{"id":"QVXfcIb3OKo","comment_count":1290,"extracted_at":"2026-10-01T17:18:17+00:00","extractor":"yt-dlp","extractor_args":"youtube:comment_sort=top;max_comments=5000,all,all,50,2","note":"Reply depth limited by yt-dlp YouTube extractor; browser \"load all replies\" automation is not used.","comments":[{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Comment FAQ:\nGenerative AI defense comments: \nArguing that your Suno/Udio music is equal to my music was already done in 2023 when a federal judge decided that AI generated content isn't copyrightable nor qualifies for the same protections as human-made content. If you have a valid argument for this, then go appeal that decision. This is not the place to argue about this. Go read the actual, concise, deciding argument by searching \"Case 1:22-cv-01564-BAH\". \n\nMy \"ai detector\" model use:\nI've already had some calls with data-certifiers/content-ID companies that I had previous association with and it is completely possible to integrate this AI detection into their APIs. What I would much rather see happen is distributors release a blanket policy stating that they will not be paying royalties on content generated on Suno/Udio/etc and directly uploaded to their distribution, and will remove/chargeback royalties earned from that material.","like_count":1000,"author_id":"UCshObcm-nLhbu8MY50EZ5Ng","author":"@BennJordan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n4yN6OoQTOtdKr9MtPVRhT38hPTP0NUkc10Ni6wZWljek_9XRq0EuBi7PbmJb2bRs_WxcgQe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":true,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BennJordan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":true},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dACzqBoo7L24","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"So great you made this video. The fact that AI tools have been trained on already-compressed audio has (for me) always been one of the biggest \"tells\" for AI music (and the main reason that even though the song it makes can be usable, the audio is not). If you've been around bad mp3's as long as I have (since the spec was written), you will recognize that weird sound that a low bitrate mp3 can do with sharp transients (like snares) where they gets a pre-suck almost like a reverse reverb... and now I hear that in the AI music....","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCLJrhZ9lnZ8mPmdMLuKAE9Q","author":"@ZapAndersson","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lvlTq2KZO264YbhyrJ03dkdpOMoxqw4TciifLey2Q8PbZO=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ZapAndersson","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD9HzSjZFof","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"To everyone saying 'it's weird that you only use one case' or 'that was only one case': that's EXACTLY how legal precedent works - off of ONE case. In this case, the judge left it open to future legislation to decide how much AI is too much AI, but still ruled to the letter of the law as it is currently written and understood.\n\nTo those claiming this only applied to \"international copyright law\": the plaintiff was suing the US Copyright Office, not the international one. The judge confirmed that - IN THE US - his copyright wasn't valid \"on the grounds that the work lacked human authorship, a prerequisite for a valid copyright to issue\" (Pg. 1) because \"Human authorship is a bedrock requirement of copyright.\" (Pg. 8). Y'all need to work on your reading comprehension skills and stop 'assuming' what a judge meant. They write opinions for a reason.\n\nAlso, I'd love to know where you're even getting this 'international' law claim from. All discussion in the court's opinion is centered around US law, not international law. Even if it were for international law and not specifically US law, as Justice Gray said in 1900: \"International law is part of our law.\"","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCSolf2RABOcsZvfD33J4VXg","author":"@TheRealCeeJai","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lQO_lGMuFlqj5Ocvn2rZqDPf_1hJmgdrFLTa1yuJY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheRealCeeJai","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dADUflL1NuMQ","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Just a few thoughts, that come to my mind, reading some comments. So to give a Star Trek replicator instructions for the desired food would constitute cooking? Sure it is food consumed in the end, but no one would say the generating person is a creator, a cook or even creative for that matter, it is a glorified voice command button. At least in my book. But whenever there is a real significance surrounding preparing food, Star Trek characters sacrifice their time and effort to cook themselves. When I’d find out my favourite restaurant served microwave meals, but they ordered those with their own wording and “recipe” from the factory, although they didn’t even know how to cook it, I’d be majorly disappointed. I know that’s not the same, but I simply love music and also the fact people create it with their own skill, thoughts and emotions. If Benn for example was just generating away I’d let him, but he could do it on his own terms and I wouldn’t like to listen. I like my frozen pizza from time to time or the occasional microwave meal, but music and also art and photography (and all creative output) I’d like to keep those real for me and I want to know if it is or isn’t. I hope I’ll always find those creatives that keep things real and not just some illusion that it is.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCR5GJKIHQ7QgIWtpqXKcHfg","author":"@cooloutcoexist","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mqVFrKX9OHyTiCcTUHixqIuaJJJlzDd9YVjCh5qXWxOy8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cooloutcoexist","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dACy509b8qe6","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"hi, your points on how much the streaming services pay per stream got me interested: what's the pay on bandcamp like?\n\ni'm sure less people buy music there, but a single album purchase must be worth hundreds if not thousands of streams, right?","like_count":21,"author_id":"UCC-U2Vlyo96kXhMdjkvWYKQ","author":"@jan_Sanku","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/X2q3urQjvnlczGKAtPjyutNHPKCiudLMiUUQZrhu8AM0YftdX7UUK4aLR8Kc35egV9TGk_s1QKs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jan_Sanku","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD6gKt5ITDh","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Thank you for sharing the case number/ID/whatever. I knew about this case, but not that.\n\nThe only thing that concerns me about using your model to not pay royalties on generated content is that these companies will use that to further boost their profits rather than redistribute it to artists.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCZZ-RBp_D-a-JIuKDykhegA","author":"@guard13007","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VVhhVBM-tvsVgMdiLlwy86luhU_npxXiNjG4TfXf5qi-O3oeah9MQqJhkSR40iST9sMAEm5B0ts=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@guard13007","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAE_MD2KGU47","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Thats not entirely true. USCO has allowed for AI generated content to proceed to copyright as long as it can show a certain amount of human creativity. Prompting not withstanding. An example might be an AI song whereas the artist wrote all of the lyrics themselves, but not necessarily the musical composition. The USCO would, more than likely, allow it, but you need to disclose that info. In such a case, the song as a whole is copyrightable, but the underlying composition that was AI generated is not. Its the human created portion that is copyrightable and since the song in and of itself is a comp, the entire song will usually go forward. The underlying music is public domain, but someone can't use your lyrics with (or without) that music without violating your copyright.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC5jtz0jPJCqepzyW8ojok-w","author":"@TheFinnster12","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/68Qin1Sykv1bm_RBaBFcqxtwdiIIBKcDwIi1e_CRlxOwms1s0anEBzt4VGAtdVj1TVg88lnm=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheFinnster12","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAZnqo4b-obR","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"That is not proof of anything.\nWhy?\nBecause ai detectors such as Deezer still list ELVIS as 100% AI.\nAnd they do the same thing to nearly every major name.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCsr3qK446yy_29ORrP7Drzg","author":"@KiraHeat.01","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dPy60LIf6TY3fLioHBonDxMKvDg_4IgZolIidxhFtoqqYRVWd6N7i_A0BancOAISvlJifBUb=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KiraHeat.01","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dACyGgR0OP5m","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":" @BennJordan  actually, globally, mechanically randomise music has never been copyrightable under international copyright conventions. I believe that US judge ruled that US law applied the international agreement","like_count":16,"author_id":"UCyur-ebr0KBwqW1l6JnBfGg","author":"@crunchysteve","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h9qgSn8LFEZ5vFEmCwWlvR-bfTl3cZw-NZVveOviB_DaaY_4V1bm2IBlI21q681BO8fwk6cQyhA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@crunchysteve","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD9YxTwCsWq","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Awesome stuff. I’d love to test out some songs that I suspect are AI 😭","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC210aHZBGIIqmMpZL891l-w","author":"@alexbochelmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l1jJKu_oE1HAuQqZ0o_mF7u6R5hQNGm68NRy378t25CjA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alexbochelmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dADKRPOAg3tX","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"The PirateBay is still operational, your laws are inferior to our technology sir.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6o8vMZ_nEGlQ2Wk7DPtGLg","author":"@NerdComix","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oc8MaCjhqPQe4iEYEf3pjigu-wkXGnNY3yIq0fvUgd7LGg5lZaSu6M1KBAH4tfH4K2rPrrLKgg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NerdComix","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dADM9HRhUgMm","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"you are our savior mate","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCakpp9L3gpYTb-2JE6ZOleA","author":"@epic233-officiale","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vQmNUPhQOz3W5yAMzifLF7zxvTRfbVLgCtQ1te-m4mlVoG_X24tAwYMJArlfJ71YvqvANaCzcQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@epic233-officiale","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAESj9pxZasd","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Lyrics written by a human are absolutely copyrightable so if someone writes those lyrics and uses AI to generate the track thats their copyright.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCD3VJ2E1U9_1BLHA8-W3SRg","author":"@greyfoxzero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RPHOCkdfZGQNQ7kc3rglTp7ironqkT30tlyhoRvxpn1OIWWzoFhatsteuxkJdgQuMmrlC9tTVA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@greyfoxzero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAFoR6EF9Xj_","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"People who lack the talent, knowledge, skills, and abilities to create original works on their own will always argue in favor of AI generated works being eligible for copyright. They do not care for copyright law or judicial opinions, and they never will. All they care about is their new-found ability to monetize the derivative works created by AI.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX8HI3I8iX5Ik5Ba94bPruw","author":"@GaiusTacitus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kW04cmMvKctW1flj1c-FsaB1mhfFMaxtthOJ77G47GQg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GaiusTacitus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAGZqtOeW3KK","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"creating music for other countries arouses interest","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiHYWzPMbZV--_lC43ZR8Ww","author":"@MustBeTitans","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/r4yykgkffFNEmLJrGIlMnffbg0cwT1bSRbtp7g3OxTw0Q3-cosvYzl6K19WXqgyeOX9TNLd_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MustBeTitans","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAHL_uJbFK1A","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"This “modern” strife is really making me reconsider even wanting to make music in the first place. It’s just frustration now","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTv5paJ2TBAraKlo6vfQmOQ","author":"@Dreamcatcher_4886","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lNXDbSHvxdnIr_avp1M5UISXzB8C6MpCsk9YIPGRFG_fFHNUbSE4vIRMrxogkx0YT5y2t-pPDN4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dreamcatcher_4886","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dALlfNMR8PKS","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"\"What if you write a score but can't afford an orchestra, or you make a song in a MIDI format but can't pay for studio musicians or expensive sound libraries? What if, because of that, you decide to use AI music generators to realize your work? Does that bother you too? Or does it only bother you if they make money?\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1DmkD2iTUijX7s4EVgdJLw","author":"@mondeluz2491","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOo5xyJSTKiUVdw_RNnW9OHSQzZiszqEHDYMtPBu28mwA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mondeluz2491","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAM9oFI41_Z0","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"I would prefer if a label be put on all AI created music and artists . So listeners know what's real and what's not because I'm starting to see a lot of artists that I suspect of using AI because they are putting out albums every other day","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1idZ1hDb7IGICCobmhWuAg","author":"@matthewmachete","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WhZRtdSOBThvE5_UoOt36CiBp8L939CnqOiAJNgGWx3-4b8WTEsYRfFF8-u1mQcLWYvr5Tb3=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@matthewmachete","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dANAw20Nuwyd","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Well from what I've learned via first-hand experience is that it really doesn't matter what one federal judge says. In every way the legal societies have designed a system filled with loopholes and zero accountability via compartmentalizing segregation and cohesive Unity when it suits their benefit. It is literally the JU$T U$ system, which is literally an aspect of the banking system. The only entities in history that had courts are royalty. And the same entities own all of the Courts in America. The courts are literally quasi-public private for-profit 'foreign vessels in Dry Dock' and they make a fortune processing and fleecing the American sheeple. That is fact! Anything other than that is simple noise and serves absolutely to the people, but it does for the STATE and the legal societies that own in benefit from the STATE. You can walk into a court any day of the week and start dropping hundreds of case law rulings from the past and you are completely wasting your time. Because that judge is a sovereign citizen to granted the Sovereign capacity, by the unseen King to make any ruling they wish, and there's not much you can do about it. Everything else is slight of hand illusion and part of the magicK trick","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1CK1cwd3K2PEwZJi6jcSkQ","author":"@Farang-a-Tang","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/i-AbasM5wy1m7BoN1KHIvadsE-OWP0jUZC9zm3gdfY2RAkoPVyb8t5Qvadja7rjjvb1aqxFc3g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Farang-a-Tang","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAZhzGYVGswy","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"If possible can you update this (this video) for 2026. Curious about the AI music info","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRT2yWjG-y70gYBk_bnxNgg","author":"@Kas_Styles","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nKEotLAnQAQbz_oWPUVnCnrCwN3zff3BtF27CWRh0Cj_8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Kas_Styles","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD-N__fGKDD","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Benn, as a fellow artist, I beg of you, stop using AI generated imagery. It is hypocritical to make a video about AI music ruining things but then supporting the destruction of another art form by using tools that cause the exact same problem for them.","like_count":15,"author_id":"UC3U44TGF8G4pPCpAhrUGClA","author":"@invertexyz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LFsOG_V82deyT3qJTbWP4khF9gyCufwmtyn2qLeZUUFwmpKwk7r-X_wWma3-8507UKsQCn6H=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@invertexyz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dADLElMG7YGV","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"So YOU tell people what nature sounds like? According to your equipment and personal preference of what \"sounds good\"? Yep, that's why you are a YouTuber selling music to 1 inch speakers.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCRl_z3vWMd_agLC3GXGUMvQ","author":"@owendigity1581","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mHiCQXYGzJV9c5xEAaz59MKNWUSdDTeV0thCBtMZA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@owendigity1581","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dADwxsrHv25j","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"If you use your own lyrics, you own 50% of copyright.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCpU8xSHlow99ckgAQWWWRLg","author":"@getkraken8064","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m-CAuKRia7RGYcJ8nljqDrthQjAUoNnMnzPdHeo3SU5A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@getkraken8064","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dADRQp6g3nsb","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"The issue is, there is no solid way to 'detect' something is AI generated. And thus, the federal ruling is null in reality. If you cant police a law, it doesnt exist.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UClCdT8YVujOZOoYduXgP7FQ","author":"@draken5379","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOEZvjUov39Om4Y5-Ehh-XTZYzRq7yeeWbmlnj1jc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@draken5379","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAGq93gu-Yo7","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Where can I find this AI detector you speak of? I guess it doesn’t really matter as AI songs are the future. You either use AI or get left behind. I have no plans on retiring anytime soon.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCqkT4J_rbe3juCBYbIBcm0A","author":"@gvnsings","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fKtpZScZGwru7ylLcxg6rK7TaoMx6-TXdsp6TRmE141qP6X-ALopvgmoxJIdClhDX3XHeD32=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gvnsings","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAIQoZxWDGAw","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"What has happened in art and.musoc will happen in literally every other cognitive task.  Progress isn't going to stop and will speed up in the coming months.  Diffusion based methods are absolutely absurdly fast and even better than previous methods.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCvmyXiJyz22D6RyE88JTHjw","author":"@benschulz9140","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVEF89X-rdlht_FSAtrsI3V_BFS12P6ArJ6FKTmMs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@benschulz9140","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD9BXUDGBBE","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"federal judges dont even know what the internet is","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvixzxpeHLNXtXrNC9nmIDg","author":"@Tuuuuri","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xxCXytSBF5kPmvSKWxbLA1ZGfd2WxFIYLxIiVtAn_E_a5IYclb26FNu9Uybbs1HU322TFGAb9g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tuuuuri","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dADD-4H7u5l8","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Holy f*** bro I can't even watch it's like 5 minutes of you talking about the topic you will talk about.... Im going next","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEXYQWq_pJvuAsJTQCzQJ2Q","author":"@jasiucasic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mpBwWUzvTZTtcalURn7aTiDojFqGwsV5IoIHTKY2Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jasiucasic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dALMwec3BkbI","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"how are humans like ai?  what can the vast majority of people learn to understand that they are actually just computers. are humans just listening and training on the data sets over the years from going to concerts classes and listening to the radios?  I think maybe if you deny that you arent original you feel smarter. how do artist today in the real world manipulate people to say their music is original? like Micheal Jackson or Dua Lipa or even any other melodies or beats.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCe9HvBUF3axMXchVwEMxspA","author":"@RHYTHMRENEGADESRECORDS","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vX1ZcCvESmQxHPCSrqSX_GykodcFPcjE0c1FhGY_1112M9RhqstcZGW_er03yDfg08ot0ZNaWA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RHYTHMRENEGADESRECORDS","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dALOnfYPp4Sv","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"seems like so much work to talk about what platform...... what if its just like a bunch of people who use hammers, and everyone in the hammer group keeps yelling and arguing and hating on the people who invested money and time into buying hammer drills and electric battery opperated nail guns?  the product of music to listen to is similar to whatever you would be building.   sure a good wack with a hammer helps you work out and have many benifits, but if you can get the job of doing the thing you like doing faster... why do you complain about it?  DONT feel cheated.... appreciate the amount of new humans being able to do the thing and teach them how to do the thing even better.   HUMANS with no tools equals complaining, humans with basic tools equals missions getting completed... humans working together to build new tools and create new areas to be creative you are saying its bad, but most people like my grandma or others are actually enjoying it. all because you dont want anyone else to make music or make money off of it? Seems kind of mean.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCe9HvBUF3axMXchVwEMxspA","author":"@RHYTHMRENEGADESRECORDS","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vX1ZcCvESmQxHPCSrqSX_GykodcFPcjE0c1FhGY_1112M9RhqstcZGW_er03yDfg08ot0ZNaWA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RHYTHMRENEGADESRECORDS","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAGdBOiv0ovK","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"SUNO explicitly states that paid users own the rights to their creations.  I know they are being sued by all major record labels.  However, if one writes their own lyrics 100%, uploads his/her own vocal sample to model vocals, who owns what?  Yes, the instrumentation is being populated via SUNO's application.  I see SUNO as a collaborator that does not require any disclosure.  If I am able to produce a great song, the means justify the end.  At least that is how I am approaching it.  In the meantime, and it is a mean time,  sometimes I add live vocals to these mixes.  Additionally, my engineer bumps the files to each song giving them more depth and breadth.  Lastly, I am using an online mastering process prior to uploading to major distributor.  One distributer outright rejected my very first upload where I had live vocals, had remixed the song, sampled my own voice as main vocal.  It sighted the use of AI.  Additionally, it kept my almost $50 in fees after rejecting the song.  Ironically, their AI chat customer service told me I might get a refund within 90 days.  Will never use that distribution hub EVER.  Even though I have uploaded over 60 songs in the last 14 years.  AI is a tidal wave, I opted to get my surfboard out.  I am good at body surfing, not real surfing full disclosure :)  www.kirksongs.com","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCksCNHXn0tNDv12vZU7FPjg","author":"@kirksong7","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4sii9AIhoecNylcvFFF7P59hepZyKdKld3IMm_5Yqy-90jPIoRr-b6_U1r7DDn-8LAxEv2gptQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kirksong7","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAG_K-q6ecY4","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":" @BennJordan  and you will be sued by millions of artist like me and you will lose. If you want proof look at all of technological musical history and you will see that we have busted through every legal blockade that you haters have thrown up against us. It doesn’t matter how music is made Brother.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC7YUQhTgaR1ut8YB8svIbrQ","author":"@spaceminers","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJbXargVKZaXqMNXdTS1bsnIQGavfb9-n70S8rIHT--w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@spaceminers","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD2eLzvA_cx","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Most of the content created using these generative systems requires a person to influence the output. The act of creating a prompt is influencing the process. The act of providing lyrics influences the process. The act of curating what is generated influences the process. So, nothing is free of the influence of the person involved. So legally speaking none of the output is entirely \"AI generated\". People are using a tool to create something new.\n\nIn the specific case you cited (Perlmutter v. Thaler), that involved a person using a system which would generate \"art\" absent any human involvement and influence, and that system created \"art\" which could not be copyrighted. These are not the same legal issue.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCEDbDyZMrV_894l-uudVW4w","author":"@TeddyLeppard","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mA4G3V8IGT7j9ggo2bPnJYmo79cBgmr2GCJ4u3N10=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TeddyLeppard","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD47oJvd5vi","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Listen hater, If I wrote my lyrics, made the harmony and played my own version of keys. Uploaded MY voice and my version into the program to get \"re-rendered\" by AI with nice new bells and whistles, I'm still the owner of my copyright on my creation. IDC what you say or that case. That case is not the end all be all of this. This is just the beginning. I have a right to have AI remix or enhance my music without losing my rights to be paid or copyright it. Trying to make it so artists who use ANY AI at all , don't get royalties, is slimey and borderline criminal.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCFGp_XK-CUT2VHrZlb1z4Yw","author":"@SHNASTTV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-7l6fsEjjQgeUVlYMyDEDvclM1HUmYSWR9CukxVugJZzCCR1CyFYIADimJiywpoOSjy05ALx=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SHNASTTV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD-2NygS0bZ","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":" @systemcheck2769  Dude definetly violated their scraping policy while riding on a high horse about legality.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCFxqJmkJt3gIVBprgR0LeTA","author":"@SulkySkull","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mGCcO77qRAILeeq23h9y6AoVb-S6jhNjs55xh4H1JqzRtYoueMFrSC8S9Y7lZhzF6Tww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SulkySkull","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD3dCvod-Id","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"I don't care about your presumptuous argument.\n\nI am an author and musician. I had plenty of competition prior to AI and now that has gone 10x.\n\nInstead of whining I will leverage my talent and combine it with AI to elevate my work.\n\nPeople want music and books they find entertaining. I doubt anyone is going to turn off music or put down a book because of the lawsuit.\n\nThe source does not matter, all that counts is if it is quality and if it gives the listener or reader what they want to hear or read.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UChiVDmMobhksE5CgM0GgECg","author":"@newunderthesun7353","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kaT7iqgqFJZmwfXLF9_mTwkDcF2Uw6e_es04axqGs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@newunderthesun7353","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD2GXbE6Nye","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"My only argument is that you're waging a losing battle against the march of technology. Technology has a tendency to make anything in its path eventually disappear - and artistic endeavors are not immune. There is a Goldilocks zone where technology and human innovation work hand in hand. Enhancing our capabilities, providing positive outcomes, enriching both our humaness and humanity. With technological advancement, the definitions of human and humanity start to blur ('more human than the human'\") as we either try to create laws to (futilely) stop the progress or merge as best we can with it - socially, culturally, psychologically, etc, eventually that technology will surpase human capabilities and go beyond - in both ability and comprehension. I ask you, when will the cutoff be when it becomes absurd - from a commercial standpoint - to hire a composer when a device, in a fraction of time, will create a piece of music far more beautiful, more astounding & more innovative than any human? . To think that processes like painting, making music, archetecture isn't subjected to the same harsh reality of technology and its eventually erasing everything in its path... is both short sighted and lacking in vision. Like I said, you are waging a losing battle.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCp8fC_VLKTI3WRnewNYwKuQ","author":"@daydream-musik","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TmAp_aZ_zdiZYpumhfJnKbx0mVnO0WbCSTDdvIwYYAiNNFK_SbcFnEqkgCzJBQZatPF6VB7psw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@daydream-musik","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dACyND43_WZb","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"I absolute love your music and respect you Benn but deferring to a single legal judgement to decide the value of art feels strange to me. I don't like that large amounts of slop is being mass generated and used to siphon money from real artists but at the same time the way you discuss this it sounds like you considering generative art negative across the board. If a generated song creates emotional resonance with the listener, even if the only listener is the one person who generated it, is that worthless and worthy of derision?\n\nWith Suno if I structure the lyrics and prompt right (and especially starting with a melody I record myself singing as a baseline) I can produce something that has great meaning to me (after a few hundred iterations and combining the sections close to what i'm looking for). I wouldn't be so arrogant to upload it for money but I get the feeling you find that entire process distasteful. I get why you would be protective of your craft, but its a bummer to see so many artists completely reject new tools for creating art just because they don't like its implications for recognition/money. I suspect that generative music will become a great source for stems that producers can work into their tracks without giving away the entire creative process to the machine.","like_count":28,"author_id":"UCQMoeE-7VsbOEpHflU8FohA","author":"@HuntersHunter","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lIbyKRgznIKtyy-S1FiXrE5s29el3MsKn3roTorR1ciw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HuntersHunter","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dAD0BLtmNFwf","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"Yes my valid argument is 100% legal generation of AI music using Suno with a paid subscription illegally on the music! Music is music it doesn’t matter how it’s made. And I legally distributed it to all the popular music streaming sites. 100% legal get used to it","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC7YUQhTgaR1ut8YB8svIbrQ","author":"@spaceminers","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJbXargVKZaXqMNXdTS1bsnIQGavfb9-n70S8rIHT--w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@spaceminers","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dACy7V0vgwtn","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":" @BennJordan  \"For the foregoing reasons, defendants are correct that the Copyright Office acted properly in denying copyright registration for a work created absent any human involvement.\"\n\nYes, for THIS specific case, not for AI music in general involving some human involvement.\n\nYou just cherry picked what you want: the reality about copyrighting music made with AI is different from what you think it is.\n\nAgain: do you really think Suno terms of use are illegal ? Prove me wrong.","like_count":23,"author_id":"UCxCxBzlCRdqiExf5fjj0bBQ","author":"@NicolasPerrier","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0aDiH6XNbAcQl5JmrwRV2A5Ic_mgXEwFdjI9RIYdEHRNscTsFlhitqysEjVVREppUH7jUelc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NicolasPerrier","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg.ACxxtYz0y4dACyCQs7MkdR","parent":"Ugwbfm7-jdJ934bOxkl4AaABAg","text":"If people enjoy listening to AI and can’t tell the difference between a human artist why shouldn’t they get paid. Someone still has to do the work of generating a “song”.","like_count":30,"author_id":"UCmCV-MET2kgYFBTx50dqKYw","author":"@BallinLikeMike23","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WH7nU_hGa8TpOI9JM9ZdiRYAzQwAyOWDpjp_6nHlPIUujk3BzqAjPCK5D1QHWnEtjFmQ2Z9pUw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BallinLikeMike23","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a graphic designer AI art has been absolutely unbearable and really affected how i work, i've been forced to use this chrome extension called 'Pre-AI Search' which literally just filters to searches before 2023 (lol) and its the only way i can actually get non-AI reference designs anymore. Can't even imagine what the internet will be like in a few years.","like_count":1800,"author_id":"UCuh-MRfTqeHG16ggtdPS4JA","author":"@rarefrankie1372","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m_QuBVCM_XLGWn0IGe6auLzbvbF8rkCVj4V8YJA62-3AW8DIZweb9wvWJwVbes1JRmv0M_4trw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rarefrankie1372","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAD5TSTBoLE3","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"If you're on a different browser or don't want an extension, before:(year) works in Google to show images before a certain date, I.e. (your search) before:2022","like_count":98,"author_id":"UCmwVwX3ulgzID3S2pQiDoWQ","author":"@sax0cat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FeTP6bUrKPHCcKMsonxlMJRQlLMPD5INaFHSn0Zch3ZiR7Pr4g8Nkrsr8ti-Hhqe696bh3HMiA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sax0cat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAD3-TWjPSAq","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"it especially sucks when it's one of the first few image results...","like_count":81,"author_id":"UCmNJAb1T_OURCBGQMQct56w","author":"@dotopal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SbBmczDNaQA_cm53h5c09j9K9AD9Mw-LGCXc2-Pk6wJ04rmblDv1381Nt-yQfL5WJGQ3QvEFQQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dotopal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAD6Cvl5-AEM","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"My graphic design work went from 60% of my work to less than 10% in 2024, the hit is real. Thankfully as a long-time DJ (since the 90s) i have been able to take on more gigs to cover that (don't get me started on the state DJing is in the last few years hahaa).","like_count":65,"author_id":"UC6IPTmyTP-jmzS7XGbf0sAg","author":"@samuraiguineapig","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8WsjTfm8na2YS9bFGGBTRgyZsE1HFf_s0IjZcUHi16ao84kgMCzpTfOeCW2J2_l2z9cZGLqevA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@samuraiguineapig","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAD9pUxmslSo","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"I think \"AI \"AI Detection\"\" funnily enough will get better with time... So I'm hoping that it'll start to get easier to filter out the junk","like_count":14,"author_id":"UCljMAUdPnhCpOW-qYEm6t7g","author":"@johnathandoe6034","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cA4tzy52seqB0iP1ZuFleayWMXgmIsf6aK8zz0MLSfRTOVzroWzaLCWER4oasWbPBETX8Dxc3g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johnathandoe6034","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAD8qN7eaHcA","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"AI is really out here ruining every industry imaginable. Even surprisingly niche ones where people insist on taking shortcuts for everything","like_count":43,"author_id":"UCf-9boi-wdt3tS31deIZHYA","author":"@avonire","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RBjuwpTDIwEqR0HSFoJyUYUfa6J13Kqjliq5my_DFvYg5hf3x9S8v5CRLs1pM7eWJHldIh4Vfw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@avonire","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADH9w20uR0I","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"A while ago i saw a poll in a large heavy metal music group on FB asking if they would buy an album with AI generated cover. 9/10 said they would not. \n\nPeople dont want AI \"art\" and understand the problems with it. Hopefully this will translate to less AI \"art\" being sold.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCf1QcXlfT_LCBeakTxp6feg","author":"@TheZeeall","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nHWufVfUrPcHo8GzPZpOZdkI6zaPFnCKR-shUF0dU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheZeeall","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADEd6VlH6sR","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Yeah seeing this while going to school for graphic design has slowly lowered my outlook, i hope it doesn't replace animators","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCow8CFVdAk2pUNfQT_sH4cQ","author":"@pastelgothine420","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MOzHyDCCm05ry_55NFPk3U76E9Sw_8J33A0DEWHl4nCFCNCMUowQm_EE4IrcCmtk7RZj-CttTg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pastelgothine420","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADDVRGpWpCt","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"The only way ai can be morally right is if it can not be published or monetised in any way.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCArDbNRoOH7uVPtLDSL81EA","author":"@Dexwa0","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6Mf1IcNlNhbdbdd9RsEbKxiOzzmqcRc_ekdpR3pdagTPuR8yjDMp3bj-tHrZDaCAWDQyRjrirQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dexwa0","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADKTiYNVM6Z","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"This is a great ad campaign by the way","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCiqhg2MHwvyFy9W6fqS0RhA","author":"@Meilk27","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qUIEjSp36qCb6af32vBAZoiMkNzWRiYtHRjt2M7ir4DacPXanj8tTVvoRSZjQiWIVLnPoFKXrA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Meilk27","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAD6itbJUD3w","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Welcome to why I hate tech bros","like_count":47,"author_id":"UCw4qTLZHjhO77P9Y2kosIQw","author":"@deezboyeed6764","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZAu6CNvgm-JpBK4Fvb4J43W9ahyyxv8UD5UBhmyUbeRMORs1BrrOoUhSF1HHip9sZUg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@deezboyeed6764","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADAAqJGtPxu","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":" @Frikoppie-j6f  happy bday bud!","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCuh-MRfTqeHG16ggtdPS4JA","author":"@rarefrankie1372","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m_QuBVCM_XLGWn0IGe6auLzbvbF8rkCVj4V8YJA62-3AW8DIZweb9wvWJwVbes1JRmv0M_4trw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rarefrankie1372","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADB3HJX1e-P","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Its fucking infuriating","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCPhBPT-0QS0wLjrIBOWsl_A","author":"@NicoleHam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zw5TmUYOcWwEqj8pGMTYm4rJlvGuLAnyA0PGs0HUnXQVRRck-1KVS3bMV-vMVv0HtJDTGKrR=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NicoleHam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADHbZqdFCJ_","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"let's hope we are in the worst time before regulation and AI getting worse because of lack of good data","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCfFc4W7IuYu5jbJbugd7S0A","author":"@ggadams639","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3xWvpuasz_R3hCHPg28nzfdCh4eXnRO9LkHHv6wFZYqdJFhGiAHIVje57zy2UfIjdif9iktbbw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ggadams639","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADOS-Z4kdo4","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Yeah we gotta figure out ai filteration before the ai slopification of the internet begins","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCyfLW6TTHtAFF9R-YuJ_XWw","author":"@FaizKTG","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n9dr3gw1l3HeqTKa1U7_OniBhc_jKZnXZqmnKhn77-U5I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FaizKTG","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADWoujwbwM8","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"This video is very important","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCM26IhlzLOWUxjPWGJi9kSw","author":"@RonaldRegain","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m-9i6WfHjVE-ku5AkxRHmMQRwhCmuFQLX1vZRFK1KGFg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RonaldRegain","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADop6JCOa8K","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"I kind of disagree. I just decided to entertain this hypothesis, and started searching some random terms without any plugins or extensions on Google. For most specific searches results are mostly real images (From what I can tell). The only results that are obviously polluted are the most obvious ones like \"futuristic city\" or \"anime girl\".","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCYvwE4AgQ8zcYwyUrcf8ypg","author":"@eanfran","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ht16My75QFTj0pwTXVTw89wV-C9RIJWnnp4sP5Sebr9SN1AB1XVTXcsRh4kijAV9oPrzB0RY-A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@eanfran","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAFPKJkNaqOO","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Talk to a photographer who was professional 20 or 30 years ago. This atomization of pay for creatives is nothing new. I taught myself to day trade to make money, and it's no easy task, I tell you. At least it means I do only purely creative work for myself.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCTEgd2_eD0VKqdcg46wkGSg","author":"@foto21","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mE9QmvvrKQUAu_MLyS1ZDbKyu9pe-JpNqQ7s8k9nZ9fp4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@foto21","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADieeahUasO","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"What is the problem with using an AI generated reference design? You're not using the design in your work","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNX3MGERqrWO_FC60brgbqA","author":"@bradbradson4543","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mFygwIo7CnpTxY89LCqGBoAbFqX2tyGH7PwL1MlAM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bradbradson4543","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAFzC-f5R4Nb","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"If you're looking for reference designs your work isn't original, is it? So what difference does it make if the design is AI generated or not? If anything it might be a better design as it will have learned to distil a reference from a million examples.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwpkeY4tAgBumIHZB1Pu1XQ","author":"@filtomsun","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TJzYIepQ8aoOMxw7nGIt9DIa3_uk1u1OfEvqKANZqjG9QaZ0_EVv5ODas_zjgnnpstnyYTqiYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@filtomsun","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAKnbRxWQJw9","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Have you considered using AI for the boring tasks of graphic design, thereby freeing up your time to do projects you care about?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3f0QY5gA4YbhYLP25CKgLg","author":"@JohnPaluska","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mbfggB3b7fGcoKSw8UFbj7xpdXiGOZG4lmvBrb9F4hJbs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JohnPaluska","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDAX8_IHM1JTm","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Das Internet blieb stehen ab 2023","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3o5oIRmu9jX4t2K3iJAT-g","author":"@TrayLifeStyle","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/M0rPr1a3xmF-mKBMHcRJmPIHg8e6bIjds7Xz7cp5w0BFVTfsOsJYenSuJih_4U5d0Pg-FiZZ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TrayLifeStyle","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADA_K-7kmdd","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Highly recommend you try adding negative tags to your searches,  these would look like this: \n\nGnome stock image -\"ai\" -\"midjourney\" -\"generated\"","like_count":9,"author_id":"UChH7UpvqKAwvZ91rUf7S0fw","author":"@Wodgedev","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fxWPYkUxuywJtqWufSSXG87G284ACL87atxG4JZekySUmq1ofIj5SSKPRL_XdKC-_ww00nL_oQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Wodgedev","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADRakyYskB5","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":" @Frikoppie-j6f  It absolutely did. I'm not paying for stock images anymore and projects take me shorter time to make because of the available materials. I have more time free and make more money per project.  You probably don't know how we worked circa 2010. All of the kids have it way easier and they still can't do it. And lately good programs have emerged. For us oldies upscaling works like magic. Flexo pre-press color separation is also automated used to take us hours. Graphic nesting for guillotine cuts used to take us hours to montage now it's automatic. I can go on and on","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCvsnw9MSXsYfsoRDdI3hnbg","author":"@GiJoe94","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVfxBemKTXVOvYzuHj3r_aqBBGDF_m8iUtvR9qB3klUkFKm43FfQihtLRU7-euWiffJg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GiJoe94","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADj33HzVUxm","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"If you're using reference designs like that, you're just mechanical turking AI design...  You're doing the exact thing that AI does, just much slower. Compared to graphic designers without the internet or graphic design software, you're AI...  AI is just another tool, It's no different from being able to buy supplies ready-made verses having to mix your own paints, or create your own plaster mix, or even having books and prints...  Complaining about AI is just gatekeeping.  If you're an original artist you can compete with and without AI tools.   The reality is that the craft of art is not appreciated by an overwhelming majority, what people care about is what it looks like, and sadly if it doesn't look like something they've seen before, the public won't like it.  There's no difference between a sandcastle built in a mold, verses one that was built grain-by-grain with super-glue and a pair of tweezers, both of them are going to be viewed in fleeting glances by indifferent masses on tiny screens.  If your tools matter, it's performance that is your art, not the piece your create.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCGw5aN3g4bA2A8Bza9_RFeg","author":"@EarthWalkerOne","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mlEnA_CYn0rV_-6H-O6JC0kGdGAGuGYECltlo0LZHcLZnMN_xr6jbqVUURpcF0dDIR5g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EarthWalkerOne","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADEvtK_A6Es","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"AI imaging existed before 2023.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC-uueGWpJMGTL9CXXB2M_Sg","author":"@YouAreMyDescription","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/jKQuOqhxVDUs8_b1GN3eUXVBbbF_Z6ObB8VXnvqMS9dtezSApVzik3rrycMxVikQsVPsSH4QfI0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@YouAreMyDescription","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDALAvG2bLj9e","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"Some Higher up AI engineers are saying EVERY on will have AI access, and that specialized ones for education or medical information will be the way. They are even talking about connecting Bitcoin, electricity, GPUs as a kind of data currency. The concept is to have universal AI, and every use of it would be donating something to the societal ones that are beneficial.  I was a graphic designer at one time- and the whole  AI thing is insane to me. \nThe ongoing lack of appreciation for artists and art has  not been happy making over the years.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCyuDzJsg-_lTY70ldDhcMpQ","author":"@patriciaellinghausen4365","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/T6OrkQGCFU8dhcDePUzW1VsxRe2vn6LmZTEqt8cBxWz9jckcDYHSJQsmDSHUV8AU0Sihgor-MQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@patriciaellinghausen4365","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADA85IJw5By","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"I used an AI generator music website on twitch with twitch chat and even with us trying to break it or just screwing around it still somehow made something actually decent. While sure it was funny it really does just show the only thing these programs are missing is a real persons voice. which these AI places can just achieve. Shoot I even posted one of them as meme on a short because it was pretty good meme material. Feels very unfair to musicians because they don't have a program that is similar to nightshade","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC8lkGDxzwlzYUIfMSpokAzQ","author":"@Colorstormfur","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dkMDyfyU60CptRoro9pSxXNC4hhN1htIYTeiRi7DRXpBj5fBAY66WQyT6tLWLgWeujraAAdxLIQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Colorstormfur","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg.AD2AORd04vDADR7dc5Qdps","parent":"UgyhByKfiSfDJRtHGhN4AaABAg","text":"To be honest AI made my profit margin go up and work got faster and easier as a designer","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCvsnw9MSXsYfsoRDdI3hnbg","author":"@GiJoe94","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVfxBemKTXVOvYzuHj3r_aqBBGDF_m8iUtvR9qB3klUkFKm43FfQihtLRU7-euWiffJg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GiJoe94","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:58 \"There's nothing fair about stealing an artist's life's work\", says the RECORD INDUSTRY, without a hint of irony","like_count":1300,"author_id":"UCY6WluqKU4xW7EeFi1MIZCw","author":"@SubmitToTheBiomass","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsrz4zSg5dCaCCnEm7_KS4-_Sfa1doGWI7EyxUDUrudZ1ahvhxsdDwvXeOce18W0Drwg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SubmitToTheBiomass","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58ACxC6hY-wbc","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"lmao who invited the record company simps?","like_count":75,"author_id":"UCY6WluqKU4xW7EeFi1MIZCw","author":"@SubmitToTheBiomass","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsrz4zSg5dCaCCnEm7_KS4-_Sfa1doGWI7EyxUDUrudZ1ahvhxsdDwvXeOce18W0Drwg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SubmitToTheBiomass","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58ACwdCrJqnBy","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"To your statement, the record company execs would reply, \"Hey, we didn't steal anything!  We swindled, it, fair and square!\"","like_count":161,"author_id":"UCxEE5ITDoMfOVh9Q51wVCrg","author":"@nomore6167","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ndrOWvJ8yq0fIrVTu5LwWk5offUqoAbNqzJxAC7bo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nomore6167","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58ACyEegfAxfD","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"I'm all in on hating major labels. But point out which one is reselling my IP without my consent, because that's what AI is doing.","like_count":254,"author_id":"UCshObcm-nLhbu8MY50EZ5Ng","author":"@BennJordan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n4yN6OoQTOtdKr9MtPVRhT38hPTP0NUkc10Ni6wZWljek_9XRq0EuBi7PbmJb2bRs_WxcgQe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":true,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BennJordan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58AD5XcmvtEyz","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":" @SubmitToTheBiomass  All the legal fight is about, is who will control it, the major labels, or outfits like Suno.  Neither of those entities has anyone’s best interests at heart.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCXtFfN8l9OwUrHkbsNb2ZQQ","author":"@ckatheman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h7qi9GGQuRKxDiGbq5boLKec9XE4NNSrHfO8mrL-w5l9uRNPQKBYWK1dTlYRzhH_-YSjY69J=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ckatheman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58AD4DuhdSjxp","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"Or like milli vanilli, steal their life.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoDMHeKAW09dqtGNXuoffIQ","author":"@DJ-Daz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kG_meeAFYi3m8o-bQ-aBwJMmasD1vjSQr8yODqwzrhbAZRFS6n_hLr81srsBASydidhE0WWySA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DJ-Daz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58ADG1IQ3EldQ","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"They usually pay for it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6HzV9_o0J_DrpmKhk_RMEQ","author":"@Hakasedess","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lLz9-1fOpq4_zvubXdFdr1bTbIg6dXiJ03lHdDh9B4W90=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Hakasedess","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58AD-NsFrbF2x","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"At least you're CONSENTING to it with the record label. These genAI scum simply take everyone's work, profit off it and give nothing back, don't even ask.\nIt's extremely harmful to the arts, something so core to the human experience. But people devoid of any actual creative interest just see a quick ticket to money or views and don't care about the harm they are causing or don't understand it because their relationship with art is so surface-level.","like_count":17,"author_id":"UC3U44TGF8G4pPCpAhrUGClA","author":"@invertexyz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LFsOG_V82deyT3qJTbWP4khF9gyCufwmtyn2qLeZUUFwmpKwk7r-X_wWma3-8507UKsQCn6H=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@invertexyz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58ACzGLm2Hqor","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"If I had to choose between techies selling promises and saying \"don't worry you will be fine too\", OR record company executives, I will take the record companies any day.","like_count":8,"author_id":"UClz3zEicojcWmCYDE1ZOBlA","author":"@InternetJunkHuman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kNxgC8ci-CBWVpgP29NvJC7fnjoQOIEMYbxJz7_kKCyq9Hpu32YCOe9EXktnhHN76exg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@InternetJunkHuman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58AD-HKX8yiyq","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"Tech took my job, people didn’t care…Tech takes artist’s jobs and they call it a tragedy?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCBZrn9wNXxsmXEikWofaJ5w","author":"@drachenmarke","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hjV6Fr_e54pVPsAvdvLo_WA5H-VE9O6sxVceYmE5-l6OQQJaaY9RBTWlrls_ABfMy3UZs_vdvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drachenmarke","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg.ACvokMOjK58ACxAeE2l_jy","parent":"UgwvHSfSrIKiP9Dvbst4AaABAg","text":"Then don't take their money","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCM0PFhSWS7Ri_w9NHA2tWmg","author":"@eloytoro","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mQVwwK33uWf087VKr56v5YULupmqCY-4Zzx1BHKk2A1_4z=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@eloytoro","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You can detect AI-generated artwork basically the same way. Even when you download AI-generated art as what is supposed to be a lossless PNG file, it still has JPEG compression artifacts in it, because the data it's been trained on is virtually all from compressed JPEG images, so that's what it thinks the images are supposed to look like, and thus the AI model reproduces the compression artifacts as part of its own art.","like_count":1200,"author_id":"UC1ydE9gDHTdvbNVIgEKIKzw","author":"@vwestlife","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ULDd21lg6H148kLzwdu4bkTzl2HWjvuUc7xwAS3y0Ag26qnGLP3UIEz-U6_bICPJDLQEqXc4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vwestlife","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjADAMO80_PzI","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"Converting to JPEG is a destructive process","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0C8FuS44LPvGpQcEHlzW6A","author":"@Sam_Hue","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FswHjACZNWL9bQrfmeLARvEr9CiiovU4IQd80_VDkN8cHsrg4FwlpMtxFdk4JLZKXgaLPOBv5g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sam_Hue","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjAE59qafpdAL","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"Ayy crazy to see you here","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmyuOL90a4-bMNwGYusW0Ug","author":"@Moto_Medics","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ySn-3JBVRWgTLDb7aEFC5Fake6o5YGlsfSRHYCG7HDb2zkvH01TK_kBZM9pmgH7mtpLAFF9D6w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Moto_Medics","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjANbb7he1tuy","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"that really depends, you can train on lossless images","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC43sRL7IF7QJo1c2KArJ2eg","author":"@tutacat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTrrHNGPRIMVPlGVJWJRUZyPKZgYzMHAYeE5q4nDRgYMMh1I483VD9E0r_pf3-S3k_iQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tutacat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjAUYQiTSxFBK","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"Yes, but that doesn't solve the problem for users who ONLY have music in compressed form to begin with.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4FcrAEBS_rEaAhTn6DPdUA","author":"@FrankHarwald","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lO_-M9PIj8lhisA3BRSiFIfdY2uw0bD6-vAsOjp1OZHsU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FrankHarwald","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjAD2TjONZf07","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"Most of the AI detection tools that try to do anything remotely like this have abyssal accuracy rates, and those success rates are generally higher with older, outdated generative models.\n\nThat includes both false positives as well as false negatives. And the moment any editing is done to the image (cropping, resizing, transforms, filters, upscale, etc) their accuracy drops even lower.","like_count":29,"author_id":"UCB0a7SaPte1S3AmofkJMVJA","author":"@VanisherXP","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5MdzEwsTZUm4433Qv6616J1rFEuFOiOJFbQe1jd4KDCvSXJI9XapxJiAEA_qxN8LdmbFbddbwA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@VanisherXP","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjAD1c7Gyvz7L","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"But hardly anyone ever views a lossless PNG, so the moment it gets converted to a lossy file is it still detectable?","like_count":29,"author_id":"UCU9sGBjkuHdFUkhkcl4XyQg","author":"@agentbananauk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lAC_4YGyebzP4jHyldPx1H8ywOR8bResUrJAVwVJY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@agentbananauk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjADarJIkKI51","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"And then you take a screenshot erasing all of that","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUU64SjVHHzYv1nwbKi0d7w","author":"@WestHondurasCafe","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZB_ODzxoASxomWAP6HfrGUIwAfWLR2Rabm4gAuI5Hkj8SMeRt2PN7tpIvh96HPF2_acHjlsX=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WestHondurasCafe","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjAD2OjQAG9Ox","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"... and if you just add a jpeg compressed stock image - or parts of it - to your own hi res artwork. How would that be different?","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC5gNFEOnEsY2QwtwaiOlSYg","author":"@zzmarx","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k1hKY140XeCAIuglJ0Jtpw0kgi4hR-zPpRtgJPbulwsg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zzmarx","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjAD9BghyXoVJ","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"you dont seem to understand how training actually works\nyou dont just throw a folder of images into a black box and take whatever comes out","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCvixzxpeHLNXtXrNC9nmIDg","author":"@Tuuuuri","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xxCXytSBF5kPmvSKWxbLA1ZGfd2WxFIYLxIiVtAn_E_a5IYclb26FNu9Uybbs1HU322TFGAb9g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tuuuuri","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjAD2YbxEC08f","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"What if I just save an AI image as jpeg? How do you detect it now?","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCHa24MhwltcVlPOCuDjVhOw","author":"@kaydog890","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxw5_zTJrzLNKWJ5dtGOqLfnWDjIkSewn7rZ8VztE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kaydog890","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg.ACypCzl9LdjADVtKdZB3WK","parent":"Ugy9ePVWfAaVm74iKix4AaABAg","text":"Whats worse than AI, is people like you who think you can tell whats AI or not.\n\nStop, you cant, you suck detecting it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClCdT8YVujOZOoYduXgP7FQ","author":"@draken5379","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOEZvjUov39Om4Y5-Ehh-XTZYzRq7yeeWbmlnj1jc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@draken5379","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugztkzo_dIMfauo68c54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"1:00 wait until you find out that spotify does this themselves then jams it into playlists where people arent going to be paying attention","like_count":163,"author_id":"UCJnN-DiypnAnSMZjYKB_5SQ","author":"@HerbaceousM8","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qX9KGJim1qQnT6fepf_QzoW9Ick8Ad0KuXKpjKzIgntHBuS7-PO6kZvjKUy_sI7rkeG8rsgxVg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HerbaceousM8","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugztkzo_dIMfauo68c54AaABAg.ACyomIe8qtPACzLvHTb7bw","parent":"Ugztkzo_dIMfauo68c54AaABAg","text":"Turn off Smart Shuffle and play only music you added to a playlist by yourself.","like_count":26,"author_id":"UCQivAKOTad1G1q3R-pC7f6A","author":"@mrolowu1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kwhzEiqf9gdkebIY7JYQUuPRtMAgqXZglRqNVyCPQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mrolowu1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugztkzo_dIMfauo68c54AaABAg.ACyomIe8qtPAQ8KMv8yVo5","parent":"Ugztkzo_dIMfauo68c54AaABAg","text":"I think the best solution to this is unsub Spotify.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIuwDEphHFT-6x8pGfNKsww","author":"@LabGecko","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RjQNFuzhWiVdu07qvNw04E2frps15BQTIVTqpjx49hlep_0aOEbOOn2ywK2n_kFwtu_vYQfmu88=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LabGecko","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugztkzo_dIMfauo68c54AaABAg.ACyomIe8qtPAD00N_ijawh","parent":"Ugztkzo_dIMfauo68c54AaABAg","text":"Not true, they use real artists and work with labels to \"jam\" the playlists. It's for producers who just want to make music and earn a living.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCYRrKbJBCE5bOJXlUD6sHug","author":"@ak69981","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/t2FWSEYRFNqTExpaHCq3I-mpr1rlD7fOnPSKSDGy81Q8CLuNDaAibsO_3v_tOze4mCK5-o6laMw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ak69981","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzBuTWpnh5oCTXG-Wp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So stoked that a bit of my music was used in this video at 4:40 thanks Benn you rock! ❤ Appreciate your content very much 🙏","like_count":54,"author_id":"UC-6OyeP_Tk6G-gt5JSVKzkg","author":"@Steven_Beddall","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_spwF-5Puq-juYMsk8hBE6dfE0unAEHm63blUBivrsuTSgcJD6ZeapdTKdfUslOZ3_SSGt7U1-Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Steven_Beddall","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My biggest issue with users of GenAI is hypocrisy. I know programmers who will happily use Suno/Udio while simultaneously railing against coding assistants like Cursor which are trained on tons of copyrighted data. I know musicians who happily use Midjourney/Stable Diffusion to generate images while simultaneously cursing Suno/Udio. You don't get to cherrypick which form of GenAI is morally acceptable. Either they all are, or none of them are.","like_count":2600,"author_id":"UC_be_5GTTvV4_uiiLopwLrg","author":"@scpedicini","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mc0pCgMSo6X9MI-DKgv9XlNWNv0XRHeQXzRltG43Edgkwn=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@scpedicini","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADLPM64cWfl","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"You are so right...\n\n\n\n\n\n\n...but also none of them are morally usable.","like_count":14,"author_id":"UCsz6AEDXsVlIcDooWQXyIBA","author":"@EPICGAMER999M","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MiGGUMgA-tT2vpz-ltNd89u6el41xEQqllb03KgZ0Y6N2QmULcDNLm_F2R0JzLSP64MCEUhsOg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EPICGAMER999M","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACvUPVCmRZY","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Hypocrisy? I thought it was the stealing.","like_count":167,"author_id":"UCsQJOGhnswm6qqbR5wevfSw","author":"@jonessii","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kZy0of2JviGPB3tXGmiZZ7-gxMEVybzUcsEk4mJcs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jonessii","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADJ14wRdiTs","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"I just dont want folks to lose their creativity.. try to balance such","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCMh9c2zKnOC3T836gIWLIxQ","author":"@gonelucid","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mnB0RYwJsBNFcLIKdlcWsPjgayZ46ynRNXl2Yetzb_-_Jkyi3Es6zWmNuWPnljSSqseB0Lk0HQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gonelucid","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAD4R4QcCav1","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"\"Rules for thee, but not for me.\"\nI hate that too.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC_gweb6Y3hexV9OoTwW1ALA","author":"@Dexter01992","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wL2Rdw5iUPEGGIaekfJUN3_McICHGOSP4BkzJACsNxNfDmyasxYAP49RMyXDcE00OlOX52F9vys=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dexter01992","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAD06kj0KsBr","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Feel the same about Bill cosby. The hypocrisy is the worst part","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCE_UVuI9yS5ydyq-1eljthg","author":"@MCrObOt18","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/V0lJ8BsdJvGejYnbXDcvEHJ0nsg6oa7UsSvm8Zkiii3ZLweOng3s1NE4k2t06SyR8idGzDwH37w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MCrObOt18","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACxYg97LhBc","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Cognitive dissonance at its finest. That's how we survive","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTeK_zaRUH1MlnEAUUfqRqw","author":"@Moonlight96543","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mNkj4pW6jUvChG4gBzsrYlBtzdpsU-SuNMu6MPKVmDoCxY2_D05vAOfPJE2IATJUm0Sw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Moonlight96543","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACx_NoBC1Kn","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Nailed it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7Z9tceyDqE2mrGlxFq45fw","author":"@judsonsnell","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SemdjKD8kap-sUAJWKadt4gclBMquZJ6bekEM8H2pZO6LjeiFLoV3JnfLQk40-1syzomde4tgg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@judsonsnell","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAD00H_zXavZ","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"This is the comment of the year 🎉","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChmUHzxLOozWAqoascrfMGQ","author":"@maritimans","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mnkgoAtxq62in34qe7aMzx7dOb_pYQaZd-JGTcVRnR-UfCEo1vK5Kbm_B2Q-JToCKgF531hG5Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maritimans","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADHZg9lsAvt","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Exactly. I'm in a lot of author spaces and they use AI generated cover art, but say AI writing should never be used to write books.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn9E3uqsiCQTLrjmmHNjbJQ","author":"@shrks104","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TdWWwdsRFzZrTS4suEMZhFZ3afQSijWXJvBJ-JAtqD5lx1mMJFoNBFypKEbT0rPsVj_Hd7ZmuA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shrks104","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADIHzTn7gsZ","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Most employed programmers I’ve talked to do not care if it saves them even 5% of time on the job","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6hD_CyfaRrzOywOW4hc-IA","author":"@hepticftw","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nwvIbni4YG3rmPSRBmA-5cRkPntU9dE1RdzQMbGY2Kgw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hepticftw","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADKFazHchPS","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"None all the way","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW5hs94PZc8ludj6s2f32Dg","author":"@WinterBoots15","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nu-owLSzSAOw7v6sr7Bj1cwMcU9njrRV4TkOcKl_St_AY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WinterBoots15","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADMt_IURHzl","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Honestly I think the problem is the way people use them. They try to profit off of them. If people just used them as inspiration for their own works, it wouldn't be as much of a moral issue as it has turned out to be.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCURr3W7KSns0MHdxpolOHHw","author":"@MattMarkYT","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/l_oeEEtVFwKFG8PD0cVlmAHyjasdcCz0ygRVvma_WjI-h2EheIO9RUlVGQ-UswijikbQPYV9=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MattMarkYT","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADyOfpUxSpg","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"wisdom.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCD_XuSvMd5SFC_EwAxo0bJw","author":"@REDBowllTheDevil","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ucaJDIMRe54D1LFlG_EDsSGmD--2ds-vukcicYX1zSiork7sUZCErywG5mbNPpIEmSAeA3PT=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@REDBowllTheDevil","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAEM73ks5Ajb","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"There is a big difference between buying running shoes to run a marathon and having a machine run a marathon for you that you claim the achievement for yourself. \nGpt is a tool that can help with writing but you still have to put the work in. Youtube artist releasing five 3 hour playlists a week with Suno and pretending it is their own music is completely different.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsNejjI4k2EaznXSNf_9jyg","author":"@Pubwie","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fel_YCZLO5tF0ZCb9_ygbfsoZnIxexuWgQcvKvQ3zyZ7W1Miq1SUbmwyiFr1ZP-Ownl6p7i9TTk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Pubwie","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAGhDW1dEL_E","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Using gen AI accelerates how quickly people will lose their jobs as a result. Ideally it should matter equally whether it harms yourself or someone else, but currently in the minds of many, harm to others is ignored more often.\n\nThat said, someone doing good 50% of the time is still a lot better than them doing good 0% of the time, even though the former might be criticized for hypocrisy more often.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAjy0zlyG65Aela752f2gqw","author":"@miyalys","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/I80Q2XpeCpChnZZxh4MhLS97s_qSzWPC2PorO_Fy2Zep0K43jyPD6-JjkmtS7PgCw892m5bygpw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@miyalys","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAIbYz7O-oXE","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"The difference is that programmers are not using AI to create art. Many are just using it to do their job faster. The code either works or it doesn't, so AI can generate actual value.\n\nThe label \"generative AI\" isn't even well defined. ChatGPT is a completely different algorithm than Midjourny. Is any piece of software that generates something immoral?\n\nWe can easily draw moral boundaries if we decide what it is we value in society and specifically how software can violate it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4xVBCtIQ0XinLjwoGs50cA","author":"@Mike54831","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mkFHeNX4BB-m_0koPh5oEAUgPST9mzO9ZRTwfJBGb2tPE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mike54831","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAKT4jmJlNWM","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"cool comment ai bot 🙄👍🏼","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3KM_fnTj9Qz2nEpZ-pB21Q","author":"@DSWL_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/L9lpm7SRYmzFFDR-HglL1bIP4kaGy3AbLXJjij4FtWHvzGiY6tUkTmZxNWONNAV4w831rK8g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DSWL_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAKV8XIg3OZ7","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Sadly most developers have drunk the Generative AI koolaid tho. Either directly via dedicated IDE/Text editors, extensions/plugins or CLI/browser based tools. Producing sloppy code they probably don't even understand since well most don't thoroughly review the code anyway. \n\nMy guess is that older developers don't really care, they're already highly proficient it's an exciting new technology that won't replace them by the time they retire, some juniors that are bad at programming see it as the only way to be able to write a Hello World and the other ones don't want to miss out and have the former group get an unfair advantage on them.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoRW2Rt3-NuMsIxqHQYAaeQ","author":"@heroe1486","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nfrjNiENXYdkfXfVFGbBHDCTkt6BKhOEehjGvMw3uN2Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@heroe1486","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAKnbHPVAbVO","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"I 100% agree. But I also understand where they are coming from in that they don't care if it doesn't affect them personally. To me, I love it, and this is from someone who absolutely loves composing and producing music. What AI does for me is save a bunch of time. I can spend more time making something I am truly passionate about and then the AI can make the \"other\" stuff.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3f0QY5gA4YbhYLP25CKgLg","author":"@JohnPaluska","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mbfggB3b7fGcoKSw8UFbj7xpdXiGOZG4lmvBrb9F4hJbs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JohnPaluska","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENANuHpcoZWSD","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"The issue is not the tool but how the tool have been thought into inception or the materials used. All music, art and coding materials are overdue for compensation cause they where used without permission but that doesn't mean the tools are bad","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpZJrN3Y3Mm2KQbfJ_CTxHw","author":"@goingLive-d7c","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qJRtVkfffLb956nsSjSsH6NvhtJ-iFtOgH4pULrl5F0un9d0dg6zfavgZ58O--i0elqAeYUIeA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@goingLive-d7c","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAPb0YTB2s7d","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"as an aspiring writer, i almost fell into that trap, but fortunately my procrastination meant before I used any generative AI on something I released publicly, I learned to do better.\nI still have not released anything, btw.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyGX0hqRii_LIU0nYHHU0DQ","author":"@av3stube480","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_muT8-LwYDbMJsF-a5ClNkscrdnuQeieUAUwrdQSVQ-VQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@av3stube480","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAPvMj1PqC-C","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"As a professional programmer and novice composer/producer.\n\nI think the programmers I know who are against coding AI are also against other types of generative AI.\n\nThere’s just a lot of programmers who are not anti AI","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHHVUrYYseXlEpQymUqhGrg","author":"@notactuallyarealperson2267","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nVm2PMe_AvdfnQRAAo71mLJqBRv7xqDTRqF8peq7-1Us4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@notactuallyarealperson2267","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENARq0FoX3z3r","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"So if somebody wrote an original melody , chord progression  and use AI to generate a song does it lose the copyright of his own song even if he wrote melody , chord and lyrics ?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTzTNrENGA4xitr8w2Hn9_g","author":"@CarloCansellaMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JBqYoBSo9AuLjN-Zrr-i6EnCK9LTCF-5yzoKQpgEa58Vm-WKrIDiuUURKy21ccA4gwxpSn6t2A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CarloCansellaMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENASYNaYXL5js","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Because u think that someone that plays music and generate a wallpaper for his background , is similar to someone that draw manually a background and use generated music ? And both of them are gonna be a music art ? \n\nHere is ur confusion . If the video is presented as a music performance, using an AI background for it don’t change it’s value : because the work is music . The background is just a secondary thing in the video . \n\nBut if u generate a music by pressing a button , and put an authentic picture that u made : if ur work is actually photography or painting : yes , the music is the background if it’s AI music it’s oka .\n\nBut . If u tell me , u generate a music and put a real background , and pretend it’s ur music , this is hypocrisy, and a delusion .","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzbF1IMUp9nPRgX10f4kp9w","author":"@rez77z","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kvuROa8XpCPDnSYddq8iEsTDRLax-0yaueAcagzHT7qbs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rez77z","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENATvMBCdkDjV","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Only Sith deal in absolutes…","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3udApQ9DYHtI2OqhrP0vuA","author":"@ofthemidnightrain","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Twcrwc7g8ckLhFVegE3WYcK4W6wn2kQ9AkxLAUhl40Nul-VNLQ55_Acvbb3L9PsJ-6OiywPC1g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ofthemidnightrain","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACyPMZYQ0ZS","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Honestly i am all for ai art-mimicry as long as it is labeled as AI art or AI assisted art.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCzJzIifjo6WFaBg8Kvgtemg","author":"@somekindofdude1130","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYZfJV1vcyQmBF9MXPxQRbVh0H-OE6J6nE4Ah3mQo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@somekindofdude1130","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAD-gLcEyrf6","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"I have literally never seen a programmer complain about Cursor or other AI tools in programming","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCZFoemzbbx4r7m5Gg83jKXQ","author":"@JohnnySacc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_khSbcYOk-ZJpJdnM0KT63okOiFU3WwtWMvAi-S5gxJah9fOAID9GlTIjWJnSHyDKWk4A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JohnnySacc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAD5TkuJiewv","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Is Cursor more specifically exploitative of copyright than the alternatives? I've heard about it but never used it. Coding is a bit different because it's more open source stuff that can be scraped for IDE completion and simple demos.\nI still think the stuff is evil across the board, designed to put us all out of work.\nPeople say GenAI is the next industrial revolution, it's not. AI is not creating anything new, or enabling us to meet economies of scale. It's designed to do what we already do now, and to take humans out of it.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCTylXq1OHgnkPYbOtfwDjcw","author":"@bert88sta","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_myoBuyEYreo8yKnmRPD8bgGsG6FjeejiZFutd68os=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bert88sta","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADCgrBYny4c","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"not really. getting some extra AI-generated frames out of a new nvidia graphics card is a completely different use case from somebody prompting Sora for a video or something","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCpXgbjYVSCiWtdpCnnYa59w","author":"@dubzy4485","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iofZ10zx72rkI_aF-I-i6FczlOJOX7m5P_kD-lXmx9uulaHgNbKloL5C9B8BlncYfMBcjPhJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dubzy4485","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACzy9PCl-Ce","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Even if we get past all the ownership and error issues, AI will always output samey stuff, leading us down an all-or-nothing road, where either everything works or everything breaks, if we rely on it","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCbVjkembIqSU1BHQZ-L3NfQ","author":"@frohnatur9806","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8ANzhjH_wOKiVouhJT3AnDSwBfHEBGqRdKkRB-Xybj6d5yJ1xvr3jx26UZTGz8TBy1ajuMr3au0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@frohnatur9806","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACxb1B9fXua","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"raging at hypocrisy is seriously futile .... everyone has varying motivations, accept reality and work towards creating \"your ideal\" just know that you are but a small part of a larger \"direction\"","like_count":1,"author_id":"UChKKg0NZexJ0ZDgfJiztITw","author":"@ChrissiX","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Mi5SKfFX0F4nWLEcccdejYpGENmpTKZoeSb1aT74BaDqfktOSHW4E66bz4BCM-fA1QXdQKM1Zg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ChrissiX","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAD-VaKCkQNU","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"As a programmer, I use generative ai for placeholder assets, which are not code, stuff like Cursor or Copilot just make you a bad programmer over time. Comparing those things are not equal since they are completely different fields.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCRvC3F4FA2tgXyOVxhMAMxw","author":"@slendidevel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/P7Q-Lv_F-2noIoyxFq5eyev7kuzYZK_uDmE8qlTwYBDfRlP2dVYUNQOtotTZ99VuU7KZdGxC=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@slendidevel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAD78MLkMRmI","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"I don't think that's necessarily true. Nuance is valuable. I'm not a user of GenAI, but I think it's entirely possible that useful and ethical use cases make themselves known in the coming years. To compare to a different technology, cell phones offer huge improvements to personal safety, but tons of phone apps make the human race worse. I'm not a hypocrite if I say that I don't like Twitter but I still use Google Maps. A developer asking genAI for coding advice isn't the same thing as a grifter uploading AI slop music to Spotify and making thousands for it.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCLAtuB8IdytZSX8cpMRBeDg","author":"@JadeZsiros","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xq6-8HgwnIFnZRTYG1Ngroi1rXspx2TCA32RtXBFsOrdyFZELegotLz8q4B-VOTazLEvME1b=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JadeZsiros","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADDCOlQDysC","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"GenAI is completely morally acceptable. Where morality really comes into question is how an individual/group/company uses it.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCGtK8GUDMTLRM_rT7avYELQ","author":"@Ħawk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zPvmAg33npqSicMaMfJFg8jXWes84mlFazl289RjgVbP5l96iXGtYJ7oBVOxDkyqKyhkFj7qGe4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@%C4%A6awk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADIxmlu7qDt","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"And none of them are. It is inhuman and soul-crushing. all of it","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC7I6UeUDVjrZytNW2PHyY7w","author":"@Totalpoggersyo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vIIgnBaHkOj1GZiklYBHxhmFFBXu9k67iLif2S_5-EiaJydSFKFqfSyX0W5JGwyaAVP_cECjIA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Totalpoggersyo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAFXP5gh_DIB","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Only a Sith deals in absolutes","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC9wbFw0_WMg0yodzRupEfdA","author":"@andyhull9182","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mjL8wHVg8T1j2c8RFaIES8psZeL0Misk566p_O-0tYWA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andyhull9182","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAInLvjymNBs","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"And they are all acceptable. AI is way more based then modern woke artists","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC1cDncu6qIIpvp7ovsq36Pw","author":"@basedAIman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KX09z6RbB4bClXJ72iTrX0hGXm3cqP0WCFMzs2MWXelvQbPr1SzFy62igYHcDoBFUrzH5KBzAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@basedAIman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACyUxZXRP2V","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"my personal take on this is that it is all fair game until you use it to add value to people.\nthere is alot of untapped potential there i feel","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0Im1aPINkz2FCbHy8RuJFw","author":"@robinspanier7017","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wioMrOs2sMN49rDntfDnutp507PNrjf1ek1zFYiF07zGIHiU461shuJBS2y-vxHafKwmhNCMN7c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robinspanier7017","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACyeq4jqBie","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"*proceeds to browse r2r market place*","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCioafrJDW6c6qw9xC-oAmHA","author":"@MrFak9r","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nRaJ2gM4NfdtuDrQag3u3ZqELAK7XCbPhIePjOAPeTFA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrFak9r","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADAETS8WjEa","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"As a software engineer I can tell you that most of us aren't mad about stuff like Cursor but use it on a daily basis. Its not an AI agent btw, it uses other models like Claude and openAI.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0_GQ9qhq6MPPoP9qc6jGXQ","author":"@jonbikaku6133","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ncuyVhmAV6mTw4N-36mDQPbOz_eDtXdG0yTvmvuiqtwLs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jonbikaku6133","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADAuIs_4-UC","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":" @dan_15mm  I think it is a tool that can be used in combination with human creativity and knowledge, it doesnt have to entirely replace it or be devoid of human soul or effort.\n\nI write all my own lyrics and draw all associated art for my music- album cover, profile pics/ banners etc with no AI assistance. \nI use AI mostly to generate vocals which i can control the pronunciation and flow of. \n\nI upload my own beats and regenerate them which usually retains about 30-70% of its qualities but i also have included large chunks of my unaltered beats in songs ive made.\n\nI sample (chop up and loop) multiple AI generations and create and arrange new sections, bridges, transitions. I'll sample drums from them and repurpose them, or repitch, add effects, and the same with vocals for adlibs, choruses, outros.\n\nI quit making music for 2 years until i discovered the AI program last month, which let me create my album ive been crafting and trying to record for far too long, and it still feels authentically like me cuz i can make it use words as i would say them with the flow i would use.\n\nAll I want is some appreciation for my lyrics and AI allows me to present them as a fully finished song which I have a ton of control over.\nits the best medium I currently have access to be able to share my music right now, so I am grateful for that, and i am proud of what I made.\nI cannot perform vocals where I currently live due to shitty circumstances and environmental limitations.\nI use AI and try to retain as much authenticity as i can to share my work, and i think i accomplish that skillfully, better than any other AI music ive heard thusfar.\n\nI want artists to get paid for use of their work in training, they absolutely should. I dont expect to make anything off my albums streams, my goal is to gain a modest following if possible, id like to interact with people who are interested in the ideas im presenting in my songs. that it.\n\nI'm not a corporation or lawmaker, and it is in all corporations best interest to further the development of AI, it will rapidly decrease their labor costs, and I think our political system is too slow and too controlled by corporations to do anything substantial to combat its advancement, and even if they werent corpo puppets, theyd still be too slow to act, its progression and proficiency would still outpace their ability to make new laws or enforce them effectively.\n\nI am certain that AI will become a regular tool that most everyone uses to augment their creative process instead of entirely replacing it, you can apply what qualities you are best at to make a good piece of art, like creating generations for visual references and inspiration, color schemes, etc. in music solo instrumentalists or vocalists could use it to help direct them toward writing good lyrics instead of AI just doing it them for them. We can use it to make better quality art and improve our own skills along the way but also are able to hyper-specialize in any part of an artform, like mastering a single instrument or mastering a specific style or medium of drawing/ painting.\nDespite my use of AI for vocal generations, i will be recognized as one of the greats for the level of mastery my songs and ability to write. I think that those without creative abilities using AI will not be able to match the human qualities from those who are well practiced\n\nEnvironmental Limitations:\nI live in CA and the freeway is directly opposite my 600 sqft apartment which has paper walls, there isnt more than 30sec of silence during any time of day. its the cheapest i could find and i can barely afford it. i also live in a dog complex and theres dogs barking constantly, as well as my own.. I have no peace or space to practice and record effectively, and i cant justify buying a new audio interface to be able to use my mic, as i have to try save up for other more important things.\n\nShitty Circumstances:\nI have a stutter and it takes me a long time to practice performing my songs and getting the breathwork down before i am capable of recording and even then its arduous and takes a significant amount of time to get it done properly.\nI am very poor, barely making it paycheck to paycheck. I saved up for years to buy equipment and practice learning how to use it. decent speakers, mic, Interface, headphones, acoustic foam, Ableton (DAW software), midi keyboard, MPC. \nThen 2 years ago i didnt have enough money to move after my lease was up. i became homeless for a few months. My accoustic foam had to be scrapped, my harddrive with all my best and most recent beats died so i lost the original files. my audio interface, speakers, and heaphones broke between me finally moving into a new apartment.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCf4PvbDXg4ykZnHmHomR5AQ","author":"@ITZTLI-music","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m364CABS1BKFw2OQjs5lIZZRoUPUAqIhOpj-bdYFBBqWR6CWdxyq4VQxyPLsR3m4UBuYy8BEUg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ITZTLI-music","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADBFXuZICYg","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"my opinion is AIs usage should be for funnies. if not funny, then don't present it as your own.\n\nif you care about the environmental impact of it, just run a local instance on a PC with any gpu released in the past 10ish years","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCooKKkZaItRxJ1djQ5uAU2g","author":"@tsrenis","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6FZQkHWh6uOGYrMMzEZGGWnNg1Y7qxVFxGBNLkQ6pb2Mf_jm0-v8lXkauHYFyMJkderLBMxNfpk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tsrenis","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADFsVMZnD_g","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Why so black and white I think gen AI for art and music is malicious as fuck but coding I can see that as more beneficial as a tutor since a copy and paste of code will do nothing at the end of the day like it even says \"Assistant\" whilst the other 2 just make and post which is more disgusting if anything and you learn nothing from music and art AI as it isn't something you can just learn or understand simply by a walk through","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrNmEYVFdvG1wM8oty7Sh9A","author":"@SOS-06","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dtd4CqzGOcppG1MfIlhqV63WoEpyXgcih4gDu3_CT5b2SKx9AqwpCNmLlKKo9F1OCj7znHO6=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SOS-06","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADFwfdwDCBR","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Programming using ai is acceptable because apparently ai is good at making code no?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn8uXUFr1SWrBn2mdNr2fLA","author":"@Exoskel2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nowlh8b0F3pL2XWoHsY4JBo1BlALYvYnu0VPUBimpg2bw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Exoskel2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADHEv44DhM2","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Same with slurs","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvqkKPTrFInr4jrw6VhWGnA","author":"@hairychessat15","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/k6enL9zkb4gSgx075sOqjqD69oDC4JTa3fY9Cz4SlTeORc5fMTyGV8unlSR8JDaeIFaTuZHx=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hairychessat15","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENADUQA22DH7h","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"I use them all n💀","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVXJxvQ9BS557tTfh_v61Iw","author":"@rubyciide5542","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QAZTn9L8o4Z-0NA8nW-KBle-NApftVS2-2Fws3wlpJFxRcJO1elKjY6yQvoGVWhL_wODZPqbwA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rubyciide5542","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENAHLGbuNyKVT","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"How did you learn to play an instrument? I bet you listened to a lot of copyrighted music and drew influences from it. So how is this any different? 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyaSQ03teBghfSV0kv3RVNw","author":"@artemisnite","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1Id4CP93CKBhg3q9n5NtRBCQUEeyALx3FgGzXeFGFhXhu1FdRKSVqrzx1klcXSJg8zEGsTyEQA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@artemisnite","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACvULHyMVwa","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Agreed. And all are great tools. The training must become ethical by using dedicated, paid for, high quality data.","like_count":158,"author_id":"UCiWiVPKt8xJeD0RNjzJOj3g","author":"@huraqan3761","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k6wLxzQYSqaR9F6PfR3CYJoJ0kP64IK-X-XwsMhwMUaQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@huraqan3761","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACw3WSReMfX","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"Coding assistants probably aren't as bad, given human creativity isn't really as functional a part of coding as it is with art. It's still monetising other people's work to make it harder for them to get a job, but largely programmers aren't getting replaced by someone generating prompts like they are with art. It also doesn't generate anything 'consumer facing' and bereft of a human touch, because programming is a largely practical task. Like by all means shit on CoPilot for a variety of reasons, but I think it comparing programmers using it to automate some basic generic tasks to people like stock photographers and videographers functionally almost all being out of a career now overnight is a little disingenuous. It's still a form of theft, but the relative harm is very different. In the case of this video, no one is flooding Github with masses of AI generated code to steal revenue either. You're not gonna get a copyright ping because an AI code project used the same sample as you.","like_count":11,"author_id":"UC_Dag4HT3kwnxH10CvlXyoQ","author":"@GrandHighGamer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mHI5bO6eKyXdJhxJZGlg3H4yY66t0jv_SGp-1R-0do3Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GrandHighGamer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg.ACvO0_vjBENACyEqGW_o3d","parent":"UgxVpF7LWj3nomz1tIt4AaABAg","text":"My issue is people pretending to be an artist when they're not. This includes people who only use digital tools to create art and aren't able to do the same on traditional mediums like paper, canvas, using charcoal, ink, pencil, etc... The algorithms create the brush strokes for you and corrects mistakes on the fly. \n\nThe same for musicians who can't play an instrument or actually use turntables like a proper dj. The amount of fake ass DJ's out there getting views when all they're doing is miming or using digital turntables with preprogrammed sessions is sad and no, they're NOT musicians. \n\nAnd writing a prompt doesn't make you a painter. Stealing someone else's work to train a model and then write a prompt to generate a painting in the style of the artist you stole from is plagiarism, fraud, and theft.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCyigmWfR57vEitfD_4tKO4Q","author":"@ripleyhrgiger4669","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lwk0vjUq1u3-tQzNKXD4jgoCJduFVWfPtEBlTFrVrYGk8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ripleyhrgiger4669","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This stuff makes me super sad. All of a sudden on Spotify my related artists went from a bunch of artists in my general space to being all AI artists and it just makes me feel like shit. Discovery was already horrible on Spotify and now it's just impossible.","like_count":419,"author_id":"UCMMBYyaYpAHogSK-1geVYZw","author":"@mistmurk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NqRELvGkdg4qH0hO_-ELY6eDEhan6rBB5Xx7rOu3BD40t6CHST3kL4JIfMTbMf49RWjqc9lntw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mistmurk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg.ACwUKQj0BGCAD8JA3flll4","parent":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg","text":"For me, it's just been stuffing pop music into my fov and playlists. I am almost exclusively a metal head with obscure tastes. Incredibly frustrating.","like_count":17,"author_id":"UCRUGCYMxF3hpwFd2000oAEQ","author":"@nateh5736","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kDhHEbALtM-EVADNwBvC1d_L4yK6V17P16Zscyn7cAwug=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nateh5736","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg.ACwUKQj0BGCADF31nCw2fH","parent":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg","text":"I've always used YouTube for music because my taste is someone niche, but even it is getting overrun with AI music. Trying to find a playlist of genuine, non-AI classical music is way more difficult than it has any right to be. And \"classical\" AI pisses me off even more than others, just like the ones that rip off renaissance paintings and try to pass them off as genuine. As if grammar and spelling aren't already at an all-time low with the internet; our knowledge of art & history is damn near done for if this shit isn't fixed.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCxCtxRDboNI5rafyMbfdt6Q","author":"@courtykat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2-85bNitaAeuNB-coKzYmsqkyDm06b8-vM0pkn5hCHHu1_iBtZ8CF1u-8qanYs5p4m9WqZZOlw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@courtykat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg.ACwUKQj0BGCAD9XnVIncuo","parent":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg","text":"They changed the fans also liked algo it’s now garbage . And puts u with irrelevant artists","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCBqNBy13zICTIXOoE6AiD_w","author":"@simetalmusic1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/i885LjzSYdFpkSZzwqh5RzcLiSODqdpVv_D4fm0gENTMIh3GBtg6sKviqeCoVlSsu5c4isI_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@simetalmusic1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg.ACwUKQj0BGCAGF424RywLh","parent":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg","text":"Why do you care that the song is ai generated if you like the song?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCIuYS5-fdoqXaUkykA38Rsw","author":"@steger13","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BIy5bqymYsRE5lq4XE38DQLXxspW53NkE6yELUAPkAjPRnGOy-9WZeKp8g_Y00SF_KGI7ldehKQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@steger13","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg.ACwUKQj0BGCACxs40o_llJ","parent":"UgxLshHoJxmno5ohPoJ4AaABAg","text":"DONT lie Neon Lights be off da Chaaaaaaaaiiiinnnn dj Shooppuiiiuhhgggfdx wooo","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The low pay per stream combined with the growing low quality content has moved me towards alternatives. I don't stream anymore and instead support my favorite artists on Patreon and I buy music from the artist (often on medium like disk or tape) on Bandcamp. I feel better knowing the artist at least earns something and I much more enjoy the music I listen to. Remember that time you went to the music store to buy a CD for that one song and you kinda start to appreciate the rest of the album too? Well: that feeling.   Please keep making these videos, they are educational and a joy to watch. Thanks.","like_count":464,"author_id":"UCQnQs78eyjm0iKRtLMWJF5A","author":"@synthphilosophy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hHg71czCdVXchQFtc8LXmYOJlt-wDaiTu0KUEpedqwmWl5pY52csrphD4-H85GCRd5GImMXBfA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@synthphilosophy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg.ACwC4C2rY-lACwNleKmJMU","parent":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg","text":"I always buy FLAC (if they have it) or 320KBPS MP3s of what I like, and I download them right away and put them on a thumb drive. I don't feel like I own what I bought until I can listen to it without a website giving permission.","like_count":29,"author_id":"UCOPzemp4Ur1-kSxaYr922bw","author":"@FourWaveforms","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_WNHo8Natz1UOkKD0xElarrpUIp76CDPAo66QuBF2FS9HFRv2F9n0fUdgiv1q1QQSMRXklYf=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FourWaveforms","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg.ACwC4C2rY-lAD6xnwr7Y8u","parent":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg","text":"either that or ill torrent.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGCTkNc5cGPckr5q9w8_gyQ","author":"@Angelicbean","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Cf3v1-ILZc85Yy1iXfZzEOqRLWYECos2WASPsIGSTB1TqYKDigPUcl3wKtC2mNinYcxU4JudsA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Angelicbean","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg.ACwC4C2rY-lALC8QZDbBRl","parent":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg","text":"yeah. Just pirating yt music or spotify and giving the subscription money straight to the artists is the way to go","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCj_7s-PY7m2BDy0gbhV_ULg","author":"@neffix6976","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kZmzJqY8I35Zl-GAWhuz_XOqLJqj8BXZU6CPa2yRySGuHsiwKzLosLr4UhlysBEkBia-kbga6v0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@neffix6976","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg.ACwC4C2rY-lAD5JAYnzNqv","parent":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg","text":"benn is adept at twisting bad methodologies into a narrative that gets views. pay per stream is not a meaningful metric, even in the absurdly specific circumstance of owning every part of the process that would receive the dividends from the streaming service. a high cost low streams service is obviously going to have a higher pay per stream. you only listen to pelaton’s service when you’re on their bikes, whereas spotify you’d listen to almost anywhere, anytime. \n\ncds are an awful option, most of the money from the sales of cds goes to the label. artists with cd distribution agreements see more income from streaming than cds. also cd distribution isn’t accessible to everyone, nor is it practical for everyone. getting discovered through cds is practically impossible, you need an audience elsewhere first… usually streaming.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEHIWMhGt39c3GLhCMEaJ4A","author":"@underscore_d.t","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LZQYw-Xnw3Q0Tz-d7LhN59_Bx6PMtaKPDjS_ba1VNLVVFDuEAM3zjqIzZVQIzmDCgenmx3Xy=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@underscore_d.t","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg.ACwC4C2rY-lACx70Q744f5","parent":"UgykSI2FSqLM64HsZqx4AaABAg","text":"That certainly a good alternative. However, I think artists earning money from art will be going away. Being able to scale earning from your art quite modern, and I honestly think that making art for art's sake (instead of for likes or money), is the core of art, and I don't think art it will go away even if nobody listens or pays. Bach or Kafka would still make their works.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCXJHIXgB8pted8dIbiUJRGA","author":"@TwilightThrone","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3fJuv9v0HPuqc8e9lOoCDNtU2tLVPHnn18UZkMXDIJdHlgisadTYOAHVG7V7RLjBvoQ1DIU6C58=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TwilightThrone","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxV7X4NoKFESU0EEk54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"as a nobody hobbyist musician with no expectation of making money off my music - I am still dismayed at the mass dumping of AI generated music out there and the social / mechanical system manipulation to push these to the front.  Even with my stuff being generally outside of popular styles and genres, I have even less hope now of people finding it and finding a piece they love.  I remember from the late 90s on (partly due to age, partly due to internet) starting to find all kinds of artists from around the world who didn't just sound like everything else on commercial radio and it was musical joy to experience.  And I see just how incredibly hard it must be for those legitimate musicians now trying to make a living...","like_count":18,"author_id":"UCHZKQq2eWiFel4sutQOWMvw","author":"@EyelijnsMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Vd8NGant8F9_rN_XWaHBK79AjVUj08PVs0ZMeEed5C8fK7xpDtyhCljXtlMhXZo89KTQA3IJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EyelijnsMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxHKDO8JfQS2gaOIs94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Anything AI generated needs to be legally required to be labeled as such.  They need a certain symbol to use for all images and video and also something that helps label audio as well.","like_count":12,"author_id":"UCLaHx7w4rSMJbmPGHs0yl2Q","author":"@Anne_Onymous","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dgT6BNUww3hgr21dYCqIYml6suUSAuNL8fJsh3gG0y6q5Y4AVR91_y9cbpXCvGNuU1Yme0Aygw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Anne_Onymous","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxHKDO8JfQS2gaOIs94AaABAg.AKogLULWEE-APsmWa4o8E5","parent":"UgxHKDO8JfQS2gaOIs94AaABAg","text":"The problem with this is that it's basically unenforceable. \nIt would take a disproportionate amount of time to prove that something is AI and have grounds to remove it compared to generating and uploading endless waves of slop. \nSo you'd still have 99.9% as much AI slop unmarked online, but you'd give a small content moderation team a new job at least.\n\n\n(I'm saying this as someone who hates AI btw. I think computers were A Fucking Mistake.)","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCagiXDyMsV33c64T2bCXTaw","author":"@Takapon218","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n-_Ssm5FcAKptoC4c-jOdTd7hCbwesC2_OO606C6qFug=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Takapon218","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This video is going to have a whole ton of people terrified of being caught out","like_count":934,"author_id":"UCftnJedvZHkhpZ5U0kK1bGg","author":"@DelanceyThrone","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/p6vF7snhSgRlhB_wHUyuhv90pqpP5V780w0z6OhLMoxRENq_XUptDMq8VIe65zd3Gxaug6Zc_g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DelanceyThrone","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACvP1jNMFCR","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"Spotify is actively promoting AI generated music because they can create their own content and not pay musicians.","like_count":127,"author_id":"UCpnWPVmyXH9OdXlYIsNfPDg","author":"@DannoBoston","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lAAnUi3Y523QsogEY3GtqsaBy366v42hk_RyjEgYD2PgU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DannoBoston","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACvLCCtLhzD","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"Expose them all.","like_count":120,"author_id":"UCMyaLElURpcbblRaEowtz2A","author":"@TheM1ndTravel3r","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ihQP7pNlow0BBYjOTMSj1TyCv24D2iKYVKBsEVMFyvRJQ6gJhKI6SNRWnXo2gh_d_kG-BcojxA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheM1ndTravel3r","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACvTxOnyK6i","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"Gooood.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UChxZoxU_9__R-w80VVXvl_w","author":"@xtrememinus2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MqOyw3JlYM9vKCu4TjZWovcfL0B95b02r51LWh6e0q02L3ih1O5wu4_DD8uCVhS0LlJSu2Kw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@xtrememinus2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACwy_0IGvT6","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"Good","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCCBiyiEDohBeO_fAyLViDbg","author":"@3X3NTR1K","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mO4-cRTXdlS4O9ykd7dnvdsQxJZRRPspUDuwrCuWFdpI0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@3X3NTR1K","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACvn0p8bBB_","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"Someone should post it to the Suno subreddit and see what they think of it.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCZysppVWkfQ-R6KTUilJdDA","author":"@brawndothethirstmutilator9848","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-bzcHoCE97Zt2YMiP1NEdQm1133eMZmDffMdo-hkgN1Y75dp_Tnc43gz7tcmfC3mMFkCIh5_sw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@brawndothethirstmutilator9848","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACwxNMflbwg","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"What about those artists and buskers who goes live with their Ai Music? Explaine explaine😂","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCTsN8umCqkAkovl4tdX5XqQ","author":"@D-Rayl","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/eoTv0KC1Y2bVc8BpXliBTJrdyWixrXGHdPNStG4EVpZ_tZP4ijGV90usde-Gvd39P1Yh0Ovt-A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@D-Rayl","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACvfRi1sv5L","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"I believe if they knowingly went with it anyway, then they've probably never cared to begin with?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTqL9zzs7LD2VFZ1VHZ_dBQ","author":"@lzcrc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8TrIiZ207ZkUBVgS8lodV41JxhD70RH6N8deJBKhvfYQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lzcrc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACw2K6-8ntd","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"Aw… bummer.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCew06xlxmj-4q0R90VbfalA","author":"@iamlocknar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/U6Ma9d4mEhDNS7shk578i8OA3xodz-Mnk9UgStwCrEnVZjfULDLvKGsAkJfV3cazPgpHMV9G96A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@iamlocknar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACwYLe3F5Cd","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"About time.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDwtWe7F52o1YgypRwpQYDQ","author":"@MrJensklein","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_krT4VgWfFdSu-i74WhkEt4k8Pybx1Rz9PJ7rSvZnnUMfA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrJensklein","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpADHZ3zysQTU","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"😂😂😂 we don't care about that","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvpjUfz6IekSJk4gD5B903w","author":"@Jsarmy87124","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xZVUnHBon_NjfQSs0YAh4DKIWHblm1RL65bUk3RnUf-92zKmCVpt7khLT0zznZQvEioLk3MXG2s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jsarmy87124","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpAUO1jTgOPi7","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"no one cares about being called out rofl 98% of my music i (crafted) KEY WORD (crafted) using a.i. specifically SUNO i could care less who likes my music i made it for me to listen to and shared it because i dont like not sharing :) and if you use the download stem pack you can litiraly toss the stem pack into a DAW remove the a.i. singing and record your own actual voice and make a banger in less that 15 min BUHAHAHA its 2026 and everything is evolving look how cloths and blankets used to be made and now look how there made it collapsed an entire industry and dropped the price of textiles but yet here we are buying cheap bedsheets and comforter's and cloths :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxhFfQGdK-bLQbtYiqsCp0w","author":"@MadLabZ","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NClXil99-MTfip6esZdefqlYBIKNudyJN9ZjNhlZsw2GrHZEuaVP_jt19CZy8PumRuD3nbygmw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MadLabZ","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpAD2emrAJq9d","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"I guarantee no one but other musicians who are scared of losing studio work or a few extra pennies from streaming services care about any of this.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCEDbDyZMrV_894l-uudVW4w","author":"@TeddyLeppard","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mA4G3V8IGT7j9ggo2bPnJYmo79cBgmr2GCJ4u3N10=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TeddyLeppard","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACwDeLChWLM","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"\"caught out\".. okay, weirdo","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCiuOZ5ak7RSZKSdm-fPBR9A","author":"@Junkwave_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SufY2LufqkuVk6XVNhHwZaovBOwIfWU7SyHO0tnZiUYztIQ_68cT3GQmcIwxT1Gcg169_OttxJI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Junkwave_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACyc2aeeY00","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"\"Being caught out\"\n\nThat's not a correct use of words.\nYou'd say \"terrified of being caught\" or \"terrified of being found out\". Not the illogical combination you've spewed out, somehow without realising how dumb and weird it is.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCjM3Uev3qjBYXTjzHoGfJZw","author":"@MuscarV2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mQv97EN2X2OOQqMhMyBa_I_KMSHwKjTfiFcFMomMwxNkw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MuscarV2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACvXVV12kRp","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"I'd love to see one of my songs caught. Even though I credit Udio anyway. But Shazam has never said anything i did was something else.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCdOqVSYtKzvPXHDC68-55kA","author":"@GoodBaleadaMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ElJ51JQND4VLuwOTPNTzwkAr4IbKBnOF9B1O6ONjr1bZn5-CB-1zi42FzghC5mHqIcxi9FDQCO8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GoodBaleadaMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg.ACvJaZ-tlrpACvNi_fP5F6","parent":"Ugz6LMslkkRp2tytudx4AaABAg","text":"Caught with what? loops have been a thing for ages now, its in the video.","like_count":27,"author_id":"UCv_4FA5bsLB9Nh8ENgipNJg","author":"@KwissBeats","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lhZ7g9gTOP9VkbCErICXZFSLHQze5q89DbfERRS3m9Xw8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KwissBeats","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYrlLcGVZ2NFZGfwh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Apparently jpeg artifacts are a problem with image generation, too.","like_count":51,"author_id":"UCZTC86Fl8WkiM7RXiy_hUOQ","author":"@MoonSafariFilms","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mqceLuxj4sXJaPQbdVmyyDQtWgzsY7sfTcIsfFEechn-Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MoonSafariFilms","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwfu8geTXtDnLnJoPh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:17 throwing an expletive to check if we listen till the end…","like_count":88,"author_id":"UCeziGeU5_Lg9MMeSRDoXnAA","author":"@FranckMartin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lcJ6COZSANXHwojo8h8nAYiPbMM7aTWYDpPtDvYEOKMnO8p0GNhcwgYQeULBoJN96HUl62xRpCc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FranckMartin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwfu8geTXtDnLnJoPh4AaABAg.ACvm-97gtzVACyIPkSKmL1","parent":"Ugwfu8geTXtDnLnJoPh4AaABAg","text":"That's not an expletive, that's a body part unmentionable in polite Victorian society!\n\nNice WTF moment, makes you wonder exactly what goes on in Benn's. Patreon content...","like_count":13,"author_id":"UCQYe2lC-3AZv-h727EpNCSw","author":"@skierpage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mB4TZoNaBeWorBPPcPCZfS3U11E9AXq-RvUveB8OdkAg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@skierpage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfIi78OaFRRDB7RS94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thankful that my taste in music is so pretentious that AI hasn’t really broken into the genres I listen to… yet…","like_count":37,"author_id":"UC55EkiHFlUEGDwIxmCE5-0g","author":"@jessclark9725","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lHbE-n-VjnnJBbAcWtsFwf8bAt1yNiDhzR43OBnTfAIcI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jessclark9725","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfIi78OaFRRDB7RS94AaABAg.ADDmsaRv2YyATb6_LIWEHU","parent":"UgzfIi78OaFRRDB7RS94AaABAg","text":"you sound like a perfect candidate actually i bet youre already listening and dont know it","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCJqxvUC1cpJzxbgWQIjIZ-Q","author":"@melancholiam5676","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kWfg_VNmC_YsETYRcLmRNf_FxUQC6Pu8CfqT7YYRDXLQg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@melancholiam5676","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Longtime Qobuz user here. Glad to hear they pay a little better (though as you say they don't have the volume as they're a niche player). But the other main reason I like them, aside from the excellent sound quality, is that you can purchase the music, either tracks or whole albums, and get digital downloads (FLAC, mp3, etc.), DRM-free, to keep. And I imagine those pay artists better than the streaming. So I regularly buy music on there that I'm finding myself listening to so I know it won't disappear, and hopefully compensating the artist.","like_count":194,"author_id":"UCddv6O-Pb2rJRzXwQVmaTDA","author":"@Richardsona-39","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qIlDiiyZzSuChrTz1Tanp09CTAp1IWu2URZXuKWozVtxfnXAL73dydNver7n1iVM3dTvTN7FBw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Richardsona-39","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg.ACyzOV65ny0AD1uejTeq7T","parent":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg","text":"Yeah also a big qobuz fan here, I've found some music on their site that I just couldn't find anywhere else and bought it, paying the artists big bux and getting some high quality shit. I fw it🔥","like_count":12,"author_id":"UC4BgoQQttepog-B--6JkJ-Q","author":"@hearth_beat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x857l8YafsKYatlk_jGVyjPoN-wTphquocyht3gA2smU5OvDm-iB6OHnYiVSuR7ZPKCuYM0QkGU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hearth_beat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg.ACyzOV65ny0AD2qmBHs6EC","parent":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg","text":"What helped me choose Qobuz briefly, was that Qobuz pay per view being the highest. Tidal lets you give more money if you’re on their highest plan to your most watched artists.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC8hFMrrUvTOoOqo90KoaN_Q","author":"@qwite9309","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrisPIAc0te-Ijfed8dOJ9OaXSRAbcZRo856jkZh70-_AEL-n_wayfj3tMVJyqJP4rFw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@qwite9309","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg.ACyzOV65ny0AD2tvGmzIgt","parent":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg","text":"Is this an actually ethical streaming service? Never thought I'd see the day.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCq4u0hakzYh04_CbnuTyAxw","author":"@yotoprules9361","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vVpzmG70iPdG9xe8M4aUgG535ZJ4esl70HgT0sH0hssH78x5iV1vK2Ge16JQHiD9CsPdWhlbj-A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yotoprules9361","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg.ACyzOV65ny0AO_B1AuxMNJ","parent":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg","text":"same! The app is a little buggy but all in all it's a great service.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwZps9OdU3jsF2G6hbCJKog","author":"@Barmetler","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/U06lnh5ukRDLO0cRDvABeMLnbMH3XLl3hBYKB0R725UYqiQHPX_DHjxYDzSvTx2xN2JO5YzatHI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Barmetler","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg.ACyzOV65ny0ADFHzbOMh2W","parent":"Ugx-eFKRYTgo_fjm3m14AaABAg","text":"not to mention that, unlike Tidal, they have FLAC for most of their catalogue. (Tidal uses MQA for much of its catalogue, has been called out on this, but never did anything about it, making them commit false advertizing)","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC9SC3ilnI_rt7x1dUopXihg","author":"@ArtificialDjDAGX","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_jAJBnvU4WZ1HY5qrAB3YhPD9MSs-gI7sN4YGfKRle9E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ArtificialDjDAGX","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"YT is already loaded with low effort AI slop by people who are just click farming. The LoFi genre especially is plagued with it.","like_count":442,"author_id":"UCZysppVWkfQ-R6KTUilJdDA","author":"@brawndothethirstmutilator9848","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-bzcHoCE97Zt2YMiP1NEdQm1133eMZmDffMdo-hkgN1Y75dp_Tnc43gz7tcmfC3mMFkCIh5_sw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@brawndothethirstmutilator9848","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg.ACvl0wx3SXnAD7K8iErT35","parent":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg","text":"YouTube is already very stale. AI just makes it worse.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC_9MHpPuYg6Yrs1EpgkHs8g","author":"@YouTubeSucksHardToday","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/uHFaGUlSvPJwrZMOmeuP5FXfJhs5OtvPuxKKwEOcYQ_4gtrfF_p6j1RFMqLPgLVdumFG4tc-UQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@YouTubeSucksHardToday","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg.ACvl0wx3SXnADHZL5a6v2J","parent":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg","text":"Yeah lofi is cooked lol. The golden age is over","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCGQvEbjn6DbyyIzIgFAQq-w","author":"@wait_in_gold_ON_SPOTIFY","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NaJg1UmibKNAHTkHTRcbSSIP0sK2ol0oU4nADlLCTnaF8BAP3meefWVy08ZSQcEHcMXpW5kFuQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wait_in_gold_ON_SPOTIFY","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg.ACvl0wx3SXnACyoL1SNtYx","parent":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg","text":"i joined an ai music group to spy on people and yeah, these guys are posting their music on spotify and trying to claim themselves as artists and music producers. some even sell their ai songs as legitimate beats to real people. some have gotten in trouble and their ai songs have been taken off spotify, but they legitimately see themselves as artists. ive tried to listen to a few but they all sound like trash. left the group because i couldnt stand the entitlement of these people.","like_count":70,"author_id":"UCeIf7nKM-6TSohw_RYhd2NQ","author":"@cerebrumexcrement","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zFtVORkGEMz1PvTtw68Vom_Evjitm9FgSS8vJ5Xx7M00ZSM2YkfiQHIgXFah00qxZ65Wm1u7Pg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cerebrumexcrement","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg.ACvl0wx3SXnADMEt-QycHD","parent":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg","text":"True","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9R8rJrMNuZ9E_QTudrRHPw","author":"@railroadforest30","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mydI90yN8y4NRx5_gcOlMGyG5YW2EzFyJAW1HT1Ut-vQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@railroadforest30","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg.ACvl0wx3SXnAE38XDmqxIR","parent":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg","text":"Y’all some damn fun sponges.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzmybMlruSra72X5sPOLnsw","author":"@jarenfromvenus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/djStDAPRCSONhwL73XroAN8kx4lazcbXhflOh93iAZ8J0lNLNq3r2m2U_yGcG6VDlRNO5867iw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jarenfromvenus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg.ACvl0wx3SXnAFVFcKp9V4a","parent":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg","text":"Not just in music itself but the accompanying art/animation on lofi videos too. It’s all AI.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC89MrGqnXHxHkaRltu9yr0w","author":"@Window4503","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ljuhr6yLYMcAP93Plx4HRweQKUWXyyBVAiNKY6x8M5yxE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Window4503","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg.ACvl0wx3SXnACwNMxWHvdH","parent":"UgwBSeiF6drqCQlQ4bh4AaABAg","text":"Yeah, I don't think they actually pay for streams at all, do they?","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCtA1l_I609U-w2kTAEosA_g","author":"@NicStage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lEJUGvcavDZzXY0ygJQ8t7VFFwFjDVc_NQZFw2eenW8N3J=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NicStage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My guess for most profitable platform for artists was Bandcamp, but that's a fundamentally different model.","like_count":173,"author_id":"UCw1Jsnq8yY5_QstEjhVSebQ","author":"@EarsTails","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/E48sGkl63L_WMsXLcwXsJVUGBR2KzkIB4CSa_zyun0N221dFavTzM6dH6O9ZNMxe77B2jPt1iuE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EarsTails","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg.ACvOjod135zAD26FyYkLaM","parent":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg","text":"My BC revenue is 100 times that of all streaming services combined all time (this video made me check). Like you said, different model and that includes merch, but at this point I basically only have my stuff on streaming to slap away the people who keep trying to take my band name.","like_count":17,"author_id":"UCijTXhUKK1ftmQUQcNlPpSQ","author":"@fungalwinkerbean","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n5dCki4_UDvBwqb8xTa6ZT9Vyjj3pK_iXjQGEgkMAOkrm5YEZq-cwWFgEH4DtnqOTDBwg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fungalwinkerbean","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg.ACvOjod135zAD7MKs3tY0Q","parent":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg","text":"Actually buying a concert ticket one of the least effective way to financially support an artist (and it's coming from a concert promoter) because for small/medium artists, nearly all tickets money goes into repaying the expenses of the organization of the show and of the tour.\r\nInstead, go to the concert AND buy some merch.\r\n\r\nBuying music on Bandcamp remains the most effective financial support since it does not require any extra expense for the artist, unlike everything else.\r\n\r\nUnless you meant that by going to a concert, you are slightly contributing in helping the growth of the artist to help them get paid more and get bigger shows?","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCBYeAlnrx4ywTHbFHYDH4cg","author":"@postscriptumasso885","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mXjpz8e5JJdhjkTtNZtCYORSNe77shjxufsdYX4kNfSw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@postscriptumasso885","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg.ACvOjod135zACxfeILJKDF","parent":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg","text":"i like bandcamp....","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCVA321I14GIb1K2ROu8jStw","author":"@akkamiau","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k0ZD3DCAt-Uk_iysDEpDT-SfHPgUa5nIrp9tEoPah5OI4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@akkamiau","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg.ACvOjod135zACxeHANh1yB","parent":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg","text":"I was gonna guess Deezer","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCHxc7vrTLokmddfyphlo7Yw","author":"@DriverDude32","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n7iP5ZOpX5nNr0ntq4m3DsMtVZfn685v8tAuPhJVMesvQaDl1H_0gO386w-Xawp_y114qmRwNA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DriverDude32","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg.ACvOjod135zAD7KSn2mwwH","parent":"Ugysujd3N20h7rNnsGF4AaABAg","text":"Buy merch from the artist.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_9MHpPuYg6Yrs1EpgkHs8g","author":"@YouTubeSucksHardToday","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/uHFaGUlSvPJwrZMOmeuP5FXfJhs5OtvPuxKKwEOcYQ_4gtrfF_p6j1RFMqLPgLVdumFG4tc-UQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@YouTubeSucksHardToday","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Using the concept of missing song data from file compression to catch AI is FRIGGIN GENIUS !\nYou're officially the \"John Connor\" in this geeked out robot battle. 😊","like_count":975,"author_id":"UCvyX9zR3GS1WbGmuUMa-47A","author":"@InfoAbsorbent","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lxCKqioJy2EOtiA-FYTMEA5__f5e0JzdpRLjq6R5DnJA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@InfoAbsorbent","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACvtYQhCMzp","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"i saw a similar thing of catching ai generated images. ais incorporate so many compressed images into their training data, they mimic a lot of compression artifacts in their outputs that arent natural or dont make sense when they mash together different compressed images in the training set. because these compressed files are so baked into the training set, it doesn't seem like it is possible to remove these artifacts from ai models unless they were to retrain their models on only uncompressed files.","like_count":22,"author_id":"UCTeq02XjDmyQqHqZ6sH0k4A","author":"@cjkenney","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/a4ZG_qFw4cDNvTB1xwH2ROumhhgWDeaQLwqUrKrpuXU8-bGsh38wunoLMmUEEIHuuQpv4BhR=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cjkenney","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACvdQOhN9ps","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"I'd love to have a browser plugin or something to get to use that AI for myself. I've seen SO MANY AI songs that aren't caught in the playlist linked below the video (because there are probably hundreds uploaded each day?).","like_count":18,"author_id":"UCuvItslI0IR8xcmoh0YEn4A","author":"@Panossa","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nokqXJ8D5SqP0aMw3znrQ-t7-d0N2R0VuoozaGxn0ia6I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Panossa","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACw-pJV3bmP","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"Look at @cjkenney’s comment above yours. It’s likely doing something extremely similar. It’s probably sniffing out “generated” mp3 artifacts that couldn’t naturally occur because of how those artifacts are baked into the training data for these song generating models.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCPIMALGW4fMRRILxy-elMGA","author":"@itsd0nk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k0rKGl-qpjQAZJK15xllKifozRpeo4NefbFKHuyBIpNnM3=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@itsd0nk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACw9rQFHdtV","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"Surely there are some musicians who put their real music on but only ever record them as MP3 for space saving reasons and cost saving.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC4GGIeKMy8i8K5o9z00IPXQ","author":"@JamesSiggins","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kcUcXYTeVgiFDJTEj0VNhGbSM3LkDqtHmN8bilDir_FqAO=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JamesSiggins","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACxXRBdD7im","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"Yup, it's brilliant, until they start training on lossless data.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCjBwhg14-JNnBM-MmHRLnQA","author":"@vladsandu9713","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l7evxnRLIWhA7S9WlfRYmtKPeKJxE-pVVlqbfg8g1y9w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vladsandu9713","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACzcBl8c2Yb","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"Just remix it lay down drums second bass unmatchable","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCiwKDqPbh-KmmRcOFBsCQww","author":"@Statusss_org","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4LT0wRd-hTJ6i3UYgvhf_wAEpne3OmhWEFkUfKBtBqcXyNkIaPNobGToQnRZu-hvPvFbVaW9Qjg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Statusss_org","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACw6F4gvOzD","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"it can get weirder, Divx used to figure out the parts of the video people weren't looking at and just left them out as part of their \"compression\" algorithm lol\nSo if you can figure out the parts of the songs people don't hear, that might be where AI would hide stuff specifically because it reasons that you're not sensing it so you're not looking there - could very much be a gold mine.  Appears the silver bullet to AI would be not trying to act as a human or AI to confuse/outsmart but rather something outside of both that can visualize everything in the system clearly; the path is unobstructed because nobody but you/your agents are on it - you can see everything and go anywhere while the system isn't feeding your input/changes back to anywhere anything you're concerned with is at.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHQd6hTYRdoLy0LlcEI777g","author":"@russellzauner","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ml_7S4_Rp2fFgWL3EGFzf9myuZemK6RbC3bEYFHBUBQPg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@russellzauner","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACwgLkhp3pN","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"Wtf","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACwgMoLkOvX","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"No","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNAQuHQlaPp6p","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"There is an AudioUnit for Logic that can, during the mastering process, create an output that is never flagged as AI. I know. I developed it and hold the patent.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0R4FYuqJSAe3ODCELMnLPQ","author":"@DJShaneSwansboroughBowman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Lt8XoGa2uGP5qPgCaJ0lorgU6ozCpP353qxowIVjTpGGCVPs-_l9clzI9FIiCGu-Ya8FYphB5w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DJShaneSwansboroughBowman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACvzYFojFpt","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"I don't get how it doesn't just catch all mp3s?","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCg3qSdixNjZRY1FoIYzeNag","author":"@ogpandamonium","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QOyiRB058fVe8hpw0IDPj2feJKE92CavWMaTbhUz8IF5GUrAjQhVROaBkAPOfLBmvcjA9kEsWQI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ogpandamonium","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNAD7HPQttFrf","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"It's not a panacea, because you can easily train an AI model to transform compressed files to something that looks like a \"lossless\" file. Indeed, that's basically how they're getting better compression ratios these days!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPesfNlbfoEyL2uW-noq-Yg","author":"@Mnnvint","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nN8j2KOhv4X8SeMGR6tF1TsTHcfHFfhWLIRtB7nQk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mnnvint","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg.ACvZP3Y3TyNACvkjCEuV_f","parent":"UgxYoIAb1wyzlR_cleB4AaABAg","text":"It 100% is pure distilled genius.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCKgAg9LxYRk_W2sSxu1n9YQ","author":"@flatmoontheory","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yYG-989eH545lsCmmcnJ7xkjnYBwlEzyvp4U9-2xH4JnmfXSYIJweBxakdj7TU1XtNec23P-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@flatmoontheory","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwn-qYrBT8h402BG-14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:42 that high F# in the background instantly lit up the \"21st century humor - Hells Kitchen Dramatic Sound Waterphone SFX.aiff\" neurons in my brain","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCtMctZs25bFqL_-W8hfN-Ug","author":"@999a0s","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_njL1jIg0HnzTNHq27CaRcDK5HKuA3nATgJguXTYlg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@999a0s","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxEDy8aDiwRlbLPle14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your content is a (good) outlier in the world of synth/music YouTubers. Even if you think some of your material is too nerdy, complex, or weird for standard audiences, I encourage you to follow what you love.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCjPd0K2xJdKUtwnk8KMSJig","author":"@sana_ratio","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kZGLmKO3sZJygi629VDLBF5S3Bb6onEH5oHkYL6yjEYR4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sana_ratio","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a Data Scientist I love 100% accuracy","like_count":734,"author_id":"UCtC2uDe7xhyNvCBifhrxcKQ","author":"@derren88","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kX7fbYgl0DWMZZFyLuyjaKuzM7wFhXXZBH3Hj4PXQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@derren88","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACvakYA4Eku","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"I always want to see a 2×2 confusion matrix. True positive, False positive, False negative, True negative.\nKnowing True positive and False negative is only part of the story. 😂","like_count":23,"author_id":"UCHIiUfuxbPeTQfVdZbDmKqg","author":"@Petch85","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kRxu2UG8irgOEwZyU0MXrwmDfF3z3NCkKzotBI37om-BM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Petch85","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACwOIVwFnOj","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"He hasn't said much about how his AI detector works. Most of the video talks about other subjects","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCOPzemp4Ur1-kSxaYr922bw","author":"@FourWaveforms","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_WNHo8Natz1UOkKD0xElarrpUIp76CDPAo66QuBF2FS9HFRv2F9n0fUdgiv1q1QQSMRXklYf=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FourWaveforms","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACzGzG1ymZU","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"It's all about context. Just because a program does something perfectly, doesn't mean that thing is useful or good. I can make a 100% accurate silence detector, but I doubt anyone cares.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC96fb5ncYpZFTddfYSxA8lQ","author":"@andywest5773","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mhrpHZdyogPhKw-hCUfFReypa0e_HzSdfZreJCYDEH8w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andywest5773","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACyAkIvfU_j","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"I don't think this is really going to go anywhere as someone who has had some hit records and has been sampled by artists that are extremely well known and famous in the industry I think a lot of this is really not worth it because we are all influenced by other artists and other music no matter how original we think we are we are still working within the same constraints of music and genres So all of this gotcha stuff really is going nowhere If people want to generate their own music with AI and they want to put it up and other people want to listen to it I'm all for it I'm not into this whole thing of lying to people and saying I can 100% catch this or catch that and this is legitimate and this is not legitimate I've been hearing that sort of thing ever since the first drum drops record came out which was a vinyl recording of guys playing the drums synthesizers drum machines etc sequencers loops are all not someone actually playing what they are producing and presenting to the world as their own","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCcsEcVJb6aqqmQF5CXswpdA","author":"@hitmusicworldwide","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l0o8A74CbLpXStB2Xx3g-jWecq0p5GQrvN389sY9oAjC4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hitmusicworldwide","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACyDVCxSA6a","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"With 80% confidence, I, too, love 100% accuracy.   \n\n(Why only 80% confidence? Because there is at least a 20% chance that I screwed up somewhere and the \"100% accuracy\" result is a delusional.)","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCBP5DUuCghQezd966nLMK5Q","author":"@russell_cameron_thomas","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/24B4AGQktwBjMRx56zIr5IvpLnHN68HsdaJRPgyOYMhV2ztasUm41yj5dUgmCa6CzwzfwVom=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@russell_cameron_thomas","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACyKTgeBOk1","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"Overtrained much?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCvHb6aTObc_3U0erUKUCo1Q","author":"@two50ne77","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nM8r77Y7Us-1FW6dv-MFAEOgqP10cph49FkxXDnpVClwNGEIdM5zdTUyEgLLRRse4Z7A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@two50ne77","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACx7ly11by2","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"Accuracy may not be a good metric.  Roc curve and precision recall curve  are best tools.  F1 Is also suggested. Depends on labels distribution.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCyabugaeloRlALK5mjfGr-Q","author":"@tommasopuccetti4884","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_liM4LSO75W_24-MeIYTD-tc9e3EwQB4ITOBrUwLI4MJQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tommasopuccetti4884","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2AD2NzrpNImU","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"lol. Only a frequentist would ever argue a test has 100% accuracy 😅","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCri_tP9F7K1kYmRRITBwLyQ","author":"@parristaylor","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/PHWzR2L0-g6GzOu0Lp4DR5gGCj_Gi21yFay8th-J78jG1WpB55CN5JwTZdQyjW351DDzvUlL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@parristaylor","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2AD2w3Vuf_Du","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"As a metrologist I know that there is always an uncertainty factor…","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC1iiWjjQ73XVHnXrH4-Y9uw","author":"@enemyspotted2467","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dtBN2GHI4bgxqiTM9rKo_KwPKlhd2rWRZAZm-WebcXxlGPeH7AAVyXPjYWsg0aqJ0E8FfCSj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@enemyspotted2467","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2AD7HYKSJKW8","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"As a data scientist I want to know the false positive rate, not just how many of the AI-generated tracks his model managed to detect.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCPesfNlbfoEyL2uW-noq-Yg","author":"@Mnnvint","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nN8j2KOhv4X8SeMGR6tF1TsTHcfHFfhWLIRtB7nQk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mnnvint","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACvPYPnU70Z","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"As someone making ai for a living the past 6 years, 100% accuracy is at best an indicator of something gone way wrong in methodology. I like your content Benn but be sure you are not advertising something over confidently! I know I have in the past. Data leakages and not using good test/val datasets happen to all of us","like_count":99,"author_id":"UCT51uhW9mv8gcS-OZX2i2mA","author":"@QW3RTYUU","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n6Aln4O4M9cl5hvP0y1jfbCRQ5HXsGQY5vkefQpCPO3Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@QW3RTYUU","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACxrxxKPEL3","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"MATHS","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2AVGQbgX62qx","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"if you're a real Data Scientist, you should be skeptical of 100% accuracy.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDXO9D1B7rvkiMDO6oVsCgA","author":"@gobtomaru","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/69OUyQ8_7gefuaKTjMPYKnFhju1-BVjtIzMhqZNil0iF_ZKMw64OrZ9ieetOodQ1weE99eyITIs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gobtomaru","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACwnLD2-xQd","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"Literally the first week of Andrew Ng's machine course at Stanford is that if you got 100% accuracy, you've screwed up.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCd73Pz-spWLcIupG1rX9j1g","author":"@akagordon","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJExg0LScJTA_5hVXTcwWUrylqmmtMzD5QiFFU3sqHQBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@akagordon","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACvk1BLR3uS","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"Not a data scientist but even I know that 100% accuracy is a huge red flag. AFAIK the best results from the academic community are in the 90-95% accuracy range.","like_count":29,"author_id":"UCQMEdocXZFWlG2SCYrm2lCA","author":"@spacepxl","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8-SVX4VF4qjerupaFR3sS9XQRM_MVqZNtyJCUIzLzrvNXHyE-OcQv_do3N2n3NRy10HT137Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@spacepxl","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACvNFrFC49L","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"As a random person on the internet; I approve this message \n😊","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCnX16I03p7yUBOcdTcBHfAQ","author":"@BoBandits","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/krnfTAVCEGTz8RZePbBcHiJPYMKGUPW_X1XUagZpe_Z7epqTxwQIAgYX5C0XzFTy-MAEL5sNmw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BoBandits","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACvN3FKyWtt","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"🤖... I like human fluidity.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCxwp_BXtbZ0vFTsl6dphyZQ","author":"@Truthinshredding1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kK6NVt0W_O0Bx24tOv0sjLt60R-1_PpD5Gt-4bZbC1x7c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Truthinshredding1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2AD2YHInVpmZ","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"As a \"data scientist\" you should know that accuracy means little. Precision is what you want","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCHa24MhwltcVlPOCuDjVhOw","author":"@kaydog890","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxw5_zTJrzLNKWJ5dtGOqLfnWDjIkSewn7rZ8VztE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kaydog890","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACvL9zYHcE-","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"Same. Like do people not have the time or talent these days to learn an instrument? 😂","like_count":11,"author_id":"UCMyaLElURpcbblRaEowtz2A","author":"@TheM1ndTravel3r","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ihQP7pNlow0BBYjOTMSj1TyCv24D2iKYVKBsEVMFyvRJQ6gJhKI6SNRWnXo2gh_d_kG-BcojxA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheM1ndTravel3r","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACxpgqiWlpP","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"Data Scientist lmao you must think yourself important","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWhJ32IbQfaWXryQ0Gd4P0g","author":"@russia4biden221","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhoOi8Lhcr7w0l0Ur6N0ern1n6gqe49p8sDZDsXjKezsAllwS3frRAi1p45L_qVDrCfQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@russia4biden221","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg.ACvIvisLHR2ACvfS7q8PLf","parent":"Ugxo7InbxQpzyyPKZVV4AaABAg","text":"Meh, just don't use loops! Get some synths, a mixer, and a recorder, BAM done.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCf-kiJReUzmmXgvndcT6a5A","author":"@infn8loopmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/D8DqPwE9zjousKdCjISoGDZV4LnA-_JYY1HMy8xs1BxQjG53ARMV8V6Yml9eVBFzdegns_cjGy4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@infn8loopmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:16 wait, your what?","like_count":329,"author_id":"UCexZDZKm4CO9bE4pdY4EayA","author":"@dhillaz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kWXnX_M1pvO_kwXkK-tO7ZVxDKYI5j9tI1CAwVteI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dhillaz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACvt2LbecWu","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"I was thinking of giving this to a class, and that'll be a good test of whether any of the students watch till the end.","like_count":122,"author_id":"UC4LwM1TMMhGaafl1-jXttGg","author":"@jamesarthurkimbell","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k5YzvDRQDcYX4AQ7PbftjDv9Kn3PdOX8abIudaSO364PY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jamesarthurkimbell","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACwpq0Vog7O","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"HIs pianist.","like_count":13,"author_id":"UCjUEnyJmD4tpkB5__CvGRgQ","author":"@trollingisasport","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lfG9bDJ7lu4AWh5-_kZSrsKI0c_Ng3C3790obNlB4u8A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@trollingisasport","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACw_FBraNCT","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"Bro is  thanking us from his chakras ….😂😂","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCeWFJB7lWxkD94swLj5BgfQ","author":"@This1That0","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/R0Y5rbJjhw2DitVxsyyp6dg384Zyf3eJQBoXjSrWxd7velkMmNG8d-A0hA2CFgE8Sgv9E75Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@This1That0","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACvuqvm6wx-","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":":face-turquoise-covering-eyes:lolol","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCdFLCVCDR-d2Z0SHNv7w5WQ","author":"@amentia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/upE8PgiOxNydWrnZ2TZ9JEs9Emak7VqeCOdmM5mwyvHgSUjir4UOOtqOQaeruA0Im9JIZ8nkUQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@amentia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACwPUEf06iX","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"So damn random","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCIvMM4aJykqzMKQw8IGNNeQ","author":"@Knardsh","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kwveKB9llg90Juxf_twGyewLINZFugp84eFoTaWiThrJU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Knardsh","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACyt61Fuqk5","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"But, from the bottom of it? What part even is the bottom?","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCQfLjaieixL6rGLI5kKStLA","author":"@prognosisunclear9445","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kqmm4agXIjx2t2j97hTI24Blq3fkB0_lY6MRNVZFve1Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@prognosisunclear9445","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACwEf9CZubm","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"His pAnIs","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCO2lIyHdUR3WpNe3A0FPKaw","author":"@robertwagner8317","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_li_iNo4uRheruIU48619z8al9AvSnkLOuufa78nLzrfA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robertwagner8317","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACxFZwj2zwJ","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"Glad it was not just my mind playing tricks.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCAaWjoSUfIcy5JgMsQ_fZrA","author":"@johndray2326","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l2Yv-CWMCdMxUtY2vOVdzCd24LdI4NUuOC72QkdQlE0C4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johndray2326","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACyMHv1qB-X","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"That WAS shocking.  He usually uses the term \"pee-pee\".","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC2_CUBUUGhvSRkToFleO8RQ","author":"@sirnickity","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kRTLUpuGK1JTmdia6bniyUWjHsP3rg80IgpGCgsBpHLKs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sirnickity","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxAD-LRIlRsWC","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"\"I'll just be sure to edit that out later....\"","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCYL3bRajWecChaKamjJQ_cw","author":"@brokenhalo22","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ldzXNOaRJAFvuLJT3iK7_ygjhQMap62TcJOuv1dpY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@brokenhalo22","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACxnrEB9Sbm","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"Legend— you absolute Legend","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCXZtFR3gQfWUgYI2iFhSqMQ","author":"@xdcountry","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVu1mkW22tVC8tfiGnCyyQOBJJJcz17_iweQ_Awv4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@xdcountry","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACwQdPvIjao","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"lol, heard that toi","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCQwhxEtY9bWln5xj40ZuCIA","author":"@thebreathalyzer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ypDxET9JRaDbywG_WOLNq05R8qLnm_nZEpoeSjGILVdwUwaxjVKYiVFxPHnvniVNpm6gRsOy=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thebreathalyzer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACxTlCbVHL2","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"😂😂😂 I had to rewatch. Wait…. Wait WHAT?!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCghx1IWSYHlJFK2aiJRnlEA","author":"@EcomGraduates","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yYTTBcVU4nLdnV0Zxi1DtVIcp7Tvu74QOS9ezhxKvPT7e52MpTONhUfysi_y-KlxNVrmLgoR_xU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EcomGraduates","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxADB3vt6x8Js","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"toe to tip..","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCPhBPT-0QS0wLjrIBOWsl_A","author":"@NicoleHam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zw5TmUYOcWwEqj8pGMTYm4rJlvGuLAnyA0PGs0HUnXQVRRck-1KVS3bMV-vMVv0HtJDTGKrR=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NicoleHam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACvyMDDC3O9","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"That really threw me. Wtf dude!","like_count":15,"author_id":"UCAAM9RwhHuk3uQ9UoHn_xyQ","author":"@jeremycorbett9085","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_no7xvb6kWpUyo8dbIXA0SPJYpZ0DL35wVRafnpah_s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeremycorbett9085","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACxtCiO5TBO","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"Why Benn, why?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzgLazpyeiLds2NtfkPr6-g","author":"@lupo8282","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lgLdpCwmdidmzrx76oWKMzWLMdQMktFbyXSpmmXhE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lupo8282","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACvw6Oggkzq","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"You heard him!","like_count":14,"author_id":"UCzM_164-TFNROvcl5sJltnQ","author":"@raw_000","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lHs6YMVv3ijhZE3Pk4WyzFpgQ9hNAonSk2XkeU8D8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raw_000","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg.ACvY8cERGsxACwEFz5gaFn","parent":"Ugy6I-4ecwUBtxfyz5Z4AaABAg","text":"🤔","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCf7sbOfPKxB-iMc9ziZ-rrA","author":"@andreylucass","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BvOxg_qlqG_sHKMMGOoq1kHCzBVqeMQuHa2e7uBPKfAiVsAXZSwPwwo9vHyU7gcZXSCdj1f_Dw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andreylucass","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgycnC7B8xmgO4H_yc54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This video is what’s up! Another thoughtful and relevant piece. You’ve convinced me to both sign up for your Patreon and, push to to inspiration from your work to make more meaningful content on my own channel. Long time fan Ben, keep it up.","like_count":32,"author_id":"UC33DHkz7f8DnCJH2LTJDSpQ","author":"@nickhillmakesmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XkuHN1ljBIABD3RA5ZXZM1okfDk4DsLsc4_aVvXw9GC0iknluS71-ShalI9lSQlrAsbgWJEdPQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nickhillmakesmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz27AHfpmRG5iIMdvh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How has youtube never recommended me this channel before. I already watch stuff like this but its just more and honestly a higher quality than most channel.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC1EyNaMGixqcf3pSHJYGaWg","author":"@ewlynnn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3YzdJwAVEjow1-e06aYT7n0VVtMpFkOTTbCZG2T80ro366QUkWRppHTnSmJfD03ZC0FtTgrf83k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ewlynnn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwYhoOG4YgIjPVwAjx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I decided to buy all the music I actively listen to a while ago. It feels better to know that I’m supporting the artists I enjoy, and to own the music I enjoy. Absolutely loved this video, thanks for doing the research!","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCMLnAGuLqo0K3gqagQGivkQ","author":"@machi_dev","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/21YUrQAmSyxlgueV0ztoft07n-rItngntSkDBe_4C4VpPuj4V6_4L1O0sQN3hh__2MwTo2d--Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@machi_dev","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJgHimmSTNuOPTgsN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I haven't finished the video so I apologize if this is mentioned, but one thing the GenAI boom has also facilitated is the age-old tradition of buying listens/likes/views/etc. A while back a friend - who is in a fairly successful band - and I were talking about another band from our scene that got signed to a major label before ever playing their first show. Now, obviously they had connections, but then the label has to make it look legit. My friend was like \"oh yeah, here's what they do,\" then pulled out his phone and pulled up the band's Spotify page - all of their suggested \"similar artists\" that fans \"also listen to\" were AI-generated \"bands\" from Eastern Europe that only had one song each, each with tens of millions of \"streams.\" He explained that you can just rig the whole thing with AI, buying millions of streams without anyone ever having to actually listen to anything, but there will always be signs when an artist does that.","like_count":49,"author_id":"UCEb-KaTO363fAtf5MNxOSpg","author":"@ObeseChess","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9FUr_x9slcjjzakpvypIkoHXKhN9h7GZEhkUJgTQitNRh9yJufMNZUzbvkRAi8W40FEs3v5L=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ObeseChess","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyPg8bSqcnC-JXd3-54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The Splice problem is not just a sample site problem, it can be a synth sound patch problem as well.  A friend made a track using a preset on Reaktor.  When I heard it ,  I asked him why did he decide to sample a certain artist. He had no idea what I was talking about. He then showed me the preset he used. I then played the track (a pretty popular track)  and we both were floored. YouTube would’ve definitely flagged him even though it’s a preset sound and not a sample.\n\nHere's the song in reference. That zipper sounding synth sound is a preset in Reaktor. We all could use it. But who owns the sound???  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PuriyWZt9uM&list=RDEM-wbiBr2bRaHIh7xrGMAdDg&index=8","like_count":48,"author_id":"UC-8wrQ9ehUzXphWc9ADpWxw","author":"@dazeja","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/y4sE6KyrpG3eKyjTZXct0AAvTPXEplIyQGZX4JJmbUCZ0vPSR_NIv9qleHr0Kog6QSvvD-1RojA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dazeja","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyPg8bSqcnC-JXd3-54AaABAg.ACvdLBrpMSHACwGq7CYZ-U","parent":"UgyPg8bSqcnC-JXd3-54AaABAg","text":"Starsky Carr has several videos addressing this where he attempts to demonstrate filter sweeps on analog synths and they get copyright struck by someone who has taken Moogs, Oberheims, Prophets, etc. and just swept the filter slowly. That kind of BS can definitely threaten Youtube as a platform for gear reviews. Youtube gear reviews have plenty of problems (lack of transparency of financial support to reviewers for one) but taking a raw saw wave and sweeping a low pass filter ought to be an easy \"non-copyrightable\" sound. Sweeping a filter over a raw wave doesn't meet anyone's definition  (except Youtube) of a \"transformation.\"","like_count":17,"author_id":"UC3YeylyNyJan9JF2CVOMqNg","author":"@scott21113","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsruIRqfcMl9AJ9-GSu57RXPwcczl_xOWyzT96qnaApNQ-M3s6Upf5zZJKrA0rVul9Zw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@scott21113","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxWDLgbCbnsN3QfWUZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"...Everyone wants to be appreciated. Everyone wants their work to matter... To be found... To be *enjoyed*.\n\nMonetary concerns notwithstanding, this entire thing makes it so much harder to simply do THAT: make music and have it be seen and loved. To be appreciated. To be *found*.\n\nIt is incredibly discouraging, in a field where self-motivation is already so very hard, so very often. :'(","like_count":9,"author_id":"UCjmmrtfIoSMT_P5IQ3wGSBQ","author":"@Kacey_Jaymes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nRoyy-yIwMAHHttBq_BhNTuX4NmdoX9IunZ_e9fTooJGY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Kacey_Jaymes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxWDLgbCbnsN3QfWUZ4AaABAg.AEKMBO--gKiAHAMbJl7Ljo","parent":"UgxWDLgbCbnsN3QfWUZ4AaABAg","text":"It's not been realistic for years. The internet is not good for getting an outlet for most but the top 1% of people.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCir57M_TcAT0nmzrEkUa76w","author":"@johnny5Hobo7","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/riWJKV1gjUyz-79fcouu-GxU0hFsuKqOYiolUXx8PqyHb2a0yuzu8Vf3H_tf6KUIQ1uDc5INMA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johnny5Hobo7","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBhY6j9A_kEvMP10x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What continues to amaze me is how few people realize copyright as a system is fundamentally broken.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCZZ-RBp_D-a-JIuKDykhegA","author":"@guard13007","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VVhhVBM-tvsVgMdiLlwy86luhU_npxXiNjG4TfXf5qi-O3oeah9MQqJhkSR40iST9sMAEm5B0ts=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@guard13007","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy5LMjbdm72WdrQWfh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But Ben,\n\n\n\nJoking, thanks for another excellent video! Also, though I’m sure it would seem like an honorable… finalé to you, please don’t do anything badass enough to get yourself (how to say this) sue-asided! We tend to have trouble believing that anyone would do something like that (for whatever reasons, either way) until “hey this coffee tastes kinda weird” IF you even notice and then it’s almost certainly too late… this isn’t a thing to ‘test the boundaries’ with, and we need you to not be… sued aside. \n\n\nThis is one of my absolute favorite channels - aside from being informative & helpful, a music-making alumni, a (clearly not radical in any way) political ally, mentally stimulating, funny and well-produced. It’s really because the host has proven through action a genuine compassion for others that I’m finding increasingly rare in this (hopefully not final) chapter of history… please don’t let our regrettable situation get to your head, we do see you mate!","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC-ruoFZHCEA0mO-E5xRNFsA","author":"@shainemaine1268","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mzbQXVsDwQccDUUbsv6tXGHI3C4c3UEszKqB4ppPU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shainemaine1268","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCDkyaZEp9hb9S6bh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hey Benn going off the happy note of the end of the video, I did want to say, I have recently canceled my Spotify subscription and have no intention of going back. And your videos on Spotify and how they treat their artists were the main reason I did so. In its absence I've been buying most of my music off iTunes which might not be the best as a large portion if not all of the money may just be going to the labels, I am still happy to have made the switch off Spotify and will keep trying to find ways to more directly support the artists I love. thanks !","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCoeY2V1HeK-XLEgE-w2LWOQ","author":"@cobywilcox4649","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kd6srdgHkOK5pty3zozyeKX09CbYoeMG3lQRIqhrs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cobywilcox4649","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy46jj0pGLOmSSOIhR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think the work you are doing exposing serious problems in the music copyright system is very important. Hopefully, this will be dealt with fairly, eventually. Content ID has been abused already by bad actors that steal monetization with no downside risk to themselves. Now, with AI music production in mass, it is spinning into a fraud race to the bottom that threatens all creativity.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCvY2U23w-bZNQ7hC10pof4g","author":"@TUCOtheratt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVsnWrFesrMqPAkiHA0rwVd104BZSl0R_iNLag_JamhKA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TUCOtheratt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx71v4EkIYJjqn9iPV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Most (or just about all) of us complain about AI in the artist realm from the comfort of our lounge couches. And then there are genius heroes like Benn and Cameron who does the work. I wish I had half of your brain and all your guts Benn. Your videos are SERIOUS game changers - keep the light burning.","like_count":17,"author_id":"UC1BZKl7FIw6kh3bA2k9y4JQ","author":"@Quicksilver87878787","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k_tOMCPtKoxbZNJqRdJEFJhr1SOfLJkBIfvMu64YYzVaaO=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Quicksilver87878787","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwsAiD6ukd83JwUSeZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn your channel is so awesome. I am not a \"music enthusiast\" nor a musician, but I really enjoy the science behind your videos. You do your research and bring a genuine, honest air to whatever subject you're approaching.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-sNLShcuZcLoXGN66n7xNA","author":"@nathanwilliams4364","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/q2ryGE9wjQu9YnfFVdevORnWM5rt1fAYXS--fZ83SWRTL7i9Fzd4eUUYlqQF3J8-yhGKY6VYsg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nathanwilliams4364","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy8fq7XgTybC-Yvzo54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I only discovered this channel a month ago, so I appreciate I'm massively late to the party but I don't think its hyperbolic to say I think its some of the best content on this platform for my personal interests. Thoughtful, considered and articulate content from someone who seems like a really top bloke. I'm bingeing the back catalog like a boxset rn.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWM2UXcBtF5f4rvQBK0bOWg","author":"@Begly-k1i","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nSY3SKVIB-lh59yGyZKnSBMStdyKAx-ey6Y__AoaVIck-hLXmMGqnd_XiRQfZveTs5Jg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Begly-k1i","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyRwczq_DSktgeiI94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Lossless and Compressed are not mutually exclusive. It would be more correct to use the terms lossy and lossless to differentiate. FLAC (lossless compressed audio codec) is identical to WAV PCM (lossless uncompressed audio format).","like_count":167,"author_id":"UCFhpxLM8JZ_Kyw9_s9bfJ_w","author":"@heyyoo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lz2--ti5MEqtPtD4fQw-yS5p7Cn9p_JszKZ9pwolo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@heyyoo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyRwczq_DSktgeiI94AaABAg.ACvWOw9aRmEACwdV4DEToS","parent":"UgxyRwczq_DSktgeiI94AaABAg","text":"was looking for this comment, cheers","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCHYOkulODvfFmzbFfO-pnKw","author":"@containsnosmashmouth1849","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ko95Q3N9v0DE4Mc2GxDSldHpCP69apmPmtnaUEUF1m6A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@containsnosmashmouth1849","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyRwczq_DSktgeiI94AaABAg.ACvWOw9aRmEACxqrKb-cBS","parent":"UgxyRwczq_DSktgeiI94AaABAg","text":"And almost all people wouldn't be able to tell the difference between that and it run through a well built compression algorithm. That's the point of \"Lossless\"","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCdcp6g1crjbfjVSmAv0SBtw","author":"@BDB7614","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/q7USql991rb_o0eHLNrgSVN5OyokTZH3H_vDDHfFEvaE3lzwUfokuKr_ERuh73wJ8qFVYV2kAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BDB7614","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyRwczq_DSktgeiI94AaABAg.ACvWOw9aRmEAD-N4HeHDWJ","parent":"UgxyRwczq_DSktgeiI94AaABAg","text":"there is also the possibility that the experiment they mentioned had flaws.   we dont know if the equipment and song choice and people had any affect on the sounds.    plus the song itself could be lossless but still have lossy samples .     and some people like myself whom are sensitive to sounds can really tell when audio sounds off.   i for one cant stand lossy audio.  at least when its compressed past a certain point.     the diffrence is there but i think its not \"most people dont notice\"   likely its  \"most people havent experienced the difference and are used to compressed audio as the norm\"  i mean most of the audio consumed nowadays is trough compressed social media sources","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1ZP_hSfce3G-B5bFYDs7eg","author":"@ali32bit42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/W6tUgDgHsFDfnfDuLIcGUhW9zYZcYFv_j60cXWb-jUaH9mxrz1YENV_N3mQLGXZBKVYGYfFD=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ali32bit42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLGmc2LRHIBBKZsdd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:30 It’s gonna be Deezer, isn’t it?","like_count":11,"author_id":"UC6yAHlxtmE1pypEVtpL7L5g","author":"@JaredtheRabbit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nOL75m-9I_XQVLJ2MQ3fr-IQCv3JpUPP-z9Zfc0gytdHHf=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JaredtheRabbit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyjcYiaf3AM0tCVZ54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The ability to detect MP3 depends on the high frequency content of the track. MP3 (and others) break down when there is a lot of high frequency detail, since I listen to a lot of live real drum music, if the drummer rides the open hihat or the ride cymbal it creates a flanger or phaser effect in the MP3. Once heard, can't unheard it. \nA track with 808 drums can be indistinguishable as MP3 though.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCNLTR4VirWASQAnUnRua2Bw","author":"@bu5hm4nn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/nOTRZa0IbbZ7nbu5TcV874VI6QXcMUllXNCN5WbOZGGT3prnu6Fbd1fCsoQFXfjbnbOB_fFuMKg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bu5hm4nn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyjcYiaf3AM0tCVZ54AaABAg.ACx2PyhYasoAD0Up5xUJGM","parent":"UgxyjcYiaf3AM0tCVZ54AaABAg","text":"I tend to hear it in cymbals first, too. And reverb tails if it's a sparse enough arrangement.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC7GuN3sLYYNkT5gcmKf813Q","author":"@theothermarkwilliams","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lglXFoF2XekHRzRAv7kAxMErxsK2SDpSTw4kpOvbCaycI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@theothermarkwilliams","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz8LiOZnPKfdiOmuOV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i love that you literally left your video in log colors. looks actually nice.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNE5QY1Cns_ctoXur5YHuWA","author":"@bamoida110","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VrmqB1u6_0l4y_NL_DsiXuUHsc0hcXL_yYa8fBO9vzTaw4YrsUrHdP_zvByd5CEnUzcBJSkh=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bamoida110","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx4BE0P-3-fREpbr1t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Subscribed! You're a fantastic presenter, I can't wait to catch up on the back catalog of this channel","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpUqV-RsACKUSw2oG3Ybqtg","author":"@JJRicks","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/y0jmfIiFaqcQbWlZlDQX-YTSH6X_U8osG9xYrZqcsdAobansDX0MPft2sU4sUcIiZaULWpYUaw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JJRicks","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Copyright and patents need to be completely reformed.","like_count":148,"author_id":"UCS8eDBYiGNAajecYz0MsXJA","author":"@rollingrock5143","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXNBnVor2T5FVc9Go-w378cXn6JmX-YLkW1G6mVZyFzwgLjg01XTaBOrjvCuKmfuRq9g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rollingrock5143","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg.ACviQqHETFUACxZf9IPRGi","parent":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg","text":"look up their history and realize that the only reason they exist is to shield a few from competition.. they are constructs to to allow a few to maximize profits without the market being able to correct this, as competition is prevented from doing the same thing.  That is the definition of a monopol.","like_count":19,"author_id":"UCYcyFypd0U63yphsO1BveVw","author":"@joansparky4439","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_mJlDb3pYl1ccu5RroinN1mdYtp7fHckO8fJBzmRVHvMwOVblJsQgvfKfFFylBjwDIAmJASd=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joansparky4439","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg.ACviQqHETFUACwg_idZ2bR","parent":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg","text":"Noo just Add More neo lights","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg.ACviQqHETFUACyvuhGdozS","parent":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg","text":"*abolished.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCvVMZowSbnZJ1w2qlpwgo3A","author":"@a_ggghost","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VO3Zd3q7jUQiL-GV1_Hl1YhBwSlTNllh_JotzIJzLOJxvaCUqodpEPrvf4bBwwg0QL98jhGmYp0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@a_ggghost","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg.ACviQqHETFUACxsnnZp3l8","parent":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg","text":"True but the real problem is scale of the enforcement mechanism. Whatever the law, any company at YouTube size is going to cut corners and live with lots of false positives rather than spend millions protecting individual users. In theory we're already protected under the law.\n\nI think the true solution is artists hosting their own music, not depending on gigantic corporations. Getting from here to there is the problem.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCtrQ0xHh1gJjNkQoQvLhPKw","author":"@mr7clay","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOQy_xDOm0mxVt4UcNl5k2q-UBjw80WalazE4U_ug=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mr7clay","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg.ACviQqHETFUACx7NSp7nbS","parent":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg","text":"100%","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCqkY7kIHdkUvXKeY0GRyJQw","author":"@FireF1y644","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nh21TIXgTaAUZxHQpVvXxxptHoQNtXdBlH1ysL7zbXhoU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FireF1y644","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg.ACviQqHETFUACxplX-JtH_","parent":"UgzALCBvXqegKV8dlb94AaABAg","text":"Nah using AI is pathetically lazy and you aren't an \"artist\" using it","like_count":12,"author_id":"UCWhJ32IbQfaWXryQ0Gd4P0g","author":"@russia4biden221","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhoOi8Lhcr7w0l0Ur6N0ern1n6gqe49p8sDZDsXjKezsAllwS3frRAi1p45L_qVDrCfQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@russia4biden221","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxgy6CbsOqCkjZYqaB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In a world where “ that was inspiring” is something I think less than I could have ever possibly imagined, I’ve just typed it in a YouTube comment on a video that inspired me and meant it. Well done. Well done, indeed.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCXe3wSFQ9yUu_iQsTaFrt_w","author":"@ap0ria","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l7tcXJXbIvJUhn9oqriUVmjzaHoXSFBLVA5VPxrMOSUhoo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ap0ria","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0x--tuyUBq1LfAv54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Interesting about compressed vs lossless audio. I general I have noticed a difference between FLACs from CD audio vs mp3s. Usually the cymbals get distorted first and you start to hear a watery noise as the quality drops, as if you have water stuck in your ear or you're listening from underwater. I've never done a blind study though but I'd be interested, but the difference is there to hear. Unless you've spent time comparing A and B however, you may lack experience to make that judgment. I also suspect there are times where the right bitrate of an mp3 and the right frequencies used make it less susceptible to being analyze in this fashion by a person, I suspect.","like_count":13,"author_id":"UCY04EFeortvncnRgWyxd6vQ","author":"@Sevalecan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m1I_Yy31iDz0Y8hCsLPEuvqzUv-g6jdzP6ftSCNJM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sevalecan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0x--tuyUBq1LfAv54AaABAg.ACvtXyvEfn8AD0Byi773wB","parent":"Ugy0x--tuyUBq1LfAv54AaABAg","text":"I did a non-scientific non-blind test on myself compressing down a ripped cd track (can't remember the genre but it was a good mix and production, before the loudness wars) at 320, 256, 192, 128, and 96 CBR stereo mp3s listening through low-mid range headphones. I recall starting to hear differences between 192 and 128kbps (edited) as the stereo image seemed to narrow. As you say, cymbals seem very susceptable to distortion in lower quality mp3s, and I hate that sound","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCKFgPkX5dSHd6am2xIiFMYg","author":"@mrl4342","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrr-mYcTlaxHmfz1lgkgrL_ddzIYdWl52wrDdwTzQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mrl4342","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0x--tuyUBq1LfAv54AaABAg.ACvtXyvEfn8AFtoH61Avkr","parent":"Ugy0x--tuyUBq1LfAv54AaABAg","text":"The psychoacoustic compression almost certainly prioritizes midrange over high frequency","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJCSqEWpMs9lWJrnkKNdYug","author":"@benchociej2435","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kXaHeYLSitR4IEfVckkY4SVyYfWRYjzO0TaZFk0zRTSSY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@benchociej2435","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0x--tuyUBq1LfAv54AaABAg.ACvtXyvEfn8ACyvbpBuRBU","parent":"Ugy0x--tuyUBq1LfAv54AaABAg","text":"It’s like wine tasting, just because most people drink wine and think it all just tastes like grapes doesn’t mean there aren’t flavor profiles one can easily distinguish if they know what to pay attention to. Similarly music listening is a passive activity so most people listening to lossy audio streams just hear “the song” they’ve always heard and liked… it doesn’t mean there aren’t musical layers in the signal being thrown out that a discerning ear can listen for a hear. I can always hear a difference between lossy YouTube/spotify music and my Qobuz stream and flac files.  To be fair, cheap Bluetooth earbuds that a lot of people use are poor equipment to detect these differences. But us music connoisseurs who have resolving enough gear can always hear it. And the kicker is the higher bitrate streams/flac files always sound more emotional/musically engaging to me. I feel closer to the music","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCcjXh-fiPrAudDWIQ4BHHqQ","author":"@farrellrose4230","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lsq6MzlAJuTWkDLEuENXuARktu5SXTz_VCCCbkdXw_ny4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@farrellrose4230","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgywRlbovjDd5M7_EzR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I really hope your channel grows rapidly. It's important that more people see videos like the ones you do. \nCan't afford patreon support at the moment, but will leave with a comment and a sub.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBHfd7mpMa47IZtlAkMCebA","author":"@scherge","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/msWDeyF9rzEEWI3YOd1T8HPJJD698nfd1IKbJY3S1lOa9MGi3yNJf8ZgXkVYcSZDcV-88-no_A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@scherge","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzpJteV5PriOxjs0lV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"First time coming across your channel and I am impressed by the quality of your work, research and using tech! Nothing better than mixing programming/tech with music production!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0Ycl1g8aRGwTTSOU0ltW6w","author":"@Lip.Smacker","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iXWRwEkyPTHCbH2Ws095bR1jKgoc7-Y0E4BWMI_zuGzT-mo0X1_oaNMJx1a-LfSw5sMmI-8CrA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lip.Smacker","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxdCjUcFd9Z3jnS6-N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Love it that Benn and Venus Theory had a talk one day and they both decided to start giving zero fucks and being way more honest and freewheeling in their videos. Love it.","like_count":20,"author_id":"UCyQLJJpgfQOUeQmEo0XxDDw","author":"@gonesavage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mPEVfV0_1sIuM8S2EUcWsvN-vGdCg6Of2ZzZ0tFQk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gonesavage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxdCjUcFd9Z3jnS6-N4AaABAg.ACwdwtEqxxaAO1SqWLXZjv","parent":"UgxdCjUcFd9Z3jnS6-N4AaABAg","text":"still censors random words like fuck though so that gives some indication of where his heart lies","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkfCIw9FztPkMKcP-_MO7MQ","author":"@YumekuiNeru","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NsOjqU_c0Ggi50pn2nsnbOk0Dbv3XIsIhk7gqx4p-_CEXSY3fIFx9yNMJRNG-xfmFRl31bPS=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@YumekuiNeru","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxy3dhS2jTm3ESFEoB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"make cool shit, and put it on the internet\"\n\nKeep doing that, because it's helping.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCbGddlZM7z6vaDg4Y8BeUCQ","author":"@theafro","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lyktuxUr6prhgcLUYk5yVb37LFKJPtdO9S4JH2B5k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@theafro","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxy3dhS2jTm3ESFEoB4AaABAg.ACxGKuEHD3OAD3-jcaEPIf","parent":"Ugxy3dhS2jTm3ESFEoB4AaABAg","text":"so if it's an AI building on my music sample is that also \"derivative\" and no real value, or not? lets get those braincells firing","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCjp124CnTPrHSOxjZ5dZ8fA","author":"@through-faith-alone","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Kww-jIflCM2205hXGdKOfblWdsw_ExLR9Ky14S-7F2fHGZ7aUxXAlAbI_-bEFz1M6cIUQO7Qdw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@through-faith-alone","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxy3dhS2jTm3ESFEoB4AaABAg.ACxGKuEHD3OAD-5WidYBx0","parent":"Ugxy3dhS2jTm3ESFEoB4AaABAg","text":"Ironically, this is what AI allows more people to do though 😅","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCwTsoCSMW4eO6FI_KyJ6VnA","author":"@TheNexusFM","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/J3T6zQS14ydeC4U9sjIuGWV_a7E3D-_hh70EnQiq2kqAN-oVJu4dId4I5swXOwXp5yujFHM35g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheNexusFM","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyoDn9ub5VflZ_h3fx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"instagram already tried integrating an AI detection system and it caused a bunch of people to think artists they loved were using AI when they weren't because AI gets lots of stuff wrong constantly which people will know from how often Google's AI confidently gives a wrong answer","like_count":23,"author_id":"UCx3yx5DfpJOc8v4x7cMAUfg","author":"@hsmoscout","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nv19EadS1EiGkVNZUmyDEy27vpLkp4WTnn6VSyVCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hsmoscout","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyoDn9ub5VflZ_h3fx4AaABAg.ACzmDDMHd8dAD3QnwYcRw0","parent":"UgyoDn9ub5VflZ_h3fx4AaABAg","text":"Using AI to find other AI... We live in an anime now.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCFTd5dH9X-VlAR5az1rlQaQ","author":"@dyrtknap","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m1vXgcIE3wISTfgZjM4OUiABcJwiALq4lXwNi4JxAwNWSSHXfL__Q-FchHu0alrDwOzO2doctLM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dyrtknap","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyuDsc0TGx51tXL7IZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Please create a music streaming platform that is fair and just and I feel that you are the man for this!  I would help with whatever I can (UI/UX design, graphic design) to make this happen and I mean it. I think that others would chip in too, it could be a community project for the community. Thanks for all your great work!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCsdjQGQfJG0GK6mlo-uW--Q","author":"@webizual5605","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RSFkYysnFV0PXCDevi5-Sw3ZZAzYbkLSnrQexeiqYufMu5wQiHiN_MENcum9zO6QKQXMViVSDDA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@webizual5605","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx0BhLONhL4tVVdDqp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey man love your content. I think you should take all of your videos from the past few years and boil them down into one large video explaining all of the information involved with the music streaming scam industry. I dunno. Anyway keep it up!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCmhe97U5j14nv_-nJYXtZ_A","author":"@adricklynn8882","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n2vhawj-Q_xhdgoXom0Hvqll0w_cfv9nWN_pV-mNZ9f2c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@adricklynn8882","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxS1BBGFSdoepvlglh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Found your channel and bought the zoia because of you! Your interests and experiments etc are very inspiring thanks Benn... you're adding massive value out here","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCEMmP0Xzh2iXsHVA2S8NQig","author":"@meowcat4245","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ki8Ai2Livt1gNX-anUoALd9fR6WvtNiRCvkhVJ_NPVkQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@meowcat4245","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzbso3PF685O3xs_Fx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:16 🤣🤣","like_count":15,"author_id":"UCsbkbXpcSNrEWj4yEW9UWAA","author":"@widezyp2228","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m5xhrVzb8B79hDowmfWdek4CrL6PnLD6HneEuWZI4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@widezyp2228","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzbso3PF685O3xs_Fx4AaABAg.ACvLW21AvnlACy8dEB56Yl","parent":"Ugzbso3PF685O3xs_Fx4AaABAg","text":"👍😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIrW5em68Hi-ZvCnToX1y8g","author":"@peoplelikefrank","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5-CIQk4zvIxKOi-bRMj2ZPuSxs6P3MnExEnulRn44g-K8R3zQyFUDEh3TxWc0VpZRFR_Ez5xQng=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@peoplelikefrank","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyB4n5DrqICHq-pMrR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn...I love you","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCfSpBxW8JNV9M5popTf5rQQ","author":"@christopherreeves5272","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/E3VeWmhoWo0daXibI3p-UQ0lsRwIbrf8cZX4U1RFOL1hjVam6T1LR5FD4HDiXrbrpUSdH7Pkiw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@christopherreeves5272","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyB4n5DrqICHq-pMrR4AaABAg.ACvLKvHNIVnACvLlkTk0oQ","parent":"UgyB4n5DrqICHq-pMrR4AaABAg","text":"Love you too beebs <3","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCshObcm-nLhbu8MY50EZ5Ng","author":"@BennJordan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n4yN6OoQTOtdKr9MtPVRhT38hPTP0NUkc10Ni6wZWljek_9XRq0EuBi7PbmJb2bRs_WxcgQe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":true,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BennJordan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxjZzue65-py05TieR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Such an elegant solution for identifying if something was created artificially. \n\nJust getting into your videos. Not a producer, but programmer. This scratched my brain in a new, awesome way","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7G7g6f92fyY4djiryRvFaw","author":"@HankTTN","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SVurk7kFQOS06VGkPOrNwjsvJG0sDQomUSo-5CEZptCC7MWwR_hh6DXiHt1j6cVJsPvzb-rnjA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HankTTN","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyMsfU2O6__cia71g54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You are truly doing the world a service with your content, pls never stop <3","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVaber7kEis7L9sb6nCwFpw","author":"@andrewstoye5081","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXBJTZNASI7oSMjgXxAV2iYvGhfBDbKxS5r2_oA2w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andrewstoye5081","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-xNC0v9yeoamFMjp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I couldn’t tell the difference between compressed and lossless on individual tracks but over time my ears tire from compressed audio. When MP3s came out I loved them until I started to lose intrerest in music. Vinyl and lossless brought my interest back and I can listen all day at home now. In the car on mp3 im  good for an hour then it’s podcasts.","like_count":15,"author_id":"UC72bOvyVNAeEH6uHdMFVWxw","author":"@mcrunk1977","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qWTQ43bwE0kVkzOhTvvJMXtba5CF3Cxm-hmouyryhqSP2DLUViE6iQggNIVCzD39Mz4qpDSQ7g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mcrunk1977","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-xNC0v9yeoamFMjp4AaABAg.ACvJiiAeoX5ACvO_lLa1W5","parent":"Ugx-xNC0v9yeoamFMjp4AaABAg","text":"Even lossless music in the car is tiring tho. The inside of a car is a terrible acoustic space.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCpamW8aYdKJGXPyAKFelklg","author":"@promethea-sy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/G45BOCjBCOUB7NTmCNTPJLho21XMN_EsWjWgs_6EtVjyZhcLGd0-rtjkSpAoqxVaHtsMzZd1=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@promethea-sy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-xNC0v9yeoamFMjp4AaABAg.ACvJiiAeoX5ADbreI9moVM","parent":"Ugx-xNC0v9yeoamFMjp4AaABAg","text":"Exactly right, the compressed garbage causes fatigue. Single track a/b tests do not account for this.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQc72xLO-bdvH60SWONd2gA","author":"@spiritlevelstudios","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nfF7KpIPpXURYmUwdF5bcr-cLFCqQ4X86-byrLwDplsQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@spiritlevelstudios","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwIgA2o8XqOsRV1m2F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The reason most people chose the lower quality music as being the higher quality is most likely due to the fact that the lower quality is their \"norm\".  So many people stream low bitrate music on their day to day, and rarely (if ever) listen to CDs or vinyls, so their mind has made that particular quality the \"standard\"; and since everyone thinks their way is the best, their mind has set that quality as the best ... You then ask them to compare what their mind has deemed the best to a higher quality, and they're of course going to say that their normal (lower quality) choice is better.\n\nThe mind is pretty silly.\n\nAnd yes, I dork out on neuroscience podcasts all day at work.","like_count":12,"author_id":"UC3aMjvNVmOHpIRQirXm_neg","author":"@OriginalGabriel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_neVz9nr_UXC4tqZv3OWWDdqZX56KdoOwOZCwYHhz3ea6Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@OriginalGabriel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwIgA2o8XqOsRV1m2F4AaABAg.ACx1JNIbfcbAD4O7W-8b3G","parent":"UgwIgA2o8XqOsRV1m2F4AaABAg","text":"The other side of the coin is the systems outputting the music. Air Poops are all the rage and they sound horrible, meanwhile my Sony, Koss, AudioTechnica, and other headphones completely blow those things into the water, with the competition being 4-5x more with the EarBra Max Pros barely keeping paces with headphones that are DECADES old at this point. That also is part of the problem. The smartphone market only had LG, MoonDrop, and Sony the last few years providing the mobile experience that is feasibly achievable outside of buying fiiO or some other extremely niche device for an already less mainstream niche that is HQ audio....... People these days are spoiled with 10s of thousands options, all of them poorly made crap from china with no prior reference to \"good\" sound. You won't find the majority of people running Focal in their cars or having 5-7.1 surround for their TV unless it comes in a complete \"sound system\" box.\n\nThe thing that gave me hope for humanity regarding music was that Vinyl was making a resurgence before covid and platforms such as bandcamp are readily available these days.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsEZiab0qy5ttQeU7BGn6sQ","author":"@WhatWillYouFind","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMDhdBH36mlK6ubPqm1LX-3Rb6s7l-XAGtTPTgIog=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WhatWillYouFind","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9fxmlT4bamFFJAOF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're doing some of the best journalism online, Benn. And you're doing some of the most effective science communication online, as well.","like_count":41,"author_id":"UCK0dIfdsiR0rr2KyODlb10Q","author":"@glenmorrison8080","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8pHmsns5W_pPDMwBL2IryyYYiRGozMbtruL2G0Ms21Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@glenmorrison8080","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzaP6BE2I8lgsb6rol4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey Benn, great video. It would be interesting to see, in your investigation of copyright strikes, if included, there was also a song that was %100 original recorded with live musicians, and see how many strikes that gets. I bet it would not be zero.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCoKqX8j63Fks6Mjt2nZt-jQ","author":"@tomlyne","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZVweQS4qFtmiZEG10n8uQw768LoSW_tkkulogMUMY7uw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tomlyne","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzwupMxEEB7LbGVbeR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just discovered your YouTube channel today, this is my second video and I realized oh shit, you’re flashbulb! Been listening to your work for a while now","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEnPI5XPxblgxoFB967NFeA","author":"@natasha2296-g8f","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3w5pHbAbv1UvTOPK0opzB0B7dPW0ZNUdarnydvhKgG4l6j3Av59TtPzgAeNOLj7pxDQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@natasha2296-g8f","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxkBRA-RMyTCIrH3lh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Having used Suno for a fair amount of songs, about 500~ or so, I've noticed that in almost every creation there is a weird residual sound that appears in its creations. It sounds like a bleeping synth and it usually occurs in parts where the song is becoming a bit more calm, so right after a chorus or before a buildup. If you hear that sound, you can immediately know that it's AI generated.","like_count":13,"author_id":"UCLg7vDPWieYzZkzwhhc21kQ","author":"@johantitulaer1052","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l7tDEw0f7pN79t68_h-v-vJX-43lkf03xO1xmTSOGHKLU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johantitulaer1052","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxkBRA-RMyTCIrH3lh4AaABAg.AD4KyounBPVALAvhIbBsU8","parent":"UgxkBRA-RMyTCIrH3lh4AaABAg","text":"there are ways to clear this up. those vocal separators help","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyuDzJsg-_lTY70ldDhcMpQ","author":"@patriciaellinghausen4365","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/T6OrkQGCFU8dhcDePUzW1VsxRe2vn6LmZTEqt8cBxWz9jckcDYHSJQsmDSHUV8AU0Sihgor-MQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@patriciaellinghausen4365","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7J2CHbI-nHrsG3dh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"1:12 I’m skeptical of anyone claiming 100% accuracy on anything. Only a minute in and I’m already leaning into this being a cope post","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC1p90pb3S-FwYy1IraOyaOw","author":"@siamesestormtrooper","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m93s1ELcpsNF6ahuw-KwofBaN5ygQKyfcqjPZxpbGli3I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@siamesestormtrooper","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh-3O1D00lpccQ8zx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn, what's your plan with your AI music detector ?\nWill it become a public tool in the future so people can identify who's using AI ?","like_count":66,"author_id":"UC8QDcwFw0LBiPSuHo0_Frpw","author":"@sabienprissette2922","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nRQlM1_EZuIJCSLGvNp1f_5wdKCajX9wzDRhFxFPNoxbI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sabienprissette2922","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh-3O1D00lpccQ8zx4AaABAg.ACvTx9TFRvMACvVq3ufpkw","parent":"Ugzh-3O1D00lpccQ8zx4AaABAg","text":"I've shared it with some colleagues who are ML engineers. Ideally it would be used by services like BMAT.","like_count":55,"author_id":"UCshObcm-nLhbu8MY50EZ5Ng","author":"@BennJordan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n4yN6OoQTOtdKr9MtPVRhT38hPTP0NUkc10Ni6wZWljek_9XRq0EuBi7PbmJb2bRs_WxcgQe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":true,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BennJordan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzh-3O1D00lpccQ8zx4AaABAg.ACvTx9TFRvMADnBhJ45l2L","parent":"Ugzh-3O1D00lpccQ8zx4AaABAg","text":"does it identify bad music, then you would have to throw out 99%","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyWBPhufThhPbee7hMzYHQA","author":"@theend9494","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m10zIY8Vx9wj2yDfc970SJ-Jak_m6yJlXkN_uScU-eHjk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@theend9494","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzFk_EXqU0VpXjGkDl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just the conclusion of your video is a freaking great representation of why I follow Venus and you and will continue to do so... you guys are role models for me !","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCefBP3DYc2PJiasyIjbajOw","author":"@kevinpannetiermusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k9UxnvSEs8JwuJDQ-mV6u1Ei1FmVZ81IqmMkbvtyEEUuGBEHgOsXdETp1IQUaanB9mRA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kevinpannetiermusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwn9vMgLNtFxEE5yod4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I kinda want to get into the visual art version of what you're doing as an film animation student. I also have some sound design under my belt and am learning about sound/music: it's a lot of work! People deserved to get paid for their work! Props for all the work you're doing and sharing. :) <3","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLZxuragSIcl5FyepML3OFA","author":"@Visualatrix","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kgpoo4vRQWZ7v_XumqsPMaDtrEjVX38RC7dyIMLxuy2D832dS0H_y2mFgsRDNPotjB3w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Visualatrix","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzinFtOJVPilQI6ZVt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I was once in a party with a paid employee of a local bank, which is also a huge IT company branching out into different things, AI included. She worked in their music AI department, she said she was in charge of training data. When I asked her what's the process for getting the music, she said \"Torrents, lol\". \n\nI gave her the coldest shoulder I could. But I doubt there's going to be a comeuppance for this, unfortunately.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCyhOZP5dyxhvyXBgJngV_RQ","author":"@cowbless","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kozwMB1kEySZI0n1cgtbPIGpxH1pL3UTQsbVuNSnwqKqc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cowbless","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynG8OYBT8BI1h1cGt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"1:50 The Cannabis leaf there for no reason at all to represent the randomness of the video?","like_count":12,"author_id":"UCEnCdzphG_KdMUYskAXjx_Q","author":"@karmacomaxo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lRFsZIcml7rCjYnCve1T7B1N_U_jkLgJupfoEK9pIRmMBYszZymFLmnbb8EMsdwQe5HGd_dwpw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@karmacomaxo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynG8OYBT8BI1h1cGt4AaABAg.AD0evX0fNC6AD5-FzSh2lC","parent":"UgynG8OYBT8BI1h1cGt4AaABAg","text":"I laughed","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC7Tqlzal_bUlU8pXAZVRL3Q","author":"@maymayman0","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mhbVe5_GXgN8beVYN9BlC1WUZTIalcQZxhDSEpHeuTSdc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maymayman0","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxljR47HoOthmi7y2B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:41 I would have thought Beatport to pay most.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UChE7aAohrwytbpSqCx3duwQ","author":"@Schuda","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SYuPD8ZdSpibPT4CQHqm41HpyvQRtN5Cdr0WhQJ0y-cI5bzJwTiZhSQAQ7gofi5MnJwp_pCqa8o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Schuda","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYcu6q6yGMdrMVT6l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This video is both informative and inspiring in equal measure. Thank you for your hard work Benn, it is appreciated by more people than you can know.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCA8t7HU-CobiZ5kRf0Md4Cw","author":"@HugoLeedham","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_MS034CoXP0shU1o9emKwx7ldSQsfXipwbIRf7wMUxQYCe3inprIxbG4rl5PAzyPTEHFH8zy=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HugoLeedham","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyayjePAQ-QBV-UD8d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Top stuff there mate, please keep on doing what you are doing cos there aren't many who have the time, resources, knowledge & ability to call out these companies. Cheers 🙂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnJrxnB9GoMJWnWaYco6Jlg","author":"@AidenGilbert13","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lkzmCAAotXgETmtqaPHL7CgVf5BjZsqbdpSepzCpKNWX46=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AidenGilbert13","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxFGA-omYTIPpuZMjF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I have fallen in love with your channel ever since that video about Twitter Bots, lovely","like_count":19,"author_id":"UC_mX2SzXO4IHNx0-FfQWEbw","author":"@Billy_Herrington1969","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cAvSzpOr-L7cgYihVWTcsl0HT96fen3pfFeP6F4PS5Im7hhUn9nJsQgn9bNTex6KPvkdW8IlVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Billy_Herrington1969","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9UUv72oTuA7mzmex4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What better way to start my Sunday morning than with a Benn Jordan video that is going to make me have an existential crisis about pursuing a career in music? 😅 \n\nAppreciate your videos so much man","like_count":48,"author_id":"UCy_bbwPsSwNmdlYpExi9fYQ","author":"@devinbelangermusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SSQc-FPUE9d81eE1cesUzj8UfLBwZN8O4tqyWQaLKK8HG17ZUnKwuFTELnqs4LNXMnqICqpI9v8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@devinbelangermusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9UUv72oTuA7mzmex4AaABAg.ACvTkyGti4QADAvcG77yXz","parent":"Ugx9UUv72oTuA7mzmex4AaABAg","text":"I think it is a tool that can be used in combination with human creativity and knowledge, it doesnt have to entirely replace it or be devoid of human soul or effort.\n\nI write all my own lyrics and draw all associated art for my music- album cover, profile pics/ banners etc with no AI assistance. \nI use AI mostly to generate vocals which i can control the pronunciation and flow of. \n\nI upload my own beats and regenerate them which usually retains about 30-70% of its qualities but i also have included large chunks of my unaltered beats in songs ive made.\n\nI sample (chop up and loop) multiple AI generations and create and arrange new sections, bridges, transitions. I'll sample drums from them and repurpose them, or repitch, add effects, and the same with vocals for adlibs, choruses, outros.\n\nI quit making music for 2 years until i discovered the AI program last month, which let me create my album ive been crafting and trying to record for far too long, and it still feels authentically like me cuz i can make it use words as i would say them with the flow i would use.\n\nAll I want is some appreciation for my lyrics and AI allows me to present them as a fully finished song which I have a ton of control over.\nits the best medium I currently have access to be able to share my music right now, so I am grateful for that, and i am proud of what I made.\nI cannot perform vocals where I currently live due to shitty circumstances and environmental limitations.\nI use AI and try to retain as much authenticity as i can to share my work, and i think i accomplish that skillfully, better than any other AI music ive heard thus far.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCf4PvbDXg4ykZnHmHomR5AQ","author":"@ITZTLI-music","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m364CABS1BKFw2OQjs5lIZZRoUPUAqIhOpj-bdYFBBqWR6CWdxyq4VQxyPLsR3m4UBuYy8BEUg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ITZTLI-music","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9UUv72oTuA7mzmex4AaABAg.ACvTkyGti4QACvVbg6MJHb","parent":"Ugx9UUv72oTuA7mzmex4AaABAg","text":"Aren't people who make music supposed to be in a permanent existential crisis, though?  It's 'edge'!","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCG1tyM_se42xm4rn7T-Atyg","author":"@GoldilocksZone-665","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/EmxF-jl-u0pxEuCkBN-ayhgj5LdNkoPRazpxurI128TIMsATiVcP7d5R6Fhgw4VhJzBLvPN-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GoldilocksZone-665","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7GEzrGpDHCJSyaUR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't have a single music streaming service. I tried free Spotify for a week and went back to my MP3s. Thank god for being such a fan of 90-00s Warp Records and 80s heavy metal. It all fits in my Sony player which has a 3.5mm headphone jack for my 12 dollar headphones.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCFec4hv_oez4aqdEA9fPF4Q","author":"@bitspacemusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nSnfC4iJ1IhCm8XXLf0H6Vvf5pSmL8-z7a6D_4b_w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bitspacemusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7GEzrGpDHCJSyaUR4AaABAg.ACyPkvnL0wkAE5DWg3pmDC","parent":"Ugy7GEzrGpDHCJSyaUR4AaABAg","text":"Legit👊🏻","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCnR53bc7uvAmzdlSFz9UUng","author":"@shmk1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lleXqmuGpDfVejrNsovB6mbVD5LBXvKCBjUYIVSzN5Og=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shmk1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKzX-RfniB_L33Dr54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So happy to see this channel flourish!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9-UobeVY_x5xaeJ6ImqPaA","author":"@dancorwin9232","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNiFtFPBQ4a38IGVHY2P4lCZnuqdTKmhVE58dUj7s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dancorwin9232","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzLscIK8E5rvL02ixN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I did not know what I signed up for when I started watching you from that noise video I watched months ago, now having watched most of your videos and knowing that you chose to stay with Youtube even with the offer from companies to what I assume is to make content for those platforms is truly king behaviour.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQXZfmO12_rDZijS-ImQjiA","author":"@realjames1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wqc8XE6a0jFDKwCVw7bon4TxSJLoihh5Ap1wYHA4CeLUXNy0gcw4lF37ii9zUeCoGusDqVnDoQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@realjames1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It is a little misleading to say that compression throws out, say, 80% of the INFORMATION. It throws out 80% of the DATA. In theory you can compress a one-hour recording of a sine wave using two numbers, the frequency and the duration: e.g. sin@440/3600. That is WAY less information than a 128kbps hour long recording, but the reproduction would be BETTER than a transmitted recording. All sound can be reproduced as sine wave combinations. So, while clearly music requires more than one formula, compression does not PER SE mean information loss, just data reduction. Further, sampling error forgiveness is not JUST a psychological effect. For example, so long as the sampling rate is twice the highest frequency, Nyquist and Shannon showed that there is a mathematical stability to a sampled result--a result that can lead to compression mechanisms that do lose information, but not at the same rate as they lose data, for example by first filtering out barely audible high frequency content.","like_count":287,"author_id":"UCpoZuJ-cIVfa61CbObvyDAw","author":"@joshuacoppersmith","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_na03eQ5cLaFWnGXmDgBfwc4S955rcRTQX9wvunIiHQBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joshuacoppersmith","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACvbPIz6wJE","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"Great clarification about data vs. information. To say a bit more about the Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem: while it guarantees that frequencies below half the sampling rate can be faithfully reconstructed in theory -- the practical quality of frequency reproduction depends on factors like bit depth, filter design, and other implementation details.","like_count":30,"author_id":"UCAdutYm0Mln7hBL7qgFZ92Q","author":"@Mikee512","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n-rT-JV2ilJ55hl1wc0se1G0mXPfHSjHK_7McYQHCLjA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mikee512","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACwWGKumcfD","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"All cyclic sound can be represented as sine wave combinations. Any finite sound requires infinite sine wave combinations, so this doesn't count as a “representation” and certainly doesn't establish anything useful about compressibility. And “'lossless” in the current context generally refers to lossless digitally sampled sound, which is to say, lossy. Not that physics lets you do anything noiselessly.\n\nIn short, this is a whole philosophical and practical can of worms, and attempts to provide a “simple intuition” are probably doomed to be misleading.\n\nIt's interesting to think about Kolmogorov complexity (which is worth looking up if you don't know about it) and how to relativise it to different (not necessarily finitary) basis sets.","like_count":11,"author_id":"UCzkytbB4wyN4C92qm_TRJAg","author":"@stephenspackman5573","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mNcry71jL0m752S49WXIO0sv-nYXbDvi-gmXL7itPE0urI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stephenspackman5573","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACwHIyySP5f","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"Great explanation. Another way to think about this is JPG vs SVG. A rasterized version of a vector image might be 5MB, but it's vector original only 50KB. The vector image represents the same contents in different way, leading to similar, or even better reproduction at higher zoom levels.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UC906raRGc9uvihGxUrX1O1w","author":"@itsbazyli","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_npK2kXNwoRTIos8g9dqGPdB2oFo2QilYImw2VhvMU6i4Bj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@itsbazyli","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACxHMnWhyfx","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"From an entropy perspective, a 1hour recording of a sine wave didn't contain much information to begin with though\n\nYou could compare the best lossless compression to a lossy compression to estimate the information thrown out by the lossiness","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCe7kSghB_WzJVLHVVERdZjw","author":"@not_enough_data_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7yaxDkz-tgUnsA0p8T1wMsyhReqPkDYr-OkYS3nDplmPrhaSyDOGICwxI9Gzg1L4J0v89e6CDQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@not_enough_data_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACxeXKcCSw5","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"all the above = audio nerd heaven, i like it","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCPMui38Re-as8v-VJ4ijNbw","author":"@jorisboulet8137","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ktf9w-_Y-Ykk2WaCOrvRvto-DqwRfZrCwkWm-etOgO-lhcHcpTYkUtyPAuK6d42C4TAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jorisboulet8137","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACzzYecXErt","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"Im actually developing a better audio stamdard which may be available incthe mext few years.  I have no fear of anyone introducing something similar before then as there is no one who is utilizing the method nor technology that i am going to introduce.\nIt may be a while before it becomes a music standard but eventually it is likely.\nAs for what i know about AI Design & Data Sets, I'm sure i will be able to detect AI generated audio.\n\nAs a matter of fact my higher priority project is a method to detect Image alteration (whether by Photoshop or AI).  Essentially creating Court-Evidence Grade validation possible. Then i will take some of that and apply it to Audio.\nThe Image/Video version of this should be available this year.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6hKqX4PqlT3Nxx_2SYQ9xQ","author":"@LG-qz8om","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nyabX6jwwke4SB1uwQKB46l_qKM_Cp6rOIit1G-V6TDA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LG-qz8om","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RAD2YR-n-hx7","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"Thanks. Glad someone has a brain and commented it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHa24MhwltcVlPOCuDjVhOw","author":"@kaydog890","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxw5_zTJrzLNKWJ5dtGOqLfnWDjIkSewn7rZ8VztE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kaydog890","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RAFFV0mD6lDv","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"Not all information is relatively useful.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCN_a1eSp2QBszgTgSzvX7qQ","author":"@MentallyEmpty","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1_ZvmzxvIdqMUFUTUOixSgvPs2eiCJIvtLZAtW0Pz1gKFee3aUMsNqcVj2g4WwszuJb0PCe4j_U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MentallyEmpty","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RAFto2l7oNRS","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"That's begging the question of what counts as meaningful, desired information versus noise versus encoding overhead. You're certainly not throwing out much information about the human-audible spectrum, but you're absolutely throwing out information with compression. It's just information you don't care about. That's really the long-winded definition of lossy compression.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJCSqEWpMs9lWJrnkKNdYug","author":"@benchociej2435","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kXaHeYLSitR4IEfVckkY4SVyYfWRYjzO0TaZFk0zRTSSY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@benchociej2435","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACvezAen-yN","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"But that's not how Mp3 or any similar lossy compression system works. It absolutely throws out information. Sure, it isn't necessarily information you would have heard so you could say, in a sense, that is was redundant, but that doesn't mean it wasn't information. If it was a graph of share price, for example, rather than music, then you wouldn't say that throwing away 80% of the data did not lose a large amount of information. If the information was still there, you wouldn't be able to do a delta between lossless and lossy compression.","like_count":27,"author_id":"UCD2v2aOwh3qgiJhDEVr-8WA","author":"@MattNolanCustom","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOVBlhLR8Rf9y8d-4dcMViTFEzbZ1ElvMlR7LPrtS4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MattNolanCustom","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACw9YyPDaSL","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"Lossy compression clearly throws out information. Just encode anything on the higher frequencies of the audible range, compress, decompress, decode back to regular frequencies, and you'll see how much worse it is.","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCaJkvmjMH24fBz7oTU5JYKQ","author":"@DiThi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mPoI77cCZ9z4NYRmhSRot2weereVAZP0_7-8UwG7g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DiThi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg.ACvS-yvE94RACwBj-tCnGw","parent":"Ugx1CCvZH-usfoxfZEZ4AaABAg","text":"Storage is so cheap, lossy compression is ridiculous.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCY9jQBGyYEUNV2EMzXNhTQg","author":"@bélalugrisi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Nn1ORGlD8We_spV55RaGFYlXIUZpPg8Fu5V_ApMkV2G83vQ4ABATPJnmzTy5au6lfmoCEg4lQA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@b%C3%A9lalugrisi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Beatport claim:\n\n\"In 2022, Beatport paid an average of $0.10808333 per stream, while its service aimed at open-format DJs, Beatsource, averaged $ 0.17773333 per stream — that’s more than 30 times the industry-wide blended average streaming rates across platforms in the United States was $.0053 per stream.\"\n\nChecking my own royalty statements I see payments of about £0.02 per stream from Beatport.","like_count":9,"author_id":"UCEOHUQIIDO3F2KAsjS3TmVw","author":"@friendwithin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LgW5CHLe31r2CzM2tmEvPlxRrEAFFFgz3EnFUI5DPWa8rd46WG2JhWOSJi5TRhMOcbOJ00h27Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@friendwithin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg.ACy4F-RYwSvACzR4PyFTQm","parent":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg","text":"Nice! This is cool to know, though I need to verify","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnt7vYCx7GDyh8VEP6k6AQw","author":"@benreiter7218","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DLlxmlwA7-otkWvU1jpJwF-GazPrkYizwSqURN4l4lF-X-_oajad3AEtbphE_uGtXa1aivaXnw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@benreiter7218","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg.ACy4F-RYwSvAD-H-dnAOzx","parent":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg","text":"who the heck is going to Beatport to stream?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHaS03BuC8MsrHHStT-h4Bw","author":"@blackcatalogue","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lyAU2k6KFZuwxd6ClYS3yJzxLEb1EnKrUcL3AQ2xiDNg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@blackcatalogue","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg.ACy4F-RYwSvAD4fordCPvl","parent":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg","text":"Beatport is horrible. They require you to be subscribed to their streaming service just so you don't have limits to downloading the music that you bought for yourself. They also require extra cost for lossless formats which makes zero sense.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNrAPJ25jQdDJKKYvR3sonA","author":"@Simon_Denmark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NGoSaM5Xjj0mLxh-IHd0li_P7DRYeFm_s3PFsvWpl3LuJk21IdXkxoHOJe3O6ANtS0GehxsXSQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Simon_Denmark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg.ACy4F-RYwSvAD4gB89ivUt","parent":"Ugz0XBDsMd3mBYlKEDF4AaABAg","text":"Don't have to suffer from anything like this in Bandcamp.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNrAPJ25jQdDJKKYvR3sonA","author":"@Simon_Denmark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NGoSaM5Xjj0mLxh-IHd0li_P7DRYeFm_s3PFsvWpl3LuJk21IdXkxoHOJe3O6ANtS0GehxsXSQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Simon_Denmark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzaRYgl401z4gWyIt54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The best way to support musicians is to buy their music on bandcamp or mirlo and then sync it to your music player like it's 2004, or run Plex on your computer and plexamp on your phone. While that doesn't pay per stream, the 80 cents or so that you pay the musician up front goes a LOT further.","like_count":13,"author_id":"UCiSrFdXaWAf81-xdnDvf1xw","author":"@fluffycritter","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lX12qKdrQi8uEdNgODujajlsk9qM2uZReZWEFEXM59D3Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fluffycritter","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzaRYgl401z4gWyIt54AaABAg.ACwFw8XR5sLACzcZ3fZRl-","parent":"UgzaRYgl401z4gWyIt54AaABAg","text":"Yeah but also that sounds like a nightmare listening experience. Especially if what you enjoy most about music is being exposed to new music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8S5QZeDi1qE2durE5MnpLw","author":"@lamBOwheel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oZgFRpNfYX9dzxIQ1L9uwaCOZUScaIsb-93awKok1esnO0R0_PfbPj3LhbfhGtq9dYk1GrVLZQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lamBOwheel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyIe_YNW68f7Q-MDUV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi, Benn!\nAwesome video, as always: tons of research, tons of insight only someone with your experience could provide and a fun watch.\n\nI hope you finally found a greyhound with a big blue rubber deek, and I hope you release another Acidwolf album. ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKGT00rn66cbQtKQqLrDp_g","author":"@CreationProblematic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nRXC0W0q8QMZOSnE-cYVwktbHa9MUhdkbobASxQGW2ig=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CreationProblematic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzEaoKhHEm_UyWkSst4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I did learn that DJ's playing music very loud can spot an mp3 straight away.  And I believe them.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCt1E0KXgBtOCrpI91erBArQ","author":"@telegraphhill803","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nMOMhqpdPNKWTlRFkFffH1T47NKhN_I8bwxlTq2b8RBg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@telegraphhill803","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzMrtcAShbzSvNGui94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I appreciate all the people on a music channel straight up coming out and stating they have absolutely no love for music, art as a whole, or the artists who create it.","like_count":60,"author_id":"UCZSPp0ukdUtGH0aIpk6lEaw","author":"@Electric0eye","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9r14w9-fl7ethf34yOts1SBoHRS36hLfj-8Jlt9z3Dcfj8G2gdbe-fbRUVKRD3JlDMBtqwbD8eI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Electric0eye","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzMrtcAShbzSvNGui94AaABAg.AD874zYWWLOADieypsq6eM","parent":"UgzMrtcAShbzSvNGui94AaABAg","text":"Nobody said that. You just decided people said that","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCNX3MGERqrWO_FC60brgbqA","author":"@bradbradson4543","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mFygwIo7CnpTxY89LCqGBoAbFqX2tyGH7PwL1MlAM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bradbradson4543","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyeunsWLmZICF8QLxZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love me an mp3. Even if its crunchy, or glitches from years of data loss being moved around from ipod, to sd card, to USB stick! Its like that \"dirtyness\" of an old mp3 tells you a history of it. I think high quality wavs and flacs are great for certain songs, too. but i'm more of just a fanatic music hoarder, instead of a full blown audiophile, and those lossless files tend to be huge. i know i sound like a quanity over quality person, but thats just how i love having my music!!! Love the video man, puts an interesting perspective on streaming services as an artist! Great work!","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCSIr8G8_IFXGGDbBI2OfQvQ","author":"@iwasthefirstgoofpaste","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/tf_dHMyPeCaPCpzU3_vfppSzfeY-ZRB33xcHYgBBc31tTbD3ir2Fh5MBcHKMhojhHPvzYGsU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@iwasthefirstgoofpaste","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyeunsWLmZICF8QLxZ4AaABAg.AD9N6vOznQ4ADDVAtHx5qd","parent":"UgyeunsWLmZICF8QLxZ4AaABAg","text":"Same! Some tracks can sound even better when ripped in mp3 with a low bitrate.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMu5DR4hbuqMrvoTuW0gllA","author":"@who_s_afraid","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kJ1Eun_aZsYWCh533nGbcYC2jS9VBr-3zDzDV-lfkM9QU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@who_s_afraid","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’m gonna say this again: libraries of many countries already have sort of streaming services and I think that’s who should be taking up the baton.\n\nBTW: my problem with every mp3 versus WAV test I’ve ever seen or read is that they mostly don’t do it with music that I think I’d hear the difference on or indeed that I would want to listen to. I can definitely hear the difference on the live and studio opera CDs I ripped from my own collection about fifteen years ago even though they’re all 320kbps OGG or MP3.\n\nEdit:\nI’m not talking about cymbals and other such high frequency content. I think that’s long ago been taken care of. And I admit that I haven’t tried testing my claims for easily nine years. I’m sure a lot has happened in codec development since then","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCLVvY7tRNO2H_I79uKwI2Hg","author":"@Thr3-Words","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oi0s4w3NPAai25fKn4T2Q6WeTfwF-PcH0uxAvolRarz380sOYUAbpmEZJIx9zO42TZKG-4ck=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Thr3-Words","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg.ACvLL7z7qdrACvNSfpGx5v","parent":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg","text":"tbh I only noticed a difference between MP3 and WAV when listening to very sonically crowded music, since that is where the compression hits hardest. Since then I'm an enjoyer of lossless.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC1YobrCuMTs7-zuyn9T8YXg","author":"@Lodit24","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GHWiduyj5Z2NZwb101kJWHHrQiKg2OsmqpqKQTY_V9d_JqXTXHn-jYMK4KzN1yVAiV36ZsvvkQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lodit24","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg.ACvLL7z7qdrACvT0A9-XuF","parent":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg","text":"I mostly only listen to metal, and its pretty easy to spot a low bitrate song, the cymbals and hi-hat are a dead giveaways if the bitrate is very low. Just sounds awfully crushed and hissing.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCCLJPJf2bcH_p0vbGlSB69g","author":"@pronstorestiffi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Cxo6a1YP5ZUm85zzQXnzGwedf1Z6Icf9zsDzzPsYEqUOGNq0ns--cNuos_a3XrQcMvuf8yCLYA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pronstorestiffi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg.ACvLL7z7qdrACvSBLeGrGH","parent":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg","text":"I agree.   I probably couldn't tell and wouldn't care listening to Michael Jackson, but play me some chamber music, some acoustic jazz, or even the high definition Dark Side of the Moon and I can tell you.   I also have pretty high quality audio equipment because I DO notice.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCjMvESGwmB6Ci5nOFmGsCGQ","author":"@inmitch","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOs6r6pF1qPKC-cBNYpi1mxLwXWD69Y4sTyQdvr7EcgA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@inmitch","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg.ACvLL7z7qdrACvUMRZMruK","parent":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg","text":"I say that I can tell but even Ben admitted that at 256kbps he lost that ability. I would love to see a video of all types of people from pros to musicians to younger and older to audiophile to average person try to define Flac/Wav vs mp3/opus/aac/oogVorbis. \n\nFor me, specifically hihats and cymbals tend to lose that shimmery sound. That is normally the giveaway.\n\nCould it be that older folks with their hearing slowly getting more and more low passy might have a harder time identifying format? \n\nIf that is true there would likely be a peak where someone's ear is trained more and they still have not had that decline start. Something like a sports player with the experience and joints all still intact...","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCrMg-jKzupK35LwGmZxN7kA","author":"@MaxUgly","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m6uvL6_P7CFlkDjxK8h05LglnY-MneRuOkiOUX4AU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MaxUgly","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg.ACvLL7z7qdrACyPnKkFsGx","parent":"UgzXH9vsXVIoU5R9SN54AaABAg","text":"Perhaps the problem is not the bitrate, but the encoder.  The encoder has A LOT of influence on how efficiently those bits are used.  Back in the tail end of the 90s, when I first started ripping my CD library to MP3, I found a very fast and convenient encoder.  It also sounded like complete garbage at 320kbps.  Ever since then, I've used LAME, and picked settings that prioritize quality over encoding speed (since I'm almost always going to encode once, in the background, and listen many times later.)\n\nLikewise, for years, the best readily available AAC encoder was iTunes.  I'm not sure where FAAC is these days, and I might have to run some comparisons since it has been a really long time since I've done any.  I would love to have conveniently scriptable workflows, but if I have to sit there and input data into a GUI for a little better audio quality, I'll continue to do it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2_CUBUUGhvSRkToFleO8RQ","author":"@sirnickity","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kRTLUpuGK1JTmdia6bniyUWjHsP3rg80IgpGCgsBpHLKs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sirnickity","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz4DiKQjcC9F9Y89J14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Tremendous work. I started convincing my pals to cancel their Spotify subscription just by sharing your videos with them. :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWsK8eMs5R7ABXo7n6SLbuw","author":"@orphic-trench","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/j8pxxymLm5QaokZcaUBIA_8ecrw57U13Gw0r7pbJmGrlYPLCfMSwx82DSm-B2gyvHUB6jxj1=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@orphic-trench","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxre09iA9lNxD4CYG54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Really amazing video. Been searching for a channel with data analysis & research about music for a while!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYZObvbgaR1cPf6ngUkhbVg","author":"@juangodfrid7386","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nBGVr_79mRWUvywno4jUd1ICP3sBNuThtLGq2t584eJy0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@juangodfrid7386","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bandcamp?","like_count":30,"author_id":"UCLcyG6ZlGSX3pQyoInxqQ3w","author":"@bjornark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mJ-HSiMcabuK9SrFIccfU78L9ta9ex_2nvKvHsBcpTvUY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bjornark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg.ACvNpVAYzE-ACvVCJbc3gV","parent":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg","text":"That's what I thought too but bandcamp isn't really a  \"streaming\" site.","like_count":20,"author_id":"UCyieBAE_6WQXidyXdDP9ENA","author":"@ihaveagoddamnplanarthur","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SRx8jE9W5_6CJeqgenO4vf_Gqljp2rLJTPmFF4ZIr7Rjp-SZsXCQsLF4ThqV_vzbz5fvMf4eag=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ihaveagoddamnplanarthur","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg.ACvNpVAYzE-ACvoDz4A_fc","parent":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg","text":"Bandcamp actually doesn't pay at all for streams. Only if and when music is purchased.","like_count":14,"author_id":"UCTkG7MxvErKA4mGVEg6i7kg","author":"@davidpeck","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Jopuj5os12FQ_SVX22EynvjlmNdPFJWefdRhNxRIjmSIcF-Raf14SbA7bkcppvRi7hdI-73YoQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@davidpeck","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg.ACvNpVAYzE-ACvqWEu0YLy","parent":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg","text":"as of i think something like tidal or some obscure streaming platform like the one by virgin mobile, or, idk, a chinese one.\n\nthe problem with nicher streaming plats is that fewer ppl will be listening anyway so i dunno xp","like_count":0,"author_id":"UComrvPzUcPQ6RpZUIlwoi4Q","author":"@klovexthewolf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YvXEmaHTS7J1JTGR8UMzDyQeEKGv54gGqR23Gzgusa8_6kGCcsoI14dxiP00FgSYdQl7bfqAIA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@klovexthewolf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg.ACvNpVAYzE-ACwgfJhpCvw","parent":"Ugw8soMbs3Yl_4HlM894AaABAg","text":"NO . UDIO and Neon lights","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw0hyAG8pduO3Mh0Tx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Suno's V4 model has a distinct and consistent kinda rattling laser sound artifact that appears all the time. It's very slightly noticeable on V3.5 but very obvious in 4 so it seems their model is converging on it. I'm curious if that's what's being picked up that got your detection rate to 100%.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCQMoeE-7VsbOEpHflU8FohA","author":"@HuntersHunter","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lIbyKRgznIKtyy-S1FiXrE5s29el3MsKn3roTorR1ciw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HuntersHunter","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw0hyAG8pduO3Mh0Tx4AaABAg.ACwDnbKszq2ACwVYd9hOgq","parent":"Ugw0hyAG8pduO3Mh0Tx4AaABAg","text":"Suno calls it a \"shimmer.\" I think more prevalent in 3.5 than 4, but just an opinion.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCXDSSnJYVT7tQDNAUvSQx9A","author":"@ordinalkirk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_naxQhDGSsGibHzsC8LerBKzJ2MROwIyE0wSYzPV1fE-pE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ordinalkirk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw0hyAG8pduO3Mh0Tx4AaABAg.ACwDnbKszq2ACyGw1K5MBD","parent":"Ugw0hyAG8pduO3Mh0Tx4AaABAg","text":"Modern pop artists will probably start adding the \"shimmer\" to their songs to please the stuffed ears of \"pop listeners\". A bit like what happened with autotune, which is now the mark of a real pro singer instead of being perceived as cheating.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC8KHVmQPvJJ3sQySF1H_FbA","author":"@IlBiggo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wNF4x7KCT9lBNvnYYA0Qi_b0qEOWULY6CUsHajRxsBeiPYRINqIu9-zg0F_rhzqtQGeuZILbK78=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IlBiggo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0yeJVpw3HbHKHOFp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your videos are refreshing in their quality and depth. Keep going.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCO7HJz7UIpZ4p5x2MXcdxCg","author":"@jlachman381","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nkBDl_QQQfqLsp9XMx8ooI4Nuu7VdjBG9o6npXG_evx7g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jlachman381","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx3qjR8kB9Rh9icqMR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is extremely useful work with lots of applications for a pretty niche field of hobbyists and artists compared to the numbers and views you could pull from chasing a more viral topic with your interests. Thank you for shining a light on how AI has been shaping the monetization of music for artists and people who actually care about the work that goes into music. Even though I only produce music as a hobby its so annoying how people who have a true passion for creating new music can have their work undone by some kid with a keyboard and a subscription fee, built off the backs of thousands of years of artists with visions for their art rather than a chat input.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkqVlu8jjKsY9bPXP3tlN0Q","author":"@canoodlepoodle7892","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NDmGZQs0nZaLAVJyJOtpe5PitzL4ZxjICb6bC3_BFvNXSspEut6rSS_5NgEdiTbrvKkyZEYqWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@canoodlepoodle7892","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxutKDsMNME5tkDmHx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"between your video and GamersNexus's commentary today about recent AI news (eg social media companies standing up their own AI bots), I have to say I have not felt more bleak abt the future of AI. humanity trapped paying for endless gray slop created on ever-thinning margins for - being extremely honest - the sole purpose of preserving the egos of the most incompetent, cowardly, and unimaginative corporate management teams in history.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UC4mAKnBkRrd8KHpPit1eZVA","author":"@raptros_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kcv2mMFIeBA_LPNiSn_-4owWawBySgybqFPfDUh6eAh59GY1R0DOr5vIlKZSm6872asOdqSLVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raptros_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You know, . . . I just grab a musical instrument, any instrument, and just start playing.   The business of business and the highly-processed product consumption . . . just makes me ill.   Hang out with friends, man.  Tune in to the stories and rhythms that are happening with each other right now.   It's so much richer to be alive than yanked along by faraway sound-hook factories.","like_count":96,"author_id":"UCNefpLJUwk9L9DpVnPI8gxg","author":"@ColbyAzimuth","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5t6Yuu8mlVC6sf-mFg0FZ77QkK96peNCy26qd4V4NNLom_D8SQNlzrbWQj_YaqgtYPED9LaKVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ColbyAzimuth","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg.ACx1MDM0NAEACx46_YlJ-M","parent":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg","text":"I use my physical guitar to play \"music\" to my cat. Never been copyright stroke once! But it doesn't put food on my table.","like_count":11,"author_id":"UC5PC8a38XoSnPwTiV2fC4Ew","author":"@emanuellandeholm5657","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sNyHeq_XIrPTccmA3zsaxRTst90R6gp4E8attuAaEvLoahBZnKH8sKERB8R4vfe9yUR3pQmTVRs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@emanuellandeholm5657","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg.ACx1MDM0NAEAD30_TIie1D","parent":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg","text":"Thanks dad that’s super helpful","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCPfQMCgyFqTE7U3LQBiG7rw","author":"@Cowboydjrobot","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xTxG1WhBa2JpiDjEACgUr58tX7Kfw_UJddxkTkwP0j4kzuASbRzs-Yvmgg8qZpbf2wW-pD5mOA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cowboydjrobot","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg.ACx1MDM0NAEACx9K8OfS7G","parent":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg","text":"I really like this. But also some people fell in love with the recording arts. Hi Fi gear. Preamps. Tweaking knobs. Finding mic positions. \nLost in time like tears in the rain...","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCNvi96YJc62Uh3r_mrbw8vA","author":"@suitestheband","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/d1GcWDcYjpXY-wapPp7fuCgY7LJKt44u6rL9JaO9e_XTUKPS9VFqrK_1UznRuxtkyKNg_neDFA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@suitestheband","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg.ACx1MDM0NAEACx3-0n2RCe","parent":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg","text":"You mean anyone can just sing or play music whenever they feel like it?  Is that allowed?  😂😂","like_count":26,"author_id":"UCa_oN7M2B96cOJlXMbMNz7Q","author":"@SharTheo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ln-9HYXgytSDFQbDRDb_rgH6bzytH6hE2dknWeVZrk6K8go1x19Eeds3jB779sjKtoDw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SharTheo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg.ACx1MDM0NAEACzbeB7bu4b","parent":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg","text":"Oof. Hard disagree. The amount of enjoyment i get from producing art depends heavily on whether or not others are enjoying it. If im not inspiring somebody or bringing somebody happiness with my art, then im failing as an artist. Mind you, there’s nothing wrong with your motive for art either! Im just so tired of listening to this stale ArT mAn take that insists art has to be some kind of masturbatory practice in order for it to be authentic or real.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UC8S5QZeDi1qE2durE5MnpLw","author":"@lamBOwheel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oZgFRpNfYX9dzxIQ1L9uwaCOZUScaIsb-93awKok1esnO0R0_PfbPj3LhbfhGtq9dYk1GrVLZQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lamBOwheel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg.ACx1MDM0NAEAD40qjGlpUu","parent":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg","text":"Why are there so many extra spaces between words and ellipses in your comment?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCu0Ctn8tZyIT7-WX_FMcGyw","author":"@TheHonestPeanut","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vRIv3XVsqUNZz4tHKvmiQNAmz0-nwiC8z2Qk9xDp-EzG3RlN4HAK1nj2T7WJOLk6hZ6u8wdkMsY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheHonestPeanut","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg.ACx1MDM0NAEACyUAhvgUic","parent":"UgysPlGjHRgoVx55Nu14AaABAg","text":"Not all of us can be an extroverted “people person” who wants to collaborate with other humans. I play real guitars and I’ve played in bands. I currently spend most of my free time designing and building my own custom instruments out of wood and metal. Mostly with my hands. I’ll get something cut by laser or CNC if it makes sense and I’ll use samples generated by AI if it makes sense. I get a lot of joy from the things I create on my own, on my computer while not having to depend on other people or compromise my art by letting others determine what it should do or whether it’s good enough. Nobody gets to tell me that my music is any less valid than the next guy’s. If you don’t like it, don’t listen to it.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCaXiMzwkWVJiBJupvoFjySw","author":"@micah_noel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DfYdDtdxz1JF9-0DHyq5QROTJJ0uq-vd9qH2AZxIZ_EsXqOTLi3PZ3YaNttOwWZyEKNYKKynHQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@micah_noel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz8tdxncKsz6CO_lLV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:37 an artists own website. There I solved it 😅","like_count":15,"author_id":"UCNdi-elNF4Rv3V3dIT1g60A","author":"@BenCaesar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h2nZkydXC5wmrMolx3eCda7CpLvubGcvKTkIzWPXRfNBrAiPSrCdm4rfXlSWIwyeT79U7mp3LA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BenCaesar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz8tdxncKsz6CO_lLV4AaABAg.ACvYqs1mwhFACxadtN6Fej","parent":"Ugz8tdxncKsz6CO_lLV4AaABAg","text":"Except that far fewer people are going to spontaneously discover and listen to that music. \nAnd the artist won't be able to make revenue from advertising, since they're a little website probably won't have any advertisers. \nAnd it's harder to get people to subscribe through a website than getting them to subscribe to a huge music service.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC7kxsMZ9F8rvUx5b8QN9LAQ","author":"@KAZVorpal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nWhV7P_JZ8AyaluTf1PYzG1QlK_ZITNpExuyelUI-kC2Jp=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KAZVorpal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz8tdxncKsz6CO_lLV4AaABAg.ACvYqs1mwhFACxrY4TIB4_","parent":"Ugz8tdxncKsz6CO_lLV4AaABAg","text":"Yes all true man discoverability is more work when you’re directing your own traffic. \nBut the return is higher, that was kinda my point.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNdi-elNF4Rv3V3dIT1g60A","author":"@BenCaesar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h2nZkydXC5wmrMolx3eCda7CpLvubGcvKTkIzWPXRfNBrAiPSrCdm4rfXlSWIwyeT79U7mp3LA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BenCaesar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzLJex8-kM0PO22XVl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Insanely creative video concept on this episode. Legend!!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6qsaJYHDcibnhMRUPRY82A","author":"@jonokerr5094","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0Sn2vyIVEv7Gtw2_XvawzJ8lWnYCzsPnFo7yQsvXGxqEK6PLKdQFvsz3saHdIPVVn3SXHB0rHQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jonokerr5094","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugys2DTU5z4cMtwdIJt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've seen some of your videos before, but it wasn't until I saw your \"drop\" video with Mr. Bill today that I learned you're also The Flashbulb, and I've been listening to your music for years!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyvy2qkFcyCRtWgs5mAwIww","author":"@michaelroy6630","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k1ANeV498kC7PrN7HzD6uzW51KOl1jTc9yvplU_W0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelroy6630","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwGRtmG4sfQkoaTDmN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wait go back the song at 10:38 ripped","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCQ0odvySWdvHJGIvypiFOSQ","author":"@JacobAndrsn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1v4-YA32es2By3sthqmD7H0biq_QsMvSf2mHH5Ufedac35fOeE45xjHExnykalp7qBYf0P4-qw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JacobAndrsn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwGRtmG4sfQkoaTDmN4AaABAg.ACvQAwUkzVVACveQbNGLBn","parent":"UgwGRtmG4sfQkoaTDmN4AaABAg","text":"What's the title??? 😭😭😭","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5IMhGtNVgzrYthpDi2voqg","author":"@TheMagnificentRaft","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mD6juxqf1RoWH0UpZx7kpvUdZCVnFrv_qgiRnjksuEHhY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheMagnificentRaft","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwZZwLnlN7qRe_jLOV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is, quite simply, the BEST video on the topic of.... wait, what was the topic again?","like_count":5,"author_id":"UC6BWO4JfxBFSSf41dtF8hqg","author":"@PeteJohnsStudioLiveToday","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/F1QaFwlpc9IRcCHtbcgXGbny4Bh40q-0NWEBYWBvCUV6hXMUVOuttpnbvhMGRpDtLT87JOOkoiE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PeteJohnsStudioLiveToday","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwZZwLnlN7qRe_jLOV4AaABAg.AD2lWTmYSNrAD3-UvMfRbx","parent":"UgwZZwLnlN7qRe_jLOV4AaABAg","text":"detecting AI music\n\nnot that I care, I make it","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCjp124CnTPrHSOxjZ5dZ8fA","author":"@through-faith-alone","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Kww-jIflCM2205hXGdKOfblWdsw_ExLR9Ky14S-7F2fHGZ7aUxXAlAbI_-bEFz1M6cIUQO7Qdw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@through-faith-alone","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwTCyppVTl97lcTj-V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think a really sharp reminder of how poorly streaming services pay was revealed by Polyphia. Their main source of revenue is now through selling the tabs to their songs since they understand a large percentage of their audience are guitarists interested in playing their songs. I can't even imagine how far behind I would be in my musical journey if the tabs for say, Rust in Peace or City of Evil were locked behind paywalls. I'm not even blaming Polyphia, I would do the exact same, since we all need to eat at the end of the day. But the effects of bad practises by streaming services are profoundly impacting every aspect of music.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCossoD8v-d7ieiutgEi6jvA","author":"@cybervillians","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GpleZs3NhY6XWO9HFHmXVvwFNkHoAvq2p6LL9nVRSIbbPR5lStFYnlMkvP_FUS_MNfB6YzhSUVY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cybervillians","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwhqRWxOxMxF0mOkId4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for both those playlists. Those are a few less \"artists\" that can pop up randomly in any song suggestions.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCw5n8rWTDiGbfF0QaIwTiGQ","author":"@Akkordinator","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nPKXocBjIwnTiLtfzvaUf1ah6VFralOUnHEIL9acKD=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Akkordinator","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzkL7KCNUfBdw0rybV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As always, an amazing video, really well researched and put together 🙌🏻","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3OCFTUfbrlJfdxj2JlhL2Q","author":"@richeymcc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n-Nn2FuKNP8-UOWfL6qDYeH0Vyc8c0ZN3z2heWt-jO02U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@richeymcc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0Fty7RrNSyVVHVll4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The question of which service pays artists the most per stream, is a nonsense distraction. \nIt ignores that the revenue of the artist has more to do with which service will spontaneously increase their listenership, \nmore than the hard number that is paid.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UC7kxsMZ9F8rvUx5b8QN9LAQ","author":"@KAZVorpal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nWhV7P_JZ8AyaluTf1PYzG1QlK_ZITNpExuyelUI-kC2Jp=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KAZVorpal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0Fty7RrNSyVVHVll4AaABAg.ACxaOxrCsunACzckg7Cbu9","parent":"Ugz0Fty7RrNSyVVHVll4AaABAg","text":"this. i dont give a rats ass about the per-stream revenue. All i care about is the algorithm.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC8S5QZeDi1qE2durE5MnpLw","author":"@lamBOwheel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oZgFRpNfYX9dzxIQ1L9uwaCOZUScaIsb-93awKok1esnO0R0_PfbPj3LhbfhGtq9dYk1GrVLZQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lamBOwheel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgypB-KYZ41R951erzt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Music : \" our brains are collecting pressure waves and then passing  them through latent inhibition...\"","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCMsU-wbmRfOuF-zEtB8AIWQ","author":"@smkh2890","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nWBvzeo1pDd9LbR3QCwrcv3_s18FVLZTtgk9s730xj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@smkh2890","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgypB-KYZ41R951erzt4AaABAg.ACvR-QBfYTeACwgcN5OZDq","parent":"UgypB-KYZ41R951erzt4AaABAg","text":"NEON LIGHTS","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLqCI3oVV-cc_Ubh54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Disappointed in many of the comments on this video. Where is the beauty in buying creativity from a company of thousands of engineers rather than cultivating it on our own? No one can convince me that I'd be better off with this garbage product than with my own hands. I don't care if I don't produce anything worthwhile, at least it's me producing it and not some amalgamation of stolen material.","like_count":34,"author_id":"UCKWULQdIzBJKADivNg8H08g","author":"@ericd.9038","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lW_zdZvI8XaHwQLrKe5gnhnX8RRwaI5tOH8gf4hXYi4Wo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ericd.9038","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLqCI3oVV-cc_Ubh54AaABAg.AD6ILDmd0tvAK3ojdDcpvM","parent":"UgwLqCI3oVV-cc_Ubh54AaABAg","text":"I think people forgot that making art is fun and fulfilling, and that the process of making it teaches you and often shapes you as a person, that it's not just about the result. genAI spits out a final product, for cynical people who only see art as the final product. It's a soulless and corporate view of a form of creative expression that has existed since the start of humanity...","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCskHALBFIRsx2ElO3q3Ac4w","author":"@user-oh6uw9mu9u","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nP-uyJTy9LJUhx9RUjjQD31p_mmzagFZ1hgPsXzCnBS6U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@user-oh6uw9mu9u","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLqCI3oVV-cc_Ubh54AaABAg.AD6ILDmd0tvADSkkFZCKdp","parent":"UgwLqCI3oVV-cc_Ubh54AaABAg","text":"Think of it this way. If you, like me, have shared a talent (musical or not) with another person, you might have received a comment like, \"That's so cool! I wish I could do that/I always sucked at that/I'm not smart enough to do that/etc.\"\n\nThese people usually genuinely believe these limitations are something we were able to surpass via a stroke of fate or a blessing of some sort, or that these limitations are simply given only to some people and are not surmountable. Alternatively they're self aware enough to know that with practice they could probably get to our skill level, too.\n\nAnd the biggest thing to remember is that that desire is legitimate and often even stronger than you'd first think. But many obstacles stand in the way and they're many of the same ones we all start with when learning a new skill: fear, lack of energy, lack of willpower/ability to care enough, low self-confidence, sacrificing time, spending money, and others for certain.\n\nBut what if you could hack off a lot of those obstacles? Well, what if the odds of winning the lottery were suddenly raised by 10,000%? A lot more people would win the jackpot.\n\nFrom there, it becomes a matter of values and ethics. Artists value artists. Not everybody, though, values artists, or at least values them enough to have those strong ethics that give the person the desire or willpower to refrain from using things like generative AI, pirating independent artists' music and small artists' art/films/writing/games/etc.\n\nThese tools are truly appealing to many people. So what gives a person reason to choose NOT to use them, let alone advocate against them? As a society we don't generally respect artists the way we should. This is evident enough in the art/media industries/economies.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCQnYCp9szVyVgSzySBdUTiA","author":"@saltiestsiren","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-sb1bn24G7uBeIIiSjcw6y0xAx6HulnIbjEjI1S6XL2AuXJDUF8MXD9avpKYy847kzp9o2BE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@saltiestsiren","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxrx5cmb-gU0xDS9Qp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Finally someone who can spot this fake Audios online. But i still believe if you get the mp3 file and put it on a DAW and export it again as a WAV by just applying a minimal change it won't be detected.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCSAszAhdBZjojAyJvfuHdQQ","author":"@henokdemiss7541","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ngIYhiGgZLBkG8iML34Pbjw3e-0BtM-6VXr_guf6qVETg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@henokdemiss7541","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzlzhJcuvJcOv2AuyJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I will be sharing this video with everyone, Benn always bringing the important information","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBVg9ma3UZ0y93aQOOUX-CQ","author":"@thomaskinsey3424","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMY-gTWMXdAEoSORu9T0Ru0AELqS1buWCv-Ppu1C4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thomaskinsey3424","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJl2ukAcbslhTfEqB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:31 I feel I need to make sure that you know that 90% of the information is not gone. The phrase \"11 Qs\" is only four letters long, and QQQQQQQQQQ is 11 letters long, but they convey the exact same thing. 63.64% of the information isn't \"missing\" it is just stored more efficiently. Of course, that's not an exactly perfect analogy when talking about lossy compression, but I think it illustrates well the misleading nature of your statement.","like_count":12,"author_id":"UCRSmsMjaxee7hAMfoNl_lAA","author":"@myownbiggestfan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nH30kjuK3mf_n1gxYV7DaV6YX4hohJSyHz9rmfgd3MIZI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@myownbiggestfan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJl2ukAcbslhTfEqB4AaABAg.ACwSX2uNz7fACyNqqT9dLd","parent":"UgwJl2ukAcbslhTfEqB4AaABAg","text":"Lossless compression isn't just about storage efficiency.  That would be something like the Deflate algorithm, which does something similar to your \"Qs\" analogy.  Audio compression is a little more like substituting Qs with Os, assuming that most of the time you're not going to miss the tail; and similar with zeroes, or with ! and i and l and | ... and then using fewer bits to encode the reduced number of discrete glyphs.  ANO YOV CAN ST1LL REAO 1T JUST F1NE.\n\nIf you're not looking closely, and the context is sufficient, your brain will probably pass right over the \"OCR errors\" and nothing will be missed.  That's not simply storage efficiency, it's exploiting our lack of ability to notice fine detail in passing.\n\nHowever, the encoding is actually very efficient as well, so storage efficiency does play a part.  It's just not the primary reason the ratio can be that high.\n\nOn a related note:  I once did some comparisons between compressed audio and the digital source, by inverting one and mixing them together to derive the delta.  It was a bit tricky because of timing and phase relationships, but ultimately the difference is not as much as you would think.  This is the basis for codecs like DTS HD, which use a heavily compressed original DTS \"core\" stream that is backward-compatible with older DTS decoders, plus the difference encoded in an extended stream that DTS HD decoders can understand.  It's really clever.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UC2_CUBUUGhvSRkToFleO8RQ","author":"@sirnickity","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kRTLUpuGK1JTmdia6bniyUWjHsP3rg80IgpGCgsBpHLKs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sirnickity","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJl2ukAcbslhTfEqB4AaABAg.ACwSX2uNz7fACyZBlsp6iH","parent":"UgwJl2ukAcbslhTfEqB4AaABAg","text":"That is runlength compression, a different type of compression than psychoacoustic used in audio files","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCysl8JOcahGGHtgp7M4lvXQ","author":"@mattsephton","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mOD0b5iMA06ImXwpCKvyToTKOscNpPMiih69Z1DUVCtLtF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mattsephton","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy4yUXR28qXNf3GaMB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Regarding your AI music detector: You seem to emphasize the difference between music that is created with AI being low res (128kbps) while many human songs are available in lossless formaat. Are all samples in the same quality (128kbps)? Otherwise, what you have essentially created is not an AI music detector but a fairly trivial quality discriminator. I think there's a significant difference between the two.","like_count":17,"author_id":"UCU1IdyKvw9cs01xWzdVoh4Q","author":"@ColorfullHD","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kK7_Ry2d9x1qUQdD3KVZ1UmmnJ9_B5vT3WkR3K6zxnAenU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ColorfullHD","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy4yUXR28qXNf3GaMB4AaABAg.AD4KomvNsNmADbF1jLyU6R","parent":"Ugy4yUXR28qXNf3GaMB4AaABAg","text":"It’s not looking for the quality of the music. It’s looking for artifacts of compression in higher quality audio. Basically, since the vast majority of streaming services provide compressed audio, the AI models think that most music should sound like it’s been compressed, even when it’s generating audio of higher quality. If you can detect this misplaced or ‘wrong’ compression, you can detect AI generated audio. \n\nAs a sidenote, you can do the exact same thing with AI generated images, looking for jpeg compression in PNGs, etc.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UC9ex9b0uO8UaW-aAJP6Pezg","author":"@manavali92","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mrLVh0pojqcxPi8CgIt8_nowVAUJ29tZCFtW2nmxa8Pa4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@manavali92","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxxLsnY9lKBbrY3Z-B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"At 14:00 you give numbers that are 10-100x smaller than the numbers you show on screen (eg \"point zero zero zero zero five dollars\", so 0.00005, but the graphic shows 0.005) which one is the error?","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCUuLUm-oiQxEM3unWUf4TSA","author":"@GaviLazan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5sH0Qhm5PpNvkL3fJ-p1SJaahJISOLEbEalIGGmu27_xes-0ndSr0emwnGdAHpKLDSrK73kB=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GaviLazan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxxLsnY9lKBbrY3Z-B4AaABAg.ACzrK3jvAgEAD1AtRoqn6f","parent":"UgxxLsnY9lKBbrY3Z-B4AaABAg","text":"hes talking in dollars but the slide is in cents so two of the zeros get chopped off. so neither are technically incorrect but it is confusing to look at for sure, probably an editing oversight.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCSb2Maf5uj-Gp7d4Wbv4IGw","author":"@the_sidious","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GbUHitLRhVqPPRVSB76PT7EAborDwqNgPRYVRj83d9AxUsXPj_THxJxi-ix_k8hQzdbdb3iCsA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@the_sidious","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxxLsnY9lKBbrY3Z-B4AaABAg.ACzrK3jvAgEAD-U71j8MIe","parent":"UgxxLsnY9lKBbrY3Z-B4AaABAg","text":"I'm pretty sure the correct number is the one he read, as he mentions they are all lower than the streaming platform revenues. Still... WTH is with this slide?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCxH-o1BpgiADwX-z80S1MlA","author":"@nachot6592","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3c6dJ2v1RO6ySXYiC0Jm9eSozRKpdEWNYe53jMtsY56Kj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nachot6592","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxxLsnY9lKBbrY3Z-B4AaABAg.ACzrK3jvAgEAQA3OIOqg34","parent":"UgxxLsnY9lKBbrY3Z-B4AaABAg","text":"Was looking for this comment. Confused me too, but good points in here.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIuwDEphHFT-6x8pGfNKsww","author":"@LabGecko","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RjQNFuzhWiVdu07qvNw04E2frps15BQTIVTqpjx49hlep_0aOEbOOn2ywK2n_kFwtu_vYQfmu88=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LabGecko","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxNIjJS50K8PprzMZh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The colour grading on this is crazy","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCoGIjzfnRX2Zh11PEEiEnIA","author":"@educacionespecialchannel3756","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7OI-Z1ynzgBv7FGcvEBs-n9q9gftbVbMnbP0SBD6AShyVHSAL8iOQWIfWZtICpQqQ7RWIEPFSA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@educacionespecialchannel3756","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyHoROIQPE7nFHOCXN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This would have been the reason I started collecting CDs if I hadn't already done so in 2023 due to the general enshittification of music streaming. So much awesome stuff has been released on CD, and still is.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCtermqri3qN9Xv2fOwfp4qg","author":"@lukasegeling5205","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsnQ_Hehe4pJA_E9jCKXLZrxzARUg2YLH75MotTc8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lukasegeling5205","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxUy6hO1ZaL60EXfnZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:30 Im going to guess at Soundcloud.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCnICuM7nFg7rTZBhc_Hrx6Q","author":"@DoubleSlashCJ","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oqaQL8MEw3ErPd0PXDTLKhCncC1IdtJdT7KVMJ5e3CtHbmi8-Mcw1A8dgSlj9vJqsDeQocLe0Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DoubleSlashCJ","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9T4OdGK4u723Zbqd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm surprised that there is no soundcloud on the list.","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCSa_1g8ta4u07hQwMQdVLrQ","author":"@JazJazgot","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Dr5X2nj_NwfMlgQK4kT5dAHpJwGStiJ1zTkes68m25z7cXFNkEXzMwhXNlAw9llvzEBhs8SY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JazJazgot","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9T4OdGK4u723Zbqd4AaABAg.ACvVatCrVyhACvezrBAJg-","parent":"Ugz9T4OdGK4u723Zbqd4AaABAg","text":"Yeah was waiting for that, cause im planning to use it since they are one of the very few with user centric model and i dont wanna support pro-rata.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtrva1CJnKSC_c1pTnv5AUw","author":"@johncombo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l8eo8-U6Hq182HvGSivhWsfhg3pOCinNGPXomA3iYdj_2Aq9hR3pP-TUmOw-mA8K_Hzw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johncombo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9T4OdGK4u723Zbqd4AaABAg.ACvVatCrVyhACwghpsTvHS","parent":"Ugz9T4OdGK4u723Zbqd4AaABAg","text":"Not enough neon lights","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9eTcNAkTw7TffALV-WQGA","author":"@AMPProf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YXy6ARPka-n1F4Nwozl0oKwRW7lS-EnqMGvZYqShUU-N4jpcH6S869QD0fg7HRbMWs2MJp1lYW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AMPProf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzu6g9Q4ucDo11m9H54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So what if they start training their AI on lossless uncompressed files? This is still very good, but it's not future proof in the long run.","like_count":9,"author_id":"UC0c53-HeqcZdXGLCqo_1pag","author":"@deedee6761","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lVUqEC1XsS9ymhzi31G2Eww4mUeA4YDlQhRwS9dUN1AL0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@deedee6761","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzu6g9Q4ucDo11m9H54AaABAg.ACxybnKG7QKACyFaVohwPX","parent":"Ugzu6g9Q4ucDo11m9H54AaABAg","text":"Lossless uncompressed files of real music aren't free. Training an algorithm with millions of songs would be financially unbearable.","like_count":7,"author_id":"UC8KHVmQPvJJ3sQySF1H_FbA","author":"@IlBiggo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wNF4x7KCT9lBNvnYYA0Qi_b0qEOWULY6CUsHajRxsBeiPYRINqIu9-zg0F_rhzqtQGeuZILbK78=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IlBiggo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzu6g9Q4ucDo11m9H54AaABAg.ACxybnKG7QKAD0C_WeR-Qr","parent":"Ugzu6g9Q4ucDo11m9H54AaABAg","text":"Let's hope AI cloud power and storage limitations help prevent this for as long as is appropriate / ever","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCKFgPkX5dSHd6am2xIiFMYg","author":"@mrl4342","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrr-mYcTlaxHmfz1lgkgrL_ddzIYdWl52wrDdwTzQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mrl4342","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwHRaXja2NLqgBYgH54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Slowly becoming my favorite channel.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9eSvSgwyMDMY6ty6nbsDqQ","author":"@GuildOfCalamity","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LCeW9JGLOnsm-alVXOT6MwahqjmE7nMgU99aon-dbNs4BcpXaCJwlmXA9kh93Th6eMu18p-xVA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GuildOfCalamity","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzJCPBaA3a4idtxAPd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video. From now on I’ll be calling you Professor Doctor Jordan 😉","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCmwXYbVQuPEdfYaUwtP9yjQ","author":"@robbret","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kpzZq8FFFE9WuGCPDQ0_V9dzGK9rGzwxczM6S9qeyKqg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robbret","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxuVzAI8noNCWbEa854AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Also, how to spot the difference between an MP3 and uncompressed WAV. It's not a matter of detail or clarity, it's artifacts you need to listen for. The hiss of a cymbal retaining it's metallic sheen and not sounding washy. The echo, room noise, and reverb immediately following percussive sounds and how full it sounds and how big the room the instrument is in sounds. They are very subtle things but in those double blind tests you can get >80% accuracy picking the uncompressed audio if you listen for the artifacts.","like_count":10,"author_id":"UCFj2SgLPqRBAhk5vVangKiA","author":"@Kodack-ki2im","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n3Xx1mvCz_szHdpA0RIWCc5V_SU_8pU0mTDoG0t2ChO9BdC1UxtAQdNr99K6YVG_TEcg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Kodack-ki2im","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx71eDMbQZRsJyFO-V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about people who write their own lyrics, but use Ai to generate the music and vocals?","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCy7aF757jhij5mBUKYlMyaA","author":"@philjohnson725","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lBuoh7mSfxFUfBl44yJncsxpia3MSYBxi0TrrILBc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@philjohnson725","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy2v78UGlyIYoTPgOF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"at 14:04 the amount of zeros you say vs what is shown on screen is different. which is right?","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCB9nzU--v_LJzG597nUbe_A","author":"@RussellB","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kLCW-yudmkyiFpiNgIGSRkJ6be34VJPxEExPVJ4SMchdw9=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RussellB","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy2v78UGlyIYoTPgOF4AaABAg.ACvkkFHVPviACw7fCTcrTw","parent":"Ugy2v78UGlyIYoTPgOF4AaABAg","text":"The numbers shown are in ¢, but he says the equivalent number in $. That's why the zeros don't match. Confusing I know, but it's right both ways. Example Snapchat paid 0.01 ¢ (or 0.0001 $).","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCJz1GK1Y0bPSCLolxHMNotg","author":"@snizzhound","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pUSShnnmwSZbN8Z76lbF5G8mW7PL1lsrkAC-_a8_-ByQIX2fbGKAWJRKP7bhtMxfkB73Mgggeg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@snizzhound","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy2v78UGlyIYoTPgOF4AaABAg.ACvkkFHVPviACvyXv2YoT6","parent":"Ugy2v78UGlyIYoTPgOF4AaABAg","text":"Yeah, this is very confusing","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmlK0_Ln1nw6_E0HDm5BI9A","author":"@grabson8232","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lqCzqKaTUpt9uY0au3BLD2VcWLnmNMLauoJmmP9gra7ODQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@grabson8232","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynAr5wCZ5wGTKvlXh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You make this world a better place with your videos. Thank you! Ah, and greetings to your Pen is","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgsKTTLjTF-w_7QfOD00-aA","author":"@AngryIdentity-j2j","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xrK07GQ-uiJ9Z4HZKthF_juwB6IwIyyvzwwP2P34msek8xsXofj66xHnB9T2l_VCYKBjw_lFGA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AngryIdentity-j2j","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZOVAKUuy1A5KSm-V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're a gem, Benn. I appreciate you on a very human level.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIJ1-UDKopvSXB9aX3h6M5w","author":"@without_wax","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WENIr9J-jr3K5wsO6pwjO_is0t8BZPNgYh0UvsbYV11VP1K3j3kJ1BulOyDJ50Eq5y0psI8aeg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@without_wax","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxefJ8RQLmD9AiPwg94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"- Makes a tool to detect AI music\n- Doesnt use tool to detect AI music\n\nNice video","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCr2ZTLFRztmguSATBnUkLyw","author":"@Hodevine","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/je31YBZfZvaUtjJ_F05zXc_2i_NlCtO-Z1FSfhOQY8LFCta-hFjyc5De-QU9HGeDIW-gZoqKQg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Hodevine","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxefJ8RQLmD9AiPwg94AaABAg.ADBug5FlH-hADD0TXI7eL7","parent":"UgxefJ8RQLmD9AiPwg94AaABAg","text":"He clearly does lmao","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCiMbNHrSnd-qlUmE3QWE_VQ","author":"@PRLCKLY","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vMGtRhncG5xM3n6RHkhnnT0mtqjiENGPj_2MZhmhEs70DtkfTHsYK89G-qgZ5mFE2xSwZWRL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PRLCKLY","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw6dJfVWE5YTqokx2h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I hate mp3's and always will. It killed pure music quality. We had dozens of CD's uncompressed beautiful music and now we have gone in the opposite direction. Thank goodness we can now find music in FLAC but I  have to be aware of fake FLAC files as I have encountered a few as well as artists selling files as FLAC but the sounds they use to make music come from a crappy low quailty mp3 source(s).","like_count":3,"author_id":"UChEvCVUWI3MFBhYoznqME8Q","author":"@Bassotronics","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lj3lsZcQ1_MsED9gWuaViXPpkVP0R8WfLZkFSed97FigM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bassotronics","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKT4s2Vv5T2Rb-r554AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Lots of misinformation here, both Suno and Udio allow you to upload your own works (things you make in a DAW) to work with, you automatically assume that if it comes from either of those platform that it must then be uncopyrightable - this completely ignores things like first fixation if your wrote the melody in a DAW. You're painting with a very broad brush here and should be careful about that.","like_count":9,"author_id":"UCCPaBAdJNZqH-FBF7ifJIPg","author":"@ZyzyxVile","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kTEKQ0cPDVd_ROjzACQAo6sOanRZOKcfgtqA_nZwV3Z5c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ZyzyxVile","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzRdTwN9bPh3y8bkfh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're doing incredibly important work, keep up the good fight!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_17o3ojAvMnniwd8RhlGRQ","author":"@hpqphpqp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l6cUsHRs6bx3-ZQTI34qX1cHavh89HcX2smXnJP2qCEw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hpqphpqp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzb9EmVP2tui_H4_0B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Commenting to help you in the algorithm. I wish I had more to comment lol.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC5pje97T7GHE4tnJMSolFAg","author":"@SuperGameFan77","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1kzK7Er0UUkdMPbXOA2DdYhXaoqN3jkgj1RJmNKXrlJ4D3_0gr8P4j6p3mOuJBIEdmUCQ46vlQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SuperGameFan77","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQGvIElRA4IULZIUR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think this video overlooks one enormous factor: If an AI-generated song on Spotify receives so many plays, it is because people like listening to it (unless it's all bots). And in my world, if people enjoy it, then it is good. Who cares if it was made by AI or humans? Eventually AI will be making music that is so much better than any simpleton human can make. Also, any song made by a human is also literally a song that was made by something that has been trained on copyrighted music. Your brain is a learning model that has learned from all the copyrighted music you heard, and produces a \"new\" song based on it. This is no different than the AI generated music.","like_count":8,"author_id":"UCaJTmwA3Fsr1KkOAmbaAUVw","author":"@DanielSymphonies","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SZkkEMXH9l9SHRA6Ew15NOxGF1FBgl9GptmE6IAQeNMIWFFt-qQgaiRuRrBnwmQEnMLzDdFSkUU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DanielSymphonies","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQGvIElRA4IULZIUR4AaABAg.ADWGN-HjbI7ADWORv92Ytw","parent":"UgxQGvIElRA4IULZIUR4AaABAg","text":"The difference between a person's brain and the AI model is that the AI model legally can't create copyrightable work.\nAlmost nobody has an issue with high quality work, the problem is when that work is stolen, and the thief becomes the sole benefitor, trying to sell it and pass it off as their own.\nIf everything worked based on if people enjoy it = good, then copyright and ownership would fall apart in its entirety. You could spend hundreds of hours on your album and I can just copy it and spread it under a different name, so long as people enjoy it, then it's good, right?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgEtB8--Tmuln7tOL1bAFHw","author":"@translatedbird","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nfV2MRSauVtwFa-XQ9_TYq7pEeedUNZ_4l4T5OLNM_bA0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@translatedbird","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPBTxPQd46h4pfgHZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI didn't kill music. It was already dying, AI just finished the job.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCKnta05vBDTgJyeiltz6EKw","author":"@Joldrath","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mlCuoJn4yThXSY2r8-sNd__ecoqtnJpWOZOyyC2-Gsiic=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Joldrath","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgztRNK7fa_ORu_K6D94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Most everyday consumers of digital entertainment don’t care whether a piece is created by AI or a human. They simply want a song that resonates with them. Whichever song delivers that connection wins. People often forget that digital entertainment was originally meant to provide affordable, accessible content for the masses, and AI-generated, targeted songs are just the next step in that evolution. One song = one listener - this is the future. Meanwhile, another group of consumers seeks a deeper bond with an artist, going as far as paying $3,000 for concert tickets to experience a personal connection of a different kind. Digital entertainment is undergoing a seismic shift - one that many fail to see, distracted by fear, anxiety, and anger toward machine learning and AI. We will have no other option but to accept this reality because this is what the masses want. The best thing talented artists can do is to start educating themselves in machine learning or working with ML engineers on a new set of products that will deliver the connection I mentioned in the beginning on a more profound and much larger scale. You could also start touring and playing in clubs, where audiences will soon crave that genuine, real-world connection.","like_count":5,"author_id":"UCT5ZYIAuSoOhdpwtN5_K8uA","author":"@felisynth","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZariqWZN7KpJEI27thTGOO4CMyA6dDqG79YLT1mtIAm1TSYtOxOkHOfeO5DrVgAEFKdml4XpHA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@felisynth","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgztRNK7fa_ORu_K6D94AaABAg.AD0AnK62L6vAHAMrzJlOs7","parent":"UgztRNK7fa_ORu_K6D94AaABAg","text":"What a load of rubbish.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCir57M_TcAT0nmzrEkUa76w","author":"@johnny5Hobo7","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/riWJKV1gjUyz-79fcouu-GxU0hFsuKqOYiolUXx8PqyHb2a0yuzu8Vf3H_tf6KUIQ1uDc5INMA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johnny5Hobo7","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxAoR4CG4_xiXwZf9B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn your due diligence on this is amazing, thank you ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3AlWIUMf5ngKZle1dx3mew","author":"@chasestrader6475","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3EGFutKa1r1g4VsDZozj99dJDxChQNk4hZ5k8urjYDQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chasestrader6475","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwos0PVslHOHqc83B54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're awesome, research like this is incredibly eye opening, and concerning.Thank you for doing work like this.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKXNGwC1pd_wmoDUnxjgUhw","author":"@rystmusic1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nbUgFlz_2Dd2NQXRWYo2Yd92p-vf-EGsRmGmGg7P9WIpQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rystmusic1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxgdw2ruTTX1kc5utx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Not all AI music sounds \"fake\" or as crappy as many of you are making it out to be! There's this AI rap song that came up on my recommended page called \"My Hellcat Trippin\" by Piink Ivy and, I don't care what anybody says... I LOVE it! To me, it sounds like an actual rap song that I would hear on the radio. And this female AI artist's other songs sound good too. My point is, don't paint all AI music with the same \"it sounds like crappy AI music\" brush. I can have Latto, Nicki Minaj, Piink Ivy, Flo Milli and GloRilla on my Spotify playlist, and all that matters is that I LIKE listening to these artists - regardless of whether they are human or AI. If I like how vocals, bass and rhythm sound in a particular song, I'm THERE.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCYieAUQR-8Kj4k_JAiwWUeg","author":"@enchantingempressoflight","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bDmEeIzU8iEs84qnjq4oQmU32HSmIPelGBIAuD4pAEj1eOa8B1oZJm7LqflZVR2N1zwVyEzhwQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@enchantingempressoflight","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxgdw2ruTTX1kc5utx4AaABAg.AJsq26gcxqxAJxFIQDS7z1","parent":"Ugxgdw2ruTTX1kc5utx4AaABAg","text":"least obvious ragebait","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCh24MxXo-hfjIkNy20ZVtEw","author":"@rafs0uu","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mqtTk8EcuK3rQFoazmjPJAXHxpw97JurxlB6-odExaj3NIwlKAujiIp9388chSLO7cKj2tKD1g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rafs0uu","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKdJs1U6HZ9wPjCeN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think the point of all of this went over my head. Why are we trying to detect AI generated music and disparaging them?","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCKFlwqsi312C03Ygmv0yKAQ","author":"@MatthewSabia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2Of0NP26_DK-LI8f6SlI0WbWNJTjLiFCSYdqJyTAUukCgo0SDXfv03pLkYuslgxDsfpgjXyv=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MatthewSabia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKdJs1U6HZ9wPjCeN4AaABAg.ADEXpX6wmE9ADQYLKRl-VF","parent":"UgyKdJs1U6HZ9wPjCeN4AaABAg","text":"If you wanna listen to AI music, no one cares. Do what you want, you have free will. As a consumer, you are not responsible for supporting artists.\n\nBut if you want to know why, the people who care are the people who care about creativity, inspiration, and the human element of a song. A piece of art not only integrates the person’s own inspiration into the piece, but also their own unique life experiences and emotions translated into a medium the way they’ve learned is best. An AI simply looks at a database and replicates the patterns it sees, without any life experiences attached. The people who use AI to flood creative mediums are often unpassionate, uncreative husks who don’t care about art, but the profits from that art.\n\nThis is why we need to push toward a future where we can more easily differentiate between AI-generated content and real content. So the people who care will care, but the people who don’t won’t have to worry.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC74IsHiPNbUtgTWjucIsmKg","author":"@ginick","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BLNpc_NRNFSu-pXkORL9b0LmyiiLh-9mC6EZEzwE8mTuWjY9bs_1qlYH5ju8IMSrFvgGq1K8vA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ginick","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKdJs1U6HZ9wPjCeN4AaABAg.ADEXpX6wmE9ADG6eKs6hF5","parent":"UgyKdJs1U6HZ9wPjCeN4AaABAg","text":"Because they're delusional and petty. Those anti AI people, not the AI music.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCp7PdU5RnGk-bHH2-ECCOHQ","author":"@goldencookie5456","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOZnwmKO-Cn9DhjWmXLb1PK3L65GpyyU0NDzefj4PMMg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@goldencookie5456","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGTVfHafsSKiA5LjV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I write lyrics, and use AI to produce music, and you are saying I'm not an artist? wow. so rappers are not artists... what about all artists that you use recording band... not artists??? Imagine being that narrow minded in 2025.","like_count":6,"author_id":"UCtYzfSgX8ZGTXnOi8cj1HSA","author":"@JLDraco","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nKE-O7C5Z0VpmaQBX32aofpsyzEM1Ygl97DK2BcbbtiqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JLDraco","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGTVfHafsSKiA5LjV4AaABAg.AD0WEaBX4EyADASpf2GMgu","parent":"UgyGTVfHafsSKiA5LjV4AaABAg","text":"By definition, you didn't create the music; one just configured settings then a robot will make the effects on the song. Also how did rappers got involved?","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCSBtQno8-aP5crBw4Kgp4-g","author":"@D3sidero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VUPWwOFUTDBw1bnmApsfw0Ofha2GGAFTu_ouQDFd6rOfJFh_b2DKcnnFbKbLOFxTSc-VyYqL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@D3sidero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGTVfHafsSKiA5LjV4AaABAg.AD0WEaBX4EyAD2JjpSNNLm","parent":"UgyGTVfHafsSKiA5LjV4AaABAg","text":"👍","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC8_ct8SxKFpMC-BY1ReJ5tw","author":"@Ryanez93","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KCyo_b6XvGLbMaA9h-wrCcBUxq2wCUIieBBwVcwPrR4UOBdY9cp4EFUqCF8FGz-jZIURPvT_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ryanez93","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzEpin6ZutpuXXACDl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"WOW WOW WOW 2 minutes in and already the most important video of 2025","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCXn-jxml9VfSPdnuPfjwRtg","author":"@jorisvoorndj","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/AvB4BWZVNvcgGI7ZF0vZjjT3zllAGiIbpWWnLXVhHgJq8yYcgrsWzuK3BtgyQ6iDWvCGOIzo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jorisvoorndj","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwon9iJ_ePTq-CCR7Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is such an important video. Thank you. Such a public service to everyone in the music community.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmoa3gImU_rGNUC2eThMYHg","author":"@michaelkonomos","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kb39BxxQ_IjxMOnDGAio9t_PKwRevleK6WhUzoB3GBGfdrH18mnmKwefAoCFVB6Puob2UkvO1Hg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelkonomos","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7pSQHIq-grNeo4qx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI good.. Not bad  I'm a musician, and I also used to believe AI music is not music.... -- until I used it. On Suno, and other AI DAW's musicians like myself can upload their own riffs/songs/lyrics etc and Suno does an unbelievable job helping you produce YOUR original music. It duplicates your voice / instrument input really well when you upload your tracks.  The possibilities are amazing for low budget/high quality original music combined with a non AI DAW (for now). Better than working with a human producer.  All music will have % of AI input/production within the next year guaranteed.  Original music production on Suno is a growing trend, and there will more tools coming for music production to make it even better for original work and the idea of \"detecting\" AI music is about to be a moot point very soon. Society is about to get used to AI everything and a good song will be just that, no matter what part of the cosmos it was summoned from.  \n Complaining about AI music production is tantamount to calling a digital picture not an actual photo if not produced in a dark room, or what about that electric keyboard pretending to be a grand piano?  AI is just another tool allowing creative people to be free.  It's glorious!","like_count":7,"author_id":"UCfi9xZeWuoXjEfedGCuVlZA","author":"@ferrisbuellersdayoff","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mrwoLVQhk3RkiBMCFvRso1PLWjkTYzR7lRj8q_9UmgbQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ferrisbuellersdayoff","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKxvZ2P-BFJnH-AMN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"TL:DW; Dude claims to have done something interesting to detect AI songs but then spends the entire video not doing that and instead drones on and on about money. Complete waste of time.","like_count":4,"author_id":"UCVgIMv3PNAAsIgFZcM3MgLQ","author":"@boltvanderhuge8711","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n9exunGz-6UseCibXrME1K-LGQENrLJU2-n1fApESRCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@boltvanderhuge8711","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxtwHhU4UYqxo4P8NN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Brilliant video. Keep up the good work, big fan of work like this.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCL-Mu6hcjTr9GOQX8JriUwQ","author":"@edtalktech","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mlEnA_CYn0rV_-6H-O6JC0kGdGAGuGYECltlo0LZHcLZnMN_xr6jbqVUURpcF0dDIR5g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@edtalktech","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPcDZu2QNrQP2xfbR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi Benn, first time caller. Massive fan of your content, just wanted to thank you for the hard work you're doing and all the information and wisdom you're sharing with the world at no cost. Like you, I've co-founded a company offering a protection platform for artists and content creators to prevent their music from being used to train AI in addition to other forms of theft. We aim for a full release this year, and we're currently seeking artists to participate in our pilot programme to get feedback to help improve the service. We'll also be incorporating an ongoing robustness challenge where if users can reduce our recognition to 0.0% we'll give them a month free as we incorporate the improvements for the benefit of us all. I, like many artists, am terrified of a world where AI tribute acts ape our favorite musicians and real players can't earn a buck. Keep fighting the good fight, brother.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8bczXyelTguc8sfApW_dWQ","author":"@Charis-ul2xh","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lXlZa6bWYvq__DPTiGtezb14Y42buZ68sv0DoHJ9M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Charis-ul2xh","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwc04IR1GCmzGsYSiR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi Benn. I've been sitting here watching your catalog and asking myself ... what can we do about these problems? Hearing that there are groups taking notice of what you're doing and actively moving to resolve the issues you're bringing to light is the answer I was looking for. Thank you for what you do.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCY35ZLVitGn3HWCX8L-ahlA","author":"@DJFariel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lFZKBt3IgRNnQQagDAa0Klf_wUk8njIU6AcB58FcM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DJFariel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyCXeAFZIOhLFJ5wwx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Interesting work. Thanks for taking the time and trouble.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCg9nVhVYQ2bp9h6BE5MWpTQ","author":"@DaveBessell","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/A9RgZ7CEoFrFg-RVzTfS9BpL0yIsNcFWbE-07sMG7DwszAMwFir49UdJhwBQX-DtWEZmYlbbxw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DaveBessell","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaZzGdie4R6FQp7KV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video, one of the most useful channels a musician can find. no way that's how you -pronounce tracklib.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxKqNS-fJU1dbRdYf2GYKQQ","author":"@catp1ss987","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Q-RptjEw9NlOEwFu-R8e64RXSo5rtfdzskkgnKcQNpjoDn6Mr2UBwJhDbf3asOFITKZmUN6gCA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@catp1ss987","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxCF83_URNAorQYUc14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Love you Benn! I've been a fan of your music since like 2006! Your videos are amazing and I hope you're doing well! 🐶","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClQ4XriFyHnHCM_lVa1FPBg","author":"@buzzbuzzgames","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iBULOIKjWZEAS8KU_T3mfLW0Kr6uzZy52CAry8XQQuJxtxxtMnM62O1nkegPgDmim9f9v7tMNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@buzzbuzzgames","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_Ox8MC3-pCZYWTVp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Literally got an ad for some ai music generator on this","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCM84e2B76Ip8ymbIeMrgIaQ","author":"@NChomsky96","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_njv5bj96nXZPdVSGWFsAya7ecRhM4u_78FX5cOyq1Aefxs0LYhy-CVDYRCpSNnYeaQwA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NChomsky96","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyOSqvuJYDB5jaJ3H94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Interesting video.\n\nLots of discussion around these sorts of points, not sure who to respond to, so just dumping this into the discussion.\r\n\r\nI think the problem with all of these new methods of creation is going to be the speed at which they are all likely to erode innovation, and create a terrible convergence into a grey goo experience of art. The biological method to a ‘creative’ pursuit in any medium is normally to start by making things that are a bit like other things that piqued your interest in the first place. After doing this, you learn about what is at the core of the things you like, and they become influences in your work rather than being a pastiche of something else. If you’re lucky, this practise enables you to explore the particular pursuit in a way which is unique to you, then again if you’re lucky, you might create something which is considered innovative, and you’ll pique the interest of other people. Every time there are advances from the tooling side of things that democratises the medium, you can make a version of the argument that people aren’t doing the same kind of ‘graft’ and aren't (forced to) learn the same kind of breadth of knowledge to simply do the thing in the first place. You still end up with innovations because you’ve now got so many more practitioners of whatever the creative thing is, even if there’s a growing sense of luddism from the older generation, who think (insert creative medium) has “gone to the dogs”.\r\n\r\nAll this may sound like I’m about to make the argument for everyone to start joyfully producing short stories and prose on chat gpt, illustrate their new books on midjourney, make some promo ads on sora and come up with a jingle on suno. But there’s a huge chunk of something missing here in the creative process. We’re now generating entire works, which we’re then claiming ownership of, off the back of our snap layman's opinion of whether or not we like something which has been served up without effort on our part. We suddenly cater to our lowest common denominators. When these new creative works then go through a few more rounds of training, and slowly the pool of people with even the knowledge to curate reasonable prompts to generate unique things starts to dwindle, everything will converge, everything will suck, and no one will really know why.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCMvJsRwhUHkpfgYltrSs-YA","author":"@alexrumsey3946","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lloUSTsiDRrfnpJ8vU27vjLy6u4rQp2xqVKliXhkGTNww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alexrumsey3946","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxiKpG3IpglrXrRYpl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Timberland is currently working with Suno so I guess it will get a lot harder to detect it… also I know artists have been using this technology prior to this popular technology. Also you look like Kevin McAllister… I like that, just subscribed❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbzvLiYQkBKVjbNQMUiND5w","author":"@mprice10170580","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/9sYJfcweLI_TBiMEPC0CBeENwXm22mmnHV1qwo1VssXENau8eLWcyhPlchWGsHcoAIxxbAvB=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mprice10170580","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx0hemvMexuJb6oUGF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ben... you are a literal genius and i feel like im a better person for watching your videos over the years. thank you for everything you do, as lame as that is to say to someone who you dont even know lol. i do feel like your tenure on youtube has added a lot to the world however, and thats not a joke!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZEmjLPFCXvzjCnaRFDWu8g","author":"@Cloudsurfer69","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/gGhMz14UAMFLm3i5SBDMwq3wp3l7tQclCGFPAu4M5NkJiTxkaCddFzPWykBdKDxpxUzLvYAwgQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cloudsurfer69","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzkHZUaSzOjor2f7aJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ironically, I got a suno ad","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCV4JP9qDiiz887I_gTTnOPQ","author":"@CarsonC.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n68ziQLwlP2zE2AoW58ea3RWol98GNssqM9F9i2ODfKsPj4j3sBfuxm6Wo8-ppOXb3Jw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CarsonC.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugynwk5Q0P2GWdiA5U14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":". I have loved music my whole life. It has been one of my best friends greatest comforts and greatest challenges. Same with digital art. and i have been utterly devastated by AI. for years i have not been able to bring myself to even try. And this gives me hope. hope  that a world in which art matters and truth matters such. a world is Possible and achievable.  never forget that you are a gem. that you are beautiful and rare and full of star dust. your works and projects are filled with a spirit of rare genius. You are someone i deeply respect and i am so glad you are with us.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCxfxuJzFCuKBMjK_LKCljsQ","author":"@MarigoldSonata","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TXk2T7PZgScLCd-_0gzQhTzpMUo1yLmKpORGZyJrkiUs5PmFoiTHqi1_xAVVZpfFQbI7ygJxPA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MarigoldSonata","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9cnL3XrACwqpONzh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"About the difference between lossless and compressed music, you are very right. Usually, 320kbps is far enough for the majority, even 128kbps is okay in most cases. But one time, I crossed the road of THE exception :D\n\nI played a game I really liked, The Entropy Centre, that also has a good OST. So I checked if it was on a streaming platform, it was available on YouTube. And gosh... The songs on YouTube were terrible, awful, the worst thing I ever heard. I was sure that it had to do with YouTube bad compression and that the OST buyable on Steam would at least give a better quality. So I decided to buy the OST directly on Steam (about 5$ I guess). There were 320kbps MP3 and WAV (1300kbps I think so) files and the WAV songs were in that case a pure joy to listen to.\n\nThe Entropy Centre OST uses \"large spectral\" instruments, which is a pain in the *ss to compress without loosing quality (at least by using MP3, FLAC compresses well enough without losing quality). It's pretty rare to have this necessity to get the original quality files than the compressed ones, but it was noticeable in my opinion!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCt3DFo4Up-4ypr5M7d-eHHQ","author":"@iamgly","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lAtKuUSHxd4sCQUrqqiDuxzEIm0APt_yzsInZOBtqLVfw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@iamgly","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx5-zeVgJWLMsTyiod4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is such a cool video. Thank you","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVzSs_tdJPbgBkjy5IhCmYA","author":"@jloiben12","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mDFXeBkuwlVsFnogk9X2O4gWkAH1vxGd0w3YBl2l4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jloiben12","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzbi86EPx5LJ1FXur14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"13:51 RIP Amie Street, your pricing model was so awesome","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCamR0al2mp2ZoHBCkTKtYTw","author":"@SolaBismyth","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/w0ckoHh41K9qe3T3zwYSsZ6T69gBPvNlsOaLptR14_fG1DaSe6H7fLLmHtFGF9Cm07aQ1AI0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SolaBismyth","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgylwQhIi2ns8lf8ZQl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Always great work you're doing thanks!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCI1Q10o777QHtrbfSipalAw","author":"@pfavr","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kqfcWK0hQYqHZAaVUy_BZWDprvcrhlghCHZMovk_8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pfavr","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx3ogCwqSeyktO7R8l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you Benn... this is insanely important work <3","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZfqqh5SXxQBXC7v4zCXI8g","author":"@hubristmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4MMEn5cF7Lzy3XF_BHeZ8Tj35ISy8BvZHQ76EKZeDnvP283acGy1ghDKKQ2WJgriIeVpds-hYA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hubristmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxY0AB2uYyFPiRPiAh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"great deep dive!!! thank you","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCi1LpUgJtNe-OkHV0d8-iig","author":"@melsyoutube","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nH5NtGixv5Cu-PE8Tn1KG94cuLd6DXgNAvHGISKwionCc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@melsyoutube","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyiiKmnzLPXqmgK1dF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think you're a really cool dude, and I really appreciate what you're doing!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC19vOjq1YLuPSShBvYFgojg","author":"@raisage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LkHV85_97lVR_IIZgSoNnm94oK9Xt03fjWQ3iHr3uN50r42xKvbvHg9XI1U8TBrO9CsEvqK12g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raisage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzRn6HzW1cmqPvCS994AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"when I first clicked over to this video, there was an interruption ad, of a person demonstrating how easy it is to use gen ai to make a song.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPj6Me3j-fyr0nV4n4JdYSg","author":"@netvapenavigator8348","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mkQMV5_A3z9pyWioT3QsG79AOH7_llbAfCkKbcN654PQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@netvapenavigator8348","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwB5CL5J3D_5eR1AIp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for all the work you're doing to fight AI slop, Benn!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQWMM0dFHIWPYOjFmv5gWIg","author":"@FunkAndFluff","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n7dLNVyaRghsjpuig972EBwGiSwf4dKAybUYe_2Agw2u7nt2-ZdhZE5yt4rvLj8KTV1mJh8C1SA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FunkAndFluff","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxXS8NRZdRXaTOWo5V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"lossy vs lossless: As I always say, it depends on what you listen to. I can clearly tell the difference between 320k mp3 and flac in my basic car stereo when listening to metal, double bass becomes muddy garbage in mp3 vs the clean and crisp individual drum hits you'll hear in flac (expecially 24bit flac, which is all I have bought for the last ten years). Most popular music made in the last 15-20 years is mixed for mp3 specifically, meaning there is NO sound outside of the range mp3 will capture and replay, so of course they sound the same in flac or mp3. But I also noticed a huge difference in the sound on live music or heavily atmospheric music, mp3 tends to cut out a lot of the atmosphere. You don't need expensive equipment for this, just decent. And even my totally normal friends who don't know or care anything about sound, they come over and watch movies on my surround sound, pretty much always on lossless blurays. I tried to have a couple of watch parties for day-and-date home streaming releases, like Black Widow on Disney+ and they all commented that the sound was so anemic and lame compared to normal (even though it was \"Atmos\" sound according to my receiver). Streaming movies are compressed to heck and sound like old TV audio compared to bluray lossless audio.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNVAlJeebFBSPpHbCi4CpHw","author":"@LazarusXavier","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m6KGX4Yr9J-tYOaJYUUKXKAs2KSVVFowHT7kah_5dPIFNS=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LazarusXavier","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpzwkMgr2drrC24wx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"just found you, so happy I did, awesome channel thank you","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCd_tm1vN2xkYiHJReY2pIGA","author":"@SimonHendersonMusic_SIMON","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LPB6FADlIIvKqh9e2C_ONo-8vfbrS5DdMv2Jz4Ak41tRxgvmo89LlW70umPHHybWzqR4j1spXA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SimonHendersonMusic_SIMON","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxPVcgQm8Fbhf4tsfd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I almost skipped when I was at the end and heard \"speaking of patreon\" because even if I'm supportive, I've heard it before. But I'm glad I didn't skip, it's interesting to hear you were contacted by Netflix but wanna stay here for now. I like that. You make amazing content and yeah it would be very cool to see you get a bigger budget and hopefully fairly compensated for your work, I also think it wouldn't feel the same in a lot of ways","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_D17d4-dTpT0L9fMJhe50w","author":"@TrAnonNoName","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nM8r77Y7Us-1FW6dv-MFAEOgqP10cph49FkxXDnpVClwNGEIdM5zdTUyEgLLRRse4Z7A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TrAnonNoName","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxm347N_R6Q1d4v8Ol4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is the only channel I’ve actually considered joining partition for","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdj-uTVn4TcuFaVNr8MWWdA","author":"@urgaynknowit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_FYTT3qWX3aypdWzYYCE_FyD2Am90vBOJxmD0qAjFu0l72wApCtev6jCCzC_jvBARxClY0vaaw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@urgaynknowit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzx6eAyY05htedQK1h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"MP3 and CD supremacy! Some of the only modern technology I grew up with that doesn't have any ads! I love MP3 players because I can listen to EXACTLY what I want to listen to without paying for subscriptions.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC3z2i-eLTuCEyad9yqymNUQ","author":"@notall2gether","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4wbi_Mx1-AjPDJfjeM7BoFBxSBc5eOp9Ij-oD7rR4pLEeZwoCSr6Eef5YBWD1Fxtn12x9wBlcw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@notall2gether","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzx6eAyY05htedQK1h4AaABAg.AD05A-NKZhvAD4KNFUtAxw","parent":"Ugzx6eAyY05htedQK1h4AaABAg","text":"I'm continuously amused that billions of people scammed themselves into giving money to streaming sites for music.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCvZlK4lftKwue2BASsD2AgA","author":"@Bluetag9009","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nqOYwleVmlb7SK2vX_OV4xWkZAccvYCcKV6Ne-p3OC6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bluetag9009","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqtgNIc1_g9Qy3Zzp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It was great to hear on your views on lossless audio formats. Personally, i do notice a difference with formats sometimes...it definitely depends on how the track was mastered. If the track was designed with lossless formats and audiophile grade gear in mind, thats where you hear the difference. Once you get used to a good setup, you do start to notice the drawbacks with mp3 files vs lossless.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBgQigJRPylU5Wku6uidi0A","author":"@POPDELUSION","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kl5DflvSAt5cCateTrSwaLn4GBN9r6Kpu3KbWBVHt3T53dfl0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@POPDELUSION","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYAYPeVYKOmRvp5jt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Pretty funny about Peloton! I hear they are on a comeback according to the financial markets.  I worked as a session player in LA for years and also glad I learns to write back in the day without a computer, but love working in it and have been since the 90's. From a Synclavier in NYC to my home in the NW US.  I will tell my EDM artist I am producing about this, but also.. Never had a reason to do Spotify account.  Seemed sketchy from the jump. Enjoyed your thing with Miss Krystle Delgado","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIJSTdO_OdwpJmVu8Khz-Zw","author":"@gregoryivesdolbyatmosmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mO-gt7qcOyI6531ZzzeJiRkccKy4lY5DaGNYi3jZosZyE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gregoryivesdolbyatmosmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxFDoN3yFBvMg1PsPF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Charlie Puth’s dad has the middle of both eyebrows missing. \n\nGreat video bro","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjgU8YoxJcQLSGx6hwxdDwQ","author":"@noahsherwinmusic9478","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oekc13mKbscz_TBa5aEJyHSmB4z7pUrMNBUKxibiFlew2KYh9qcRApHqRYs6r44tOHXJhWFZ8_k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@noahsherwinmusic9478","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzrgNpSodQ4OeCnMtV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Good vid buddy. Love the reserch covered","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVvbdvRCFWgTuVkaUTuPBJg","author":"@mrmunyang2476","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mLYVddWuBj0O9yDMhmbDUG38I5ir6i_5jG9GCt91N2Pg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mrmunyang2476","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzF819uvpJy9cEnReJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great work! Thank you for your dedication.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCezPIY_h5IzA6LlLzprjfRA","author":"@LuMozMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/nOurhHPytaM7kYlVu-db9l6vZ1HyQFzL-y7t8tSYVUkkxwav2o-qLGlsQSOHzje6m5vLGSY-QA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LuMozMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzIVhT-Bbp-2G8p554AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"just found this channel, its depressing but i love it ty big dog","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_IKKAkFDDlOT2MywzT06pA","author":"@Stormtrooper6941","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/v3KW9uIjZ7-3RUdPItkbqJ9tEPK2x6W0JG_BLPnLg0FDsbeLJrKHfW2iqpNeU67UsRBprHl-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Stormtrooper6941","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxNw8ZiJSoQ-B3g7_N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:29 I got really excited to hear this sample flip ngl","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC20CS8yl5IgtdnVQz0FVZgQ","author":"@frankie4197","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mixJu7bDHTHO9yX7eZ7xO588OycGKJLuWkM3Yfz-U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@frankie4197","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBnKE3uU1JA24vaed4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"this man is already an amazing musician and an amazing content creator and now he's single-handedly going to save us all","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCB2IMNhAWsuOKe8SPqk49eQ","author":"@Nick-yi4tr","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cOPGUEjEm7Z5kCLuCQZVqB32crFpjck3crdBDLkf8xJV_59pIjVDis-23gBTwEZ0ftkHCGMn=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nick-yi4tr","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQRgnU-dLxntLwu754AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"13:31, that artwork lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaVit1lPeo4FsY57djwthdQ","author":"@AlexWilliams-gn6ud","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zcMXZJARntQBGcBLJ7qzqO2SwH4aCZyDUNNzECC6Y1ixUDPlrWouxELEItzYyVM7UuwM6jF-Lgs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexWilliams-gn6ud","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyRgUT7ag9s4Me8ARt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey benn, as a dj i can assure you flac compared to 320kbps is 5-10% better. When you are playing music loud,little differences are way more profound and obvious. Especially in a club setting where the fullness of a lossless file gives that extra clarity, bass etc. So yeah many people cant tell the difference because they ve been conditioned to listen and love the poor quality mp3s through h-fi speakers or mid headphones. So \"better\n is a relative term that doesn't tell the whole story. Btw recenlty i was comparing iio-rapture yt(128),mp3(320) and flac, and guess what, i preferred the yt version cause that what i was listening to when i was younger, it hides some information on the reverbs and the bass and the track seems to be a little more fast, jumpy. But still the flac has the most detail and clarity (compared with the 320 as well-though not as much of a differnce).","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCgNK6fsLvcwSuBowcXVfGJQ","author":"@DenisPhy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mBYvRadtqBEn0i12_Vo6xLzAEUi_3KJXi8jFCuXEE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DenisPhy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxh45lS4WM2hrFrmBF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I work as a music director at a radio station, and we are getting AI generated music submissions now too. It's nuts.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC9FQ2-aAJmXa9MEgTECiumA","author":"@velociraptor5962","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lRO2WGpnqGXtIZgCkML932nS3ltC81kfYLVy3Eh3LAGxP7zqcU0IN1NJqjepLzRjpxgQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@velociraptor5962","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxh45lS4WM2hrFrmBF4AaABAg.APj54DK0ncZASYOXpfK1qj","parent":"Ugxh45lS4WM2hrFrmBF4AaABAg","text":"People are horrible . I don’t know why they don’t go and learn something if they like it . How pathetic it is to want to be a star without any effort or talent . How strong faces they have ( in my culture someone that has a strong face means he is not or never ashamed )","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzbF1IMUp9nPRgX10f4kp9w","author":"@rez77z","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kvuROa8XpCPDnSYddq8iEsTDRLax-0yaueAcagzHT7qbs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rez77z","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyiGMG0_JuP-D2eQqF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:49 my first guess would be using own song on tiktok","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCy8DEblAS0Pv06bbr3qda9A","author":"@and-bending","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kJPqWvKueKR6ve-T6-VP0Iwzbv9i7XSlkmXRqJMTHFLW0PvSU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@and-bending","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzSYMiqkN0IrmRpDKN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What great stuff for those interested in the fair payment of artists and how to reinvent the music streaming industry.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbxJeKshv_bNHedoJTxcEzA","author":"@smportis","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nkRzIaa9e-NIGulyGpKYfBDm-u9g71xnyS9099rPvelg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@smportis","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyLMmp9s8x7SLmNbOp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I guessed Amazon at the top of the video.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNQK02XsVxyb8mMjqfzftGw","author":"@OMGrant","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/91LrfBF4Zlxe2UkJTZe6BCLkSoHJQ9c3m_dnV8MEvhn3Q6Wh6mt5Dt7tCC1ay5oICxCGzNsoWA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@OMGrant","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgznabBHsAdcw3-YAzd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Paused before watching the rest to guess. Napster, right?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCsjfW9mUoFmTv3sfyGq4M9w","author":"@AlexDeLarge1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nUg6_0TNuoJpPkxPuNUE6hS--i9LbULVOYEpZilv8c8w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlexDeLarge1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzV8feuJ3cF2UBm4654AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"problem too is that a lot of \"copyright\" claims are broad & generic. Not necessarily the specific piece you uploaded. Just a general melody copyright or claim","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCUgZHy54JDeWitUbXuCdwVQ","author":"@dxer22000","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/IhQ4Kgep1MMsxifL2LUrdKc5BcxbAPGOWHzq25tF30rdB1qAbMw4Gwlts84JwhjoWBl1An83=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dxer22000","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQTmF62mPclQH00kF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"cant believe i waited so long to subscribe.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4A-237WOELU_KqcU1YOcrw","author":"@DJ-bq8ng","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mqthQ5JQCBw3cyyRSKufKjbgq6bqr3kgLcAOIUh6XvyBw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DJ-bq8ng","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy51g1GrhP7uBZDLwt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'd really like to see a similar breakdown of royalties paid from digital music store purchases (e.g., Bandcamp, OG iTunes store, Amazon MP3, Qobuz, Beatport, Juno, 7Digital, etc).","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2wKE9rHwaIK4AQwyhaICaA","author":"@JamesMincey","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nXScPEm5lQVHAU7FE4KQFr-mIUPZEu25JS3PLEy34Ofjra=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JamesMincey","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyW01GEW-SL5vjUm9x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"as a kid who would convert every 320 mp3 to a 128 mp4 to fit more songs on my ipod i’m pretty confident i could figure out which song is the better quality file clip","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC8ifggcC2HJ8r7gXZqcU3PA","author":"@ethopathos","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NCaRovzm9OWMDBvTysTAw-qOnUTsRR22WujCf0NU9gwIJ8VQLiLmiagPKwuibdX8P5woJb6p-w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ethopathos","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZOWZCG8cF7bnz_YR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just wait until Big Music finalises the methods by which they can consistently earn Big Bucks from AI content, then they'll switch camps in half the time a coyote needs for a sneeze.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCgK78pWri36nEPJfUVj-Rig","author":"@abcabc-m1q","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nB9Tm9qpNPeUVqazDqRe4FZV6uFd0W3Uq2mMGoCDO5-URC1guRJ6X6izUpduu-J5L48g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@abcabc-m1q","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyiL5Y5rYUvKUZtE1F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Top video and investigation, subscription earned.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCar2LK3ftSh7uiTfFHi6_OA","author":"@dnmnsmith","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mQbDe6hbQEP54km4Z817tmZszIPmdA-3X1Rb5nSnk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dnmnsmith","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwnUn5v1DR42DQ6wap4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The guy that is my number one motivation to be supportive to ai musicians and creatives.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdB55w6WDyeH6J5RERZEpvA","author":"@AiDIYTECH","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DA4ApwXv2MlIsNK0YVc4rXkwqVWGviZEkQB0ooF2LtvvBra4x23qSn0KO4v6-9or0sMVxg3V6vo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AiDIYTECH","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyK2UEAxZsT9xM38DJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Fun fact: AI image generation also includes patterns of visual artifacts from file compression found in the training data set even though the output is uncompressed and the the inclusion of those visual artifacts is clearly included at random and not as a result of any real file compression. I learned this from a video teaching people how to spot AI generated graphics by looking for random and inconsistent .jpeg blocking in the image","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuB3dcipUczdi--mloYZcTQ","author":"@Lambda_Ovine","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/l9ZVHpKIKBDjsyNC5q0SbImpXP26nnmarZSGIHpOWSCP6C2y6d0k0oUR0mE9fMNM2drWBhvj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lambda_Ovine","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2OzVJlae106FjG4J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"your bot spotify ep is pretty gooodj. i dont really like money, its not fly. \nbut i love the idea of using technology to distribute resources evenly thru  out the world. and one day. beyond ❤ get some sunligth would ya? ❤use a solar screen or something to lessen the UV's 🎉❤ music for life ❤","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCHMVNIp3Ixoasve_dQxMEOQ","author":"@Dan-rw8dg","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_laJelIcucXz--tvr_jIvZbPjAZOPZ0NJStrveUoyHpOg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dan-rw8dg","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwwGRkNQb4mpLtMJnZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:00 \"This video's gonna be kind of all over the place\" Benn, we know what we came here for.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1UboIlHvJDDnMz5CmQYNcA","author":"@TrotterG","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mym1ey6Zp_x_Ako2vV2Gim7eSn4Vm6taD8KrYNnObjtSLP=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TrotterG","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyvfydrbi5-6TR27qh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Didnt see that bit at the end coming, WITH AN O, but great video all the same.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_OjV6J4k6kogTBRr0eAJnA","author":"@michaelinglis567","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_my_VwRVEIa8bkSwQ2yOdyA_l7-vCmtGIaCNGOH6vY0hPo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelinglis567","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyapuuPVszACN7j2wN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I mean the most ideal way to consume music nowadays is an MP3 player and buying digital albums on Bandcamp or something, imo","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCbMHyQBfgjkCfFM3_YfLrQg","author":"@lloydnoid6506","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NEhUCUjjZkdbsFrl9j6akKXMclIgXVIRRvhbb3Rrk3kcSpwGQ5sFQsuCAst6TovoY7_SyneKrg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lloydnoid6506","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9mpgRhiJwol7wW9N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video..... thankyou for keeping it real :yt:💯","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCovjIBglaFcJTXzgTDgqgbA","author":"@Seven2kbeatz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cjW9WLLYbO8a0JWiI_kOreCVKqE1RWE9IhIK-s4PpdLSSgWVBPjJGEa9Chn8f1bczxVrGF-VvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Seven2kbeatz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwwNd7ZDOO1E0w8IIV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm very curious to see the model classifying songs as stolen or those that have AI usage. Mostly because typically if you have 100% accuracy in your model thats a sign your model could potentially be filled with false positives and that it could be overfitting the data. Working in this space could be incredibly interesting to look at, and I had never even considered that something like that could be out there already. This is informative! Inspires me to look into this more","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTKkRuh2fstJ_77g7sp1ZhQ","author":"@edwinramirez6380","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m9i5QRcA8fj-Hda_3O_D9FhVYH_yzhRgSEHfHvxxExfhMN=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@edwinramirez6380","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzJMGpMKg_lXnhDtrR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I cancelled all my streaming services some time ago but hell yeah I'd sign up again for a NETFLIX x BENN JORDAN format","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNMJh-tU935RqHy8PBcg-AA","author":"@freddykuno","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xSyJ_z-CoUeKuB50MAq8cFdq0dQeHBG48OM04CfygmMjxu0kFIq0oVv9dke_EMosSg5NodTvVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@freddykuno","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwhnQEFqCerPxiEaAp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"what a nightmare","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCaXRkt9jrEnVsfRr_PNwoUw","author":"@MadsterV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_HwK0b0_WV_1774a9jor63raUEKz1lUQfOxO-wTGGCg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MadsterV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw42_foZirENkiEZyx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Don't stream... buy your favourite artist music directly from them... this is the way. Great vid Ben. Imagine how hard it used to be for a new aspiring artists to break through already saturated market... now they have to break through AI layer just to get to the real people layer... real/human music just lost it's value.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGFvtMYG877U5XjXhQ6J1Bw","author":"@TakeOneRecordsOfficial","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WxMmhqeLaatVmlZizLGMIwMNJhrgUF3qTbNZaXEn-quW7seuU44F4iRBLt5g4DZmJj8Y1Dlq=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TakeOneRecordsOfficial","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyeVni79PjTAyTjXBx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This was such a great video!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpMX0jf4AfQaRWg86zgvZcw","author":"@mr_coldfield","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/EeqZ56FjDOJ22pIAFqsdLJ62bLcq588R3xAggYQGVjNVypKLPpE3pNC93ejO0XPVshAUX5zYSQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mr_coldfield","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9XnVktpbyNKZrF6N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey Benn, great video, thank you.\nYou mentioned that it might be possible to register samples with ContentID before releasing them (so that false ContentID claims can be avoided). \nDo you have any suggestion on how this would best be done? Releasing samples as songs seems a bit odd as a strategy - or might one release one long song with all the samples lined up in it and hope nobody has to suffer listening to it? 😀","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5ZEIQ-owq_WnnzsJUd3_BA","author":"@AndriSoren","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mjlhfl740dtgP2MnCbBdbw5LrNpuqn60EGxgqAapeF1GFP=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AndriSoren","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyXjqfXsdHXCjQ49zZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Everyone is missing a very important thing on this video: an American calling football “football”, and not “soccer”. Impressive😮 1:56","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCw8RGTOwCgdqRWY4ppzGS1Q","author":"@SineBeta","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_cdb12iEvfbconWqKW89iqSh69jL-NdmjZIuXCkr9Yg3iLzKFdf8SG32lYrR3AmrM9A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SineBeta","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw0euh8xBB6ObmYw5B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Regarding lossy audio file compression. A mp3 that has been shrunk might be very good sounding. But if it would turn out as converted to a wav, the compression losses will still be there. Now would one want to compress the Wav that came from an mp3 the compression to mp3 the second time might suddenly not be forgiving. Cascade compression is hard to do without audible differences.\nAnd, perhaps unexpected, audio with poor sound quality on the original recording, like a track on a CD, are inherently harder to compress without causing audible loss. Poor sound quality are typically associated with unwanted distortions of different kinds. Distortion alter the sound and adds sound like harmonic distortion, transient intermodulation distortion, and some. This makes the audio much more complex and it is for this reason harder to compress with a lossy algorithm.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCnz2BEuOVmaXTDYZhhnxT-w","author":"@johnsilfen70","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kZGmjzIANUymkr_jcxxHDcM4AHCIuUEywvbTNOrZc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johnsilfen70","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxHAp2Nu8QuO0NGclR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great vid dude. Thanks!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuLcOrk5kDoUOJ2q5dmJM9Q","author":"@vancedylan5842","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/HEhC6GxWqwRvS4AqSkP_Ek1lV16n0P-Mq5Qp_nQu5B1uctJXYThf83rIDc9NZdd6UDbr4hYehgU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vancedylan5842","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyEFpGvtBGMHKv5rvB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi Benn, there's an even more interesting aspect i'd want you want to know. Essentially, there are this two Swedish Record Producers Dennis Pop and Max Martin you certainly have heard of. What almost nobody knows is this: This two guys are deeply connected not only to Spotify, but to a literal CULT! with \"Ordo Tempelum Nephilim\". I dont want to go more into specifics as there is a great guy on Youtube, Arkheim Ra. He has a channel named \"Disclosure Now!\", where he shares his extremely interesting life story's  and he recently released a Video about the Spotify Cult.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCINHB-X1IFgbhP5YrTHtPAg","author":"@Denkmaschinen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XB8aP_r4uaX3bqa9IHxR_n66RrI9Kw5AUTTd9ZLwMFdQ0AB-63fqbOvFFZKg-l_oW8UApH_C5Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Denkmaschinen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2QD-S4sho3MzSRQt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Not sure what they pay for licensure but Radiooooo is all I’m using these days.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC3JZRdn_5A0QN9UtD7tH69w","author":"@syverjove","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/giv-coyUqa2q1mjq3bYLSTn5vS5aeV0qt_JBdUab4SbUwznFbXNWktZjEOwMnfdToBKuBJI9bg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@syverjove","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZDVUUtw8z1v0K-BN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love this man, thank you :) ❤","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCn4IES95m9zGawfQJNHfpzQ","author":"@UnlikePluto","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/f_V7kaxCEG-BhmEVGmNDhVVUO1PfV9sM5BpycROTp606v1TvddiaMSqvSaiAyAdTjBXK_ABFww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@UnlikePluto","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYR-xtmE9JX5NMj894AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’ve always thought of sample packs and loop packs as being the digital production equivalent to a toy guitar.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSQDXuEs8mBFk6ZXAmi0ocQ","author":"@geoffstockton","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mFLXyg2fN9dtJJq149_8UkWS19qfqSdWr24BKhdG3MkDU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@geoffstockton","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyEnyHDMjv_abszsJV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As usual top tier educational content. Do you receive one time donations? Being a Bsc student money is tight but I do want to support you at least this semester break when I’ll be able to work again","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRJjfEdIi2qchO8K_x_HoKw","author":"@lhospitalfan_69420","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/tR0-KQ_ci2IsaXRigehoVqCYMvQWGAaihk-D3CfWo_LisdD4EmYRJp7YJIlflj7iVjLKDoUwvCw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lhospitalfan_69420","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwSKPQxbRBP-AlSCUR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Need to watch this twice to get all the info into my brain cuh","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQ_OEQ8hPJY2sL_WpIdnrMw","author":"@DJ_Ghöstly","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cQNcT3q-nFHLSd5-mrjQT7CSPZzO_4DZrHV3K_A41rws2_ZDaxOIhCDAVBaOSroWCRT3gHKbaA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DJ_Gh%C3%B6stly","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzoXFWJVZZ0wIStv7x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This was awesome! Thank you!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKO1J20w9Hpfsq7dJxGiN9A","author":"@zero11010","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lU-WSDNtbZ61xRQEZza02xxmhpJbjFuCxL2jjz7Kw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zero11010","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx7fSTbndHWHwcf_XR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Majority of people don't use good loudspeakers , thats why they don't hear difference between mp3 and wav","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCpBDH_rNAej7HFoihhKVsTg","author":"@amanray","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mqVs6b7cyZwpzQ4TuywQBUdopO7zTCKaxq6Npb-M82BLQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@amanray","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxtX_XxK9ghz0PwPSh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:20 As someone who works with media encoding a lot, particularly with FFmpeg, you get trained to notice the differences over a long time doing it. The main problem is knowing what to listen to; most people, even if they try to listen for differences, they fail because they have never been exposed to the \"quality\" part of their audio listening experiences.\n\nI'm not an expert in any technical field, but one thing I can tell about myself is that when I play games, watch videos, or listen to audio, I'm less interested in the actual content consumption and instead always tend to theorize how it was made, at a technical level. When it comes to games, I try to recognize which game engine was used to make them, and how the logic was programmed (kind of like a mental disassembler); with video and audio, which encoders were used based on which compression artifacts I'm seeing/hearing.\n\nI'm not trying to seem like I'm any kind of special case. I'm simply an example of someone on the other side of the extreme - someone who, passively at this point, goes out of their way to notice all the technical side effects of any media that I'm consuming. It has been so ingrained into my casual media consumption habits that I can no longer listen to music on YouTube because most of them have too noticeable compression artifacts as opposed to listening on dedicated music streaming platforms, which has less to do with YouTube's encoding and more with how people upload their music on here.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3ElL9fs3OZ6cJax-MBiBwQ","author":"@deivedux9342","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kIazzExyLleeVr_uq0Z-NBg7aIYuO4HKQ9WPGW1SdzcEg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@deivedux9342","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwpg5uCeO1LnEZnmf54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Cool data info! 🔥✨👍","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2wn6lnctM1s-98Ubkl0t0g","author":"@astrocat2008","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/z7TfzjiPRzz2MqNZewwGhTVjcNWh5dzboAyMCdtIhdDTUh_lNMeytEG1XkDLc9m7vScbpcOIng=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@astrocat2008","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxp6oLTCyTPxATz3eZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I would love to see a technical side, maybe on patreon/second channel but the data science behind it would be cool to learn about","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCO8QCjFT7k-Vk-X51l0A9WQ","author":"@ekjfinn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nAAQaZncceiKApHleeYXGZJimnfVM6uPzzgnOoz9ckdx5xSQ2w2xq3ytWe9CejXfzmEQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ekjfinn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy8tksDUMy0j1rHomh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for your outstanding work, sir.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgmtxUOMh5K3enXLxBSRZSQ","author":"@teleharmonik","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kzrRYpbLT5IRt5ESoamEaomgbYLHd-0ew3h1FTXs-sTqdEhbBw4_ffzF5OaI2i9mQURJ4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@teleharmonik","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgydQ1WEybgLwjUR-IB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn, when are you finally starting your own streaming service? I‘d subscribe in a heartbeat. I don‘t trust anyone else.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6BbugMWQt-nTJyF6FU9mdw","author":"@Laiserball8","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kiUCV7MAa7jgMcAnlMmS4LfrACyTrYSWPoeQ66yjHWVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Laiserball8","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzEgLnTPM9BAEBHlZl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"damn thorough video. Good stuff","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwm7xq0XGJe4BFVVjZUItvg","author":"@odeonhealingfrequencies2743","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nHaPX4ilA82BY5O3sq_FrsU9a_wEnqf4qmzvQ_j3q_wH4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@odeonhealingfrequencies2743","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGhfXxWXmbnA4IGQ94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’m glad that your (P)Denis are supported by us ;)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCywS7119cWbf2BCgjS9dsgg","author":"@SlavaChrome","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Z2xMf7qRjKj8B-iBC5mPG2qF7x2k8MXPACDnDOEZ7QfkA271pxU3POChZJ8nLjVwVieoHSZMeto=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SlavaChrome","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxjtUF1bbS3zYJhA5l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn you are incredible...!!!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQK2oXS8vFhc8Q9BtKAOhCw","author":"@frankscherbarth8641","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kMl1UV8t41Jph_Cefl_7MuggqQFf_czW1pO0-9h7I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@frankscherbarth8641","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxtRlna95vD-RHittN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"THANKS BEN.. the lazy part of me was considering signing up to suno to get drums and bass created .. so I didn't have to do it myself... AND I can do it myself 👌\nAfter sampling a little bit of suno and seeing someone else labour over one of their drum beats I realised that AI cannot cover every degree of the universe \n\nI'm looking forward to being self-sufficient and doing it the way I want to 🙌","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtQYI5LMk47DDdZPO4hqJAw","author":"@SuperQuarter","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YnqeGyakFaY3AuJKTn0krh1Xkp_wkHL-d-RMmAKt2U0wcMolrpWskcvlSF0dmIKp2thWo75aVA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SuperQuarter","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxm7TnBDdEsZrDIkTd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"thanks Benn, i think you will save music! and thus my job","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOvkA0d13-3XFm8krfuxL3w","author":"@tommy.countach","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n2bYyoEq62QiAEAoAoxk055MGOEXFSIJxmxwOR_wmFb4HOhjnxQR48nDMlmdqDxAqNgCi8yCJr4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tommy.countach","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyhcWAUMgLQF7K4ZG14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I got an ad for Suno while watching this lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4rrawWepQKeLtx2eoIV5zg","author":"@rustyleftnut","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xYTbrjvpyzbgGqMk4PJC6LR1ZoqUo3P-MNpZ8Y1c9gKrgkPLT7WR43Gc5KAX7B--Dyf3JiEf=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rustyleftnut","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxvgJuE70e1lqnsrJx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"No.4 was my guess. Great work.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRSq2M9de8lBWdimTD47IJw","author":"@radionotespodcast","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_msfGiyL4U1yVY1-z7AoSkZ1cCO7ZMOZpcHe57aJpdgAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@radionotespodcast","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzxRaMCkeO_KYniH6p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi Ben, great video. Definitely off topic, but are you still a little disappointed in the SY1000? Has it grown on you? I've no real good way to try it out without buying it. Not too much top level reviews out there and really respect yours, especially if it has changed over time.\nGreat channel!\nThanks \nDan","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_6R-mn1Gt01GX2GgqJVwrw","author":"@TurboInfidel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lG5zENisnzbWQgsUvactjQK-1ezLPAiOu6Gg5NSqY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TurboInfidel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXDnEnA9GDBdn2udt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for talking about this!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2lvJrNVQhAuppY42PE3B8A","author":"@andymac5tet","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fz1zM3S3r1gwSoPm2CUp133gQMBdLiv5H2n3-f-bo4VT9nvoivju2INnDDtvegAM_KKAbRlO7w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andymac5tet","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzIKRnYeJBrOp_BU5h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Excellent work, thank you.  Direct to fan is the only bulwark….","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5qIdYXz0x0_q3vCa3RDAxg","author":"@zlbdad","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kjZh1nobh0o088eXGq_seDrMDyTeO0MRJmT8-u6Jpfj0Vb=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zlbdad","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzaEOEDCr9oAnL_7Fh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"got a gift card for christmas so went to hobby lobby for art supplies yesterday.. the home decor sections are now full of AI generated “paintings”… seems like a slap in the face to their artist customers..","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLo1HvWpq5idHeTlb_AcMBQ","author":"@michaelg8642","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mjWSt6SE6I6dJukq-i7MdDaxAmUTJPpuLldLSI2P5afw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelg8642","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxgw6z51SpzwEgHG0x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wasn’t expecting Peleton…  you’re right. I was expecting something like MySpace.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1lgVb67IP9lt9LUHytLXEg","author":"@ErokowXiyze","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/IXLNHuwZweqPwfI43417Jhsy7DO3-jvim_ZwfW6XQ5h1TecwDvLrcA0UHM6xtI75hzE6Ohwm=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ErokowXiyze","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 days ago","timestamp":1790294400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyC7fHdTv8zl16xaOh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I completely respect the fact that people dislike or even hate AI music. It's understandable how people feel and it's all justified. That is why since the inception of Artificial Crypt over a year ago now, I have always been open and honest about the nature of the \"music\". I have never once tried to play it off as real, and I always, always, always correct people if they think or insinuate it is human made. I am completely aware many people (including myself) see this as talentless, and that's very fair. Everyone has their own reasons, but mine have always been to lift people up and bring to light some issues or mental problems others may be facing, and to make others feel heard. All of the newest lyrics in Artificial Crypt has been written entirely by me, and if it wasn't, it is stated in the credits.\n\nAs for the future, I hope AI becomes more of a tool rather than a replacement. I love the prospect of making my own guitar riffs or drum beats and having help making them into full songs with AI, and I hope the industry strives more towards using it as a tool, but I know money means more than morals, so I doubt it will happen.\n\nAnyways, thank you guys for reading if you did. 😁🧡🤘","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC_5nhuf6wpAWyuNDmcyy29Q","author":"@ArtificialCrypt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_A-W0naWPvq-ps9RiBHWSettkVN58owsRujbbhWBk4cyzOTvf0T9Lv0_2zMdXeeXcPnVuLxBJ5g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ArtificialCrypt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyC7fHdTv8zl16xaOh4AaABAg.ADPZxMTEOpAAK3oB8U_V8B","parent":"UgyC7fHdTv8zl16xaOh4AaABAg","text":"If you're honest about it and the genAI is trained on data from conseting artist, then it could be a fine tool...But it isn't. Right now 99% of genAI services are theft machines built on the backs of artists who never consented let alone got paid, and most people using them don't disclose that it's AI :(","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCskHALBFIRsx2ElO3q3Ac4w","author":"@user-oh6uw9mu9u","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nP-uyJTy9LJUhx9RUjjQD31p_mmzagFZ1hgPsXzCnBS6U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@user-oh6uw9mu9u","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvanNtLFhJshq_t8F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Recently one of my favourite bands HEALTH suddenly dropped two albums on Spotify out of nowhere, both were simply called \"HEALTH\", and I immediately could tell it was some AI-generated bs. They were quick to notice and make fun of the situation, but the fact that some random person can just upload any music under another artist's name on Spotify is still wild to me, yet alone that it was AI-generated stuff that simply fell into the category of \"generic name\" (and HEALTH, the band, are far from what any of that that AI-generated stuff sounded like).","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUyqTrorXIBeJ0p9leBB2-w","author":"@RocketRacer2142","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CYDX5NFCmT-TWC8Ncl7kEuu27KDkVybYjTgLqmRKqSAHesJV-8NCczVQySc2LhTxBi3uARiCug=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RocketRacer2142","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvanNtLFhJshq_t8F4AaABAg.AD409jOIClYAEE7VoZPug6","parent":"UgwvanNtLFhJshq_t8F4AaABAg","text":"Uploading under another artist's name and not eventually getting sued by said artist are two different things. haha","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyHeZUzOZJvLxPNV9_4__7g","author":"@ManBearCowTV","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RfG9BsOwt0gFE_rhMNaKDKdVNYzlRofaBOSDOmzmQ2llEXa3H9MmJLIYM-H-ZAE-ycKAwH035w8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ManBearCowTV","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxPC5SDTxmyq0B69OB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wings of Pegasus Fil deals with this on a daily basis with his videos.  Good job here too🎉","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7tIdklhuh5NS0nERClxe_Q","author":"@aves6851","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mwNCQ1t4AILLSFoVjmVGEBkufwQEa_teOITbOhoAJdu53wycHLcV3VsJSYm5tfmdWZPw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aves6851","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwhadoE5mbUF_YQOYZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is how it needs to be done. Bravo!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-sWy6Wv_dFnyzbdqnzLcSw","author":"@xyzcbd","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0jvO_w8X0WrwLOSZy52IHb86Dq2uOEqTrTQ5MNAqQI4RSBLQ5ni9nH5i3_hi876-_MOABesG=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@xyzcbd","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyPk3h15i8LzgOphpV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You can really hear the different between compressed and lossless if its a big enough soundsystem with bass oriented dance music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwCSX2ZDgOqGsxM3XAS8big","author":"@long-long.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7NPBECek-w_LvnIvbAsK6PVOMkURaBCRuSpuAzfSIGwZZBzcf9OzTJccsOEMFU6CF2li-HF9=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@long-long.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyxkWx2cHtizE7RMoR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If I want to support an artist, I'll buy their art from bandcamp or patreon or something.  That way, they get like 90% of what I sent instead of 0.1%, and I get an actual copy of the art to keep instead of just streaming it.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UClBP4eGxNaVXH2Kz5r56VHA","author":"@ToyKeeper","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/HtU4SmQ2Iju1JPWBElaDotdqJrrbH0P4LcdO2K9LOSRKRFnKuNRFOJv3f24UFRnk20Yo9lDwxlE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ToyKeeper","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzby5tHfp-PwJoMjmh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What is your favorite A.I. song - anyone...","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCeLuGRq-VCefm5uD2-5JzBQ","author":"@JohnGreek-v7c","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_khSbcYOk-ZJpJdnM0KT63okOiFU3WwtWMvAi-S5gxJah9fOAID9GlTIjWJnSHyDKWk4A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JohnGreek-v7c","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzzvejS0w2rKl4hkRB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"on club sound systems you hear the difference between mp3 and wav files clearly.. There has been also research that indicates that mp3´s cause a higher stress on the brain, for unknown reasons, but higher stress or activity  might be experienced by some as uncomfortable or tiering. The separation wether something really sounds worse or just feels worse is mostly not made in audio research, but since the human brain is the end of the trasmission line, it matters the most how something feels.. It happens that distortion feels better to humans than \"clean\" audio..","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuZ9fWWrTzKFsJSUkA_k9AQ","author":"@3phaseBerlin","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/et0HPJ99zozySaaw24CcLhFN3ZTuqLTnaRl4-EZ5ITqq9_atgiW6cJsQ_3_3aPeEvq6r6wgelQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@3phaseBerlin","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCwtKw5Mzti-q8F_14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Excellent content!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCq4fLuqaE5V5LLlRTSjghDg","author":"@Bamamarama","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kaYUArKJdQ99ONlMutBCLw-mFUpeUrF3Ld8PWAJz0Y6C2_fXl9tgVaOFSVxOgB7HszmyglQamQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bamamarama","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCV7hjsLQ26NVj5CZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Made the switch to tidal, was super easy y’all get on it!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEgtq6mDTjjxCTxlFPNGovw","author":"@neverbetterband","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wjgOvnR8W2EQXbIE1vYr3WTXxPE8lDMIiqT0_S8rjo0tcbClUvncwiwFEJacDzblSHtrFb3wUg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@neverbetterband","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynbyQv3KWYUu_1ZnB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"this is audio version of \"PNG should not have JPG artifacts\" I love it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwCsgQlxHoHyyCA4qH8ifJA","author":"@cola98765","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llzpzatbB_5JUHkkWnS31mm7B88v9q0cNjchVTfmuKXv0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cola98765","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzCZqV0MbdHCvU22Yd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Very informative, Thanks!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxQB5dHBgvmE0wWcoX0-6ng","author":"@aimusicbyelevar20","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/eu8MW32z1yjGJlK1hd9ywJ8Tnh3_Dp-SA8wFWe-g-9He0Y105CkSKSaR3dLN50gnejWiVS34Bus=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@aimusicbyelevar20","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzBWEVQBO8KGCZbz5V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ironic: on this video was an ad for an AI music tool.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6okCN0e0BhTFbHiyH5soIQ","author":"@dervishmadwhirler","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kgLx7uUN2J3MmU1eORvA33jawC2H-WALWCjTFEpp8bXQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dervishmadwhirler","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw_s7uv-Q56N-ajcVB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Can you please make your AI music classification model available through a web interface or some public tool? You don't have to share the model itself but I really want to run some tests.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCGDEFfzHs-XIwqh--DHHahQ","author":"@jochemstoel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lc8ZoEwT1gMRpffFukTytu8w1Q1rz99LL0LyO7b5Us14Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jochemstoel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwyJ1uTenShnl8ulAp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm currently paying for Tidal because my Onkyo NR686 AVR has the app built in.  Sounds amazing.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC73Fty2wUaq_5KCYrdzfwew","author":"@FortyTwoAnswerToEverything","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nm16VXpiHpA_wHf-Vk8mcg6XvSbn80YnhNGGHmsqMfGA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FortyTwoAnswerToEverything","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzxnlOg6Rz7GmcIUyN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"No surprises, but I really am glad to hear progress on the fingerprint front.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_k4IJsYlQOad94JT_EELEw","author":"@orbatos","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nF746h5wDDwihZ1JjPFvdfKVlSnXPIPswRPX3vg7w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@orbatos","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDPYKEdh1W7742Mll4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:07 you can by training the decoder to output what it would have for an uncompressed file (given you have some dataset of them) even for the compressed version of them","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcQwgi4cCoGUxsafMFMp8qg","author":"@roworline","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SadY0Ap0XMWA5WmtN0n_k7T9RTB1ATyeeTtinyAmhdC277XGMUfchPdVX8Yefous7Fi4xFlvIg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@roworline","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy7_I1uDyxEapJBAXh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is PhD-worthy work, I’m not kidding","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvvRwdqwmakpaS-0iNTn1FA","author":"@EmperorOfPotatoes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/p2dP-k26rfpVM18oTJrD0FyUF2bXN0U7HVWyohpZU0eyhBvLgT6IHcUOQTINjJh5TzF3g3lm=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EmperorOfPotatoes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxlCLWW6T4bYQRJ7x94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm very late to this video, but I feel like it's still very possible to identify a lot of Suno's creations by ear - so I'm not surprised that it's possible to algorithmically identify it.\n(I also reached the conclusion of 'it sounds like their data set included MP3s from the LimeWire era', go figure)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTXyx1c7uCHkmoMMfyjxwkQ","author":"@åsnan-kiki","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YEgOKxEeuvOHzhLEtwiLxS7GCcReCaU1-2DHmz1hRG48CIZh68OiPzYmlmV4TNh2BJzhTaXV2A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@%C3%A5snan-kiki","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwTl6NVAPmM94K--rl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Regarding lossy- vs lossless encoding, if you know what it does to audio and therefore what to listen to, you might hear it. If you are aware and made the original music, you will hear it. If you listen to someone else's music, good luck with that. Having said that, the way lossy encoding (such as mp3 etc) operate is (among other things) to parse audio across the timeline by quantizing it into time-frame windows as well as segmented frequency windows, and as a consequence there will be issues with transients, pre- and post ringing compared to the unadultered original digital audio file due to quantization errors in the time-domain as opposed to the dynamic domain we all know how to listen for since the 80s. This is subtle at first, however down streams through multiple stages of mixing and processing, it gets worse. Noticeably worse. Enter streaming services, distributed media, TV or real-time mixing audio assets in a video game. The same issue applies to using FFT and convolution, even for something as mundane as a reverb IR.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTZvG5rDlsfuzACl9WhEh3w","author":"@DerDanko","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/g1Q9UTol0gF6dwWIgM1g0-I8vATicsTWl6Sv9LwWN1LVy1O8MT4GuK3tX3ExIaqho7Ize_7k2HU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DerDanko","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCnBHoUQ8viMXKMbp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"its crazy. \n\nIch höre seit ich 10 Jahre alt bin elektronische 4/4 Musik, vorwiegen harten Techno und produzeire diesen auch.\nIn den letzten ist mir jedoch sehr stark aufgefallen, dass unglaublich viele Künstler spawnen, die alle zwar krasse und gute beats haben, wenn man aber die beats analysiert (einfach in DAW ziehen) kann man erkennen, dass die meisten AI generierten Tracks keine konstante Geschwindigkeit haben und dadurch eine gewisse Dynamische_BPM haben.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCv3xRh-SaDiOL0XHfjXw-Bg","author":"@Floriankramm89","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l2A0Y26tbovdM7Ul_q9HLipUMwVpxxDNDz7MxaXUbDFjM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Floriankramm89","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyVpgeQReOBp56Lsct4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:17 was not expecting that lmao","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCo9MAD4DBCb9qqwKq8vzgCw","author":"@RimshotsAcrossTheSky","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lK0s6-oh__sOh_kNM-jWclwmVuOoJUq24dhsU2AzOt=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RimshotsAcrossTheSky","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZAL3_nyc9m2w-wzd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for your work ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxH-gaa6J6oKDH3ikKrp3Jg","author":"@Skincaredidi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/wNNyo3CuLlaJxDFzYmGkbPKbLc7YrXKPzoMSPYkzdNdB3p6XABRGvmd-Jwlz_KlBxOyPO296=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Skincaredidi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw98_WPli8Z60kUPMd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I know I'm late so this likely won't get seen, but I think it's important to note how Spotify determines what the rate of pay is. It isn't just a set rate that they've been choosing to lower year after year. They do a system where they take all of the money that folks have paid for subscriptions (well a set portion of that money) and add it up, then they divide that by the total # of plays on the platform. Then that money is distributed on that '$ per play' rate. So, in my opinion, the reason that the rate of pay is going down steadily (and will continue to go down) is the flood of low effort music and system-gaming that occurs. If you put a 2 minute long 'white noise song' on loop as you sleep through the night, it is racking up plays that are taking money from the artists you actually value.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7MPzBh6-LMkrx-Dm9_kvvw","author":"@EnderoftheGame","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k37Jx-Up8E4ObvDBP7XQYsKzPVFryLKSDcDIc1srg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EnderoftheGame","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwI8RdoLWhE2l5mQqR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"SoundCloud?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCcryXejB5Os20ZCSSdJtU5w","author":"@EricWagliardo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nLaihxDFVmnJ3BNrRAmxQrbA_mCKWJCT4LKngxCiB_0GgMeT12zvtvULsylDTrrmZaZg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EricWagliardo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyRVW5-nAZcLHs2VKZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"the part about lossless and lossy reminds me of how i used to be obsessed with having all my music in lossless 24bit/96kHz flac files… until i started using youtube music when they offered a trial and i thought \"well this sounds amazing what are they using? … oh, 256kbps AAC. hm, okay, so i can't tell the difference\"\n\nnowadays all the music i listen to is 256kpbs because fudge it, if i can't tell why go through all the trouble","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuzo4dYi8iPwV7PVwzWS0NQ","author":"@lurmirari","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fj4KU-2ykhdu-IvTl_mIGNq7QQ08E65BfiVC3Ca9i8Z0-D9XVxnE6tSfaEbbf1PQRU-v40d9=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lurmirari","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxAhUm-LbLBKNgi3ux4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How about a video that shows which platforms where you buy albums/music to keep give the most to artists? \nI've gone back to buying albums instead of using the money to stream, mainly bandcamp but I'm not sure how much they give artists.\nIt's made music a lot better instead of just listening to the same thing all the time, I've had to think what I want to buy and commit to giving it a chance instead of just trying to find instant gratification.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCyq_Q4iejrh2Oe4pSu_fTZQ","author":"@tomfurstyfield","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_muQ6W_3kJBZO51Mvz9CWm98p_ZemwVZ8DYLJk1hzMAf_c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tomfurstyfield","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9VS4N2MFQHz1n60p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thumbs up just based on the mp3 vs wav quality issue.  It's like the wine snobs being fooled by \"red\" wine which was just white with red food coloring.  LOL!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChiFtbByzXdlQJ4sp5uK61Q","author":"@MichaelCampbell01","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ni2lt0ragbykbB-CRvM20jtnEHBUZ1i8pKVKLoN7HbI1xG=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MichaelCampbell01","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCn0EtOcJLjKk8iDZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well researched!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLRdoONw-3bjjrx3Z1egNFw","author":"@morphiusfilm","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/agLwu62qybVB0NIWMJCwfjE1PTLiUFR1SRp0k6RnNVLXw_T4IjdiGgnSPpCV2G3_LTwKFm2V4ZI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@morphiusfilm","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzN6RCYcQcWRwXJgu54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I used to listen Autumn Insomnia Session on repeat on my way to school back in the day, and a video on detecting AI-generated music is not the way I expected to learn how the author of it looks like","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6GuvbE2c4k6csS1I591hzg","author":"@ItsukiEsper","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lPmv3dAw2bLSoUDQmLlKRqAPx0X76lih3vCyT658F0OQ8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ItsukiEsper","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQKTZBDXebXhIqJCt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about Bandcamp?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC3dLw6DKKGZYMFA7vMRq5wg","author":"@salmonbear5433","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mbBVsu44Nw_oPng5VfUQ7sHNOwwt7wmyfIMtFm3Xo65Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@salmonbear5433","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-f0wa95gFUsMORvR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Holy cow! Am I only one seeing this dude in leather jacket while carrying Lucille on his shoulder and grinning lol\nGood luck Benn, Ai is f*king up everyone equally :|","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHpu4Quuww3XE2BFwgw2MVQ","author":"@domino6755","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nGgtvYz5FK8aTPZxyJ9ebme8HC7xK7Gu6LG40oIVZtoKE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@domino6755","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy5n7JWvr1WGCkW9qt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think the problem with telling people to leave these streaming platforms is that they feel like they can’t discover good songs otherwise.\n\nOn the flip side, I’m terrified of streaming services because I can never know whether the next song the service recommends is ai slop or not.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtTQQYA0BQ3-fZpddLsVuBg","author":"@chiffonkek2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mcQV1blZZGdTiUX4cVsdf4Vy1SlQ-i1uoE3AVa33Ptbpk4q41f12BxxTp0ggs_2KzTew=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chiffonkek2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyXW8eADaaGDyIsnf14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"1:59 \"Pauses there to look at the picture in detail\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPq8bQ2Y39DjR6soYWOxOQA","author":"@lowskill6406","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZhB8D-pmLw0DqfYYSJFmO6XZZYdn3UbwQeS1q0z1D58l2icD3fRIfUNwuWHdj8M2-MA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lowskill6406","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzICZ8WiPrQzBNncgB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I listened to the Suno/Udio Playlists and my best guess is, that AI messes up the stereo field, like having the vocals spread out by a lot. Could that picture at 8:00 be such a stero field analysis?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCwYSE0c2mOGlawmSTOMOixg","author":"@TimNeumann","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nBaIV8P-T67KUds2qxVhq17A1TCjnd0i6fYRkt_AqU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TimNeumann","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPxFvdqpcD1LVd1Dh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Gonna never use a sample ever again, after seeing this. I will use pots and pans and wooden cooking utensils for a beat. Funnily enough, I'd probably still get a copyright hit at some point. 🙄","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCQomnK85Vebx0_W5z_ag_Sw","author":"@laserfloyd","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qKwAraeIvTZrlZnVGKCYTM2qQtw6_jVnSVYJxfK2F1PGLgFu_vRTYXaEb6vCFf5wtg64Y1cV4w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@laserfloyd","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxrDayVKF2H2qlbriR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Originally found this channel through the Poisonify video and been combing through the backlog now, so impressed on your attention to detail with calling out this GenAI nonsense.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_Z4BZOOEJuXcM2I-BP2-bQ","author":"@Ashtarte3D","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JMlrmhAQY3VNQFbq9k0WPeO4-6kUsvg_n5ZCVq8Vxwk-wqMytDsDdP1kTO-ZaLCFrfzE0SUuhtc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ashtarte3D","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgySnO090W_b6fjhmMR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I used to be able to tell MP3 appart from lossless when there was a lot of brass instruments. My ears have been further damaged by my metabolic syndrome. Kids - eat well, don't do much coffee, don't smoke ... keep your ears well!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC32Tq6gmne3zD69PjIcg7Bw","author":"@maxheadrom3088","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xOKSc-W0YUguVAKnyCE5cdRr2PX4gwWTXej8sSZayHgw4TmSaxYe2FFwhwV--4VH4ahhSw54NA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maxheadrom3088","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzW1YIIXqo9VEJRgcF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i was sure i was right when guessing qobuz at the beginning of the video lmao. interesting surprise!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_tMQ1XcOfhPjHj5rRf9J1g","author":"@caldera-seven","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RP2kOyW9vd-n03gYUvEI1TlsHdaLmebHcQOJOZ9i0B_YrEsTu1xXkf6BlAJD2w4GL3s7pey1QQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@caldera-seven","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxS8JlV1ZnfuykdhCB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't totally agree, I think there are some giveaways to low quality mp3s.  I'll list a few that I pick up:\n1. cymbal crashes sound more like sand in a glass tube \n2. Clean vocals are a little fuzzy\n3. Rapid drum beats get jumbled and mix together.  As well as staccato guitar notes.\n4. Hisses and pops are completely missing.\n5. Everything sounds more \"tin-y\", or less \"full\" when wearing headphones.\n6. Subwoofer is almost inaudible on regular speakers or earphones.\n\nI grew up with music and listen to it every day.  Maybe my ear is more tuned to what I am hearing, but I am pretty sure my hearing is no better than average.  Perhaps that study was done with people that don't have music as a priority in their life?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCib-UzYdyp5MgYLqcsMH1Ag","author":"@lordvlygar2963","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/erYJTWO0O_B-5nb65oQHXNn55faK8KWSaRQZ8BaKXfBRq33u_5X-7pE3f0pB3Sl0HhJaW9s76g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lordvlygar2963","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxZ1mVM25zSRFIY5l54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love my Peloton, i am glad that you are being compensated fairly with THREE WHOLE CENTS","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHdsykxvvZzg_DQEk6KRHXg","author":"@ostalgi-tv","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h9hp5EBstdNWZ75BLHrQJl_cxmdcx8BE4WE-GrarYuplwXJfTCjgGxPkyNyBDWSSstdP4Y53HQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ostalgi-tv","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzp4iyTAJmlfz2QOHR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey Friendly here. \n\nAs someone who enjoys singing but does not have the means of studio's or financial flexibility to afford such luxuries. I find Ai to be a great \"Tool\" more so then an absolute replacement. \n\nWhile there are people who go on suno and say \"Make a song about falling in love\" and boom. \"Song\" made. \n\nI turn to Suno for the instrumentals. I write my own lyrics, and lay down my own vocals. \n\nI feel like theres a very VERY thin line between Ai and Art. \n\nThanks to the creations of Ai Art, I was able to get work done musically and even start working on  a card game for art work. \n\nI feel like if you are just going to suno and saying \"Hey suno make me a song\" and claiming it as your own but if challenged to perform it live, and you cant....then this is not \"Art\" this is just Ai. \n\nBUT\n\nIf you wrote the lyrics yourself then there's an art in that. If you sang the song yourself, there's an art in that. If you produced the beat and let an Ai sing over it, there's still an art in that. \n\nThere's a human touch in it, meaning (no matter how small) there's a \"soul\" in this produced work. \n\nI do think its criminal that there are people who go to Suno and just have Suno do EVERYTHING and they claim it as their work. \n\nBut for some people like myself, I see it more as a tool for me to use to make up for the lack of access I have for certain things. Like a Producer, beat maker, mixer, etc...Suno becomes my \"producer\" while I write the music and sing the songs. The only difference here is im not using a person, im usig an Ai as I would use a person. \n\nI'm not going to you (for example) and saying \"Hey ben. Make a rock song about getting wasted in a bar, also sing  over it, give me the rights to it, and ill say its mine\" \n\nSo i do believe there's a VERY fine line between Ai/Art. As I feel MOST people do the Ai side of things and few people do the \"Art\" side of things. \n\nMost people see this as a short cut, while few people see it as a \"Tool\" \n\nCurious to your thoughts. Again im not being hostile or anything.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSnX4Jq9onNWA5rypPJT-Vg","author":"@A-Wake-91","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/PKw59I9HE9dmXjcRJCuRvfUksnmvCoxaqbjxmGjL4oXaTrjuIhOH1H5SY5iPVNnTKS2NPHRJzMA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@A-Wake-91","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQZMbC3e5QtDYOIdl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:20 I spent some time to find it after finishing brushing my teeth become I thought my brain is glitches in the end of the day 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClImHe9h3K06hBo0sL-OxIw","author":"@Mulnader","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lbc2XNlXUGmUIwwix241Dhajvru_f0rp-5nREvHpWPeQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mulnader","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwr_ZpRP7sO09Ox9eR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It would be amazing if artist would set up their own streaming platform","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC75ADVUP27l6zsJTheviHkg","author":"@martinpetrusbreathwork","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NElIPbgLBrw8ITz5ybj8aYdhTj7ChwuOeZY2ZDNK9mZs--o6nkW8bgKghP6vffmLnZCEtswNRA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@martinpetrusbreathwork","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwoa67ubvrBNC0AFZ14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You and Venus Theory are like Batman and Robin protecting music producers. Btw I consistently got 5/6 on the NPR MP3 vs Wave thing - thought it was being able to hear high frequency well (could hear the cymbal artifacts) but I can only hear up to 14k, so maybe a good guesser, or psychic?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCE0pzD6THQFOloz7LM8xNuA","author":"@brendanmattson","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nDqFPFIkUvVenXDUMGCyKCWtZaEHm5aV1tFMIGk-mU-w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@brendanmattson","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwVc7yYUNxi2zWRtDV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Nice job !","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX90wkV74DlD14yj0Gkryzw","author":"@fredericgaufichon7373","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mSoXTfQPWzS8YPzlw4llFVpxqCVNlKlvUZeS0ua7Nu8pM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fredericgaufichon7373","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyG_64PdMhKjeLgQpN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Where is soundcloud? Did you not sign up with them?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCJrZmICaJFDAFfu84JJfg1A","author":"@jimmyQW9welB6Sm90cHNy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/leXVRYXbjhWfsiNb5zVOaAhZ-57LoaewTi63ahZQWtA8Ui4qH8J1FiXc6ZaeuI1GvE4R1GLanvg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jimmyQW9welB6Sm90cHNy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwsraIdV36CVG6lwtN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your video is reminiscent of the death throes of artists who want to be paid for the effort you put in to make your art. I am seeing content like this a lot, lately. The fear, uncertainty, and doubt around being replaced by AI is almost overwhelming. I've decided to simply embrace the AI and I no longer care about monetary compensation for human art. In the future, it will be a niche pursuit that will be seen as a hobby or novelty. Similar to doing outdated professions are, now. \n\nYour videos are always informative. And cheers to you for your efforts and music. But this video will age like wine as the AIs get better and better. UBI will only last us so long before the concept of money itself becomes outdated. That assumes these AIs will even want to keep us around. Who knows!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdYPqNDbquFY6x9mWbon7ZQ","author":"@rogerlouie1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lQ3rdMcjp87QMvC4GGR9gnVPu2YXz_sZ92GsTNQHAs2Jk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rogerlouie1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy12qD35zVrnKoV9j54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Genius! Absolute genius idea to use neuronal networks' inherent ability to detect patterns in large data sets and the fact that generative technologies include those patterns without rhyme or reason to detect AI generated garbage","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuB3dcipUczdi--mloYZcTQ","author":"@Lambda_Ovine","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/l9ZVHpKIKBDjsyNC5q0SbImpXP26nnmarZSGIHpOWSCP6C2y6d0k0oUR0mE9fMNM2drWBhvj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lambda_Ovine","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9E-63AJq95lanXI14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I had to do a double take….”from my pen is” 😂 that was unbelievable","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdh72hLk5hsR-XKyiaNrIxQ","author":"@YayRaven","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CvnLZqWgi7UFz6zGMIYrg3eLUMgFVFpKOKYeY8hq2pjYbA86Fn5bHZXNhOm1j4UMgY3T2mXb=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@YayRaven","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKEpbDKTq_Qq4Av1R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Good to see another video","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmbcUtyhfz_brqm7BQ5TncA","author":"@michaelhampner7672","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n32y83n58hCq863cLMb7El_ERq3998mEl7TKogwgneGQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelhampner7672","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymAjX8qYfm1LDN4zJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"the ai music detectors are causing problems too .  some real artist are being flagged as ai when  they are not.  i just saw a story where  ditto music removed   someone song because it was flagged as ai .even tho it wasnt ai  at all ,and she was able to prove it wasnt  ai  but they still  pulled it from  most platforms except spotify","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCfb4OdJRTIJXMUn-Af4iJxA","author":"@Sailor-Alpha","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ptdjp9KZ2nr05Vy4TASIRkI7ZbweJ0THR4URmZYqjA1364dJnwFpxXN3tVKq21XhmbvuTXUlmBQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sailor-Alpha","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJyCEWLZ1AvVPVII14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Can you do a video(s) re: psychedelics, insofar as sonic reception, interpretation and how the hallucinatory effect in it's auditory expression affects how we hear, feel and experience music and/or sound in general?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCagMxPXtbn6uKY5sZhNHYtw","author":"@noNdeSCRIpt732","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mc4Y9gQCEiemTFxftMBzkVs4f2dFVKIi2EzfEXVVougJ-byH1unVlcX4jadECPvzh2lg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@noNdeSCRIpt732","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwePNVddwR7ncU2JYh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The issue is now that digital distibutors are making musicians be a part of the AI catalogs.  It is also important to realize that the subscription models have their own catalogs, and the work is considered a work for hire, so an individual has the right or release ir commercially as the owner of the music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSnVnwvuBklLlHq0mMKCE_Q","author":"@Provocateurofendtimes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qIGIu89xcmBWmtLYerOZRr6DamCj_hzIOH29HMQKywEF-GMhxUM7QIVUG3cQAOehcX1PkUy5M0E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Provocateurofendtimes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzI4OuQpO4oTIkUJXZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"1:50 hehe i noticed the little leaf :P","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjTVYTG7jzlZLfdmI5FxGUA","author":"@Pyroific","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1cj3jeWL1Oyqgnarw73oPSptYiM6ADBDfPMxjndoZSj_RxRdHgJPw9bCU7diBCbHDvnZyHD_-w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Pyroific","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyCK6auJTznx7Qr5B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Am a Patron, happy to be one. I don't even use it for anything, I just want to keep watching your videos.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLilLp9bYmGi3kOfngWhUaw","author":"@ToneSmith.DownState","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/b9B5E61eYHBvWG9YbBdgjMsiP3S0rTgVWjz5cCBcPm_yVzWDvJsj8zsByUEG7AQpCNbvwn-C=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ToneSmith.DownState","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzl3P2LIvUEK6yvMAx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:10  I bet AI could accurately read and write these numbers.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCF6DEtaoKw5NMy6F2rgC9ew","author":"@BerkmanHouse","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m5SPzS-Fews5qjBgjTw7gDi-977jn2HgnIBsiPQ5uIIw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BerkmanHouse","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyCu-JtyWtI9Vd-pIJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I must say, a pretty interesting video and the comments are interesting too, feels like what you'd find around say 2010.\nI came here looking for a tool to detect AI music, but if I can't have that, I at least want to know what song plays at 10:38 .","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4VAVP8ZtJmFvm_WNW0sH5A","author":"@jking4854","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mZ0qdNj37q0jFa3A-yTYuuxpsnOBUi0iwTyWhWaTp70Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jking4854","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFZRkKd0OIcSFAWy94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Tbh, when you said that we'd never guess who paid the most I just figured it was some small no-name service that I'd never heard of. I was still wrong.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSJCGhwxEhtOGUpSYMhayyg","author":"@spykercar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7fNpagTOi_9PEepDvypzeFdeMUCZ9c_yZVaRc6lPK_EGVx8Q9Rn_wQWSzV5E3_Uy33UyIKBXNwM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@spykercar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxDQ5TWUIQ7YEultZh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Best channel on YouTube.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxHo5sy8PLalR-Ma2zIPlvw","author":"@randomgeek6035","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3eSdJrs9xkcAFM7kExUd2KzasO2x_y1BOcwBOQFRsO4jhq02GQpbHzLNdWF64M9fNlQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@randomgeek6035","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwWGFJGb092-1pMAbx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’ve been in the music industry for over 35 years, and the real issue now is that the market is being flooded with low-quality material. What Suno is doing, however, is a game changer. It essentially opens up a studio where you can take a track, separate it into stems, and then convert each stem into MIDI. If you’re stuck on a part, you can run it through, generate multiple variations, and build from there. You can even create your own custom loops.\n\nIf this continues in the direction it’s going, the traditional music industry as we know it is finished—and honestly, I hope it is. For years it has done little more than corrupt minds and push disposable content. For writers who have strong lyrics and need a track to showcase them, this is one of the best tools available to promote real songwriting skill. Personally, I made far more money DJing than I ever did from streaming.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiruUKWJ4MPFcwSwZu1N2-w","author":"@Electro_Sabotage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/OzuvTppxPgUoehz79eP1mY5K8TKiY7tpEj1T-OllFND_6G3aJWA7axKfLzUR3Usew3osa9-C1g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Electro_Sabotage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwW4VqTgrmIZpNQinF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:18 0.03*","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCvoF3r14Y5iZ3ggIipWJ-8g","author":"@Jamman1403","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cpNGDR7Qv0-cErKi73qI9n4rvCz6lakCTDgusUk0IevEYJVmY1jIyjIywi9bVMUdMeR87GITLQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jamman1403","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxl2u2xMV_J3GMGl-Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"While I never would have thought of Peleton, it doesn't come as a surprise they pay well considering how much money they make from, and throw at, their 24/7 live service group exercise routines. Those machines are fancy.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCU0Nz7zYYvXROJp1iROC-Kw","author":"@PBOZAI","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/igz_VWtm-pBh3Vyifoh2KpvJxRWnjV7kR9aela0SFId0x5aayJaVSgWmtmKdGZi1rssSRsI6iQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PBOZAI","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_Xccf9_8AALe2xYV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Qobuz is where I buy all my lossless reference tracks from. Most songs are available in multiple formats, including raw wav files. Never used the streaming but it’s been great for buying lossless music files.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCw11zcCaH4oW6CAOWE-r--Q","author":"@mrnelsonius5631","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nEhUp8gIDnyAGfjd0xl2VULlQbBWPGcJ4C5TuyHwc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mrnelsonius5631","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzaVYRvbGVpIE9m7hF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In other words, now and the next few years is actually a great time to start an original live performing band. The reasoning is, ai song makers whether mostly original or not will not be able to perform with the same fidelity live or just post consistent original content that their fans enjoy in general. Being an original live performing band would really start to stand out abit more in a Market that is now saturated with small hobby artists and ai generated crap. Something to think about.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqqWHzx66BPdT2rYMVs0k4Q","author":"@Mrskyrimtroll","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNZtDRN-ZdYsI3yJHxXCutfQU-24R0-ucFEwh35G-Iv_E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mrskyrimtroll","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwX4vIHA9WMctYgI-p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Every time I see a video or a body of work from a creator where I think it is worth more than what they receive from my youtube premium membership, I feel a bit like a leech because I simply can not afford supporting the creators that I enjoy more than the meager payout from youtube premium. Since the whole subscription thing started with Jack (I was an active listener and follower of Pomplamoose when they were starting out), I have only ever subscribed to a tiny twitch channel that I never actively watched live but still felt they deserved my support. That has ended a long time ago because I can't even afford that. Recurring costs are one hell of a dangerous way to go broke, which is why I avoid them wherever I can. Making one time donations is something far more manageable but when money is always tight, it's very easy to look at what you saved up and then spend it on something you could really use right now, instead of splitting it into many small chunks and donating it to creators. All that to say, I know you can't pay your bills with warm words of gratitude and the few cents my views and listens pay you, but it is all I can give. Maybe one day I will have the disposable income to be able to subscribe to multiple patreons, or just buy all the albums I like but that day isn't here yet.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIv_95pF4LOZSAN7434U0Qg","author":"@ZeroKey92","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kf_djLuZ23vKD8jBbnNSRdPQAD4hiYrRIgY6Dmz58=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ZeroKey92","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy3GbAq9vXa-OHOtFN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video as always Ben . When will artists unite and start a mass exodus from platforms like Spotify ? Is this because the labels won’t ? I think it will not happen by consumer behaviour wanting to be more ethical , the large majority will stick with convenience .","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXqqvOvfx9FykhZ54F3ekDQ","author":"@neurodelicus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lsAcKph6gLlA1tfwfcMM5yuZMqrrmmaGYqkpZkMBI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@neurodelicus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxReHLs2XQ97guohtV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My toxic trait is believing I can hear the difference between lossy and lossless audio files, and I think I'm actually right","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4BgoQQttepog-B--6JkJ-Q","author":"@hearth_beat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x857l8YafsKYatlk_jGVyjPoN-wTphquocyht3gA2smU5OvDm-iB6OHnYiVSuR7ZPKCuYM0QkGU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hearth_beat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-AXmmApMsaQoG3lx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My \"problem\" with this is as follows: I play guitar. I am by no means proficient enough to professionally record me playing it, but I do enough that I can make it sound pretty good and have some riffs I'm really proud of. Plus, I have been writting my whole life. So I welcomed Suno into my life, I played my riffs, inserted my own lyrics and let the AI do the thing. Then I edit and polish it a fair bit and  shared that as the final product. I do not consider myself a musician,  and by your standards the music I have put out is AI generated music (it is) but there's some human touch in it that, in my opinion, will go without notice that really shouldn't. I am proud of \"my\" songs, I play along to them and it makes me happy to be able to share them. So my question really is this: what's the line? Where is the line when a song that you wrote, have written the words for and have edited to the best of your abilities, stop being music and start being seen as AI garbage or fake music?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCukuJQOu8AMgu0roYDqPH_Q","author":"@carlosmgpinheiro","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k81r7EhXh-GL2IUyG8rUmUSQwvpvOR_YKmw4bTeAbtVg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@carlosmgpinheiro","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-AXmmApMsaQoG3lx4AaABAg.AD4Dh5rCfYMADARFfe6MKs","parent":"Ugy-AXmmApMsaQoG3lx4AaABAg","text":"The line between is if the majority of what you're liking in the music, and listening to is the AI part. Ai should be used to enhance the music, not make the music. Try to make music, like online instruments, it's not boring","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCSBtQno8-aP5crBw4Kgp4-g","author":"@D3sidero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VUPWwOFUTDBw1bnmApsfw0Ofha2GGAFTu_ouQDFd6rOfJFh_b2DKcnnFbKbLOFxTSc-VyYqL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@D3sidero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzwtwkOW_o--Au1VFR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"suno 3.5 and v4 still have that recursive twang and rhythm that make them hard to mistake. They make me want to scream within 3 or 4 measures (assuming there are no vocals) and within the first sentence if there are vocals. I was really into the tech since riffusion though so I guess my ears just learned.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClTjpf-pyFBRWDF3dPfLcJA","author":"@sleepy__4est","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsruIRqfcMl9AJ9-GSu57RXPwcczl_xOWyzT96qnaApNQ-M3s6Upf5zZJKrA0rVul9Zw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sleepy__4est","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwuS9QUCl-Y0Bk_HpR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i like using my album collection, backing it up in my daw then use aimp for my music player. i didnt know how much i missed messing with the files on my phone.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW0w-fB_X3tgmFmm5JHCk7w","author":"@Indigamesforlife","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_loTZk4uCT9a2IjwdZ2wTh9ffTectXTSNlw_qyRMPaJkgw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Indigamesforlife","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxfl5-4M-qz_B-Vg0d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I have something that is able to identify AI music from Udio and Suno instantly. It's my ears :D","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdLU47yRsEK_gwaB1zyo9eA","author":"@TomášVician","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mDPjp7u1hfC-vIJ9E8n9Z3L-5b1beK-vHO0aa0HCfVMWc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tom%C3%A1%C5%A1Vician","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJMNj8NPUQzywnylp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"because of the way \"ai\" works, it will eventually turn out that Rick and Morty were waaaay ahead of the time with their \"human music\" 😂😂","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC4vmbSDrhyu8PsYGTaYvTvQ","author":"@rikkt731","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yofxQEavQGRHx832UO45YzctNCKSJV71Yko8Yue3_OEHy5rXIC41seau9ywbaAYER6JmHJ7Brw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rikkt731","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxisxJ2pg5fnMHAJW94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hearing the difference between mp3 and wav is only ever easy when you work consistently with raw audio. lets say i spend a month on a song to release it the next, when compressing to mp3 the difference is clear but thats only because ive been hearing the raw for the last month. because of that though im able to tell and i assume others who at least mix/master can tell. regardless, because streaming services compress so heavily, its best to upload in the highest quality possible (wav, 32bit depth, 512 resampling)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvCtFLH_xa6l_Ou3Yi6GECA","author":"@Burner1938","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FmA0NnBrCcblxvMyDmBaHpzygFm_yg9xJSWumCz5MFHpFLANBvEPWwazcOpY-IYepX2-aejX9Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Burner1938","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyoc-VabgI8OdNCrGx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Our reality needs to be accepted, everything around us is changing. Previously, you would have to walk miles in order to reach your destination, but now you will not have to walk miles as AI is the same thing.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCumR7J6W18wkmKnpSviwQqw","author":"@ebrunostation","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KGH6FdtMyY2U8epTmVmaEgeBBFyG-0sD4Tg5wXVwMfSHxWCsjh_fp1ffCAEDE3KMEuJerxTbgFM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ebrunostation","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzBd6KiIKCinwDYgLl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi Benn, I don't have a specific problem with AMU, mostly because I bought into their speaker ecosystem. I recently resubbed with them, despite being with YTP. Now YTP has become essential, so I'm having to have a second music streaming sub to AMU, to make use of my speaker collection once again. Unfortunately (the reason I can't stand Amazon) their speakers do not support direct streaming of YTM.\n\nI wonder about your take on YTM, I don't think you've mentioned how much they support the musicians. My assumption is not just YTM alone but with the side benefit of being part of YT platform, helps in the overall numbers. E.g. at least YTP sub contributes a greater portion of the ad revenue to you from views of your videos.\n\nThanks to this video, I feel good about resubbing with AMU.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRjqeoCF4-xQArUY_4cN04w","author":"@CloverMind","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhvZkbLJ79K9roiYHSwpdEAHFWiGJLn6hNxGDimc4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CloverMind","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxCUtQUvUBXmsIYg4d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bandcamp?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCRKfa8auKsg1DlwL-_KejcQ","author":"@eliotcamel7799","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_JuDVn7sIxJ_SFjb5GNRf9rgYt0fQ6k2fGuQ-2J9ZCWI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@eliotcamel7799","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwvSp-oPlrHxcCq5ZJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:17 I... didn't expect that","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmWXj5id_yASkgeC8qfO8nA","author":"@smol_white_bat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/f03bQfboHP02Rql42rZ42pfc9xAx3bzHbOcyebrjpeGLi-Ife4-RuYWOTrOeX19j8nqcW94pG7k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@smol_white_bat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzLetNGLNcoiuId6hB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"First of all, I'm glad that your channel exists and that you make such serious videos about what we're doing in music production.\r\nOpinions.\r\nIf you want to use the suno to take loops, either a part of your own imported YOUR SELF CREATED audio samples that you've cut out a part of specifically to use the ai as a tool and then edit the sample that it will produce for you, or even if you import a demo of yours and then take parts again and these become samples of the production and then you orchestrate the song, play other parts and complete the song traditionally.\r\nAll of this is like taking samples from a sample library. The ai becomes a sample tool on demand.\r\nIf you take this song then it will still be defined as a suno song if you haven't tampered with the sound to a degree that it doesn't even make sense.\r\nSo what's the difference between someone who takes the song as it is and someone who uses this a.i. as a tool and not as a a.i. composer?\r\nWhy are they both defined as suno (a.i. generated music)?\r\nIt's not right to put them all in the same bucket.\\\n\n05.44 I could always hear the difference, focus to the higher frequencies and listen the rotary like effect is like the highs \"crying\" while \"they are less high\" than the uncompressed. You need to understand first the difference in between same filtered and unfiltered frequencies.\n(and I know some people will troll \" you can't hear it\" I even had a \"competition\" with friends to convince them mixing different tracks specs and I did. \nHowever my listening diagram goes higher than the average and I am an engineer","like_count":2,"author_id":"UChppOjL1LRI-FiL-mZ6znbQ","author":"@DontReply2me","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bsiR_YyVwoONS89PJ9cIt2K3yWUbLdibX_p02WsJoZLnC3UpJHvGZM2c3etUuu-4kLyQOw8YTjA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DontReply2me","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzLetNGLNcoiuId6hB4AaABAg.AFc_pcmHtMNAFzGFRROJ5d","parent":"UgzLetNGLNcoiuId6hB4AaABAg","text":"\"It's not right to put them all in the same bucket.\"\n\nI am using Suno (and other AI) in precisely this way and you are absolutely right. Suno is a fantastic creative tool for musicians and Benn is turning a blind eye to the slander he is engaging in when he claims his \"detection\" will prove a lack of creativity.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwpkeY4tAgBumIHZB1Pu1XQ","author":"@filtomsun","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TJzYIepQ8aoOMxw7nGIt9DIa3_uk1u1OfEvqKANZqjG9QaZ0_EVv5ODas_zjgnnpstnyYTqiYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@filtomsun","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6BbAN_Axmpqo53at4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The thing that frustrates me about music streaming is how America-centric every option seems to be.\n\nI'm a fan of a particular niche music scene that's dominated by Japanese indie artists, and while the artists that are still active are using Spotify more and more, I've basically been forced to use YouTube for the longest time because that's the only place to find the music I listen to the most! Even if I tried switching to Spotify, I'd be losing a lot of older songs (including some that still only exist as YouTube reuploads, and their original uploads on Japanese websites don't even exist anymore).\n\nAt this point, I've started buying my music again. I'm planning to get a refurbished ipod so I can enjoy it without notifs but it just sucks so much.\n\nCurrently I'm more broke than I've ever been in my adult life, so I really can't afford it. But music is important to me, it helps get me through this crap, so I'm gonna have to figure something out. I'm worried we're heading towards an implosion when it comes to music streamers, and I don't wanna lose the music I love if things change","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQwxcyLIrPWNQfGMuXBA4Ow","author":"@jaceybella1267","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nOyuGwcGEJbd1E7ghDD5e8LLw3TT5pVj6kmUYqNHALUw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jaceybella1267","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy3SHMSTrGDIj2OVIx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I would have loved to see how often Apple loops get songs copyrighted since that's my main usage!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3z2i-eLTuCEyad9yqymNUQ","author":"@notall2gether","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4wbi_Mx1-AjPDJfjeM7BoFBxSBc5eOp9Ij-oD7rR4pLEeZwoCSr6Eef5YBWD1Fxtn12x9wBlcw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@notall2gether","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxPkCF961myId5RHlN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"this is good for now, but it wont be good enough in 5 years","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC_jy7deTzCku5GRfySX22ug","author":"@NUVERSA","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Ti9IoQHDBwx1HPm69id8dOC2_Aw-UN4UB8IvjEgdmiEP0lnM464C2nN9L5DSKYiKRiA_FOmqrw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NUVERSA","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxuFMqkMzOg-GwoqzR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you Benn, you are a God send to all of the people who actually care about quality content. I will pray for you making sure your ass goes to heaven.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCc-NbhDm6OcHLjIT0v9s_JA","author":"@crispyluck9763","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0pQrDtG7nUKYIaq0mcAivlUoVQUArWiK_ikd0IJjsZITRtRRx4teapahhttazDFWT_zlWmzQOUU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@crispyluck9763","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx607aRLlziQ0JGZGx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about samples that come with a DAW? What about synth presets? Or is anything shorter than a couple seconds, less likely to trigger these content ID systems? \n\nI think all this opens a can of worms leading into what actually makes music unique… people are really going to have to push the boundaries to stand out and the only way to get spotted will be using mixed-media… which is then impossible for an independent solo musician to release an album of music videos, interactive content, visual art and music, without hiring numerous artists… which would then make music less democratised and accessible… Its all a bit fucked really, isn’t it?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCwJGzmCvZI9Hb3gDedVyEaQ","author":"@RobertKgma","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nYlu4PY8ZZj_JELG6yYhb3o-PbKxqHT1U3Wg0cMFsGx1I=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RobertKgma","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwGGBqmfaY7lWmshvp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Inflation acts like inflation. No mater what the subject is.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC0O_0qiefjORJ6HeNmenzyQ","author":"@GolfswagenGarage","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7XzlrrQaO-9j-K2oGIPZfYLPUQQ0bg-DDYeGJNM7B9FCISOIWLea7Vq4Tcp7ax9DYbqUL2Kxnw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GolfswagenGarage","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxMwngVYsyCKOOdaV94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I haven’t looked into audio ai in a while but the last time I did most of the good ones were literally using wavetable resynthesis with images representing the audio. So it may be that you’re also picking up on the resolution of that image rather than double compression.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCh5kzk-2iBRmJ7wQiBdHCWg","author":"@yoyofargo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mMk6weWQVbCQqwgswJxTp08NwOyN0K-GS9ywfIfBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yoyofargo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwNrYIXKn4-qsHwrNh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great points, all spot on Benn! \nFrankly I am so bored of Spotify, Tidal, Apple coz their algorithms are really shitty, haven’t got a clue what I really like…  nothing worse than a shitty algorithm 😂😂😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvzyLu01vgrP3Hy6J2LHc7A","author":"@jupiternteardrop237","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mXl5vEZetSFCfuG2B7_VLqc38fE5TVJMtL_CGIeMUbdXJf55quvy5KONcX81xCv66Llw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jupiternteardrop237","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzvYBBy65bEwK-xz6N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're hacking the system. \nThe Avantgarde.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC48oQg54olwrUthlJnCRlnA","author":"@speckles9251","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/OFS2DFZbqhUpHIn7yhpompuHSD7ea3pNYk3MaUphXnNddNs3ghO1z52nZAfEV5IshZ_lWeyUNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@speckles9251","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyDASJbm5abzGBpKo54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"GREAT VIDEO","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCikg8hEUAr4S2HzdpyEbmfA","author":"@larsreifenberger6800","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k0bhdgxFVqZMZQV-B6NnjY6XCXu76VFUA1JnkMY4O1wvTyamt7Ebo8tPQ0R01kLPCHsQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@larsreifenberger6800","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2Vr_k7hG0PJiAFth4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"im gonna guess apple music. just because seems like all the famous people use it","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCszg2TjDMaL30iLCnNe7QnA","author":"@adamreynolds3863","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lgs9tTCp5OweF6wX89z8__DpfrbsYtIdV615jnFBQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@adamreynolds3863","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgykXBknQc5ujz8NAiB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:08 - 6:06 the only time i've been able to tell lossless from lossy was the intro to BT's \"Suddenly\". All those granular glitches sound a little muddy in a lossy format.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCus_6dP3sgJUvP8TpKSHsLg","author":"@birchwwolf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TBdOwxnXy_wvwcHnBTV8EulYzwPQlgILdMYqBdDEpKpkJv9JimuT9fNw1WfwbxA2Xv3MKW6kWg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@birchwwolf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwMKLqA_JD74oSqvpJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"am I crazy or is the image at 1:13 when referencing the guy he talks to AI Art?  It sure looks like AI at a glance, and that would be silly like \"ay it sucks AI is taking over music\", and then just use AI for art in your video?","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCSbDK_H2erMwurkNbIlDicg","author":"@GivenKittens","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/OIyTZA0ckMCTynbQd1ONbT5EejLaV3x39Q-WreI3kJJFtjaW-bx8OLBg_XDRcWiWzaElJAW5Uw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GivenKittens","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz4pUrlBnsdtkAcfyF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am one of those rare people that can tell the difference, at least at around 128-192kbit. Never tried more. And I noticed how compressed and terrible sounding AI music was right away. It’s much more obvious to me","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC0ecA3O7Ay1JrYCV06PcNew","author":"@drd2093","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kFmx7dqJ3IeFYh8EVx9k_VVcgijgIIEZTfgDy5Vx8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drd2093","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzKzGg-xLazkrR8OKF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I really hope all platforms start labeling tracks when they’re detected as 90%+ AI-generated. Right now, Deezer is the only one actually doing something about it — the rest are letting AI sludge slide through untagged (at the moment)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCThSPfq9Nml9mvyRRaohlVg","author":"@Aylinkamusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WoO0hEc6VPRd6HEqSn0nakk7EGbCWpUrf5JQeiOOBPK4JyDJYZwl_JyrDFFdEFoljml8Gs2yYQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Aylinkamusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzj05aQ9G8wvYALTUZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Got a suno ad on this video lmao","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCC4w6UTRD0wYe7TvYPzRuQw","author":"@thermo_vrc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3eTFIq74fMVzBILtF7tlZTcp5DHFZtjFTf9ImFnHHgLAy9sZUi0IqFWdP_2juQeItXnVjU-mCVY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thermo_vrc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWA46FBsducGI3xkN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think all AI-generated music tracks sound like... well, AI-generated music. They're easy to recognize. They often sound weird, with an unusual texture, almost like they're mixed with white noise. And AI doesn't really feel the direction of music. It's as if it's just switching scale degrees and chords randomly, without any real sense of purpose.\nI mean... does anyone seriously not notice this? I just can’t believe it. Especially when it comes to vocals. It’s so freaking weird and annoying!\nAnd, I really like your channel, dude!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsSWXxDDvLovto-0UIlI9fQ","author":"@kovoliver","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lA0GAjykl7dhxBrMeNt-L-cSOvp-jjfiyYlMxi9FU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kovoliver","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWA46FBsducGI3xkN4AaABAg.AIV9Val-atcAJrrLaoWDnq","parent":"UgzWA46FBsducGI3xkN4AaABAg","text":"Not all AI music is \"weird\" \"unusual\" or as crappy as your making it out to be! There's this AI rap song that came up on my recommended page called \"My Hellcat Trippin\" by Piink Ivy, and... I LOVE it! To me, it sounds like an actual rap song that I would hear on the radio. And this female AI artist's other songs sound good too. My point is, don't paint all AI music with the same \"it sounds like AI music\" brush.","like_count":3,"author_id":"UCYieAUQR-8Kj4k_JAiwWUeg","author":"@enchantingempressoflight","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bDmEeIzU8iEs84qnjq4oQmU32HSmIPelGBIAuD4pAEj1eOa8B1oZJm7LqflZVR2N1zwVyEzhwQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@enchantingempressoflight","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbpMSx8ej5wxwjL8J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"thank you so much for your work!!!!❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgfF1QAW77lD5_TjPmhzVJQ","author":"@kayosipoff6423","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYXWjb4uti23S6OUJFlKqqBIC9WdD2oxTwlQ0w2pOXSQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kayosipoff6423","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyJ3801YH9NAr5ULjV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As for my guess for “streaming service” that pays the most is gonnna be the good ol radio","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-i5kzLnxWZL2fk6aNzBGgw","author":"@lfraser7128","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m_LcoFYiVm8kIJI-Qd-6Wdq4-Z6a6vZkdPv1wHzVsyzsY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lfraser7128","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxT4gSXpz8Mqf4TOP94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you Ben 👏👏👏","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC73lPWCETsyn365Ae_ghJzQ","author":"@mthomas1091","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsBrK1lw4dV11a0fgBp0rS6sd5GnSpQAHEx_UMtOg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mthomas1091","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzbRPPxLccePIl3Rfx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"There’s enough public domain digital photos out there that when combined with non-AI filters, a “copyright free” stable diffusion can be trained.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCi6FF4baR7Rr7ahKDD06D0Q","author":"@1dkappe","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nFkofkMRrShqa_JTG1Z2uY_vLrWgrAtXSTU6TGMZdhBTw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@1dkappe","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzy7sCW4oe1CFuZgiJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I knew Qobuz would be number 1, as it literally dedicated itself to hifi audio and buying physical/digital albums from the artists. However seeing Peloton isn't confusing because performance royalties get paid more and differently than mechanical... and it's literally an exercise company... they need good playlist.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxc2xitHTTe7l59-A6tyFDQ","author":"@Reddison","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/B5KfxOdwfysE1FGqVa-STERpgWO2oOQbIx-bFbZ3tllz1BM38qQUvHvGpaYNo7KbDjKRf3AvtA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Reddison","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxseZMACQx73GEXsjB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're my actual hero.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCG1lP1A1OXJC9k9ogG7JlZg","author":"@TheAlchemistsWork","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fRvuI52VL3cAFbFybJANV_xl3aeV6XCZrI-DiLnLBKra6kD1srlUsrUAWpTtBTFkYvkSHfTHPg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheAlchemistsWork","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzZY7MwJGlbVNnx1wJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Several things I noticed comparing AI music to recorded when I looked at somethring similar \n it becomes quite obvious it’s AI if you convert the soundwave to a spectrogram; things are very quantised in the AI models and AI models also typically suck at resolving chord progressions (and more as I imagine you’ve figured out)\n\nBut by converting to a spectrogram first you get more data to be able to reliably train the model","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqM45_vhNPKUCcn9GjN19yw","author":"@BirnieMac1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lp_kdoiklW6b-8ZMaBNK_gGcJzNBxOdgyGdfL7ARD1Ww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BirnieMac1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxyKyeIgvlbY3dTNwh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I make my music in FL studio. I was JUST TALKING ABOUT THIS. The crazy part is, I had no proof until now. AI IS not supposed to replace us. It's only down hill from here ladies and gentlemen.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCerrahoDt6xfxfsvaRh6uuA","author":"@IncredibleMeep","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOAFOdRIyT-3B7hd8dJuTPq1NTwiYZzvdMik52HIaO4DU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IncredibleMeep","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_m6V1cy6GtHoyB9t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I hope my music doesn't detect as ai","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC4ggfl57RyeI0MYhmRlq64w","author":"@bapnap6218","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_meHoTC439QlqEVjYhOYsQyCLUuJdgSbFlpau0QAQWy-Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bapnap6218","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz5-vBkKsv7saAVlMF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bummer not to see SoundCloud mentioned in the streaming ranking, tho their amounts aren't much either","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtYgF2x705VSZTBl6247ywg","author":"@coderedblack","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n-iyWu0PxLhxuJl5X-4h0MGWFPfmZM4lRTGbtEcUc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@coderedblack","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxEqeswSf6-M5zL1jR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you for staying on YouTube!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJpJ4L0HnZLZSV40mgzJyog","author":"@Greenteabook","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mITfPZeKDMPDaInMY0o9QZ3UCV1337x9qrf-ngWMg-irmr=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Greenteabook","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyXo_R-vKR0dxHxN0d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"respect and thanks for video","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVA321I14GIb1K2ROu8jStw","author":"@akkamiau","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k0ZD3DCAt-Uk_iysDEpDT-SfHPgUa5nIrp9tEoPah5OI4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@akkamiau","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzV7k1cRYat_kEqe8J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How about learning to play music.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC5-YcTjJevp00rQGHDMH92Q","author":"@ericwalks1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lz9LFhAhrDVma2B0alF6NL881xKEE-flL5E7IPTXu9=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ericwalks1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzYZ_RqHZB3pF9BKIl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Worth to note for the Indian listeners that Jiosaavn, gaana and hungama paid zero. I hope some Indian indie artist makes a video so we know if it was really no one streaming there or they don't pay if it's under a certain threshold","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnUtrtbR06XWLdu6DHFNNLw","author":"@Nopey-none","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hzf5SXMGIQYJc9093KWhs8vR0AId_qQIQ8E4IBHX3E3OBSXTzrpekZakgp4e7GkqBaA3vQvY4g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nopey-none","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgybO5-M1b5EGnGCjtR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wish more artists sold their music digitally. I personally am addicted to kpop right now and you can get Atmos versions of songs but only through an apple music subscription. And the only way they actually sell their music is through albums that are mostly just photo books with a cd slapped in the back","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCilCqplaPdjTDJRmmjk0GyA","author":"@DropIet","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hLDwc90q8-CUmkgBtyj0Z6qQ0BH__QrDjVvt_lW9cgr4D1eD3i4AX5EmjryGISdLRD6mKoh9PQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DropIet","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzj_4RdizRsPEkp69B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The entire music IP protection ecosystem is a dumpster fire. What a mess.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCE0lgvbLAueJuAes8zSQN6g","author":"@touchthatdial","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kZuilMfxj5PImZM1A3I8BnU3xb8QbnaemgnBUQDMYq2DP9oL_IKvimuDh7U2oAw-yNMA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@touchthatdial","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwFhCp1FVIsbhC4Xcx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Good fella, right on.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChBbJAIf_z5hDPMm-Mubn9g","author":"@Happy_Biker","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nHLplf38HhcthMWd94rHoP0bQlWvMPXXP2wA94JR81dw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Happy_Biker","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyOWZFeESaAXtwIpyp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm fine with using AI to generate or critique code to get things done faster but not something that can potentially be part of your personality. \"Art without human connection is not the same.\"","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCKKAc_bGNdUZZsiHWTuICPQ","author":"@FlatMcdonaldsSprite","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GzQgvE-sf52FCE56hmUcwr45rORSrM8ldU_nnP6Ap-PWlctFuD71ajVSpUE47mHnFa9-kuwPPg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FlatMcdonaldsSprite","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw1HC9PiCpwn5pbZw94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Every time I read the thumbmail my brain goes \"proof of AI poisoning\" and I think I'll just leave it there.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCK4ilum_LbCgNAqk9IL0mlw","author":"@That__Guy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LGeeJGVAlCx6zMee9lU19ynXF2BchYaZvgJwfaNdu_xUlUzHeX0_VVfrtYxdKYrUR9kxcOLWJA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@That__Guy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyv9h04hdWr1aCemDJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"sure I hear it quite easily but, I need to compare them. The difference is in the lack of details and precense.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkzWey2JlKL4kTyt4cI8cgA","author":"@gunnarwaage4343","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kB10mwafyqYNjXRZbG4akJKuJ4srPDwSpCV3_NUiiwnWc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gunnarwaage4343","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxeD6soNZel9CiR4Tt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Musicians tell me: I'd rather have my entire music career ruined,  plus all the careers of all the musicians I know, then to complain even once about the Universal CEO, making a $300,000,000.00 (300 million) bonus, while music sales are half of what they were in 1999.\n(The Big Three Labels that control the entire music industry and your career are Universal, Sony, Warner.)\nThen I say, \"What???\"","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCrCw_wCm3xVof0YrHQhvvLA","author":"@TomHendricksMusea","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l_mi1JHlL0oCMadfL7GxnmEJfeI6R8Nb2hoBZWlQQnSN0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TomHendricksMusea","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwmHLBk8c2kQXu555F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I was hoping to see SoundCloud mentioned in the overviews. I wonder why it's not.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKu7sPiUElOo6_QHhWZy1tQ","author":"@Slurkz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n7cKKoTVveU5xi9oUbSidpWj--d2UwyKdh3m8DgdYvt6g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Slurkz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzONjtsTH3BJtNnuW14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"surprised soundcloud wasnt even on the list","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCr6-kXCJKKGsYu6uXo9SAwQ","author":"@edeltobi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kmZjb4mxuwwzm4mCgudMfsxjFKMERd47eGRKKswNM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@edeltobi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwzHbB8wCwtN0VzXJR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did you really create and implement your own AI-detector from scratch? Most impressive.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRpRmd11krbz2AyVxAyFhSw","author":"@trapkat8213","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mBAE8a3C1UADw_I5ZDtWXkWWt1XR5rvjLRRsGN0yo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@trapkat8213","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx8wBq1Mu4wnpMMEvB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"interesting, cancelled my spotify a week ago because i will quit (hopefully switch) jobs and simply wanted to reduce monthly cost as I have a sufficient digital library via cd' rips and bandcamp, just was too lazy to update much. it had me finally buy some of my recent fav albums and using the disk space on my phone that was usually unused for songs doesnt make any problem. i just havent for a single second thought about the points you bring up, just thought the app was messy in design and a bit laggy.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHBNU8nwOQ-JYVJhfArIdFQ","author":"@trveheimer6360","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dQ4sqEOgiwKrMebpSPiQFrJhTkEmoCG0s4Kc05BzqOQoY7ibX4YAGRLbpjlUx39Ogk_DQUlNHrI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@trveheimer6360","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqoNjRzV_xIt-U4nZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you so much!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCleDF5idYTmjWUexN3HMgyA","author":"@cojack55","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lT9_A3ieNi4QnTNb1eBRDNftiELxeuw3BWKfwWBBV-I8Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cojack55","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxTipskyqhF3dztNU54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I create AI songs using my own lyrics and for the female vocalist songs I created a cyber female artist. Not trying to fool anyone. Just enjoying a new type of creation. If I create a song and  you enjoy listening to it, I feel that's the point and the payoff.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCpU8xSHlow99ckgAQWWWRLg","author":"@getkraken8064","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m-CAuKRia7RGYcJ8nljqDrthQjAUoNnMnzPdHeo3SU5A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@getkraken8064","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwOXwE37x3n_P8rU3F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I can easily tell on YouTube if the audio quality isn't right but they do have very aggressive bitrates. 128 is where it's obvious if I'm paying attention to details. But if you're not using nice gear and have that attention level then it won't even register.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1u8BBMaE4MjJOBSdStndGw","author":"@joeykeilholz925","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mO_7JkYmjHZS_dZy5S1AiIYpNam8hYO7FPr1Bu6X_6As80=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joeykeilholz925","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLU6KSdci-PumHvM94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I feel a little violated that your peener thanked us.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0F174i6GJFMZkRpHoRMadg","author":"@thinthinwalls","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_laBkO0_Glup3UMcgP89JUNobQqEW44y0xUzkuFBQU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thinthinwalls","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzDjeJQxguMoIToNbN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:30 Limewire, final answer lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtB7Sl4Upaxf97X9GlhMleA","author":"@josephkebbekus5780","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lDk84aa-lWsHTpRnOBXEt7aTGdRfhLBN2V6vgkPBM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@josephkebbekus5780","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxnrgvqFnssefB6T4J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am looking forward to the day some genius comes out with a browser/app that somehow magically filters all the Ai slop away. In the meantime having multiple tools at our disposal to filter thru the muck is not only greatly appreciated but pretty much is becoming a requirement.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCw_G86AxzO1xLy70lmtD9Rg","author":"@evo2542","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_BQmT656RjTB0Fo_RmWtkxDEv1qMnCO750QJ06QA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@evo2542","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyH5VhC2bErBwozF6Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This guy fucking rocks.... just saying.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCfXbHh6GOPcBZP-FGOeWwEQ","author":"@jeremysharp4218","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mqVeLam5TH4WQwsovTRf5P3dDnKXRvQXwcvq6_NpdGEA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeremysharp4218","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzBS6inbeU4BywwwDB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Buy digital downloads of albums you like direct from artists if you want to support them, thats money directly to them and often you can get a physical disc and digital download bundled for a decent price, like 15 or 20 bucks.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC49TOorbE2CN-AyShi-vqHQ","author":"@augmented2nd666","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TJi3n2Wj-sgIF4pSskmGMswFWyJ2ooSxn-OHIcWjJDvsA8RXEUbYkYBkGIImNuLYHlyQTwD9=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@augmented2nd666","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwL5SsayWFYZjCP7bR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"😮American calls soccer 'football' quite correctly.  I'm blown away.😁","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOdMeMmwlo6tinY2y0w7olg","author":"@DungeonTV100","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mTgQUUfZJO3ooAVOh9ZAC_14Sh8t5OveiHMMCNCWCkgX0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DungeonTV100","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGKc32d1EcZuMbktV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Strangely enough you can see the difference of quality on the dancefloor. If you would ask if they could hear the difference they would look confused yet on the dancefloor people stop dancing when the quality goes down. I've tested this a number of times. It's not what you hear but what you feel.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtJHrlL0ulpT74Q61TX_eog","author":"@blu8print","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kjNoyR7PS4vhI6zkVgmju_7iqpptxJd1dsqLQ2ZJmrwXhGYyV6dzb9lGdFAIlpKCasCw0aYra6A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@blu8print","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwWpYqG__tnL7qs24h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i used to do different bitrates of the macarena and post them on napster/limewire as a new release from random band :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqMMCGiSRDf5gTfZEqZWdwA","author":"@BlahSnarto","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k7_XW2DiPNyNG4Z_wNgnHGg2KXAgflkT9HKIMaN8x3-50=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BlahSnarto","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-zFHDP4pmlnx-TNN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Please take this video out of slog 😭","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCsJadfwM6nxj7F7ni4zht_g","author":"@nekumelon9121","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oGfQdBWFx5Wi8Ruzd3QqPWg5l0PYt5Fa1dBJA_mrhIT1t64g_fvG6y3lsoGqvruZOxDSu3TT=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nekumelon9121","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJNgJ-utwh6f7Jk8h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Even with my 52 year old, thrash metal damaged ears, I can still easily hear the weird, high frequency \"shimmering\" caused by low sampling rates. It kind of sounds like the susurration of metallic crickets. Weird how the actual quality of your organic microphones (IE: ears), is less important than the software and hardware of your brain. It's exactly like how I can still see stuff that others can't, even with my blurry, long-sighted vision. The human brain is a wondrously mystifying thing.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTxRf83ELCZQzWjV6EtEzhA","author":"@samvimes5124","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mJIS19VN_I25qv3bHAMFALoLYceIjtoGnOk6v8nR5UGg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@samvimes5124","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzFxefi5-UFQarFoXd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Problem is that by the time the court cases proceeds 95% of this \"companies\" will be broke and gone with the bubble burst and the damage will have been done","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCB0EFKPCibS1NwT7H8RgKsA","author":"@notimetotell4538","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yzU4HcNXca7D9ub0HcQT--FHa_XGft61xspbYkZxgvFTTVIq4rpEYFpbtoC8WOSXAdXryKpNYNY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@notimetotell4538","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyu5Q_Y-ccBni10-054AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I quit Spotify several years ago when I heard that Sony bought almost 6% of Spotify by basically giving its artists music away. Several Swedish artists puller their music from Spotify entirely then but are mostly back now.\nPatreon and similar solutions is the way to go. Don't forget to complement patreon with a non-subscription payment option. Sometimes when I find something interesting I feel in a giving mood but don't know if I will feel the same next month.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0V59XBwltFnYxddBpGJ_Xg","author":"@bertilorickardspelar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nWyPWxkLouOOka6GuHM8izDlE_yXnC5xTup5HP8T7CMeTZxq27qge_MoyYv6lzf2FRtw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bertilorickardspelar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzDQazZ1whzq1lM1gl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"All those other platforms may be paying more than Spotify, but I also get like 1% of the streams from those other platforms.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnICuM7nFg7rTZBhc_Hrx6Q","author":"@DoubleSlashCJ","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oqaQL8MEw3ErPd0PXDTLKhCncC1IdtJdT7KVMJ5e3CtHbmi8-Mcw1A8dgSlj9vJqsDeQocLe0Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DoubleSlashCJ","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVJOkiruJnBj45hjR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"15:07 Based on Amazon's track record of invading a space with really good deals to kill competition and then removing the floor, I expect this is their goal. They're fighting Apple though, so I don't see it working out as well for them as it did with physical bookstores and then ebooks (and now audiobooks). I think it's fine for artists to flock to this now, just be ready for them to pull the floor out as well. That's the hard part, being ready to turn away later. Because they want to lock you in forever, of course.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVTar-Meaqbtb59D6t-eF1A","author":"@tangentfox4677","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zE7lEAfWG3OP0fR7zLkZ9UajuiLfTU1JuIZRKjHfLZL9ncEIk-zLs8R8h9Ii99g9ni_3XB8Hgw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tangentfox4677","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy2NnTdwv1TDy4nJvp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Some heros don’t wear capes 🫡","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwIzkmbYsD0Vl1kNmfUJ8vQ","author":"@kylebostick2601","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kdU__-N6ElxrDa3c9yfvaeOk3IHUYCn4a9b7ZLoiQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kylebostick2601","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyJKqhbhZDqYEaBKyh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm not being elitist or arrogant etc at all really but I can't buy that fact about the 128 to FLAC for example couldn't tell the difference, 256 would test me but for sure it's noticeable. I spend my life with good earphones in so maybe I'm a bad sample but I'm by no means an audio engineer and even I can hear the difference in clarity.. that 4/5 fact is a bit depressing maybe.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCXX_fiNJJDF3ay65aNXf5fg","author":"@GamerSofa","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nt9R24nNyA5yeVNlMIEPh2lMBzP4iW-tPbAICTXsni3AM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GamerSofa","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugww9kvAX7Qj8SY_DAB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So these numbers on music streaming are way more cooked than they first seem. \n\nAssuming an average song length of 3.5 minutes and given the last published data on average listens from Spotify is 25 hours per user per month that means the average user is listening to 428 songs per month. \n\nAt $0.0029 per song that is an average of $1.24 in royalties per user, per month.\n\n$1.24. for a $11.99 subscription.\n\nThat's a 90:10 revenue split. FOR AUDIO. \n\nAd revenue splits for Twitch are 30:70 and YouTube does 45:55 for video. \n\nFOR VIDEO.\n\nSPOTIFY IS TAKING 3X AS MUCH AS TWITCH AND 2X AS MUCH AS YOUTUBE DO FOR VIDEO AND IS JUST SERVING AUDIO.\n\nLike I knew it was a scam but Jesus. It's ridiculous.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCYv05pGTs1QwXDR3ok1jrlw","author":"@goawayiwannawatchit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nismy8BWfEZsWME8CJlx_LVaMy4qDk6UyaoBd3Yyhcng=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@goawayiwannawatchit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyj5IyrCdQKfm_lWbl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's heartbreaking to see when you actually create music yourself. There were always superficial people in music but Ai really makes it difficult for actual human art to be seen or appreciated.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCN_mWdjdTI3sn05Yvo8paFA","author":"@heatrayzvideo3007","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Efnc0rR4VrmC-SlzFC07JQ7vA5nuOkNtjfYfgo2Z3p6qDsxJoz_V4YexpPluCEPMx4xsuBTJ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@heatrayzvideo3007","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzo4iX9u7hpzmSNHKx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Benn exposing the streaming payout nightmare is proof the system is broken. Forget paying a monthly subscription to ride a stationary bike—just put on White Lobster's album Free Drugs and work out harder than you ever have for 36 minutes and 31 seconds. We’re out in the Gulf of America dropping high-voltage gonzo arena rock on our own terms.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRH6Tz5neWM1zfjPKP0azrw","author":"@WhiteLobsterRocks","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GDZ4RrpF6TnVp3nYd13p8J1Mm0S71isIEvjQIQ8d-dH1uXp77KrDXxCKmhVoPpvHO5ZYTveaC8U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WhiteLobsterRocks","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDc6lfbU4PYL_8hVx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The way people describe the difference they notice between lossless and high quality mp3 falls into 2 categories. 1)they changed services to get lossless and the new service has different eq and other base settings (it's so much louder!!). 2)they talk about it like some audiophiles used to talk about the benefits of CD demagnetiser or CD shaver.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTzopeTCnpE4qRbq5rPRnmQ","author":"@Ruinwyn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kVt-2KnstlTCEKQNERtFu1r0nkoGfCbDaBeHqzzAeOW6FjInY1ji4XDCDXS_eKGhY0Pw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ruinwyn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzBlMjwjE3chmnV8qR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is a great review.  Nice to know that peloton is paying so much.  Lol.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCETk8TOBPj8c6-lqSiUgRHA","author":"@ethicsforai","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/O0J5TjVoozNf_y2SCiqKyweq-7yMooRZG-ZQinPsw08lie3hpTueF1NVj7zNYZiCsHRED7p7iy0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ethicsforai","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwblRxUXgFQ482W6FJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What we need is a non-profit streaming platform that pays artists well and can't be pressured by shareholders to pay them less over time... So, let me know if you need help with that :)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCD0FZ6eqBePlDyHD1tLSqtA","author":"@AaronSherman","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kaNqwVWbVV5_16H8MzoiNc0M0h1tQakR_Erykm01q7cXM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AaronSherman","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxBzQ7vrYjNvl2gHvF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i remember finding out about suno and being scared and excited at the same time, i generated a song and was surprised at it's quality, at first lol to me all the songs sounded cheesy and obviously fake. It's INSANE how many people actually use it....","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCh-MCV3B_nAPDlMfUk1fWBw","author":"@vythra-78","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iiLqyhTx_Vyo-pdY8nk-E2fqBzmfDqpoV0WyrC-V7xeFed4VsIUHg3QeOEpgtGkuGqpQgUm0H_Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vythra-78","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxD4kl3oDlOP8QG9OF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Excellent!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtVryuOY6sM02rbQoUhGXyg","author":"@domshov","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mNW-Xm6S8LTTp-pq_GcbziC9TrbDRsyL9uavBDeVyGnTY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@domshov","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6Zokz2c0fh0YuAgt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"applause to my ears is a dead giveway as to if it was mp3 compressed or not","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgSDw3ZOf1OJnylGDcTHJ2w","author":"@1dgram","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ktJDu7fOmJzF9DU-cuxd7OGKysBUte-HNL2p-xNoI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@1dgram","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyb6rHu-JXSuUaM2qV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In just listening on spotify in general, the suno generated ones always have the same 'feeling' / sound profile to it. Especially with the solos. It would be much more honest for those song to have an 'AI' tag.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuOM6WfLS-GJJ-N3yyJl5hQ","author":"@masheen_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_loFCK4UAPAngNzUVgLMWnZFKm9uf0n2ksAkz3lhADraag3=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@masheen_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw6LMVEPckf1ZMhwRJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just as a copyright note I did a random remix of a song with no permission and actually got struck not by Lil Wayne  but by another artist who did the exact same thing but decided to copyright strike others 😂😂 its litterally the wild west sometimes.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC-AjxiVQsxBe2BrUjJlYT0Q","author":"@baddkarmal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mmkFbVre8Zhjrj8Mf_IPRhwHYbsPARN9pmkNbqIzmA76QuJDkSb74nrsHATmVeWtlysA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@baddkarmal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzd7k6gN5QPi-1_Gmh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ben I'm curious!!  \nwhen using the compression artefacts to determine if a song was generated by AI, I assume you have to use an \"uncompressed\" version of the song? \nHow would the compression fingerprint detection differentiate between an AI generated song (with MP3 artefacts) vs a sample based song (where the person used MP3 based samples) \n\nAnd a mostly unrelated question - do you plan to publish your code under an open-source license?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbpUwqdRdfLGzuvunBquMig","author":"@afristralian","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mS1OwYdgMbfl1OgUJZBr45mG_jLC7PqbG0RwHPXeRRtao=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@afristralian","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyodSwtCsyzFZ2lqo14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"On calling football (⚽) football, I applaud you. 👏","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_3qgXdJ14M5SdoERULN-lA","author":"@teroalitalo3469","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4B7X7rVGvmUJU0BhvJy5M-dW7ikGTdVnW_qhKwdU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@teroalitalo3469","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx7yxhJOXTdP46df3V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"We should not cultivate financial incentives for art. It is a labor of passion supposedly, so you should gain energy from doing it. The reward is (or at least should be) intrinsic.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpjd_65MeaKGmE2isszrgYQ","author":"@alronthunderdrummer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lWUGqqDVOjDMQhT79w0dQUCtCcagcr_9GOWJZbhvFUNxk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alronthunderdrummer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxdqjUExhOLCYmpyZR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:50 sounds like Sing Low from One Touch of Venus by Kurt Weill, but I don’t recognize the arrangement. Where is this audio from?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0cqQcl6x-1QVqxsijG6t4w","author":"@jenniferlamont7460","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kR6fedWuiw9frWK0p8Zo-ktMQ0dlR1AJs3nBocIFUso30=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jenniferlamont7460","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzX9ARKpHGTuT-KucF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ai tools have been around for years - all photoediting software from Corel to Adobe, all midi instruments, Apple Logic, etc. It's just been advancing to where we are now. Before AI got to where it is now I wanted to add a singer to one of my songs and found a program to do that. When you designed an image with Adobe was it really \"yours\"? When you created a song with downloaded instruments on your favorite DAW was it really \"yours\"? You could argue that Adobe gave you the license to call the work your own, but Suno's paid subscription also gives song rights to those that pay for the subscription.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtSHLhXGxx6VijMKqZrOqzA","author":"@digitalcreativearts","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8n8mJeM0Oos3joBuhfitL_9VxAgDVClHXP3qbJp2lsczwVik6ljA16RyxiwC7YwO556hsUU2QA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@digitalcreativearts","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzavzRxS74MzcD7X_p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well done. Let’s play them in reverse.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6OkVaAKbMSdurIWH-g3kgg","author":"@carlosp.1846","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m0owDbLdjbL3MGcfYNmyggPMOV4xT-6ij5Sq5M-1nQPhk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@carlosp.1846","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzd63GhJMeARu9HOrR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"what you get paid per stream is largely dependent on what distribution network you use. Repost pays good and the most when people listen on SC.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGTvDOrQAp-YNPFupox7bhA","author":"@RockIslandYT","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_sFTCVMjL7FDWs1i5Ea_X6SepQWeL5I8EmZabLKn1ebFjV5rsAD_fil_jMajU63_3YALNkfpiB8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RockIslandYT","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxpAEfg3B_vjSjoOMd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:42 Could the Spotify payout be so low because of their free  (ad-supported) tier? Amazon Music, Tidal, Apple Music have no free tier. Deezer's free tier is heavier restricted than Spotify's.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCVDXvnqS3KvwabAnBRFsAxQ","author":"@Post_Polar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kXGmM4S1B7P0eWaTcvqqrlLlnQdVtPkqpLsqLMMTR-qaE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Post_Polar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJF9oaSSGYSxlvTY14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"All french to me, but I ever did figure out what Lars uses as a trigger for his drum beats.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1EBrg56KQhshsEVpwjRSNA","author":"@Ed-ty1kr","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/m5GmD8IdB_ATFoW1A-lSVk41BKUuQeYksSICFM16cY80oDK5Afdn8NQ_QJVp4a5F8h_aeHKeag=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ed-ty1kr","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_mzduxtrpTPpZjBF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"art piece of video!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZVo_0TaxSI4QOWzmf1eOsA","author":"@fumarolas","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lRTWRoJ5Mm1J6dwSFwLZYO2tYqK3zKpN4VbdDGguTxhPP-sB_V7uVUqTAw-NzD5GCobQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fumarolas","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynKWWzI71ofEarVgp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"People have such a weird relationship with art. How many carpenters don't get paid for building a house when they do 10 a year because a company \"can't track\" what they're owed? Our PRO's and streaming services could catch every single stream but they don't want to pay out the back catalog of what we're owed.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCQJL8A_8Ul79cdvsLSm1xyA","author":"@joebordash3160","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bIhK-XDVbiZhc8PW41cigWHvZlyWNDzPSjbz0YPNh7WP2H_-ZhoG3O8wVNe7c3ymJYFR15c50g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joebordash3160","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzlyvnPh7EfCfD2GBd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"I used the stones to destroy the stones\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6RfRmlcMNQs-B_zeUw4Dqg","author":"@AeneasTerran","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Iyln5pMPIc9iRY60rb_eTKkvEfYPuhE5u-F7kkhlGLTQyt30q6s_1IBCfhpe5f09FQZ-_uRMk0E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AeneasTerran","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGXYhvof95EycTv6J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"One day we’ll just all leave the Internet and a I can talk to yourself.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1WNtel-93S7zwbCtHWrjSQ","author":"@tenny810","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qzR7vvTPcVCVxeP8t4eUBC9lpBycoXVdIoKD-01mlMTRvcHyqadzZkZqlDdb6i6so_bJHgx6W4Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tenny810","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzr1hjAN63-NckgZaR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Awesome!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5SlOYM8FB04IhV0zsRTAyw","author":"@rjhgn88","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mAqi1DCe1OrkqQj6n8crhcyqMZhL9dmy2bAWGDODY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rjhgn88","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxE2Cca8ugLJZOXiXh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Song at 17:37 ?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1Jf2CEswswnlfDfGtNnxDg","author":"@C-Llama","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/rN9mSM5bJK9DhcJJftzw20TDvyan8FWVcXVe-67dkH2xC2L_pTfC8Gwj7Z-_K9TWi41pLbgV=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@C-Llama","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxnuWJ_0YjAah7FT5p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'd look at some youtubers like Roussea and Kassia too. At least some or all of their content is ai generated visuals. Roussea got struck with a copyright warning, of another artists recording. He used his \"live video\" as proof to dispute it. Shortly after he stopped posting and vanished for years.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqNx7DWh5bWAp77IO2mQM8Q","author":"@tomcorbett6089","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/HA8FSHTLKvONnL7R7Sc3LD6g5ukkPx-aA5Quu0d-rekJ0S-OXwSX1ALQM967oVuH9tFN3JvqxA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tomcorbett6089","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaM-w3HDRS5kr7iXR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI 'music\" at this point has driven me away a from using any music streaming service, since they seem dead set on including AI slop into radio playlists.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCUB5mlS177-8RzyiBvRZX0g","author":"@joebot86","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_klzUGUM7xmgGj1xYJx901w9nV-GAxSwEGL6ZrE-hLoLg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joebot86","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCKVEDAsqQSvopqOt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"we used to use MP3 for its characteristics when mastering lol . but yeah do it enough you get used to that squelchy sqoich spoigy mp3 signature.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcxNj0is0sZ2feCC3mX_ljA","author":"@Ready_Fire_Aim","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LwVuuofJJ3WPDrHmXfQf9TObjMZ3rJA_aW2wtwB14Wa-MDzy6iacJDQ29UqvWLowNRGuvtSr7Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ready_Fire_Aim","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwv9mUwpXj9tvJKexZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sexy data goodies. But I wish this covered more on the AI garbage. I think vaporwave fits into this problem a little too since people will disguise their lofi remixes of vintage songs as their own without any credit given.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa4e1nlrmFO6LY_ns90oo8A","author":"@kirkydaturkey","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kkxwYpVzH2v3-vfRHeiSrg3nlpOP8ZMPNNy-wq-8Nexw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kirkydaturkey","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxoB0WEuLG6eA0nq4d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Trick question. My answer is buying the album off independent first. or the labels site if they are labeled, or second best is buying the album or singles from iTunes or amazon music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7OckxJIowI1RcoX3SiwbTg","author":"@yocobicus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l8_hp77xm66KZEjQb2Pnm78tIooidRPFGUiM4Vl9pW0w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yocobicus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwMkg6jSXb-N-uP_Kd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"bandcamp my beloved","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4jquH3E6jSfOfxIjRzj85A","author":"@soweliSapa","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/63u9RNiUR98nHlRZQwfJsUiHARQdXzmN3c0gDdZBxWifQ1YpWKcagQUdcJ8QuOIzaXpo5wlr=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@soweliSapa","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwoYibJ_BX9jRH_G0d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well now I feel better for switching from Spotify to Amazon Music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCy2JKE9OkBpvaU4EXCnKy-g","author":"@virkgale","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kZC05RJ7p1Hovg8JOE3acwhKGHQiBZgKuJbNYLWIUp7A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@virkgale","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQBnaPo-2X-btNox94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My model is called 3ARS it works pretty good usually","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpansRfjtiYVZhDMMIT1sOQ","author":"@vietpandamonster","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/W_K7xgRpbNZrfmFsVZkSzD1q1EZAzDhewHxkgq9OIKHqo4XkvZ-idSJiy-ArEDXRQWP5pFFMPTc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vietpandamonster","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPjJ5OBpiDIj26sLF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I hate putting porn in every word.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCDjPbgJsoKtdqL7R0jknQEw","author":"@sugarforthepill7798","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nj2xp5HEyxOEyFdXr7Z6FMNE_dccGeCO-TKOTswRBtqc8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sugarforthepill7798","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzwiS-R0JJC7YifZQx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So do they detect the loop file itself or just how similar the songs with those loops sound ? \n\nLike if I recreated a loop from scratch all by myself but made it sound exactly or almost exactly like that loop/sample would it still be detected by those copyright detectors?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCe0mF_0EVN0bLOW2OwVgJLA","author":"@CandyDreamMUSIC","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CL3fltXsTC3eDq4Yw2RJCaQSZmiV9m7-fnuudi5jRE725Irk7nNrYAXcEryM49-ymBz86v5qnwA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CandyDreamMUSIC","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzhggoNSTidUV1i5NV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank you from the bottom of my wenis is definitely a udio song title","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCV-tb-Ve6IwJ3mm_p5bW7Cg","author":"@RabbitRunway","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qRAUADnDi7_X7LVw3eB-m16stVGhVHuqB0dKPapRWCuiny-xjhO00EcHQlUEmZfrP5FZdf-ZVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RabbitRunway","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxV_WOK1EYzZ_DfYi54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I just love downloading my music, because then i have my songs even when I’m in the middle of the forest. But, to be honest… i’m a pirate, most of the time (sorry I’m broke). Question is: do any of you know where can i BUY mp3’s with most credit going to the artist and (that is important) with an option to download?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNXThjbk06NUFPPMLhBSL8g","author":"@drosophilamelanogaster3121","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0kokAxHyogrXzFZ1kTk1vZegH78MZD9gk8Z-QR-OnQCTuxIMu9d1u1CFPAsCmYw759MHqpKX=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drosophilamelanogaster3121","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwp5rW5b4v_vhCLNbR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Before checking the video: Napster (I think). I’ll get back with in the end.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6CLbeGbRBsO9pCVnU65QRg","author":"@camendoza95","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-r-HK_pSJNauxh02kZkXaZvqCkmoPgA9dHKRBQW4VbkBGH9ZJYkY648heoVgcjbBYNGvQy8HZWw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@camendoza95","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwp5rW5b4v_vhCLNbR4AaABAg.AD6yUygoGNwAD6zPyCzekO","parent":"Ugwp5rW5b4v_vhCLNbR4AaABAg","text":"Update: TOTALLY WRONG 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6CLbeGbRBsO9pCVnU65QRg","author":"@camendoza95","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-r-HK_pSJNauxh02kZkXaZvqCkmoPgA9dHKRBQW4VbkBGH9ZJYkY648heoVgcjbBYNGvQy8HZWw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@camendoza95","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx_DK2e8PsN9WfToKh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Did a loss less comparison test over three hours with my father. You’d be suprised what conditions you sometimes need to actually physically hear the difference. That being said, I think 4/5 is wildly inaccurate and these numbers probably need to be blown up on a larger scale with a larger data set to actually claim something so specific. My circles are musical so maybe we are the exception, considering not a single one of us dosent have an understanding of relative pitch and one dude actually having the ability to discern pitches in any scenario.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqqWHzx66BPdT2rYMVs0k4Q","author":"@Mrskyrimtroll","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNZtDRN-ZdYsI3yJHxXCutfQU-24R0-ucFEwh35G-Iv_E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mrskyrimtroll","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxR0Fpaos59P4U58lJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:43 I’m guessing Napster","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoUcvuOwKmYRctL5kiQH6aQ","author":"@Rozie_Rabbit","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Ku4zqRXHn3vy5hp3xUuPpT9xi-EVUmhpwtd5daTpGM8hi2SrKKYDUGjOVU5iop9djW_5nEaPhhM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Rozie_Rabbit","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJ-ZpflzanOISxyLZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:18 ??? Bro really just slid it in there and for what 😭😭😭","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCL1AhdYKo5_GVEwRCClUckw","author":"@railroadisolationist5452","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ncSejCG5YxPg9mZ8oWHnPIh7tGe8TvodSLPaWspvKSWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@railroadisolationist5452","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxfOUh3_QSg073w7ct4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The general idea of hiding the fact that you're creating music with AI seems off to me. It's like saying \"No, we used a live orchestra!\" while clearly you did not. On the flipside i find dismissing the effort put in by some creators using AI and assigning it zero value is off to. There needs to be some form of middle ground.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCogf_jaaTy4SQiKs1LKjqyQ","author":"@graph1ks","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CVID-gtc8rTKli_uftWsdMoBGMF_Q9yBi7Sn9EIctMMbdbnYBciRMJthBtQPzehx6KX3_Ue-Tw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@graph1ks","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxRSPGBVMhboFPHngx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Such a plastic world we are getting into","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpvuqdEGcT7JrhitAWlgKXA","author":"@FabioGnecco","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XTx5CNyI781jrYG56Xm_uzdTmVahcDrLrD_dW9a9wA8bznUi-1kKD4dyy4bj7gOjqtCe6oJK=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FabioGnecco","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwpq0ene-KwigrnwmB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI isn't making more art more accessible, it's making more artists more likely to abandon their craft.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-rhUXmduaGx12WRFBL5MWQ","author":"@TENDRነL","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ocVH_yK1VYqwWslVB3jmV4PgiIMVyRTXDeNyl0Wcwr67YEPraACfVAobR6Mt6JMot3se59f-mx8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TENDR%E1%8A%90L","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzEJspOaY6d4TqmM4p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a small indie label and playlist curator I would love access to a reliable tool that can identify AI music so that I can avoid supporting AI generated music. I would be super interested in finding out more information about this.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa9ofZkbmUVWqI_7faHtmfw","author":"@h1massive","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJumygF928YbpdM0U4J0Yg_hf0_26am-AzrjcrStBcsA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@h1massive","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxU41-n9v8FYt3LwkB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"6:50. I have a really hard time understanding people who are talking to me when there is background noise. And i can here the difference between spotify at 320kbps and youtubes 128kbps when i listen to the same song on both. Maybe somesthing is wrong with the way my brain processes noise, but it makes every song ive ever heard generated with AI so far sound \"crunchy\" like there is a constant static in the background.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGtK8GUDMTLRM_rT7avYELQ","author":"@Ħawk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zPvmAg33npqSicMaMfJFg8jXWes84mlFazl289RjgVbP5l96iXGtYJ7oBVOxDkyqKyhkFj7qGe4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@%C4%A6awk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgypIu8qkOJV1XvKPk14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"They're poison for musicians in the music INDUSTRY, but not for the creation of music as an expression. Before the internet, most musicians had no chance of being discovered. It's definitely a catch 22.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXYdsI0oW8602fNVPPCeTwA","author":"@cultofneg","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QaouHBCfy8KW6lLlKuQKUKjxuec8nVQF1lCnlERkr6v4uLDWNeP_INbVuEm_EbSo1ZOn0F-m9f0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cultofneg","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJpqoyQHCVRFq4GfR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is AI generated slop was a valid form of art, then any ‘made with AI’ label would be a badge of honour. The fact that people are trying to hide it tells you a lot of how much value it actually has.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9pDvMiebEBx8a4RbWFHn8g","author":"@EeveeFromAlmia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n0LwEdURcxZihFtABcQOLTvPC2rX-FHz_YB8v9IpUc_HA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EeveeFromAlmia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwv4AjDTgr2XQhk_td4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am surprised no layer is willing to jump on this and start suing Spotify, Apple etc.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5Wdr2DE1TnKLNkUBrK324Q","author":"@Harveevideos","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mCZzcvwHG-GGxVA6QrFt31LMK63CGSi0U8hz2ROcM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Harveevideos","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwtRGLv22HrazQ2aAV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think AI generated content is interesting, particularly with images. Even Adobe uses that technology now. However, with music, I don't mind if it's good, I just don't want to pay for it, or have people earn money off of it. At least not in it's current form. If AI music becomes more like a sample tool where you still create the main parts of the music, and only uses short AI generated samples, it may be a different case.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCh4M3NDY4cgxTire6dDYa0g","author":"@zaph1rax","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kjwdl1nSStVINDqdKepa0BmjkkbWpnw_S3JTEqO8Jo3Nof=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zaph1rax","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzdRwcHOjMGzW7AMzZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5.000.0000 used for saying ‘Please pay me, not the other internet person who’s music you actually listened to’ 😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZzFT-e6OEJnSdI2X9px17A","author":"@warius1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kBpD6A-uzOU4oEP-k-TP97fe0gaygogVAVKawCE1kCig=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@warius1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhXAgwoB3ujh8kdgx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"bro, you rock","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5vrV5qEXq2A_mL0Q9F2YPQ","author":"@AIwithDwayne","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DQ7RkRumv-NviFrZ6JYUAqjXhFrOzmCq1VmaxFAIzzn9oPHnWHjVqXgC00D15zniNwly6Sl6IQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AIwithDwayne","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwsP3HEwbgAkDV3U-h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:18 audio quality flac mp3 compression","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCg2PaWVD8u9pkz5DhWHUBng","author":"@ThankGodItDontGotThatInIt1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hNO0xlylE92zl2lQ3JnFbBJ9uonF05orh4sjDOA2A5ygif4QU7BmGm1NavNL8dRTAwz8WDN0JQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ThankGodItDontGotThatInIt1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy3T2kWEcvhU2-lQ0x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"No matter  how much anyone wants it to be the case, copying is not theft, and it's not even copying when you do training runs on masses of data. \n\nI have no problem with attempting to detect AI use, I think much AI use is going to be lazy (just like much use of any technology to do something you could do in other ways can be lazy, this isn't new), but if the tool ends up being preferred by the market (not at all clear this is the case right now, or that it even will be in the immediate future) that's the individual person on the market's decision.  The nice thing about the market is it allows for niche preference fulfillment and for people to build businesses of those niches. \n\nBut copyright is nonsense, it is a state privilege and not a right in any sense.  None of which is to say musicians/artists/etc. can't want payment or that people shouldn't support them, but the manner of that support need not be based on \"per copy sales\" and it's not how the world actually works anyway.  It is most helpful when systems recognize the foundational reality underneath things, not the wishful thinking that state privilege props up.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJwcxvl3rCrXoolGZ-3WRkA","author":"@Korodarn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mo-ngw2iXTjilc4X3R9TWfKMVubJaaWmP-E9AYx2N-KkwGfZ7Ck2wgooJGVstqf0wbRw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Korodarn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzc9FF4nqnSsWVd0Q14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Okay! You won me over for music. Bye, bye, Spotify! Now, how do I get my favorite horror story podcast artists to move their stuff to Amazon Unlimited? Or Qobuz? 🤔","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1vDIQa1UifbGSeFrgb41pQ","author":"@Just1Nora","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oa7-4Kprbgi1Tpv-CyFGEPW-vS7AJv1ph1Nn6KpqedVe81duZuFBvlNY3akSGwSUuRyG0A4L_28=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Just1Nora","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyCSzDvNsxMIrll2B14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I feel bad for using YouTube music now... but I get it with YouTube Premium and I watch a lot of YouTube. \n\nI did a bit of a double take at $0.01 per stream being fair compensation, but then I realized at what seems like $10/cd and ~12 tracks/cd I'd have to listen to each song ~83 times before my price per play dropped below $0.01 and some albums? yeah, I've listened hundreds of times, but others? a couple dozen maybe which would be closer to $0.25 per play that I would have paid if I'd bought the CD directly.\n\nEdit: And that's even at the awful deflated value of albums today compared to yesteryears","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfcXwL0wofiYLBDvXz5YaEA","author":"@Dysiode","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_metPu5k_RFGLzuIS8Sa6LrlTd8QmvnYzteSXwZgL8y-Vr6=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Dysiode","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwf3nJvbJI6FWfSeop4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've always found it amusing that people claim they can hear the difference between lossy and lossless. A 128 kbit mp3 from 95, I can hear because the algorithm sucked back then. Now? Nope.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCzWfpmP6h8KMxlA8rC0e4rA","author":"@peppepop","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m7or5kgyrbMAZS76nZ8aseet4R3AbPQXQWnnlYHit-zz8p=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@peppepop","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwf3nJvbJI6FWfSeop4AaABAg.ACzcWcJOZaUAD4kNKvrSIi","parent":"Ugwf3nJvbJI6FWfSeop4AaABAg","text":"It's not amusing at all. If I compare a song in FLAC that I'll play on Foobar2K and then I'll play it as AAC on Spotify the literal first thing I'll notice is that I'll have to crank up my amplifier to get the same sound level as the FLAC. Sure most of the time you won't be noticing the difference but you need capable headphones and DAC and Amp to be able to hear the difference.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNrAPJ25jQdDJKKYvR3sonA","author":"@Simon_Denmark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NGoSaM5Xjj0mLxh-IHd0li_P7DRYeFm_s3PFsvWpl3LuJk21IdXkxoHOJe3O6ANtS0GehxsXSQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Simon_Denmark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymHpoc-iSjDqn9Xuh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I’m having random fake tracks coming up even for more a obscure artists like MF Doom/Viktor Vaughn. Listed as a featured artist on a completely nonsense track without any rapper, let alone him. He also passed away a few years back, so it’s massively disrespectful too.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCspiEFiUKnkAwNsddN9gwYA","author":"@NL-fg6it","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kipgvh_h3BsAPWtoIeGhNvfG8WiddX5gM_lonXP0Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NL-fg6it","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzb8_6wLt-qfOlr5cJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Don't be fooled by Amazon paying out more, they're just at an earlier stage in their platform cycle where they still offer value to their business customers. Once they capture enough market share to lock in users and producers they'll drop their payouts way below Spotify.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCowPjnHOewJPvMUl1hhHqYw","author":"@quietreason8679","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mW0wIWF733VwC85Bo-sfK8BYaAN1jIkagZSM_VTyvDaV8pikwKamXMfNL1ooWPvDJvlg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@quietreason8679","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyVylC7aOeaROWAiaJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've been meaning to stop using streaming completely but building a physical library form scratch is quite difficult 😔","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYZnDwY-b24Y9tptqHh2Ofg","author":"@mpx41","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mr4BN1ZQhfs-byao3f_izLOQT1vVridzY1lRglmd7cTw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mpx41","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGmFxiKss2Rd3ztWx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As much as I hate this... Im starting to love the idea that everyone here is going through the same thing. Music people crying.. sound the same as the artists....  soon the 3d artists.. and unreal blueprints will be the same... so  ....     AI hosted youtubing will be here soon...  so this video could be made in a prompt....   You can see how Youtube has aged Ben in such a short period of time.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC9Kv4yXvj2jAynbXJKYBuHA","author":"@RoeJogan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nTwlGvMl4c0xZWz1BVyjSrQKzfMubZIMaqUtfMkD6jXqE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RoeJogan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw1O3eWFo6LdD2scqh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"you rock\nkeep it up","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCP9ssWBQCl26EIJ3WRv0bSQ","author":"@EranMahalu","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kEickPbev1F1FjIqQB075SyUJs96fcUVGb78lnXHkPykQ1=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EranMahalu","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzxTUqcdZlkdLaet8x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"NEVER KNEW ANY OF THIS !! >> SUBSCRIBED!! >> You are destined for much much more for the efforts you have put into revealing the TRUTH !!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCe4q64xk000u3kDpga7CXqA","author":"@StickyGreenStuff","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6JIOP8LwwdZud8VCEh0_bjcSluiLHcjZUQ1HMQnpjzWKKiNrWLt4RE5yai_4NSqqeHum3QRoLOE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@StickyGreenStuff","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzv8sD_Mf-O9KfpL-94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"bro i fucking NEED that funk song at 6:45 please man its been stuck in my head for days","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-Yj_B7FTw1Vdpd1_oBHjRA","author":"@willk113","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lEoz2GQUbAIe3GySInW6eNKXsCrA3LET9psxKJhVUkvdxf=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@willk113","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz__JbYi-c6fp2Eidh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If Macaulay Culkin had a tech channel and worked out","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfp6OLRxfhk_-IGuLKNaYUA","author":"@cancer5895","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kfksUSbz8yKTJTF6WWTdkTYW1FF-LpVLXfMpgjs-DNkKI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cancer5895","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7t-24X6cRruLQfqJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe I'm super lame, but part of the reason I don't unsub from Spotify is because I've curated a massive list of songs that I like over the years and I don't know to effectively transfer that information to another service short of manually typing out a list and then finding and liking all those songs on the new service.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC22k-Ig1bTW0C12Oc66d9DA","author":"@venahtmusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kBDxNtq-Ipi3R8tsFRk8vHba6nRCdjPchn13oL-Hv5d043r8MY6jbfAXwHQtq36oufMp5JjLvw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@venahtmusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzcZlDP3D3Q-saNyyR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's quite oversimplified when it comes to how Spotify payout royalites since they don't really payout on a \"per stream\"-basis.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC94-cZza-yOrt4gInLqe52A","author":"@hetsie9956","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l0Rp4EE6iPofG8_5-wRb9CraO3XCAXLFAbcEwR-r8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hetsie9956","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwXDUgBcOFIYMa49ZV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What did you use for the Content IDing? Since Spotify depreciated that endpoint of the API I’ve been looking for a replacement","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaYY6yeJQr03qSoeDXl71Rg","author":"@ClaireNighten","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l54JuFkfz_MPuEzHjXdxfvxURY00Junn3arhXrUYET02NzrFzJeqJsa24OyzDDUvdakg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ClaireNighten","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxz0x_no4taFuoAx4B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"tidal pays the most! at least according to my royalty sheet","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8ifggcC2HJ8r7gXZqcU3PA","author":"@ethopathos","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NCaRovzm9OWMDBvTysTAw-qOnUTsRR22WujCf0NU9gwIJ8VQLiLmiagPKwuibdX8P5woJb6p-w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ethopathos","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyO4RJdHIoQGwZHD8B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Might just buy a Peloton now","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT9b07zGHaGhBzYLDffMIYA","author":"@bruceguy247","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Q1fcZZfvQFMx_eOYf8_Lz4ucx37QTJ70LgfGMT6qEKsLrGNtEoxAm8Ez29Gtu4yjZjYqipkUfg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bruceguy247","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwjnIr0pND4eMA1erV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm curious if the problem with streaming platforms is more so the increased accessibility to streaming more music per day and the increased accessibility to create music, spreading the subscription revenue thin among creators. That and corporate taking their cut.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfXGtunXzIh1SFo87yKFlXg","author":"@xPorkchops007x","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kkd8_iFCzM18b7huLwXPebHP1c6JUupCdloitz8JS8sPg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@xPorkchops007x","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyXDVs-HlJuq1C6Wrt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It is fairly easy to train models on the difference between compressed and uncompressed because it is so simple to generate training data? Then you have what you need to generate music that removes the detectable 'compressed' artifacts?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCI47nHeRoVDb-44exwQgXsQ","author":"@ostfab","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zC8iaoNAEIttv_1f-qePpuVG0x9v93d9pLAVEfwzaCGga9OoYEfgJml3F0XMOGE9UXxZbQ8ClqU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ostfab","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwkgBkbkUUX1WOmiF94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI Over-saturation is driving me nuts.  Most trends last a few months, we have time to get over it. It's like every waking moment I'm forced to see, hear, experience and interact with some of the most abrasive meaningless ugly shit I've ever seen in my life","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPhBPT-0QS0wLjrIBOWsl_A","author":"@NicoleHam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zw5TmUYOcWwEqj8pGMTYm4rJlvGuLAnyA0PGs0HUnXQVRRck-1KVS3bMV-vMVv0HtJDTGKrR=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NicoleHam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgweMxAJI7lj4oTptSd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Streaming music? CDs!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4kO3FQdjOn-_rmppQJQD7g","author":"@alexandera.1411","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n81XtWrJ2gykcR7_x9At8M8Xdczf1Sygxt9UgGIvE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alexandera.1411","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzgikQww68Ko1UAQD54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Uh, you are saying \"point zero zero two\" but displaying 0.02. which is it? Regardless, great video! Thanks.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYA3KV_Oxj0j-NzMf3Gvi4g","author":"@briancase6180","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kHGXFbHRa3GLTkcXgciw9DQ1_VQ2csaCM-sRP33s2JMMY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@briancase6180","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx8MwOGnEFelixW0fx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hmmmm i recall a certain Vsauce episode about music...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCszg2TjDMaL30iLCnNe7QnA","author":"@adamreynolds3863","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lgs9tTCp5OweF6wX89z8__DpfrbsYtIdV615jnFBQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@adamreynolds3863","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx0tYEtpRjsRu-pYrl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i love the patreon model, honestly i would rather have that than get royalties, i want all my music to be in the creative commons so royalties doesn't feel appropriate.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrH-hm2BOaOgxlPr1gxcttQ","author":"@AlizabelaRosa","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GwrV9Ix-f6gT4-LnrV0i0qZyO5q3PijDKfHKI_NFS5EM0X4Qn1QHqJbdFXskBaOKveMpbgom2A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AlizabelaRosa","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbyMbaNSoHr0TXJFR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think the decimals are off on the first pay per stream bar graph page.  👀👀👀","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0y_6Rx-Fjoa0OV2NDig3qg","author":"@cerseideverreoux5745","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mwb-lVvNrFAKsWzb_7Ms_gXjRdfin3ijFWDmvH-V4akA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cerseideverreoux5745","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx7ADtLQSIQFbDqxXF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Probably dead question, but any way to get technical view on this project? I am learning NN and would like to see how they get practical use in situations like this.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxoq-fj-Ia6GFCadXMElPMQ","author":"@musicwolf4655","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kugbxOoJzSiClMA36ccWDiHiMXxPBNWWF4ObuZ-6rnTc0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@musicwolf4655","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJd9D2tx6xdxe3ZjR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Circumvention wouldn't be hard now that you've told everyone how you detect it. Train a model to do super resolution on sound, based on an uncompressed file and the compressed version of it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBpxHtLGf3XQJ7yPAOrfz8g","author":"@whattheheckisthisthing","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nAt6g6WaKLnrN3laVMdZGBKMMxqX-BzkMoyE5xwPrSmvVSfviAg4AXAEXzSqB9NDNuyg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@whattheheckisthisthing","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-4TIOQvJwA8MMWHt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Was I the only one who died at 19:20 with the comment “I love you from the bottom of my heart… and my p***s”? \n\nI’m on the floor rn.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbfascCFHbJ2PF1hfsn8JcQ","author":"@Aristheticz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GT67bsORtrwcMrrJ_dg6J-Ja8ugD0DvJYSukc61VunYt4-pc8BRZUi5jFXTdok7i5Ts4r7T3=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Aristheticz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwumscWTvbspJCO8J14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"subscribed","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrcvoR1jx-DGLntN7DY60Tw","author":"@staticbeatz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8-ZqLwpmpGQxL7fLnv-5hWJQ6jvI8_7unj32nIkvknH9T87qMcX4dj-JJ44wMPhyg_mrFLbY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@staticbeatz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxPNmkVKOVMH_aqTON4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is the best video I've seen in years. As a 68 year old American expat living in SE Asia  living on a moderate pension, I can certainly sympathize with everything you said. I do use Spotify now, but over my lifetime I've bought hundreds of records and CD's, probably attended a rock concert every week or two, bought several electric basses and guitars and attended the Seattle night club scene. So I don't feel guilty using Spotify now. Love this channel!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCWIKDyXLq7q9et2m9ejO0Nw","author":"@ebx100","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mlEnA_CYn0rV_-6H-O6JC0kGdGAGuGYECltlo0LZHcLZnMN_xr6jbqVUURpcF0dDIR5g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ebx100","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzgiiWRZESvimFasit4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I like your focus against streaming platforms but most people wouldn't even consider cancelling those subscriptions without a feasible alternative. Also, as much as directly supporting an artist via Patreon is fair, it's still another subscription, and honestly, have we not had enough of those?\nI would love you to get people into the habit of buying music on Bandcamp and helping them build something like a Plex server which can provide all if not better advantages of streaming plus almost complete support of artists. Let's go back to being able to own something because subscriptions are just not it. Having a file in my hard drive that I paid for is much better than relying on a digital store that \"sells\" me a license that they can revoke anytime, and also let's stop forcing artists into a workflow that \"pleases\" subscribers, we're just not built like it and we shouldn't be doing so.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNpOefD6u_agWp_Zl64PFUQ","author":"@kikencorp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8_7c5QrxUQNX_ytg8LKcXvUaPeazsePLRisQoWSiuqQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kikencorp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzCltBnrHIm3jEOSF94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A friend of mine used to make AI lo-fi beats, then upload them to streaming, run the plays up with bots and cash out","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdui71Ak8H5YkP4W-ZhK7Rw","author":"@AubreyOnfroy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k07rYU7Q63leZsZOJiu_fBdNVzYhSWwm2IfvKHPPD5IuU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AubreyOnfroy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyx3S22zO-gzY5uwhJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about soundcloud, mixcloud, and say bandcamp? how do they pay? it would be nice to see the whole list of services you compared.  (please apologize if this question already came up in the 2,084 comments before)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCw3Y0DwzXMFETVNiaG1th3Q","author":"@weiss2go","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nTSo4bHr80X0ZkcZ7ImqR9x9hu38uvEsUSmTAk-I6lwhBl=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@weiss2go","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz5XSVjp3ZDRXesIdF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I really hope there will be easy ways to test if something is just made from Ai or not. I kept thinking it would be an arms race kind of thing. But in my opinion, it should be a legal requirement for a photo or ai music to at least have meta-data detailing it was made with Ai. Maybe even details on what it was made with and all the artists stolen from to make it. Wouldn't that be nice? Yeah I know it's totally unrealistic.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCw_G86AxzO1xLy70lmtD9Rg","author":"@evo2542","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n_BQmT656RjTB0Fo_RmWtkxDEv1qMnCO750QJ06QA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@evo2542","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxb98SzPSI1-HL6GIB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Everything i’ve heard about the #1 highest paying service has been against my will 💀 And also it makes sense why they’re losing so much money in their industry despite thie product being so simple at its core","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClziU9vBt81RiLaQMgpSp0g","author":"@Neuvalence","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x-qPfUgvqrWUNZqrG8dQk4Livctct8pS4cOwNDt7kBAcQURBCyZajzDPfPSvwot6yeOXBDlF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Neuvalence","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx3a9RHiRnaUZQFq7R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"ive been hearing a lot of AI generated sounding music on the radios in the grocery store lately","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChro_nc1UWo0ZZbyJaq_j4Q","author":"@IceGuadian","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-Q1cTykmDPJo1arFcfYLr56pABxIaW3eY3fwoxRcZmmklfkjMgaS4K2BVaFnZxwF9SRS0NybFg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@IceGuadian","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxbyy_D3ob2YHsaXF54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Most per stream I would assume amazon, at least that is what I have seen in my numbers.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnY8IMbywCXZuyjidUR1k9w","author":"@areallyboredguy5825","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k-XuzBg8X1R5rS7bTdt5f2pNTtfPmzqZtQ6V2-VAiYBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@areallyboredguy5825","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwHwfb8rV4QkUtzpGB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"At what point does AI ruin digital art in all forms and we go back to physical mediums?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC2K07Re9e5MnRT7FNdtSlGg","author":"@Whenuknow","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/EXQGVwTW3ID8HyXrUbT3f5pKScRL7FyZ8Kt1wfvRP9uzN5wOLnbBHyMTt-g_1SpvkjwIxpd9SMc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Whenuknow","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwHwfb8rV4QkUtzpGB4AaABAg.AD-f2VdyQF6AD4KZ9K139l","parent":"UgwHwfb8rV4QkUtzpGB4AaABAg","text":"Give it around 10-20 years.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvZlK4lftKwue2BASsD2AgA","author":"@Bluetag9009","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nqOYwleVmlb7SK2vX_OV4xWkZAccvYCcKV6Ne-p3OC6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Bluetag9009","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugya_D4gichLuXIoJ9p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As someone who used to make extreme noise music (made by \"surfing\" internal feedback loops not by actually playing anything), the last few years I've been wondering: would a complete lack of the generally accepted musical structure make it harder or easier for an AI to replicate? I know the likelihood of it getting scraped is pretty low to begin with, but if it did.. I wonder how difficult it would be to tell. Could it replicate \"Diamorphose Rings of the Akousmatikoi\" in a way that would fool me, or would it try to make it make sense in a way that would make it obvious it's applying a general knowledge of song structure.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwN4plu7Rv1hedqe9q4wv4Q","author":"@BoredToDeafRecords","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kjElJDwHqIL8JFD-adxlgcn2zMiOFfYjBQO-vC31l2mw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BoredToDeafRecords","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxclIEgpce8rESEgC14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if someone wrote the tune themselves, the lyrics, general structure and then one of these AI music creation sites spit out variations for the user to edit a bit more and/or chop up to their liking?  (different voice, intonation, style, etc)  Can you really copyright that or prevent people from listening to that?  What if an existing producer loves all the weird SFX these things are capable of outputting in almost real time.  If people enjoy it...what really is the difference?  You can't beat or match the classics, for sure..(yet)  but there is also soooo much human created content that is absolute trash but people still make a living off it.  Why would you take this away from indie's that are trying to make a bit of money off the machine, especially in this climate where industry is one of the major pains squeezing artists. (both visual and audio)\n\nOut and out copy pasting variations, yeah...that is terrible and really needs some protection against, obviously.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCtDWzTvmd3EV7lDRdJ-WNjw","author":"@jenkem4464","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxqIwhZo-tXHXLIypnITXZ8l1uC04rK_VYFK-KHFQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jenkem4464","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzKkMO-jfAxE6r3wbN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is anyone able to confirm which streaming services and distributors I can upload my music to without consenting for it to be used in AI? Thank you!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyDYhWKPCThQaZFbIFCReqw","author":"@SageGarlandSingerSongwriter","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qTpiW0elUHLWxQiEBY5-m-wbQRjQNL5WEt2-0ld2CDga7M8ODCnFldEchVbpqqwC3Iju6Xyj-A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SageGarlandSingerSongwriter","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz0IOviQep--dvY72d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:02 a little confusing that you show per cent while saying per dollar at the same time 😅","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdliPtPrLGSh-Q-2BR4E7oA","author":"@pindebraende","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WBQHo9DgR2cBJ_9mZ68z8RSmEvSH0aPPavej4kKgiQv7PnaISzsOsM5J2EN3p3D8-PAP7Pj-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pindebraende","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwdw8iO9OodkM3qujh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Soul is THE most appreciated and least understood aspect of creativity. It is almost impossible to define, but people know it when they experience it. Ai has no Soul, and it is easy to detect it for that reason.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZMzYPyZ-Wn2Y1bNMxrFmFA","author":"@batmandeltaforce","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_krNLrJQeUtdQfysh5aLyahDQe1zHgViCEQhT-ZFgBqug=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@batmandeltaforce","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw1hPd_GwBmxr8pxtN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If bro shows up \"una1v3d by suey-side\" on page 7 of the news, we know he was onto something BIG, in typical whistleblower fashion","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9thq5Oj08gQsMmWBsA4yEQ","author":"@Mastrodali","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vtQN52kfP__h5W7nLGa8pKAydwcXYWIdaRWJMx-dAptNuD8YxLK8-honOp0sUIDMztTtUf3INiQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mastrodali","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw8kjE7BGJkJMaSSQp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"On one hand this is horrible because it means the age of making a living through art is truly dead, on the other hand, it basically already was, so maybe now we can just make art for the sake of art and free ourselves from the notions of monetary incentive (assuming we aren't starving).","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSXr8D-u8lzygZvEwoLobTw","author":"@edgyzero6305","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lT0uPKir72G537WqVxzVEtdWog6IOPBbgTTnfHyU7D2es=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@edgyzero6305","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxfvseG0dUlijy7F5R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Funny how the guy who looks like McCauley Culkin grown up bitter thinks pressing chords on a MIDI controller makes you more ‘real’ than curating an entire vibe.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCLnPu51zkcEjQJi7AdPJ9Yg","author":"@CaptainofthePoopDeck","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/R3GkdwsLUujU1BFyBU3RzJZB1Px0oDM8wz8T1IjyvGldPQAFraygkQtQAARZVi90Nw-I_tQZ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CaptainofthePoopDeck","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxfvseG0dUlijy7F5R4AaABAg.AJ7V8P2-4TpAJ9cecMd6Wz","parent":"UgxfvseG0dUlijy7F5R4AaABAg","text":"Your bio speaks worlds about you. Maybe a midi controller will be able to cure you","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCj_7s-PY7m2BDy0gbhV_ULg","author":"@neffix6976","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kZmzJqY8I35Zl-GAWhuz_XOqLJqj8BXZU6CPa2yRySGuHsiwKzLosLr4UhlysBEkBia-kbga6v0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@neffix6976","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgybJ-zPCFEf8AkE7_V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I used the stones to destroy the stones.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAeq7sSVmxwU0I2jzzbN5yA","author":"@ChamAramis","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qCKWskpPqc4JTxm5HQXkesfELAitlJolKRw0tpr5fnIZLN7v66XlZGpm76trUmQNGat76ap0xg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ChamAramis","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxdPdbmCQBvskOYiBh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ik I should hate ai cause it’s just gonna create extra obstacles and hurdles for me to get threw to get even a tiny amount of attention to my music. But I just can’t wait to use all the tools to make screen more creative music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMT3BxOhx1ezDgFQHXevc_g","author":"@ShaMoneyRapBestFr","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qzGaUmbP1ILvVNeoPOkwM_imEzDsMpA6YQoOb-YRH5Xtgi0JosUBkJykishDXFlHvST0yhLH4A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ShaMoneyRapBestFr","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz7VtTo9VAzjLFw3Bd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The dollars per stream number is a total red herring if you are not also looking at the number of streams. There's no way Benn had a higher number of streams on Amazon than on Spotify. Amazon is paying more per stream, but significantly fewer streams. It may all even out, but it's possible that Spotify still pays Benn more than Amazon in total. But he did not tell us. Red herring.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzHBJArMgxajug_R7qwqd_w","author":"@kaistrandskov","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lvrJvXmSbDs0zSln29kNgWRGrH8WzUwDFfAG_TvmtpHqU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kaistrandskov","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyxEG_e_gk22t6tVtd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"guess: youtube pays the most","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCjsg4LLIEQAbZgMCWg7zKHA","author":"@michaelwesolek","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZvI9QXh7qwUOsYHcakORu8Szcp-mlP6mXFR0uqXA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelwesolek","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxWLgUTKqi_28QtS054AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is the sky blue detector lol.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClCdT8YVujOZOoYduXgP7FQ","author":"@draken5379","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOEZvjUov39Om4Y5-Ehh-XTZYzRq7yeeWbmlnj1jc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@draken5379","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwrB1ESLTOqV7k-Wxd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:18 HUH?? where did that come from lol?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4i5N3dq5RaX7VLCdO_PDyw","author":"@lestersmug11","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/g65MCHmhaRpTynpHtxIAb-BoiOhbbP7FF0dt_T2hyPGdjz1m7EUBANrsmDKjfMsOJiS_5nTDXv0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lestersmug11","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwmrGzlrX-mkiY2Kz14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:00\nIt might be that English is my second language. But I'm confused about the statements here.\nThe \"point, zero, zero, zero, zero, five\" through to the \"point, O, O, two, one\" statements... the extra spoken \"0's\" is confusing me...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk4SGAgC6OD4JIO7d8uMm9Q","author":"@avinavianelli8012","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lxqNgsn0FW3slSmIgLVt02kW95DzSHWjai5OicOuobYWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@avinavianelli8012","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwo7oEnZfnL57-VDDd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"soon we will have to answer \"i'm an ACTUAL musician\" to the question \"what do you do for a living?\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBhQLDyNhUSRacuY1w9LY7w","author":"@ulfgj","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ln2nNxhpb_hTnjD6oZNmrGh2BvUjXKwpclGCYaDDtiMOk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ulfgj","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVP-uN-9Icjlu_UXN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't mind AI as a tool, but streaming has been utterly flooded with low quality AI 'music' and those platforms, as you say, don't seem to care. So at this point I'd take any solution that helps, even better when it's grassroots and comes from creators.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCumXqxlw_BTpjdP18bXg66g","author":"@Nebelkorona","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ntAxjqmMBcQwP-fvbH9P4axEJiu9aNID99RRgFgvUXtZU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nebelkorona","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwR23wK2HUo80rH-Y54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Doubt will see this but yeah just finished I made an app (hip hop lounge) so far on Android and paid few artists\n\nIt's 2c per artist per view as that's on average mainly 100% of the ad rev\n\nInterested if could combine and make the platform a lot bigger for artists as the audience size could be bigger and have IOS expansion soon","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXg9Q0HQQ9bO-7PQQaZXXYA","author":"@projectsync1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dwrIzbSGyFv2cCsf22EKEbYZg-tMGjnTgfN2cOHoa3_DIcPg4ijmbMYVBXPl7bzBqW_zC0gjJQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@projectsync1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwm13NL_UK5nbcYnuJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thank youuuuuuuuuu.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAMEkcB7YERJ-I6CoaMXX8w","author":"@bullpaxton2001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l92hnGYRBjBEUeSdkU3TsyvhHnfvCAdEIHLU6_JJuJVw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bullpaxton2001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyNI8wBrq5dSdRXwGh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I absoultly need my music offline as I work where there is nop cell reception. I buy my music...albeit digitaly.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzkrgqGXPmhqOBaMYqTxbyA","author":"@freebiird420","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Csmj_Usr_uIXxymZTISawM-3VFAZj6yyLZ79w-4I_JS5n8zf1m1UGqFU5hRh-b2L2Gm7eput_KA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@freebiird420","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxjyq7bIjCFZrloish4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Commenting for the algorithm","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1k5cUOLUBgp64eFqztbqpQ","author":"@DissonantSynth","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bDft_Ki04d0wULvoDXrdFr-QSDXH147MmcZsy6b1mUS3GYbNeNG6dkonWkTYT33YN_MDegdy=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DissonantSynth","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxqcQJPVfR7jyDA4gZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I, personally, don’t listen to music. Cool for me. I watch cause 1) it feels honest, 2) I hope you release your adversarial AI tools to open source even though I know why you should not.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDxsASukfg3qDeuYQCxA_eQ","author":"@pepaw","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/y4_DZlRKs8I-sxAoTfQLw6O2LfXxUcpVeHS6tEjIqsP-kCx9CKQBjMcmvQjKRKoImFQ-15C9vGY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pepaw","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzMgoqI39-qNNtTwLd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Will big AI undertakings (Grok) be able to overcome the watermarking or poisoning of the audio file?\nHave you ever extracted the wave file data that is unappreciable in the 128k mp3 file (wav - mp3) and output that \"lost\"  data as a \"missing data\" file in and of itself? What are the perceiveable audio signatures in the extracted \"difference\" file?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLnpGV6RZtEUx9uXzxTmNAA","author":"@SomnoNaut","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxGq79cPP_VsSjYu0pz9K4ZEdMEMFoiRyhnYtBs6L8Iw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SomnoNaut","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw-IE_EtfA-ZGg2cpN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Everywhere else I’m reading puts Amazon Music at about the same as Spotify per stream.  Not that I want to give them money. Any more information? 14:59","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXInZYodtVX66R2RGLw0Oyg","author":"@felixdadeathcat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZv1K5v535nllLusMvUfN06jHbLjJEfMGEtGc9_rM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@felixdadeathcat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxZu8UTUxFuUM0gNG94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Could you use .WAV files to train AI to start with an .MP3 and mimic a .WAV file? Not replicate, necessarily, but eliminate (or bury in noise) the frequency-spectrum \"fingerprint\" of the compression process?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0URFA372CF0q_Klqm8nE_A","author":"@danpatterson8009","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kc143wob2vGVDlUyjpHHLemtb90yh3b6wlmdWY4VlkFtA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@danpatterson8009","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxslMV6WYhsg15Sxq54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I guess this video is to disheveled... dishevel. DISHEVEEEEEEEL!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCD6_Jz4Q7CXcojkcgBrW7IA","author":"@pip3guy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m8v8P5TaKjiF19Tk06HhVnm_0uaKc4q6oYfMnLLibe-g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pip3guy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz1Nq50466XyzplEFB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"min 10:29\n  making proper Mexican folklore beats ! lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzsjgPe0HAY1F8i9IjdDl_w","author":"@sandalero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mKZi1kMsYj_FxectPC2Xy07BNggrGSswnzvVoiSIkM5tP0h-9NJfEmV0QqKdWOX6nSMZl09Ugg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sandalero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaYHIFU3WwRoqR4SF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Good lad 👍","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxsrh7NHxLOZcVe4jSQrLmw","author":"@pluckingthespectrum","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJWRr5Z0fDOYo-I22zSJ71I7J9y0Kr9fFsZeat1XNBDw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pluckingthespectrum","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz1Nb9zh5C62gyahRJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I have never felt better about never moving away from Apple’s music ecosystem","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVzSs_tdJPbgBkjy5IhCmYA","author":"@jloiben12","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mDFXeBkuwlVsFnogk9X2O4gWkAH1vxGd0w3YBl2l4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jloiben12","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzdilw4KumafqubiMV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Are you able to see the difference between a regular YouTube user and a YouTube premium user? I was under the impression that those are different compensation schemes.\n\nI’m liable to keep using YouTube music regardless because it serves my needs better than the rest but it would be nice to know","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCg_PdyNnOaTUkH9wF-v5E-g","author":"@shadebug","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxDtN_eakXCvEm1RgNS1eqrJmvSWJ2028gCVU4xl0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shadebug","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLjwyzRN-y2JTAeu94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Musicians are just petty wannabe copyright infringement lawyers now.😂😂😂","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCtM6mX1FhqabIEAlm4Qrm5w","author":"@ryshellso526","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_leAmSeaUVgETMHt5TdMGCnuteea5gXn87gVKWLfScdaYE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ryshellso526","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx31deHytAxhIQuBrB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If someone is able to get purely Suno to produce a song that attracts nearly 1M listeners, there's a good chance they spent as much time trying to splice and generate it on the platform as a traditional musician would writing one from scratch.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRUhfgLvSg5OIJLQQWIqIPQ","author":"@casefc3s","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YE9dYFd26PCK6M8Ino-tYwik6IdPlsB75uo7GomEJDifWFv4X6IMllaT9z3xVm2DRHjNt3Ux=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@casefc3s","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyeatIgrmDmWxAyTPd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":":face-red-heart-shape:","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCl8JlSEBn2cDu7gYPP7TNaA","author":"@noyoquese..","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/j5VOxM_16ZskRK7q6k4VNCU8vrUE74sQyrRm748fYGhNQKnjMkv6NzMnNVwIxg8IEwWZAPEl=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@noyoquese..","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx99RWKl_ASpJ02iIx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10 years ago, laptop songwriters were stealing money from real musicians who could play instruments.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCh2PIJWIsKO03X0YtD-vWuA","author":"@DJOdieOD","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lBrEjTUBd-ERFD8dqdI13N5z06j4UYZ6-slt7WP6D06w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DJOdieOD","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxBmtaqa51hPa6OfDJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Fighting Ai with Ai is just desserts","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXxocNy2FedSHM35bRJjqgw","author":"@Vividxful","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lbPqGIG8ugZ4GVuDMdzrcIxV0uZGXsN3chfr3UOIU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Vividxful","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx3IN-PAALjrlMTZwN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Many things generated would not legally qualify for copyright because there is low level of creative expression, not enough creative thought. Or only the original part of the work can be copyrightable, i.e. lyrics or parts of lyrics.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC43sRL7IF7QJo1c2KArJ2eg","author":"@tutacat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTrrHNGPRIMVPlGVJWJRUZyPKZgYzMHAYeE5q4nDRgYMMh1I483VD9E0r_pf3-S3k_iQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tutacat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxnjQ8FuPorlgDpsGJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"am i crazy or has compressed audio always been noticeable?   what if the experiment you mentioned just used bad equipment that didnt show the difference and what songs were used ?   uncompressed dosent mean anything if the source audio was recorded in low quality or is in a range that isnt cut off by compression or if the song itself is low fi as the style.        you can definitly tell when something is over compressed.    i remember getting 128 vs 380 qualities of songs and the difference was really there.   some songs became garbled at lower qualities.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1ZP_hSfce3G-B5bFYDs7eg","author":"@ali32bit42","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/W6tUgDgHsFDfnfDuLIcGUhW9zYZcYFv_j60cXWb-jUaH9mxrz1YENV_N3mQLGXZBKVYGYfFD=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ali32bit42","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyjA5fWc05Ehv0HFBt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It all comes down to wannabes looking for an easy way to fake talent and corporations ruining everything for the sake of profit. \n\nHappened with the  internet, gaming, movies, and now music and drawing.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyigmWfR57vEitfD_4tKO4Q","author":"@ripleyhrgiger4669","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lwk0vjUq1u3-tQzNKXD4jgoCJduFVWfPtEBlTFrVrYGk8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ripleyhrgiger4669","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyDrEtRFIPp9GCURrJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think some missing zeros in the first screen of bar chart","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCysl8JOcahGGHtgp7M4lvXQ","author":"@mattsephton","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mOD0b5iMA06ImXwpCKvyToTKOscNpPMiih69Z1DUVCtLtF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mattsephton","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwMeSMC7rTd3fym3hR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm sorry what just happened at 19:18?! LOL","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcqjm9kmxftrBw-AI-fPUIA","author":"@kevello","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nR0-PnJgN8KG342ASRrq9BF_TFLtJJ-Aelw3rt7sCasn0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kevello","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz712Vo_NJFQ17AVt14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Switched from Spotify to Deezer for lossless and partially because they pay people more. Unfortunately it seems that Deezer has very poor QA when it comes to artist pages, several artists I followed on Spotify have their Deezer pages infested with AI-generated \"lo-fi\" tracks by somebody using the same artist name and Deezer is happy to just throw it all together as if it was made by the same person","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoh7_cBDWXKLCD0ERAuuouA","author":"@Deadly_Laser","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lUEpycfXjAXYgYnRtGyHvP-Iu3hjdzXRVfHNeE6DizRw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Deadly_Laser","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz8dNfbG54Ue2gaY-t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Buying the physical CD?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6c_dTNJkmQH6wtdaJGD-RA","author":"@skeetabomb","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/F3PnRUWipCRet7uSKT1bfMes9PzH8P7Z5Dy4AN__lOH7CFlng2RreDfkZnuu41aad7-6F1Ga=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@skeetabomb","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgygX2ecIrks-BAJ6j14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I make AI music on this channel, but I do it honestly and am open to artist and musicians taking it, and using it for their own purposes, I write a lot of the songs. Some are made entirely by AI.\n\nI hate when people pose the AI music as real artist and aren't honest about it. I think it is best used as a tool to inspire.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJxuEjG7KX9T3sAj1fH5Ksw","author":"@AIMusicTheRoundTable","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TTnXG_NBmpmclSFQbc6SIgvVpRT2Jh93G1DgguBHOhqwSey2o5-JnM_MC1LGmyWKgQZ3Y02BGg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AIMusicTheRoundTable","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzM-5SCOxvQcOWhJ354AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"is your ai detecting tool available to use?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRuKFRWf2_c5hxapvA3FLmQ","author":"@marcin-man","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/s0sqcZ3gyVgXoNsci7LY2r5C0PsW8L__6ClgEqVPK4JgXSoaAxnORk2i6qZGGyTd0wC0hO4J=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@marcin-man","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwU13T4rFoUVrqmemx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:32 I wish people would stop repeating this - it's besides the point. Yes, I agree that you or I can't hear the difference between MP3 and FLAC for 99% of most tracks, and depending on what you listen to, a large percentage of the tracks you can't tell at all. But, for specific parts of a performance (specific 'room', highly noisy sounds like particular distortion, or famously audience hand-clapping, etc.) it's almost the opposite. It's distracting how bad the compression mangles it if you have a good ear. You probably do, you can probably hear it too, and the fact that a lot of the music you listen to doesn't have those sounds or effects does not change the fact that you can tell the format in those cases, and won't like it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsmkIcIEADCB7bs94FQYWNA","author":"@JaapvanderVelde","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3SDlxcMKvK9v_bZo2bFnXB6NBCiGo5TzU8pZB9ChOirE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JaapvanderVelde","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwU13T4rFoUVrqmemx4AaABAg.ACyQISHDqedACyQkxYuMLh","parent":"UgwU13T4rFoUVrqmemx4AaABAg","text":"And before people assume that a single critical comment means I hate this video and am trying to get others to hate it - I liked it, it's great, and I hope future ones will be even better.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsmkIcIEADCB7bs94FQYWNA","author":"@JaapvanderVelde","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3SDlxcMKvK9v_bZo2bFnXB6NBCiGo5TzU8pZB9ChOirE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JaapvanderVelde","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_02sNKsKUrOJ7I0Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Better than using a “streaming service” to support your favorite artist, why not - you know - buy their merchandise directly?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwwL5uVjyKgRYF6FU33MmFg","author":"@feywer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nHrJPGSlOH_rtmM3c5l589lGO22C-gaGu3N7UEkO-nZUs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@feywer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxCclPEfMh1KRg8On14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"13:42 - Napster did not pay anything? Shocker :D","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn4DygQtDQbnkr66rZHorIA","author":"@XDRosenheim","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kjUrpDct84edA_iifjb4fBh2ttCQXwj_5tK5MpzKKfpb0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@XDRosenheim","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx7n5iibzsSUsr2t_p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"is buying buying physical media new better than streaming? or paymore  once vs pay less every listen?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-l90RfWQRlKDzkN4oM0qnQ","author":"@allenlark","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nFvE2JJXeX9F8SNvCDl4HrqqTOq41hk4MYiYjoUKV95FY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@allenlark","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzDDAkJmou_4CqlokF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It’s a good job I make music as a hobby and not as a job as those numbers are shocking","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgpU5XGGvls_16JOkLofDxQ","author":"@mrdrgonzo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nOxIrU5tUSKF3_QTO6TYn0hHuWS_78bpb7ddolLZkD5A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mrdrgonzo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwrqQ7Y4kaTDelaQ-54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I can tell on the high hats and it's irritating. Currently 1/2 of my music on spotify currently has issues with high hat sounds where I hear quantization. Super irritating.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCl7xA9mG-ix57_SmpgCbYGA","author":"@andjohn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_naBpUBwlsEpfHMICtiq-c9_TJjR3aj9lT-yXKOHbIheA4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andjohn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyMh90v00KoRzLBoO14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:23 looks like some of the values might be off by a zero 😅😅","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCyMjPwDpev2coukDyTmTnZQ","author":"@ProdDJD","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4AUzrP1vU9orngWZU2lszfLh4VPNTaP3zegzVzpQN-SBT4f8J6FZzH2lux9hK2yywn_lgQn_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ProdDJD","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyMh90v00KoRzLBoO14AaABAg.ADCrvZ7xciGAEx6B-PoMWY","parent":"UgyMh90v00KoRzLBoO14AaABAg","text":"It’s displayed on screen as out of 1¢ but he’s reading the numbers out of 1$ so the math checks out.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQ5xMpUuyVAqrQZb5vsp49w","author":"@teguh.hofstee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kq-R91TtpHgn-9UW2bNmCd75T7DLJtH8mLdP7NKC-KOEOK=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@teguh.hofstee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwkz9epFu_TFmqDw854AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"did you just say ? \nnevermind","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZeetfDFut227EqoXmRHn1w","author":"@charliebaby7065","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l934Htf6WJYnN3yHuMz4nswrNitVfA9PO3DBA2CI1eww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charliebaby7065","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyE1orBoymtt88lnLN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Napster and Tidal pays the most per stream . Peleton isn’t streaming service but pays a lot more","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgb0PunNAHYTRvvrsn2CWyg","author":"@simpsonsmafia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MqsmzbeLB4uRy3nFqJ3Qnpm8YA5-B3tU8oQTxzZ8sSSDmIESL2CjJy5mOMLG612z8iSXnOGEAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@simpsonsmafia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzT9u0bt2zVFAxjMOF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"YouTube Music is packed with AI artists. I stopped using it because of that. It was constantly recommending fake artists to me.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC6qfgz2bSH7UuBfVQ2vXDUw","author":"@johnneiberger","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhPni7P3eWJTP7LA0Uk1ow8LH8G4dTuefSSYXKQszHjH-m=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@johnneiberger","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxikF3yJD-6N8Bdokh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Look for the recent Freakonomics episode titled How To Poison the AI Machine","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0hOGGJ6H61E0qofEwxPlwg","author":"@oldasrocks9121","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_klDCs59t1JkqeC7DUwX4HoExz2dC4lwfZEphwzWC8cVw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oldasrocks9121","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw9S-7zAlRi_G63-x94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I can definitely tell if an mp3 is 128k or lower. 192, 256 and 320 is much harder to tell, but isnt it obvious to everyone else (audio lovers) that the hi-hats, crashes, and other symbals are \"pixelated\" and \"shhhy\" instead of a clear \"sss\"? It's even recognized in speech clarity, \"ch\" \"t\" \"s\" \"k\" \"z\" especially if you are familiar with the person speaking, you can tell its not a lisp. Obviously it depends on the media content if its Lo-Fi or whatever, but in my opinion 128kbps is pretty low quality and noticable.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCstxoWvb-C6I9758DogLySw","author":"@SunAndMirror","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KhRwUU9ndGJEYxGNVJJEAwddqjjmsNx1d7HFWcKnhOx05gu7j7ye_2IBHe7YW81eep7M_FqYFw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SunAndMirror","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgylOAB6oWt3rJ6Mf8F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"is it possible the amazon music unlimited payouts are including album / track purchases?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfK1O62LqK55F7qiXgFB5Jw","author":"@nono-ky2yu","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n8uQEUfmV_U_qQyEvf9Q7hXXH61qX5-M7SAqggUdI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nono-ky2yu","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwNB2w-_MVyiMlKc6h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:14 fire","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQICSCBJV9snQca60BkOLxg","author":"@Maou3","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/q5S1U-fjoe3ER2w7xAWEfVrw2M85NiKI6-2IiY-bx64qjZP5tNIa65ltuCWzScE65SL1-37UOzY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Maou3","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzayCqzpL2zDtb3rCZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Like the velvet sundown?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKjnn6jE_I91Bb_M_nXHEFw","author":"@SeemoreDunkan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/y1DOO5IcoDUJVX6X2s9YORN8ZnvanaM1bBJMnaHUqzfG7YFM8yaw-shVh2kjZ4r2PBpYfxcK=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SeemoreDunkan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGO2d7QQv8RPanF7F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My question would be can this model of detection tell the difference from AI mixing and Mastering software and plugins vs traditional mixing and mastering. For example, If a song was written by a human but mixed and mastered using AI software like Izotope Ozone etc would it come up as genuine or AI? I would be curious to know the result of that question.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_ZnW5PybCmxRboWjwetDvw","author":"@scottrance2818","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nPGQrN-BIp5mybn6P9UyAwo8pFvG9p5j8EeqIB8sg-xRU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@scottrance2818","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw3CPKuFaBy3-N-TLV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ugh but the problem is also that Spotify is just where everyone is\n\nI hear this loud and clear and I agree it’s the moral thing to do to jump ship\n\nBut then I just know I wouldn’t be exposed to a fifth of the artists I discover through Spotify alone","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiOpO8UARvlthsP-uldtCTA","author":"@serapheogen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BQmP_FgrGaa9wXp3wYZLsU-U-eQVneCT057HqgOdEe3lEwKom6RgMDIU3wgvpa0WApP9fYoRe4Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@serapheogen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwFIK7i-uo9yTBxwRN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I watched a video about this AI epidemic and decided to completely switch to downloads. I'm not going to be tricked into hearing AI slop.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn2fJcbKfvmyTjrTqsy35ww","author":"@ant3t3","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/WAvuTQiQJ61HbmtFuj5b20vU1MuMM7h-no9olruhOnGhFw38dQLOMJzmDwgvCcl35u7EiL6ciA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ant3t3","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaurWPy7t8pLmQUMN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you are in that 10% or whatever that can blind a/b different bitrates, Qobuz has a ton of high-bitrate lossless stuff.  Their selection is nowhere near as wide as Tidal or Spotify though.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9oFIXV5UXiuh0yNxB9TwSg","author":"@VerticalMammal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BEvADuwo6wxrSezZotV_fB5GfuYyx9ECWVp2orp9wuwNPLHZveo9FVE53xul679GndRubpV7nQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@VerticalMammal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzx9F-mhKMNMWsK_Jx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Fantastic","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHGLszDtvZW7b9AUVInzjzg","author":"@andythemany2826","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KX4wFN97IH2o56ipAZI4TCGGc1QVC61SL4W4WeZVLAd3Fd5IDe4fRDV08rKaXyKRTgZts9ZoRQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andythemany2826","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwN_wX37o5BYMZgAdJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"does deezer still have that system where your top 4 artists get a higher share from your subscription feed","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLC1yu_YGReDhMMWEz5bwQA","author":"@Nairolf0007","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k5jR0Qo9cZhu8FB7c-dB0m1O2G6uSuWebyTIQzRCAZdek=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nairolf0007","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWzu4bMXA__i01RTF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Curious how SoundCloud stacks up in the payout rates","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3LtM9At2Zf_U6jicuhCJlw","author":"@tannerr_dev","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GyOnEo1RFu5e-dBOkUQOUeJSfkrmZCeS4OVULKShKdgF6JgZKM6VG1AB-uD1W31ti-OPzmDhnWI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tannerr_dev","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz3xaF-5JUZD7udSJV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How do you release your music?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCo5OoWTPLwc2-KzYxnxvuSw","author":"@mcteacher1505","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kIQd925lZn3kNvSQBuSIvxotU3QPyWJUGr6nl8J4Bbkl1bcFpzgHabStJf-LedxUFwQA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mcteacher1505","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyl-aGAlbDyi9e7SxN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A service could pay you $1 per stream but if they had no users, you get $0. So you gotta compare the volume too.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCf7lHs9rduPv3DTZBOxW4Sg","author":"@thingies4U","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mwcBpWvdj2pMhDHydrYgwTKLPw69rB6S6nzXj_UCykCA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thingies4U","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxFAQOiG9CylZqHRK54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i’m 4 steps ahead and only listen to midi files","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmqLcylkaqHfZxssySiDSwA","author":"@RalseiGaming","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kWZnq7q-GiJk1wN62M8z9ywUAAajP_diJKg9sQQa7t_g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RalseiGaming","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzHjQq5w4b0S39h2tN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"does anyone know how to find an original for vocal of generation? for example udio-generated track, I liked the voice, I know its from some band, I need to find a vocalist, what should I do? I don't like ai's theft of art, I just want to find original artist & listen to them. once I heard how it used Kim Gordons voice from sonic youth even!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2hD8kC9biaN7NC_PW-d6bQ","author":"@anastasiasolovieva6488","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOSGnRGzfb_jAAcBZfse5wSgyiC6vjodidTqM82FU9MA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@anastasiasolovieva6488","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxNEEVbD5Vpru4CoAh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hey it's the flahbulb","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCBuAqfZwFQif4ZfcblOczQ","author":"@electricdazz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oYIkfgA0QB_HeMnhR0QGPh-AT0qGuMQrldkcXAomSgPw6j95zE3CrycJ3HrFiza3oJwVU0u8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@electricdazz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzOHN7wZZa57BL6DiZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I knew it was qobuz!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdKqhRDmVUk37W8wsjRNhjg","author":"@navienslavement","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fdXYuaummCqyOFBY16O9b2lPscioTw5nlp78SDNmLoocr--pASbBAZjxmw1Ff3sjgVhh_AS_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@navienslavement","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzlMtQikMc9QEvWVzV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Udio etc creators are definitely „artists“. Mostly not musicians, but artists. It doesn‘t matter that it might be „easier“ to do ai music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJqb2F7dUfcng3eqWKB89UQ","author":"@vincevangoat1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/25QeTx40fBeBac_0WW5OqNtQnvhN8USVfZ3t4x7__06m4FyAEzWGECXbmB4spC461ACaZdyt=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vincevangoat1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwsD1GG2oaJY1J0gpN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You look EXACTLY like Negan and The kid from home alone in one","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwZbZsVQXX2oLqPPCtPsiAA","author":"@officialmayxday","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/U4wDai9ZTBvG_4cRe9HvBSoNSjYXOW9WRiXa8MCX8R5TF5rBko7c2NVZt9Hs2ug6cmLnI7y61nk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@officialmayxday","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw5bdD_TSjKrNnyDGN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It's funny how potent people think AI is","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHBSbhXxZEHCaZvA0EIcthQ","author":"@reboooot","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n3CWQy9EVKfS7a3eofX9ULtCY8SuzCdZWbMFStpa2mqsbzMM4JLjft7-FA_U0kp3tmOQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@reboooot","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwU3YP8HFxnd4sgy2h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I have started buying records and CDs again. Im just so mad at the entire tech industry. Generative AI is a betrayal","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7fxs8Mu51OcqT9cctBhP2A","author":"@1015SaturdayNight","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dgDtMFch0MGNzPsBJXnau4sh0l56qqt04yczzRlgzd8o6fGVzLeQt_ECimv3KosKd6fg3LPB=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@1015SaturdayNight","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyPcHw71HhkqGhKfR54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In the Splice segment, how did you find out the tracks with samples got copyright strikes? Is there an app that you can scan the track to find copyrighted material before uploading to a streaming site?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCihwqsqwIFgCTZE4TfbNfA","author":"@MrBanana808","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/URepmChla_QerpBZfchVdzLxYlxnWHFTMLL6aDecxjmtPw5DNTojhwMgQrBxPUSKWhewIWYntg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MrBanana808","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyPcHw71HhkqGhKfR54AaABAg.ACyoKWD7bFAACyzdoqWeZU","parent":"UgyPcHw71HhkqGhKfR54AaABAg","text":"Unfortunately, they're mostly B2B platforms that you access with an API. I suppose you could sign up to one and put down a small cloud deposit though, then just access it through the test terminal.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCshObcm-nLhbu8MY50EZ5Ng","author":"@BennJordan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n4yN6OoQTOtdKr9MtPVRhT38hPTP0NUkc10Ni6wZWljek_9XRq0EuBi7PbmJb2bRs_WxcgQe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":true,"author_is_verified":true,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BennJordan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwhfypAKU8wevjGSlJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great content but the artists I like are only on spotify and yt.music so I can't switch. Also, for a new viewer like me, the framerate on this video is so out of place, like my 4070 is breaking or someting...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-1tE5nFR3Mq30tsC74M4mQ","author":"@raduvalentin6122","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nKOKSwGDHsVjem-QDeDfW8j157n39iAqNh0tnPmGbT4xQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@raduvalentin6122","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTiunX0zCCvnFVhqJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm curious about something. Is it Suno/Udio full songs? Or are they making the songs for samples?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4eqX9rEjuNpCn9A5mzo2yg","author":"@TwdlD","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/onXvjU09Gst6jiGQtQNCNnQSrk_sxa-9lwoqtMQQQLmZiRh-QEl1QJYMWM2EGw0D3Lt_OEXGzA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TwdlD","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6DPAukOEgORb869Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Australia's APRA/AMCOS pays AU2c per broadcast play and this is a figure supported by legislation and the Australian Government recognises this industry body as the primary source of how songwriters get paid and how much that pay should be.\n\nUnder Australian law, streamers are supposed to pay for batch online licences at the 2c/stream figure. Very few even acknowledge artists' rights in Australia but you can hear Australian music from Colin Hay to li'l ol' unkown me until last year, when I took all my music off all the streaming services they were on. I've had 5 radio/tv plays for 1 tune but can't take my music down from APRA.\n\nAnyhoo, I now only use bandcamp. They've banned AI training as against terms and banned AI music. They probably don't care that I use there site because it's the last safe haven for artists, I'm a nobody at the end of a fun but unlucrative career, but they have a fair minimum price per song, give me control over the right to charge more than the minimum and they have a blanket ban on AI music and using bandcamp artists music for AI training.\n\nFor the time being, that is where we should be getting our music from.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyur-ebr0KBwqW1l6JnBfGg","author":"@crunchysteve","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h9qgSn8LFEZ5vFEmCwWlvR-bfTl3cZw-NZVveOviB_DaaY_4V1bm2IBlI21q681BO8fwk6cQyhA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@crunchysteve","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz5p4j42mIpr_vAgdt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yup. Spotify has been on my shit-list for the last year. I need to figure who to replace it with.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOz33YJg9GvBzlEmCjjxQ8w","author":"@domakesaythink2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DtloDYKJVmdLulqiWh1IwmStYtqhuxRTZdJVlih-IL7newIb8d6yUW7t4_0Auew4U8uYVDtSqqs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@domakesaythink2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwkeEBnudz81yxiZth4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But I can absolutely tell the difference between YouTube and Spotify (High Quality setting) on my beyerdynamics.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKFWCxu29w7EvGxhCkoJ4fw","author":"@_modiX","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5udBwH5WYS95D6f2Wt73h95iwyDl4mv2Q17x_4a7gjh-DNRePNajlYfcDeZcaDJGbM4SDHOF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@_modiX","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy9XrfkT41DIfUswdJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Pretty sure youtube premium listeners have a rate closer to amazon music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTIDgSFkCves2e1370iXc8g","author":"@browner1873","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k9YcJkas-lAJ8Phjmh5wiMDjLbZSqjhjWgPdJJu2lW5gI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@browner1873","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzJo46XverRDCiSqER4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Can you make this a browser extension or something","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXbuxwej8lnD1EjKOOyd5Yg","author":"@flet2flet","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/sKli9Aeq-R28UK0x6RjbNBoZ9MJAVDLdFQ02vJ-R3I2hb_I6mSfLiO3uRQNE1f8hlsth8Xkb=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@flet2flet","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx4UuvLIAhgzprk45F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The future will be strange","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzu8rcps90gfNq-qPQe8g_w","author":"@RubyDimasStudio","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ehIesrK0wsF_6tD1ic6UPdctYsRcwVgpOJTDJUKR6ha0k6_XI3OzALw6M39_0WD-Oqw3bpUZSg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RubyDimasStudio","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz147A6HqtDLZSUVol4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"been having trouble lately with sc flagging completely original works for the smallest things. every time I look up the track it flags as it's been a track by a artist with no footprint other than the one track release. I have a hunch these ai tracks are being created and uploaded en masse in order to claim copyright to as many samples as possible, original to them or not.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEm-PqDX0C2B7qYYD59W5zQ","author":"@MiLi-on4wp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsA0TtwshOdNkz2Fd5faUdaJgULW4Od3wwJd-nbQk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MiLi-on4wp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyReTZ5fCtizmZT6UV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"It would seem to me that digital royalties are all ultimately based upon ad revenues which means they are piggy-backing off of more foundational economic activities like cheap energy inputs.  Seems likely the game of musical chairs is going to hit a wall some day, sooner or later.  AI generated music is going to need to be regulated which means the Internet itself is going to have to be policed, which means…","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNjmF2rN0CQu3u1JVpOM38g","author":"@christiansmakingmusic777","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/HhqApgH0WVr7BlKNayTeujHd1NCMgFYcP58jUTK_i1XAJoYb6F6Du8Ban7Ret6SqigYsE5z8RA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@christiansmakingmusic777","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzMFsux7tdGjWItIEN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"u rock!!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMrfXSt8jj1hDPrngBqwXHw","author":"@temporaryautonomoustelevision","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fsE2P4svqc7GaQex928L-ILrsadxtK9q3RULN-oe1iLih4nXw1IV6WTa6hCGczZm2YSs-kk7Nw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@temporaryautonomoustelevision","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyR1uIEcOzgdqqR8Ql4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Please open source you AI detection system","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCTZxFuqexgmaZTj40zDRY1w","author":"@TommyAmbersonRD","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nA3fZdOoB-sNruqifAY-lsqpbFvuhSFlnF83Rar85Z_w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TommyAmbersonRD","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxfRWXkKh3SPdjCzb14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm very curious would it still be able to detect content created using AI but the AI programs are running locally on your PC and don't have access to the internet?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnwzMCbj59RkeI98rhYiRHg","author":"@DazFx81","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RVws4Pi0ftN53ZsB5j2S3ygmDqtw1WWtObaPEgfCmXuRTaENapb9WoXrKEQ4TbjgoWra-tyoubM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DazFx81","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzNlsTPel4gs6xAg7p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As a musician and audio engineer, I find it weird that you can’t hear the difference a MP3 file and a CD quality file. The distortion and crunch of a MP3 plus the lack of stereo depth makes them pretty unlistenable. Even a AAC file is better than a MP3. The same is true of AI produced tracks. I don’t need software to identify them. The distortion, lack of stereo depth in the mix and everything sounds like it’s been time stretched screams AI. All in all a pretty low quality music experience.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCmKHGcsTSsTja_XUCKHBvA","author":"@crazymfcrew","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m9FciVioYdRD9bJZrGqgAa8rmBKp0CHYy2njSTbws=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@crazymfcrew","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx75xxSV0_7VKhut6F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"1:49 is there a specific reason for the leaf?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXwgi-Jj239lHAqKu6F4Jmg","author":"@WallaWaller","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CBzQqcuADEN6hj0AsUNf7HypFryVbdRW66FMXyrfnlnAbu-RoTZuK0wUFyo2ZWKscJ7gsVryeBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WallaWaller","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzRBIsWcnnDXKtqu_V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"@19:16 i beg your pardon","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRUGCYMxF3hpwFd2000oAEQ","author":"@nateh5736","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kDhHEbALtM-EVADNwBvC1d_L4yK6V17P16Zscyn7cAwug=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nateh5736","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwoKYiuEOqSo5mP2R94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"pausing early to add the comment that i think the winner is Deezer.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVlyefcTHZxljlIiLbEbcsA","author":"@garbageface","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/UX500mqo7Rv_61wzl1X9uaPEB_lkFH_QHXqgUfmpJCcs_Y9EZQEpiixEGgcBP1OTcP2IINTc9A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@garbageface","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyhqj9Fy64u3Ss1mGx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This makes me a bit worried now that i want to finish and publish alot of my songs or keep making new ones. Im","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXDogOlwl5ked0DNXUy4Ldw","author":"@phyll24","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lI-oiyq614nG0ii8oW6Mlr7u7cZoV3QhP_2ipBuPyc1H9rNC6pmEbJVjQVGJNFCF7UznmslhDnM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@phyll24","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzHW_1vp5N5esa-_Gt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is there a tool that can detect AI music on YT? People have made some videos about it calling out some channels and pointing out stuff one could look to identify those channels, but it can still be tricky to find out wether the music is AI generated or not, especially with lofi music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC55ZpLBW_DkArYQgA_d5_Xw","author":"@sweetvenomhehehehe","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mitOKXKk-EEp-XCKDnzIJvJVq6BrsZvc5wQDzLI0Zs3Vc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sweetvenomhehehehe","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyWxjwfQC53TcP69Rh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is there a peer to peer style client that allows you to pay artists directly for their music , but isn't insular like patreon?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqzrXwjIlTcYfMXvI82XSWQ","author":"@MushookieMan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l1DnMfzeMY-hrgxq2zQsHpdBkmwXaxssLdM1_WPaU5pdc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MushookieMan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxnn5pUsYnx0Kvd01h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So, you took a PhD proposal and made a 19 minute video 🤯","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtaBatvle__8_36HbElLclQ","author":"@Eleanamaymusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Besg_yw268TOSvfihPnrdg8m6T0mzcK_xCBsPI0m_7Bl6_X_x27dGHM5yd5I9lEUdwOVuezX=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Eleanamaymusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyX9mKr7rgnYzx1lpp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Using AI to fight AI is literally like using fire to fight fire\n\nSure, you'll get rid of all the fuel and oxygen. But you'll also have destroyed the entire building.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClln0aHkRCly-FrdbFGSHew","author":"@SHDW-nf2ki","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cWOOk_xSZRS0Q59KGGRjKhmtjBQ0qawzX-9csvdKZU_FlP6tQHIt1W9268Ijbo9bmjvUf8Scbg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SHDW-nf2ki","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz62pddh_xZAKLsN314AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Tim Macuga has been busy","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCF2ZesDQpt4ieIjyMMewjvg","author":"@mangoeshoe","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mWCQLu4K8MZcTd2gpRDOMHu-DXiqqi2JMttHplomKoZCA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mangoeshoe","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwHhR0UGJSRASLj0PB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How can you pay proper money to musicians if you offer all the music of the world for free or for $10/month? Why isn’t anyone recognizing that most of the problems on the internet come from the fact that pirates made it free in the ’90s and nobody stopped them? Daniel Ek says: \"We can't ask for more than $10/month because you have all the music on YouTube for free,\" and he is right. Google started collecting personal data because nobody wanted to pay for their services, etc. So we should start with the input; otherwise, the output will not change.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBPp1gkiQfOJSKvFS2K_2lw","author":"@EmilBiljarski","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BnZI17tk9JOem7fGy0vlZWIZcr8BDcjKOGkehl9MLULUxhp1Sjw67svlYPdxxX6Xyq9_JpFRkA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EmilBiljarski","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyOFhgl2BDVwQfF7jl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I ended up removing my metal band A World Divided and my solo electronic project Morphine Machine from Spotify because they are promoting AI on their platform. I've been writing and making music since I was a kid in the 90's. Until Spotify stops supporting AI generated music, adding it to playlists, and the likes I ain't putting my music on them. I do have it though available on my bandcamp","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClbys5HkrpNRByBiWJB76CA","author":"@satanicaleve","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/O1X4t0-H8-JrVXqV1YCpvArYLx7brwbSfJoqF0PGo39e5PUGXWoDgUB4x7cctb-kYCjPCnP-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@satanicaleve","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyvUpBlcJfjTgdlzKZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Challenge! Find a way to find out who’s listening to the content, people or AI?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCuEogUuzEsMqm4mkuPHaggQ","author":"@My2Drumsticks","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nzPzWtycTSeqTwE17J3TqbJ29wN87Fz_u84Y-a3KY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@My2Drumsticks","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyte_G9-hvjfXmx3il4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"fun fact, someone was bragging about distributing 150000k songs onto paid platforms in 2024","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNj69AltiOT18TzMFCcvSGw","author":"@SlyProfits","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Kigf4ADZlGKLQTfJWdjQkqIC4FQIzRZqb_cZaRQiGGODhZnVNOUy1kY3A_5oVQu43lVwY5CT=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SlyProfits","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxdPrg--lz6NkDfo-F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hey how about SoundCloud as a plateforme for streaming music ? What’s their compensation ?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrtvAznkA7oMdlrx96gg0rA","author":"@gregoirenedelcovici6194","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nk34hTxcRQW33U__l-UU32Dlk4a6qubLatX204ky7xOO9b=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gregoirenedelcovici6194","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxdPrg--lz6NkDfo-F4AaABAg.AD0K3Pl4jYsAD0K7iix1Hx","parent":"UgxdPrg--lz6NkDfo-F4AaABAg","text":"Thank you for all your work ! It’s priceless ?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrtvAznkA7oMdlrx96gg0rA","author":"@gregoirenedelcovici6194","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nk34hTxcRQW33U__l-UU32Dlk4a6qubLatX204ky7xOO9b=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gregoirenedelcovici6194","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwzI0uSqnL3mYKy2ER4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why are all the numbers you're reading out off by an order of magnitude from what's on screen? Which is correct? 14:21","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsmkIcIEADCB7bs94FQYWNA","author":"@JaapvanderVelde","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3SDlxcMKvK9v_bZo2bFnXB6NBCiGo5TzU8pZB9ChOirE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JaapvanderVelde","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxqXwIwR1rVc-g4Gwh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I never use loops from Splice but I use one shots to make my own drum patterns. Are these at risk for Content ID claims too?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnk_Ijp0-uJfdh_quVqH02g","author":"@TheSeandroid","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kiXC_t8BW2znZ1QIR0LjIW2pr4L75acX5GxsjuRHZwRw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheSeandroid","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxMX8p_A-Otz_988kR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Great video, however: looking at per-stream royalties alone is incredibly misguided - sure, Amazon pays more per stream than Spotify, but they have far less users, ie less streams ie less money overall.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWh0mZeCpu-2_3XJ6V3H-PQ","author":"@DavySolaris","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llYl1GLVGIwqm3QxlIpEoUc0As-D20j89OTgE9ulg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DavySolaris","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0KE5rvGOwA0OCVbF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi so i am an artist and I record my vocals but the instrumentals I get from all over the net. My song Heart Song has a bit of a weird sound in it and I think it was an A.I. generated beat. Is there any way I can find out if it is or was not?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCC5VAClaGvDCPidGOoa4-6g","author":"@Official_Arista","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3tUVvJ-D-ulCAcGPQ3T9MfQ9i4kmIiwaKXAeYxiqKXY0enfAQTCw8CFZDgeri1XmSYRZpXN3aQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Official_Arista","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqHCIA0ayU-P-ftYF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"There are also people that just upload famous songs like JuntunenPhD","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3WXtY0lyR05KgXvzI2TleQ","author":"@A-RonGG","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zhylAqZnj7FR5PRYOlfIEHOggR9cLHlmgGYaDJ8vzVzM-lid8lEksTHJzqZqow7Tdnhvt8p-=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@A-RonGG","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgywlnAvTDsszvdaDyR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"if i only use lets say a stem thats ai generated, does it also detect it?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfR26CBccdLawwHDBayGFOA","author":"@Drunk-on-Bleach","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qATzPIdUrT00R_7o5Cue0hi3yu1XpxKsL_42nw-Id8L4asmOdGyQVBUDRdtMHCtxEWTmdPFq0w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Drunk-on-Bleach","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyX9yeKRvZaIQBFmYp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why is there no soundcloud on the list?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUTtvU3bMlQi0d0G45Ys-hQ","author":"@magnuzzs6186","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mPUJrmzRll5M9GPvaNE9Dnhy8NxdRMBR9WwMvXMiibww=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@magnuzzs6186","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwBIRp1mNEiss1TojF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"PUT A FLASH WARNING BEFORE FLASHING LIGHTS.\n\n\n\nBad negative harmful","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC2IFV-LMYbyp1JLwJlnfd4g","author":"@alexcaffri9091","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mlgNGxGgIOR3OjE_-1CLRqzTNUaCodhNTS4x8fXk6yqq4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@alexcaffri9091","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymAthXwUZm9UkdEFh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Can you tell what percentage of the spurious ContentID claims was for something other than a melody?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4EZvsXHTny0NhjkVlC3bXQ","author":"@ombilicdes","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nQjisncRqf-ZZqgIyUM68L6njSndu9Lbu9DrhJJ8g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ombilicdes","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxU7aQmZU2dqvn-cRF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"really curious how much python was used!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBhQLDyNhUSRacuY1w9LY7w","author":"@ulfgj","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ln2nNxhpb_hTnjD6oZNmrGh2BvUjXKwpclGCYaDDtiMOk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ulfgj","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgysHiAPnz8H8VMnolV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Really need to explain that you are talking about file size / bit rate compression and not actual AUDIO compression.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLpGLQ62e7nHy4jm_2MeU9w","author":"@stevew7214","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/xEw-IpCZICccwdt-KgINrMvXN2sgrtqV8nkg1RCKPo5N4SMa4SW_cMmc3dGzlsXmQD4xynv4tw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stevew7214","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxsIMc-WzCPcYhTKgZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I herad that in some cases if you use Melodyne...you can ende up with the system calling it AI ??? is this true because alot of my stuff gets aligned usiing Melodyne, i don't like using quantization  or Autotune or other pitch shifting programs ..how are they going to decern the difference ???","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT11HzrBx2O_TE6VJS4zaNQ","author":"@TheRichardEmsley","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Jjd5FQfpUgqGN7iLsXMBIbinD046_vcW0cE1c1nXOqFupFqbtYwIiIwd8Jnx75r9Br5TeSJQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheRichardEmsley","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz7TvRpZkWVFxIO2GV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The bottom or the whole thing?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmnacv9doeJaHiy1_r4-1Ow","author":"@Jh_93641","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nUADnmslG6LEnAtTKvFZzPC6_TYxRzpWtK8tYxe6Y=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jh_93641","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy5AZYlErC1BaQy15l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"wait.. where is the title?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXKJ1YAhiLS9r8KyI3pWuLA","author":"@giridharpavan1592","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kBNBhyJp7KM1JQ2zOdc-LkORRSJmMtkpeRxpnYjOM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@giridharpavan1592","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy5xpg2wDBsWklo6hR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:43 maybe YouTube?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3JlL-y4GdMF6oG_E4hZ6Pw","author":"@CrazyCobraCC","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dhIst6wyEPpa4XN0Nc7Yi-hvrSFqb_uRTEzo6SpW4HBsaa4anAbnrZ_ZNeA248znkU9-_6QbVQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CrazyCobraCC","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKsOkNCSULycirrNt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i don’t get paid that much per royalty via amazon prime. what distributor did you use?!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8ifggcC2HJ8r7gXZqcU3PA","author":"@ethopathos","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NCaRovzm9OWMDBvTysTAw-qOnUTsRR22WujCf0NU9gwIJ8VQLiLmiagPKwuibdX8P5woJb6p-w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ethopathos","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzn4XILQ3HbQO6maGx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My guess: Fairmus","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClb686CU5TAL3pnj9CT5ycg","author":"@GetsVR","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kCgNC4dcoUQqM9HydSUHlQLivTaF5PsENDJGv_fyg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GetsVR","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxx7BY_275QqXua0QJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Where can I find the tool for detecting AI generated music?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9yRbTdnRnem_SVbW1JG-wQ","author":"@BorisMiljkovic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n2afUFpT5A9qfazYruL2HCVUJbSibDqrAHSDmGNlpPP0s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BorisMiljkovic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxe_i2oQiCoLD00_3V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The one gripe I have here is the title, using AI to detect AI, even if its technically accurate there have been soo many awful cases of idiots using \"proof of concept\" AI detection tools to badger legitimate creators, be it art, writing, etc as if they are reliable at all. When they can be just as bad about hallucinating false positives as generative AI is about hallucinating extra limbs, or making up \"facts\". This is especially becoming a problem in schools trying to fight the use of AI by students, catching innocent people in the crossfire.\n\nObviously that isn't what you're doing here, you're actually putting in the work to make something functional and trying to do right by real musicians, but just the phrase \"using AI to detect AI\" is such a huge frustration for so many people, honestly it's what made me click before I even realized it was a video of yours. It makes me worry someone could see it as justification to continue using those unreliable tools to determine what is AI and what is not, looking for easy off the shelf solutions that simply do not exist, settling for something that creates more problems than it solves. Good on you for actually trying to make something helpful in this area though.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCTNdb4PTGTdYYsC92P53D-w","author":"@OmegaGrunt","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kzYsOSNCVqVK2CdkscLF7HeNocRhHvQzcsyuDJArFJsQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@OmegaGrunt","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxe_i2oQiCoLD00_3V4AaABAg.AD0mjKom-ieAD2JP67KDEh","parent":"Ugxe_i2oQiCoLD00_3V4AaABAg","text":"👍","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8_ct8SxKFpMC-BY1ReJ5tw","author":"@Ryanez93","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KCyo_b6XvGLbMaA9h-wrCcBUxq2wCUIieBBwVcwPrR4UOBdY9cp4EFUqCF8FGz-jZIURPvT_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ryanez93","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyJGI-ANzOGMFpSPRF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I imagine the eshitification of Amazon music is eminent.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLyUMoI7Uv_EJO5xXYDZC-g","author":"@erikm5753","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3jvqRuvcM2JVJRzROYipLtdz1qGCZM6eXJy3ttU2q4io=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@erikm5753","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw9zscdZQQrYuimX-F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So it's not video that kills the radio star.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNUY8ncyG9zu7-WsmNtPkHA","author":"@georgedomse","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lPaAnBNwmF1dtRhL4B1P44B1fzi2N7RweUrDInXsBmUko=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@georgedomse","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwkWWd-kZg3LbO2oxh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"They can't detect if you redo your song using a Dow.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIuYS5-fdoqXaUkykA38Rsw","author":"@steger13","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BIy5bqymYsRE5lq4XE38DQLXxspW53NkE6yELUAPkAjPRnGOy-9WZeKp8g_Y00SF_KGI7ldehKQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@steger13","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzldEaPLD9Txch6J1N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The thing is spotify is an amazing service for users","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCd02U366c-s-1CoygvIgD8g","author":"@ethnicalbert","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lPzyH5Ac3K00_CevDYSpiQPTi2a4d3ydiRaWRPmdY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ethnicalbert","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwTSvEVzDMtMG9n5Ex4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I just join your mission","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQfL30UWlGlV-oiRKZB8wkg","author":"@Rkcuddles","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kWyBcW-RxGeXSLopC830fkrJUeb0X0A9ZX-uW-13A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Rkcuddles","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzjNhJGVcoiux6xrjV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What does Soundcloud pay? I'm surprised it wasn't in your list","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwBYkMTdq2CgzFLTudvftqg","author":"@MikeAuerNixego","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mYiWROy8_P3-0eu55uGxBJmX47zLFWKLmK2ZF2gZ5y82w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MikeAuerNixego","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrOb7WFOTusSDA8nZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The thing about detecting compression artifacts tonl detect AI: Isn't that the exact thing AI can be used for? Fixing such artifacts? For visual stuff, there is AI denoising, which speeds up render times for CGI. Rendered images start out noisy and the longer you render the less noisy they get. AI denoisers just cut down rendering eariler. Wonder if AI can be trianerd to fix compression artifacts the same way? I seem to vaguely remeber attempts of someone making an audio codec using AI that way. Lossy compression and the AI to fix it during playback.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCydt6q2XzBl9zPQS7iLcaiw","author":"@bloody_albatross","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kOrAaP8pKTD7aNwtvZUzBJa56mtw1Xb7DoTvy9FRP3bA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bloody_albatross","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxmAJtwyOmzLz_lP6h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Photographer here: most if not all of my content (hundreds of thousands of photos) have been used to train AI models off it, didn't get a single penny out of it. Hell even this comment is probably being trained on by some future LLM and youtube will make money out of it I'm sure. \nI could be mad about it and call out the companies and users of said AI, but honestly? I don't care all that much. \nI do use LLMs quite often, from translations to writing letters to the administration to explaining how the freaking tax system works. Yeah it's been trained off copyrighted books and magazines and reddit or whatever, but I'm sure most users of those chat gpt or otherwise don't bat an eye at the right holders not having been compensated for it right? \n\nSame with AI image generators, I do use that myself actually, it's a load of fun and can be pretty useful at times. I do random prompts for some inspiration, block out some ideas etc. \n\nAnd if you ever tried to render some images of yachts or luxurious interiors, chances are, the result comes from training off my photos since there aren't like thousands of us photographers out there doing that job, but honestly, I don't care. Just do it.\n\nI'm confident enough that I don't have to worry about me being replaced by some AI tool as long as I provide value to my customers. And I believe every song artist should feel the same. I don't see an AI taking taylor swift or Lamar's job anytime soon. \nI did try Udio when it came out in beta for free and it was a load of fun. Made some music I wanted to listen to, funny ones for my friends and family, hell I even tried to dabble in song writing (lot harder than I thought tbh). And some results were genuinely good for my taste, I still listen to them on my playlist and I enjoy it, but I'm under no illusion that a real song artist will always do a better job , just like I am with my photos. \n\nThose things are mere tools and I'm sure will be part of creation process in every art style (photo, drawing, songs, writing etc) at some point (photo editing is already full of it with photoshop's AI) and we just haven't adapted to it yet.\nA bit like when auto focus came in, some \"true photographer\" thought it was cheating, that it wasn't right, it wasn't how it was supposed to be.. same when digital editing arrived etc.. I think no one nowadays would call out a photographer for using auto focus or editing their photos with lightroom. \n\nAnd NO ai would ever come close to the level of a Michael Jackson, a Nobuo Uematsu, a Alphonse Mucha or Stephen King. So instead of focusing on fighting off low level ai slop like it's your opponent for last place, we need to focus on being the ones on top that will always be recognized as the bests.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClHbryZPd1vqhFurdRH3ZyQ","author":"@seraphin01","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/c1V-wP-fDwpbFAgYJS--m4xmaP_xtBr86So9YFrEZ7yuazaOIiPf-mF8QW3CT_NviBTr8KVkdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@seraphin01","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwmBWjFvYbZmwvHhg14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A question! What's with music which sounds like it was stitched out of pieces played in reverse? For example, there's one 'Victoria Gabrielle' on Spotify which at some point recently even got affiliated with Audiomachine somehow (which used to produce great epic music), and 'she' is churning out album after album of something that sounds like a cat being minced in an electronic device. It is not pleasant to listen to, yet 'she' amassed 20k+ monthly listeners already and keeps getting recommended by weekly playlists. 'Her' album covers, avatar, etc are clearly AI-generated, and bio only has two words: \"just follow\". \nAnd 'she' is far from the only one. There's regularly at least one or two of reverse-sounding tracks in my weekly playlists, plus they're usually monotone in how they just keep playing the same simple loop over and over again for two minutes straight. But the reverse puzzles me, - does anybody listen to that, and why??","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOS0Y138SzHBw-_EKI1oAHg","author":"@fourleggedlys","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RaWW-VB1S7374I9eq1IY0L3UzVVW1_y6vHq9tEIz7dCDeUv4hFh-FYeXR86ZTsWaFCewODyM7A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@fourleggedlys","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz79AU1BqjIGSVVBNJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If it sounds good does it matter?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCIytAkljoEVYYVDWjgal8Ww","author":"@Byronze","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_krQsbCAmxyMiJ6RSKkxk4vvNv3uI-I2Uj5A42sOxVOew=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Byronze","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy-CNoB6Mwi1lq31OR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"what will you do with the program that identifies AI content? will there be an app for users to identify AI?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzsjgPe0HAY1F8i9IjdDl_w","author":"@sandalero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mKZi1kMsYj_FxectPC2Xy07BNggrGSswnzvVoiSIkM5tP0h-9NJfEmV0QqKdWOX6nSMZl09Ugg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sandalero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzHNdCNLFdTTiwZDgF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you can't tell the difference between lossless and mp3, wait 10 years.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0Qy7zqcye3dPVbh4zhKA3w","author":"@Haddedam","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l0OQXsA_mSHpTLu-FnD0q3xRcBy8Q0dq64pxCsyw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Haddedam","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDkDnrM2xCLeMfXut4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"just wished AI actually made beats based on my humming for a fun hobby. All these 'tools' seem deadset on theift and quick cash.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCIwYy-2bOlYf5_sWgZvp29w","author":"@cetriyasArtnComicsChannel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l9EY-F2KXgh7tjXdiqoMYCJ968yzRNjPFen5fjlij-rw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cetriyasArtnComicsChannel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzL8UuQx-xd392wjv94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hello . Are you aware that you can deconstruct & isolate instruments by extending & trimming generations. How would you detect a songs which have been reconstructed from individual components? \nEG\n\nhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZgT_Dbjkr2c","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCRQYdJJOgKkIqlsbQ_Fp-Cg","author":"@element64","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_msDbJEHylVjzikfQ7LwHpdHTQVxbdtLn-SxP4w3N2Jgg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@element64","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw3pFbfQWvdstUD6-l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Somehow people who monetize Ai generated music like that reminds me of all the cryptobros who buy all graphics cards and cause scarcity, only to barely break even.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0RyhgmvFMU70vpxblV-oXw","author":"@teresashinkansen9402","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nqaHbKiN00COPEPYkMyMj7rcLSILI-sBAixLf_6u0tdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@teresashinkansen9402","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx0RNPjiRmssENe4k54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"10:47 I can't hear you.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfHSx_91CFRIHdqs1Elc14w","author":"@saintenjoyer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/rjGXch5Jt4ukZduN22hCZ0pjBGxW92aJeyRmLYl82IbND75xqu9wzvw_u14upoJFJ8JEdA7c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@saintenjoyer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxAE5Lao2dn-kQDaHJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The problem could be easily solved if Suno and others would be forced into storing each of their AI songs by generating an ID number that is stored.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQ5ruoJCkf6KiYBaA8wQhOA","author":"@jerrymcpommes8473","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mnHqUY0FTKsamoZjH0P9tQoBWlZXzGsND_80ZbUCQumHxnzproI3u1-WllQUnlU-r34g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jerrymcpommes8473","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzUt8IXZj9Hl4Jh0P54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I gotta say where is Soundcloud in this? They tout paying artists fairly as one of their core features, do they just have such a small market share?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQ5wu4rC_X0YPabmcIK5nMg","author":"@sleepless_001","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kI7_4-gKQ20CyD96RW71_1rzuC1Rcit4WL9FgEiQXt_cs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sleepless_001","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyxF3Hmw1Stx4acUth4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Youtube has AI music too....lot of \"cafe\" jazz..( some of the music your playing in the background).. just seems off to me.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCad1cBj-1Sy7acOGVKFphTw","author":"@andgate2000","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nJCnngf7YzH3FeqlRbWRlL4T8Nsjr1_q1KUT15tGM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andgate2000","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwoBiW7SlY8XicgXqV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"@0:36 I hope it's YouTube music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUlNG7MOwvr2-pUJGzpaR2Q","author":"@lifeisgood12341","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l9Q-GoCJuhTsnXAubTkqGweI4tEYDqpPxKXZryPozl6Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lifeisgood12341","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzmxflLxKJBHLSukhh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about bandcamp?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgMzwqU2npQ_sxMcOhJvBMg","author":"@scoresandflames","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XoccH6wESDLwI9N2ck60W5SSmJxb8wWyTCg9eLztGiN4VoPQpkAynJ52Lm7hS0Xlf3raQ5BCKg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@scoresandflames","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwJWKf3ktDChagvTjh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Please help!! How do I get an AI \"musician\" (with bot social media accounts on Ig and FB) who has stolen my artist name taken down from spotify and youtube??? This is so embarrassing, the music and amount of releases and artwork is all obviously AI generated. I applied for trademark registration and am waiting but I should not have to do this to get this fake music taken down and customer service doesn't answer me / is impossible to get ahold of. 😢","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFs5Yxkg9pB_febddfpLyAQ","author":"@LyraMuseOfficial","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NpkWu1jk2unqZkCRD7ffYP4qquMQJ5_0wxiBusV673X-fissqzVzWwPHZVzPLPc_IPzqxsf6oKU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LyraMuseOfficial","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyC4mspvz6WZXyR26Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A sound engineer or good producer should absolutely be able to tell the difference between lossless and compressed .. right? Otherwise why not record in MP3 and skip compression 🤔","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvFrB-LECQlEmYn3k-3evLQ","author":"@kieronsinewave5016","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYb1zaAAssRT-C3hf3s6PT7blPz8t1nGyGaVCJdBNlPA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kieronsinewave5016","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6c-6rCs2nynTArQZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I use YouTube Music only because it’s free/included with YouTube Premium. Question though: is that rate per $ the same if I listen to the song in YT Music vs someone watching a music video (which provides the YT Music song) on YouTube? Example: I find a music video on YouTube. I click like and then go to YT Music and play it in there from my liked playlist. Am I screwing the artist by listening in YT Music vs YouTube? Finally: Epidemic Sound - how much do they pay their artists and how does their music being played on a YT video also give them?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3tqbsd4NMdckRXooVDOppw","author":"@ohheyitskc","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/nzIKETfN7fO-tRDP1m0puXVh6-0VBFFpxyoCV1o0LEp3B0jxEEcHmKxRY6tD0AyD5mFt4s1h=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ohheyitskc","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxiwJWMNiplLGXud_h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Freaking awesome","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQ4vaMIJHE3k_-WaKvnGRRQ","author":"@chadyonfire7878","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lFFguNCW_c5hVbcgBbeZzQys4cHCnJb01AZmTfdcBB_Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chadyonfire7878","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxKn5Y8c2EVtyD6b5N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I hope we're not being detected as AI. We're real artists!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCeTU9fqnDz4qmJoYCaGGXpQ","author":"@donkerbot","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GnykFxmxXMSBkN2S3Y3CKXr-MqCTDryCXR6pJPUhX2WsynoAHmSU_EIbe-WxKdi_3cDOjbD7nHo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@donkerbot","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxTZBg7TYQRlscbo8p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Getting artists actually paid for their work is easier if you just give them money, people aren't buying cd's anymore, they aren't buying an album or discography. In no market, none that we're served with any convenience at least, are there accessible tools to directly support your favorite artists without fifteen middle men getting in the way to charge everyone involved with endless fees","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSRW8QUvqfcJYPjZ7YpNSkQ","author":"@KayLee-lw5iv","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nenw_SlZbHbcLbDPRIhO1oTezW-JEYgkAUU7bh-yg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KayLee-lw5iv","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyZGE3Zw5NoPZ5WoXV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"X-Box my guess at 0:42","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8Uw3wcgTTDE1WUH9ifFmVQ","author":"@NicholasStein","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n6PiqGOaro7CidA11sU3DhT1tFjO9D2k5i5fbGJ4NWjMw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NicholasStein","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQEz1v6kKvn0CU_OR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My main problem is that Spotify just works perfectly for how I listen to music. And I kinda feel bad about it 😔","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrf_rsYt4QAv9rGObIW-2rw","author":"@cg21","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n9VaHEBLeIwAGK0kFu_bhZFqkDhZaKN24kPY1cSV4rbouU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cg21","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQEz1v6kKvn0CU_OR4AaABAg.ACyA0MTGdt2ADOwH0CoDX6","parent":"UgzQEz1v6kKvn0CU_OR4AaABAg","text":"Who cares? In your life the only bank account that matters is yours. Spend your money on the way that benefits you, not some musician you’ll never know, none of them would change their lifestyles just to help you earn more money at your job","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCfW4YeB2qHlUBMor4bpS74Q","author":"@Xathian","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_na7HR3gQ_kcfOf49tNIOsyw-3oeEiLhcFQsEX8KB0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Xathian","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQEz1v6kKvn0CU_OR4AaABAg.ACyA0MTGdt2ACyHlDZHkp4","parent":"UgzQEz1v6kKvn0CU_OR4AaABAg","text":"You shouldn't. Most art and artists are gradually being replaced by on-demand and generative services. Consume what you like on the platforms you like and if you run across an artist or producer you particularly like, buy their albums: AI or not.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdYPqNDbquFY6x9mWbon7ZQ","author":"@rogerlouie1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lQ3rdMcjp87QMvC4GGR9gnVPu2YXz_sZ92GsTNQHAs2Jk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rogerlouie1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzaUAkxr0ZnQ4kItB54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How do I even report fake AI music? There's no option to do it when right-clicking the song OR going to the report page of the artist. One of my favorite metal bands just had their best album removed and their 2 new top songs are 2 absolute dogshit AI songs. WHYYYYYYY, HELLOOOOOOO SPOTIFY YOU ABSOLUTE GARBAGE COMPANY.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCmx3fS01IeJcOC7bYWojVmg","author":"@maddyleaf","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m6BhoOhkKsoz4w964z46-J5e_fHu1Yb2hYrNdW3d1QbSU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maddyleaf","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy1BK1eRIsu1tqIUzF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This video feels like 3 independent videos mashed together. Started nicely and fell off once you got to sample library. What have these 3 parts of the video to do with each other? 🤷","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHkKNz50jozXUa3qU_bCVbg","author":"@gggentii","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nX9vHuw4SIevbJL-q5Og91pKf7X0Get46h3bFsnYyWWboOH1zLoQW4agC9Il65p088aw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@gggentii","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwVIEerjqIx2jge26d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"thankyou for a.i music detector","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCClMxMZllomx-HYMumZ5Now","author":"@Flarejamstudio1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/D8WYkzml-N5WjH-0wLwIk7wJ4MYBnvbj-3IHNHEfgSXJBVVwO65fQgPiOrfuki21UCykr3lN7g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Flarejamstudio1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxB4Zx-cNvHuKrK_p14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Does YouTube Music pay more royalties or is it the same as YouTube?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtZ6fron_MGqqMmezbdK_YA","author":"@Ueberkombo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTq7cHqF0oFeybdko9VCjEDJe8o5vrBc2I2XwXNswiMQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ueberkombo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy_zU9ymom1KnID-zZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i believe in you.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxfxuJzFCuKBMjK_LKCljsQ","author":"@MarigoldSonata","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TXk2T7PZgScLCd-_0gzQhTzpMUo1yLmKpORGZyJrkiUs5PmFoiTHqi1_xAVVZpfFQbI7ygJxPA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MarigoldSonata","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwxX4d14ShTjOkq34Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"bandcamp?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0LkYqYULOJ_KjWpqfgnsRA","author":"@TomAtkinson","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/B2ZTJGDG0FWK62OrQ2lHsCeVl_vZcjm-NBwEU8RCMjTld22yjDLRaNgPB0HDdmu9ixtfPx1g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TomAtkinson","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqlgrbQP1-E18j00d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you own 100% of your own music, then how come your older albums (pre-Red Extensions) not on Spotify?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCC7yZc6BVgwGUNVFWuHLIjg","author":"@bornon18","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nUZADwBJX34td3cNist4ghQQ3y9ugQ4Tw_G-kCWH42TI8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bornon18","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzpFluUoKB2CD-UjLF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"4:01 The song with 600k streams is not AI generated. It is stolen from Ritandi Kusuma ☺️\nPlease like so he can see this","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAcsFZEmBCxDJF9N7gh2fAg","author":"@TypicalURL","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_8ifZoZ0cUkjX-V_umDVeZ3oJHcyJxKwm9zhqchyUE6oOpkCjvP_b9ste2Pkep4XT6M8tIZIEA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TypicalURL","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwB-YDSCUczqUOUWQ14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've only seen people with grey hairs complaining","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNbmbcnNUT8BJM1PvhgVwIQ","author":"@OfficialMattLuther","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LanUX87_EP-i1g_n_DifmXwOd2QVD59VA763iidoDLbVr0AANuVFBMtEqzI4rHWIo6Krc2xUWg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@OfficialMattLuther","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2xtc89kZsvAvLcL14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Anyone can get verified on Spotify if you have 10$ to upload music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC364rs1RDRzLkVti6rt08Jw","author":"@Saymaven","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Wgo5EbqNMcUjOuKUOo7v8FT_p9f919UiMypiSSP7EGp7n8uxO94kC3pu4q8xCB-OZJHb3VG_KQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Saymaven","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrAn1FSIPISHTcAtZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i noticed the blackpoint is very high in these videos with very low picture contrast. its en vogue, i know. is this to counter the high contrast phone displays or has this other reasons?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzsjgPe0HAY1F8i9IjdDl_w","author":"@sandalero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mKZi1kMsYj_FxectPC2Xy07BNggrGSswnzvVoiSIkM5tP0h-9NJfEmV0QqKdWOX6nSMZl09Ugg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sandalero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhL9LuLeaEd9KrOsx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"We are cooked, that's all! The more bots take over the more fake things gonna grow. I can work up to make music for the next 15 years and get better, then an bot can release 1500 music per day gets more views and money than me... -lenisbeats","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCsV0lf3nDrjqhJll1KIP8JQ","author":"@serdarmarkar7962","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lvO71o3ezoGSoL0mLUEbcVelU_eCe8Q8klaKsRmmsgpl_6=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@serdarmarkar7962","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwI8nTnE0c6sajQvfd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You want to thank people from the bottom of your heart and your whaaaat???","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpXTNpGudBHazAq3iGKKq4Q","author":"@NinoWhite707","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YEz6hLkZHdb5Z1YmkcPcjdYSamflGop-r6xcKeWC_UD5Py6MyH4j5yCewIoCGlMat9C_O4XSgg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NinoWhite707","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz6XkHFVoCag30VoGN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't care about the artist. I'm using the cheapest option, which is spotify student discount","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVoeqVFiXjEO8jvddE9NlGg","author":"@ksneidndkdoknnw","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Jig6g-GoCPonNYst0xqIKRqdEsWfg82hw1FtnhlsuU4qimAAG9pwYFP_AbopTVgfxO6d_6t0fw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ksneidndkdoknnw","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-kdlnbGDQXf80N1N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Song at 10:40 ?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCA0buLnLJ4FewhWz2wx-xew","author":"@Ark_bleu","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k8_An0AuyRRVoOqPq93xfCHcj4shwSRCvlY20kv7M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ark_bleu","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy4DBO1sTHyHMIJ2td4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Best paying streaming service guess: napster","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaNuAH_fHpcnBB-ymSWMiUw","author":"@doomscroller1722","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/tMR2RNOy8WWST8ch1H-xCVT0idqT1_S9UXVloMD0DR6svoua-yXc7cXhYO6Kn3CPWgp-aGio=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@doomscroller1722","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxnvqSB0uQkO-FhlCF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think we are closer to getting into a trend of wanting to pay or own human-made content (like a vinyl rebirth trend) than wishing music distribution platforms or record labels will ever protect real artists. If I would think like a record label and would have to choose between an artist that generates 1 album per month versus an AI music farm that can generate and upload 100+ in the same time, the math would be easy. Streaming platforms and labels are already trying to force artists to pay for their own promotion.  There is also a question of why you're doing AI-generated content (music or whatnot). I am doing it for the sake of generating good music and having me or other people listen to it and just enjoy it, rather than making money on it. If that is your main source of income this is becoming problematic. Starting with sample farms that create AI-generated sounds in an automated process via API and webhooks, posting it for free use, then claiming them after some time, people that feed AI with specific real artist content and many more. \n\nEverything can be a tool if used wisely, but there will always be people who will just exploit it for their own benefit.  I can use ACE Studio and generate my own vocals while spending time to set them manually, set key, edit vibratos like working with a sample in a DAW. In the same time there will be a Chinese farm using 1000 online servers doing the short way via API and generating millions. AI music models will feed on real artist content, then someone will generate a song with your voice, copywriter it and you will spend years or months fighting for your rights. Use a stem from Udio, redo it in a DAW, probably untraceable. Then someone will automate this or even make a SaaS to make money on it. You can make a verification solution, they will work on hiding themselves by doing the same and the whole industry will take their side.\n\nThe best option, as you said, is to cherish your artists, pay them directly, and just enjoy their music. If you like AI music, create it and listen to it, but don't exploit it. Easier said than done.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChityN6KO2jlC2O0ArRmazw","author":"@SoulfulBalladChronicle","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/c2pr1N_bOWiVPWvOUHRQFbmNLRxORemyCTJqJcWYlDI3OnFENUNbgPrt1UH3Q5K2E1lhPjknFAI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SoulfulBalladChronicle","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwHkZkv8Jbm_2NugXF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wow, Benn. Thanks depressing the shit out of every legit composer and musician. 😢","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYpNX7OiJx4U52OUvBaM2SQ","author":"@zwdband","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JBvSPweX8AuIR_orJSubWHq3zejtMNy3IUcJFjYXRvohf-Ec7-ozQa2shAL7-tkNnX8vW18Syg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zwdband","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbRFumrnA0hSDzSxx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What if AI generates it BUT they still PLAY it? Would the detector still be able to detect it? “Made” is a very loaded term in all this. What if I just use it basically as a drummer because those are endangered?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-ruoFZHCEA0mO-E5xRNFsA","author":"@shainemaine1268","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mzbQXVsDwQccDUUbsv6tXGHI3C4c3UEszKqB4ppPU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shainemaine1268","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxX7dK6uay3C38Oi0V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You mention getting $.0021 per stream from TikTok, did you mean per creation? I thought TikTok pays per creation and not per stream?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_XotL7tSu0hcGm7VKVP1Hw","author":"@GG-sb5in","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ntClCb4da-RU5R8zr3fA9pirxFr4tvmMslugf_Incn0nA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GG-sb5in","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz9K8uPeKVKDBGoh7V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:30 Napster","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCApM0sE_7b1cdD_3SgJzC9w","author":"@HeyYoItsPhil","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kj7uIbs92p2KD9VwMJmlwIfDEVAr2yoErKZR3FLqWS_dA6TxW2omBsnezRNjoybUp1PAGcI0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HeyYoItsPhil","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwB57bS3A6pTLFokIJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I find it hilarious the only people defending AI are those who completely lack creative liberties","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC87ULMIJUblLdY8f47aF-6w","author":"@Ardeact","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2nCqswpZ5b7-MOYKsGCJd7hiUwUEu4OjamMMasVsb4QCSrxGgFqCi4Ekkl0efkQ8bwIUnfhQBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ardeact","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwZM2An0uxw0f3MebZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What artists? There's no artistry anymore, just sound producers.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGScRE8gw_eqLFfnQ-eeocw","author":"@nigelwitgunn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cHFvcivvOiVXXzfpRSWFp5j2zmr-WbIdY4mp1OxrLsZQ0q1RjgpEVQoIAyjTgci_JgjPwJ68uNg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nigelwitgunn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzxDimJIwI_J9oq0R14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't even know what to think about some of these comments... Even just a comment describing spending the time to learn an instrument as a \"waste\" because AI makes it possible to generate songs without learning a single instrument is so disheartening. Maybe it's just my perspective, that learning an instrument is about so much more than being able to churn out recorded music for streaming platforms. There is simply joy in actually playing music. I'm sure plenty of people enjoy crafting prompts for AI generation, but it (to me) is a completely different endeavor. They are absolutely not substitutes. (I know the video was about recorded music rather than performing via instruments or singing, but the fact that someone would take this idea so far as to believe that it makes real musical performance obsolete is astounding to me.)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjYjXlflLGwadYwp8WGpPRg","author":"@crw02","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_ITByO8V0U13uspgd5fTlsHEDDE1ghdGWQa7y91tOJXm6g2hLwsNbjwuPB9C28sKgoZPVWotdg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@crw02","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQd6VvFMenwPPsrit4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well... since \"good sounding\" music is actually a golden ratio of notes and tempos and etc. -- and I say golden ratio loosely without knowing if the golden ratio actually plays a role in the mathematics of pleasant-to-listen-to music, although I would venture to say,  it likely does. I digress... -- produced by using a mathematical formula which produces sound that our ears like to hear, would it be reasonable to say that there is only a limited, mathematically discoverable, number of beats that can be made? can you patent things which are diacoverable to all, like the math of building a structure? A good construction method is just good science, there isn't much creativity involved. A triangle is more structurally sound than a square.\nI know almost nothing at all about music. I merely know what my imagination indicates relates. With only so many combinations of notes that sound good, isn't everything made today just a melding pot of other peoples works? Can there even be originality? Music is like chemistry, there are only so many ways to put the pieces together... i guess","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCTkjnFr4vWhT0fY7oD5guKA","author":"@dennismcclelland8196","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mi5FKJWLRsaa1TvNJGL55_Al2735BboabzgAgYVjQ8emFj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dennismcclelland8196","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQd6VvFMenwPPsrit4AaABAg.AFjAUd07MtRAFnKP_M1nza","parent":"UgxQd6VvFMenwPPsrit4AaABAg","text":"As a generative musician who was once acclaimed by the likes of Arthur C.Clarke for making music from mathematics I'd say you are absolutely right. And I'd recommend you unsubscribing from this channel because a huge, polite and detailed comment I left disagreeing with the host was deleted because his ego is clearly too fragile to cope with an opposing opinion.\n\n(And I'm guessing he'll delete this too...)","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwpkeY4tAgBumIHZB1Pu1XQ","author":"@filtomsun","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TJzYIepQ8aoOMxw7nGIt9DIa3_uk1u1OfEvqKANZqjG9QaZ0_EVv5ODas_zjgnnpstnyYTqiYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@filtomsun","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzzj1xvoSLx-xZQw8p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If a majority of people selects .mp3 as the one they think is higher quality, it means they CAN tell the difference, right?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKqt02FEebck-wfNhYRP6iw","author":"@XscrewdriverX","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lgsXYKfesE6d-TCvOK7jB_VxsLQgdq0Vt8C8C3kv0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@XscrewdriverX","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzRYHlen507fbhyrH14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I am an extremely rare exception","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGJsORsQuKBaIC54P4qd9OA","author":"@SearchingForPlayers","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VITSAdo-2tXo0dBjvOiUjBar9ZUrHmr7ZvfDwquzx7eSUn6n7N_MYaBtBiY1VtMXVtHhhYCn=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SearchingForPlayers","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyBCs12ClfL3VfxIEN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A.i is also a simple way to get simple and fast work done, people who are not familiar with it will feel like they are being cheated. After a while they will master it and praise it. Do you swear you will not use it in the future?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7slS36XakLmX15Ks_XEj-g","author":"@zaxtlee2929","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/AHqwaImEclC_YAzv-7-ZxPtNusZ274mGKuC5cVVs3fT5NO8oIZtfmGEZ7GA2ynNir8rIW7nx=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zaxtlee2929","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_-21OaL1EQIP7f4Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"eCO should copyright Ai music when there are human-created elements in the song like your own lyrics. So what if there is an Ai notice attached to each of those songs? Just let them compete head-to-head with all other created music- human or partially Ai, and let people decide which songs they prefer. There is a market for them. Most people want good music no matter how it was created. Now, if it was 100% AI-generated, then I'd understand about them not qualifying for eCO copyright.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPba5HDm6oGZxK5Qw3uRrmg","author":"@SUNOSTRATEGIES","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QzfXs524mqZNDbsZ3MMyHkp9s8XccvWQ-kt_7F9VQ1-YpraBNKMkc0akxvzwXurVdjqyqCMv=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SUNOSTRATEGIES","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw4HVbqDUZyIfir_854AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"apple music?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLYPjp-fkksyGLsUn_69AHA","author":"@kurtrunte","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n7T2HLU7JQUvDRxPv3L4O8Bt6iJvjdFI3DbJCb2haaET6FyolDnJdpfFCiEZLMcXsZpw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kurtrunte","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxqe7Png6WljHWmv_x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I work with AI tools to create music using my own cloned voice, music samples from my recordings I did 30 to 40 years ago, my own lyrics, and my melodies and chord progressions. Why should I not get paid because the AI output the finalized version of the songs? I have the entire chain from the original recordings decades ago, the iterations and modifications of lyrics and genre descriptions. I can connect the dots.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa6Sl_KkBRNyN1tCJqqkLsQ","author":"@JonJubal","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mDLB06P3G5bqnI5WdnLRQ2u5TgTMYHKen495U7N5_rq8o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JonJubal","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPkSb2qqwEjnCuumN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"soundcloud...maybe pandora?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAxC5lpJ2cz2qcsWC_Pa2_g","author":"@taboo8614","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/hRwEoFz1D00ciWrY-rraTaZz6hVoBCjCvXWmF3CvjYCdPezVQf0xtaWeSipa4MmKNI755v5P=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@taboo8614","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYGh_DbCq8o2a6qn94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"problem for the consumer is the simple fact that not all stream platforms have the music the consumer wants to hear and oftentimes it ends up being spotify that has the most, i think that says more about how terrible the (language) support is from the other platforms even if they pay the artist better. just like the artist/creator themselves, everybody is self-centred on their own priorities, and the creator getting Fairly paid or finding that balance between being discoverable and getting a Fair pay is really gonna be put into their shoes rather than the listener's, their problem is simply wanting to listen to music at any time, preferably legally, on platforms that supports whatever they are using: think for example sonos devices needing basically support from both ends. i think this video is reaching the wrong audience, as i imagine most viewers fall under the listeners category and not people creating music that want their music out in the world and get fairly paid...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_lxUFzslXCAW90uJeCni8g","author":"@jeannetitor","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/J-rpJ6PTnOr4vft7vRyqWcp3iAcIGUYYJDyv-lNhPiy7YiZJvHsJNwG2d6k8XexR9872UaAwsQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeannetitor","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzRPMKm17g6FvXFD4R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about bandcamp? No? ok...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0-PtmS9OzdDNLsfUZuplYw","author":"@Rintastic247","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GY-s3rja1Ck4spUv1KkX7E-74FA3sAUwk-qqvR9S6J8SxE_e9xGAbk8nNRKm_dfcHL32cn_YSg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Rintastic247","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwwKy0NBq4VArseHdh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why didn’t you count Bandcamp?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-cOMaQY8bzPDEJVdXdhq_A","author":"@CraigAdams-s9i","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_njv5bj96nXZPdVSGWFsAya7ecRhM4u_78FX5cOyq1Aefxs0LYhy-CVDYRCpSNnYeaQwA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CraigAdams-s9i","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz21fdiZL1B_Pj8agl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm unsure if I missed that part of the video, but which platform is the best if you don't want to listen to AI music? Spotify slowly gets more and more unusable. I already stopped listening to neo classical playlists, because there is way too much AI trash in. And the cinematic/epic genre is also getting worse.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0yF6L1eacKXOsHG4u5VEGg","author":"@belinda9642","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l5ZIbBEgwtZgFkpa5rNV02u-8Vx6YggfmL2j0PeAXobTQsCm2wmmfwdUlmilBjHqr4mA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@belinda9642","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzBGi0_F1ZmFzrFtF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI content sbould have a different page from non ai content.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC3oxU3NQYfiayDdpfbDGMWQ","author":"@jasonbrody1619","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mYwiVVnF6_gX766adtEll8WVXVZpUUxgwKwrrP3biMW50=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jasonbrody1619","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwbbj5D4mo0UCxVTkp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Instead of wasting energy being just another anti-AI bro...  I just adopted the AI amd  use all the anti-AI comment farming as fuel for post-ironic anti-AI folk song series❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYahrMA1quKD6rOe2fomCzA","author":"@Heartstring_Virtuoso","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5dizdZeWnGAG6ysobB0iuv5uNysT9HQXDq0H-BdoLpnX7bkq24rGc5bh3RI_F3gDoO97jCBP1w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Heartstring_Virtuoso","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzH-hBIEBxDaITjaW54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Do this detect A.I music accurately? if someone using suno/udio is real musician and modified the composition in the daw itself and recording it, Can it detect as \"A.I\" or it still call \"human\"?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCT16zKqXy3GOFpIx_RXh-fA","author":"@clothes4060","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lV4EVUJjfyrZWZf9qP2fnsXTX5JUyIuNCycSmrXqUqFXmW0KkXlpkTMqJcmNtqagOLEw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@clothes4060","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy_Yv-dvH90K6P7-x94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You need to neutralize the data by using uploads in years before to calculate how much is from it already rising each year and how much from extra increase","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJqb2F7dUfcng3eqWKB89UQ","author":"@vincevangoat1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/25QeTx40fBeBac_0WW5OqNtQnvhN8USVfZ3t4x7__06m4FyAEzWGECXbmB4spC461ACaZdyt=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vincevangoat1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx4HZzMS0FkgxTPuHx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"soundcloud? 0:40","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaTY0eWtvMaGRVbhQLj312A","author":"@dylancleverdon486","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kaDGTpiV6xtvJ4wXuWskmzW_4gSv-91jKbaUJXo_zias0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dylancleverdon486","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbVejFB0AkYQNzPCJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Phew, good thing we don't enjoy using loops and stubbornly insist on doing everything completely ourselves. :p\n\nAlso, hmm. Come to think of it, one wonders how many of those commerical loop libraries use AI to generate their loops. 🤔","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCV_P1dU_bvfPYoE5b7vnLmA","author":"@CaptainCasualMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cGZQwq5NQKNEMeuUtwasCdG3sFj1amBi2jCvSgxGnNu0A5MSoUnSpWBrBbpxy7XazEkFrBCCFw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@CaptainCasualMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbVejFB0AkYQNzPCJ4AaABAg.ADB2PEWaZF-ADD1XQs7GPw","parent":"UgxbVejFB0AkYQNzPCJ4AaABAg","text":"Your music sounds like AI to me","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiMbNHrSnd-qlUmE3QWE_VQ","author":"@PRLCKLY","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vMGtRhncG5xM3n6RHkhnnT0mtqjiENGPj_2MZhmhEs70DtkfTHsYK89G-qgZ5mFE2xSwZWRL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PRLCKLY","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxR9a6WQsSLN8t0bnB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Getting verified on Spotify is ridiculously easy","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCA1Q7y-zoewnMUneiJfCVaA","author":"@Alphabeter","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/X2Dq-HYgnZKYRg5p5GSzzjXpSDcfsnpkrJKGsIMs9wQmKWyXzb4RaGx_GQiCOsGsoOVUMS2TI-0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Alphabeter","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzlHWzccqcwin85jrZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You're so cool","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5zmVONWLLean_MM945DYcw","author":"@cole_smith50","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DJrfKhm9qLCMLXKQL8YpvQTfSx5Rgol8USD6aKxWlf1nxMtaBSAFEjVpqm00CflOjnUHma0Iow=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@cole_smith50","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwS4NYXbAfKQQQRqzN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Tidal for sure. If not YouTube is the one. I doubt Apple Music would give more but would be ever suprised if they did . Suprised like you said I would be. Sus? I think not","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqqWHzx66BPdT2rYMVs0k4Q","author":"@Mrskyrimtroll","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNZtDRN-ZdYsI3yJHxXCutfQU-24R0-ucFEwh35G-Iv_E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mrskyrimtroll","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxi92YFp0Nbyo9Q8M14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI is genuinely ruining my online experience. I'm trying to enjoy youtube shorts and I get these injections of unwanted generated videos full of AI slop visuals with AI slop voices reading off copy-paste baseline factoids about topics with misinformation casually sprinkled in. I don't downvote, I specifically report the video as irrelevant, boring, misinformation and yet? They still find their way into my feed. I like ambient soft music for background noise, and more and more accounts are popping up with repetitive AI music that has no sense of flow and spontaneity. Commercial AI is created with the intent to deceive, that is its entire ethos. \"Trick people into thinking it was made by a person and make them pay in money and attention for something nobody cared to actually make.\" Thoroughly, truly rotted. The Liars Tool.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCa6iliFpWAfElmrFQUqgbIQ","author":"@kenbasil1996","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bFG6ifsGTMfHD0or00kcRq11HB_2CwVnsWr3oAfaNQlfqlaD5p9QK70__bOU8M2EbrCsarHrAB4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kenbasil1996","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7uJzgXfRwgDIBdu14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As an actual musician who uploads real guitar and vocal tracks, All of this is very disturbing. Spotify has always been a double edge sword. Its amazing to tell someone \"hey just Look-up Harrison Monroe on Spotify or Apple music\" but sadly at this point, actually being paid enough for living just from my music is all but impossible.  It wont stop me from making authentic music that I like I will also keep getting better at recording, mixing, and audio engineering.  But is any of this effort even Necessary? Are most people really okay with just not listening to real humans anymore? Or are they being tricked?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6HScL-A1PPB_r-mhO0LoIw","author":"@HAMOCONN","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/eka7AnvvpFZAzIMugLJqinn3xQTh7gaWejp7pr_C6fF09Co-UvNx_u3S3n7jMGJ35exVmGLaIg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HAMOCONN","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGjgTeXYvLi4xsqch4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i support the awareness brought by this issue, but why would you not only give them attention by name, but also make a playlist that makes it even more accessible for people to listen to?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqyMz5fPHfkz6qFN3bHU7PA","author":"@sully1721","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Yussr1RYJOGytvEwTNpj87p2FDy7TvP9Z1bsz-W0OjFlS_Vk_nNWS8OBM4smC-Trt_Tu07Sl=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sully1721","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugza-vV4EnZczpDjRbx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Cancelled Spotify last year!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFQ6MI_DoKlPYq1ORPo5BPw","author":"@jstuffco","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_niUe4PYmDXysHryyFaefbJ0Y-2qY5a6QkosIQFj4b1LnE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jstuffco","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxaavo9ghJi4TvdDiJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What about Bandcamp?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGG5doK5TV5fzM7Nc804zsQ","author":"@adhdasdfroflxd123","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/lMCppa_-IEvPXkaI5980ob3cm1fYQ9GfFybFToH7QOBRwiP5rqEf20hDP6FWobk-NxTXhUNhXQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@adhdasdfroflxd123","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyng9-H10fzx2JiEth4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Drew gooden predicted this","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3cTP5Rfc8J4ZdiZk1u-eiQ","author":"@BoredVHSlover","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JhCX3VsvwvYIvvAXu-L9PkJgpB4rd5ikEXCsTGUFnzk8yszBbTxHMZNFOKEm2IUEHppYs-jsQg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BoredVHSlover","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxTeXygld1jLcdwYLd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The color grading on this video is wrong.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTEgd2_eD0VKqdcg46wkGSg","author":"@foto21","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mE9QmvvrKQUAu_MLyS1ZDbKyu9pe-JpNqQ7s8k9nZ9fp4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@foto21","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxJUDVfTNfELZiNaYR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"NONE","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcxNj0is0sZ2feCC3mX_ljA","author":"@Ready_Fire_Aim","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LwVuuofJJ3WPDrHmXfQf9TObjMZ3rJA_aW2wtwB14Wa-MDzy6iacJDQ29UqvWLowNRGuvtSr7Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ready_Fire_Aim","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPFV8mJwnr8JFP1bN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"7:51 It's machine code.\n\n\n\nOk, I know it isn't, it's an output of a python script, but I couldn't help but make this joke.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfEsXGaYN81_y2B0ra9uYXA","author":"@trainee5471","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n9F4u3Uq6Sl4MbXyqIaHaJY9VJFH89ap1kEjlyOOvPFrLmoFZWAx0VGba-Wg77ki5gDQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@trainee5471","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxdt3aGSRVqbPsVsFN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"mm... i have a big problem with my music distribute because their ai are saying that my music is made by AI  they dont let me upload more music... BUT my music is totally original... :/","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCB8JlDVOm2hUoCFoQcnrS3A","author":"@David06-F","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/aLqe-AGDmjcXGwEaTHuwLJ5-8k5z3tRlJ0HGbbqnZv3ccXJ6cvoVLP7jeGtwaMqOkZ-jRZM962c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@David06-F","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6auOpZ2opdVYM9Wx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yo if anyone sees an AI song on streaming that isn't labeled AI (with a high number of streams), reply to this comment with the artist/title. Ive found a reliable method of getting the songs taken down WITHOUT being the copyright holder of the plagiarized work. Ive shared it with a few musicians irl and they're having succes with the method too. But I'm not gonna comment it because AI music people would pay good money to figure out what we're doing. If they knew exactly what was happening, they could easily work around it. You could potentially figure out if you are familiar with the workflow that most AI artists use to get a song on streaming and copyright law.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCf8ykEOkBv-KWpReRAVrXfw","author":"@middaymeds","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2tAp6fmwAiFRtNl29K9x-XtRgRZ1zjoWpMDbAmc2xwYSiEfx9t_DN7oTgo5aRwRoV4EQZkevlw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@middaymeds","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzhIzmUpukTi5x3eWB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"wow wow my amazing AI music here on YT wowowowowowwow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCFW3-KfbTBwKKQLr51qLoEg","author":"@AEyes-complexAIsongs","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k489dbUjVHiavMXCVBLGMHjuZ1MbGhFgMATRJyE25ZAk1KhQl3s6Hf7REnBDXFhbKjBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AEyes-complexAIsongs","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2nZ5pDruCrY1tg1F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Reject streaming and return to buying CDs and albums","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCyIdv15dlQtpWMxT9-llcg","author":"@StarScream_47","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Yk1MR-7yh4yGyoPETsN9UOSiDikLUndqixqDwZV3r2nUhpjYIw-BcTjKGHyahJQo2EZjvBLCzw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@StarScream_47","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxg4BAC9R12Za8qZ0d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Plenty of people bent out of shape about AI, embrace it , it's your future UBI is also your future , let the robots do the heavy lifting","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRdAlJoTT1KXU75mZ4DYFWg","author":"@SteveJones-gz4vd","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mhpdt52gf-ewuMICMSpf58jqqKXetktX-rAgmJkXZktJrVu4vDkBYngfAtIfmb6uJy3w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SteveJones-gz4vd","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgygLP10nJ7_azpxMH94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A better system would be for streams to be limited to 30s and people would actually have to BUY the music they consume. I'd they buy it through Spotify them Spotify can get a VERY small cut. Otherwise streaming is just death.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbXZPkIWckPtR5Mk0P0Cmrg","author":"@keithdunwoody1302","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Gl4Hekb2OJjtNXEr4J1TCbbDtKZU86TeG_tDC0hZBQXDDRAy4CrkjutAK1UbZGfNnmFdp2gjmA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@keithdunwoody1302","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz25HLYGGz9y_6LsQJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"45 seconds in and my guess for most paying streaming service is Youtube. edit: not even close lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPI-1JyKV234xafo2Yj5c5g","author":"@controlvolume","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kkIla__A6RJY_SdkKTNpDrSQJacqiHs_6EhnJT89NePn8xrNpqfmEtM-Lh84LKlbdEbnY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@controlvolume","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgylLjmlP9-cnRjf4Vx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You don’t want to be able to tell the difference between compressed and lossless trust me it is nothing but frustration","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbAzxyZTCVB4zk6IVQg_BrQ","author":"@kopeschka6748","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m_Rngj8xOtXk9PGhbPyvnTUouti1JelggOF5WVhNY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@kopeschka6748","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgySFMCHwBTGI5rb5w54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I've never used Spotify because it always seemed too good to be true... Or rather, too convenient.\n\nAnd that convenience would come at a cost eventually. \n\nTurns out, I was right.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoU1qZrnsTjr6YcdoYnM4XA","author":"@MartinB_Art_Design","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/6avKXniqVurcCVz5CFSC3nBZKiJi-OxKwkLCjbeECWyFEa3ITyhkve88GhS4ZrKlESoo3rpmdHI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MartinB_Art_Design","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx2Kucn-TvQ60unt2d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is it Tidal?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvTb1x0jABgwmA3j4Qu3D5A","author":"@pumpkin_prescott2835","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nuDvFV-R_Vpw7K_3JZq6dGS4yF3lqTwecSOVopL9o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pumpkin_prescott2835","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrKAJ2ZwCz9ca8SK94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Any take on deezer apparent goal to demonetize AImusic from their platform?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClWjs-nMvYJfQh-JPpA30iw","author":"@florianabry9932","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ncN5ZRyqmgBIdKcsKbvQQsXYBQ3TpuhhTpLrQclcSH_y1g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@florianabry9932","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrKAJ2ZwCz9ca8SK94AaABAg.AE7FiJcrezuAFTyy2Daw3L","parent":"UgyrKAJ2ZwCz9ca8SK94AaABAg","text":"Awesome","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxUS2bQCSCsiC2HlpUeF_pA","author":"@GrrFromGrrland","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SN1maTtSLCd2ejccaMNHLZDjwm1M-WAxqc1fs1nnpslYGJQAhS-KD13d8SjML95Estve2SylKA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GrrFromGrrland","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyXf1Fnm_5GLp-S4AR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"After the “free” trial AI cost more to run than social platforms \nRemember AI is not free","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvL7fUEaVVZPF7fq5WoJr7Q","author":"@robertlee6338","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lY59QUV4VKramTLK16GmrdxcGfIjxWR8UB0e9Rmjk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robertlee6338","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwolFYJiEZBXG9G8nl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But surely this way of finding AI music or art, is only valid for the time being? I mean, if your algorithm knows what to look for, someone can make one that knows what to remove or hide?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfpllV42-2EhB7KJSaBCx3A","author":"@eivindlunde7772","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mDUEwt7LXJtU55EQx-4yXmaQP9DptgHm0nEmV5AEY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@eivindlunde7772","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyYz3-5aVXnb-84Oz54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"aye at least nobody is going to diddy party word up....","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCiQow3v1401bKT1f7oRjrfQ","author":"@stay.in.school.","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h-whJkoSF-qQXEuhoH9gB8AH-ZgS3okg1u7ey7nTivqtPRZiw0NXSY4h9fBuz9zeiIP2zdzd1Bc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stay.in.school.","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwgH-auxG0BebHgVrF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"688k Spotify streams is def not 2k$","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgb0PunNAHYTRvvrsn2CWyg","author":"@simpsonsmafia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MqsmzbeLB4uRy3nFqJ3Qnpm8YA5-B3tU8oQTxzZ8sSSDmIESL2CjJy5mOMLG612z8iSXnOGEAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@simpsonsmafia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzKW97YkbhsyKtzw_p4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I have a question.\n\nWhat if I generate AI music and I only take small part of it, for example, the opening guitar melody because it's good and the rest are trash. And then I use it for spicing up original music? Or maybe use that only good part to build a whole new song on my own based on that good part. Is this will count or will be detected as AI generated music since I record every instrument and sing on my own?\n\nTL:DR, I stole AI idea to make my own music.\n\nSometimes when I'm stuck, I'm experimenting with AI to get inspiration and trigger new ideas.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCeN36hRtryYJjhgbiAoWfiQ","author":"@biajuuu","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/aUocz5icYu1RyrgJW-yohf2DkqVIeWZKfzaAa46US1LIrxk0d8HupgnwI2_2IfvvcQ3Zv1Hkvw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@biajuuu","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzKW97YkbhsyKtzw_p4AaABAg.AD4-aYyZ3wQADARlJ7tcRO","parent":"UgzKW97YkbhsyKtzw_p4AaABAg","text":"Don't use Ai, go to a free sample website that has \"guitar melodies\" on the go. Also, listen to your artist or at least know a genre and listen to that. But music theory is the best, to not get detected for ai, if you just leave the part in without changing it, they can still see it","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCSBtQno8-aP5crBw4Kgp4-g","author":"@D3sidero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VUPWwOFUTDBw1bnmApsfw0Ofha2GGAFTu_ouQDFd6rOfJFh_b2DKcnnFbKbLOFxTSc-VyYqL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@D3sidero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymNeoRY_DDr6L5KiF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Are you worried youtube will pull the rug out from under creators?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCQXp8Vq_55vSJh3Le5RZqug","author":"@bats2396","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k6E7UTsF655DeERRis1BYvl8uSsF973x_Fdovm3dYObcg6BnyGOi5TiYl_QS1VWQCHTQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bats2396","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyu_uG2J6LiEWK8zs94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"0:30 Watch it be Spotify 😂 or maybe even YouTube 👀👀","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvi3kbrW1VQ26ZsWTrPZm5g","author":"@ANaiyaZhane","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ONLtOJR3LckQ4aKp-o4K2LMK8eeN9qN533ftjEUgqL4QisL6jyyAe369-mZb6i0jkvqWQTSVdks=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ANaiyaZhane","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyWBoue6Um3s6g4OKd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wow AI done took over music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCu3G_3Ke0BT25QyUoHbKg8A","author":"@angellovesjazz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nmUgelu4S6TbvxQyxZZpZycI0ADnQMnQjZ1pwV7bswa3c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@angellovesjazz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxmM9WmPc1CZcz1O_d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Можно ли из этого сделать вывод, что на прослушиваниях сейчас очень трудно зарабатывать?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0ijgM4GakEDgk6DvwnDOBg","author":"@VectorXray","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/BX3UPdWlgNnAIpDX4ZZ-j68bM-DhyzE-fx__ZZkGaT82yI46MXaxEZc1FffzkBI0POpFsddUKw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@VectorXray","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLkYKgz6nIxEjN9XV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"NordVPN wouldn't sponsor, but you know who would? Manscaped.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCY_K-h-wx0O1SP-44tWmRkQ","author":"@Justsomeguyyyyyyy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Qt1O_BdV3xje7adlvB0RXhHGvStVqPDv2u0w4_poI6gOcsv-5A2JJh9bKindwKgylti72dNHfJ4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Justsomeguyyyyyyy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYh0FK6PZgN-bI9aZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Mippia is the best AI music detection service available.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChYdwMdRBzFIZb9pmyIN61w","author":"@hooh7545","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ldFzODXPzYYk_0V3dvjmMv5OLdDH8FS0kyeuiQQV8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hooh7545","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy5Z2PxLDulv54a65l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The graph at 14:23 is all wrong, BTW.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxH-o1BpgiADwX-z80S1MlA","author":"@nachot6592","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3c6dJ2v1RO6ySXYiC0Jm9eSozRKpdEWNYe53jMtsY56Kj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nachot6592","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxqAKLxlrPyVJq209F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"apple","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwswi3JKM2pfaEgOwc4Swhg","author":"@FailedSquare","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mnCWojBN7ND7EQH-77fl4M2dcMqNynBL6zpaV1wUmk_Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FailedSquare","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyub2kpHDxukz39IPx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:42 you need better ears and then.there is big difference in quality","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0XJcF4VYJQUnHTZh9NjQ8g","author":"@LophoWilli","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/n2MTvJbeLwiJRo9Fb_jYaiSM3w5ZUVwszM9VkaNaBSUPTikluXlNpq1bNSe3tHnBFDWyHRds3w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LophoWilli","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyiN2iFrUQkvuMEKSV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"had to make it weird","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCM5Ucbpl8VbJ8pqtE8aMDAQ","author":"@chateautemp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mvZsNQUOTTFS1-IkTNOsz1-VEF3_LSbyhGcP2dl1k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chateautemp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwUj6ERyIgg5EVODdB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As long as you’re up front about your music being Ai and in my case the lyrics are mine. What’s the issue? If people don’t like it move on as you would any other music. If you do like it great 👍🏻\n\nI’m in the UK & own my copyright by UK law even though it’s Ai music it still has human input.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfMKKk0krAhIq1ytVmh5I1g","author":"@Ulfhednar-AImusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yAv2A8sDWXHTts4AozmoRGVja7xpdNtld3ZVyLqUclYmnaoo-k0WIANFjQEHXLO1IdsNpN6pLg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ulfhednar-AImusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyveLG-gzd7Rf7kUcp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"At least AI can’t get up on stage and perform for a live audience… yet","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-LUBNM1Lh-QKY4BnBKlrIg","author":"@JDPower-mk3xe","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/aPPE4Q-ja7zWV57QpP2pS8ibC8zPr9qTEe5ou4uAXL2X74K2KDN464pPSYOpAd_Sch4Jn40xwg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JDPower-mk3xe","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxzXdUHU5OBBg6CesJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i canceled spotify years ago because of joe rogan.  now I just use an adblocker on the web-browser version of spotify, boom ad-free spotify listening for years","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxg4N9KyOaYCykuExLpOhBg","author":"@SuzukaSpec","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/e2rLh4pntxcIwQ399mGgQfGU8DPX1LuhB3-_BhTrZhtSvNA-_YFbyBXEDDVkAOcU7bAFVz2TIw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SuzukaSpec","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTasMPqKwE_Ln3nhV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i have noticed that a lot of music that gets recommended to me is really bland and boring, you still get a few bangers here and there but it feels like it's getting drowned out by the uncreative filth even more these days.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCE5P9blpwcgfAyMXzBX90jA","author":"@freelancepear87kakkoka11","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ns0sAya9lu-r1TWAzTSVYl3pg93Koo3ZPrmrb7EoZb_Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@freelancepear87kakkoka11","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwfgxa6s5ipZ0aMuVd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"as an electronic musician, you can use your ears to tell suno generated songs. The vocals are obvious and the structure of the songs seem to be the same. I play with suno as a joke with my wife and sometimes to create a sample for ts. I have no issues with artist using ai as a tool but using it it generate songs and claiming as their own is bs","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCL0NCayD8NVVN598EgCbT0g","author":"@iknowbroikno","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7GqsPBIi4rABMJzIYfV6Nclwt9KLvMJho2VnwaEhN41sLU-q-cV764YYD34sgp6iKIwixTIRyNQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@iknowbroikno","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwfgxa6s5ipZ0aMuVd4AaABAg.AGCJR3Lo4dZAGEasbEV4N7","parent":"Ugwfgxa6s5ipZ0aMuVd4AaABAg","text":"I think it's ok as long as your input is over 60% into the ai to what you are trying to create, That's just my opinion!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnwzMCbj59RkeI98rhYiRHg","author":"@DazFx81","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/RVws4Pi0ftN53ZsB5j2S3ygmDqtw1WWtObaPEgfCmXuRTaENapb9WoXrKEQ4TbjgoWra-tyoubM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DazFx81","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzFL04gzC7ZAYtC1uR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"my guess:  youtube music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3b0pDcRYsV6sM0M6Tq8suQ","author":"@Forbizz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxCnm5AOGi2Y5wHJ_1RM8n54tHZFNLXh4jOkHaqyQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Forbizz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFCtnDOBKh2hNm8P14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"1/5 is not that rare....but otherwise point taken.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCimdBHjWqBybfTrMPGUxnfw","author":"@ZiggyAndTheSpiderFromMars","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kT6LSQl0gkhLGKsnzmh6nCQN_Lse-eHutSqdjFtLQ0DU5jze6nPxZmgeH2QcOJT67YvA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ZiggyAndTheSpiderFromMars","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxc0p4zT3DPpAZ7jep4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"That Peloton pays most per stream is a good illustration of why the \"per stream\" metric is bad. You know how payouts work, listens are pooled and subscription fees are paid out according to total listens, so the ideal streaming service for a musician - from this flawed perspective! - is the kind of streaming service which a ton of listeners are paying for but not using. Typically something that's crap and which was likely bundled with something else - good descriptions of Qobuz and Amazon Music, and exactly what Peloton's music subscription is!\n\nIf it wasn't like that, you could pretty much ignore AI-generated spam on streaming services (well, apart from the copyright flagging can of worms). But it is like that, and you KNOW it is like that, because as you said yourself in this video, they're actually stealing from you when their bots listen to bot-generated music, because that comes from the same pool as real artists' payouts.\n\nSo why are you telling people to go on Amazon music or Qobuz? It's not those sites which will turn bad on artists, causing payouts to drop. Even the increased traffic you send their way, will cause their per stream payouts to drop (because I assume Benn Jordan/Flashbulb fans listen to more music than average, and definitively more than average on those bundly low-quality services.)\n\nSPAM is a far worse problem for artists than low payouts per stream. Spotify used to be best about fighting spam. Virtually all the other streaming services do NOTHING about spam. But a few years ago Spotify dropped the ball on spam fighting, and now they've even fired their main spam fighter (the Echo Nest guy). So which streaming service to use is a hard problem, which I would love to have Benn Jordan's help in figuring out, but it looks like you're dropping the ball too, with this foolish fixation on per stream payouts.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPesfNlbfoEyL2uW-noq-Yg","author":"@Mnnvint","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nN8j2KOhv4X8SeMGR6tF1TsTHcfHFfhWLIRtB7nQk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mnnvint","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxcio3GKmDDwHAo0TJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"14:23 something is a little off here in aligning with what you’re saying","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJjuNQgBs-8X8eNk0SLLluQ","author":"@bongwater-villain","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/kphKBwNj4LSpPMnVTRGPhPZbTokbHG38F1DL2JBaVfzQEX7RItdDU7lto70F46V2jLc-CmgF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bongwater-villain","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwPbG1GO2WDTP7Cjx14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bandcamp","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUKabYvTLUs3fFR8aBNXiiw","author":"@tomashcroft7024","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l6BG-YvD6Qcp00LY7W4GtCNXrxdNAU-5IH6Y7iinA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tomashcroft7024","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynSI-cV9h2GrPU1Wh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bandcamp","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTdQDvBqhf_ZnxGnrU5IrsA","author":"@Deusex63","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_koVV1D8qzUpJgNoIw4nAhJVgkEVl8ZuOgBCMF3lOs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Deusex63","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyzZtpU-l-SfmVB6iZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you use a paid generative service, you own the copyright to that generated work. So, YES... they \"created\" that music. No different from hiring a professional to execute a task for you. This is about rights ownership. Who \"physically\" created the work is unimportant. If people like what they hear is the only thing that matters.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEDbDyZMrV_894l-uudVW4w","author":"@TeddyLeppard","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mA4G3V8IGT7j9ggo2bPnJYmo79cBgmr2GCJ4u3N10=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TeddyLeppard","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQkthnx35huOhHdUd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bandcamp","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC859qKJ_hgqcqieq3iVl7vQ","author":"@AntoniGawlikowski","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lFYzhVVM9nhPkdqXN6AHy-vlsXqC3f19Nz5BFbRC0FwY6M=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@AntoniGawlikowski","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwwufAaj1-lAAdL9it4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"No, \"machine learning\" is not losing as artists, people or scripts are.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC43sRL7IF7QJo1c2KArJ2eg","author":"@tutacat","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lTrrHNGPRIMVPlGVJWJRUZyPKZgYzMHAYeE5q4nDRgYMMh1I483VD9E0r_pf3-S3k_iQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tutacat","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxu8HrJ-8nCjzwYXXx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"How does a ..nis thank me without making it awkward for HR?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfjlJMoZWv8etqSLaVTjVKw","author":"@henrikjensen608","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lKlndGIxlaE8uhhLqggcD5FRVDUD_BKEVJhUoNPWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@henrikjensen608","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgybN3tTuKMld-hhUWN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bandcamp","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCE6odFDgaVz8sHjNJnDdQmA","author":"@queenluci6664","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/exUXVi7Q84yE5LJHHJ291iieZN2UB8ePyfo__yfCzIWBZsmWWYQOwvjSV6kFdVtTUef3hEYPTw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@queenluci6664","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx75lo4YoOO06LQ0PN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"can you keep appear\nyuu2\nsploota\nbiscuit fountainn\nsimilarity\nhold the phone\ndizzy dreamer\nfirthy\nwindtonic\nqueen of you","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCqecMspfZcgSi_cWDuN_JA","author":"@Claveen","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/EH1ei-2hJWbWddwnlD20Rpmm0zovSQJ08IOZyS6loP_jhQ2eyvYSHWEUZczVXbJ40t6XnW2UzA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Claveen","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzjlWHGDyEB_yG9Sgl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I dont listen to music anymore.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCc_1pUNCms6kSqGtSEAcI7A","author":"@BeattapeFactory","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dNjm2gLI4q2A8a-zENwNAkfC5tJHhnj23FR_H7lPUBpKnadzKM43EFSzMRpGkXuuae0atYjWGuA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BeattapeFactory","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxlH6v-alFu99dLc7Z4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hi,,Check out my Music which I create using AI as a tool, but using my voice recordings, creating my own lyrics and I am proud of it and happy to have this be possible. I am also against people starting it only and directly for profits, with only using prompts to produce garbage without any work or checking if they infringed someones work.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCCHxe476yKtLyCwbLaku2vQ","author":"@brziarzi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/PsBq5vTWMrI8q41hxRqv_vtChO4WIvEsX2Pd484XVtbktwjHWUGJEGKFhxUPBGSbIMqmUOn0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@brziarzi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz-Sf29ScesYm2RUsV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI music is just making the artistry sad. There's \"ggg.\" on YouTube, Spotify, etc. pumping out tons of music in less than 3 months and people are being fooled thinking it's great chill music. There must be tons of others as well. They should really put limitation on AI generated music before we accidentally make something that the AI has already generated and get copy strikes.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfXL2pRfBDvg5bCJQ7rn-_g","author":"@PaprTape","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/c68wHXwupCA98VDN0F9NmutkcZUYKh3fv0L1u8PKdqOTwjfJ0hm86SVLQKWRdb36MY9EerfLcQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PaprTape","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwwKuUyyDLafK-xk8h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Peloton Spotify farm","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCE5eZ3fLURzlDaCy6fAA5Xw","author":"@robertizzy10","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mtKjA8Z1odJKuEgjoylzXL6UPC5da5j0a8huLdJ35OFw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@robertizzy10","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7bmYjJOELw1fq08t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You should get paid more for the first stream (per user) and then less for subsequent.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC44k46eStl2dr4WhmbLYlyw","author":"@NGreenini","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XW91qV6cAvRzsgm4mV7FA-brcd8uLhpQ2fcL_Kr_H3iphHqRiiPPVggBI7spf_VOKW0HhGmDkw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NGreenini","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwQiC6hG_2sTrFxVNx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"What's going to be absolutely hilarious It's 6 months to a year from now when my AI gets finished up and it can literally create anything. There's going to be a worldwide reckoning.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVPdCbvRTkpNZnqSvJPc6VA","author":"@softwyre","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mXBiA7-w4l7hsosdseUuTjivxT7WcbjPThqLX8wroQKnc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@softwyre","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymeC9mGF1tsRiZ-3l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Youtube pays me the most.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkyTer9tK7t905lt2B0JyJA","author":"@NBC9music","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fVLO8IPqAcsC1F6rcltxHApKvyYJWCRUDdZIG6U_OXsEnwZRjjjMaSlIwDPwUtPbmu4KJ4Nv=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NBC9music","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxj64BrZL2wnE0mGyh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Using AI detectors that use AI to identify AI songs is \"cheating\". Lol. Seriously, it's ironic AI has to detect AI as people can't regularly identify AI.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCYPBs5hevekKxfkXlHFXrwA","author":"@Jersey1203-DEMOS-R-US","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GGmvaa7RjYUNCgxJDpDHProE-1Xbo8IZ36CrK8vJ9lmB7OiE6tcB8VCx6g9QmszNzVxn7WkzEg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jersey1203-DEMOS-R-US","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwRK_xVBugUi570kcJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"spotify pays me the most","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsGFG_cHg6yMRB_-7rtlL2g","author":"@logicsystemsmedia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8AmjrnDFrInS6zvFF36Gng_BvwXp1MtUzbiDkmtB7oHqZkAAc_3IE53Lk9m5xYBHkOJsCWhVFA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@logicsystemsmedia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLB6iX1Yg8LVYNaQB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If people want to listen to AI slop, not my problem...","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCV17UpTXfU2CRpcHUhQO41Q","author":"@uzefulvideos3440","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/OuPOvD-xFCjEK-oaYCa5JKuhn2cnWD6Aqs9LEfZn0TC5d8L_OGo-8dhb4pgYPY9HpzIM0Cujkw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@uzefulvideos3440","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLB6iX1Yg8LVYNaQB4AaABAg.ACxYstbHImfACx_e0FIlG9","parent":"UgwLB6iX1Yg8LVYNaQB4AaABAg","text":"Yes it is everyone's problem","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCCHpM0M6TTGBBm2j8T03lIw","author":"@Idontlikecsharp","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/GmVvsYUtkxwCSRnWqFstQwhIOuAdHIeCKEg_QMb3PyojyvowlAaY4o94d-D8uhZEbycu7MJdLg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Idontlikecsharp","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLB6iX1Yg8LVYNaQB4AaABAg.ACxYstbHImfADG7g4yQFBm","parent":"UgwLB6iX1Yg8LVYNaQB4AaABAg","text":"If you want to be delusional, not my problem","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCp7PdU5RnGk-bHH2-ECCOHQ","author":"@goldencookie5456","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOZnwmKO-Cn9DhjWmXLb1PK3L65GpyyU0NDzefj4PMMg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@goldencookie5456","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWu0TkCSpYz7gKMTF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm already refusing myself to listen to music published after 2021 from artists I do not know. Same with youtube videos: is it a recent published youtube video without the host appearing (at least from time to time), and I dont know this channel? OK, no...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEYRTBGd9COL5oAkP2kp9mw","author":"@just_being_phil","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vBLmFKCXCLabvtChq1iJsOKwVs3iCONQ3N7RsEi_h8lJJ25R4RtlNuA9UZuqBXoqPWU9VEZM0g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@just_being_phil","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwjqPApgSWIUy4O4EV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"based as always","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmwNLUcDhJg8qAQLrBeo8bQ","author":"@templarexemplar35","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nBJirZqilZ9W2u4NYTxFFVeiFTHW5vjbbWtqpQpFW-JAQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@templarexemplar35","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx-Zp14N4-b1f-pk4F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Looks like my comments won't even post to your YouTube Channel anymore due to the auto-stuff. I cannot even say it because it will remove it.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdYPqNDbquFY6x9mWbon7ZQ","author":"@rogerlouie1","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lQ3rdMcjp87QMvC4GGR9gnVPu2YXz_sZ92GsTNQHAs2Jk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rogerlouie1","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgziuESPfWSOzar4cRB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yeah but if you make a hybird of ai and human made then should be copyright able.  .","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAboRBQIrx2xuWCO6yKnC3g","author":"@rockerrockstar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kzX29Oi0xslvLWRwPPR5N5GoKxFWowpf8IaMCGJxs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rockerrockstar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgziuESPfWSOzar4cRB4AaABAg.AF2C4yChIMJAG38L71Ds3m","parent":"UgziuESPfWSOzar4cRB4AaABAg","text":"true","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCZk_1gTwKULY45FJQzjeIA","author":"@jackied962","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lzFEjYUWqiTgjmUJkeOPsrcbHFkvm9viPAT5_5Lq0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jackied962","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyazGVPHsU842E__cl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But YouTube music is included in my YouTube Premium subscription....","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCm0fx6gi3VvFat2na_B3-DA","author":"@chrisjb241","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XQeujjWXHOSgT959FLhw80L7HrPbbCR9yk7QCKH3nRPBd9ldk27TTl-Q8H5c0xaxPr9wqDJ8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chrisjb241","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx1obKCmSXdcbbbXY94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Hot take: AI music should be made copy writable. It will dismantle the idea sooner","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPJJSu4XyPUVdaYc4-yW-Xw","author":"@miketothe2ndpwr","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n0TpBnD4S0V2jG3FJ_I0eq5D6yMJP9LTJVoDQFsq0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@miketothe2ndpwr","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx8XiJ1dTuSHPRzvsV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI is telling you how to detect AI","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCA4dMkCgFv76vFW0c2uvg3g","author":"@lueco1715","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lDxJM6E-idm3SnDrGSZhhFBZ86cYvNwm709qLUMNfuJ88H4QqPg4TZLcXzk54QlooBwg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lueco1715","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQpKqyh4UrAno2D4d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"..the software is good, but not perfect, it can't separate suno instrumental with human vocals, it detect's like human...but overall nice try, i hope it will improve..regards","like_count":0,"author_id":"UClWuf7VnDNugelq6P2Mzskw","author":"@djerikfox","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iKUtqYd_XzLqUTcvEuQqyIZW7HZe_9-S1Q-XEPyVbxSGbCq23hM4RQMHfHa787KoyAlSqBJXTA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@djerikfox","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyOPW9FABvNnoKUAG94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"wait does soundcloud not pay anything??? I though there was a verified thing for you to get paid on soundcloud.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqr6eG2v_2qTT2nIRrsPggA","author":"@broodlingg","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-BPzIluE4NkX1N4dL97LTh5EdoveUeVJ70WDy1LVCuEac-actshQ4vjAg7Lhm_JQsShfUEgq=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@broodlingg","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwVikqhBzSS9cU6uoV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you don't believe, just come and see....Echo","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCboKTWRF6fbQz6j05Y19duw","author":"@JimmyEcho333","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/y2fFXAeYoUrJOlR8jubf-pym5FdfAEtfQzfMUwUbkFJ3xlgqr80zHfsa2YOFV0U8Ukz_bJwq=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JimmyEcho333","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwD2E3BaafrQT1Zbqh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Well at least Benn isn't pro AI any more...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCz0nAfuKd_WuNsWWKNQEdFA","author":"@MikeNorvak","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Duk7Am2HOyIIZPwd5tCw2baJN4y-_q_-CekRx7n3_1TP-J5n2K9AEvbPRUYccDYNbuo27AxAvQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MikeNorvak","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzFP-fwHyWHZ4Nr5Z14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"“We know it’s a competitive world out there so we’re developing creative AI to make it even more difficult.”👎","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCb44WzOYYtT7fN4w5tranGg","author":"@ryeguy7471","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n1qazWggejK1HmMrjNuziIfMGEeBrbvBDGiTj40nk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ryeguy7471","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxNQ6kqrRRD0oXUxJB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You think using pre-made sounds in a digital program to compose a \"song\" is any different then using generative ai? If you are that much of a purist you better be playing all of this music manually.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_KgAsiLv9mwlwAlgQCR-GQ","author":"@williamforsythe5850","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nftkx0debTCI8LLlVBqscYTY2nrsWcymKJyJrIbkmug2o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@williamforsythe5850","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzsJu95vLcVUd-z7hZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Apple Music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChniBdk5c-Zb3k9_7V_4ftg","author":"@TalkLouis","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vNOAp--7aasOIGzNz1Ewc09IAOEH0VS90mI7Rke2XIN5WaMR7kwxHgG2v6JBerHBAl7QfZTU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TalkLouis","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyDgQPUF2eoAlYkt_N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"In my opinion, AI should be used for mostly shitposting purposes or (if you are an indie dev and not fucking Activision) to ASSIST with game development","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgjk3QJSZGHZJBT5fV-JVbg","author":"@starlingisarealperson","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/H0t--o0aZ-5UtO0QoPCYBY7ZhLDesdRX5qbo9dZ0tuKeTgs24i3ccre6yeRyhsc75Bwboj7d0A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@starlingisarealperson","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyuevfc8017rr2OKXZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"it's fine, the audience wont even notice.... ;]  but it makes me think why i lost interest in music scene...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVA321I14GIb1K2ROu8jStw","author":"@akkamiau","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k0ZD3DCAt-Uk_iysDEpDT-SfHPgUa5nIrp9tEoPah5OI4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@akkamiau","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzeoQgePMijV0yVEqN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You sir are doing the lord’s work, this is awesome 👏","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCT3U5uDALVOp5jd70FcTgbg","author":"@Lanessan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0Il5vbE_NMJdLNJ_Qtw6quzO7rUbITwF3RPbgO0oirnLygFZymG-xpXyowlOzxTA2lGKU-FrJMI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Lanessan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2NmBgrWeNhxv8c5B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I can't bother with music that isn't from a verifiable producer or band. Even better if they've done something live at least, just to avoid the AI slop. Even then, there's no way of avoiding artists who are also using some ai prompting for lyrics or easy chord progression. so lame","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCcb0HY_wqQabqYxfDAOb5Q","author":"@markv1006","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mLu5amYe870h9eqIBYEWLqVETODuJXTJ3y06IaSk3lCrI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@markv1006","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwI-I0mEDS-1JN5zB54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you don't copy someone else's original song from start to finish - then who cares? Copyright? Patents? The average user doesn't give a damn about corporations crying.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkK8ez7bD_IyBlp5mveqtcg","author":"@HLDeadMan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mLbHH-uwaqgb3iz_e7cB2eUjUPFnFQNcriosRHGTe94Wo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@HLDeadMan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxzvJRt2X48GgY4YIV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm guessing Apple Music pays the best.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCf4-J7dkYBY9e7clabLV1wA","author":"@WillyOD","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n8n_v126lvO8ZqXlQe_Yuwt33Ekg0hivFSQddcekFyCQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WillyOD","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxObUF1XqzP9-0K0-x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I bet you wont find the AI generated music the industry is making. \n\nBy design? Only powerful should be able to generate it?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSgzXPykR06ZG-gqkZldidw","author":"@BooleanDisorder","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Qv2_sq9MxRCsl-JdpBkQsJJdRpWQVwRe0apL8q9EGIm998opp447mGQOaOvn86eDQCwcoGe1=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BooleanDisorder","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzXQGUC4ZFzaPscKkl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I just switched to Deezer. Bye bye Spotify.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-8oh5AaHxynhvMYakwmTbw","author":"@WilliamLevasseur","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n4GNgaHiXlT4U48UHiXwsRsJ9LTYsUWMv5RZqkAs_wqdA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WilliamLevasseur","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxPtMI6DJASmXeBG714AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"record labels are definitely using Ai to make music. I put nothing passed them","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCt1aBqpZJ91jcVfqdxK2EOQ","author":"@ShawnBloom","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lkHZTsNtLAwkoU-7JKANaRUXpL9MeHnSeUH6nhJkLWX1U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ShawnBloom","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwKKMGNDRKUB6TUdS54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"100% accuracy is probably misleading, as your sample probably wasn't large enough to account for false positives.\n\nEither way, even 95% would be very impressive to me.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5hJF3Nz8MMx4gFfjYGv4sQ","author":"@legionofthought","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/x0bzK6YdTqm55H3it8UQzEWFHUMD7k2B7h_bO8rYhn2rcLeF6dXwfG691QCZTo_DvEgvijRB=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@legionofthought","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyTyRs87vx1gCoka7V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Peloton pays the most","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX6b62tRHvRz4-OdebgxqbQ","author":"@DrJerryDoby_PhD","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ZJRJJrBL3PBHj_fHv18YiN6iEEF0XwepQgH_XWTcdNiWc3SBvjrsEY_NjMaeGGNJY1vFBwoLpQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DrJerryDoby_PhD","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzEKbERq8YrWgenoeB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"There is no \"AI\" (yet), is just a buzzword everyone uses now, what we have now are computer programs with access to massive databases and digital duct-tape","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC9wbFw0_WMg0yodzRupEfdA","author":"@andyhull9182","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mjL8wHVg8T1j2c8RFaIES8psZeL0Misk566p_O-0tYWA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andyhull9182","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyQ7iucDWyjiRiU-A94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why would you need to detect AI music? Have you ever had to detect music that contained other types of synthesizers or drum machines or samples? Who are you to decide what a real musician or what real music is?  The “Splice issue” is something that even a very legit and talented musician could fall victim to, as you suggested. Yes, we should be encouraged to do whatever custom work on our loops to make them unique as possible. And we should be encouraged to do the same with samples generated with AI. But if you’re anti-AI altogether then you may as well be anti-keyboard too. Because the lines are very blurred and nobody other than the consumer gets to decide if it’s quality music or not. I’m skeptical of the musician who is earning income and obsessing over their streaming revenue because they’re less likely to be putting heart into their music. They’re just trying to make something that is commercially viable. But they’re so quick to say there’s no heart in other types of music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaXiMzwkWVJiBJupvoFjySw","author":"@micah_noel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/DfYdDtdxz1JF9-0DHyq5QROTJJ0uq-vd9qH2AZxIZ_EsXqOTLi3PZ3YaNttOwWZyEKNYKKynHQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@micah_noel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw-FcFXCVqQlpdcOrN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"CANCEL THAT SHIT\nhe said through the 90% mark while airing on YT","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYqEXfq36yMvsEo8GL68OAQ","author":"@vecvan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nx1sQ_aFKfPUSGNDHpXEJLQasTUf6XTauJixHs8BrDdg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vecvan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy6YnBoLXsZ5jWzPc54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Im glad i never used spotify","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnHGnEyWsVtJ7mNK_xgBIfw","author":"@boscorner","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lOF6OwwNZehOAIB0Kz9rce0zt7m6Qe7DCWgft0y_DZFw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@boscorner","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw_ql9DEJMOlsyeRLt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"All the \"audiophiles\" lost their minds when you said most people can't tell the difference between lossless and compeessed music. Its funny because they all speend money to listen to systems that are skewtoward what they find pleasing and spend insane amounts of money for the most useless modifiers (some that change nothing) claiming its so much better. I know its in the video for methodology but these people are still going to come out of the woodwork for this one point.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdcp6g1crjbfjVSmAv0SBtw","author":"@BDB7614","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/q7USql991rb_o0eHLNrgSVN5OyokTZH3H_vDDHfFEvaE3lzwUfokuKr_ERuh73wJ8qFVYV2kAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BDB7614","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFyOjY6Sxfq78okqR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Kevin was left alone at home and decided to deal with the digital hustlas 😂 Sorry Bro, 😊","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUHGvbn18xVpU-1Q2GaayAw","author":"@ZVUCHI","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_liAuJC2zfdpko11O9r-xdM0mxt6k54Zq6vkpthDa8NCg8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ZVUCHI","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"5 months ago","timestamp":1777680000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgylfUlohPWLpJN7GfN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Luckily I listen to death metal, still very DIY","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCz9WdwXqiDlxKl2vwGVJZIA","author":"@jslaughterofthesoul4939","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nE3TNB_hKn9m0Z-7PG-WlxtKPDDcmCrJ7dUWaaXkzm9Bc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jslaughterofthesoul4939","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyKtOPFWSk0GiF6HTl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So if an artist writes a records his own stuff - completely original - how does one get plays on the streaming service??? I'm perplexed. My stuff gets a few hundred streams at the best. I never cross any threshold - never see a dime. So your're saying I can skip all that work and expense and use AI and get many many streams. What a messed up world. I quit.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCPNzBAGm3z2C2kH0CfW6RyQ","author":"@craigwillms61","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kpaiJCfRZt7cyT-GotkeyKdRJP0CG66bHLKz2Okj1VTf0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@craigwillms61","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzcQbpGOGReWMtVs6J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"youtube maybe best for per view pay","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCX7FAkYmER29PazEPs68rbw","author":"@ggggagi","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1qOHoB-QP79k8yb-KRfFtVAJek4PW2pX10LuLpAv_aB1TzeRuOsu9r9iL2bGBAG_KTlnTQGKd1U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ggggagi","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWiEZzUscLS1j1ppd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Idk my first thought was YouTube pays the most, just by the amount of views music videos are getting i think that could be a good guess haha (didn´t watch the rest yet) lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRWkUmYuAZ6F1_9Fdp6s6UA","author":"@Tonydeezer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1vidkGvKrhYR_G-jED9dIQUA0zxG5Ekl_rEFMxkrqZZbKhGTjpEdmAGMxOfYRpnFCF2tDFg6Tw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tonydeezer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzWiEZzUscLS1j1ppd4AaABAg.ACyV_wIspVeACyXeAV7Jn4","parent":"UgzWiEZzUscLS1j1ppd4AaABAg","text":"Well i was wrong lmfao","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRWkUmYuAZ6F1_9Fdp6s6UA","author":"@Tonydeezer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1vidkGvKrhYR_G-jED9dIQUA0zxG5Ekl_rEFMxkrqZZbKhGTjpEdmAGMxOfYRpnFCF2tDFg6Tw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tonydeezer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxYx4A1asrpR4jlY_B4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Music have never been human made.   it is more deep than that..  it is bigger than \"Human\"   War is human made..   polution is human made..   everything bad is human made..    Music is spirituel..   mindfull..   it is everything that human is NOT!!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC72Yrvz38o_apfQEanUXDjA","author":"@Ananda7uk","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_8pLggBq106vln1QDYyPQVm7TVy7I60eDqWiepUKGwk4QQZPYiDctStpIHJbUt2NBHEKzd1zVw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ananda7uk","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxQqNyG8G4uwk4qYRR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Just follow this simple AI hack. Companies will hate you for this:\n\nUse one dataset for validation and testing. Boom. 100%.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW_RARWnvYuerGoScp2SxYg","author":"@Mefistofy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mFYeeHyZ-Ow8tvsFP9jSlgkvn1New3JQn9kC0pUg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mefistofy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwYT4zWS1GEm9zB5Ch4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you love average boring music with no artistic value. This will be a boom time for you.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMedA4zTq2c-VCYRK40xSXw","author":"@queasybeetle","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nCoOC57MXTtT0v424Rkjd0IYOXAFNJ48MCPiU_fBVkN5o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@queasybeetle","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzJgAmhdWhnns17YIh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Call me old fashioned, but I normally just buy CDs/Vinyls in person or FLACs off of bandcamp. I don't like the idea of renting art.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCbNfIOxmhRGLKSRizmPjkDg","author":"@esoteric_nebula","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mRLHDd8NjgcJzYOjfocI0lyyr-4xsFWa2Rk1N3X8UlnC_JG2KQE1IaoSm4cR9C7ymAZA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@esoteric_nebula","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxDP0IpkN0jMunMmZV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm curious where you're going to draw the line however, because would AI generated music that is sampled and then add it to \"real music\" still be considered AI music by you or your algorithm? What about samples, what about song loops, what about generator presets, at what point do you say okay all forms of shortcuts beyond this point is okay But before this point it's considered cheating? \n\nwhat's stopping anybody who creates music on suno from just going into a simple wave edit and adding a few sounds randomly to the beginning middle or end and re uploading it as original content and that's just the top of the slippery slope.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgWJk1k_dSgiwEVCVRnmCEA","author":"@ErinskiEasy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k-7t_84f1RZXeOAcNvM3VkOP4M3Jc5qSqsI_Cn63POv0LQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ErinskiEasy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzQTqxxUqJvGtqkbsF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I like anime .","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCGgBCUOreiRMDNfdHC5BXpw","author":"@nongmar8783","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kYRmvZAueTs5TVwJxovIVDIsiv7tC2kDjGli_6HW2ONAE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nongmar8783","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwyYfXhvqompK3yJ754AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Wow if you can't hear the difference between 128kbps and a 44khz flac you shouldn't be allowed to listen to music. 320k? yeah ok that's difficult for someone untrained. 256k? eh, if you're listening through Windows (WDM) audio I could see the confusion. 128? Excuse me? Were they listening over bluetooth?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCykRtwRjJiMRfIRHxYD1vw","author":"@stug77","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/72DIHMCszVqtop8fT2E-cNFmLU-qPJsAJqpLgwLu3XElJgcBsYK49kGxZ37wPAdBpw6mEOK-VTE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stug77","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxOmojeNdU0Tva2bSl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Dead internet theory as is","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXAaZAwtGDROFSBEzDAFWUA","author":"@illiteratedud","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/QSGj47HIqXKffizwMuFGUinI5bqKNusoZv_YvhDzhn8dQjvKtxyxwvumGtWUukPUDC_Xa2TxzQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@illiteratedud","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwTae-REMK7E-JaaXN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Deezer paid a lot","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCW8ytuDF3sPPeI4YAsI6yUQ","author":"@Nevadem","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/fw2B0fw1D3sx8q2UNQRfok8hpnMRkDAI_ItAAC1ulZ3Gwhs3_YnagsWnjZ3zfqiLPdk5jWePYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Nevadem","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwjxfbUr2VIB2vN9wt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sorry, this is well intentions but it doesn't work for users who ONLY have music in compressed formats to begin with.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4FcrAEBS_rEaAhTn6DPdUA","author":"@FrankHarwald","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lO_-M9PIj8lhisA3BRSiFIfdY2uw0bD6-vAsOjp1OZHsU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@FrankHarwald","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymbCsOiQJgaCYiWwh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"A.I. isn't posing as legitimate artists, people are using it to do that. It's just a bot program, it can't do anything on it's own.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCzQFVHF8YHaBUGG2lRd5S4A","author":"@NeonShadowZ","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llzThuNfkPLke4AgTDaazTZz1ji8zSWMdW4sD5SHV_Ew=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@NeonShadowZ","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhKHg51USoF-fmUCF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I don't understand how a data nerd can know this much technical info and still not understand how AI trains. They don't take LZ Black Dog or any other song and plug it in to the AI so it might generate part of that song in re- generation. What it does is take millions of songs and analyze the probability in all the songs that chord A was used and followed by chord B and when chord B was followed by Chord C etc. It does not \"copy\" or \"scrape\" note for note from songs. That is ridiculous. it breaks it all down into data. The likelihood that any established song would be re-generated is about the same as infinite monkeys with infinite typewriters eventually writing Shakespeare. If you could break a human and all its chemicals down to its base metals and elements, what is the likeihood you could re-generate a human from that pile of material to be a living breathing human again? THAT is basically what you are saying AI can do. It can't, at least not on purpose!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyuj2Ax_zR3IRuYZ9nHS_og","author":"@Diamondback-s1s","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8yJwY5SbFydBg5Jfc6zqtL0hwylyNIwAD2VvOKExLqP1mPCAL4uHCcz8XqGoCHjkv09mtz-4Rw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Diamondback-s1s","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw2vWTVwcBxtQU2JYF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The Gospel \n\nJesus Christ loves you and died, rose from the dead, and ascended to heaven to pay for your sin! Repent and turn to Him and you will walk in light and be saved. Read the book of John and Luke to see God's love for you!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCpz5-xps3kipr1HU8czO6YA","author":"@MemeRider","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VxSdnbEZRDbt9oZtOCEubFOOQNdty5T3mkbe_rnMGXyA_2JGXGGpjB5xgeT-YNqIm_y3g1mk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MemeRider","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyrTsaK4lmkvaYs6Gd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Is it Qobuz that pays the most? =P","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCrXknHeGKdvIcYzCqt3MP_A","author":"@GiftFromGod","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k9EiYw4pzcF6tCkrTCCGQI66fcgqhXj5K8mPU8CktG8LJD=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GiftFromGod","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzuTgBlX1hOuSI12AN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i mean this in the kindest way possible are your eyebrows ok and have you been to a doctor about them","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwXgt3OlAUiwfA2NOMrDOdg","author":"@oosihx","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SF9SqcTIWRN0qwNN_Z9IZ4tvjFVgWRnXifuZxdkBpgZ11vEJONHyM0xEG_52oOQqcOJ6mTzGwQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oosihx","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxKJC6u6CD_EKRxjLt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The year is 1990.  35 years ago, and DAWs and digital instruments exploded.  \"real\" musicians freak out and vow NEVER to sell out and use digital instruments.  Fastforward to 2025.  Everyone is using digital instruments and DAWs.  Fastforward to 2030-2035.  Everyone, including existing artists will be using generative Ai to create their music.  Artists will be \"given\" their new albums for simple approval or disapproval for release.  This current \"training\" issue is small potatoes that will be rectified, and the industry will adapt.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC2hMyU0xF-9jx_1sxzEemTA","author":"@natevelar","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ChaABoYJUXRSedQahwGYGH5pjldgkIsIqQlPUb8LZsZRnHaszOwJswfYEPIEDR9IDR1QRvL6_Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@natevelar","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw412ygX-66bHxJ94l4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Or you could be a live musician - play real instruments/record yourself playing  those instruments on original chord changes, grooves  & melody that you came up  with and completely avoid all of this mess.😉✌","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC6uWWVfvhVncP66SsozzoPA","author":"@funkycat251","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XZ14eQTRgp0BK791ny3ZAtyts0bBstcHuO-yUVUIVjmSd0vU1iXgtAEQBJkl0d5V2p7M6Po=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@funkycat251","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw412ygX-66bHxJ94l4AaABAg.ACyslb5GraZACzAI4VuX_G","parent":"Ugw412ygX-66bHxJ94l4AaABAg","text":"Who are you talking too? Surely not the person who made this video who has done and does all those things.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmNUqdAQnrK82VIwJ7cHTPA","author":"@Heakz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lCz-5s9xX2KhaXt-SgRQrSh7xSIu9Mi5iKddZZLTjvY5aH0-HZod53kfuRV4K-zm-cvg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Heakz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwNpJobYFaCZ3y58MN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Uncompressed audio files are the REASON your game is 150gb. UNCOMORESSED WAV VOICELINES. MUSIC. ITS NAUSEATING.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCWMuZzkp2fZiJc3WzsGR-wA","author":"@pauliman1098","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nJDuh6ZW9XleVKL6OKjKLgwCPi2L0K6xw8ptMmyuV_vqo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@pauliman1098","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6bs1oz9uYs7j0RPh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Bear with me, Ai is just exposing the whole entire industry’s hypocrisies why? Well you could arguably say that the last musicians where classical musicians like pianist, live vocalist basically anyone that played live drums or instruments the same way broadway actors consider “digitally” edited actors “not real performers” sampling takes so much creativity and talent but that does not change you’re sampling another persons composition. I think people are just scared that their talent and ability will be challenged and either force to withdraw or refine his/her craft! Ai music for now does not impress the same way real music does and for that matter a lot of modern music is exactly the same which is Sterile. Btw ai platforms inbed a “noice” artifact that sounds like static but is actually there way of signing music.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCs7vnipm5eB7MKDW2z0uPqg","author":"@DynasticTP","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/8aaqM6LZAOaQtHBYgac19litF-ppe-JFBaOKD3Zj-xh1uUyTYdp1CJlgGnT1iSfVGzN8dMHf=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DynasticTP","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"9 months ago","timestamp":1767312000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxVdb23hTsmkq3ivWB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"music is music. even when it comes from human brain or AI. you forget your brain also a big AI neuron network","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoD6p2Wju22GaamKxF57VjA","author":"@vngvuvo6968","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/AreyWC2-FTrcXdQj1rgv2CIKTUqO5YYWIvK5qAj2S1XJRh85AxHxIoGK1v2opDZ8Tib5Tb0Z=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vngvuvo6968","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyn5Nma1Air9Y-91nd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You did all this just be slap down by supreme Court AI & human working together good to go","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCr-nmJLbPhs1GumY7ryrnw","author":"@TrapBoiFuse561","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JTWMXxcBL2ID6PMuWE2NZ436JnqTM0I--sFskUuo-4XbKdzykYDcq-cUvEuQ26OpeRjVbdSKCJI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TrapBoiFuse561","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwM2IOmAdrbHsOClYh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Don't use streaming services","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZ_IIQ6vPrb8Eg4xlA-uL5Q","author":"@marcinkarpinski9163","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kXBEnx_ParGtQFUjn3_1uw9zREhaQ1cTcmb12j6C2eQAs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@marcinkarpinski9163","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugym0Tmh6P6dmTheQOx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Regardless of what you think you see. The issue is not and will never be AI.\nThe issue is a human issue, not a technological one. Deal with humanity, with its continued immaturity as a species. If you cannot do this, then don't complain when bullshit occurs. It is literally inevitable. 🤦","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVZc8cO3wmXuMJ0Vd3y1ayA","author":"@vorcanvorcan9032","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_msXLd8FyJgmktdiZrzmiWo0nW07GjC0mSc_HJZ4aA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vorcanvorcan9032","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwDl75aCpDgCFdLSsZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"👀AYO","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBKKzH8yg8RKuESEoYNsADw","author":"@mattwesthaver6909","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kguV4JgX6rTDU3aUxwJqDkKdSaSRjNVibUr-GX9oE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mattwesthaver6909","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyxiJfuuIc5PbEtSb14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Now make an AI tool that finds copyright infringement on \"human made songs\". I'll bet you'll find equally, if not more, copyright infringement there. Humans trained for years, off other artists, before making something they think is 100% unique. In reality, they are blending many other artists sounds and simply doing it wrong or bad or intentionally altering it with tiny changes. Just like AI does.\n\nNot one artist has paid another artist for the training they \"stole\". Few, unless it is a blunt cover song, have ever split royalties with those artists either.\n\nUnless they made pure noise and lived a life in isolation, the chances of NOT borrowing another artist's content, is nearly impossible. Adding to the fact that only a finite number of keys, transitions and chords are \"pleasing to hear\". As well as scales repeating, in tones... It is even further unavoidable as more songs get created.\n\nThat is actually the point of the song \"Four chords\" by the fictitious parody band \"Axis of Awesome\".","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCny3gVSySz_D9pgSBjBqNbw","author":"@JasonArthurDAngelo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/o4HaWmo59SVjC4-_zPe9794OFwpsHbIcDifK9TJ__OnGD_I_9K5V3OyOUa-1rEXp0mgv_gWXHYA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JasonArthurDAngelo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"2 months ago","timestamp":1785628800,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwgqjmy6GSGT3-cx794AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Its okay. But its no substitute for a real job.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCvgkhitxuTi-ADUqhFaLUDg","author":"@barkerbiz","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k1KJziutousLX5LuhsdSNRQdDRxphT1vPwmmrbeGw407k=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@barkerbiz","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw-lYSAFISJZnq2GyV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yep another video that doesn’t understand that YouTube could not exist without its id system \n\nAnd whitelists would need to be maintained and updated \n\nWhich for a site that already loses money would probably destroy it","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCokDVo0doR-JykX8Ry9zApg","author":"@michealjaymurphy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mS6buSaAYqjzQ2Dgf01hOoJ5hL3-ONAjunQbXJ_GoDgtw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michealjaymurphy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx6Aub7IvB9dhzmC7d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'd never heard the -lib suffix pronounced that way before. I mean it makes sense... I guess...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCM1b3zpQQmgVH4xGoX_5MBw","author":"@All4Tanuki","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qEsfHw_TvMRa0TNI7DUz48XBKIFYKRC-9L0rtKZAxWwll8DTAsZpN1a87hax5XxkI3r4hxlp=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@All4Tanuki","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 month ago","timestamp":1788307200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxLhiwwgXRrZUwsx9t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I write my songs. Y’all are being so disrespectful to the way people express themselves. I’ve written for 20+ years. The arrogance. Smh","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCzmybMlruSra72X5sPOLnsw","author":"@jarenfromvenus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/djStDAPRCSONhwL73XroAN8kx4lazcbXhflOh93iAZ8J0lNLNq3r2m2U_yGcG6VDlRNO5867iw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jarenfromvenus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz3UbYLRiz8sDHzynd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I hate Spotify and I have never used it and it smells. I  mean I've used it but I quickly decided to not use it","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCeDj1u5caqt3m617NNNim6A","author":"@BGDMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/CPrDH7WohCn0Fr4E909BmxdMv9YChcJ2-heZZWZxglk1R4KqhzHqYG2sD22LsYl09OVhaze9fg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BGDMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyoA7AvfgkWW1nJOit4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yandex Music saying then you have 478 listeners a month","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCG3UiPWHLO9Cch17OxyT6fg","author":"@Andy-dk58sn4","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/nsok_gUKvknShJsO6eixVMVEzMZN7h6HfUtQJ9cWuX-zDdh_OWUPUzPVjdB_eqb-7V0epuPDjQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Andy-dk58sn4","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyP7Yk7vJNn0pRS4el4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I can tell a difference between mp3 and WAV or Flac when listening on a proper studio monitors especially songs I know well","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCfuuKGEJp0G0gc5YZ_WuBEQ","author":"@BenvelMusic","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KRNLOaBh_S2Pw3pw13k7kbcSQpdHw_iOb4rYsqrZ_2tHrBRFukfsKbZQjAROCLq7azRCi__iHQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BenvelMusic","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyP7Yk7vJNn0pRS4el4AaABAg.AD-Ag-GPdZcAD-FfIdMekT","parent":"UgyP7Yk7vJNn0pRS4el4AaABAg","text":"Hahaha sure","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTCpDK2nQtZF2DA2IpCDsUg","author":"@JustinKoenigSilica","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m1AfHLo39GmoUCRh-2Vzn1XSP_GaNJqvXT4xm2DXMYzhg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JustinKoenigSilica","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzASLgt4cwKF0v1UHp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"yes yes yes","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkwxLPmP2Mg--boDY4cwukg","author":"@yosh-hi6xh","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/iK3QX6Vl2TWK_rlAwxefyLlcqtmDFpvGtCyR0oYv43QXOMKlWaQYDkjkQVAjZjvP2SCWr1LmCQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yosh-hi6xh","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxvlSrkWQbBV8y6OaN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think music business is a dead one","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCLmX7w2ZUTbeyM6XyThduw","author":"@marcduchamp5512","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n0ps4s83k758CTt0KGos-xN_ui-o6Muo809F-Wzl0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@marcduchamp5512","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxt0cEPxRDbWR7HDx94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Its for all of us creatives, be it 2d art, music, graphic design, voices being stolen to make lowest of the low tier youtube video, to make fake news, now they are getting to make videos, ai is a mistake and ai bros are scum","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpyyA27lQOeAjzneZZARs1w","author":"@luheartswarm4573","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lKrqNENvV267dJgdvtDeRpjgO9oc8KdthduK03kzWP3TM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@luheartswarm4573","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugwnn-AsAR5VwWEm7sB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"DEEZER","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpsecBtcCQTOuUMnXXtw-8w","author":"@biyahmusicproductions","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/K5FcpEKsfn9vVYrM1HzFPFsveBCqLYo6cQumVb1ZBP-zIZKDlPoS99Fv5s_UYG9fEwE_NPQnh-U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@biyahmusicproductions","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyXPU7HWNXDl44rFH14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"bro dont put p*rn in the title!!!! algo hates it and you'll get restricted","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCFtr_5wAm1l4ZFCsX5H136Q","author":"@renbelmont","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YTXMJL64BcETBXK7Kay-062V3e7pp1tTQj7T_XfufOthAtOcd1_n707DD1fELsMJqs-phTxi=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@renbelmont","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw-KGr9f7m0FKkap-94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"13:00 why are you adding extra vowels? Lib like \"liberal\" not lieable\"","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2Prp76ZuBTfwYgr-JDqP2A","author":"@ScalieBloke","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/mBt92aTjNIBe-Tj882w6aO7bE_IwJciQEOtM7KzU9iDSIsgupq5qf1kByXRNl31ImWinG4Gi8g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ScalieBloke","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw1RF8g9TbtgPeCGUt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This gave me the push I needed to swap over to Tidal from Spotify, thank you for the data!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCeDIwlWW-e5-cdfxGPUkTpg","author":"@apuppydeer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/H3Ug4OPfHqi4lF2DlTkCMF_6q9K4BdQ9Q11XNmjY5gnyY9roYhoNqmcuRR02qKILNvTWEDSCyec=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@apuppydeer","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaaERQtbBQkQhqKz94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"GOA^TTTTT","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC-t94C47vPG9zHWflWnuLCQ","author":"@1NoDoze","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/UZ_KoFdfzCKg3XStpAEQSkMiZ9QDkOvi1aJRMYAt69d7tSg7U95lz9aH_xOElI_vGyO2-qK6sg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@1NoDoze","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwqAzXv73SwFM4TVCJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"the \"which streaming service pays you the most\" section is presented in a fairly confusing way, mostly because your commentary does not match the visuals by either saying the wrong number or contradicting the graphs. you say the wrong amount of zeros pretty often, to the point that i cant tell if your saying \"all social media is worse than the streaming\" is correct or not. at least to a knucklehead like me. just wanted to let you know.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0utckEPPckAAPXr5GMweKg","author":"@putriddivine","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pUFSnVj2l2BARg8a7aUbB5Y3u0iIGNtmGlxmK1HB7M5HUyY8XPg4B3_2wRPidJjzCSauEIEl3Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@putriddivine","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyefBXlt_w2DjyOJ7R4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Where is the Peloton Affiliate link, then?  Lol. How can they pay more. Isn't it because the pool is smaller and people overpay on their service. If you are a lazy person you will not listen to music on Peloton and probably not yours, unless it is suits  gym activities. \n\nThe problem will always stay the same. \n\nThe pool is big, the money pool is small. The Giant labels get the biggest part. Hosting the sites/bandwith costs.\n\nWhy don'T you create a plattform that pays by demand? \n\nBut the extreme listeners will just download it again. \n\nBut I guess a federated network that is connecting you directly to the musician and gives you money listen is better. \n\nAll your suggestions are just another company, that provides access for fee's. \n\nJust become a Patreon-service for streaming.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBpPvNO6_ZvcO9ILzHPq-iA","author":"@sasa-sv8kd","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/2BnUqQTwRn8ywruLbU_uP8z1iFWnZiyp0MJHQoUA4l3ss6HGuw94FgW2KHVkniCeoO1Qjeg0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@sasa-sv8kd","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy8qqlYU8rq353hVy14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You have a stonewall insurance company that tells all the butthurt people to try and soothe their anuses by stuffing their own complaints up there.\n\nNice.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCJtkiiQYcx378_RCfvpqbhg","author":"@TobiasSample","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kiUkGLc-oJsXUVlqaylCAvsCri8jdxRd9u4io_0gI79KY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TobiasSample","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGzzvlFJufesSRpOV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"https://youtu.be/kp5wvpkf-EA?si=ePjOK8Q5NL6_gW0j\n\n\nIdk I love me some Ai music","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCr-sFsQDllJbKcG9-PKbzHg","author":"@SkullKingZRo","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-dFPheI4z1natLS6GQMwdVrP2Cs2WE3eyMCh98ASVtv8Jj9B_YI9-Ja2eCm91_jUt0WChU11=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SkullKingZRo","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxwV03ztKzVUl6bS4F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"ok so streamers are crap. we all know it, but look at the amount of self-published artists. If not for the streamers, how would they do it?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCSJhcFQlSSfK1ur8UcNbZlQ","author":"@xTerminatorAndy","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mdO2cXzDy9yQGWMX_X8CW7IsKuLAqeo_5l0KK7cWBZ3NQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@xTerminatorAndy","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxwV03ztKzVUl6bS4F4AaABAg.AD-3XrITJpgAD-wv2ZAeqX","parent":"UgxwV03ztKzVUl6bS4F4AaABAg","text":"Direct to consumer...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCueJcs-TBmbjjpbce9gTycg","author":"@chrisscott7092","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ljaE1MDVFSgGqbk3kQ0qAUr35O52OY0PvqVdSeaBHAanIs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@chrisscott7092","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy_8O8hWZ3mQw3G4XF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Honestly the suno crap is so repeatable and generic that if a legitimate creator wrote something like this I don't think they deserve royalties either xD","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC4unQzZhHkblwZQZv9qwD5A","author":"@Sk0lzky","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_bWCXkF_9USdwuWgIXJeaPIfS9sRD0Sx3sSPxYXAGDaqs3QcRXKeCcU4FcOQPvZffDT44NfMkg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sk0lzky","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxKBywHel1zBAjxMUB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"why don’t you start an certification organizations/union for authentic music creators. like a official nintendo seal of quality but for music. a (so to speak) official NinBenndo seal of authenticity. ok, i will see myself out 🤣","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCJ-6TDc2jGPYigNpZx1-D2g","author":"@tan00k1grrrl","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7JMwNg6NVmRKpKQqITo0k_O3srfELaUZnPrVzR3aNDYwYGsMbuSBAcX0FRmeWm72CmOaYcabsKE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tan00k1grrrl","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgywmEFGkvAvzPuTlzx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Spotify is garbage. I canceled last week and I won’t pay a penny to them ever again.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwJur_PMGvyhYy2MjNPjOIQ","author":"@rayrecordings","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/h8abiEHu26CDl5Ob7BRJOB0kYnliWqG44ctYWMBZuC3g_XL-E0NDluKNshEXEw-_7JbTw0-A0Yc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rayrecordings","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzs9v8y5vRgr87WFP54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Excellent! Now I can exclusively listen to AI-generated music instead of the tiresome humans trying to figure out how to become an industry plant.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCaIKZ3OzrBw-kBlKuH-bTeQ","author":"@DeimosSaturn","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_n1p6A-4fsJW5ZehHUzQ_qHHRsAYPMI9vOCEhcAhvxQvS4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DeimosSaturn","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzrRyBBaKjKQ73Dbd54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"19:16 funny","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZgll2glszgUKP0exVhhcnw","author":"@meatstanding","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/-8mLi4O4oEbiIigqXBVtYaRgUjthgNRjr8xoGiJCGr2YdbYjDHdtMU00GqPNA7TZQ3LvnGe_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@meatstanding","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxl4xvrlMywD_tkWhh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Seems very stressed","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLjJGy2adaMWgLAD6SOqXKQ","author":"@BadassRockets","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/zc5p6Hxb8WnankO3Q3-qseuPErevGDa0e7GoRtAnJNazIrxG0MCWtxzVM4PPAg84XgftH7ht=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BadassRockets","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzd3ugrXqGxXc0rBsN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I just buy CDs and use youtube music on my phone when I'm out and about since nobody has ever made a dap as good as the ipod classic which is fucking bullshit that Apple refuses to appease those of us that just want a new one!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNnyzoLH4zFMH1AsQpHM8yg","author":"@GoufinAround_","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7W9XH9OQox8fn6WKMCiUIn3GnDDSReP2O0qZruLgvBkf-ZYkiVbOygFG__8hbZTC60-YT3gVZQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GoufinAround_","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx4xIqLbFSXC-a0yyl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You can use both AI and Traditional!, its a tool, this song is a clear example of the potential\nhttps://youtu.be/SjSv_lqnhLE?si=I7p3VRw_guOqxHvb","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCtJAD2daGtybaod1AjOW3ZA","author":"@TheOrangeBastards","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VodvsX9MwbGhJFbqj-bOD8m8yZDWN5dkv6hlWN-RgV70A8FGLw3VKMGAt0LX4PO6H0QlWfMY8w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheOrangeBastards","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzc3DESYHkb9pN58Kh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Maybe youtube shouldnt pretend to be the copyright agency. and left that job to an elected and accountable legal institution. Dont be mistaken YT dont do it for justice. They are just a club that want fame and money to be keept near them. Forcing their own rules and taking chance from anyother person. As they they pick the content they are editors of what is presented in their webpage and they should be made responsible for the published content what ever it is. This unless they decide to be a communication company that left the policing to the police","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCTU6Nkih35AFoKNmS7XlZTg","author":"@zacman9667","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k66oozHfGkKxLs-srO_rdZHY4p-albELoWvqHUjR-njQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@zacman9667","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx4u5SEuiOGGy_b5Gt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"\"Artists stop posting because of lack of incentive\" … because the only reason people make art is money. 🤦\n\nCapitalism ruins everything. 😒","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC5ZMTbOx5S-yEQdL8PPE29g","author":"@mr_law_johnny_awesome","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1-3jZFERuuJIe68omb8XtjjHkjsvlon5bQD0cgIj9I4QlKmGW9pmgjWj4x-G90i2zOrWAbw1vA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mr_law_johnny_awesome","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwO7-RsNlxHSo84bgl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I create music using AI.  I'd honestly love for it to be on streaming platforms not to make huge money or \"steal\" anything from anyone, just the ability to say \"Alexa, Play (song name) and it will actually play the song(s) I've made.  Also, in some of my songs, I've written the lyrics entirely myself, which creates a \"grey area\" in terms of copyright, the AI made the music but the lyrics are my own.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCZe6ZtsGSsEjXO-y7-IJKig","author":"@videowarehouse","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/yZ5IkNpl7fA0RanwANNy0WLKXTJSfjMYrjY8HIPKXThwZFu3WRzR7WFqGL4KNhk28261gIUlW4c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@videowarehouse","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz7uSeLt6hRjyo_3JZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Distrokid are thieves. Charging me  after trying to cancel sub","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLN14t4Y3BLIpaJ1APFoYSg","author":"@LoveItDirtyOffroad","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ks9M3yiQ9eU8rMssSzws7TjMM1w-xIBx2eRARlvLbxH99qIorKgWcMuQjy1Ax8x_uhCMZt8cdQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LoveItDirtyOffroad","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwLA5LjI8k1-UHC8rJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Heyyy… hate to say .. if someone isn’t listening to your “actual I’m an artist “music is not because someone else in this big world is uploading their “fake “ai music …. Sorry","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCCq1MTDuWPqaUw6Eq5dNM8A","author":"@rachaelb8686","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_llHLcuMyht1zjHAfeAgqhzz0LjxOVk5MLWLQuzy_qt1NQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rachaelb8686","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxWnD_OoSnCjfDuHxB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think the streaming services should flag AI music and allow it but not reward the creator financially. I have played around with Suno and it is impressive but I would never upload any resultant work to Spotify or any streaming service.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCdHk7XcwIEz7ZZHGlkyn3GQ","author":"@justanotherjoe337","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k0BeTvOoIAqq3OcHCwnd9M8iTf-I_wfcpwM0_GQwupi4rI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@justanotherjoe337","is_favorited":true,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyOFZ228KP9pPDvADF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Brojack horseman, the gorrilaz song that made them famous was a preset on a synthesizer. Some of the most famous songs of all time are \"samples.\" Stop acting like this is a new thing. These tools are out and either adapt or get steamrolled.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC_KgAsiLv9mwlwAlgQCR-GQ","author":"@williamforsythe5850","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nftkx0debTCI8LLlVBqscYTY2nrsWcymKJyJrIbkmug2o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@williamforsythe5850","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwcrBrh0xqG_5_sbIZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI has been around since 1990s in the music industry utilised by majority of the famous artists. Autotune is one of the AI and beat makers. Stop crying over just because its available to the public as open source or for cheap. 🤷🏽‍♂️","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC6qgHz9p2NJZacEY51ucsGw","author":"@glitchfyre5188","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k53o3chH4e5Z2zzw7AdvKqfweGaqspbbLk_53sCWngSNfj=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@glitchfyre5188","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzb9k1h3C-Ywfhjomt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm an AI researcher (profession) and musician (hobby). I do not work on generative art of any kind. My research is based on my own curiosity about minds/intelligence, not on applications of AI. \n\nThat being said, I don't fully understand the alarmist perspective that artists have over AI generated content. It's very hard to predict where all of this is going, except that every will be drastically different.\n\nNow, I'm not trying to make money from the music I play for myself and with friends, but there is an analogous situation with programming. AI is generating so much of my code now and it's amazing, I can do SO MUCH more, and eventually I won't even be needed at all. Is that scary? A little yes but it also implies a world that is so radically different that I don't think we can apply our current  expectations about work/value/compensation.\n\nI'm not saying AI is good and we're all going to be ok. I'm just saying who knows, maybe it will help a new generation of artists make things we never thought possible. Or maybe it will just replace all human labor and we'll starve to death. Or something in between, or worse, or just different. \n\nWhy worry twice...","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCuXeaIPjoPW7V5Za4dob_ng","author":"@michaeltraynor5893","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k2e49zsX6YQLxD6C0iSFKmuAg5RbCsTdr4OVqCvkw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaeltraynor5893","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzb9k1h3C-Ywfhjomt4AaABAg.AD-dkwBAy2xAD2MBMfExJw","parent":"Ugzb9k1h3C-Ywfhjomt4AaABAg","text":"👍","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC8_ct8SxKFpMC-BY1ReJ5tw","author":"@Ryanez93","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KCyo_b6XvGLbMaA9h-wrCcBUxq2wCUIieBBwVcwPrR4UOBdY9cp4EFUqCF8FGz-jZIURPvT_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ryanez93","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxc2OQJ7jGeim20L3F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I like that you're a nerd","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCxEue1E9Yes73hXZAu08rZw","author":"@michaellk2254","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lPqgtW0ASf4fobSIu4JKvvLeFhBI9hXAlmMmk0obTcN2E=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaellk2254","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzAcdGbHMIbX0BQUGl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Get rid of the music that would not get recorded, and then talk about streaming income.  Because someone calls themselves an artist, does not mean they are good","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCAOtd5uTb2qeDZPt5CcMT5w","author":"@yesnomaybe1220","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mSi5BW_UR2q8H6RFJy5Nwoke9jMicBTlHyByHhyDaAQggqAB1VERuCiB4qTCrFpbzqCw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@yesnomaybe1220","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago (edited)","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyAliKW741IpQtNZvJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Tidal .","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVM7727A_mHafWpfHV5e1Gw","author":"@charlesanderson1966","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ngxFi2GvUaCdTNq21uHtoN_HgmSODWJnVa2cu4P6OUEQaszFZz7JS5k_vWkDdAdZuWNw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charlesanderson1966","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzVAQyG2oinfCV2HMJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"u bored me a lot dude.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC7pJjeezkzrCfoP2q13NpMA","author":"@dtveron","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/FcByBQdWcI55Y-1GeDF-xRoYsvSRKANGeznXCTRy8btaD-GPGTygwJ2x4REGyZ2qoi1ZM3BGeg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dtveron","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx70LvYuwp4Xv8WiSl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Please have your physician check your liver.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7_6NOx7Kq4WrtV7-aD12Wg","author":"@jemoedrjwz5289","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nQWtDjnkGaIYmOsk65bxLAmt6sDD9KGCnr9j4CzKha7Ht707dqW4PbsI-coFFXsWHIFA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jemoedrjwz5289","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGyVRAvCmxBXbmKwF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Algorithmic bump:\nCall of Duty Fortnite Star Wars MAGA Ariana Grande Taylor Swift Useless Drivel","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCRYPXPc9YBeQGp5Nl1m842w","author":"@jeddfthornton5782","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mbgwSh9miFVJoXcknkhJ9Z7IRRpHjNt0MXdkBijNfM5lY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jeddfthornton5782","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzFaf7_c4nTsV5gQot4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"From the bottom of your WHAT","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCYvg7eUnKiV1fV4xPTkClyw","author":"@denomaly646","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/OtzeT9I3w1CjpgkDWIOOp6bQ3r2h9tPGHM-ddIk2WcIHWihvSXAhbzq9EYHzpwqu56hNJRRP7A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@denomaly646","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugws58fwxwv5jdfIXBZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Beato is doing his own analyses here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QVXfcIb3OKo. I wonder if he's aware of what you built?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaXDamJynq2uRHMOnLzCvQw","author":"@EelcoHillenius","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ldU4pXjmYi7_1DRz8ChcdgsP-u6Fw8PP722chywJuMdhtL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@EelcoHillenius","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzFbQ4zZKxqD72N99d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Subscrimbo’d","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCNNQFpk74QS8Uu1qFlZH3zw","author":"@Drawson6","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Ir5g5bYMs4rd6SgVjPIMfuN2Te_m4ihDwEFFo_UNXS6_akYj1h5an8cxYWvMAEjqBtJl1rxc_g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Drawson6","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwenHZkWN5uyXKW2Pd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Jesus! The world has gone mad. This is horrible. True artists like Abba, Bee Gees, McCartney, Randy Berlin… They all are extinct!!! \nNow it’s all a scam.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjSwx742dYa-4AnOBSaKLtg","author":"@numberones9831","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nUJD7GBMFlqN254Tk3rVBwhiOYPmfkdUgQOhY1SRI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@numberones9831","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxZNREf2nP9HT_gUg94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thanking us from the bottom of your what?...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCg8u2ytL7ub5mgbPce6Jyiw","author":"@vincentlortie3007","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lrexrukPtUslC89z8SvZBoUYbSniAtD6vFGYpeiVc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@vincentlortie3007","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyfmfBeEdaQEpIQEdp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"there is a problem arising now that accusing artists of using ai generative content is being used by platforms to keep streams demonetized even when tracks are genuine , one case was denounced yesterday about sound cloud claiming that one distribution was implied in generative content , the artist asked for ai checks on 2 companies and ther results given were negative (human created content) so isnt this the start of a speculation with the excuse of the ai ? its even your fault dude , a mediocre sound engineer that claims 100% accuracy is already a scam....","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCOCV9uIfu1CZYZFe7uv3bTQ","author":"@scambattler","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l3deyYM-Bn1fEbjPUVXB1Y_CT9FaLnYuFyhmrJHY6Pcs_OQFpdKEOSsmbO-HQP76DP8g=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@scambattler","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzN6-0jwRlHHAxCM0F4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hahaha you are the BEST","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCfTGcUCBXRj4U2SlDMVO6kQ","author":"@panosmalandris","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/r3O4bbxyCyJA_0ST5DN6EgTsBaeBXoZTF5XE9Jx2I78eRYYcRuNfLkAuSG2R6_u1CQYZHLPF=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@panosmalandris","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhmUUPXlHzTGCfBU14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"🍓❤️","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCsfjmgg4heCx0SOn5BL5_1w","author":"@angloland4539","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mCxDdH0wQ_qPRMgLnfNoK_hZyrSxkpCqdNu6V2zKQe=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@angloland4539","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxlyvylNQtZ0kry6dJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"00:30 the answer is it depends because “pay per stream” is a horseshit metric that ignores how streaming dividends are actually divvyed up.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEHIWMhGt39c3GLhCMEaJ4A","author":"@underscore_d.t","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LZQYw-Xnw3Q0Tz-d7LhN59_Bx6PMtaKPDjS_ba1VNLVVFDuEAM3zjqIzZVQIzmDCgenmx3Xy=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@underscore_d.t","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyDKH38BKpgNHjGiQh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i'm slow...  is this where a bunch of the stuff in places like delta airlines' 'Ambient' playlist or 'oddities' like youtube music's many idiotically sorta' named 'Ambient Spa Piano Ambient Gentle Piano Guitar Spa' 'channels'?  \n\nuggh, as i type this & the video plays, my give-the-fuck-up-on-life urge balloons...","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCp-uarV6tq8Bs9tcf5tjXuw","author":"@esaeelljae","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NheM3_8mfg-qJ4dpt3XurBp_6LMz1pakYakWksLBSV-Ib5EhGJUBis2uxy5pGLxdV5IgOPn9qA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@esaeelljae","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgygJpPxaTntpoChZVl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My biggest issue with genAI music is that I don't have an issue. I hope we get lots of great AI generated music","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCNX3MGERqrWO_FC60brgbqA","author":"@bradbradson4543","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mFygwIo7CnpTxY89LCqGBoAbFqX2tyGH7PwL1MlAM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@bradbradson4543","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxIunYtSLPXEHdrjy54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Using ai because you can't tell it's fake. Why. Just enjoy the music","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCaGRiarYmCAcpFn-HR2-M6Q","author":"@ignaciosavi7739","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lAfX57290LWe9qbmsbZyGbd7ok4l3fkuMv0nwU9-s=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ignaciosavi7739","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzE-fm1NBgmoaP4DYF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The truth is, this feels like a witch hunt.\nIt’s pathetic, because Vocaloid and similar tools exist to open up new, boundary-free ways of making music. Sure, those fully AI-generated Suno songs are often ridiculous—but it’s a free world. There’s plenty of musical crap made by humans too, so what?\n\nAnd humans are funny creatures…\nThey still haven’t understood that AI is a tool. A T-O-O-L.\n\nThis whole debate is typical Neanderthal behavior.\n“Oh, let’s hunt the witches…”\nCome on.\n\nSamples have always existed—and honestly, it’s often less creative to just buy a pre-made loop (sometimes a borderline theft) than to jump into an AI platform and ask: “rising synth solo in D minor.”\n\nThis discussion only reveals how underdeveloped humanity still is.\nInstead of joining the witch hunt, use the technological tools available to create art, my dear.\n\nDoesn’t matter if you built an instrumental using electronic tools or recorded your morning farts and turned them into a chorus.\nIt’s all art.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCt7tf7qSlFJ9HyMZg7JHhmw","author":"@Jenn-l7p","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_khSbcYOk-ZJpJdnM0KT63okOiFU3WwtWMvAi-S5gxJah9fOAID9GlTIjWJnSHyDKWk4A=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jenn-l7p","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw307JmFereCz5c7TJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Nice AI generated video. Took me 2 minutes to realise that everything you say is gibberish.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCU-K9EGD_pCN938Tu-fcUJg","author":"@karpai5427","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NZN7qt-854MV5J5E8_W6sKdA_IhUWQYFETtomT9x_CUv4ENbgmYJUSwLaYMNL-c77hvWvDcGjg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@karpai5427","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxPAHEGu06PduYunix4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Artists who against ai need to look in mirror tbh, many edit own songs and fine tune them. Even dub own songs. Unless songs steal lyrics and very similar song tune and title they don’t have case. \nEverything else is not taking anything away from them in fact ai can improve their songs and will exceed performance of humans in future and why should we deny ourselves amazing sounds due to whingers vocalists who want too much control over sounds. \nShall we stop breathing next?.\nRave I can use as an example , it’s beats not vocalists on most .\nVocalists are the only people who artists who can complain , but  tunes that use notes instead, hell no! And should en ever be the case.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC0yDnSzWZlxgJ85MO-1Wzaw","author":"@RJ77M","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oGTD0sqkRPSkZjKbwC57MxUGEqd_hJkMLNkrApHA0O19Y9U-Z_WI4teuZZPBVf3FgPVGnpWz=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RJ77M","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxBn5_L2lk6oY7XDR14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"godlike doode.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCZzrUYVe4QcVtJRALWR2iaQ","author":"@the_audiofiles","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Y6QMyi9vsgZhQux2jP2YG65nAKihvbQ0Tkhq350HZMLZvxulGAW5c8UDE90iA9Y3UL19jj7Z=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@the_audiofiles","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzNEtkCs7hT-Gxn6up4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I will still use AI to get song ideas, because I like it","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCajuupNZnA92H8IwZJZKBkA","author":"@grzesiektg","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mYWcS8mUrDUWDOs9dbgb7EnjG9IlGcPyCpvyRXpx8ptw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@grzesiektg","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzkVcDvBa-ryzEz1lR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"And it’s become very sad that people like this speak in a way they think they should speak on YouTube therefore, lacking total and any sense of originality sad sad sad, unlistenable","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCak-f2iwmGUJTFAU0eKYxCw","author":"@michaelbisceglia9154","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/pg8VcTokKzMdky6vViKM8djPLvxAzBSvyx6gZR_2vQ5elJJJFoV6x4cR1DG2pQFaeTkft5vn0DI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@michaelbisceglia9154","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzAHo2G2yFGyN21OFZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Why do you dye a part of your eyebrow white to try and look cool?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaKLIpN9Ssrewn6TYfU1u8Q","author":"@tickbaby","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lak_jg5JRfk1d7kEfL2jrE-02EEFrOp4RpRI2oCd7hskn2=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@tickbaby","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwfzxNPHWF4_ik1SNN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"We've come a long way since Viper - You'll cowards don't even smoke crack","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC89F0i4Tvbo0pW0TrVTTBmg","author":"@devjock","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nvRgkQEe1mpRs6-RNxhjI-iqHFYnZeI8OEfNFYKMSXItk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@devjock","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx34jP62DJzJur9X1h4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"holy shi*","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCaHsTOCEqMIDJhnBlNzSimA","author":"@YUNØ-9","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/3RpGSQcp9LSnuRG5FvOi-q25T_gNNl6LwxO9Lmfz30SZ9x4aWwpYtbkO_Vua5HaeDBz0Ukbesg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@YUN%C3%98-9","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwCpK_g14uHaSTm81N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The bottom of your what now?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCMHGmtavipprNlrno0YKUgQ","author":"@JaCrispy360","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/d98oN7Whd2otht2EmphNrF1aUXMiJ9LJ3mtcyqPkCrsPcmBLsHkzV7OUGx_Os_SQY_nqLuH1Ig=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@JaCrispy360","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxqQ0G3Vp5mOKIPkIF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Synthetic \"Garbage\" Intelligence 😏👎🙄 #artificialintelligencesucks","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCnpku4YkibWYvq85YNEHPYw","author":"@massapower","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lGD4alVhALOtjFtz_jZ9cD7mg7xDVfCkbXjJonTavMUWQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@massapower","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPxkEqmEDw4_VHaAR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is why I keep screaming that AI and AI research HAS to be stopped! Even with war from nations if necessary! People are not evaluating the true risks of AI and exactly how bad it's going to get for humanity VERY soon! These are just the annoying starting growing pains. Soon they won't be stealing your music, they're going to be stealing your life!","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCZiluVlg8mUIMIvVvxM9kCg","author":"@ShootingUtah","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k_H81ePjN8RyBoIep-b32oQ_brjrW79w14WeV4_eFFUQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ShootingUtah","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzPxkEqmEDw4_VHaAR4AaABAg.AD-pJQaO5cpAD2LmvY301X","parent":"UgzPxkEqmEDw4_VHaAR4AaABAg","text":"They..?","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC8_ct8SxKFpMC-BY1ReJ5tw","author":"@Ryanez93","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KCyo_b6XvGLbMaA9h-wrCcBUxq2wCUIieBBwVcwPrR4UOBdY9cp4EFUqCF8FGz-jZIURPvT_=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ryanez93","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyRkREEfKwrrqLsYfp4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Thanking us from the bottom of your what now?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCoW8ORdoLRUYpi7Ls3FRriA","author":"@nathano2778","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mAHUHwUrKo7YVI-qHlJgohijRtiWOoPcRnbsPBcBc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nathano2778","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyjHk1yMVt5712bClZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm going to solve this music problem soon. Watch. Billionaires are going to stop harassing artists. Data \"AI\"  companies are going to stop stealing.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCLHNDkbpi7CNJy2K7NyKY7Q","author":"@Jay-v3r2i","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/XjVluoas1wavVxhN8Y_RWgweoO17KQwRpW2N0TIrBRtAPxrXOT_VnEGmGRpz83HpVu1OEPlaKQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Jay-v3r2i","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzgoFSuv88L4_sFvNN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You sir are outta your mind or your ears are toast. Anything lower than 320kbs sounds like trash in the highs. Even 320 has a slight duller sound than original…","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLN14t4Y3BLIpaJ1APFoYSg","author":"@LoveItDirtyOffroad","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ks9M3yiQ9eU8rMssSzws7TjMM1w-xIBx2eRARlvLbxH99qIorKgWcMuQjy1Ax8x_uhCMZt8cdQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@LoveItDirtyOffroad","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwXM3WA9KtsSBDcLxR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"People who complain about AI music usually just don’t get it. They talk like experts but barely understand how AI even works. It’s not about protecting creativity; it’s about clinging to their own irrelevance. They’re not threatened by AI because it’s unoriginal. They’re threatened because it’s doing things they never could.\n\nAnd “AI music detection” is a joke. If your grand contribution to music is sniffing out whether a track was made by a human or not, congratulations. You’ve become the hall monitor of irrelevance.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC8l2L_rnMmjd2qiGQ544Efg","author":"@Tekniq182","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_ki7N6gl3SUDFCwJly4XPy18rodyzkemY_kdPnrY6p1OIo=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Tekniq182","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxZ3DqETE8zYNIGgDl4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Honestly recorded tracks shouldn't make a musician rich... Only live music should","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCm1Yv5JqjU8aD1T016P63GA","author":"@dante7228","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lNi8T4s3IwHBlH1J8s5pQZIiO3m7l9ARHN2fjXbw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@dante7228","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyFihY6epMpqvFJwk94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"This is bogus because it has been proven that AI can't reliably detect AI generated content. In fact, there is no way to tell whether any content was AI generated unless there are telltale artifacts in the result, like messed up details in images or videos, all of which can be fixed with a bit of manual polishing. In fact, AI is a lot worse at telling the difference between AI and humans than humans, and it doesn't look as if it will get any better. All the people who are selling AI as a way to tell AI creations from human creations are just trying another way of making money from AI. \nLately I have been accused of being an LLM on social media by several people. I can assure you that I am a real human being, but why should you believe me? I mean, if it matters to you, you can cyberstalk me and see for yourself that I am an actual almost 50 year old human being who has left a big fat data trace on the Internet over the past 28 years. \nGenerative AI still generates a lot of sheer bullshit and weirdness. I actually like the bullshit and weirdness, I use it to make my own anti-art, or rather, elektrodada. Then again, humans are often weird, and human generated texts contain a lot of bullshit. People like me who aren't neurotypical, people with autism and/or ADHD or other neurological anomalies, often talk and act in ways that make \"normal\" (neurotypical) people see us as less than human. Texts written by neurodiverse humans are often flagged as \"AI generated content\" by AI that claims to be able to tell humans from AI.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCs0C5xyobbE3GASCMC9_A-w","author":"@elfboi523","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mxx_rg9E7dP0Aze1Ky1tpJK717B4WmOiFKVCDq-kw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@elfboi523","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzK9Lg63q2fmM4opUd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"are you salty much?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC19P9TcTpO4ideYHbUQgrOQ","author":"@BustaNut-k2z","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l-sTb0TDAUjJSzXF0YMIxm-GPOSJ-JBJhTfq0RFjZ6wBnYWdvZDSMmBi5u9Ay9p1Dp1Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BustaNut-k2z","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxjsWctPGwtNL2P5mN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love the fact you ruined them lmao by posting their “creations”","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCdFkjdIB6C1SFOwqlsRWDow","author":"@andrewsingleplayer9513","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/0Gj9dpeJZSUSIvUZoqMMP85O-kwCdb-9I41n7WexFiJYUR7GaGi-cYGALGRuNbeFP-FIXVYigg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andrewsingleplayer9513","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxmfcywBxDoLqdHHSZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCe1NPLX60Nf8ZzT-vRPCgWw","author":"@stellartoad","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qgJ2Sfz94zTfNmWAC8v9eESCkJdWdjqVVGVSBuGODVz6G-vdISLd0dT9Dltx8ZY-g3UJfuLERn0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stellartoad","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw7ZjdTpsdjS_PV0ap4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"As someone who has multiple profitable AI artists on all streaming services, yoy can hate on me all you want but youd be better off whinging to my listeners who make it profitable 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC1O1mdKrW3IBmgY-RglLHWg","author":"@Abvro","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4ANaXXthWb3HyrFK-LP7QQ2vKHsFCTIAjzzHWMrtTfwQlBfs8hVnmZqVax5iPHpX8BBFF-37=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Abvro","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfkSG6wW6OXreS4uN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The tide is turning. Those who reject everything outright are often the ones who haven't yet grasped that AI doesn't replace the soul; it amplifies it when you know how to guide it.\r\nThe haters who cry \"fraud\" are often the same ones who use Auto-Tune, iZotope plugins, or samples without a word of protest. It's technological hypocrisy.\nThe worst are those who use AI to detect AI; they feed off the rejection of others for their own gain. You don't do this out of passion or conviction; you do it because there's money to be made off the backs of others. You are vultures of the worst kind. In a few years, we'll be dancing on your graves. You disgust me.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCce4r5LZZmDQabHdeb-90Yg","author":"@RionaSL","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k5KCgjkBCzTXn93YqXa2EziGOSqxYMrPy7nOW42SmAkg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RionaSL","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzi9fftwz-lCoHkS8J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I cancelled my Spotify a while back in large part because of your videos. Also haven't uploaded anything new on there. Thanks for doing the research and spreading the info.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCk60pJ38x1p9OuTDjAwhi6A","author":"@Obscurity202","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nDZoCq6jAren7UsLV6pDo-RMDTeDXjxhNpTIxlH6o=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Obscurity202","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxrz2Psc4wKol6QcyZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Good music is good music i simply do not care! Most of the time listening to adult swim bumps from a decade ago.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCPesrIr5jjAbnr0f6hEMdjw","author":"@done1338","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/5tjB1vgYOKbYFi9nJ7or4j8Tn7QZsy3x33HSKGbcHexq9SnVUTXvqcueuFaDZNGzfNwk8tqKuw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@done1338","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzqKOPGfS7o9uRw63x4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"why the penus ahah i guess nobody gets that far\nnoice","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEQcKykBzXTkxHMsDLoImcA","author":"@thecognacsipper","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nV5Ak0p5i8yiSukaH5dkVajV4LLu5ItrpL5W6NilUxJQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thecognacsipper","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxnXc19Sj9mdnW4qUd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"First make sampling illegal, then we'll talk","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCSD-FYChH1AdFV00Qno1MkQ","author":"@Humble_Merchant","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Xx_ynY_1ndMGIiarzzAyO0-5j-6LGxuucmbS_wK4wDDkVZMlkkYAoUCn9VzlWWNk_HgB0AxEtYM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Humble_Merchant","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyEh6f6TO_07XQ_DvR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"i just upload my music to spotify and what not so people that want to listen can do so on whatever platform they like using. i'm pretty sure i pay significantly more to have it there than i get back from it, which is upsetting. but whatever. shame that significant portions of that money is going to AI crap instead, which is adding insult to injury.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCMzco7HSvcQCngi7IEKfR-A","author":"@combatplayer","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lqH2v_UBP2xIga1t2prs-Wdhyp0XFbMbUqb0yKeLdnyA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@combatplayer","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxGZWS8mE0uhbJxXBd4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I dont get people who make \"serious\" music with AI. The single biggest upside with AI \"singers\" is that they will sing ANYTHING, so I just create funny songs insulting my friends mothers for example. If i wanna make a serious song im picking up my guitar and opening FL studio. but typing in some insults and getting a full song that you can send is just HILARIOUS xD","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCHzYQ5Aw2iOksp1y3T4aTPQ","author":"@XDFreakLP","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/q6CmuSthbGFIGFRU2p7HH_18vo5TSj5XlfrfSHh9l-398sCqNRjFT79bvQgivVeAKa4I-2KH=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@XDFreakLP","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2-DgmNjSrPjidntt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"LOL, AI utilization in art is such a powerful tool when it’s used as a collaborator rather than a replacement. It’s funny how quickly some artists have handed over the creative reins to AI while hiding its presence. Used transparently, AI offers an extra perspective, helping to push past creative blocks or bring fresh ideas to the table. The best results often come when humans and AI work together, each contributing something unique to the process.\r\nThe balance is key. AI can amplify creativity without overshadowing the human element. Hopefully, more people will come to see how collaboration like this can elevate art without diminishing its soul.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCBvmagdPDLZA_YNghGmD0Eg","author":"@Sfork","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/bK-JCfc4B2CM7y-9nNIQTz1VBQGWG3oLOktVzeytvLAUxl-tN_by44tRI64X9tfR9zuHEiYtMZI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Sfork","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2-DgmNjSrPjidntt4AaABAg.AD7aEC4kS38ADD2_hSDSBB","parent":"Ugz2-DgmNjSrPjidntt4AaABAg","text":"Makes sense why your music sounds so awful when you’re saying goofy shit like this","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCiMbNHrSnd-qlUmE3QWE_VQ","author":"@PRLCKLY","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vMGtRhncG5xM3n6RHkhnnT0mtqjiENGPj_2MZhmhEs70DtkfTHsYK89G-qgZ5mFE2xSwZWRL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PRLCKLY","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz2-DgmNjSrPjidntt4AaABAg.AD7aEC4kS38ADAQSLwuwhC","parent":"Ugz2-DgmNjSrPjidntt4AaABAg","text":"Ai should have no real part in ones music. The songs they generate makes the genre of the original song different. In regards to creativity, learn music theory before releasing a song, then letting a robot help you","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCSBtQno8-aP5crBw4Kgp4-g","author":"@D3sidero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VUPWwOFUTDBw1bnmApsfw0Ofha2GGAFTu_ouQDFd6rOfJFh_b2DKcnnFbKbLOFxTSc-VyYqL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@D3sidero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwG7cVEqAO6JRhrwud4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Heelll yeahhh","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCUOBj0tXeeWx7FUavudjdgA","author":"@oskarsvito","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_manoxpnfgviJwXek0qOPVEGTK1kg-Pi7f0fKXOwtuPcAWt=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@oskarsvito","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"8 months ago","timestamp":1769990400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwtJ-vrGqqiUjUv6pZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Twitch just checks for music level - levels then blocks it.  All my original songs get blocked even zero days... and I'm strumming real instruments.  Most of the music copyright detection is just a decibel average that assumes your a POS who can't play music.  It's a Schmidtian exception for them but not us.  If you ain't paid dues to an algo; you don't get to play on their platforms.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC26o5WCiPqwxvpoah9kmgiQ","author":"@d74g0n","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_krigGeAknXBtMvGTiiLE2s25Ekd_sH2zKXGaDN3Q-P1AQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@d74g0n","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"4 months ago","timestamp":1780358400,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwkeR6uzG2N-_9vER14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I'm currently listening to triphop mix and it's described as AI generated music and lyrics....and I'm thinking....\"No way this is AI!\" Scary to think that a music track moves your soul so much and relate to the lyrics so deeply only to fond out it's created by a robot? I don't know what to feel anymore.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCeB70dM48RnnaqmAEpyHNiA","author":"@nilobeebee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/7kVMzVyFMOEJdF1D9mwv4gYxi0s2r_BG_V9o5f0DD000ctW6fb_GGDR0e4ZQ61TbKwg8EmkO=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nilobeebee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"11 months ago","timestamp":1762041600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTf7oOK83vF5VZmIx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"5:43 Actually the fact that the majority of people selected the 128kbps MP3 as their preferred option suggests that they can tell the difference, and they preferred it. Probably a bias from the resolution of the music they listened to growing up.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCn2yCb9ZYBsT3yUgK54vDAA","author":"@DanChristos","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lfb2MxYyVSwN-E2SM01wLkxXfNn4vNQqa-fqOuhcD-inw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DanChristos","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyJ6pnjmS8A7BrakkJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"oh nooo musicians have to perform live, oh noooo they cant make millions with stupid tracks now oooh how saaad. someone please help the poor musicians oooh.","like_count":2,"author_id":"UC5XdOAKD3Pg3v-SJ7IJWPBA","author":"@TheHeretiCan","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/p2pM851NX4XWoBPCEVtiKXQZc0bjYQOPTQVQHzpE-H-nTmn7gIJ3amsUBWG0xA4--NjRWF_c=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheHeretiCan","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyJ6pnjmS8A7BrakkJ4AaABAg.AD-yWUx_sLKAD0jFYh9V-F","parent":"UgyJ6pnjmS8A7BrakkJ4AaABAg","text":"99% of musicians don't make money","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC8KaV4HpGOZfWmg3MwPVOdA","author":"@stoogel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/C0SP7cxJiO-IyVr_darBJ7QbqP5-Mul56omrrtYduIRkfGRWgkGuqY6XGludNOP3UI-fouaLpMk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@stoogel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgycvPbWFZVzPsjoW3d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"The internet has made AI come to stay in every industry...LOL....wat we gonna do....AI have made tins so easy ........","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCqTUeiD8bs9xzvG7PZib42w","author":"@TheSunnySlimEffect","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/4I6iqcsbi6Bh_PmOxevLP_9L0iNt_7ZAPC-jKfYDaSVHxa_Mo4nS57bViNxR_CJO_YibYwDK=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheSunnySlimEffect","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzGqxmQbHJsYRo171t4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Pushing AI because of your own laziness is disgusting Benn","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCWhJ32IbQfaWXryQ0Gd4P0g","author":"@russia4biden221","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nhoOi8Lhcr7w0l0Ur6N0ern1n6gqe49p8sDZDsXjKezsAllwS3frRAi1p45L_qVDrCfQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@russia4biden221","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxKJNFXZjyD0t_zTyt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI is unethical. Full stop. Real artists and musicians are saying it, but so are AI prompters. Not with their words, but their actions. You don’t HIDE ethical behavior. AI “artists” ALWAYS hide their use of AI, because they KNOW it’s bad. They are not proud of it, they don’t want anyone to know. They are ASHAMED of AI.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCw8rA4DStxE4zfFz0Ri4PNQ","author":"@Mike_2501","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/rIN0qs7NmllNMJFlos7pvOor7RAbXlMdRNUAUe87xxpQSE0clJl3rO1w_YwfSlIFHuWrN9Cxa7U=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Mike_2501","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyblseBHLJVi7l-cfV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Music created by any means either human or AI still requires someone to like it. Who is anyone to dictate to someone what they should and shouldn't like ? \n\nIf your're a legitimate musician you should be creating 100X faster than someone asking AI to create a song about their pet. : )\n\nThe average individual using AI doesn't know much about song structure, music theory and other technical aspects that give musicians an advantage using AI. \n\nDon't lie to yourself because everyone knows real musicians are using it too. They get away with it because many are already established so they aren't scrutinize the same way.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCN3JK8T_wBxli_un-lGjEGA","author":"@mediastreamview9528","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/YAteCygT_FTVy5oUHiGmrOh62MafomUjQOoEd52pTF2zN97WIbnnf4fjJmQ09FALdLETmTEylA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@mediastreamview9528","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyCjIZYWlCy6jsMF214AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"My biggest issue with ai music is that it sucks. If it was good, i would 100% support it and enjoy it.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC8S5QZeDi1qE2durE5MnpLw","author":"@lamBOwheel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/oZgFRpNfYX9dzxIQ1L9uwaCOZUScaIsb-93awKok1esnO0R0_PfbPj3LhbfhGtq9dYk1GrVLZQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lamBOwheel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfjQ-KQXvuLajsrap4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"People who say ai music isnt real music don’t realize generating good ai music is very complex. You delve deep into meta tags, layering, lyrics creation, song composition etc. it gets so complex to the point where its considered music producing then being an “artist”. Music production is legitimate","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCx-vqpG2iGhHu0WkOd7h19g","author":"@BryanTaven","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/G9KQK2XSUS3FnlUXHYsFDjQhxkVX1i6DeWA69EdPUBF5lvA4z7ZoFOwq4BexXnMDdgwZz52HPqk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BryanTaven","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzfjQ-KQXvuLajsrap4AaABAg.ADHr1v1xXM3ADIVusM3R36","parent":"UgzfjQ-KQXvuLajsrap4AaABAg","text":"Shitslop music","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCDd53YCVdba2tK-jpOSY6Sw","author":"@Alumii","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Dw5WlucOLBdBjvdqNX0Kp9dsC5-sS_mdTURCoBNBnQe_hP1RRIHHpWtyg8KkRxu80hC0a6ERbQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Alumii","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz5xLjkl5L6zp1XbJV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If you think using Suno to make music is a matter of entering a prompt and outputting gold you're a fool. You've completely overlooked the fact that it can be used to upload originally recorded demo tracks and then be used to remix, add vocals to, and remaster them. And it takes a LONG time and a lot of trial and error to get it to produce what you can hear in your head.\n\nIt's not just a matter of enter a prompt, press a button, get a hit single. And if you think that you've either never used it, are being disingenuous, or an idiot.\n\nAnd in the same video you confess to using sample loops. Literal recordings of other artists, as opposed to new audio inspired by AI learning from what has gone before. What a hypocrite.\n\nThis is the same kind of luddite attitude exhibited with \"home taping is killing music\" or \"VSTs will never replace hardware.\"\n\nSHOW ME the musician who has never learned from the copyrighted work of another and I'll show you a liar.\n\nAI isn't Skynet. It's a tool. Barely different from a Photoshop filter. Suck it up. It's not going anywhere. Either get with the program or get left behind.\n\nAnd I DON'T appreciate you deleting my previous comment because I happened to politely disagree with you, by the way.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwpkeY4tAgBumIHZB1Pu1XQ","author":"@filtomsun","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/TJzYIepQ8aoOMxw7nGIt9DIa3_uk1u1OfEvqKANZqjG9QaZ0_EVv5ODas_zjgnnpstnyYTqiYg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@filtomsun","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz5xLjkl5L6zp1XbJV4AaABAg.AFnHbxCUQ_dAFnWLZeWwtm","parent":"Ugz5xLjkl5L6zp1XbJV4AaABAg","text":"agree with you it takes time and patience to produce that as well","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCgXKi93XU-93h3Eo9fKvCAg","author":"@Vortex_Gamer23","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/cMjNlDhqXslf5g766ldTi5EjG-HhnjJrn4aNDrxw0O83T2JlEz9KjyIdqarxQ0mskhrurL0WtA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Vortex_Gamer23","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgymcDJVfyAsl-_6fad4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Btw, Spotify is always looking for new ways of blocking people from using pirated versions of their apps, but don't put the same effort into compensating the artists in their platform. Not only they are a company that is greedy and predatory, but also they hate the poor people with all their strength, and for this i support piracy more than anything.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCENuNFWJ_QJzbqNMuTCMwjA","author":"@Cybergeists","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/I9QTiAnFZZrLZVjGIvgvof44ndCBkqTyp7RIaleeYGRhhvwxlf_vi8zkhcN8q6M7quQv1mxj0xY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Cybergeists","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwTVro9m2XafwWiR214AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"no one cares.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpOhvgyNMbi5nphGhL6ktlg","author":"@MoraesMusician","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/z36m-SnrIN_MwF5EDwlqhISTk7AzA4U8oXa9uwGK_2bB2LZDKMDQIpD39J-2jQgCzMfAn8zfAA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MoraesMusician","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwTVro9m2XafwWiR214AaABAg.ADCyfGJ6qGtADD0ClCeUrc","parent":"UgwTVro9m2XafwWiR214AaABAg","text":"🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCiMbNHrSnd-qlUmE3QWE_VQ","author":"@PRLCKLY","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vMGtRhncG5xM3n6RHkhnnT0mtqjiENGPj_2MZhmhEs70DtkfTHsYK89G-qgZ5mFE2xSwZWRL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PRLCKLY","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgylNJKOJ3FrlW_7fSN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Music is music you either like it or not. Most music ismt even written by the artist and the final song is totally computer edited to sound completely different from raw stock recording.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC35fDq-Ya5DjWCe1SIKwJMg","author":"@BMetal75","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Q518YNtknHJGIiNy-TBQR281h9Xd71AZM8ekojjzTWDqkftZ_lbf70dUlN2IZ0PfM-8cXZGcMg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BMetal75","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwZQX6_V7fUhadZgHx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ben im actually curious what you think about people like me: songwriters who are not talented players using these ai generators to craft the songs i have in my head and then place them on these platforms. Music and lyrics all mine, but i essentially hired very cheap robot session players to do the recorded performance.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCEaoAvk3ChAVfL4RfAMRTfQ","author":"@caulds989","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nEeRnlGCKtLqMdMbPC87mJ5iyxCsUfSR8w56F54bP-pso=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@caulds989","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxMOaxDpNBrX_s0IjB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Somehow, you bored my socks off. \nGood job!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCmkRTGWEhTLxNXRz_fj6wKA","author":"@wolcek","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lZ6rawVJ4WpzQAYwkK0CHjmKWIbGte9A9IcvjSpN6qfg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@wolcek","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzN9kRjrUqJoJ7nvs54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yes I can agree, you can pay for Digital Audio Workstation, you can also pay for ready presets, packs. But Not for entire song.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyKnQtlNKnda-GohYreAISw","author":"@SkillShaperLeague","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Nw2-jpdkfbkwG597TfPV0gnG2HbUys4Q5C_CAOENYI99nr0gaD5b3RpI3a2ndxwypKJ4etqdBA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@SkillShaperLeague","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugyn442t_gIx8tCzUkV4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Love that AI music is coming out. Sounds so much better than humans . Have my own big AI playlist that sounds incredibly ❤","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2O86W53o_NrBtPEuDyIcsg","author":"@lasse3412","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/nN4EhIQXtQ699Osl7SqUOigfkx_hC2DFCpKZg7SqYb1zJ-6cXkCDYDL_WpjwpZjF7wkbaCU9hdM=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@lasse3412","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyGRC_AtfXEfU-5S8V4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Music is Music - its like saying playing the digeridoo is music but if you go to a recording studio and have it \"altered\" and tuned its fake :) nah man ai music is not going away some \"ai\" music is fire and some is brain rot slop just like old-school artists, times are changing and its becoming quicker and more cost effective for average people to express there inner ideas much quicker now, Suno is great and if you want free Sunato also nano banana for image editing is great saves me hours and still lets me express my inner ideas. if the music is good SWEET if its slop move on case closed if the wind blowing through the trees makes music its still music bro you've been on a pissy a.i. rant for a hot minute we get it the old heads are pissed but eventually youl all get old and disappear lol and all the gen z will be ai trillionaires","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCxhFfQGdK-bLQbtYiqsCp0w","author":"@MadLabZ","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/NClXil99-MTfip6esZdefqlYBIKNudyJN9ZjNhlZsw2GrHZEuaVP_jt19CZy8PumRuD3nbygmw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@MadLabZ","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"6 months ago","timestamp":1775088000,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxbWg-FKTFtba3ZL294AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"hahaha! thats fing  pathetic!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCkY9GfND8xU1h8NsgImU3Yw","author":"@Keepler22b","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_m7OG7Hwl183PUIB0IKRWlCsUGRYsWOF0dplK9mNJ4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Keepler22b","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxx_JTnXCOSDBlk0zR4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Today we are us AI to detect music created by AI then altered by another AI. We use this data to train another AI to hide from the first AI.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCakPlsy8XZS4n_wsrUM1qyQ","author":"@DownloadeousMaximus","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nKqY0ov7AxbEguSsZtYon11-yvjXFo73tbqNBxLBqicW0=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@DownloadeousMaximus","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugx9JD7GbIF8Pwzny-d4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I think if you're competing with AI you are not good enough. I guess the one hope we can have is that AI flooding the market with generic derivative art will force us humans to express ourselves in more interesting, novel and innovative ways to seperate ourselves from the slop. It is just sad people will probably never be able to get compensated for good music/art in a way we used to but that has been going on long before AI. Massive respect for what you have done though, have no respect for people using these AIgens to make easy money because they have no talent.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCswm4EkaIrmgAiAKtvAvDCQ","author":"@buoyanProjects","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mmahaMJN_M3HVhc7WOMvBJwhW7kv5jtRrPn3_4xZc9gEk=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@buoyanProjects","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyUMwdYEqBuWs9xkmN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Garbage AI music incoming flood to Peleton in 3....2....1....","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC3YeylyNyJan9JF2CVOMqNg","author":"@scott21113","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nsruIRqfcMl9AJ9-GSu57RXPwcczl_xOWyzT96qnaApNQ-M3s6Upf5zZJKrA0rVul9Zw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@scott21113","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxfb07X9fqqOgjB8iN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Ai is about to kick the door in on the music industry! Hear how good it is getting here: https://youtu.be/viAIPqIwGcI?si=HZr2OJs7cpKlywIg","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCwHlZZ0L2lyjhstcM7EkILw","author":"@BGtvLab","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/rOX4s0C4yXneIrsypk9EgDi_mjm_7YWl-ebCcklmeYfiKE9CQKXt9isNOU-mu2gGnMWHZ1NI=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BGtvLab","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzBUvpI0QTP6Ag4pSJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Unpopular opinion, but streaming platforms like Spotify solved a massive problem, piracy. Back in the early 2000s, illegal downloads were at like 20 to 30 billion songs a year. Most people (myself included) weren’t buying CDs or tracks, literally never paid for music in my life until I got Spotify. Torrenting was free but annoying. Streaming made legal music easy and cheap enough to be worth it. Obviously, artists deserve more. But the reality is Spotify’s business model focuses on growth and revenue, like any company. If they raised prices to pay artists fairly, plenty of users would bail. We’re already seeing this with video streaming, price hikes are driving people back to pirating videos. The same would happen with music. There’s no fix here. A service that pays artists more would either charge users way more (and lose subscribers) or go broke. Let’s be honest, most people aren’t willing to pay $20/month for music, especially when piracy’s still lurking as a free alternative. Streaming saved the industry from collapse, but it created a new problem of tiny payouts for artists.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC77fV8AyWvTrSpcEzt0bIMw","author":"@joshs.6155","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nZLnqeEe1pyAUzzy-ggG4S4WC9WnaCi-GQ0-8EeZ8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@joshs.6155","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynNlfLWrJkx5a04o54AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I wish you would qualify what you define as ai music.  Because you mentioned suno ai. That is not only being used to fully generate songs . Sma to of artist like myself will record and use suno to master  and sometimes add elements i don't have the money or backing to do otherwise.  Theas tools are allowing independent artist to without a producer and label put out music higher quality than ever.  Labeling Ai music as lazy cheep or fake is just not seeing the people who use it as the tool that it is. Really the convention that should be had is it's here let's teach how to use it and retain the ethical and quality art that had been the hallmark of good entertainment.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXGolfFvDmczjb2cJSaPzhg","author":"@thomandashkaycraig3533","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kmuqzvWI0-SwDGY7xBTXZm1yvpUxVfIt98iHf_1pkqJuXY=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@thomandashkaycraig3533","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyqCrsOY-eN7LKNLTB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Your information on pay per stream is extremely wrong","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCgb0PunNAHYTRvvrsn2CWyg","author":"@simpsonsmafia","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/MqsmzbeLB4uRy3nFqJ3Qnpm8YA5-B3tU8oQTxzZ8sSSDmIESL2CjJy5mOMLG612z8iSXnOGEAw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@simpsonsmafia","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwaXZ7GCEQKXc1q9RN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"what the f is your editor is doing with the zoom. just stop it, i really wanted to watch the video but this is an instant block for me.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCpV429eBO0k-zVKQH7EI0NQ","author":"@RobBot34","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/KnWlKudllAvLbgAfJQtrqS__e0rZVgh3yBFVjcZ6LawrVNRFeGmBNTND-cjSHwE6EpJkHqHUdLs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@RobBot34","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwV-RP2I6Rgbw2cIPJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I hope you get arrested for this. Technological terrorism is going to be a crime.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7nohoCLS8xNG0BrwRjJINQ","author":"@GODCONVOYPRIME","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3HGsGgAOdJYAouQOXeiCGTxZa5Jvcca9hwjRjBw0SKk8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GODCONVOYPRIME","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyoZkBAmj_FHoSazYF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Music is music Brother it doesn’t matter how it’s created as long as it’s created! Don’t discriminate against music that has been generated by artificial intelligence. It would not exist impossible to exist without human intervention so don’t tell me that the computer made it and that we’re stealing it and using it to make money. No different than playing in the instrument and making money off of that. Music is music grow up and get real! I happen to be severely disabled and can’t play any instruments. So I gave all my ideas to the computer and it does it for me. People like you disgust me because you’re a discriminator and you need to seriously rethink your attitude","like_count":1,"author_id":"UC7YUQhTgaR1ut8YB8svIbrQ","author":"@spaceminers","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lJbXargVKZaXqMNXdTS1bsnIQGavfb9-n70S8rIHT--w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@spaceminers","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw3N5zXkV3L0xGfD_94AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"But here is the truth. Who cares. No one should care. If you like the music you like the music. If you don’t, don’t listen to it. Pretty simple","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCDhqBrtXverBhGJVP7iRAcg","author":"@garrettl8247","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_lZiaBcakvQF-MAXrMt1LXvR-s_JIOfaWtumu2WpDMfrbg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@garrettl8247","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw3N5zXkV3L0xGfD_94AaABAg.AD7MBgUnJogADAQYIw2Eeo","parent":"Ugw3N5zXkV3L0xGfD_94AaABAg","text":"That's true, but I haven't seen one good ai song. They can't even use eq right lol","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCSBtQno8-aP5crBw4Kgp4-g","author":"@D3sidero","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/VUPWwOFUTDBw1bnmApsfw0Ofha2GGAFTu_ouQDFd6rOfJFh_b2DKcnnFbKbLOFxTSc-VyYqL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@D3sidero","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgybifH3MwQphpWDhLh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If an AI SONG takes royalties from a studio artist then that studio song must not be that good in the first place. What is the difference between a number 1 artist being better than some other artist. Do they complain the number 1 artistis syphening royalties from them??????? Makes no sence....","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC35fDq-Ya5DjWCe1SIKwJMg","author":"@BMetal75","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/Q518YNtknHJGIiNy-TBQR281h9Xd71AZM8ekojjzTWDqkftZ_lbf70dUlN2IZ0PfM-8cXZGcMg=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@BMetal75","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy0RwQCxj0vm3lshox4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I love how a \"real artist\" and \"real musician\" goes right into money. You are a trained musician, you can call yourself a artist, literally ANYONE CAN BE BOTH but the people who have bought into the music industry BS, sorry but your club of cool kids is over. It is people like you and your industry that has stagnated and killed many peoples love of music. I have listen to more music created by real people, many of which were professional musicians and song writers without bands to play and create with, more in the last few month than I have in my entire life. Real people, writing real music from the heart in my genre. I'm not interested in what you, as a \"real artist\" has to say, your bland, mass appeal, photoshopped, auto tuned, copy the trends drivel that has clogged the airways for 30+ years. I have no tears for the Blockbuster employees when the home rental industry blew up than I do for the lame, clicky, pedo filled music industry. If you make a living as a professional musician, you might want to retrain. Digital was always better than LP and the \"real artists\" like this money chasing \"real musician\" are going to be left by the wayside of history just like vinyl. The music industry is just gatekeepers and we are all going to side step them as they die just like the mainstream propaganda.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCvTo30KGPlEr6DL5tA1wb9A","author":"@nobodyhere4667","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/OvD5SrIQ-Un9zFAZTUMCXZX3ve74_xFxKofGTVbalHj9GCJrC35_6IMnFHkwKbKGzYE1hsBoiw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@nobodyhere4667","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgyBvT6phuTMTw7KluF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"So you're just pulling the ladder out from under you.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC7nohoCLS8xNG0BrwRjJINQ","author":"@GODCONVOYPRIME","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_k3HGsGgAOdJYAouQOXeiCGTxZa5Jvcca9hwjRjBw0SKk8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@GODCONVOYPRIME","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxn-bVhN50002jGVcN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"you can moan and cry all you like. AI will be here to stay.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UC2ZRh7rROaNRA8XqVOKm8pw","author":"@adeaiy4559","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/dnChShKZ0epLTFJOqo2V84jJMyHEg27qr6ljyueYeDkhTBRZe9ZUtJbroZvt8ia5Hmy02Ko5ZA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@adeaiy4559","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxn-bVhN50002jGVcN4AaABAg.ADAtFdvwgn1ADD1avq9scj","parent":"Ugxn-bVhN50002jGVcN4AaABAg","text":"🤡","like_count":2,"author_id":"UCiMbNHrSnd-qlUmE3QWE_VQ","author":"@PRLCKLY","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vMGtRhncG5xM3n6RHkhnnT0mtqjiENGPj_2MZhmhEs70DtkfTHsYK89G-qgZ5mFE2xSwZWRL=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@PRLCKLY","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugxn-bVhN50002jGVcN4AaABAg.ADAtFdvwgn1ADEN9tijH_3","parent":"Ugxn-bVhN50002jGVcN4AaABAg","text":"The thing is, he is neither moaning or criying. He is quite calmly explaining.\nSo the only reason for you comment could be ... projection","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCStiqU0SRMjWSTnWPleVoMA","author":"@insert-name-here6777","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_mIX9gptZFvYGhNPpxnYTXqwYjlCRvm5vkAm6s62KE=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@insert-name-here6777","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz_gPHHn91N13qg_-N4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I feel like this comment's gonna get buried but I worked at Udio (I left about a month ago before the UMG deal) and would love to chat with you about AI music because, while it's controversial, I think it's super cool! I just found your channel today and have been binging thru all the videos so regardless, this is dope content.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCVmYXz3ISye0LuRQInZakXw","author":"@jonaylor89","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qArvHvvssH8lzu7UdT17bBd5lCYKG9pQZbvsoed327ZpOh7F--DT7sJniRWQ8SwwLnrRGvp3GQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jonaylor89","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"10 months ago","timestamp":1764633600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgynNwOfUmuj-pbHPRN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I dont see ai different than any other innovation. \n\nThe \"i play a real instrument\" sounds no different than the film guys hating dslrs, and the dslr guys hating iPhone cameras. \n\nIt still takes a good understanding of music theory to make \"good\" ai music. 99% of music on suno is hot garbo, but it's not from being ai generated, it's from being posted by someone who doesn't really know what music is. \n\nI make plenty of music for myself in suno, haven't posted a link anywhere except for friends, does it being ai generated take from the fact i spent countless hours writing and refining my lyrics and prompts to get what i wanted? \n\nThe issue would be someone pretending it isn't ai, but it's not \"intrinsically\" bad. Just handled badly.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjq6a6RCNUNoj5l5orkv_8g","author":"@ellayennee","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/rLXkcR3szIz1K48a2NsB1_FFij7SL1mAsDgfpCJClu4bzYO1nglAVuk9HRgLjIIL9_0JShaffb8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ellayennee","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugw-UexJbdm-ZbbtHcZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"AI is a disaster.  The perfect tool for a shithead evil music developer.  Just like writing and criticism.  We will never know if something was gemerated with this fraudulent and illegal method.  Just another huge setback for real musicians who just want to record and perform the idea in their heads.  So sad.  Might be the end of creativity.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCPWa61lxgJfyFutOae4SMFQ","author":"@widescreennavel","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1Woq07Xh5qYocEnfOQxhQaq8Xu4p0LMr9VUWmFg8wa8JknznRr7yCVsPnqV0Y8NXhglRJBa4MQ=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@widescreennavel","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwHTjNZDe3O5V_pGLB4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"I guess my question is.. why would anyone care what someone else is listening to? If someone likes a song, they like it, no matter where it came from. You think someone’s gonna add a song to their favorites and then hate if if they find it it’s AI? Who are they lying to? Themselves? lol. Just worry about you…","like_count":0,"author_id":"UChGdJmZ4GWWvszvuVaUeCAA","author":"@TheLastOfTheRockstarsU2","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kEGBa9ttBXsL23nQBwlWwJUW48_ghAWJnHPXeB6q4eCAc=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@TheLastOfTheRockstarsU2","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy8CbqBtrqfhh9zO_J4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"You can’t tell 256 kbps audio and lossless ? Damn you need ear training 😂","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCKf7EQhC6xHDMDpiROby2WQ","author":"@ApexArtistX","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/JL80fX-nBwByovZZAxe7DJxG4J4M0HyKTk8LtzgjVbUIdEBK4z4wdpc-9yEwjXN6_6Sa-lJQLA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@ApexArtistX","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgxhUc0waDh0KF3lIIF4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Yeah idk how accurate that is, Because Ai can barely do half the things it says, so How could it tell if another ai made something? It can't, unless they are all making the same beat. 1:04 Its kind of odd your using AI but don't like the uses people use AI for... 3:16 The problem with it is if they even change one thing from the AI, its no longer AI music. By law it would be copyrightable. SO its not a easy thing to figure out.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCielTqq49EygSQfRnzZBn-g","author":"@KingKatura","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/SccvRlEfVv7zLPoR1j6FM2mX6htz8O1teLlrAj7yQFAhGhmJmY012R4udO7fD1at_kEcmKKP7w=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@KingKatura","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwuBGPEOVOOtn0c-SZ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Pay? I use AI to make DMCA-free music, can I still get paid? Never though ot if. And my plan is to use YouTUbe. I already got 500 songs made, and thousands of other non-ai ready to be released.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCjLEJLwOlqHA-sxgaCazJbg","author":"@Enkeria","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/_ZAQoCUhYeD5a8piGbCfx8YEacdJoraEdzVzCpU-uyxnQ3Fy5cQz5PnynpJii8VfBB8RlSG8=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Enkeria","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgwuBGPEOVOOtn0c-SZ4AaABAg.ACy9FetwGBJACyDwuIAIrI","parent":"UgwuBGPEOVOOtn0c-SZ4AaABAg","text":"You don't make music.","like_count":1,"author_id":"UCZDdfBrfVakutoHaZ1B0G9A","author":"@d10modifier","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/vg0eQLgA-SWjzhtkM8TB9DvAZKLg1r1RpfHV9wECvqcK756t6OeTUrhOIm1q_CTEbqClCSm5sw=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@d10modifier","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzRtWCCLA1hbb9TvPx4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Done food for thought,  Venus theory as well as you use AI for your avatars because you don't want to hire real photographers and graphic artists?  We use drum machines and synthesizers instead of hiring people who can actually play real instruments, and we  call out people who use AI to produce music out? As if  everybody who is on that side of the debate are some sort of judges as to what's \"real music\" and what's not?😅😂  I use the same Roland synthesizers and Linn Drum machines as all of the top producers for my hit record and we use some of the same patches too so I've got exactly the same horn sounds organs and drum sounds as then so if you extrapolate from what I've seen in your video because we're all using the same sounds this system is set up so if one person makes😂 a song using a particular patch from a Super Jupiter or the classic Linn drum down tuned sidestick,  that means that everybody else's songs using that exact same sample grub the internal eproms and sounds generators are going to be flagged? gTFOH!","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcsEcVJb6aqqmQF5CXswpdA","author":"@hitmusicworldwide","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_l0o8A74CbLpXStB2Xx3g-jWecq0p5GQrvN389sY9oAjC4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@hitmusicworldwide","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugzs73hSRsMONl80oRN4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Okay, so does it bother you that other people are making money by putting in less effort than you? I don't know, it's not even your company, you're not the one paying these people who use AI to generate your music. They're not taking money from you. You're basically criticizing something that doesn't affect you, but comparing it to your work, they're doing better than you and that bothers you.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCglXndYUiiAG3BObZAjtP8g","author":"@maninhopozzebon","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_kzLt-bq75iRr84Bp-CdFRijq2j7Iofa1Yd4CJ69kK9hNSd=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@maninhopozzebon","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgySzuJk6p1i5y8tru14AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"If AI is stealing it's because A HUMAN IS GIVING IT DIRECTION TO DO SO.\nThe anti-AI sentiment reminds me a whole lot of transphobia. It's a brave new world. Keep up. And frankly? An AI takeover from the greedy oligarchic rule we have now? Might be our ONLY hope of surviving climate change or ending world hunger. If you chose art as your primary source of income, you had to know you were taking a risk on your talent. Don't blame ai if you suck too bad to get noticed.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCyaSQ03teBghfSV0kv3RVNw","author":"@artemisnite","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1Id4CP93CKBhg3q9n5NtRBCQUEeyALx3FgGzXeFGFhXhu1FdRKSVqrzx1klcXSJg8zEGsTyEQA=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@artemisnite","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago (edited)","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugz4Qbuijd1IVYsgjol4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Lol sounds like your butt hurt because AI took your job. Welcome to the world bub.\n\nDo more science shit it's more entertaining than listening to you whine about how life isn't fair, from your fancy studio on your farm on a literal fucking lake","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCLDGmke4CqeGbKoBnfnLCgw","author":"@WarpedGetaways","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/qRZcC9DmoMTvmvwGEcuAcG6lVxWqg2bPInUlBXLlR5e9gAUMBCxaaAbK6dODyFu95KT4sk4=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@WarpedGetaways","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"7 months ago","timestamp":1772409600,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzTuYc6X7PGamy-okJ4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"so DJ's, Loops, Samples and shit is ok but AI isn't. GET REAL. learn a instrument FFS.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcxNj0is0sZ2feCC3mX_ljA","author":"@Ready_Fire_Aim","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/LwVuuofJJ3WPDrHmXfQf9TObjMZ3rJA_aW2wtwB14Wa-MDzy6iacJDQ29UqvWLowNRGuvtSr7Q=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@Ready_Fire_Aim","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"UgzcgqyvPhtp2b-SYqh4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Videos like this are just sad. What's with all the anti AI religious zealotry? Can we grow up?","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCXXtxSUGv_lTf4wJ8BKY9nA","author":"@beakhole793","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/1qcQASKTWk4QAZvA9FVjEIFoHPB56IZukil3GxJHPoNGg2ikt9qKjFN7dILa7r8_C4yYpmMZpbU=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@beakhole793","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false},{"id":"Ugy74W6Gt9EOoV6XXjt4AaABAg","parent":"root","text":"Sorry you don't like the new tools.  AI is no more theft than you hearing rock music and then making a song.  \"Artist\" are just upset that anyone can be a creative today.  Y'all sounding a lot like \"get off my lawn\".  Music and graphic art is all made with computers today, artist complained they were being ripped off when computers came in also.  AI does not copy anything, it learns.","like_count":0,"author_id":"UCcI2ZnWFoYbFwvIEFGIkgNA","author":"@billtwok6864","author_thumbnail":"https://yt3.ggpht.com/ytc/AIdro_nyYmLpCWyEmHgkAeEjW0HuD5q0XG55v6VQg823Mzs=s88-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj","author_is_uploader":false,"author_is_verified":false,"author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@billtwok6864","is_favorited":false,"_time_text":"1 year ago","timestamp":1759363200,"is_pinned":false}]}