7bVuIT8uDme5RoI6ptXAg","author":"@LouiesLog","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6uxiuLgCRaipgzAeYmGqXM27QUUqLuFdvyJ9DR5cy3jR4lgrQML3EAvbfGfbqQcbfwxYPWGtASI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LouiesLog","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyiPoxtGJTJVtJQKfF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"ok but did you control for middle C being 440hz instead of the traditional 432hz? LOL","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYFLNs_48hqyU780QfxU5Iw","author":"@gregrich91","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lGxcNiTouiyS2_KXnTw4jtg2b5OmiVO6cxH5vnkj-Q7tQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gregrich91","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzAyiyKsDEhcTxQqVJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Theory number 4 the plants at the bottom grew better because is closer to the earth. Run it again with the speakers on the top row.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCt6ElAH0pSk1EDRPtlS1EFw","author":"@since1990kevin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_sXeEUCYBJ_n4crhBUncSJLAnuhQbyXqp3iEuFS9HoNUuXaKs4KEud_hhpSTay8KgTCXRytptWo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@since1990kevin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6tJ6fcsaP_ThrA6Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Can we prove plants don't have feelings?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHZp5z_PbRAStfrmGbNJO2Q","author":"@JasonKnightDJJasonK","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m4vJNGJ1ByHW-VIIYHasg1gC0ySXDs5m6VNhTwndqKxRc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JasonKnightDJJasonK","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwbFrPR-cl1kNfPrKh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Never learn formal math or language, it will make you regret this video.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFGGue2wtCjU4tfw9Y5Cdpw","author":"@lf1726","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_muEHkyYPgRr-5ztt1a45tBBagb1q-zSbCEYGExc4SBZY4sVlLtrSzm4p8vyS8G_BkK0VE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lf1726","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzYTlHo86N9VVxylHN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Not lucy growing away from u while u talk💀 like she melted to the side","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJu8PWVaDWinCmGD3JzTlQA","author":"@Scynthia-h2w","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mhpdt52gf-ewuMICMSpf58jqqKXetktX-rAgmJkXZktJrVu4vDkBYngfAtIfmb6uJy3w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Scynthia-h2w","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLoax5GzKJl9PLZl54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"vibrations were used by nasa to stimulate muscles to reduce loss in space. cells are probably just getting stimulated by the vibrations. string instruments play many different pitches at the same time. more vibrations than other instruments = more vibration?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQOk17UfYdjiIR7ctCDal0A","author":"@zeragus707","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m0F3eE052Hx147f0yax7R2Cfbd5bEle7iRpXy76lIjfQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zeragus707","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzoUJtfVoH7sAQrBoV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The basis of a practice is to do it…","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDNcUwGJHEWeKh4WgDu6HLg","author":"@TheFurlock","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lFuBIjHkCjYSIccpBCOGtWkA7HObkUQzgzjnuXWxMXQw4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheFurlock","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxajxMJVhnJixuQvZ54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My plants and pets definitaly get affected positively by music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClGkTmTkTNcG75HsgxBH1aA","author":"@patty-bettychronaki3001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l1vtXzim1eC9Txoi0PL-TUXsEOBDhDI6QPA6jdD8kTHb8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@patty-bettychronaki3001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyjnDyH6yqp63tgZdF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did I miss something or did he not have a proper control? Sounded like his control was still subjected to the sound, just at a lower dB.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCr96_uSvhrPTbUyrEChGXGA","author":"@leesonneville1817","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lW-51MtAooNbaGNbWzNS22HjPg-13QGfRCammzTKI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@leesonneville1817","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0uG38so2t2elR2O54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if they grew bigger faster because you paid attention to them and gave love to them and the rest was placebo? :D","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMGjz6oB41a_arBNHoZuVSQ","author":"@kaiowasdeath","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9ANb3ep4UeeZ1vB48mZ0zW1OkixvNjjhoqmdEaIw_X72vNQIoqUlSYvxmvCJOsG21mxdYaGpjA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kaiowasdeath","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynaBG0cObvL7erRSt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sonic bloom","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQWz64j7bpoCn__QCggSdpw","author":"@Greg-McIver","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NSuIq9I0o3lFrY5IjzYDwA0tAORhTa6Z4k9GJBZAtyQZ6xYQFcAba0IlLs3l0Fr955ewXY4qxA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Greg-McIver","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy_aHd7TNEcpxebC9t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"thank you, Benn. I always really appreciate your incorporation of articulate analysis regarding the liars subterfuge happening in society today. I share your videos with people who might benefit from your knowledge. Am I to understand that you are self-educated? You didn't explain beyond your not qualifying for fed loans.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVbGlcaBw6S7V1GLSHTjukg","author":"@UnkleBen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_4AlbsWj6o2NgJBwN3O02dBHmImdEU2uf08lBXWPziE0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@UnkleBen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwIsZ0ImGeLOa5TkWJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"https://youtu.be/6xHF1WB1loU?si=iActr_G684TueSNg","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdCssEt_SvzZisQbG94eqOg","author":"@TheMowen21","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOYZwDWn3ewD7tTx971f3PCxnaUywKUuL_TdesW0U7NKcu=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheMowen21","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwhuIKg_iX8n5xMklp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Where my grow garden players at","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPO-fZ8dk65uYrVBtqubYOQ","author":"@TRKhero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fs-LdDm7u6RetUGTwctjSuioQY04WP2T2zbUMUiN6Ul1UawvzE2Gp_ZD5xAuMBZ1UUMU-BaAVA4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TRKhero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYu3o7glI4VccbDxZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I used to grow fire weed back in the day... Everyone wanted to know my secret? General Organics GO Box fertilizer and The Beatles 🤷‍♂️","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDEVEOymGuCX8yyEtZPkLnw","author":"@DrScott666","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mhPmVB6oLhoiXKeir6vpuv2uDJ0NZUqk0OQpOCxDg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DrScott666","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2ZnJCx5rmFFo6Zxp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've never seen a difference in seed weight...Only colour.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPLk_nTVIxBiWsuj4KHjHBQ","author":"@t3dwards13","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Gk049LfOwSSK6DFf0uPUaNydZW5nBBTvQzZzmm7hrUbr4DazouM30pQiH-c8FNYQmx09RmJB4g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@t3dwards13","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzgJt2hgOwDNef-GsF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How do you know it's the sound and not the electromagnetic field generated by the speaker circuit? If you run an experiment with a non-electrical sound source like a string or a bell, which can be rigged up via belt to a motor which is in another room. Isolating the electronics could be important, then you can say you tested the effect of sound on plants. Otherwise you can only say you tested the effect of speakers on plants.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRKnl61Et9kywfcF5b3cpnw","author":"@jugbrewer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nWlQisgPUD6dh5IN8Q_W7EuU-Uo5KxUTpD999XdUc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jugbrewer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwb72djaoQAeaogvhl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"From what I've studied at my university, Gödel's incompleteness theorem deals with the nonexistence of proofs for true statements in logic systems, not with \"there is no hard binary, everything is about probability\". I'm not saying that you're wrong, just that Gödel's incompleteness isn't a good example for what you were trying to say.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUiaZQO8kOLAOoa8mS81Z6g","author":"@user-vn9ld2ce1s","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lqjU4E6LvtoXXle9J5V_tlZdoLElmydBZM736mnNw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@user-vn9ld2ce1s","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwIouZZqwR-58s7eHV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i bet all of your compositions are in the key of LAb","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCt5Gp0N0dhhEkgZZ2gt5isQ","author":"@jamiroquaiordie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJWvPa0FnIw7zrcur2--6owwj1H91FOEmFAjWI0hI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jamiroquaiordie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwOQcfh8bU2ljnFQ554AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A puddle of oxygen would settle in a hole with heavier gasses layered until it dissipates completely?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUQ6ztEDi8o5XEMN25rgcjg","author":"@kevenlaursen1790","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_meYAh6NPkc3qZ9RQbztfozX2jknUqc69hcasQTLZa7CCWY6MHmzRI1I6I59gYFhEiQXA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kevenlaursen1790","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPpSMXinSDx8-1zGN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"you cant even use the method on plants like that but u still can replicate and see for yourself, even if they say it doesnt work it doesnt mean its the truth","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6p9Dx1LO2d5itIlQY7Qx1w","author":"@EinMann123","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nXFHZiA8-Ik1AiYAzaDot_Tvy6voQlNI3r5q_jszg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EinMann123","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzNfGHCdjEhCfkHYd94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"jazz does it the best (or bird chirping)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_cXrN2pj-1ogspld_Nn3PQ","author":"@LokoCraftMC","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Y3XakhNP3GgGbEEF7_k7VSaNJ0dkzbx-ka7JRk25afS4tOtDqQw6-32uqpyMuGfPhKpg_-t3Lg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LokoCraftMC","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzbwgGVzUbEnNtMuLh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is it possible that you are using the speaker as a fan and simply mixing the air better so that there is a higher concentration of CO2 near the leaves?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzXsZIwAcEr2rgoQqJQLDKA","author":"@bernardkermanadventures5961","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nENfWgCDhDp48rp9auJt1X_GL6poxQ0k0ejoBLpJV9zA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bernardkermanadventures5961","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwY64M5jrAnOgxE_hh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why do you hate contrast?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0HGqsbhg4-_heMtgNRMI3g","author":"@remedi8r","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lkDhfR4IQoQOti0IosPsSAEqhLLgtyGqmMmRGIpKBIdhtOTK_iy1Z_GU0MKBc9sh8dlA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@remedi8r","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyTfKgE_c3Ns5OEkxJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants can hear themselves being eaten, other than that I doubt they care.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClmuTgQ77WJ9FKAn3Nu0MXg","author":"@chitin122","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m1zECtUWwDk6Z9g_6rOZA_RX9nkQUKfcdMjLF93axfWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chitin122","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzA-yhcmPA362JSgFJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"12:57 What you probably meant was \"neurotically\", not psychotically. 🧐😁","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPNAPrJuMWGrlzPJjDFXIoA","author":"@AkiErebusGR","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/q-GHo_inDLivBBzTI_Xz8RN_wl1Mqp_R8fsAjXKR7rinES-SoyL-FM3YlOtkBMhq3-0Kvu4dUvs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AkiErebusGR","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxTVACNAl1eYSfyrsF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Nope, you're spot on Benn! I gave up Environmental Science for the same reason 😉👌🏼\nI came up with to many real world questions, solutions and viable alternatives for the content they provided 😂\nVibration, temp and bio-ionic transfer is VISUALLY observable and measurable from leaves to roots, soil/ medium and symbiont mycology/ bacteria. The shape of the leaves, flowers are an EXACT bio-formed energy collector for that plant's sap, sugar or seed production. \nLook at a dahlia flower... no, NOW... look at it. Think cymatics... or scared geometry? Nearly like a sound or vibration collector? How and why do bee's, humming birds and pollinators find flowers...?\nNow every tree, shrub and leaf shape take on a different meaning, yeah...?\nI'm just a mechanic mate 😂\nPeople like us abhore ignorance... so, aren't good for corporate profits 🤷🏻‍♂️\nKeep pushing, learning and creating... your content gave my brain EXACTLY what it needed after a debilitating work accident to get back into nerding. My brain too needs constant REAL input, or it starts eating itself... and depression sux 😅\nMany thanks from Australia mate 😁👍🏼🦘","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHh_kUIDGbDUnCGqCUJlGOQ","author":"@Jnr079","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kP4erGjnAUhiNQ0VnPGXooaQw781Bn_1h1gK1YHwah-AhDSPIfdE3GhM2SEw5u20eWVtLgEe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jnr079","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyqMfTNd89_hCmETpJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Would love to see a follow up rebuilding from the video about plants have more sense https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E8SJlyrEDX0&t=2617s","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZCpyxM9GqmpjYekveaMSnw","author":"@ALongBlackFace","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Zr_k3oUlkSkE87Pt3v_Ud98bX4Ja0kNHpusU64bR45fXeG5hbqtfXsLBPhEc06mgw5O0dsh2SLA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ALongBlackFace","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyVWJV5TIjbj5xASVl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"9:30 shit dude I think you smashed your chicken","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZTlybz5VpoJr1-yJPp6B8Q","author":"@Tobio-DEV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ALHGBN_vgEya2zcVJKkH17rU-AvHwFhhoKtZfPlXzJjQN3hrwaYWQr0bZDgl1gH3Qv1MXACEIQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tobio-DEV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxmNZNhoThGGakBVv14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"good thing our governments are investigating how sound can pop the eardrums of protesters and not useless stuff like this","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3x1XjEh-gtwTljoQaXYDYQ","author":"@croozerdog","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NxkOo6ypYo6Yha3nwfll33Kt5ZpnzFbAA9HfhuUxpbJoBw57SWMz4VZ6cGPzrbyeiMQQ52g20w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@croozerdog","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzvgvBc8zvzjhyfDSR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"HIS DRIED SEEDS GREW 30% BETTER......  that's news!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0mRegZEFk33Cy3E3wvoG5Q","author":"@shaec3405","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/aWPJLBohT1N3NtZ40geVHGzze-Yfd72xfh6c8ltSIWKrU7QUJ-LmqKTWm2Luhhk_gevJEDxJnd4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shaec3405","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwgPJ6RVVOSEz8LI6N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Frequency is the real key 🤷🏻‍♂️ it’s well known that it helps plants grow","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdrod4picC4o8WSGYB8sX2w","author":"@Highdrogrow","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_npcUR6XsdtEyWk5O0DUPbiBwaX_JeUikuODvjwubz_UpOPbxUG2HLiUrAGCHsdKbjT0g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Highdrogrow","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2SmT5VXpjpLal5XF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Isn’t sonic fertiliser what comes out of the mouth of most people online? :p","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC805iakZr-lWanZb0d7pGzg","author":"@LyraelRayne","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZKlO3RKWiKoCdyTzleurZgbov4SIwuZY34HTPiiMCW4-8pm68BL3F2FmI7SOMIdCzoT3EWkOvg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LyraelRayne","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQk_pwOF0vxhYbQp14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It was proven on myth busters","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyWFhAwSVxmD0dhqouZNatg","author":"@JMunny816","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nQWtDjnkGaIYmOsk65bxLAmt6sDD9KGCnr9j4CzKha7Ht707dqW4PbsI-coFFXsWHIFA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JMunny816","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLW6xVfdHEAwOQ6Wp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Another year, another update?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxHo5sy8PLalR-Ma2zIPlvw","author":"@randomgeek6035","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3eSdJrs9xkcAFM7kExUd2KzasO2x_y1BOcwBOQFRsO4jhq02GQpbHzLNdWF64M9fNlQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@randomgeek6035","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx5w4amawabaEREpLV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"maybe the americans knew about music affecting trees and thats why there are giant tree stumps in that arizona valley","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCt_o_2I9s0BgGfBjhLY4Gsw","author":"@shockshotz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mIV6YhbbTxCUueoAttQE3p-Rz9BqyPyW14lsmbFVQ3Vg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shockshotz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyAes17PqlDwN9IP2B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"dude i got thrown out of school for marihuana posession too.. That didnt break me at all tho, my family did...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCV_tqrfRKVMvzoMiGY9h--A","author":"@krystofon","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yjVygg0FV46BDN5TMVS-WLc5ED1GYIULknla-rLp10C9HPftjMpV5JHO7mg2ABiNaPEoqA0A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@krystofon","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz4RGpO3rY_jbLOpJp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If quantum physics is teaching that our observations affect observed reality (double slit), and if relativity teaches that our position relative to something changes it's effect on us based on our distance to it or interaction with it, relative to everyone else (even something as seemingly foundational as gravity - as shown so well in the movie Interstellar), doesn't it stand to reason that the act of the observation and the thoughts/emotions of the observer have an effect on the outcome of the experiment? Making it much more difficult to measure what's happening in \"reality\" because reality is really a consensus mechanism (combination of energetic resonances becoming a solid state - as shown with many philosophical and scientific studies - an example being Schrodinger's Cat) rather than \"reality\" a purely objective solid constant?\n\nAnd maybe our realization of that is why so much media now ends up diving into some kind of demonstration of \"the Multiverse\"?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCe6z7LlEVklIcCtYACzwDng","author":"@strive4impact","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kN_prZAcLlmHYAfLIO-5R5sdyFsdYoJgBNJtgzKjSs6w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@strive4impact","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxA-yoU7B4oFAi_HVh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Already been done and it has been proven","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEoU1lZpahLNRsQl4BBV6nQ","author":"@NathanaelMallow","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k71KNjoIDU-n_1aHl2C7Udyr90Svn4gTS4V9ZCVOK8AQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NathanaelMallow","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxAVR2mRj8HmPIXUJ54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"All plants grow well to Cotrane 'Giant Steps'. No plant grows well to Muzak. Done.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChFrcNu9p6CdyvH2iMv2U9A","author":"@raoultesla2292","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJ5stcEhb82kjh-J-SDRNhogDOSi28zOSPLc76IiE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raoultesla2292","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhL7u7pBXqsMuBf4p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants Don't have feelings  - well, I beg to differ cuz if I swear at my collection they'll lose their leaves... if anything they can feel energy bad or good - it will show eventually 😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZvsu-qwyDPJGmoZLtCMBgA","author":"@smajliiicka","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XrgZrNXZt1UMqt5bR1_WbK4bvvV7Eeja6P6oHtZsHc8JGOodRUrYHOa6FAadmtS_KsAfaxZDSDg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@smajliiicka","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwGrrPt1wDdMWr7CU14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't understand why Musician and Scientist isn’t considered the same.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-z4OrPzDS8eSheeOlb7AbQ","author":"@chemagracia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kc8YHKGkIWytqa0JvrZZnfpu6Cr0OARxEdqBSJrY1RVg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chemagracia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxdY-bTVSfS5XSuK9t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why don’t you do an experiment along these lines.   \r\n\r\nI’ve heard that the frequencies that birds chirp, primarily, but also other “morning sounds” specifically and deliberately open up the stomata on plants    {Stomata are tiny openings on the surfaces of leaves and stems that allow for gas exchange, primarily enabling plants to take in carbon dioxide for photosynthesis and release oxygen. They are surrounded by specialized cells called guard cells, which control the opening and closing of the stomatal pores to regulate water loss and gas exchange}    after being closed for their nighttime sleep and waking up for the day’s work load of making cellulose and oxygen.   \r\n\r\nOf course, the electromagnetic frequency vibrations of the EM Spectrum (visible and non-visible light: AKA: ENERGY) also do their intelligently designed purpose of “waking up” the world so to speak.  But you’re not focusing on light or energy, so let’s stick to the vibrations that we call sound.   \r\n\r\nSo. Do an experiment that uses natural recordings of actual birds chirping in the morning and see if  that makes any difference. And that is probably why rock music makes the plants do worse. They use a lot of frequencies and harmonics as well as outright noise, that apparently cause the stomata to close or at least not to open, thus the plant cannot function at its fullest ability.   \r\n\r\nBut, be that as it may, no one will probably read this anyhow. And also by the way, outer space is not “empty.” It is full of energy, positive charges, negative charges, moving electric Birkeland currents, magnetic fields, electric fields, plasma, particles, etc. And we can “hear” the stars “sing” electromagnetically, and it can be put together in a “chorus”.   \r\n\r\nFarms don’t need PA systems: they have birds. Birds that chirp. Hopefully. At least they used to. And the light. Both that fluctuate on a regular basis for a reason to cause plants to grow.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOiDfb1SvfjWwgM3o2ZK3eQ","author":"@spence3141","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mQlIUNV6RqSNWF69cYqbR2U4d2lvrOIA5hgMaQPvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@spence3141","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPeNmPcYJ6J0H3HyB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What did he mean when he said 6000 kelvin? Did he mean something like candela? Seemed like some unit of light intensity?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLFXlvfCRJw4l5BHpV_uxdw","author":"@Manufacturing_conceit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m5evfCF_YxC_lDCZai6PdDPi8RLB_PVhrL3a1ARTLFBM2x9-KClsWFWW2FfUzwIrVBkQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Manufacturing_conceit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPeNmPcYJ6J0H3HyB4AaABAg.AOHEjF5hvowAOHEsebNX5c","parent":"UgzPeNmPcYJ6J0H3HyB4AaABAg","text":"5:11","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLFXlvfCRJw4l5BHpV_uxdw","author":"@Manufacturing_conceit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m5evfCF_YxC_lDCZai6PdDPi8RLB_PVhrL3a1ARTLFBM2x9-KClsWFWW2FfUzwIrVBkQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Manufacturing_conceit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyM4MfaqUTxgMTuMsp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"CUTE CHICKENS","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpKy8TRypn7uGp63t38xiIQ","author":"@gazehound","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/g9qIYxVUt5qOA5Ys1CAfkJNQA1B1EJW4q0LaqBZg7EihfBlm_R2cl6LNV2ViJbJzsX533RCiLg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gazehound","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxqiQW4C8GjTqF5vst4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You can't replicate it each time well, since each plant is an individual with their own unique preferences. And they might be temperamental on some days and be totally not in the mood for music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmwNXcdR7wIGdYb-ItP75Dg","author":"@VOLightPortal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k-7DlX80Ir_EEAsIIMdn-0x6SX0Lzz3vhQH82U3Yzi1A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@VOLightPortal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzYm-0x_CTAqBTBidl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The replication crisis and pressure to publish are damaging to the reputation of academia","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCo_SqZtkmjDrnGjUVV6RAEA","author":"@TreesPlease42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RegxOjPM-aUY2ECMcLxK8N9O2vkTbIVAi5x4_BLV_6zQdauhOD9UbhiVEjbBVMPtxaBhwE0ipQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TreesPlease42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwSJDn6YeuwjyKG3SF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Robert Plant likes Led Zeppelin...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnHsX6Jtebfuo_8qnaDobSw","author":"@svena.halstensen5699","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/puL68r73xTrDOYv3-dKIisLQGJdRRtv7LiyhouYxkY_vE2_a_DUgaxPqNaXFbMETfaldkNw8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@svena.halstensen5699","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-WhLphkVfTR_x9dd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So in a previous video of someone else. He described microbes moving an going thru photosynthesis. So my theory is very uneducated lol but I theorize that the differnt sound make the plants at a cellar level DANCE LIKE THE MOVIE FOOTLOSE. 😂 SERIOUSLY so at a cellar level they are moving an excited. An thats why different music like rock, classical ect there are different results. So as they move they do there job fast an better as that shT there design an job per say. just a thought. I'm sure there is. More scientific way to say this.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2aYUA2dFfY3Ab-gQTVJafw","author":"@StephenBreaux30truth","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mGCcO77qRAILeeq23h9y6AoVb-S6jhNjs55xh4H1JqzRtYoueMFrSC8S9Y7lZhzF6Tww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@StephenBreaux30truth","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwrcseGxxjOv5QI-zF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Nice oud man","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKVPXnD5tkaZl1e0g0qxHuQ","author":"@jeffreyadamo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMSKMQ-_M4kvOHvKvJmY0Qxfd7i2M0qg6xHGkwRIS9wgc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeffreyadamo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwa-7cpecG9ogEyhXR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:35 bro what, no\nStill a cool vid","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuhe8wJMpWMdoTrRIt5UOmw","author":"@gimp7194","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bX1FL_kj-QOob05K6qpT3OKO87KeamQvN7YmB0Xiv1nQIr1xcHvx4UVxIHWzaJ-4-sveI57XCQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gimp7194","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxV_J5ukOvVHaVeSUF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Soooooooooooooooooo\n\nThat's not what gödels incompleteness says at all","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUSZ4S1q3Q4QaRAfqJpMLVA","author":"@xxJettSecretxx","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/f4-lglXpzPvgBWwmQobWzg1F5hrfl7NaeUBsz1i3by7iZeM7DlhR-0BguKMXd6Yf8WTjF6Kgsg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@xxJettSecretxx","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyMiTaf-1KNaMs3wvh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’m pretty sure Einstein was a citizen scientist?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChMBRWkkwujv-NI4pzbZM7g","author":"@grundyian1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kQnSacL5yinB1mg2R5LrN95ZCnlAD0vvaW8soOzxQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@grundyian1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzSP7P48c4l2T61LSJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Not true what you say Ben all things have Musical Preference ;')","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCIIIl2Y1fZhkzJx4yYHe_VA","author":"@RogueVigilante","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nUcnu8hRmQ_rd0cO6g9O53Q94j5G354kHtUmEPgFWo3A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RogueVigilante","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyOEIOHihG4gNF9JE54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"how do you know that the ratio rusk x inner matter contained in the seeds is the same throughout all the ones you used? Seems like a flawed experiment to me. Lmfao just kidding, brother, that was amazing to watch. I found one of my people. Thank you.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9IbSDFJAmYUQ87zAssvnWg","author":"@ninguemezzm","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YwcqNp8zGfvI-vVvngulqVQifxwK0-mL0mizZ9jIsCtN0-fJAbVCxsP7w-IKjI3cTksXYhLJzw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ninguemezzm","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6shzVTRopOHYAAP14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe a little experiment with plasma and sound might be a better approach the normal speakers.. https://youtu.be/Abyh5F186yM?si=KWfdqEgKsbut3Anq","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFx-QfhCRnZ2GNmIuaIgZTQ","author":"@livelifeimprovisationalLIMP","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k8NFQ4gFXDrpYbmjAK2t31n88HnFP5WD_ilqNGE8sUtrM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@livelifeimprovisationalLIMP","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYfPZwsvBc3IbTY0d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Am I the only person that thinks he looks like CM punk","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqUejiXcbrtzkT_ClkhN4kA","author":"@andresrocha680","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nATaj_XyZ449yTpyY9GNkkpedOEjet8B9ru95ikqwS3Mf-MXvcS1UlV0t6a5VEu6AwMQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andresrocha680","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyu1qmG5zHu39IieD94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I read they discovered a plant last year that could reproduce the leaf shape of a nearby plant. Then they separated the plants with glass so they couldn't 'communicate' in any way, & the plant not only reproduced the leaves, but when they replaced the focus plant with a fake plastic plant, it still copied the leaf shape. How does that work? Some media sites picked up the story with click bait titles like plants can see now, but there must be a more logical explanation, besides the whole thing just being a hoax, which is also a possibility. But if there is any truth to it, could the cells of the plant be picking up acoustic ques which could some how let it know basic shapes nearby? How are the plant cells in your experiment picking up on those frequencies? Is it the liquid inside the cells reverberating or the cell walls or maybe both? Could the plant be using sound's effect on it's cells to see it's environment similar to the acoustic camera you made? What mechanism in a plant cell could use sound? Are the mitochondria reacting? This is really fascinating. What are the effects of vibration alone without sound on your seeds? That could be an interesting control group. Could the magnetic fields from the mechanics of your speaker be having an effect? Would a mechanical tone like a bell rung repeatedly by a non electrical motor at that frequency have a different effect? Is there any truth to the classical versus hard rock causing the plants to lean either toward the sound or away from it? Has that been replicated? That would rule out vibration acting like wind to stimulate growth. There seems to be a real connection between plants & mycelium - could they be reacting & in turn effecting the plant growth?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCc9BaQGRAdkXLLap06toXDw","author":"@itzdono","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kmojqW9SA619vahkG0OOn7GfczchJztuLRg1L2s-sg_U8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@itzdono","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxtKKzJHXnc42GLgId4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"really a vacuum pot! yea okay.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEUsH-cDf-UPUsj0F1zKstQ","author":"@dtw-b8m","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8tzJ2KFXYjSm-fq1NMdWBeYog_pG95TqQmeJ9GfzttrZ7EBWtknd_32BksfwMcTOixmcGaL3og=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dtw-b8m","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-gwILSKiz5mo2Z8p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You shoold have used clones Bennnnn.....😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxnFAai0xcFWwydA_ckY-ew","author":"@harvester5050","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxUtdQSF2o6DoUQgbfF_PIENQX3ZsbVvod6Nhlg-4fOo7OikZ8V5GSUCvFIVhUL-2oTw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@harvester5050","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFnWpnq7mU19ztAfx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants have evolved with being constantly shuffled by wind. \nPlants distribute nutrients via liquids. \nMy guess is that sound simulates wind for plants. \nHow about adding a fan to the tests?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnih_QbkB8p_ely1dHuBkdg","author":"@Effect-Without-Cause","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lelDMi8j80UQ7EGvFTTEzwiwpuCSm0oj3qZ4Pjqp6_dp0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Effect-Without-Cause","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwF1u6WpBnmezNcbcZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wall, a scientific theory is inherently in of itself, not an opinion, whatever caused the theory to be formulated, is","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDwpyucTUfsed3VPDY3AzpA","author":"@oniswdbs","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lmfnUpVsFMWjQjO4BpPC8mdd-983xThOkb9MO2r5n2EHIJbd2NhLgnnYwRRX3zP7lqEw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oniswdbs","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysnMk8zEW1tCvFxVB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You are pumping mechanical energy into the enclosure and the plant cells and that's likely to manifest as increased temperature which is going to speed up cell chemistry.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCspMfkS3YeUuk3ZkwluPGiw","author":"@fluffymcdeath","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mzxfR4oyncbw9GClzP1X9wW0LX44DfB0V2VLJar87QIQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fluffymcdeath","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxdilKyxBCPyXLKorx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn, didn’t you say that “if one day trees could speak, they’d say very mean things”? So who’s anthropomorphizing now?? 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdgSzCDelhmLWwxp3Kp-vnA","author":"@PrognosisGnosis","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/s6tRer7SJbwWSt02KedvS5JfY2jXP8OBiSRH32UM9G6mpNgX47UZ6WKqjIayQQogTzEQCkBSNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PrognosisGnosis","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwsJux-cs8ckItxJ9F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why start from seeds? To much randomness. start whit cuttings, basically clones.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpuFSlsB4KMNTHz_RuiTE3g","author":"@coin777","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lWq3QVL2224YwKPKTry76FrzgYGPa-Bpo4fYor7pNnyw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@coin777","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxWAoOUhaTMHeIhCnB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I pray for the downfall of the greedy science publishers. They don't do the work, they don't pay the reviewers and then they charge profiteering levels of money to access the work they did almost nothing to help generate.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPJmhM5RccoDQTuk4bmFe1Q","author":"@fc11abcdef12345","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lpQeIfdMtj2QhWpncDs_3-9ZMara6-irDTGJ6ctfE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fc11abcdef12345","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy2LLGMTz9PimcKZmF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I like to hear music and i have a larger biomass on my belly because of It, i think youre on to something.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCciJzcsQcjBErhSTa0BUzPw","author":"@maximilianoroldan2808","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kzDt_Fr2jiHeO1gx2NQfknlPmrV4Mx62BQEkhhEZjA3Pg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maximilianoroldan2808","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyBguv5ckuqYoPVXeZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"CO2 is heavier than O2, so the plants on the bottom may have access to more CO2","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUIzBG8MkZZMGKu6VtfY5OA","author":"@jacoby6000","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m3qigHlvp-OXiBKV_EGgqPuPOkWCiyyEw873RWvjVFCA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jacoby6000","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyOKgvdkYLSIKH0rkN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're so awesome its annoying","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC87ShTH-xVOK1AfKfzhG18g","author":"@morgansomethingunique","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5gfkyW2o846swneH_stmGqGmw8steCkbGqvLo-GUH87gQQ1Y_05Ks4P82Agg4Pquru40agHh=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@morgansomethingunique","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzt8SefCGKg2l-tsXJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Do android sheep dream of electric grass?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRcO-O_FitiKdHreStuJ6eA","author":"@jeffreyleonard7210","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kDM2ii_t6J3vYZ1e46baZBofw60FqCMQXpZc5ka-7i6D8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeffreyleonard7210","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDhF9Rfo9c9CIxB6F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"FREQUENCIES\nMUSIC TUNED 432Hz and not 440hz. \n\nALSO MAKE RECEARCH ABOUT ELECTROCULTURE. \n\n .","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgXLy3BZvEjaGiIPnveYa3A","author":"@Jafaaristo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_la0atrgqHXqr0WccyKWYBfSSOqZfIt6MZgGKH6hcM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jafaaristo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw0bFD_MqSaACFOT2d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did you try rain sounds? If not try rain sounds.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOQWM9smTr_eTTcgLe0HrpQ","author":"@ー-ーー","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dfrQg-_9WV7O4r4mjc_OltrojHKCV3shdHwqAL9j77GYT1Gwv91-e7_vmYRZmWZj8x7poDBR=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@%E3%83%BC-%E3%83%BC%E3%83%BC","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6Jsr_IRglUfeHkp94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"“There is no binary, everything exists on a spectrum.” *chicken drop*","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnQevKAM512i6ydTUFK_uSw","author":"@Kaiju-Lightning","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/S4hrlX49wNsJ0C7M58BA-COZpDCryWhNLtRuSW4ufiYBrkMAmrDByMtbrm66epriaOF-Zuxftw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Kaiju-Lightning","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyuTQ71augpUYvW_TR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"before i watch, did you consider the fact that plants need wind to get stronger branches? maybe its the same feature via different method? would make sense and its logical that stronger branches grow better","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvD3VwLnoQ-rVONKTv548Bg","author":"@felixmikolai7375","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mSGzPPJmmjuTlpyFiFbzyERo4T21ZDx_u1Au6v2Cw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@felixmikolai7375","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyuTQ71augpUYvW_TR4AaABAg.AL9D26OoWYeAL9DRxv7uf_","parent":"UgyuTQ71augpUYvW_TR4AaABAg","text":"and how comes the japanese experiment about words shaping reality in context to this ?!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvD3VwLnoQ-rVONKTv548Bg","author":"@felixmikolai7375","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mSGzPPJmmjuTlpyFiFbzyERo4T21ZDx_u1Au6v2Cw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@felixmikolai7375","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugywt1Gfpg_rgvwCfwx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Shhhhhiiit.. my plants LOVE Ronnie James Dio.. 🤟","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTiBnk6PUay0K5yNr5XSVgg","author":"@skeemask4933","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/OFKFOD4RyfP4bjYmFuHwyIjfl_7f5y8_XVBcTWa3abfPytt151MY_uJftTbB1O5DVxXelprF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@skeemask4933","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9_4ydrUExt9mpAgR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Are you still working on this experiment?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvI9hcd7sOwYmPmWQaAOobA","author":"@ianmckenna29","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n7n9p9mI0ZKWcJ43hL3Lsl6jgfKUlEG6DNdSQhkiW3KAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ianmckenna29","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyH9KK6q6XzO-eDEQp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just when I thought you preferring to talk deep and creepily to your plants was the peak of the joke... \"All plants want to f*** humans!\"\n🤣😂💀 My tea spit everywhere!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYfPqNVUn_uV0UbOtujyC5Q","author":"@Ohh_Is_That_Sooo...","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JYqNzLAfjCstCqdty0ogh0I7imdjEA905p6YwHI0CF6JgZiDMxztE_wzzqw7uq39i823CbNKIg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ohh_Is_That_Sooo...","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 weeks ago","timestamp":1789084800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBtebFzWHKzTx5elp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"1% of video about how sound affects plant growth 99% waffling about scientific research strategies","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8aPB6mtOE8NXKLjHukET-w","author":"@Harroldsharrold","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/86bz-dHumZB3fWmpMQIagp2qK9VbG52-fRd5QdptQio3E_GT_0Ee9O3lSb6d4UKRbPizReDllA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Harroldsharrold","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxq4-vvTqNuDiIfmXF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Another one of those videos where a single thumbs up isn't enough. Hey YouTube!! Did you ever hear of rank voting? ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐\n\nI totally forgot I watched this a year ago. I need to watch the 6:56 link","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfwpABOUuFUHo4kmpEjNceg","author":"@tomholroyd7519","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BobuthLB-7763K4kJiTjIndvmyws5C05ZR4FPSdw7Z2ZYQrWp5OtcXXcgrCOEnsqrXygr518=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tomholroyd7519","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfrLjvMofexpSSoZN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Please clip the mic to increasingly weird objects.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZTlybz5VpoJr1-yJPp6B8Q","author":"@Tobio-DEV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ALHGBN_vgEya2zcVJKkH17rU-AvHwFhhoKtZfPlXzJjQN3hrwaYWQr0bZDgl1gH3Qv1MXACEIQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tobio-DEV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyBp9jhW8jBAZxx6ot4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My plants in the room where I listen to Metal music grows better than the plants in the room with fridges and freezers and less music, but flies like this room better.\nAnd the room where very little metal ever plays and there are not friedges or freezers, ahs the worst growth and almost no flies.\n\nThis was not intended as a bad science comment, but rather:\nI am not so sure that I beleieve that plants hate metal.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKVFkkxpcOu6RKfxZZ7fvJQ","author":"@MakooWallinen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7MzX9nR89delrMRkOZxtzp45G8sCilNClZ4pneeuQn4AQaT76io3e4qiYSc15JFTWP_9aqqT=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MakooWallinen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzajEWVi_dSy19td4V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well now I have to go apologize to the guy talking to his plants I made fun of in the 1990's :face-blue-smiling:","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgL2fjeoW_8Ugfz0t46Y9Eg","author":"@onomato-l9g","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/U_-6vbBOqIVlgERe1ImPXZs16nzC3EwNWZ5hZoC9Spr7WrYzyfEACpAEl0GXgBZnSwSGoI7QqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@onomato-l9g","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxDPcCGptb7md6QAmJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I only hear chicken noises","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNWJssRJY7e0_ZstsjGwEQg","author":"@lirothen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_khKqy1dUBHxRuXL3g7-o6V0LFEWXOGXPfeLGoRKRP-LQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lirothen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxnMkCca7iF2KkPXeZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I only skipped throu to find the awnser, you have a talent for talking around the subject, probably to increase watchtime, however, im pretty sure that there is a variable that you also have to consider. Is the water you feed your plants exposed to the sound aswell. It does have big impact, im pretty sure you know about the rice in jar with water children experiment. Ive never tried it but im sure frequencies carry alot of weight in this world","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQ8zOhF1cSao3PQIezYayAg","author":"@downwind_lee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k7awZYIuS9vJ2n9kHQXnXV9bVWaPOJg1vykU8ft-llABM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@downwind_lee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxWO69-O8V827NPlGh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The way you peer reviewed “the sound of music and plants” is literally why science has slowed down in so many fields. The greatest scientists of all eras were nut cases. we told the nut cases of this generation to shut up or conform.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqWTOfXYA6PxNPFHtJ2_ueA","author":"@Green-Bean1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/z8BU-WBBTlYgIHB7ct-tTj-tZbIW-IER-qhJgU1No78z6I9zgqckEu6yMVKDVfTkayho9Y4hdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Green-Bean1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzkvooVLJrlt2wAbfh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wow...19 minutes of inconclusive experimentation....still fun to watch though...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWxxd3FuEv7zrWlVq_kd73Q","author":"@VoltBolt777","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h67RcN2cjT_ywxNOHkB2KCCk4uU7N4wuT3b1dt1VPrfm9e9kYJJGZ3SeG2Hb1mkdWAv4y6loLwc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@VoltBolt777","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7kAfvA_hjLozUSMZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Westerners discovering the the myriad paths of the Dao through science . \nPlants cultivate the Dao as well","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAiy3vBShZw9d2yy2qPXphw","author":"@LostKernel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n2rg16CxxE6lD8pWH2CZsci4GUG0MTY9ZVKp4_RX3QAEH0XR7T4W2564Pl7k8XQ555Mw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LostKernel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxmZwF7sTnEp-sC6Kd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"and again as i go down these videos i am wanting to give you a little crypto","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNge41ynQAfJeVgFX_PqHcA","author":"@pebcak420","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WwmK7nt1Tbki5uMGQxycvfL8WeXspjtWtiidlwecq2jSZlRGjammncCKgH2rCylPYPtHSUe2gUk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pebcak420","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwlhh_-3t2P9Cs6y_14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Oh, my plants like female rappers, they told me actually","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqZjSZDMgNJ1qPKHpNObABA","author":"@clayirepip","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dGRJ74RjJEMjjDwQAV7Sdlh1VLvoYXoAtpPTWNkzdHiB0jM-epWkc8bDtgZS_e013zAZcyZ2Lg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@clayirepip","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyf39q8-sjMbvZ2KF54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Anyone watched a episode of Mr Bean playing music for his plants ?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTANUAInE_PzEQPkrnVAZ0A","author":"@raidoes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RCz0wFqw1jwTxSP6aWzUWU1zgC_mekeTqR21UyrwjpbM4-_6PJXKU9JdUEJ4sMDDa8h8b8J_MlM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raidoes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzHrXyAhHB1v8r9HBN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"the scale being balanced and calibrated is not nessasery. since in the results are all %based as long as the weight between the seeds is consistent size shoild not matter, unless there is a resonance frequency fenomina happened them weight actually matters as it would determine the natural resonance frequency of the seed.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuCspKE1lA4Y-HM42H86QGw","author":"@KingSheva-sh5qw","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lWAWV9_ocxo0zm_8WvBOlfNFMKz0rvfW8smisamjq24TfC=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KingSheva-sh5qw","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxDhIBgzGht7GkqmT14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Science is designed to be falsifiable. Science challenges you to disprove it. Religion is designed to be unfalsifiable, and challenging it is heresy.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMEJ7NUZxUCbiFMQ9g4z26Q","author":"@Lardzor","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m4vVsJS4h0nK89t7NhEDnSTHgRS9HQ9tHFHJCe7580ktk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lardzor","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxlhcnxSRrITELK8Kt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hey @benn jordan i love experiements as much as everyone here, and i hope you will read that comment and give it a thought. \nby changing one variable to the environement to a living thing, you slowlly make them evolve, and make them dependant on that new environement. take away that environment and the living thing will have to evolve again or die. \r\nto every experiement n+1 n+2 n+3 etc should be taken into consideration. \n\nIn most living things, if you get a positiv, you also get a negativ. I am not saying there is a direct parallel, but bodybuilder taking testosterone to help building muscles ( overall biomass increase you could say ) the negativ is that they produce way less ( sometimes close to none ) of their own testosterone, and thus have trouble reproducing. ( only one of the problems ).\n\nif i understood well you might still be continuing that experiement now, so a follow up would be : how does the seeds of the plants that grew more with the sound are behaving. \n1- can those plante even reproduce ? \n2-does those baby plant get even better effect from sound waves ? \n3-can those baby plant grow worse without the sound waves ? \n\n\ncomments are always too short or too boring to read so i will stop there","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6Q8hd18ozZ7zKjecPHDunQ","author":"@renecotynotreraisanous5594","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNCZg-cuFiosCLXlNmEHlmwEUVLwg72RCqcgBCPBhlSCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@renecotynotreraisanous5594","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyZjiHmRPyG92XLOw94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plants prefer heavy metal","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXA9DwFYs4LKGL4OJUQuVbQ","author":"@meb3153","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kfurqBXvKjpKhsZWRzjh5ZSDAeaG6LDh5BL0nx_tNqEDI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@meb3153","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFOc8Mu-Fmr5hipBl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Science is not a blief... its a method... and you should not believe science as it... if u can replicate something twice or 100 times, that means that the result is true.. not that science is true.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCnr8yzx6b-MAfxmystYQFOg","author":"@o74769","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llu4D7TiTYjjuhmOxbWO5RT4jKlrgHy1oL87YE3sfm=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@o74769","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzt0l2Di9IXEJZ4PFF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"sound helps plants grow because vibration means more air flow? 😂","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCR9RfItoHVEmmGgYHDJMInQ","author":"@SilverScarletSpider","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/q0j6CeYvAIADNyEC6as2RXnnYJUMwMcfZBoikQCNImAwtZ6Hm6_Qk6p5YiwtKRgi7rf1lDZY8A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SilverScarletSpider","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2mEOBDh7VWoF42QV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I have a thing with my ability to remember numbers, i don't know why but this number jumped into my head as soon as i saw the title of this video 528hz I have no frikin idea why or where  i may know this number from. But that's what my stupid brain does lol.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIyfJyqdews3CLe66fjfuPg","author":"@imaCupidStunt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kobtIKB48kYbyoIbTaEMN7k6Obdij_-kVeSMbC28jaAlf34P-acLGJTORMNvUS62PM0Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@imaCupidStunt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2mEOBDh7VWoF42QV4AaABAg.AXBVe78GXzjAXGcHrqxI02","parent":"Ugx2mEOBDh7VWoF42QV4AaABAg","text":"Your brain is beautiful friend ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNKtdoyAG9MUNqc9fhMaS-A","author":"@Whome.1122","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kNJc9RnBGBiYAcGAPzRP2vQMy9skHrI069ZGthQ8UhrfNMbfsmOyYes_FyBWwe6GTSzg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Whome.1122","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxfY5VYIQVdZA3onc14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So that's why Vegans never shut up.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCw1JiGo08p19e0ujMCxPc7g","author":"@zer00rdie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nx9JkZKaW0j7mXtsLfvWeI_3Gjco_wTpAF0hoV8QNi1A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zer00rdie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxSK79Jec-KGdRLNNd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm commenting before the end of the video so I hope you realized this during your experiment. Using seeds introduces genetic variations that could influence the results of the experiment. Plant cuttings grown from a well established mother plant would be better suited as they are essentially all clones of the same plant and therefore far less likely to produce any variations outside of the ones you're trying to control. Gonna carry on watching now and if you do address this in the video I'll delete this comment 🙂","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCIIGzACtLFmtSyi7C1ZSXIg","author":"@meta.aesthetica","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_w9JHB-Z63tfHiX640rcz4npupKNKN3_2V_I-71oSKo0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@meta.aesthetica","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgywpixIj2mt2dkNt754AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But plants don’t like boiled water","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClpdIOkW1sbejSXgzddKGJg","author":"@maindem","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lDbIsKnlOqqwedk6N3zyFUT4rprL6LIbJKulOzLJPVjYqXZjXPVA_ykplP-wghwuKZ0bl1st=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maindem","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx0_9aWaO85dthepNt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"We have proven that plants can \"see\" (as in the mimic plant that can even mimic plastic plants) and sense \"touch\" (from mechanoreceptors of cell membranes). The idea that they can \"hear\" shouldn't be surprising. Scientists regularly underestimate the intelligence and abilities of life because they think of the world as \"mechanical\" \"materialistic\" and thereby functionally \"dead.\" I say this as someone with a B.S. in Biochemistry. Scientific assumptions fundamentally underestimate the universe, because while dissecting things tells you a lot about an organism, it fundamentally cannot grapple with the thing as a whole. And then it takes dozens or even hundreds of studies for scientists to grapple with that fact 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7YCD0v3PDCz6Nlzw199pCQ","author":"@Purepeacezone","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pbR10LGraj5OAFHegaHkeg3I8tMoGebSQlsuWGwCwZ45KtAna2UrDVq6XQ3Ue50tfN3IaoQeEl8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Purepeacezone","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwv27gV7gbbQUxGCRh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Carbon dioxide wouldn't hurt them because plants take it in, split the carbon from the oxygen, and \"breathe\" the oxygen back out to us. It's fine.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCP19pZWcwKCmf-RY1_9BKBw","author":"@jessiehermit9503","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nnj8ePmgoblzRAUeoLFCU7WX3QWQ3e_yFtJhc1_B-KpQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jessiehermit9503","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxODs1cpA0Bmeswo8h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The scientific method couldn't be that important or else why would they avoid much of it in the field of virology?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoqN6SWtscN_rzMEsUm071w","author":"@ricoloco2803","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrC8dU1qXQUJcpoZX5Zxc53GkLZD0bJpJ2uGOIu8oEXH0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ricoloco2803","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxhro9DMXd5aPbyP854AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My plant's astrological chart says it will grow faster if I play it some Mozart at Schumann Resonance, just like all the industrial farms do -- because they like profit.\nGet it?🤔","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCC1LywlpuP_PjV9FD49THDw","author":"@morgan1719","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nrIvC2Bk13bkFQ406Yc2iisQS8qydXODVGHIoKAE1M8PuT=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@morgan1719","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw1DhMWZ35CRG-PvWN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"two thirds of published research is at least slightly wrong","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC43sRL7IF7QJo1c2KArJ2eg","author":"@tutacat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTrrHNGPRIMVPlGVJWJRUZyPKZgYzMHAYeE5q4nDRgYMMh1I483VD9E0r_pf3-S3k_iQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tutacat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyaIw4vb1FIHdByIRF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"YOU HAVE CHICKENS =D","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgiSxi-FRCfuI5jE2-cjbYw","author":"@chickenmaster3879","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XZ5jt5Kg2vEv6YLGxfTJrYU_RY5VhY9-ZQ5Zxov3j9dhmUWGdrSsySTwq7fISeYtJkIvM3B3QQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chickenmaster3879","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxEjATiiLA3gGb7Hr14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just because you can't hear it doesnt mean it can't be heard. This is bad noise pollution that is disruptive to nature.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHRXz8qKHsqmTcQCwwBHCxg","author":"@chiefschillaxn1781","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m0YqgEYG9VqPd4nIa7ZM6phEwvW7jeQaGuWA8zAwQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chiefschillaxn1781","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyHqnXLT7z0Viu3FBt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dr Bob Beck","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBqpfP7pdC7TFUO4oGD9Xcw","author":"@AJFrost-kn7iw","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m-yXe8H_xRB9ZsKvDkoCJsHw3V3UePbV2XMhweMa4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AJFrost-kn7iw","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyT45WJ789AhkMhM154AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"😂😂 7:28","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbIGPzKLMpj4rob_OXbH4SQ","author":"@Astecheee123","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n9VzUkX9wcEibRnhZxqNJ4q6wl8y5l2gCoo0GkxzpGkak=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Astecheee123","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxFRwl60-knrNLUKrl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The worst aspect of science is paradigmatic thinking - For example, we have a fully unified physics theory, 20 years old (Basic Structure of Matter - Supergravitation Unified Theory), that has correctly predicted dozens of findings, inclusive the James Webb findings. It is not discussed and only ridiculed at best, yet nobody wants to read a 600 pages book to even make himself informed. Absurd world we are in.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvPFCKJjnBZbzfRnUJrr3Eg","author":"@AllToDevNull","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_koo5wETQgMoxhxZhmL1bg0LO-nxEhPeji70LYnk2A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AllToDevNull","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwRLqxfdm2tlhcEWWB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey who are you calling a stupid hippie girlfriend, both of us were thinking if music makes them grow differently!😂 It's something that I've recently been thinking about since my monstera actually seemed to react to the absence of music, I've since tried reducing the amount of factors. I wonder if this is linked to stress and movement of air in general instead.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3yiZeKV3X2fxmIe8PcAa2w","author":"@inxomnyaa","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XubbjywrHFiCQol3DJ8_qN6IXxTComKXUalIWK8BLTk9WWWESDWLTLBnCg6ml6QVooNAuXeJsA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@inxomnyaa","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6NUREQ0fnBzClEXp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0-15% increase in repeated studies so idk","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1M22sv4OnSk99zc6m0nTbg","author":"@kekceo3942","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nPr7FlfmuALoS7vQjEM1EURuGZzI5cyFkxFC20N4RNAg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kekceo3942","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz1H3IyKh3fmLVlAJN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I would suggest a simpler approach. Plants are alive and are in constant motion. In nature plants have evolved to live with wind. I would suggest it’s simple vibrational movement causing the increased growth. You’re exercising the plants with sound by moving them like a gentle breeze would. So do a study with fans and see.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHoE-kDt6dgKeB-Z4p1xSMw","author":"@joefeinstein6804","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mkUmaWtZF83pynh5eUQSeIg6-8Rm64xXPuje46O1vMUbU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joefeinstein6804","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwfzsTVvRCNnqu5M5t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The reproducibility crisis is about widespread malfeasance.   Whch is mostl done by people NOT in a system of \"capitalism.\"","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCxtqW7tDiSm8jsObrE9Nh3w","author":"@toomanymarys7355","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k-2EP3dq0bHXqp7KglKmy74hRGgXJ49VkXuohwHuulEA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@toomanymarys7355","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJuHhVhcSZJ0PIbVZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Water fighting Entropy somthing something ask me later","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFOmSJZhMTbORtGt8Qvxi7g","author":"@oouziii4679","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mkvXEyWqxN5qGPeg81GD8aaLK6w-iUQ-wZz26Q3r8uR_8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oouziii4679","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGvqb0t4dPHJ1Ip1x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So you can't get a student loan if you get caught for a small crime, but you can get an education IN prison if you're there for long enough.\n Hmmm. Why not kill the fire while it's an ember instead?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKhkoxfasaA5ATsVPCUBYGw","author":"@flawmore","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LKeU5dXYIqlAJzUQ3ffJWH5W2WbVFpCH2R_7jWgMhswmVHq7xWyDpA9RYNYGB-ZowA4SKetjpQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@flawmore","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9FXfHzmJ2VnAigVx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Space is like gay.  At some point, ya can't breathe, and you realize you are a bundle of rocket sticks.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRICD2dg4cC62kJcnVtLErQ","author":"@obtorgecirb2100","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/I_h17dwiIz8JT3Ah-2VljQKR_xI8rC6imgetVQ31MmNU4MqXmUMngqRebKdRcoVqaOk41VLobaU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@obtorgecirb2100","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzRn5yvy1S58FEYEgN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"my plants like Metallica","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChpyXryDfSHG8-YoI9RJ7FA","author":"@makropixel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nn_gfmkVOesEgb6oab6LW5iSakSmlP6V8cyoGqatnK1rD75MmkpgLpVlllyAIAGhvexQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@makropixel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXptGyI8feaqSFvqR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What frequencies are created by a plant in wind?  Would a plant, who is a product of thousands of years of evolution, react to windy areas by 'shooting' or increasing biomass. Theory being that depending on species of plant perhaps it would be a signal for them to shoot to out compete similar plants it's ancestors would have had to out-compete in the past.  I think even framing it as 'out-compete' is silly as genetically it just so happened to be the superior way to grow in a said environment, not like the plants are Rocky Balboa - take that grind set folks!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbN1WbRdx_tiGfXCcU2KU1Q","author":"@mdfalse","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lO2EzCejbLWFo4r2fY_gidG7a7XfBglccHlcQlCcc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mdfalse","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-sy-U_0MzhNWDgVR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dude, regarding your coffee.... The MOST IMPORTANT variable is your grinder.\nGet yourself a good burr grinder. Seriously, it will transform your coffee","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZep8cjQd3Uei3CuCiEah4w","author":"@TheSe7enman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lg5UfyNrYk8hdCAv6UG9dRYbPsfZNNZsg1xw0Do_Lv5wA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheSe7enman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyWCEgmK2GY4qK8--F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The replication crisis is because null results don't get funding or advance careers so there is a huge incentive to lie. Similarly, replicating studies doesn't advance careers so those don't get done either.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWTQglFS1yWxVAO38eduAFg","author":"@Brickcaster","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mKJ4KEEw3nTO0cS9koGmqjF-1lDtnQgr6Hq3V7tdXnGw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Brickcaster","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwn1rdesuBUda_j7j14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"That explanation of the incompleteness theorem was... really really not accurate","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQ1O9Ent8ipOwKV_rRx4_Fg","author":"@FoleePrime","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mrufPgi9aoFpTaK9PCrWEh-C5A0Rd5qmQ5mqSN7w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FoleePrime","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPsVYfpRO9J57oJAF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If the idea is sound, it has viability. Does it matter the education of the person who came up with it? The formal education systems are other people telling you what they think is important and how to do it. It is the individual who has the thought processing, the ability, no matter what the formalize education may be. I'm a lifelong learner. When I finish my formal education, I've been educating myself. The best thing you can learn. Is how to learn. How to seek the information. How to process what you're taking in using critical thinking.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7SXoHx8upvVuE2RLg_zPPQ","author":"@CRMcGee2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ntCL9Y8Xzo1fUnhO8vZkQRyu7pxqPMCwM0aNMDBte5tg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CRMcGee2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyB4Z9MxKoKk_p299N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Vibration expidites osmosis, it's not 🚀 🧪","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOQo-YhPDwqicEKMV2tMzzg","author":"@amelliamendel2227","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4jVUxes5K13oh8H5BNHHQyl9pbvB_MrWrZQF8rmnMgMc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@amelliamendel2227","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugze0taH_QkvqprzOoN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"... being completely fucking wrong\" (shows picture of RFKjr)\n\nI bet you haven't read his book, have you? You've got your conclusion and aren't about to let the facts interfere with it.\n\nprove me wrong - you read the book?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC-b84eZ5nGl65Cbhcjt8sig","author":"@DiligentNinja9","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/uTsI9LaUEJ9vyfxmKKkcPWI-bwLPcLDL6RoyxXyc3iVZbqSTvIswEsFjMCvdTZB-NvpMJWY0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DiligentNinja9","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwE4tzITjEUX-BiH494AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I play Donald Trump speeches to my hot peppers 🌶️","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCccyVxwiWXs3WJLzIXqg4qg","author":"@mikewho341","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/gCWjtdcWUzNyw67y-EqJf_WOr_BR2sTby9Jaz7P3Lhu3Tu9DtUBhkRU5kU9cTi_Z-gdw308zPw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mikewho341","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2ZaBYiYOXBIxTihF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Saying plants don't have feelings or emotions is risky nowadays since The Telepathy Tapes podcast aired. Non-speaking autistic people with particular psy abilities claim to routinely communicate with plants, animals & other humans telepathically. On rare occasions, neurotypical people have some of that ability. Note this ability has been demonstrated in scientifically conducted tests, it's not just hearsay.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQkrN1kiiQmAqXBd7IxFJvQ","author":"@meetim6271","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/jXBnfhcSuJpTR25ekBA-d0jRLuosqTHZ9LD5qKoeXYsXPYRNIVAp63swfZjpbVcQ4sY0HgwhRks=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@meetim6271","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIRAMy6tB_uoadPs54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The only problem with science is the bias caused by the corporation or entity paying for the study ! YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR !","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0LcAC_bxMxzvQHUvzFx2DA","author":"@wideyxyz2271","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOU2RATsZIjRkm63O0Owz8LU4CXyfAoL9nQtXpOLUzNxM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wideyxyz2271","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwEUI8vFmR7FVSdduh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Kent Hovind has talked about this for years","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCp8ffixNneZwEOhQd2swLeQ","author":"@roccoelliot","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NykMxeZUdKJpDe0REkAhTomOJu2dGMgJvVYNyfAoSmxQeFBz_YUgtYbyGTjxb69MXw1GJ8GZ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@roccoelliot","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwC5sOPRXOqFZxV-dJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn, your experiment was interesting, but I primarily want to thank you for calling out the classist redlining of higher education.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCChsRKHVmwX-UzMf6hEFtog","author":"@hahayouarefunny","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Ox4Pt4uLosPZC5U9JKmaXGWJ_3Z8XTKTG1rz9vIfLIFLd5jYAsiqJJev-UC0dAv6h4Q3hv8n=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hahayouarefunny","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyfdkYyE0-KJROZh954AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I believe this works on humans too. Listen to heart warming music like contemporary Christian","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSQTkxul6CebQBwbzFcB31w","author":"@Jep-x6m","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ltG5Vixvi3d0Yh00mrIlUB2on93_zWY8hkMojmBpX9mvBiNJjt4vNgL5Rn8XCPf9bnFg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jep-x6m","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyR4JzRs0lQQNFUYRR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"do one for weed please","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC29RjVDCxaQIsrXSQH0xE5w","author":"@Yogachara","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/nizlqaxh_2DqiXkjHi3WBadqV2QL89EZ5-ILCnTmirshKIwtTxg6Td_LyWHQMbckVQL1_ovDaA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Yogachara","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzlbBQ8092LohbGhop4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think the reproducibility crisis is more about what we're measuring.  If you require people to write papers as part of their jobs just to stay employed the quality of those paper is going to trend down.  You'll get papers that aren't passion projects.  They'll just be something to check off a TODO list.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5cN2W3vIh_FybnGyWuBrLw","author":"@oggatog3698","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qg2S1e3NDR2a2byJceri94hZoLy1uxPmnal1y1n_6Nsod6cG8ZbQCd0aCJ7ao7ufFqs9GFDDgg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oggatog3698","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLz_cZ7bkvY-lP90F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yup- this guy is not for me… \nWe tried-","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCy3ah5oBcg8vPB1vsvAVPjQ","author":"@thedustmancometh","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7cgVStvAbsEo1Pn9aQIV205Pa-c1VXIr1Ew_H3Hr_0rx4_-7cv56OGK0eKdo6x3HZCzBzxJH9g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thedustmancometh","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyptpkrNk0N4VxMCNV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Screw your video where do you get your coffee maker? Your welcome for the  comment now tell me where I can get a coffee maker like yours thanks","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmYg-VJtj6ZmThyVfFTuJaw","author":"@k90rbitrescue","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m65jQZVDDaplTnq9YOtLD7xMpTVH0u8vFDNf-6ToF9Qa6e=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@k90rbitrescue","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx449Sz4M_zuoMLy4h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi I'm one of the people that beat up on Bill nye, he didn't lose his credibility he threw his credibility away when he replaced science for the golden calf of political narrative.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCan-Erp1BubQ0c2lXMs4bMQ","author":"@garfieldwithissuez","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lxDCb-4trTNqMstf4z52ZbdWjEEKx8tJbErsqYzoE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@garfieldwithissuez","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwrLeKB3FqbWOnRT4p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"9:29 there are absolute truths. A triangle has 3 sides. No triangles exist with more or fewer than 3 sides. A bachelor is unmarried. No bachelor is married and no married man is a bachelor. One can act in ways the other does but they are not the same.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSETAUH3RePmTOpcwGE58Sg","author":"@amphernee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kGxvnpFOuU4oXs9Bv9C097KWIdDwec2bZaw2CMU90=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@amphernee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwrLeKB3FqbWOnRT4p4AaABAg.ANTIMr5nn_0AOGm-RHlKyu","parent":"UgwrLeKB3FqbWOnRT4p4AaABAg","text":"what is a bachelor? what is marriage? i reject the institution of marriage\n\nwhat is a triangle? i reject your definition of a triangle. define a side. a triangle doesn't have 3 sides if we don't presume it exists in 2-dimensional space, but rather exists in reality which is 3-dimensional","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgyOqWFHYfaPAVV2hAlkCKw","author":"@CyZit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yYhoALRYHKcw_OlVCisJFbOkiwP4ApxPcom4q_4S_Qv3WrL45qM2wMhqUQaK9VveHxt72poJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CyZit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxiLGcdNjBsfyAwjOV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Mic'r'crimper 🫪","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXJyLofn0iLo2lz23Z1_ZZQ","author":"@Mike-m9p4k","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mNkj4pW6jUvChG4gBzsrYlBtzdpsU-SuNMu6MPKVmDoCxY2_D05vAOfPJE2IATJUm0Sw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mike-m9p4k","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwgh1fAWR_f-VUHggJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"All this science and dude just throws a rooster. 😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClXT0FNJwUIl1FCtgXvreuQ","author":"@ADHDeezNutz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bsDIvWwelPf8KXFRozPTpHWFnojTJFCmdWnDacD3lFAarS_4bznwHiyKCqRd0xsF2NSZAt_x=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ADHDeezNutz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwybbEmWlJPB90FF_p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I loved the video, but the one aspect i take real issue with is your explenation and interpretation of Gödels Incompletness Therom.\n\nYou said (in mathematics) \"there is no such thing as true\" and the idea that everything (in mathematics) is on a spectrum from probable to inprobable.\n\n1. Yes truth is not a subject explored by mathematics. But there are absolutly things that are true in a given system. Escpecially if we are talking in laymans termes.\n\nYou used truth in the \"universal thruth\" way. At which point it is a meaningless word. The fact that you do not get universal truths in mathematics does not make these things not true (in the given system).\n\n2. But my main issue is that you said it's all on a spectrum. Which doesn't really fit with Gödel. Neither the incompletness nor the axiomatic nature of every mathematical system, means that they are on a spectrum. There are thing which are on such a spectrum (in a system) but not everything is on such a spectrum. \n\nNow this \"everything is on a spectrum\" is a valid philosophical position you can take, but it does not arise from the incompletness theroms. It is instead philosophical and not mathematical (even if it is about mathematics)","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCzr-y_CK84Xsu8ta9xoktDg","author":"@gifs_for_the_peasantry","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kEscP1Qczub17e7ObSjEDeftBTgN8aQHHyRXdXLyHz-g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gifs_for_the_peasantry","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxZkev7fSGqjb6OVAN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maga, if you ever learn to read and listen. This video is for you.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiuwvNgYouv7pktPjC6qOVQ","author":"@lynnwilliam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGiaPm00GNQg-B5ZGyTGZM3l4k5_cPv9-5ZLHfgws=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lynnwilliam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwm8vW_d9roQj2ukIl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you're here to appreciate this channel as fun video the cinematography effort story telling and pacing is top notch quality. As someone looking to educate themselves on this topic:\n\nIll save you a view. There is often more variation within a plant species individuals then between differing plant species. \n\nThis topic has been extensivly studied. I discovered nothing new in this video. This isnt peer reviewed so this isnt a meta analaysis or synthesis i could actually use to forward research, you didnt start the video off showing any ecology/agriculture/botanicle/biology credentials, so i cant even call this expert opinion. Essentially this is brain rot packaged as something trying to be intelligent","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChlY9pboS-tR5BNW9UdmLVg","author":"@Alpachemist","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/K0mDsvnvkkrMHhQ6KRkpivrzkv1OxhElFGRtPweDRR59wuMFAyS9RUnT3yXc5biu_nhGaFJ8yA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Alpachemist","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxY6DbslM3X4tTu9uF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm a Christian with a Masters in Theology and read Greek and Hebrew lanugages. I ask Christians all the time \"What does Jesus mean when he says \"X\"?  And NO ONE can tell me .... except a \"preacher\". Same thing with peer review in science - if you don't hold to the \"Orthodoxy\" the \"Elites\" said was the \"standard\", you aren't welcome to discuss it - even with the right degree! For Christians, the authority and standard is ONLY the scriptures - nothing else - not feelings, popularity, etc. What the Greek says in context in the earliest manuscripts....  Sciences have a similar authority - reproduciblity. Theoretical physicists piss me off, quite frankly, declaring one week X is true, and the next week Y is true, not X, and the only thing that changed was an equation on paper - no one looked in the world to see if it is so. Same with Christians. Religions are deceptive - Truth is divine.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCV6rZtf5d4nl-dbf3aZ_iJQ","author":"@bjmurrey","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/jysQgY2ugFkcK5fjwJH9j_vGJQk96_5oUlBqqGg_9EiPVaR3q2mPA7I1BxWcuOn0Ey20LHvPpQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bjmurrey","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx8NepXSYbW_KFXiLh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I was about to say. Hendrix has got to be one of the best things to give to a plant not the worst. That makes sense now. Anti rock propaganda","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkcINm5FVCqPLVOt3NG6XeA","author":"@jonathankosyjana","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kn46WnoIubZBTFOQ1X0lROBzgVSbyM-QZesae6PawqCTs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jonathankosyjana","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgydQ23nXfFIORVauJJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You need CLONES for your grow experiments, multispore/seed/spore/germ cell genetics are highly variable.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmqbWrNlRmPdqoIF_U-UWQw","author":"@LemursLabMycology-e6i","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fbNfcnTNv1MN9Ma2fxsoUtIkb7eyW7miqFgIr2Ep6L2uU_J2DWgKGbmOr-VitTBd5rWKdE8J9w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LemursLabMycology-e6i","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyWkS6zQYnipOVLLQt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Our world was heavily populated with bells.. they have since been destroyed..  frequency is very misunderstood..  ask Nicola Tesla…. \nSoon we will be treating illnesses with frequency, as Royal Rife did, before they (Rockefeller) labeled him a quack..","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUNQZ0dooVLN8cJ1zX7LRvw","author":"@zoeyshoots","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8rbGvVxHBeHg4kd_k5N3AyZUbNb9rTxHl6IIDuaQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zoeyshoots","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzAP_ZDrF1pgUZEv8l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"you need others attatched to your papers to publish. we should talk.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvYrksARo7Aquez01n2Fkhw","author":"@Phil_From_Canukistan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZCSc5cj_SGGYx8ixi4l4T83-INIjPnJIzrdVtU9ki3uW9Pk4Rsr4kagvRjHfBTfkg5JXIDXFTw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Phil_From_Canukistan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxC0NOFFVOiXBivbs14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This would be another argument to increase sound-making biodiversity like insects or birds. In an \"undisturbed ecosystem\" plants and animals fill every niche of sound frequency. just listen to the sound in the Amazon rainforest. Lush, majestic!\n\nSo probably, the \"natural\" soundscape helps plants grow?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYABrSDfs2vSCs2GsDojFLw","author":"@jollyjokress3852","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kwwKbvGjEUuHSt3oHxRVVFZUWym7E10TZ9VGzkHk8Rx3w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jollyjokress3852","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGAQq3_hTKjiSL1kR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"how did this become a political message","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCnLZ5mQMgxowuRAgy42btxQ","author":"@d2ccio","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6YBeIV3Xt5i6ldek-THa2P6_byPEwvLV74e9hQNmBu_cZsf7YxJGCxcRq6zme-DgBh3t32lc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@d2ccio","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGAQq3_hTKjiSL1kR4AaABAg.AJl4TMJUc3mAK6hsrTAl9w","parent":"UgzGAQq3_hTKjiSL1kR4AaABAg","text":"not just a political message, a political message that directly contradicts the message of the rest of the video lol.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4QiEoSTkO8VFDPu1ca68Qw","author":"@face0001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lziHycyh8NSZpgk-9BnembuSmGg7ufcwMBtBl1U-VI7U8Dbo9yF4kgdhowTJBLsuIz6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@face0001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwbpynDJIH1KGvFr-V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Fool, my father doesn't believe in gravity. Denies computers and science","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCj7N8sSAdYMOPKCM91Wc-CA","author":"@smikaFPV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5cUvHkzTpz5bFAX1WEhuqOBhDO59P4v6Czc3wHlj0sWxTKrSxj2pbBdsbiZ85kubTsJI93TrKk0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@smikaFPV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwl9-X1ZlGHs4RM89t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You should have explained a bit better how every truth has a level of detail and context it applies in. And that any demans in change in the detail level or context xould toraly turn thw truth of anything around. There can almost always be more reason found why something happens than is known yet. Causality is a huge chain without a limit to complexity or resolution","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDJpiYS0I97ncugtBb0Kwrg","author":"@lucelxebinog","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_leFFe8KMeL6dviJz4lflNtiouNm3lwAszN8UUFbfSwdMLOPurEgsecMSCzM5JDe-AUAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lucelxebinog","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx5Y4cWPzwDYf_Z1h54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How can we fight and stop Maga ?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiuwvNgYouv7pktPjC6qOVQ","author":"@lynnwilliam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGiaPm00GNQg-B5ZGyTGZM3l4k5_cPv9-5ZLHfgws=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lynnwilliam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxlb32dFaBaZrlfn0F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I graduated high school, and im a fucking idiot😅😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCt3q1CyBdaPPlykVQepqqrQ","author":"@randellcrawford6361","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mJt-idSzocn6k5MweDSX6vL7VHtbW6bYm9QUQP_s8BjF4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@randellcrawford6361","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwFjtYNPKC8AeVnqgV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm not a mathematician and I won't pretend to know the intricacies of Gödel's incompleteness theorem, but it takes a little basic philosophy to see that your interpretation of it is contradictory.\n\nYou say that Gödel's theorem proves that there is no such thing as absolute truth, but absolute truth MUST exist, because if I say \"there is no absolute truth\" then the automatic question would be \"is your claim that there is no absolute truth absolutely true?\", your answer can be \"no\" and you basically discarded your argument as false, or can be \"yes\" but that would entail a contradiction as you say that it is an absolute truth that absolute truth does not exist.\n\nMoreover claiming that a proof proves that there's no absolute truth is like saying that a proof proves there are no proofs, and that is contradictory","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCaJRlmjFb3dUWE-LN6q2H_A","author":"@Furetto126","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ORz554TJWKrT8Y1vUB1e2o3sPkf6rS363zbm8qFef0b30xXa2QgBHTA4xcB76s1vc5s2HzihnSA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Furetto126","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxTTjRx7UmxYdbK6qt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hmmm so I see the capitalism argument.  But I think its a more fundamental problem:  PEOPLE HATE BEING PRIVED WRONG. In North Korea they have the same problem, they just aren't allowed to talk about it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaeiZnq76gJ04AUetD1IO2Q","author":"@dollardelights8953","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m1oCH_LsdAdZnkYpSnQoeAmHGYrfqj8izksIpw-G9ue4Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dollardelights8953","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzNH5rY7Xx1qhWGxSl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Money and science shouldn't go together because they result to bias/misinformation and many other problems. Today, they are glued together. Also, I was disappointed you started this experiment with the assumption that plants have no feelings.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_VZPFMkdcHnWe_meqAIegw","author":"@AfT-ip7bl","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nLOZiVoOnOY9sRG6PEfbeJQZgNEc94Ld_-R0YhapW-QHpFlNNHtQIwpPu8VJKX5wVYKg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AfT-ip7bl","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyzjf76kjaaNrBy_el4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Science can't explain it. Layman can explain it, but it lacks the tangibility of formulas and graphics.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCS9THQaA8CuNLZ-4KMEBhRg","author":"@Sav.B58","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/995GCmpcVjPqr_88AOtjzsjzJY_psXJoFvad4X3f37UYpqlx78JmGH3XxTGXd_5o_iQDWZefqA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sav.B58","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyua6zrt82PTTi_H7t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Too many ads","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCr7ISabrYsBf_CHxRsygSlg","author":"@Bob-y4x1t","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYQvAmUyrYtkF2soc7ppz6IxaER9_xGSrVZLHiG4eUGMeY1Tl-U5nqn34h_UtOew4GdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bob-y4x1t","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx60uD3C_ooX70pP054AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is great, but gatekeeping is actually pretty useful. People shouldn’t need advanced degrees to be able to have access to good science or be able to sniff out every source of bias. We can’t know everything, so having some shred of standards and being critiqued by others who know what they’re doing is a good thing. I’m all for anyone being able to do science, but we also need that science to have some value to it and I know that’s vague, but I think we can all agree that if there are no gatekeepers, the environment gets flooded with bad science and you can’t actually find any good science. There’s just noise and no signal. \n\nSure you can trust a select few people, but that just makes you more biased. \n\nAlso, the incompleteness theorem is a bit tricky and it gets into some weird semantics. The way I think about it isn’t so much that there is no such thing as truth. What does truth even mean in that context? Everything is a lie then? Instead it’s just the idea that any description of reality or way of thinking will at some point be self-referential. You have to make a baseline assumption somewhere that you pull out of your butt. Or you have to have an axiom that you declare as “true” without referencing something else. It’s profound and also not that profound. \n\nWe are conscious (whatever that means) and we don’t experience the world as it is. Instead we have a bunch of sensory data that gets processed and we’re the act of that processing happening. In other words, we conceptualize. We can’t not do that. I mean what does it even mean to know reality in its entirety? In order to bring a concept into being or a way of thinking, we have to declare that it exists, so we create a definition. This is sort of like how direction is meaningless and doesn’t actually exist or is “true.” But it also is true. It’s preposterous to suggest that orientation doesn’t exist. But in the end, it is just a way of thinking. You declare one direction and then the rest of the directions are defined in relation to that one direction you decided existed. Same thing with mass. We arbitrarily decide that a certain mass has a certain weight and then everything else is measured in relation to that mass. But we can’t have a concept until we reference something else more fundamental or we’ve gone down that rabbit hole and just decided it exists. Direction depends on space and mass existing, two more fundamental concepts. Mass is something we sort of just decided existed. Of course reality is reality regardless of how we think about it, but mass helps us out quite a bit. \n\nWhat ends up being true is what is useful. When we assume these concepts exist, can we solve problems and achieve goals? These ways of seeing the world are really just models of the world. Models that we use science to test. If our models are true, then we can use them to predict the future reliably which means we can plan for the future and we can use that to achieve goals. If our models are wrong, then we fail to predict the future. No model will ever be complete because by definition, it’s just a representation of reality. But we can’t continuously make them more complete. And as we continue to make the model more and more complete, we’re able to gain more control over our environment and solve more problems than we used to. \n\nIt’s not an excuse to dismiss science. The models we have built with it are almost certainly more complete than the models some random person comes up with who doesn’t use the scientific method. The proof is that they work better and can predict the future better than the random model which makes them more true. \n\nSo yeah, incompleteness just means that even mathematically, you can’t create a conceptual worldview or model of reality without arbitrarily declaring that the foundation of it is true without any evidence that it is. For instance “I exist” is a classic example of that one thing we assume without any reference to some more fundamental truth. It’s just an assumption that is considered “self evident” or in other words “self-referential.” That doesn’t mean it isn’t true, truth kind of loses its meaning when you think that conceptual frameworks have to be complete in order to be true. \n\nIn other words, don’t get bogged down by this. If you want, think of things being less wrong. Truth is worth pursuing. It’s worth being less wrong and it matters that you are the least wrong possible. Basically, nothing in your life should change. This is just the nerdy way of saying that perfection and knowing the future perfectly are not practically possible. There’s always some uncertainty.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCglpbtv-y2_BVFxY9hBRZMQ","author":"@scottkidder9046","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ltvEtstLuZfrJkcOuDW2mNl1EO_PidTpA3NRxqWayQF2g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@scottkidder9046","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyJ3s3tTFIYY9lNHLh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The fact you said plants dont have feelings like it’s a scientific fact seems biased.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCozXVtP7SVsLJhcFhHyHgOQ","author":"@itsadoggydogworld323","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Cl25vgSkw835CnmmLoHI8cnDuStEn30r_hMwYgvMsw1htUSr7_HTrnNtO6LJpYpsJGoy9hK5Dg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@itsadoggydogworld323","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx7hhlSU4Q_hXogTZ54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It would help if you lose your far left political allegiance. It might help you see things more clearly just like the passion you have for understanding whether plants improve their growth with sound or not.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCig_ad-c3cT6dOwHTtMRbSg","author":"@teachonlywhatiseasy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kSGfJDEc-ehaGCvwnyuNBr8kfhML-Yew76Nj8hUUSrrke4-fZIU5cLYjQMy1xZcxRHzA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@teachonlywhatiseasy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyuxp3P-53O5vFhPg14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The reason I hate Bill Nye is that he pollutes my search results for Steve Nye, the amazing 1989s British record producer.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZxo54li6jkrq9PG8rncMkg","author":"@sea-ferring","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VR7gEB9tLORsw-Cin66S_Mnbkf-Fzh6z7w5A7aHZTrXye2u0E4D1HEH9cd7wNSGmEXTZ5TZtyQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sea-ferring","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQIBr0HhuzM2kvVxF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Awesome work but you’re growing the wrong kind of plants in that grow tent!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3kITKBSsH9AsroTCW6Ai_w","author":"@johnnydough6244","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m76hrmQSXybFdOog_2HX8ypdKVqbkz7vzdcpgCMRY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johnnydough6244","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6USGb9RADP-PBKwF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dude bill nye was my childhood hero. Note the past tense, because I went to see him in person in my town for an event and he spent the entire time talking about how Elon musk, Jeff bezos and bill gates have technologies to fix climate change. The Q&A even had planted questions by the MC about electric vehicles which became a huge Tesla promotion. All out of the mouth of Shill Nye.\n\nThe entire presentation was bought by and brought to you by the billionaire boys club. It was also the day I gave up on becoming a scientist, realizing it’s not just the people at the bottom who bend for funding their whole adult life. Wish I recorded the event because it was world-shatteringly depressing. Never meet your heroes lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHQF-qLko209QVAbtjKja0Q","author":"@reimidietrich2394","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_niCZnfNt6stOXfzXux6dXwhp6fv7GnNObFjuzzGPEDv_s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@reimidietrich2394","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6USGb9RADP-PBKwF4AaABAg.AJpvOF480DjAK6hJsfqcju","parent":"Ugz6USGb9RADP-PBKwF4AaABAg","text":"did you also cringe at the \"'sponsored by pfizer\" ad he had to throw in the middle? lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4QiEoSTkO8VFDPu1ca68Qw","author":"@face0001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lziHycyh8NSZpgk-9BnembuSmGg7ufcwMBtBl1U-VI7U8Dbo9yF4kgdhowTJBLsuIz6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@face0001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2m2aGcw6KE3fQ0bl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"science should have never gotten as political as it has","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYvshn47HTnIoHCr6qjl2rw","author":"@Filekv5","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lR3SDrwSJDnzv5GGpQptQaot3MpHVgC5bdxf-qmHsF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Filekv5","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr8YY01Xepi5-RbmV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You say a third but I'm going to tell you 2/3rds lose their data along the time of research because they are not well equip with engineers who can preserve their data and records. This ends up in a scenario where data is unfortunately lost and they can't reproduce the events correctly.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7qQMehVTx0iFRPPs5RS20A","author":"@Cookies4Wookiees","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mOYO9EkkSmEFqIESkA65A-y-og4NbHnoVAcnbPurI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cookies4Wookiees","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxn9yW0TbFngOyafmV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Proste ujęcia, ale czytelne.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyGTlAC6Q98-z8YDpfSAvzw","author":"@MałgorzataMichalska-j2s","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hR73MuEGpYm-FDBdzL_AT49yik_IdgD5cPn_Z9zeuaNip14bYjFL8bVg83oJZYs0bZgVJAC-UQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ma%C5%82gorzataMichalska-j2s","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz1Sdb8Lt4WOn3Ppx94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"long story short i think you should have used fertilizer in the water or/and use clones, but there would still be caveats, i dont think you can get away with a small sample either way","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNhiLNbPpICT9_7GpKDLkig","author":"@boogieman542","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l6LfiGUOovI1gGphSJuRe0J78AzT4UMRYC_hyCjtiSi8XqkNILzrxpVmBSvC9ns51YqA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@boogieman542","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz1Sdb8Lt4WOn3Ppx94AaABAg.AWs-d3W1RA_AWs3NeWpbTL","parent":"Ugz1Sdb8Lt4WOn3Ppx94AaABAg","text":"just trying to design that experiment gives me a headache\nSeeds: i dont know weather this aplies to wheatgrass but seeds at different heights will have slightly different nutrient makup (\"strenght\") this is true for basil and plants where auxins play a big role\nClones: i have noticed differences in the phenotype(branching, number of leaves) of the clone vs the mother plant depending on what part of the plant i used\nSetup: top plants had slightly higher temprature (i could be wrong if you used a fan, i accounted for water) bottoms had more co2, also minor diffrences in water vapor pressure (can prob ignore)\nmy solution: use 40 plants (34+6 backup)\ni've been experimenting with basil (i like it and i grow a bunch of seeds and cuttings every year) changing nutriotion, microbiomes, rooting hormone quantity, temprature etc my official results: inconclusive my anecdotal results: 500ppm 3-1-1 NPK, more rooting hormone better, less light in the rooting zone better, more light on the leaves better. However i have had 100% success rates with plain water and a bubbler setup as long as water temp>20 C so doing more is kinda pointless","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNhiLNbPpICT9_7GpKDLkig","author":"@boogieman542","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l6LfiGUOovI1gGphSJuRe0J78AzT4UMRYC_hyCjtiSi8XqkNILzrxpVmBSvC9ns51YqA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@boogieman542","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzoRNtTDNpFALzlFxl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"@BennJordon Hey, read mine (please) Mr. Jordon. \n\nAlso excuse my lack of education in English writing. That I insist. As you can see.\n\n\n\nSo wait though, this Gödel business. Wouldn’t it mean that his own theory rules itself out? \n\nEh, nvm, or no, I mean forevermind.\n\n\nAnd doesn’t existence also sorta rule it out as well? \n\nFor instance if you read this, or not. The probability is questionable. But it does exist. Even if just in my memory.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVZVYfnD7gRIX0CEPa24Swg","author":"@j33tsud0-t9s","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nnAi_oSHKjJEKwqVDxQHOO3zkIv5IltpbQYyG7hKf2HkaNfV_LPb9_CrTBmyqxIEhu9A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@j33tsud0-t9s","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDJmYA9p_qQvwyYmp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"this is literaly the worst take on gödels theory i have heard so far. it never talks about any spetrum, it just proves that there are true statements that cant be proven true, and the things that are proven true are 100% true ther is no spectrum","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCJfy2cWWeGE2GceoiVPct_A","author":"@gubunki","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_qpPsUqHbbhHZVnPkNOGHOqHb14Yiy-BMO1_gkjn2B_IXBI2bO1IsqVFgQmr7KdXdrg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gubunki","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXgLDSAL4BVg5MYvh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Repeatability doesn't bother me as much  AS the \"no real Sterilty problem\" \n\nThere's not a virgin space that humans have not contaminated in ANY way \n\nThere's NEVER been a true CONTROL.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQC2OqVDmdLc3loSZBWweIw","author":"@thewinterwalker","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/uJr1YLt_oqXzJ2Z5cIOPzV6_eV7zHOR7S7IpxefiwbrIP0Sb0SskY3uZmkjR6x2rg-L5A07sLQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thewinterwalker","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy4MQlliPGGnXAk0Rh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Creation is Fractal based. Resonance is key. Every scientist is religious. That's why they need their second law of thermodynamics secular miracle while blatantly ignoring the mathematical probabilities of sim theory..","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOhMXwuz5wu5Z6oLLZTH9Rg","author":"@AustinCameron","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k_-8i-djyKWJUko8iTY7xmMnuIReMfX-invNevV3jZebY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AustinCameron","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0qcvJJoiuZOy-GR94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wait a minute...  I thought repeatable results was a REQUIREMENT if you wanted a study to be be take seriously. Let alone published","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjFSC1MkDsQ90Iz3ZfbA-fQ","author":"@zealobiron","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mYPQRqaYD6bhdsTxu_xJdGKKNoxJXDFxLoBBSQNmoNMw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zealobiron","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwxQlWfYnG8gMSjgJp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bill Nye for millennial hipsters. Target audience locked in.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrjWgCNGRMlzS1Ve9v02nSg","author":"@mcharbo8726","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k2G5GlaIw8-0G-2lS6P7HW701UW68rBe-b_FmzLMo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mcharbo8726","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfOxndMOtIQrGIG4h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"At least you draw attention to how everyone is holding a mic that was NOT meant to be held.... Fashions are foolish.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgqPDWm01hLUyIGjVT5pG6w","author":"@UnstreamableMe","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ebCKY7Cbu6dOON8pK2Vqv9FISN9tTWTPTCA_CfaYaHUuKGwJ6mOf6m4Fbygb5Csv3W_BoZdC4g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@UnstreamableMe","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxq1XuzOxAXVqq9GLh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You are so based","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxd2suPqpTjl2cq9mDdCLHA","author":"@big.bikesyt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sztRWVDSc-whRV1N1QamckGF2froAOygm9EXyPfFAYHQqzXN1FBODvd8VbI4AlZaWhlIvV6QOQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@big.bikesyt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzE_a6tkbzh6G60AsV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I know what plants like. Co2. That's the reason they will grow more.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC__TLr6CbdacZKoonxxBFVw","author":"@tacticalcenter8658","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGQYu_o2FsPFy2s4a6qsefW5B6ANnjkoCVd8BevazqMw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tacticalcenter8658","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxwNc_dGgJMCJglYhd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"great channel mate! please keep doing what you do. to have a decent understanding of how scientific process works is basically as important as the ability to read.  otherwise you have no proper filter for information and you get something like the people voting for donald trump....","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCi7bhB-l-dtm5FH7wd6MU9A","author":"@germanonbalkans","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BA9N4s3pB2-TdqTscYLDGIMSyzQdXUx6hqMeq_8GRH7U8gECTjxvSzU3zghav7cQIhL1qOUc9Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@germanonbalkans","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZoclfB8oojmOj9Jh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But it has been proven🙋‍♀️🤦‍♀️","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOmwYq-KYUKoiE24WRbhC4A","author":"@Angela-heyitsLaLa","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/o7lmeF5m2ZjE4bV-IZ5o9YS7CjnLlelP8lpUoWEcmrDTJNwQ10KYc2VGTDMJ3U6ei5F_92bl6g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Angela-heyitsLaLa","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzkuLbmSfZy0FwtKmh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Godel's theorems.\n\n1) Godels completeness theorem. Everything that is true can be proven. \n\n2) Godels incompleteness theorem. There are some things we can't prove. \n\nHow do these fit together. \n\n1) Does a rectangle (in euclidean geometry) have 4 right angles. Yes. This is always true, and can be proven.\n\n2) Does a rectangle have the same width and height? Maybe. Maybe not. Some rectangles are squares. Some aren't. It depends on the rectangle. \n\nIn this case, the source of the ambiguity is obvious. You didn't fully specify which rectangle you were talking about. But the important point is, you can't define exactly what you are talking about. Or at least, you can't define any system that contains normal arithmetic that doesn't leave some subtle \"it depends which rectangle you are talking about\" ambiguity. It is possible to define very simple systems that don't have this ambiguity. Actually, for any finite system, you can completely specify everything it does and be totally unambiguous. And there are a few infinite systems that are so boring that, sure they aren't completely specified from an outside point of view. But the answer to any question that you are allowed to ask is specified.  (Eg an infinite set of amorphous dots, where all you can do is test for equality or not. From the outside, there are different sizes of infinity. From the inside, all you can ask is \"does there exist X != Y ...\" type questions.)\nBut for arithmetic, that's interesting enough that you can ask questions where the answers aren't specified.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvN-13t2V0iWtjC_O8vCppw","author":"@donaldhobson8873","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_maTQBP4GMeRtPg9_4ORSrwSbJgJCVOYl0PzBTyTcCM3Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@donaldhobson8873","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxGXHBtuwkkp_LSqDp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If I were to pin you down on what exactly \"capitalism\" does that is so bad, you eventually would have to admit it is some kind of legislation because that is ultimately what makes the bad thing happen. Who is solely responsible for writing the legislation? \"Capitalism\"? I think there's another word for what's causing all the problems here, and every agency in it is being audited now, which is great news.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQYB86W79MZZlXUPXPhgIYA","author":"@rover-e2e","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FMZlhOMHZ0eYpkfKEBXcrsaE48KcD5OYsuZHRxOm5tXvN9Rsns1c3yxtuIORejo1DzrzE-zIGA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rover-e2e","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQSZyjIIHzMBy3YRJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"this has been proven, and of course rational materialist claim its completely false, just like the love vs hate plant experiments, that have been proven in lab settings, and proven by hundreds of independent experiments done by regular people, who overwhelmingly get the same results, where they say i love you daily to one plant and i hate you to another and they measure growth, same soil, same amount of water, same sun, and the plant told i love you consistently grows significantly faster. the reality is emotions, linguistic meaning, and artistic aesthetics all carry a significant impact on our environment,  ourselves,other humans, and other sentient living beings","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtvkQY6Qc7BehWu1Yai_l4A","author":"@justinfinch2458","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kjlB25BRKgvQTqQUJwh3a3cTtIf64TaEJwYhQa_fk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@justinfinch2458","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9d9_dDiw5rFP_Z-R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Oh noes, he said the bad C word... hihi","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUcPEDo3cUha4dphwRZZCIg","author":"@Bloodlinedev","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-Z0sGqj964g7AEJyEr6y0PpLjCHLxRc8aZGWLoNOPpw8VZzGS7788gmkya2R8fV3hfLx9dC8tA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bloodlinedev","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxHUaVIY5pP1wcqvi14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This docu reminded me of your vid:  https://youtu.be/E8SJlyrEDX0 -- \"New Scientific Discoveries That Change Everything About Plants | SLICE EARTH | FULL DOC\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxQdRK7K6uRnFvahHy6Vc-g","author":"@DoYouScribble2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/G_f_xg1DsGZ7orOwfeclQ07WGHvl2ikxcxS65ZMayp4IBwZa43iL3EQ_Hc4mtuu_dc0hNEDHbQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DoYouScribble2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxn0HflwLUrVyqgx8Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Man, that was a great video. I was almost in tears laughing about the giant cock being shot into \"space\" and Bill Nye smokin crack in a box car of a train 😂. \n\nI like your approach on how to conduct experiments, while keeping a open and vibrant mind about any and all outcomes, while not bashing any other author of an experiment or the the experiment you demonstrated. \n\nNow, with that open mind, have you considered this;\n\nGravity is a fallacy, and in fact does not exist. The only reason it \"does\" exist is because of the masses regurgitating \"science\" they don't actually understand. \n\nTo point out a few discrepancies you can actually see with your own two eyes would be;\n\nWhy do the clouds float above, when they have massive amounts of moisture (and when they get to heavy, it rains) when \"science would tell you the heavier the object the \"more Gravity\" it has? Huh? Wouldn't we be trapped at ground level under perpetual cloudiness all the time? \n\nHow does a balloon filled with helium defy gravity? \n\nOr a hot air balloon? \n\nNot to get all flat earth on you, but how does water comform to a sphere ( the supposed shape of earth) that is spinning over 1000mph? Take a tennis ball, wet it, and spin it. What direction does the water go? \n\nAnd if you want to argue, \" well its the core of the earth\", then why does the temperature of the ocean drop the deeper you go? Shouldn't it heat up and cool as it rises? How do they know a core is even there? The earth has a radius of over 20000 miles. Logic would tell you the center of the core would 10000 miles. What's the deepest hole drilled, or trench discovered?\n\nI agree with you, mainstream science ( or I like to call to call it, pseudo science) is getting out of hand. No one questions anything anymore and lies are getting deep. \n\nThanks for what you do. Keep it up.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwcQo7vnJLJgzN0mdP-IixQ","author":"@ryanmelnyk3293","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lfvuUhyfrR-DFq4c7Vajmc2bKAD9KToxCbEKpUl1Eu0w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ryanmelnyk3293","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxN5UjYljqpGTxGODx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"for the average person who is unable to reproduce all science experiments that back papers, a scientist's reputation _does matter_. If you look up that person and they've had just a string of whacky bullshit papers that have been widely discredited - as the layperson, I can just skip what is likely yet another layer of bullshit. And at the other end, people trust confidence from authority over facts, so it's definitely also worth double-checking results if you're interested in them and they come from a new or reliable source.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDX4HnvO4X9DIhuul8aG5Lg","author":"@0xfoad","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/e7wLvxuKJKJ8w7OioeR4VOjqm6UPZ1lTggw_bykFVVlS5ePtnDRvwzQqW5all1T5hHz_5rAFMxI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@0xfoad","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyC8BQ66XhzaFdCqvd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"why dont we COMBINE these with the DATACENTERS Of dEATH","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3ZhLIA6vBXRX5tdRJMNvcw","author":"@fluffyrabbit.9999","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2Q0AU7EwwnXcRhxU1l7tMO7KtmI7O-8ILrrrd6wi8cpOzYGD9eq5iMiWzOXzuli0X6oVKGLURi4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fluffyrabbit.9999","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyC8BQ66XhzaFdCqvd4AaABAg.AYeN1HktAYZAYeNCpaI61O","parent":"UgyC8BQ66XhzaFdCqvd4AaABAg","text":"i should probably watch the video before saying this ill be back after im done","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3ZhLIA6vBXRX5tdRJMNvcw","author":"@fluffyrabbit.9999","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2Q0AU7EwwnXcRhxU1l7tMO7KtmI7O-8ILrrrd6wi8cpOzYGD9eq5iMiWzOXzuli0X6oVKGLURi4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fluffyrabbit.9999","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwlx4_RqcveTuwNFcR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your statement about Godels incompleteness theorem can be much more precise. You said \"The only true thing about mathematics is that there is no such thing as true.\" This is not what Godel's theorem states - Godel does not deny the existence of truth. The correct statement, in a nutshell, would be something along the lines of \"every logical or mathematical system that is sufficiently complete (meaning it has no inconsistencies and can handle basic arithmetic) makes true statements that cannot be proven using the same system.\" A true statement that cannot be proven is known as an undecidable within the system, which is a conclusion that rests in between true and false. However, truth can be established 'outside' of using that system, since the system itself cannot prove it because it is true. Otherwise, if the system could prove that it were true, it would not be a sufficiently complete system.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJMNkG8pcMjLydU1G7qgzAg","author":"@Slethron","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/IMalqS6BbcSRgM2c1O_wdXPdpGiU07R1d9IE7YaeMZ8lZYuogFZiNXB-oALdQZfAwJ5FyZyl=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Slethron","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzSSeIDoG64LCE4ReB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:30 i love your videos Ben but as a mathematician... that's a gross mischaracterization of Godel's Incompleteness Theorem, even though I agree with the larger point that 'objective truth', even in math, is a myth","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0sBreN-eYj8MV4MFic5CKg","author":"@dogwithamug","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Pz5WRxPLnZh_W6IzryP6CSUZgX8DrfCY1J5D1-UsL72AuxAqOT_6dWIdfMqPfCn73nY7TnP-JQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dogwithamug","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxXautYRhNDoP9fubF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"HAZZAH CURIOUSITY","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTkSKEmb8KORQMjr2bxzNHA","author":"@guyclegg","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m4h1-wkKdb9odKL1zemHs_HKEo9i6pba39vdhiHtZ5Z7I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@guyclegg","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaFdCWhBQSgA3UsR14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So is your theory or conclusion the only one that's right?😂😂😂😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYB89yNksNDoF89chUeAQJw","author":"@chrishayes4023","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_motUlF6CxlhY4DmOsxbEIQCkNVDL_2SSDbp0x9mMowLakT=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chrishayes4023","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9CwfsB9M-Qxku4bx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a person that makes their money using math every day I'd have to say It's reliable just like gravity and anyone that is trying to say different needs to pull their nose out of a book and go touch some grass.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCF3kBE31jLmO_eTJh_qPEXQ","author":"@timmytenders8536","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m_8oMZj_A-hyz3wV-WLw2bbr5QZxzP5G7_2i3gpWGfFYoTMr2ysZ0sDfMztyKwJqgYt_AWV5H6I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@timmytenders8536","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz702RIkcdPDPvlhXl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"IMMMEDIATE disagreement about the \"talking to your plants\" thing. \nEnriching the CO2 and moisture near the plant briefly is nowhere near as impactful as the simple fact that it forces you to look at your plants and realise that they need watering/sunlight/pruning etc.\n\nJust my 2c","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRVH1Cb_KwgTW5jJuNoPHbw","author":"@mrkazman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lfAOATu7vsnhcBdK8kz7aznv5BvflBS3iagDhyEYw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mrkazman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw51o3M_ELWV-tTAhx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Next grow weed","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiuwvNgYouv7pktPjC6qOVQ","author":"@lynnwilliam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGiaPm00GNQg-B5ZGyTGZM3l4k5_cPv9-5ZLHfgws=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lynnwilliam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxMi-4Gbh-HTIXUrV54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"very interesting but terribly unfocused","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCx-3OHEVxvqBZoUoDAjJ6PQ","author":"@L0reweaver","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTfS9-INPEAv3J0XTsDEb1eJjmGCuzZoP7BW_q2Wg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@L0reweaver","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwOqsFbz_95oQMyaoR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your coffee analogy is horse shit. Certain fields have a reproducibility crisis for a number or legit and describable reasons. Chronically underpowered studies, pervasive p-hacking, and a decline in statistical rigor are all things we can and should blame. Failure to understand complex system (like in biomedical/clinical research) also allows papers that should not be accepted pass peer review. There is a reason why fields like Physics do not have this issue to nearly the same degree (String theory failures are a different type of failure). Stronger culture of statistical rigor, able to control more variables and standardize etc.\n\nScolding those who say we need to take studies in fields like clinical/biomedical research with a decent size grain of salt instead of taking whatever the next new study concludes as gospel and scientific fact is silly. The incentives are all fked up. Researchers must stop publishing just to publish, and disclose and avoid conflicts of interest.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCokYO39AWg-zC0INseuohIg","author":"@123TheArsenal321","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kuhxFxwhQsf3cURmMb4uIBgjY9Mj030AhMPyFaDkRBY_E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@123TheArsenal321","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxOT-KENfYx_uT-LPd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bill Nye lost all credibility when he said men could get pregnant.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKsbjU2DOpRaqqSrBQLqfNA","author":"@seanhenderson8870","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kWTzaIjlFISK3k0elXXxGDK0coIhTzN5ZRY8Vk5X4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@seanhenderson8870","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyG0tqd4An1ln88GwN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just get to experiment and not mainstream science who thought everything was matter. I hate these type ignorance or hiding or ignoring the real elephant","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-QncaXKMO7AVvYopo3CgJw","author":"@theministryofsound7448","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-R3KgacDzfgm22Ty9FFWO7Mr0tdCzVkVLXJNTVR_VMCt9NovY6zyLn4h3sz9lg4D5IoRHXg2JyI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@theministryofsound7448","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgweRzp1yrVp6-DKNkp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i think your interpretation of Godel is basically incorrect. a better summary is that in any sound logical system there are true things that cannot be proven. this is more akin to... say... some particular star existing on the other side of the universe. yes it's true that the star exists but the limitations of physics means that it is impossible for us to ever prove that it does.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJIb47qeeqA1Yw7ppL8hNYw","author":"@lunafoxfire","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ux_Ojzlw__2-C83f8oDXRh88FgMVv-y6eR9SDXxHLTycewXgQkHVaOhlTeJAj350CHj7M75YERQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lunafoxfire","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIbaQZ_UOxUwmSmlB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It makes sense to at least try to limit pseudo science by leaving the burden to prove said researcher isn't just going to waste a reviewer's time with awful research.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCG_pfjOtFT8Y3OC6bCtUD2w","author":"@notusingpremium","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kBZyti_EdG7Z2tPURAhtvZcDEoq73Vm0cSpJGX4RcB-exQUY_LOdwIilGHZgafdKmRUA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@notusingpremium","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyoeMiKs1iBvyc1sBB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's the deep state trying to break the Furmament!!!...btw...Science is about observation...What your observing is Jesus Working, Thats it...You dont have to understand it....Read your Bible!!!...Jesus Loves You💖","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJWPtJaxVZ5l-gmKqjRwbdA","author":"@ChrisWorthy2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l8A9KJZIy8P6fGXdsNg5ELVBtak8xNBdD9ucxC_w0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ChrisWorthy2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKGUisKpOmGjoS9IJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I agree with you that Bill Nye can make scientific discoveries, etc. My issue with him is that he has in many instances acted pretty rude and disrespectful. No one is too good to benefit from humility. \n\nNone of your videos demonstrate any lack of humility like this, so I'd rather hear you talk about science than Bill Nye.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCv7KJf8HVHYqm3Sw6Pmm4_g","author":"@pyroboy1080service","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lkcI_0MO2BIFaJicbCAhZc1I301FQXx2qVV9DhFrmuVzke=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pyroboy1080service","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwsnmRKR1Pabd-4DlB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I fucking love you dude youre great lol no homosapien","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX12jzVa73K_doxRcHVzbxg","author":"@toetagger1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mi8cB6F5vOCBjFYeGs_893Gnx8LyLOGZ9rhZcmtcOcJJI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@toetagger1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDHEbECsgYl_51Qvh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"First off, love the experiment. I do take issue with some of your sidebar commentary though:\n@13:55 It's not \"capitalism\" it's bias. Any bias. It’s not about the system they’re in, it’s about the lens they refuse to question that colors the protocols they create and the data they save vs discard. Pointing the finger at a singular cause is part of that problem. Pretending @14:30 that scientists aren't corruptible is another part of the problem. The assumption should be trust but verify, not trust blindly which \"the science\" has become.  @14:55 every paper is a leap of faith based on your own arguments at @14:15 because as you said we don't have enough money to run counter studies for every study done. \n\nWhen a prominent scientist rallies consensus through prestige and corrupted studies, the line between science and mysticism begins to blur. When that same scientist is later revealed to have suppressed counter-evidence or falsified data while publicly condemning dissent, the line vanishes entirely and public trust collapses.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBLi9S5cFNPrLiLGhWuKAIw","author":"@Trahloc-PH","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/OUonLTni4ismK15TnfPpPNbLwVT6j01Ij_bWu4zBtuAx-uiZqx-0ayqNHJbdJsasY1wZOjey9g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Trahloc-PH","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDHEbECsgYl_51Qvh4AaABAg.AJiDeh8DnaZAK6ikHa8Vcd","parent":"UgwDHEbECsgYl_51Qvh4AaABAg","text":"it's wild that in the process of complaining about others politicizing science for their own bias (using poor examples that weren't valid) he demonstrated himself politicizing science for his own bias. the data surrounding covid (masking, vaccines, lockdowns, origins etc) was bad from the beginning. anyone following the scientific method and looking at the data knew this. the idea that climate change is some solid agreed upon thing is also decades outdated, it's very well established now that every model for the past 100 years has been wildly off and none of the claims have come true, whether its al gore or aoc claiming them. and dei? what? is this dude arguing that dei is scientifically proven to be good? the only research i cant think of ive even heard of regarding that is a paper that shows that black students that get into schools that their gpa is low for are less likely to succeed than ones that get into schools that better match their achievement.\n\ni dont get how somebody's brain can work in one way in one area and completely different in another like this, especially to the extent that he can put a segment in a video like this that completely contradicts the rest of the video and then lack the self awareness to realize it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4QiEoSTkO8VFDPu1ca68Qw","author":"@face0001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lziHycyh8NSZpgk-9BnembuSmGg7ufcwMBtBl1U-VI7U8Dbo9yF4kgdhowTJBLsuIz6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@face0001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxDwMbisIZtKYjo7iB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ive never accepted that cold doesnt exist.  Such a waste of semantics.  Yes,  heat is the speed of atoms, but objects still exist when theyre cold.  Like.. quantum computers?\n\nAnd everything we can see and touch is 99.999999% empty space, but there is still SOMETHING holding the simulation together be it \"dark matter\" or some other quantum or multidimensional phenomena that we're yet to discover.  The statement \"cold doesnt exist\" is a level of dogma i will never accept.\n\n  It does exist,  bec things still exist when theyre cold.  I'd go as far as to argue that peak heat would be the point of non existent, as it destroys data on an atomic level and causes entropy.\n\nTLDR: heat = energy = atoms moving. Cold is less movement, but atoms still exists = cold exists.  We just dont view it as an energy source,  yet we do utilize it.  It has purpose.  Its not a flaw,  its a feature.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn5f02hWKzpvcwIICgYmThg","author":"@zensational.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/P8VNsmhgg-Vl4nwDdav5PERGmuHi6qSd_LfRHcDwA33pQ7u85Amzj39D0nwbb1Ze0sSjcGC_AA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zensational.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyALVTuziUU6TcxuRN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You did not invent this my man, this has been proven for Bach. I have ran double blind studies for cannabis showing rock/ fast tempos hurt grown. Bach, and flute music seemed to be the most beneficial.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKscBn6hjORfjtEgHoCk49g","author":"@FencepostDreamScapes2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9GyrGB56HuM4C6BBvurULqVTc38nJBnE-1-rWE9B1nzAXYRAafwssjAB2t8K14fK9NPKbU09QQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FencepostDreamScapes2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2ePJ7_GlQws6fXo94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I, kind of feel like 10+ minutes of this was a bunch of stuff that I didn't need to watch lol","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCvYVGRWA0QF2mkZ97mI4aeA","author":"@opliko","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WZY000db9aPGqYClLk_vM0VJMetXl66ZKdOyeN-L3vmqB-oQJpIkJTqZJ2myamL1ZcqJUXtx=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@opliko","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2VZZCaJdFpqcj0Nd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your interpretation of Godel ... very wrong.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHbGajNeWrm2AiBoqUREF0w","author":"@stuff3219","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_klDH4w99lATLGt6qq4dgPrxGdJK4QFvoPDE7XojIs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stuff3219","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy4Yot7zu1rRqImFMt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Have you ever read the book THE SECRET LIFE OF PLANTS? Plants are FULLY AWARE, and even have MEMORY of individuals who have harmed them. This was proven back when the first lie detector was created. Very interesting. I went to school for horticulture....we would have music going in the greenhouse all the time. It absolutely makes a difference. Plants absolutely respond both positively and negatively to talk, touch, etc. I put this is in the same category of emoto I think his name was, the researcher who studied the effect of words and music on water and how it froze and effected the structure of the water and then ice.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCuY0Vmpp85xNxCWT5DzcAuw","author":"@ambersykora352","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kCwJwDpNrVeUanr6fyeYVkfvatIpVEdhjd0SBkBpo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ambersykora352","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy4Yot7zu1rRqImFMt4AaABAg.AMN8GYYqwcOAMbuDJB-GMl","parent":"Ugy4Yot7zu1rRqImFMt4AaABAg","text":"But, lie detectors are a bunch of pseudoscience nonsense","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1wa-t064oE6r7pogqG1MXw","author":"@Wanhope2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kskRORQDdiL77woWW2hQBzwjI6doIBz_bh5vl2b6c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Wanhope2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTM8tT7R3RR5IXOUl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The reproducibility crisis is a scientist's signal that the probability that the data is useful is low. Untrue, in other words. Hypothesis and conclusions are bounded (defined and specified in the conclusion's range of possibilities) by math, so when they are not reproducible, they are lies. Most likely falsified data or methods. Why study new areas instead of reproducing results? Universities are propaganda factories. They have the funding (capital), they just don't value truth. They value power.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvJ9p5R21_7jM-BezRykSeA","author":"@Roont3","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ltd-LMh1gkhRis8IJjOIXsDOSguqNnArwKI80Qc6w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Roont3","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzKKWtSRvu3OFASv3F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"3:41 how do you know? unproven claim. not scientific at all","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkp9QlGWDNxizWOGwZQPClw","author":"@thekito4623","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kail9Vu2h7JWqkMhaUxNXRNlg4noSVAuTUg4hgQbU5LQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thekito4623","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz93DcICIjkDwDIB5V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why always when we wanna research something interesting we come back to the church? 😂\nLets say you got a small 4x4 room and everything is closed off and you grow plants in there.\nWhen you inside there for about a hour the co2 would have risen enough to increase the plant growing.\nThey basically did this but added music to it and then claimed the music was the one causing it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCN7NazSbybpMZ6ANlYE2Wtw","author":"@Desperado070","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mZ1ATOy7aLOu6GDS6-qJjeVerBIsYBTyNWKvOX5AbzwRQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Desperado070","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6HWeB4ePGZNK5JuJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't mean any disrespect in asking this but how do you go from arguing \"truth is a spectrum\" to talking about attacks on \"objectivity\" in the news? This was absurdly jarring to me truth is either true or false it obviously is a binary issue. Goeddel's Incompleteness Theorem is not relevant to this it just states that within any system there are true things that cannot be proved. It has NOTHING to do with truth being some sort of relative spectrum of likelihood. \n\nThe replication crisis is bad not because an experiment can't be reproduced, its bad because research that can't be reproduced is sent for peer review, accepted, published, and used as foundations and cited for further research. If the findings are not able to be reproduced, there is - by necessity - doubt cast on anything that uses the initial research as a citation. Research that is not reproducible should simply be discarded. If all things the same, reality no longer matches the research, then the research was faulty from the start.\n\nIt is well known that researchers will take shortcuts such as their oh so common p-value ritual and the like. Academics are pushed to publish, publish, publish because that is the basis of their academia hierarchy: how many papers have you published? how many citations have you had? Researchers that have their names on impossibly many papers just to increase the count. Similar to another point you made in the video, I think this is a shortcoming of capitalism, just like the awful academic publishing companies and textbook companies and all the like that have essentially privatized knowledge and advancement. \n\nMy point is that the replication crisis IS a significant problem because we do live in a world where things are true and things are false. Is the earth flat? Do viruses exist? Can a 4000hz sine wave at 63db cause a specific plant to grow faster under conditions x, y, and z? If the answer to any of these and similar questions is YES for someone, somwhere - and NO for someone else, somewhere else there would be a contradiction blowing everything up. Published research should have results based on published, repeatable methods. Otherwise it devolves into simply hearsay. Someone saying that I did this thing and this is what happened is one thing, but for it to argue that their results are statistically meaningful and deserve attention and citations and recognition is another entirely and must be research of a much higher caliber","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCFGLXtMopP4ppLQd-Mw5xUw","author":"@phithegamer5787","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nAPi4iggu0JNO0-NWT0_yf2Cqhbhy_X-t3e_yFWjzpCA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@phithegamer5787","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6HWeB4ePGZNK5JuJ4AaABAg.AG7AuLOwVx4AK6lRfFrdb7","parent":"Ugz6HWeB4ePGZNK5JuJ4AaABAg","text":"the examples he used were awful too. covid? how many times has the cdc or fauci admitted they lied or were wrong? climate change? we've been seeing for the last century how far every projection is off and none of the fear mongering has come true, whether from al gore or aoc. dei? im not even gonna touch that one... these are not areas where the data has backed up the \"scientific\" narrative, he's just listing more examples of junk science.\n\nit blows my mind someone can make a video talking about the importance of the scientific method and then inject a segment demonstrating he doesnt value it at all when it concerns his politcal bias. it's even crazier that he did so while accusing others of doing the exact same thing he, in realtime, was doing. the lack of self awareness that editing this video must have taken is mind boggling.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4QiEoSTkO8VFDPu1ca68Qw","author":"@face0001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lziHycyh8NSZpgk-9BnembuSmGg7ufcwMBtBl1U-VI7U8Dbo9yF4kgdhowTJBLsuIz6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@face0001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyof8G4DkU93IMhJxR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’m really interested to hear more about this sound test.\nBy the way, fuck that not going to university stuff. I went to university, and there’s a bunch of flaws in that system. Just look at the woke nonsense that’s been proliferated from it and the damage it’s doing to society.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpORKbYsgTF86CVynvzcTXw","author":"@TheOriginalNiceGuy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nRm-xqfLJJWynoHGMhyHMwYUsNZJiWKxev5sYnIaf7KvGvXFXY-L9EqaMrhr3VzoI0SQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheOriginalNiceGuy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyo3qZCiXga7wkIX7R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"He talks alot, what were the results?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0aou3DaQwN6SE53BW5Ep1g","author":"@MillDull","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m-wvAwKyNneCMdoErnw329VPrjfATdBmyawkiFTmB0Tmcb0mbPWFH98RzurWL1m0u29A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MillDull","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyov3A69-QWTFATf7p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Fail. Can't use seeds you would need clones so youre working with the same gen et tix","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC1A9et1V9Z8vfP-vzJzP31g","author":"@thereignofthezero225","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mpTXifh3GwdjhQ7WGvT9P2MOUJxK3eklLQpsYJqkX8Hg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thereignofthezero225","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugydo6Ie_0T0ct7e1n54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Blaming capitalism for something is like blaming the sun for shining. Capitalism is the natural state, Marx called everything that was not his communist utopia, capitalism.\nSo blaming capitalism is just subtle whining that there isn't enough communism.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5Sb_uRf_DklL8XTmPLNBww","author":"@E1war","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGZVQzGeM9_Ge2QiunjUAmIt5Ovp9TCRhMcqdCuyOWuOo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@E1war","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugydo6Ie_0T0ct7e1n54AaABAg.AO5p5KIujtcAOfcqGaRuJH","parent":"Ugydo6Ie_0T0ct7e1n54AaABAg","text":"🤡","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCS6NcAfGtBHl-EVeUZtOcgA","author":"@Ohfwljvelvjw","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KdgAikGELgLpCANeJtKuoEvewLKglYcL_77gE1V6T8kTGypx4AzU42kRiiyxwZq19aaP9nOLow=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ohfwljvelvjw","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQNNCLphUGhpfQl7h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"15:08 YES! Feel free to wage all out WAR on the research, the methodology, flawed experimentation, etc... but NOT the researcher/scientist! Pretty universal the nazis weren't great, still use studies done by them bc the science was valid","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNYq1YM6t9tY8AYtwafVbsg","author":"@drewherbi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ky83sfKLZKg64QVSZaiBasWQFR7PKIrBMubBg--uaAlA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drewherbi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwrK8Viy8fdknKzfot4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Awful tangent placements in the middle of testing theory 3.  Please. Place them in between topics, not in the middle.  I still don't understand how your test for theory 3 would prove or disprove it and I've watched this three times. \n\nOtherwise, very interesting, as usual.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPhRj17jXK9bnvc4w4SSbww","author":"@drkalamity4518","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lLanP9P909h8I-3vNRnc0DAkkIZ-2G11LzJMqepuo3uWf_xQ0NFbk7x0sUSxzoyDss0g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drkalamity4518","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPOeF1-ZShetd8Yb54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You confidently state that \"plants don't have feelings or emotions.\" That seems like a big assumption to make. How do you know that?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCET2xsRv_BDIGn8YtE4kiyA","author":"@antilles27","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kQ8ZN0nTWPMaXG7TTl1ZA_WoMYCaujBrCn36fMXVTYkfs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@antilles27","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwGkV7MwnCMdf7qVul4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The problem with a lack of repeatability and the argument that 'it's still science' relies heavily on the person conducting the experiments isn't persuaded by the promise of fame, funding or political influence/book deals.   Humans nature and motives will destroy such programs and when 50% of science when tested can't be repeated [that is they tested it and couldn't repeat the results] there's a HUGE problem with methodology in science today.  Lets not get caught up in ideology one way [as demonstrated by the included memes] or another, only then can clarity be found.  Science is absolutely a mess today.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVU0hpViasZVLGyxWbZ9zew","author":"@blogobre","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nfAbvNq4_vbDAV4AU4m29DKSuFisDdk1LYEAr36gA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@blogobre","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwkwqPWjx2yUEnI6Zd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Unsure how you missed the most crucial, concrete discovery in all this research:  country is the WORST music. More plants died when exposed to country music than ANY other genre, including \"rock\" (in quotes because i don't see The Beatles and Norwegian death metal to be the same genre, but the researchers did)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNYq1YM6t9tY8AYtwafVbsg","author":"@drewherbi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ky83sfKLZKg64QVSZaiBasWQFR7PKIrBMubBg--uaAlA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drewherbi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw3tkqPhxEzwYPEWxJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Was fun till it devolved into multiple tangential tantrums off topic from the premise of the video.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk4w75VMJQwPBfn-Mam7njQ","author":"@RLTraverse","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k6IO_Mf245c59Uv1VrE1MW4Wo30O6WMpad8pIALN4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RLTraverse","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzdVLXS1ucwD9RAhah4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Science is not in a catastrophic state because of capitalism but for a large array of perverse incentives, many of which antagonistic to how capitalism operates; researchers have become complacent, accommodated, and sometimes even fraudulent, because we take a bunch of progressively indoctrinated university students who are barely in their 20s and turn them into what resembles public workers (up to 60% of their funding comes from the public sector), who have every incentive to defraud results to keep their funding coming. Meanwhile, science in the private sector is at full speed; quantum, photonic, and spintronic computers, AI, fusion research, space tech... Capitalism is what is keeping science afloat while socialists unintentionally run it ashore.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmaohZTAqzIPxj18-Fj6udA","author":"@matheusdardenne","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5IKGLA5ATYFL5zffSCfuYd-qV9L0rXa3d3MIpKbT6kZOrvWEx0jnu1vm8YW_TbgZbuU_yqC5BAY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@matheusdardenne","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzOT4TNW5qtcWPmmIp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Unwatchable, and I'm a plant geek.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDdcawj10XQYpdT0Zwhdovg","author":"@ghere8399","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTjWu-3Nr3rnVWW3pjtTt92B02C81EFsYtH532LAAnVfdL_xLvCVos3GLgui6Fba6opw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ghere8399","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz8UzOliimLSThb-394AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You bring up conflict of interest/bias is what's helping ruin the credibility & integrity of science but then later you do a 180 and try to blame capitalism? What?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCo5cxtLCPoCz1MP4HQFE-aQ","author":"@Runefrag","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lawf9yWTQpDKE0MLo3587nhlwH_ppxDQse0Bw_-WWV25kHUsQnoRSTBnBBFdxj69wZBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Runefrag","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgworIIDuCWUXUDHyTl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Are you sure you weren't subtly superimposing low dB jazz trumpet improvisation over the 4kHz signals?\nI mean. It could happen. Or maybe you're doing that to us during the discussions to make our minds more receptive to your scientific thesis?\nSeriously, I'm just joking. Or am I. I'm calling Bill Nye and getting his \"Science Expert\" opinion tomorrow.\nFollowed up by Michao Kaku and Neil DeGrasse Tyson. All three men seem so trustworthy and genuine. \nThat counts towards Truth and Factual Proof. Right?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1EIiBRaYhbr0w2pb4Djidw","author":"@msmeyersmd8","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYIybos6x9C6ZqJ2S2fE2_TZQPzRzfT5XZNLO2_oU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@msmeyersmd8","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9ANaatwHdmailpLt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hmmm. This spawns a thought. I wonder if the same type of experiment could be conducted with focus on plants and the effects of a woman’s voice on the health of plants. \nFocus: medium grown plants with healthy vitals. Maybe even fruit producing.\nSubject A: the healthy quiet virtuous woman soft spoken positive affirmations of peace and prosperity\nSubject B: the challenged nagging negative Nancy who rattles off non-stop from sunrise to sunset like a Tommy gun tossing word salads with shittake mushrooms.\n\nA tisket a tasket a bitch with a basket my theory is the plants with be stressed TF out with Subject B. \n\nBen, where did the synthesizer come from? Photosynthesis maybe?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHRFzwWQSsZdiw0l_7VF1EQ","author":"@cajuncrackerranch7990","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xfBxrpcr-dUzuGdk02tqPC_ddu_JQReb_PeOXmVvBVCHzxgMFqvXoCImREQAEEfxY_x9-veiUzc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cajuncrackerranch7990","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0neIgP9a7HUznhBd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I like your videos. However: \"Plants don't have emotions because I say so\" is a way of thinking that you could reflect upon a little more...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjQZUhVqAZKMENs_ucRBdxA","author":"@ArchonExMachina","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k9aKTt5RP7O_yEjKo_jxNU0EOg8VbgBK_6F1uzErKkGQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ArchonExMachina","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw9OY9gGzP5ZdL88HV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I subscribed when the \"major war on truth and objectivity happening right now\" line wasn't the hook for a Ground News sponsorship. I know it pays the bills but people interrupting their earnest essays about the systemic problems of our times to hawk trash subscription services feels so un-serious.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPM0-rt4BwpsIOKOH5seVDg","author":"@bk04ft","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mFxdT7ytpyNuN3XTBZcedG1r8bU7Z3pVBI7hwYX0M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bk04ft","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw9OY9gGzP5ZdL88HV4AaABAg.AJ6xV7jW8s7AK6kZs7I4I_","parent":"Ugw9OY9gGzP5ZdL88HV4AaABAg","text":"opposite here, i expected it to be a ground news ad but it was so much worse i unsubbed. complaining about others misusing science for political ends using invalid examples while misusing science for your own political ends is a hell of a segment to throw in a video like this. the lack of self awareness is insane.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4QiEoSTkO8VFDPu1ca68Qw","author":"@face0001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lziHycyh8NSZpgk-9BnembuSmGg7ufcwMBtBl1U-VI7U8Dbo9yF4kgdhowTJBLsuIz6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@face0001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2Rk0R6kpjQ5tzafh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"dont use whispering frequently plz. some ppl are  heavily disturbed of that. plz searchh for this disorder.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-RbYlFLqFpUd_AJuvNfp0w","author":"@mstkli222","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m2Vf0F2lr4XZ3SasUzJ8isR2xA070iqX2oKvEU-RSqkY8xVH5UiJORv-KncWkHvlzB7A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mstkli222","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyK83lFpuN1kdYprbF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"No, so-called HIV denial is NOT completely fucking wrong. You sit there talking about the scientific method, obviously oblivious to the fact that the scientific method was completely absent when it comes to the assertion by Robert Gallo that HIV is the cause of AIDS. There isn't even a scientific paper you can reference to claim it. Just ask Kary Mullis, the inventor of PCR, that supposedly diagnoses AIDS & covid, who looked in vain for just that.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQkrN1kiiQmAqXBd7IxFJvQ","author":"@meetim6271","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/jXBnfhcSuJpTR25ekBA-d0jRLuosqTHZ9LD5qKoeXYsXPYRNIVAp63swfZjpbVcQ4sY0HgwhRks=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@meetim6271","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyui0eb1G4K5dyy8bR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey I really like your stuff, but as a mathematician my feedback is that you completely butchered your explanation of Godel. It has nothing at all to do with probability, and it doesn't dispel the notion of absolute mathematical truth either. Godel says, in a nutshell, that every formal system of axioms sufficiently complex to encapsulate basic arithmetic will contain within it statements that are true but not provable within the system. Notice, those statements ARE TRUE, not probably true. And also, it doesn't say that there are NO statements that are both true and provable. Mathematicians work on finding statements that are true and provable (and ideally interesting).","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4oBucek2s-RYpPUnLgTb9Q","author":"@chrisdock8804","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nbJmhDrs33XPIl6SYURrZ9v6fa-JETdX1wdDjFDf2JUmIc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chrisdock8804","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynXBd8LBFR4cDToip4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But ben you did not wear gloves while handling the seeds, there could have been a number of diffrent germ, vira, ect. on skin microbiome while handling them, and they could have been exposed to diffrent things for that reason! as they where growing in diffrent containers it could have over time made vastly diffrent results in the mini pots where you where growing the plants!! (Is this a bad joke or am I serious?!)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCe11etaEWEodPJCDttJguow","author":"@OmniCasper","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3bdp2x0ttIP1QgLXAw6GtuTz4YhVBAjoS5d8wGfaIqg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@OmniCasper","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwRl-Q46E7h-FDWqYZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Too much talking.\nToo less science.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFABCf8ViXCKERZ_n798Shw","author":"@HasiMcSeargeant","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ndcvfGMjJ5N0T9FGGljlW0MIasnhQ51n8SqWws3I87BZNWS8mHL02lh20MpWB32TlN3A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HasiMcSeargeant","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwwqw4YSPoBZ2KPoQx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The politics on your channel are obnoxious. I'm trying to watch a video about sound helping plants grow.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPu7Uvz7d_Nu23izbKtxM4w","author":"@IronDruids","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qJpG8xBOAmxx0nMJwP6WEY3lDutIYkwDxwwHck7vdae1llhcXJ-K8iW49o1b-atfIC0iYs237w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IronDruids","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwzUmpJfg9kaHL4DR94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In practice it does matter whether people are scientifically credible. For a start, outright science fraud is a thing. Some people just make up their numbers. You need to rely on trust that the data isn't outright fiction. \n\nBut also, there are 1000's of little ways to slightly skew the data. Things that are really hard to find unless you are an expert going over their procedure with a fine tooth comb. \n\nFor instance, did you position the legend to obscure a couple of inconvenient datapoints on your graph. Did you rerun your randomized algorithms because you got a bad PRNG seed the first time? \n\nOr, in your experiments.\nDid you spend more time int the room when the speakers were on than when the speakers were off, thus exposing the second lot of plants to a higher CO2 atmosphere from your breath? Did you place one lot of seeds spit up, and the other lot of seeds split down?\n\nFor the citizen science, the problem is more that there are some people who have managed to self educate, and some total cranks with perpetual motion machines, and it takes a bit of time and effort to tell the difference.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvN-13t2V0iWtjC_O8vCppw","author":"@donaldhobson8873","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_maTQBP4GMeRtPg9_4ORSrwSbJgJCVOYl0PzBTyTcCM3Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@donaldhobson8873","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy8hmT_mxUskjt_fwB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Too much rambling and non sequiturs.\nThis video could’ve fit in 2 minutes and been easier to follow.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtCGjt18hZWb0Wy90JjYIIg","author":"@chamuuemura5314","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVcrZoauCajbUPE1aWSO6_T_3HUHm5-meTFrSo2Mw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chamuuemura5314","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYe1kXkkMYw3aVcVh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"4:15  The scientific method was created? By whom?\nThe fact is that EVERYONE is a scientist, and EVERYONE employs the \"scientific method.\"","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC3jQ7kTogiq-4rQF06ld0lA","author":"@firecloud77","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nWVI9w_CdU0L3V-esvX4McmQcm1re1YiJSN7e1Cnqqp8Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@firecloud77","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYe1kXkkMYw3aVcVh4AaABAg.AK2W-E_WfErAKPCwzPlqSL","parent":"UgxYe1kXkkMYw3aVcVh4AaABAg","text":"It was created by people in the west.  The east never employed the scientific method (they couldn't quite get past the observation and hypothesis stages).","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCus5sZIzN1O0ut56m3Al2TA","author":"@evrythingis1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mo7TgC4jxd3ktyWBI7tKmbAy7G5YVr_cJckwIYA8kbumQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@evrythingis1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw-pvyBQh3Hoere-S54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"12:22 Well, completely f'ing wrong is not quite true.  Have you read Celia Farber's book Serious Adverse Events?  It's more likely that AIDS isn't caused by a virus.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjYTxoUtk9pHIJu1kSFb4Tg","author":"@marthamacburnie8727","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mFYWftp7rI9WA_UabfD8EYuctnipHFT17V2UE0w_vEpy0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@marthamacburnie8727","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwWQn5S_BK3pblrmb94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"Attributing human attributes to non-human things\" but the example you used is the dog liking the attention of being on camera. Liking attention isn't a human attribute. Most animals have a unique personality formed from their preferences and emotions. So animals can't really be anthropomorphized just exaggerated... but that is like saying MAGA has embraced a strange set of ethics when ethical considerations are just coincidental.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCr1_N4t1DBIyrQ-CBgmVZ4A","author":"@DaruthTheHuman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iLp50JyGdt-6i3rPr8DEHSWsrKo9sorVOTpAEuGLfQ-BFWCq76m7GQanw8bIphqyDJhcu72nVA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DaruthTheHuman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZcsOOoLTUOoW4MOx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why do so many of these videos feel like a libertarian funnel by the end? If the point was to get published and contribute, why wouldn't you get a degree now that you can afford it? You can even get published while an undergrad.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGoIE81RoSTzKLRSs9JTqVw","author":"@SunflowerHauz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mbdw79JGc5mlEFb4L_fDS_eNfnZ3cB5TODqlDQLt_5YWQ-7_FLklstw7UB2tMe0YfK6w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SunflowerHauz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymQ8m5qH6NhDWwJjZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Capitalism is at fault for studies not getting redone? 😂  For every oils company there is an anti oil NGO that would happily fund any study that makes them look bad.  Especially with the hundreds of millions of dollars they get.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCC5pn_jmFlomt0_wGNKLwxA","author":"@huckleberryfinn8795","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nRAbJoisVjJ8vvTDrhWm2t1iA7PcGCXftvhFck6mc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@huckleberryfinn8795","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyJIRm8zemG7jgl1-h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Good try, but the moment you used seeds instead of clones the experiment failed and lost all credibility in any direction.\n\nSo yes, all theories you voiced are incorrect based on relevance and all time wasted.\n\nThis is why it’s important to consult instead of wing it.\n\nI’ve never seen someone try to wax poetic about the scientific method then omit it, and completely go down the opposite road. This is absolute gold lmao.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9iRXGOZl7IC-T1qNv6UEMA","author":"@IronMirror","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JNEpPbNgZoTZBIEWGjVXcQclpTXM17W-PHMGVHHIoHqsvXyLTVrcmBtqIply-HLNRyGT2T24=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IronMirror","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzsk8M7rvwZlreBJRF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Half of your video times is about capitalism and america bad","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxizsrk6IacibhBTU6e3zLw","author":"@lifeplayer7855","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mrz4OEgTCMMvY9VJGadWSMvzoEIy9a6vibsxAzZo8AD98=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lifeplayer7855","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-lnGcmWZvwFIiZUJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Capitalism boohoo 😢, you can do better buddy","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUp9C_6jE7JfBm45-XGYs2A","author":"@villanovienno2003","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fFKo1QjQ_cEdOfivWvpOUwn4xdE7BBSoC9ySjL1pkOyFrIdeOYA8i2Z8eKM-IgTcJ2wjVmTYuQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@villanovienno2003","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwWQwkWsWawdbRROgN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just love when you participate in broadcasting the false information with the image about \"HIV denial in the COVID era\".\nAIDS had nothing to do with HIV, it's been proven time and time again. Just trolls that pushed the covid hoax are affraid people also realized that the true masterpice of Fauci in his work for global depopulation is the hoax of \"the AIDS virus = HIV\".\n\nRest in piece Pr Montagnier, we will win this war also.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3_nR2rhS3I_bRKiEsOS4cA","author":"@AtlantisArch","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_BbtlEq9vsYfLiK9H8Oy5vA99mhR24rm3GJz0q4rqOQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AtlantisArch","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"3 months ago","timestamp":1782950400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwSqOgqt7FEpDn83nF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"11:30 why would you patent such a thing, if you believe something is useful why be greedy and selfish and limit who is allowed to use it? Do you believe in truth and progress or not, because these two things are fundamentally incompatible with what patents do.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdddXUL-K02RXkaQ3KVeGWA","author":"@fio-z_00","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/i3eLnHeqrAYsc75T3TnrPRh4Vrv64i9-vGjl8Xk37s1iAArptmu-V_La8VCWlAYzXib_M86_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fio-z_00","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwSqOgqt7FEpDn83nF4AaABAg.AIIvvqbYf0tAIIwHMgoNn1","parent":"UgwSqOgqt7FEpDn83nF4AaABAg","text":"I know everyone believes they should own ideas, but if you actually think about what that implies you would realize what a greedy and destructive thing that is.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdddXUL-K02RXkaQ3KVeGWA","author":"@fio-z_00","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/i3eLnHeqrAYsc75T3TnrPRh4Vrv64i9-vGjl8Xk37s1iAArptmu-V_La8VCWlAYzXib_M86_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fio-z_00","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxHtjB3mKPitZR8zql4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:56 🤣🤣🤣 aww snap that bitching was the apex of the whole video\n10:39 ummm... everything exists? ...everything is differentiated? ...nothing is random? reality is intentional? any two phenomena are correlated on a 1:1 ratio at the interface? there is no local causation? ...all completely provable. i think gödel spent too much of his attention focused in the here and now... perhaps a plane journey with an atomic clock might have been the kicker for him... who knows?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1Wfb2aiquDgj8nMYoAFUbg","author":"@zalzalahbuttsaab","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/71ErJ36baSl9X8hJZ3Zlv-lE3hI-893mAf_DTKTzUcENlHDlJ8jflMSYZZhSfB9MNQBEASMxaw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zalzalahbuttsaab","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwtIuBJ2bzq1f68_VR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I really appreciate the effort you went to, but all this video did was made me feel incredibly impoverished. the uk really is a 3rd world country.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-fzoVY2Eu0e6qncNQ7FH_Q","author":"@oliverconstance9901","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mW25EOsUEReTRPCgj0tk_ZS_V_wkhyisp940EGGAI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oliverconstance9901","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-E3Emk_dfjUnmikx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You would do much better to leave your political beliefs out of your videos!! It contradicts how smart you are.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGKmsZ9ZgI7HSgy7SWkF3nA","author":"@jamesramsey4307","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ke6VRnOzF4jmdGYNOR163FHUjrCKqQr_orzNGCb-o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jamesramsey4307","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxn-i-ne3S_6QJkqhJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"lmao , no studies ah :) . could easily be done. your quoting BS papers . better q who published them","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC902i18JmICsxquqxzxMENQ","author":"@SOVEREIGNDesigns","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4dZg45QcIPjobPSluipRQwwc1l7koKqBjbMqC8elx5BY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SOVEREIGNDesigns","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwgkqUYRbu_ZXiU_Kx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you can't prove it it's not real bro. Your 1/3 claim is also total bullshit. That's not 'science' like this. If you can't repeat an experiment and get the same results it's inconclusive. It's not physicial science. It's social and behavioural science... and the results of things like that are almost always \"shows links\" etc... not conclusive. FFS stop trying to explain science when you don't understand what it is. This is just misinformation you read in a meme and took as a fact. It's not at all science.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCswaiVhmodwlAPkKJ8cuEqg","author":"@indiefan23","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYQvAmUyrYtkF2soc7ppz6IxaER9_xGSrVZLHiG4eUGMeY1Tl-U5nqn34h_UtOew4GdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@indiefan23","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrA4bj6KXGLBwkq494AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"lol. #spaceisfake grow up","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWme6SKpnVuJyp1lRCmSgCw","author":"@DJLogos711","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0uuF1cb1LRUh-7ZcXuK1VRKTde61axnbhYN1k7yPjU6o6hTlZBnU3uVVgVbjUiYr5GP0TFwN=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DJLogos711","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwzk6l6Wb81KC2FvW14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You got the reason wrong for the replication crisis and your bias showed too much on this point. The replication crisis largely affects the soft sciences and it is due to biases and agendas in the soft sciences. P-Hacking, incorrectly formed methodologies, etc. Classic junk science problems. Because the soft sciences have been ideologically captured by certain schools of thought that favor a particular set of world views instead of just sticking to the science. So when we try to replicate these studies, we discover these problems. Or, when these studies are scaled up in size, the statistical effect is no longer there or we even see the opposite. Ask yourself, \"Why is there a specific directional bias is the one mostly being seen in the soft sciences, for the replication crisis?\" Ask yourself, \"Why is the slant in one direction of biases and not the other?\" This is how you know the soft sciences have been ideologically captured. In the last few years, we are just now seeing how bad it is because the internet, information age, and AI Age, are shedding lots of light onto this ideological capture.\n\nScience is full of biases. The scientific method is full of biases. It has to be. Because people must form a hypothesis (or hypotheses) that must be tested. The statistical power tests are tools that are subjectively chosen. The methodologies applied to the studies are subjectively chosen. The sampling methods (part of methodologies) are also subjectively chosen. And even the type of science that gets chosen to be researched is biasedly selected. Meaning, we also have an over-study effect for certain hypotheses because of interests in those areas. There are some topics that are so taboo to study that they do not get funded. Topics and theories that would run counter to the widely accepted world views. \n\nAt work, we run a weekly meeting where I get to pick apart research and point out to my coworkers why certain studies part of writeups and articles, are junk science vs. solid science. I'm slowly teaching them how to spot the problems. It's been fun. I'm thinking about turning this into a formal lecture and going around corporations to teach people how to spot junk science. Hint: it's almost always the \"soft science\" that end up in the junk science category.\n\nOther than this ONE point, I generally loved your video. Like all your videos, I love your content.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdYPqNDbquFY6x9mWbon7ZQ","author":"@rogerlouie1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lQ3rdMcjp87QMvC4GGR9gnVPu2YXz_sZ92GsTNQHAs2Jk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rogerlouie1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwzk6l6Wb81KC2FvW14AaABAg.AJb3NW9ZXjAAK6jkrvgEbO","parent":"Ugwzk6l6Wb81KC2FvW14AaABAg","text":"the examples he used were horrible. covid? the cdc themselves and fauci had admitted countless times they were wrong. the data on all of it was bad from the beginning. masks, vaccines, lockdowns, social distancing, anybody actually looking at the data knew they didnt match the claims. climate change? is it 2002 again? nobody has believed the typical narrative on that for a decade. every projection made in the last century has been wildly off. none of the fear mongering, whether it was al gore or aoc, has come true. countless climate papers have been debunked or retracted. \n\nthis is the first video ive seen from this guy and i loved it before it went political, i had already subbed even. fastest unsub in awhile, i think youre being way too nice. people like him are a huge problem in society, \"worship the overlords or be slandered as misusers of science\" isn't something we need in society. every person that watches one of his videos is a person that might be dumber for listening to his take or a person that might get myocarditis because they trusted the science. fuck people like this, they have no place in society, at least no place where they have any influence on the actions of others.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4QiEoSTkO8VFDPu1ca68Qw","author":"@face0001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lziHycyh8NSZpgk-9BnembuSmGg7ufcwMBtBl1U-VI7U8Dbo9yF4kgdhowTJBLsuIz6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@face0001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxiFbBAeF1kTV04GyN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Oh Boy you dont understand Science...its a crap ...Science is an industrial complex....nothing more to say about than physics is the real treasure and gold of a nation.... most protected most lies out there....chemistry isnt different....take your mRNA Shot, dont forget - TRUST the science :) ..... there is no discussion about if music is good for plants, this has been prooven long time ago - only stupid modern indutry science is trying to spread confusion about - sound ? you cant make money with it.....by the way how stupid to bring human music to plants when in their enviroment birds are singing??? anyone using his brains nowadays or all zombies out there? i play Birds in woods sounds and yield is 200% !!!! please dont trust me, i dont want you do have the same advantages and benefits - i want them keep it for me alone .)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmWYONLH8Phz2NzHsbg3-ZA","author":"@Zeppelin5ive","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xJfM4ZptIX8_Hlkaa1GolL9PKmMTh-NdGLSlfsGyqomlBhQ_NvrTpJkFAbRywkyNaZgoBI91WA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Zeppelin5ive","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz5cxhflzhK7rq2JXh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Who are you?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvJ90CP_NZUDWsfhNtkhizw","author":"@datcat9198","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mmsD-lV1KwwETxT6mmremZdbV8RUlIGafNT-jYKHLRNAtUV3Th-FV9QR6jqDcCNsX9gA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@datcat9198","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxlejwGifXD0V3mfOp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You know what always damages the credibility of people like you?\n\nWhenever someone you like is in power you act like the people in power are pure and benevolent then the second someone you don’t like is in power suddenly it’s a “war on truth and objectivity” despite the fact that it’s mostly the same unelected people shitting on us all. The inability to acknowledge the ridiculous bullshit coming out in the previous administration while acting like the current is in an all out war against truth and reality is just so transparent. You’re clearly a smart guy but the ideological taint is worn with such pride that it really undercuts what you’re saying to anyone who isn’t ideologically captured by the same ideology as you are.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCA6Q78c0D1Ddg7DoT1JLkOw","author":"@TehPrawntier","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n6PqtEKZcICTDilbQ5QNwikSsjsKb-0rEW0IRbu08AMgI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TehPrawntier","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxgvKlHc690zw_06cB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"11:58  Holy crap, this guy comes across like a proponent of pure scientism. He sounds like the kind of guy who ran right out and got his Jab, and all the boosters, because \"science.\" And probably thinks it's a documented fact that a single-celled organism transitioned into H. sapien through an exclusively unguided naturalistic process. Oh, and that a man can get pregnant.\n\"Holding scientific research and discovery in respect, as we should, we must always be alert to the equal and opposite danger that public policy could itself become a captive of a scientific-technological elite.\" --President Eisenhower, 17 Jan 1961","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC3jQ7kTogiq-4rQF06ld0lA","author":"@firecloud77","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nWVI9w_CdU0L3V-esvX4McmQcm1re1YiJSN7e1Cnqqp8Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@firecloud77","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxHZNN65OY-CvExeJV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Growing plants is the worse shit humanity does and should be BANNED.\nWe have to go back to the nature.\nWe have to go back to eating meat and animal fat !","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAnr59k5OHe0Od94oTTwCaQ","author":"@btudrus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nlIfjBV8jVAWEaOTicYwvTNt34IkCl0wwPvAkVGJk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@btudrus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false}]}